Tbh if I was Hina i'd get kinda upset IF I knew my friend HAD TOLD someone else. Taiki told Kyo. If the person didn't say that to me, it would be KINDA like saying "i don't trust you". Hina has been his friend for a while, so yeah, i completely understand why this came off as a low blow for her. Hina is NOT a bad person that would do anything to hurt or cause trouble to anyone, so not trusting her was definitely on Taiki. Chinatsu has no obligation to trust her, but Taiki knows her. I did heard some people didn't like Hina's character but oh well...everyone has their own taste. Hina has been friends with him way before Chinatsu. If anything, Chinatsu is the one new in the "friends group", not Hina. But it's kinda expected. The "love rival" always gets somekind of hate bc they are "interfering in someone else's business", even if this someone else is their friend.
We're not hating on her at all. We have empathy and sympathy for her. I also said I can see her point in being upset from the trust/friend POV. Thanks for watching and sharing your passion.
I mean, it's not like Hina will spread this to people around the school. Kyo HIMSELF told a few things to Chinatsu a few eps ago. It was to help Taiki, but still....idk if someone getting mad or upset bc their your own friend didn't tell them something important as this is that annoying imo. Plus, Taiki doesn't know that Hina likes him, so i see no reason for him to kept this from her. I think you guys went hard on her in the beginning. It's very rude imo saying that this was none of her business since the same guy told to one of his close friends and didn't tell the other. Hina is not a villain guys lmao
She's not entitled to his goings-on. It's the attitude she had that elicited that response. We don't hate her, we like her a lot. We like her friendship with Taiki. And we're responding as us, not from Taiki's POV. Thanks for watching and commenting!
@@TheGenreVerse but you guys did say that bc you put yourselves in Taiki's position, no? It's not like Hina was meddling into you guys's business, she was trying to know more about Taiki's situation. The way you guys responded seemed like that's how you would respond to someone IRL if you were in a similiar situation, but no one (I think) give ths type of answer to someone close to you. Idk if i'm being too sensible here, but Hina is not a character to be treated this way imo. Would you guys say the same thing if it was Taiki trying to know more about Chinatsu and asking about her life? She's not trying to interfere guys, she was just upset she got excluded from Taiki's "secret inner group". Idk, the way you guys acted seemed like if someone ask anything about you the answer will be "none of your business".....let me ask, would you guys like to be treated this way if you're trying to know someone better or, worse, had this said to your face by someone you are close with?
We said it as how WE would feel in that situation. We, who don't like it when someone is UPSET at not knowing something we didn't want to tell them at the time. Of course IRL, face to face, our tone will be different person to person, situation to situation. We can be snappy from the outside, because we're not talking to anyone real. I've told my Mom and Dad that things are none of her business as a kid and as an adult. The tone changing dependent on the time and situation. And yes, if Taiki was, in our opinion, coming at Chinatsu OR Hina in an entitled way, we'd react the same. This isn't part of us wanting Chinatsu or Hina to win. This isn't about our "pick" for him. This is just us... I even stated I could see her POV because of their friendship... That's in the reaction 😆
I've been wondering that since Classroom of the Elite reactions, but everytime a character comes to the MC asking a question, Catherine's like "it's none of your business"....why tho? If she is an introverted person, i would kinda get it, but these people are in high school. They interact, they talk to each other, they share feelings and stuff. On top of that, Hina is NOT a stranger that is trying to mess up this boy's life. She is VERY supportive of him and always tries to cheer him up....i don't get the reason to be so hostile towards her character. Answering "it's none of your business" to literally any person who wants to know more about you is a good way to avoid people actually. Taiki has 0 reasons to avoid of shove Hina aside.
Christine, and I in some cases, use that when someone seems UPSET at not knowing something that really wasn't their business. I also sometimes say it in a joking way. My tone is usually different then though. You're not ENTITLED to information, generally, and it's a reaction to characters that act like they are.
@@TheGenreVerse I'd agree if we were talking about someone you don't like or a stranger. Hina is one of Taiki's CLOSE FRIENDS, Kyle. I think in this case (and others tbh), the context matters a lot. She isn't entitled but it's 100% understandable why she got upset. She likes this dude AND she is one of his long time friends, so idk why the "business" critic in this situation. There isn't any character that is rooting more for him in this series than her, and this is how you treat her? Very unfair imo. "None of your business" is smth you say to someone you DO NOT like or someone you ARE NOT CLOSE WITH, and don't even wanna be, cause saying this is a slap in the face. Would you guys prefer if Hina's friendship with him ended bc of this? Bc i see no reason to be THIS rude.
One, we're not responding as Taiki or fun Taiki's POV. We're responding from ours. Two, we don't WANT anything bad or hurtful to happen to them. We've expressed in post episodes how much we like Hina and Taki's friendship. Three, it's a fictional story, with fictional characters... They can't be slapped in the face or feel anything about the way we think/feel about their actions. So we're not concerned if she'd be upset at US responding "none of your business." No one hates her here... Thanks for watching and discussing this with us!
![ทุกครั้งที่หลับตา (Lucid Dream) - AYLA's [ Official MV ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4i1OBAQyv58/mqdefault.jpg)
Hina really used a real torture method on Taki
Poor Hina.
💯
Damn 😂 i still haven't seen people being so harsh on Hina. I like her. I hope she grows on you guys, specially on Christine LOL
We're being harsh? We showed/talked feeling bad for her having these feelings and knowing he's into Chinatsu...
