The humor they can bring to such an emotionally packed episode is fantastic. Great reaction/commentary as usual. I have just two things to add. 1. I about lost it when Dean thru the phone out the window, what comedic ability that Jensen has sometimes. 2. The fight scene in this paralleled the fight scene in the pilot episode and I thought that was a brilliant move by Kripke~
Hahah the humour is always at its peak and it helps - especially in episodes like this! I thought it was really funny that Dean threw the phone. The look on Sam’s face 😂 I didn’t see the similarities first but now that you say it!!!
It's great to rewatch Sam and Dean through the new eyes of someone like yourself who loves the brothers and their awsome relationship. So thank you. :)
my heart broke for dean he has never really had a normal childhood he had to be both Mom and Dad all of Sammy's life and he is truly damage by that this episode shows his more broken side
Such a great episode. Sometimes when we wish for something it doesn't turn out as wonderful as we expected. A very bittersweet episode. Again the brothers' relationship is so deep and complicated and that's what we love about them. I was very interested to see your reaction, and you didn't disappoint . lol. :)
It really was! I liked that they made an episode that showed what could have been and that even though it was a wish it wasn’t perfect. It was such a beautifully sad episode!😭 Their relationship is so cute, and it has so many layers to it that make it what it is. I’m happy I didn’t disappoint! I hope you’ll enjoy the rest of them🥰
Another amazing reaction you did not disappoint on another excellent episode, definitely one of my favourites of the alternate reality trope. I feel like Dean looks at his wish coming true as a curse because of how it negatively affects everyone else around him (which is fair) but on the positive side he got to spend some time with his mother and see that civilian life is not for him.
Thank you so much!!🥹❤️ This episode is a great one for sure and in the top of episodes so far for me. I feel like it’s so hard for him because he know this could have been his life, where he is happy, Sam is happy and safe and they get to grow up with their mother. Even though their relationship isn’t good he would choose that anytime! But since Dean knows about supernatural things I think knowing that all they did would have been lost was weighing on him. But I also think it was a reminder of how much good they have done 🥺❤️
mechanic.. that's the word you were hunting for. Dean's profession in the monster induced dream This episode should have gotten both boys emmys.. Sam being so normal.. no question that he and Jess hadn't been together all along. The concern when Dean goes out with the silver knife after being disappointed in him. and every expression on Dean's face .. the longing behind his eyes..and the hurt he tries to hide..and the little boy joy in some of the simple things.. and even that look of shame.. that man has a magical face. He can get 5 emotions from 1 expression by only changing his depth of perception. It didn't hurt that he had on some epic guy-liner going on the lower lashes.
That was the word LMAO!! I really couldn't get it right when watching haha, thank you. They deserve a price for sure for this one, wow. The way they both kept breaking me over and over haha. Sam really felt like what I would have expected Sam to be if all hadn't happened. Dean's expressions, even small with your his eyes in this one was incredible. I don't understand how one person can do all of them that well!
Ohh this episode was kinda cute but also really sad, honestly i was happy for Dean when he saw Mary once again. Also the rage against John...well, I'm just gonna say that still there even after so much time 😂 And Sam with Jess, ahhhh my heart was almost broken in that moment :"/ btw, I can't change the brotherly moments of those two, no matter what they can offer me Oh Cora, be ready for the end of this season, a big memory I have of that is, once again, crying on a corner before continue the binge 😅 good luck darling
I agree! It was interesting seeing what could have been but dang it was heartbreaking to watch 😭 Seeing Sam and Jess aaaaah, they were so happy together. I love the moments that Dean and Sam have together, they are always the best! Always crying haha, thank you for the good luck! I’ve got my setting spray ready ✌️❤️
Just want to say I really love your reactions. The tears the laughs just remind me of when I first watch it. Supernatural will forever be my favorite. I am new here, so glad I found you to get to see people enjoy the show as much as I did ❤
Thank you so much, that means a lot!! So happy to be able to share them with you. Welcome in to this corner of the internet, and I hope you'll have a good time watching me fall in love with the show! ❤️
Watching you cry so much makes me question if the affectionate side of me is fully their because i don't get emotional over the things you do. An yet my favorite show is supernatural lol. Ive watch all 15 seasons 5 times. My point is i wonder if something is wrong with me😂
I feel like it's been clear for a while for me but this really solidified it. He would do anything for Sam, to save him, to protect him and make him happy!
