If I had to choose 1 at MSRP(ish), it would be EHTBP because they’re a lot harder to get in my area. But I personally prefer the taste of Stagg for now. Cheers!
Can't argue with that. I've only had EHTBP batches 12 and 10 and absolutely loved both flavor profiles. Don't get me wrong, I also love Stagg, but finding EHTBP Is so much harder for me.
That's awesome Andrew! Do you mind telling what you paid for both? If you don't want to give specifics, was it around MSRP, Slightly over MSRP, or Way over MSRP? 🙂 Cheers and thanks for watching!
The BT EHT line is my favorite line in all of bourbon. I was lucky to finally get a BP last November for a reasonable markup. It’s in my top 5 bourbons of all time. I only have a Stagg store pick and it’s good, but not great. I’d have to try more. Cheers!
definitely agree with that I have two bottles of stag I have zero EH Taylor foolproof so if it came to it I had both of them in front of me I would choose the EH Taylor as well for that reason but stag is amazing
Can't argue with thay Dave...and don't take this as I don't love Stagg too. But to me EHTBP is so much harder to find, especially at a reasonable price, that I pick that. I also have loved the two (Batch 12 and 10) bottles I've tried. Cheers buddy.
Easily EHT Barrel Proof. In the one year of me casually hunting, I’ve found 4 Stagg’s for MSRP. I have only seen $300+ EHT Barrel Proofs until today when I finally stumbled upon one at $89.99. Excited to crack it and compare them
I've gotten three Stagg's before getting lucky this weekend and getting that EH Taylor batch 12. I agree with the hard to come by choice of the eh taylor. Although this year I'd love to come by a Stagg sp.
Yup, EHTBP, especially at msrp; batch 12 is delicious. Have plenty of Stagg (Jr), but only managed to grab an EHTBP (with a SiB & SB for a total of $300 for the vertical). So, I could definitely use another.
I by no means don't have plenty of Stagg but have a few and see them much more than EHTBP batches. So I'm sort of in the same boat. Cheers and thanks for watching!
@@2TEN90 After admittedly overpaying for Stagg Jr batches 15 & 17 (a great one IMO) I was fortunate to have established a good relationship with a local liquor store and have been able to get the last 5 batches of Stagg at just a tad over msrp.
A MD museum selling EHTBP batch 8 129.3 proof for $799. Rock Hill Farms for $299 and Stagg Batch 18 for $299. Made an offer for all 3 at a much, much lower price bc they’re likely all gonna sit for another several years That EHT is a 2019 release. Will let you know how it turns out.
The only EH P I had was just mediocre so it must have just been the batch, which happens. So, without the influence of your video, I’d have to go with the one that’s put me in a happy place; Stagg.
Can't argue with that and please don't take this as I am not a huge fan of Stagg, because I am, I just don't get the opportunity to get EH Taylor BP bottles very often, so when I do, I would choose that over Stagg. But I love both bottles!
Mark I was exactly the same until I was able to grab a bottle of Batch 12 for under $100 and had a sample of Batch 10. Now I need more! Lol Cheers buddy and thanks for watching.
If I had to choose 1 at MSRP(ish), it would be EHTBP because they’re a lot harder to get in my area. But I personally prefer the taste of Stagg for now. Cheers!
Can't argue with that. I've only had EHTBP batches 12 and 10 and absolutely loved both flavor profiles. Don't get me wrong, I also love Stagg, but finding EHTBP Is so much harder for me.
Stagg jr, stagg and George T Stagg are my all time favorites. I’m always going stagg
I have both, but it's EHT barrel for the win. I would always grab that too.
Never seen them in person, I’d go with Taylor from what everyone recommends though. 🤷♂️. I’d be happy with either one.
Just acquired both! Only opened the Taylor batch 12 and absolutely loved it! Saving the Stagg for a rainy day 😂
That's awesome Andrew! Do you mind telling what you paid for both? If you don't want to give specifics, was it around MSRP, Slightly over MSRP, or Way over MSRP? 🙂 Cheers and thanks for watching!
The BT EHT line is my favorite line in all of bourbon. I was lucky to finally get a BP last November for a reasonable markup. It’s in my top 5 bourbons of all time. I only have a Stagg store pick and it’s good, but not great. I’d have to try more. Cheers!
Never had the EHTBP. I agree with you, until proven otherwise.
This was actually my first bottle thanks to Justin at Allview Liquors in Elkridge Md that sold it for more around msrp at $89! Cheers!
definitely agree with that I have two bottles of stag I have zero EH Taylor foolproof so if it came to it I had both of them in front of me I would choose the EH Taylor as well for that reason but stag is amazing
Same here George, I love Stagg but seem to find bottles much easier than EHTBP. Cheers and thanks for watching.
