I agree. Im not a fan of autotune but its used here the right way; to enhance the track. Its simply just an instrument on this track not a tool to hide behind like it is normally used for. Kanye has a beautiful singing voice and doesnt need it. He uses it as an instrument. Genius!!!
They released 3 songs from those sessions. The last is All Day. McCartney and Ye were talking in the studio about art when McCartney mentioned a painting he saw of guitarist playing a chord. McCartney played the few a few times and said wouldn't it be cool to make a while song using that chord. He didn't think He was paying attention so he changed topics. 3 months later Ye sent him the song All Day using the chord there out and gave McCartney a writing credit on th song. Paul calls it the easy song he ever wrote.
Nice review guys! It's probably in my top 5 or so of Kanye songs, I think I threw this up on a livestream a week or two ago. Looking at some of the other comments I get the criticism of the autotune, I think words like awful are a little extreme but that's the beauty of music opinions :P ... It can be a little distracting if you're really focusing on the vocal but I - personally - think the softness, stripped back, raw lyricism works really well in the song and as a tribute to his mother, is a really sweet homage to her. Almost like we aren't really supposed to hear the song at all but we're peeking through a crack in the door to get a glimpse of some real Kanye ;)
Honestly, I can’t wait for people who can’t accept auto-tune as an instrument to disappear. You can’t write and sing anymore from the heart than this - but y’all would rather Adele sing it for him or something? Just sad.
Shawn and Gina, This is cool, Kanye West collaboration with the great Paul McCartney. I think it is a sweet and catchy piece of music in the arrangement and instrumentation like you said Shawn. I agree, it has a chilled out sound.The melody is very nice. The lyrics are bittersweet and beautiful. I agree Gina about the well sung vocals. No wonder it is such a nice song, McCartney co-wrote it and probably inspired Kanye on this song. I really like this song and both of your heartfelt comments in your reaction.
Kia ora ( hello) Shawn and Gina hay now the puzzle pieces are all in place nice to meet you Gina.. hay guys have you ever heard Manic Street Preachers? IF no i really think you would like their song motorcycle Emptiness! and or (if you tolerate this your children will be next) please stay safe you good people Sean brother what a wonderful family
Oh Yes ! Love The Manics they are a Great band 🔥 A Design for life and If you tolerate this is are great ones ! with a harsh video / message . Motorcycle Emptiness is A Fab song too . 👌
Using the search function on Patreon I can see they have reacted to '4st 7lb', 'if you tolerate this...', 'little baby nothing' and I do actually remember the first livestream of theirs I watched they reacted to Motorcycle Emptiness. They liked all of them.
I know just a little bit of Manic Street Preachers. Will check that song out for sure where I concentrate more than a livestream. I am blessed HP no doubt!
Yoiks, what an awful song! Fun reaction, though, of course. Haven't watched many with Gina on board, but for some reason, you guys seem to work well together. Can't imagine why... ;) The autotune is hideous but what the hell, did Paul suddenly forget how to write a halfway decent melody? I mean, it's soul music rather than rap, which should be much more in Paul's wheelhouse, but this goes nowhere slowly until the single saving grace of the song, the slightly less dull electric piano outro. Otherwise, it's just like a billion other hookless, uninteresting modern R&B tracks. I quite like that other song he did with Kanye and Rihanna but this is a real stinker.
Auto tune is the ENEMY of real music it's a very steep slippery slope to musical HELL ..IF YOU CAN'T SING DON'T IT'S LIKE THERE'S ONE PERSON SINGING IN A THOUSAND CRAPPY BAND'S HATE IS A STRONG WORD AND I HATE IT WITH A PASSION
I don’t get the hate on this song in my opinion the auto tune makes the song better and I think the song is really touching and beautiful
Thanks for Watching!
I agree. Im not a fan of autotune but its used here the right way; to enhance the track. Its simply just an instrument on this track not a tool to hide behind like it is normally used for. Kanye has a beautiful singing voice and doesnt need it. He uses it as an instrument. Genius!!!
They released 3 songs from those sessions. The last is All Day. McCartney and Ye were talking in the studio about art when McCartney mentioned a painting he saw of guitarist playing a chord. McCartney played the few a few times and said wouldn't it be cool to make a while song using that chord. He didn't think He was paying attention so he changed topics. 3 months later Ye sent him the song All Day using the chord there out and gave McCartney a writing credit on th song. Paul calls it the easy song he ever wrote.
haha great story appreciate you sharing!