@@CoraReacts well is not that it wasnt clear for me but well cant tell more details cause spoilers but the point is what u said change my mind about something of the show 😅
Such an incredible episode - one of my favourites out of the whole series, honestly. Everything Dean goes through RIPS my heart out of my chest. Like, hes so desperate to stay, so desperate to "get some rest" as Mary says. 😭😭😭 But he gives it all up to save people and to get back to "his Sammy". One thing I usually point out to folks is that everything in the "alternate world" was manifested from Dean's own mind and subconscious. So, all the things there, were there (at least mostly) because of thoughts and ideas in Dean's own head. So, the wish was that his mom lived, so she was there, he wanted his Dad to be at peace and not suffering through hell because of him (I'm not actually blaming Dean for that, of course, just highlighting the way hes thinking) so John died peacefully in his sleep (In reality Jeffrey Dean Morgan just couldn't get away from his other jobs to play John here. 😁) He wants Sam to live a normal, happy life, so he gives him a beautiful life with Jess, a life I think Dean sort of feels he took from him when he came and got him from Standford. (Again, not true, but I believe that's what Dean's thinking/feeling guilty about.) Anyway, all of that was manifested from his mind. Meaning that the fact that he was a kind of a shitty brother to Sam also came from his own mind. Which tells me that somewhere deep down, Dean doesn't think he's been a good brother. And that kills me, because Dean has been the most incredible brother! He pretty much raised Sam, he's saved him and protected him so many times. 😫😫 Anyway, this episode absolutely rips my heart to shreds. As a Dean girl, my heart simply can't handle all his pain. Jensen is PHENOMENAL in this episode (as usual!). Jared is fabulous here too, and both boys should have been recognized for their tremendous work. Your reaction was wonderful as always!! Can not WAIT to watch the 2 part season finale with you. If you do watch them back-to-back, will you post them together? Loving going through this journey with you. ❤️
Not that I have seen much of the series yet, but this is for sure one of my favourite episodes too! Their acting is amazing, and even thought this was one of the most difficult to watch it was so well made. My heart was totally broken, seeing what Deans dream is - and having to watch him live it only to get it all ripped away (again). 😭 You can see how much he wants to stay, and how badly he wants this to be real, but he would give up that close to perfect dream to get back home to Sammy!! It makes sense that it was from Deans mind, that was I was assuming but I probably wasn't very clear about that. It made it was sadder knowing this is what he wished for!! I thought the same about their dad, that maybe he just didn't want him to suffer which sort of made same... but it almost makes more sense that he wasn't able to be in the episode LMAO I also agree, I think Dean feels guilty even thought he shouldn't! I didn't think about the fact that Dean feels like he is a bad brother in relation to this but I can see that affecting this world for sure! Maybe it was almost like a part of himself wanted to punish him for not being a (what he deem) "perfect" brother to Sam... 😭 That kills me to because he is the best brother omg!!! This was a great episodes on so many levels, but my heart breaks just thinking about it haha. I appreciate you watching and I'm so happy you enjoyed it!!
@@CoraReacts The last two episodes in S3 aren't a two-parter. Of course there's lots of build up to the end of the season, but technically they're separate episodes. There are only 16 episodes in S3 because of the writer's strike that took place in Hollywood in 2008, much like what's happening now. As for watching the last two back-to-back, of course, as always, you can only do what you can do. Don't overextend yourself. ❤
@@CoraReactsHi Cora, I think what she meant by "being late to the party" was that she started watching Supernatural later than their 2005 release date, sama as a lot of people (myself included) I watched it for the 1st time in 2020 during the pandemic, but I've seen it at least 15 more times since then, lol!)
Say what you want, but the djinn's tattoos are wicked. It was nice to see what the brother's lives would've looked like if Mary didn't die, but it is also sad to see that Dean and Sam wouldn't be as close as we all know them to be. Glad Dean woke up! the starting confused me to begin with when I saw Sammy had a law book, then it clicked, but it was still confusing! lol. Great reaction, though! ohhhh, now I can't wait for the next episode, keep tissues in hand! Happy Pride month!
