@HiddenScholar Also, at our schools we are taught this at an advanced level, while most schools use this as a beginning level form. The beginning level is the more common traditional use of this form, so a comparison to our school learning this just before black sash is not fair at all.
@MajinStar That was not Chan Family Choy Lee Fut Im training CLF by Chan Family and that is not Ng Lun Ma from CLF by Chan Family is similar but there is so many differents things
It is very similar to the form I learned in the 90's from someone who learned it from the Chan Family. The part after the second Dip Jeong/ Don Lon combination is a little different than the form I was taught but everything up to that is about the same. Most of the time when I see a video of this form it is the variant taught by Doc Fai Wong, which is vastly different in many respects, in fact this is only the second time I have seen a form that was in any way similar to what I learned from Sifu Spencer in Fresno back in the 90's (the first was just before I watched this video but was only a partial demonstration ending just after the second Tau Ma in that sequence.
@@EVENINGWOLF666 I learned the Doc Fai Wong version in the 80's. The only hands were opening and closing. Everything in the middle was all stance work, with a couple of poon cue/kwan cue towards the end.
@HiddenScholar This post is not in line with the teachings of WD schools. We are taught to let our martial arts training and practice speak for itself and to be respectful of other martial artists. We are NOT supposed to say things along the lines of "my lineage or school's way is better than yours." I have been a student for 7 years. I don't know if you are a new student and haven't been taught this yet or a longer term student who just forgot. I suggest you validate this by asking your Sifu.
Buenas noches, sí es la forma Ng Lu Ma, pero está mal hecha, no hace bien los movimientos, además de que están muy flojos, posiciones muy altas, etcétera
This is identical to the ng lun ma taught to me years ago!
Thank you for posting the video.
es muy parecido a como me enseñaron la forma a mi, en mi caso las tecnicas de manos son diferentes a las tuyas. Gracias por compartir.
me gusto mucho el video bastante didactico e ilustrativo. Saludos David!!!
This is the firts form of Choy Li Fut?
@HiddenScholar Also, at our schools we are taught this at an advanced level, while most schools use this as a beginning level form. The beginning level is the more common traditional use of this form, so a comparison to our school learning this just before black sash is not fair at all.
this is a well performed chan family choy lee fut ng lun ma
Very sloppy. Its a dead form. Would look better if he was more serious and took his time.
Good video, when did you post the Ng Lun Choy Complete?
Ng Lun Ma? Never seen hand work in that form before.
bueno la verdad si le mete mas fuerza y baja mas la posision le podria dar un mejor resultado
que deng jing ma é esse ?
@MajinStar That was not Chan Family Choy Lee Fut Im training CLF by Chan Family and that is not Ng Lun Ma from CLF by Chan Family is similar but there is so many differents things
It is very similar to the form I learned in the 90's from someone who learned it from the Chan Family. The part after the second Dip Jeong/ Don Lon combination is a little different than the form I was taught but everything up to that is about the same. Most of the time when I see a video of this form it is the variant taught by Doc Fai Wong, which is vastly different in many respects, in fact this is only the second time I have seen a form that was in any way similar to what I learned from Sifu Spencer in Fresno back in the 90's (the first was just before I watched this video but was only a partial demonstration ending just after the second Tau Ma in that sequence.
@@EVENINGWOLF666 I learned the Doc Fai Wong version in the 80's. The only hands were opening and closing. Everything in the middle was all stance work, with a couple of poon cue/kwan cue towards the end.
@HiddenScholar This post is not in line with the teachings of WD schools. We are taught to let our martial arts training and practice speak for itself and to be respectful of other martial artists. We are NOT supposed to say things along the lines of "my lineage or school's way is better than yours." I have been a student for 7 years. I don't know if you are a new student and haven't been taught this yet or a longer term student who just forgot. I suggest you validate this by asking your Sifu.
tem muitos erros mas cada escola é diferente, e tem maneiras diferentes de ensinar ... eu gosto mais como faço!! mas parabens
Buenas noches, sí es la forma Ng Lu Ma, pero está mal hecha, no hace bien los movimientos, además de que están muy flojos, posiciones muy altas, etcétera
puedes subir un video del ng lu ma bien hecho
wow, he's really rushing through the set. speed in such a foundational form isn't as important as good grounding and posture. just sayin...
When we did ng lun ma it took us an hour.
Horrible His Ng Lun Ma