Nice review guys! It's probably in my top 5 or so of Kanye songs, I think I threw this up on a livestream a week or two ago.
Looking at some of the other comments I get the criticism of the autotune, I think words like awful are a little extreme but that's the beauty of music opinions :P ... It can be a little distracting if you're really focusing on the vocal but I - personally - think the softness, stripped back, raw lyricism works really well in the song and as a tribute to his mother, is a really sweet homage to her.
Almost like we aren't really supposed to hear the song at all but we're peeking through a crack in the door to get a glimpse of some real Kanye ;)
Great comment Chris and I agree, it was you bringing this that made me decide to react to it so kudos for that!
Honestly, I can’t wait for people who can’t accept auto-tune as an instrument to disappear. You can’t write and sing anymore from the heart than this - but y’all would rather Adele sing it for him or something? Just sad.
Great point Bryce!
You guys should react to “Ghost Town” by Kanye West soon!
Really appreciate the suggestion and thanks for watching Phoebe S!
Shawn and Gina, This is cool, Kanye West collaboration with the great Paul McCartney. I think it is a sweet and catchy piece of music in the arrangement and instrumentation like you said Shawn. I agree, it has a chilled out sound.The melody is very nice. The lyrics are bittersweet and beautiful. I agree Gina about the well sung vocals. No wonder it is such a nice song, McCartney co-wrote it and probably inspired Kanye on this song. I really like this song and both of your heartfelt comments in your reaction.
Thanks Poet!
@@ReactionsToTheClassics Yes Sir.
Nice choice
Thanks for watching!
A very perspicacious view of the lyrics!
Super appreciate it!
Using perspicacious in a sentence is the biggest flex 💪 congrats 👌
This song is to great
Yes it is. Thanks for watching!
W
Thanks for Watching!
Kia ora ( hello) Shawn and Gina hay now the puzzle pieces are all in place nice to meet you Gina.. hay guys have you ever heard Manic Street Preachers? IF no i really think you would like their song motorcycle Emptiness! and or (if you tolerate this your children will be next) please stay safe you good people Sean brother what a wonderful family
Oh Yes ! Love The Manics they are a Great band 🔥 A Design for life and If you tolerate this is are great ones ! with a harsh video / message . Motorcycle Emptiness is A Fab song too . 👌
Using the search function on Patreon I can see they have reacted to '4st 7lb', 'if you tolerate this...', 'little baby nothing' and I do actually remember the first livestream of theirs I watched they reacted to Motorcycle Emptiness. They liked all of them.
I know just a little bit of Manic Street Preachers. Will check that song out for sure where I concentrate more than a livestream. I am blessed HP no doubt!
My reaction to this song..I threw up in my mouth a little bit..Great video though❤️
Thanks for Watching!
Scared of black people that badly?
greatest thing Paul McCartney has ever been involved in
Yoiks, what an awful song!
Fun reaction, though, of course. Haven't watched many with Gina on board, but for some reason, you guys seem to work well together. Can't imagine why... ;)
The autotune is hideous but what the hell, did Paul suddenly forget how to write a halfway decent melody? I mean, it's soul music rather than rap, which should be much more in Paul's wheelhouse, but this goes nowhere slowly until the single saving grace of the song, the slightly less dull electric piano outro. Otherwise, it's just like a billion other hookless, uninteresting modern R&B tracks. I quite like that other song he did with Kanye and Rihanna but this is a real stinker.
Auto tune is the ENEMY of real music it's a very steep slippery slope to musical HELL ..IF YOU CAN'T SING DON'T IT'S LIKE THERE'S ONE PERSON SINGING IN A THOUSAND CRAPPY BAND'S HATE IS A STRONG WORD AND I HATE IT WITH A PASSION
@@heathcornbeef Yeah, autotune is to singing what saccharine is to sugar: flat, artificial and lifeless.
If Paul McCartney can't save your song, nobody can. It must be how people in DC Universe feel when even Superman can't save them. :)
@@ilash81 that is absolutely wickedly Spot on LOVE IT
@@270yis7 listen to kanye west all falls down. He doesnt need anyone to "save" his music