Agreed!! The tattoos are really cool. It was such an interesting episode to see in to another possibility but it was hard to watch for the heart 🫣 I get being confused by the law book haha! Thank you for watching, I’m happy you enjoyed it. Happy pride month! 🏳️🌈
Ok call me a jerk or asshole but why do I feel like most of reactors i have seen are always team sam ( maybe i'm absolutely wrong or just imagining ). I've always seen that if it's about Dean then they feel like "it's kinda sad", but when it's about Sam they literally are crying or sobbing or using tissue. Please correct me if I'm wrong, because that's what I have observed from tons of reactors. Only some of them feel the same for both brother's. When something is about to happen to Dean, they are not as worried as When something is about to happen to Sam. I saw many reactors react something happening to Dean like "it's sad, i feel bad for sam". And when something is happening to sam, they are like "don't u think about it, never ever touch my precious sam, don't hurt him", they literally scream about Sam. OK NOW I'M OFFICIALLY IMAGINING
@@HealthyDisrespectforAuthority Yeah You're right, they are people who feel the same for both brother's, but those are few, while most of them that I have seen are literally sobbing about Sam. If something happens to Dean, in that scenario they literally feel bad for Sam. I love both brother's equally, like if i shed tears for sam then i shed tears for Dean too. İn this show I have used countless tissues because the tissues have been used for both brother's not just for one. İ'M JUST SAYING..
@@Benedict649 ~~~growl~~~ I was halfway through my comment (on the drop down notification thing) and youtube redirected me to the home page and poof.. comment gone.. grrrrrrr and me, without a working 'e' key.. all of them are pasted in. I guess I've watched reactions more from team Winchester folks than Dean vs Sam girls. I get confused by s that don't get moist eyes I'm in the *when Jensen Ackles cries,I cry* camp
I don't think I have ever mentioned being team anyone at this point tbh, and from what I know most seem to be team Dean if anything haha. But bothers are amazing so whichever anyone likes more us valid. I also feel like Dean giving me one tear (singular) breaks me quicker lol. I love them both so much!
If you want to watch another reactor that also feels strongly for both brothers, try checking out Imon_Snow! She’s on season 3 right now, nearing the end. She had to take a break a couple years ago, but she’s back reacting to it now! She usually have some very long talks after each episode, that I personally love to listen to. She just seems very insightful and calming. Idk if I’m explaining this very well lol, I just really love her reactions 😂 She’s a total Dean girl, but she loves Sam just as much 🥰 Idk if it’s bad etiquette to recommend another person’s channel in someone’s comment section, so if it is I’m sorry 😅 there are just very few good reactors to Supernatural out there, and I believe both Cora and Imon are among the great ones! 🌸❤️ Btw, I’ve made a playlist of Imon’s Supernatural reactions on my page, because she doesn’t have a proper one herself yet. So if you want all the episode reactions in order, feel free to check it out! 😁
Sam definitely wasn't googling anything, season 2 was filmed in 2006-2007 😄 Mobile version of chrome was launched in 2012.
LMAO I said it and realised a few moments later what I said… but then I though it was kinda funny how that was my though process so I kept it in 😂
The humor they can bring to such an emotionally packed episode is fantastic. Great reaction/commentary as usual. I have just two things to add.
1. I about lost it when Dean thru the phone out the window, what comedic ability that Jensen has sometimes.
2. The fight scene in this paralleled the fight scene in the pilot episode and I thought that was a brilliant move by Kripke~
Hahah the humour is always at its peak and it helps - especially in episodes like this! I thought it was really funny that Dean threw the phone. The look on Sam’s face 😂 I didn’t see the similarities first but now that you say it!!!
This is a heartbreaking episode! Poor Dean and Sam they deserve the whole world (especially Dean).😢
Truly!! Oh gosh my poor little heart!! They deserve the world and a perfect life
Soul crushing episode and solidified dean as my favorite.
Soul crushing was a perfect way of describing this😭
It's great to rewatch Sam and Dean through the new eyes of someone like yourself who loves the brothers and their awsome relationship. So thank you. :)
Aww thank you!! I’m happy you like the episodes and I’m happy to share them with you 🥰 Thank you for watching them!!