Taylor. Hope to snag one tomorrow
EHT barrel proof? Come on! Stagg for the win!
This is the hardest one yett.
I would go with Stagg.
EH Taylor is a very specific profile while stagg is always a wild card and that's exciting.
Got my first EHT Barrel Proof batch 12. I have 10 bottles of Stagg (Jr). I would buy another Stagg. 🥃
Can't argue with thay Dave...and don't take this as I don't love Stagg too. But to me EHTBP is so much harder to find, especially at a reasonable price, that I pick that. I also have loved the two (Batch 12 and 10) bottles I've tried. Cheers buddy.
@@2TEN90 Good point!
I have Staggs going for the EHTBP
Easily EHT Barrel Proof. In the one year of me casually hunting, I’ve found 4 Stagg’s for MSRP. I have only seen $300+ EHT Barrel Proofs until today when I finally stumbled upon one at $89.99. Excited to crack it and compare them
Great score finding it for that price! Which batch is it? Cheers!
@@2TEN90 it’s the latest batch, batch 12!
I've gotten three Stagg's before getting lucky this weekend and getting that EH Taylor batch 12. I agree with the hard to come by choice of the eh taylor. Although this year I'd love to come by a Stagg sp.
Yup, EHTBP, especially at msrp; batch 12 is delicious. Have plenty of Stagg (Jr), but only managed to grab an EHTBP (with a SiB & SB for a total of $300 for the vertical). So, I could definitely use another.
I by no means don't have plenty of Stagg but have a few and see them much more than EHTBP batches. So I'm sort of in the same boat. Cheers and thanks for watching!
@@2TEN90 After admittedly overpaying for Stagg Jr batches 15 & 17 (a great one IMO) I was fortunate to have established a good relationship with a local liquor store and have been able to get the last 5 batches of Stagg at just a tad over msrp.
Do you get a cherry syrup finish on bakers 7? I don’t love it at the end…
The 24A Stagg tastes off profile like an EHT Barrel Proof. Given cost, I’ll take the Stagg
Stagg Jr 17 was the best bottle I ever drank..hands down I'd buy it over EH Taylor.
EH is Taylor Barrel Proof? And I love both so I'm not arguing your point, but EHTBP to me is really special and hard to find.
Agree. But I have more Stagg because it’s more affordable at secondary
Stagg for me.
Can't argue with that...both are fantastic.
I've never had the EHTBP, but I'd sure buy it if I find it at MSRP!
A MD museum selling EHTBP batch 8 129.3 proof for $799. Rock Hill Farms for $299 and Stagg Batch 18 for $299. Made an offer for all 3 at a much, much lower price bc they’re likely all gonna sit for another several years That EHT is a 2019 release. Will let you know how it turns out.
Where is said MD museum...need to make sure to never go in there! Lol but I hope you score all three for significantly lower! Cheers!
@@2TEN90 there’s at least a dozen of these I know. If they make a reasonable deal, I’ll throw them a bone.
2Ten90: Linthicum Heights?
@@Michael_Peters yep!!! Are you near there?
Stagg all day.
Stagg all day long.
I've not ever tried either.
The only EH P I had was just mediocre so it must have just been the batch, which happens. So, without the influence of your video, I’d have to go with the one that’s put me in a happy place; Stagg.
Can't argue with that and please don't take this as I am not a huge fan of Stagg, because I am, I just don't get the opportunity to get EH Taylor BP bottles very often, so when I do, I would choose that over Stagg. But I love both bottles!
@@2TEN90 Your message was clear, and I agree that EHBP is more the unicorn. Darn it!
EHT is the grab, it goes for twice as much secondary
Now it is Stagg, but that may change after I get a EHTBP and can try it.
Mark I was exactly the same until I was able to grab a bottle of Batch 12 for under $100 and had a sample of Batch 10. Now I need more! Lol Cheers buddy and thanks for watching.
I agree!
EH TAYLOR BARREL PROOF!!
EHTBP for me
Stagg
EHTBP 👍
Agreed! Cheers buddy!
Same. Found stagg at msrp was excited drank it, did not like it. Basically really hot cinnamon imo
Stagg!
Seems like Stagg is the viewers choice tonight! I'm in the minority lol
EHT BP
Eh all day!!!
100% agreed!
17 for me
Seems like that is the viewers choice today!
Taylor
stagg not even close for my area in a drop
Stagg is better