Tbh if I was Hina i'd get kinda upset IF I knew my friend HAD TOLD someone else. Taiki told Kyo. If the person didn't say that to me, it would be KINDA like saying "i don't trust you". Hina has been his friend for a while, so yeah, i completely understand why this came off as a low blow for her.
Hina is NOT a bad person that would do anything to hurt or cause trouble to anyone, so not trusting her was definitely on Taiki. Chinatsu has no obligation to trust her, but Taiki knows her.
I did heard some people didn't like Hina's character but oh well...everyone has their own taste. Hina has been friends with him way before Chinatsu. If anything, Chinatsu is the one new in the "friends group", not Hina.
But it's kinda expected. The "love rival" always gets somekind of hate bc they are "interfering in someone else's business", even if this someone else is their friend.
We're not hating on her at all. We have empathy and sympathy for her. I also said I can see her point in being upset from the trust/friend POV. Thanks for watching and sharing your passion.
I mean, it's not like Hina will spread this to people around the school. Kyo HIMSELF told a few things to Chinatsu a few eps ago. It was to help Taiki, but still....idk if someone getting mad or upset bc their your own friend didn't tell them something important as this is that annoying imo.
Plus, Taiki doesn't know that Hina likes him, so i see no reason for him to kept this from her. I think you guys went hard on her in the beginning. It's very rude imo saying that this was none of her business since the same guy told to one of his close friends and didn't tell the other. Hina is not a villain guys lmao
She's not entitled to his goings-on. It's the attitude she had that elicited that response. We don't hate her, we like her a lot. We like her friendship with Taiki. And we're responding as us, not from Taiki's POV. Thanks for watching and commenting!
@@TheGenreVerse but you guys did say that bc you put yourselves in Taiki's position, no? It's not like Hina was meddling into you guys's business, she was trying to know more about Taiki's situation. The way you guys responded seemed like that's how you would respond to someone IRL if you were in a similiar situation, but no one (I think) give ths type of answer to someone close to you. Idk if i'm being too sensible here, but Hina is not a character to be treated this way imo. Would you guys say the same thing if it was Taiki trying to know more about Chinatsu and asking about her life?
She's not trying to interfere guys, she was just upset she got excluded from Taiki's "secret inner group".
Idk, the way you guys acted seemed like if someone ask anything about you the answer will be "none of your business".....let me ask, would you guys like to be treated this way if you're trying to know someone better or, worse, had this said to your face by someone you are close with?
We said it as how WE would feel in that situation. We, who don't like it when someone is UPSET at not knowing something we didn't want to tell them at the time. Of course IRL, face to face, our tone will be different person to person, situation to situation. We can be snappy from the outside, because we're not talking to anyone real.
I've told my Mom and Dad that things are none of her business as a kid and as an adult. The tone changing dependent on the time and situation.
And yes, if Taiki was, in our opinion, coming at Chinatsu OR Hina in an entitled way, we'd react the same.
This isn't part of us wanting Chinatsu or Hina to win. This isn't about our "pick" for him. This is just us...
I even stated I could see her POV because of their friendship... That's in the reaction 😆
I've been wondering that since Classroom of the Elite reactions, but everytime a character comes to the MC asking a question, Catherine's like "it's none of your business"....why tho? If she is an introverted person, i would kinda get it, but these people are in high school. They interact, they talk to each other, they share feelings and stuff. On top of that, Hina is NOT a stranger that is trying to mess up this boy's life. She is VERY supportive of him and always tries to cheer him up....i don't get the reason to be so hostile towards her character.
Answering "it's none of your business" to literally any person who wants to know more about you is a good way to avoid people actually. Taiki has 0 reasons to avoid of shove Hina aside.
Christine, and I in some cases, use that when someone seems UPSET at not knowing something that really wasn't their business. I also sometimes say it in a joking way. My tone is usually different then though.
You're not ENTITLED to information, generally, and it's a reaction to characters that act like they are.
@@TheGenreVerse I'd agree if we were talking about someone you don't like or a stranger. Hina is one of Taiki's CLOSE FRIENDS, Kyle. I think in this case (and others tbh), the context matters a lot. She isn't entitled but it's 100% understandable why she got upset. She likes this dude AND she is one of his long time friends, so idk why the "business" critic in this situation. There isn't any character that is rooting more for him in this series than her, and this is how you treat her? Very unfair imo.
"None of your business" is smth you say to someone you DO NOT like or someone you ARE NOT CLOSE WITH, and don't even wanna be, cause saying this is a slap in the face.
Would you guys prefer if Hina's friendship with him ended bc of this? Bc i see no reason to be THIS rude.
One, we're not responding as Taiki or fun Taiki's POV. We're responding from ours.
Two, we don't WANT anything bad or hurtful to happen to them. We've expressed in post episodes how much we like Hina and Taki's friendship.
Three, it's a fictional story, with fictional characters... They can't be slapped in the face or feel anything about the way we think/feel about their actions. So we're not concerned if she'd be upset at US responding "none of your business."
No one hates her here...
Thanks for watching and discussing this with us!
But how is the kid diong? Better or worse?
Our kid? He's doing better. Thanks for asking!
@@TheGenreVerse yes sorry i forget his Name😅. Good to hear!
Lucas