John isn't in this episode bc Jeffery Dean Morgan works constantly so he wasn't available 😊
Wait is that actually the reason??? 🥲
@@CoraReacts yes JDM is always working so it was about his schedule and if he's available ✌
Carmen is such a great early love interest for Dean - exactly right for him and it's so sad she never existed.
That’s why I hated the Djin. Gave him such a lovely partner that never existed.
I was so happy seeing him with Carmen, it's the kind of partner he deserves!
It’s a horror show but man, they do drama so well.
It’s a very dramatic horrid show - you get the whole range of emotions haha😂
I'd call it a drama with horror elements.
my heart broke for dean he has never really had a normal childhood he had to be both Mom and Dad all of Sammy's life and he is truly damage by that this episode shows his more broken side
My heart broke too😭 this episode does a great job of showing even more how he feels
Such a great episode. Sometimes when we wish for something it doesn't turn out as wonderful as we expected. A very bittersweet episode.
Again the brothers' relationship is so deep and complicated and that's what we love about them.
I was very interested to see your reaction, and you didn't disappoint . lol. :)
It really was! I liked that they made an episode that showed what could have been and that even though it was a wish it wasn’t perfect. It was such a beautifully sad episode!😭
Their relationship is so cute, and it has so many layers to it that make it what it is. I’m happy I didn’t disappoint! I hope you’ll enjoy the rest of them🥰
Another amazing reaction you did not disappoint on another excellent episode, definitely one of my favourites of the alternate reality trope.
I feel like Dean looks at his wish coming true as a curse because of how it negatively affects everyone else around him (which is fair) but on the positive side he got to spend some time with his mother and see that civilian life is not for him.
Thank you so much!!🥹❤️ This episode is a great one for sure and in the top of episodes so far for me.
I feel like it’s so hard for him because he know this could have been his life, where he is happy, Sam is happy and safe and they get to grow up with their mother. Even though their relationship isn’t good he would choose that anytime! But since Dean knows about supernatural things I think knowing that all they did would have been lost was weighing on him. But I also think it was a reminder of how much good they have done 🥺❤️
mechanic.. that's the word you were hunting for. Dean's profession in the monster induced dream
This episode should have gotten both boys emmys.. Sam being so normal.. no question that he and Jess hadn't been together all along. The concern when Dean goes out with the silver knife after being disappointed in him.
and every expression on Dean's face .. the longing behind his eyes..and the hurt he tries to hide..and the little boy joy in some of the simple things.. and even that look of shame.. that man has a magical face.
He can get 5 emotions from 1 expression by only changing his depth of perception. It didn't hurt that he had on some epic guy-liner going on the lower lashes.
That was the word LMAO!! I really couldn't get it right when watching haha, thank you.
They deserve a price for sure for this one, wow. The way they both kept breaking me over and over haha. Sam really felt like what I would have expected Sam to be if all hadn't happened. Dean's expressions, even small with your his eyes in this one was incredible. I don't understand how one person can do all of them that well!
Ohh this episode was kinda cute but also really sad, honestly i was happy for Dean when he saw Mary once again. Also the rage against John...well, I'm just gonna say that still there even after so much time 😂
And Sam with Jess, ahhhh my heart was almost broken in that moment :"/ btw, I can't change the brotherly moments of those two, no matter what they can offer me
Oh Cora, be ready for the end of this season, a big memory I have of that is, once again, crying on a corner before continue the binge 😅 good luck darling
I agree! It was interesting seeing what could have been but dang it was heartbreaking to watch 😭 Seeing Sam and Jess aaaaah, they were so happy together. I love the moments that Dean and Sam have together, they are always the best!
Always crying haha, thank you for the good luck! I’ve got my setting spray ready ✌️❤️
Just want to say I really love your reactions. The tears the laughs just remind me of when I first watch it. Supernatural will forever be my favorite. I am new here, so glad I found you to get to see people enjoy the show as much as I did ❤
Thank you so much, that means a lot!! So happy to be able to share them with you. Welcome in to this corner of the internet, and I hope you'll have a good time watching me fall in love with the show! ❤️
Watching you cry so much makes me question if the affectionate side of me is fully their because i don't get emotional over the things you do. An yet my favorite show is supernatural lol. Ive watch all 15 seasons 5 times. My point is i wonder if something is wrong with me😂
I think we are all differently sensitive to these kind of things, and I cry pretty easily! Not crying doesn’t mean we don’t feel 🥰
Damn u say something that just change my mind about something of the show ! I totally agree with u dean would sacrifice for sam having a happy life !
I feel like it's been clear for a while for me but this really solidified it. He would do anything for Sam, to save him, to protect him and make him happy!
@@CoraReacts well is not that it wasnt clear for me but well cant tell more details cause spoilers but the point is what u said change my mind about something of the show 😅
I agree with the title of this video- it was so unfair. And downright cruel. But I loved Jensen and Jared in this ep. I thought they did amazing.
It felt like a very appropriate title!! 😭 They did a phenomenal job and so far this was one of my faves, even thought it was hard to watch!
Cheated of Emmy nods for fifteen seasons.
You're crying because you love these boys, just like the rest of us do.
Very true!❤️
Such an incredible episode - one of my favourites out of the whole series, honestly. Everything Dean goes through RIPS my heart out of my chest. Like, hes so desperate to stay, so desperate to "get some rest" as Mary says. 😭😭😭 But he gives it all up to save people and to get back to "his Sammy".
One thing I usually point out to folks is that everything in the "alternate world" was manifested from Dean's own mind and subconscious. So, all the things there, were there (at least mostly) because of thoughts and ideas in Dean's own head.
So, the wish was that his mom lived, so she was there, he wanted his Dad to be at peace and not suffering through hell because of him (I'm not actually blaming Dean for that, of course, just highlighting the way hes thinking) so John died peacefully in his sleep (In reality Jeffrey Dean Morgan just couldn't get away from his other jobs to play John here. 😁) He wants Sam to live a normal, happy life, so he gives him a beautiful life with Jess, a life I think Dean sort of feels he took from him when he came and got him from Standford. (Again, not true, but I believe that's what Dean's thinking/feeling guilty about.)
Anyway, all of that was manifested from his mind. Meaning that the fact that he was a kind of a shitty brother to Sam also came from his own mind. Which tells me that somewhere deep down, Dean doesn't think he's been a good brother. And that kills me, because Dean has been the most incredible brother! He pretty much raised Sam, he's saved him and protected him so many times. 😫😫
Anyway, this episode absolutely rips my heart to shreds. As a Dean girl, my heart simply can't handle all his pain. Jensen is PHENOMENAL in this episode (as usual!). Jared is fabulous here too, and both boys should have been recognized for their tremendous work.
Your reaction was wonderful as always!! Can not WAIT to watch the 2 part season finale with you. If you do watch them back-to-back, will you post them together?
Loving going through this journey with you. ❤️
Not that I have seen much of the series yet, but this is for sure one of my favourite episodes too! Their acting is amazing, and even thought this was one of the most difficult to watch it was so well made.
My heart was totally broken, seeing what Deans dream is - and having to watch him live it only to get it all ripped away (again). 😭 You can see how much he wants to stay, and how badly he wants this to be real, but he would give up that close to perfect dream to get back home to Sammy!!
It makes sense that it was from Deans mind, that was I was assuming but I probably wasn't very clear about that. It made it was sadder knowing this is what he wished for!! I thought the same about their dad, that maybe he just didn't want him to suffer which sort of made same... but it almost makes more sense that he wasn't able to be in the episode LMAO I also agree, I think Dean feels guilty even thought he shouldn't! I didn't think about the fact that Dean feels like he is a bad brother in relation to this but I can see that affecting this world for sure! Maybe it was almost like a part of himself wanted to punish him for not being a (what he deem) "perfect" brother to Sam... 😭 That kills me to because he is the best brother omg!!!
This was a great episodes on so many levels, but my heart breaks just thinking about it haha. I appreciate you watching and I'm so happy you enjoyed it!!
@@CoraReacts The last two episodes in S3 aren't a two-parter. Of course there's lots of build up to the end of the season, but technically they're separate episodes. There are only 16 episodes in S3 because of the writer's strike that took place in Hollywood in 2008, much like what's happening now. As for watching the last two back-to-back, of course, as always, you can only do what you can do. Don't overextend yourself. ❤
I gotta say that I came in a little late to the party as well. However I'm loving watching your reactions ❤
No such thing as being late, and I’ve still got many seasons to go at this point. I’m so glad your enjoying them!🥰
@@CoraReactsHi Cora, I think what she meant by "being late to the party" was that she started watching Supernatural later than their 2005 release date, sama as a lot of people (myself included) I watched it for the 1st time in 2020 during the pandemic, but I've seen it at least 15 more times since then, lol!)
Loved this episode ❤I cryed so much 🥺😪😭🤧
Me too!! Amazing episode that led to lots and lots of tears!😭
Say what you want, but the djinn's tattoos are wicked. It was nice to see what the brother's lives would've looked like if Mary didn't die, but it is also sad to see that Dean and Sam wouldn't be as close as we all know them to be. Glad Dean woke up! the starting confused me to begin with when I saw Sammy had a law book, then it clicked, but it was still confusing! lol.
Great reaction, though! ohhhh, now I can't wait for the next episode, keep tissues in hand!
Happy Pride month!
Agreed!! The tattoos are really cool. It was such an interesting episode to see in to another possibility but it was hard to watch for the heart 🫣 I get being confused by the law book haha! Thank you for watching, I’m happy you enjoyed it. Happy pride month! 🏳️🌈
Ok call me a jerk or asshole but why do I feel like most of reactors i have seen are always team sam ( maybe i'm absolutely wrong or just imagining ). I've always seen that if it's about Dean then they feel like "it's kinda sad", but when it's about Sam they literally are crying or sobbing or using tissue. Please correct me if I'm wrong, because that's what I have observed from tons of reactors. Only some of them feel the same for both brother's. When something is about to happen to Dean, they are not as worried as When something is about to happen to Sam. I saw many reactors react something happening to Dean like "it's sad, i feel bad for sam". And when something is happening to sam, they are like "don't u think about it, never ever touch my precious sam, don't hurt him", they literally scream about Sam.
OK NOW I'M OFFICIALLY IMAGINING
Dean girl here.. I get wet eyes every time too. There is 1 reaction channel..in s07.. she's a Bobby girl.. also gets weepy in the emo ones.
@@HealthyDisrespectforAuthority Yeah You're right, they are people who feel the same for both brother's, but those are few, while most of them that I have seen are literally sobbing about Sam. If something happens to Dean, in that scenario they literally feel bad for Sam. I love both brother's equally, like if i shed tears for sam then i shed tears for Dean too. İn this show I have used countless tissues because the tissues have been used for both brother's not just for one.
İ'M JUST SAYING..
@@Benedict649 ~~~growl~~~ I was halfway through my comment (on the drop down notification thing) and youtube redirected me to the home page and poof.. comment gone.. grrrrrrr and me, without a working 'e' key.. all of them are pasted in.
I guess I've watched reactions more from team Winchester folks than Dean vs Sam girls.
I get confused by s that don't get moist eyes
I'm in the *when Jensen Ackles cries,I cry* camp
I don't think I have ever mentioned being team anyone at this point tbh, and from what I know most seem to be team Dean if anything haha. But bothers are amazing so whichever anyone likes more us valid. I also feel like Dean giving me one tear (singular) breaks me quicker lol. I love them both so much!
If you want to watch another reactor that also feels strongly for both brothers, try checking out Imon_Snow! She’s on season 3 right now, nearing the end. She had to take a break a couple years ago, but she’s back reacting to it now! She usually have some very long talks after each episode, that I personally love to listen to. She just seems very insightful and calming. Idk if I’m explaining this very well lol, I just really love her reactions 😂
She’s a total Dean girl, but she loves Sam just as much 🥰
Idk if it’s bad etiquette to recommend another person’s channel in someone’s comment section, so if it is I’m sorry 😅 there are just very few good reactors to Supernatural out there, and I believe both Cora and Imon are among the great ones! 🌸❤️
Btw, I’ve made a playlist of Imon’s Supernatural reactions on my page, because she doesn’t have a proper one herself yet. So if you want all the episode reactions in order, feel free to check it out! 😁