I am going to be an eternal fan because this is the only climate change video to my knowledge that has admitted that the earths relation to the sun at any given point in time is a pred ominant factor in the wo r lds climate
Tks. for this.:) Nice to see the volcano Tambora in 1815 "in the mix"... Crop failures meant horses were dying and in Germany Baron Karl von Drais invented his wooden "running machine" to get around... (think "bicycle") :)
Some rather odd ideas. Warming after 100BC allowed the Romans to conquer Germania (and presumably Gaul). But before 100BC was Rome actually interested in conquering Gaul and Germania? Rome had been involved in conslidating and maintaining their position in the Mediterranean against Carthage until 146BC. In the cold period before 100BC, the Chinese Empire consolidated (221BC) and flourished and built its wall. This is followed immediately by stating that that the Romans built their Linus Germanicus, which appears to suggest contemporaneity with the Great Wall of China! Rome conquered Gaul in 55-52BC and and started on the Germans then, not in 200BC. A cooling period caused Varus in 9AD to be cleaned up by the Germans and yet only 35 years later Rome expanded in Britain? Seems to invalidate the commentary a bit. The 536 AD Ilipango eruption caused cooling; this would not have lasted more than about 10 years at best and yet the sunspot warming that ended this volcanic cooling event triggered the Moslem expansion into Europe in the 700sAD and the Viking expansion in the late 799sAD? Sunspot cycles last about 11 years. Same sort of jumping around about the great plague of Europe in the 1340s. The Little Ice Age which began around the early 1300s and is said to have continued to at least 1815 and caused mayhem and utter disaster across Europe also saw massive imperial expansion by Portugal, the Lithuanian-Polish Empire (all the way to Moscow), Spain, France and last but no means least, Britain culminating in around the 1840-50s in India, Burma and China after the north Americas, and Australia and New Zealand. The Little Ice Age did not curtail European imperial expansion. The desire for spices, and the discovery of coal and development of industry in Britain were the key factors. The French Revolution? The country had bankrupted itself by 1783 through saving the USA from the brutal, evil, vile, tyrannical and licentious impost of the British taxation system. And yes, a "few decades" after the 536AD volcanic event dense (oak) forests grew across Europe. How long does it take to fully grow a mature oak forest across Europe? 100 years? Yes, climate does affect civilisations but this piece is a gross over-simplification if not also a confusion of events. The "music" is horrible.
Typical of these documentaries being so chronologically out of order it is difficult to understand the sequence of events; talk about one age, skip to another, then back again?
First the Romans could not cross the Alps because of icy conditions. Later the 10 000s of Goths could enter the Empire because the rivers, like the Rhine had frozen. Why couldn't the Roman army, before the warm epoque, have entered Germania on the frozen rivers as well? And if not via the Alps, then from the west, from Gallia which was a Roman province?
This is a * superb * documentary! Well done. . Near the end, she said the weather warmed in 1850. I'm wondering if there was cold, rainy weather in Ireland, which started the potato famine. . Does anyone know? Ferris Bueller, Ferris Bueller, anyone?
@Term limits Com the fungi that causes blight has been around for ages. The problems was that farmers in Ireland (and other parts of Europe) were growing a particular type of potatoes. One type. And when the disease hit it spread like wildfire.
Crazy how this documentary ignores how climate influenced settling of the American continents, and the spread of European empires into other parts of the world. It's well known that a major reason for British colonization of America was that the southern states were very good for agriculture while northern states had dense forests perfect for lumber in constructing ships and buildings.
Seriously if you put the words Weather or Climate in any video regardless of content, YT puts that BS "Context Box" up. Everyone send feedback and tell YT that is not the context of this video.
They sort of lost me around the 20-21 minute area. They're talking about the 532 AD eruption, its affect on climate, then the outbreak of bubonic plague, which affected the east, then they're immediately talking about the 14th C plague which affected the west as well. The way it's presented here is like the plague continued for some 900 years instead of disappearing back into the Far East and central Asia during that time period.
I noticed that, too. Not sure if it was a glitch or an editing job. I do know that bubonic plague killed millions of people. It was strange, yet explained so much just to watch this put into perspective.
That is exactly what I was going to mention. Right on point. There is a huge mismatch between the Ilopango eruption (which probably created the conditions for the Justinian plague) and the Black Death which happened almost a millennium after that.
It didn't disappear, it became endemic, and there were outbreaks consistently for around 900 years. Until a Vaccine was developed, and a specific antibiotic was developed as well.
@@maracohen5930 Yes, it was continues to endemic in the east, primarily living in marmots which (like flu in birds) doesn't seem to affect their health. Whether the bacterium mutated to a less lethal variety or simply died out in the west, it didn't continue to annihilate people during that 800 year period, though regular outbreaks continued well after the 14th century. Again what I'm referring to is this video's time treatment.
This video is really interesting 😳 but whether now the planet has already changing I don’t know what will happen to the human population but in this world nature is what I live for 😎 deforestation all that stuff 😞 without the balance of nature and species what will happen only nature has humans fate after all🙂 out of all the life on earth we were are more the half way there until total extinction for all species on this planet 4 billion years to go
yeah because stopping volcanoes and controlling the Sun's Behavior and the Earth's orbit around it is totally within our power right? I think we will continue to be controlled by the climate.
33:58 warsaw was built as a new capital of Lithuanian-polish commonwealth after 1569 union in the place of one of Lithuanian tribe's (Yotvingi...in earlier history whole Europe north-east of Rhein was called Germania that ended where Europe ended - along the river Don or Tanai) fortress by Lithuanian king who took and polish crown...so Hague and Amsterdam was already some 1000 years old
Interesting presentation. There is no question that climate has had a significant impact on life on earth and the advancement of humankind. As presented, volcanoes, solar cycles, orbital cycles, and precession have statistically and logically coherent effects on climate. One glaring omission is that they left out the effects of extra-terrestrial impacts. It is very likely, that such impacts had a very significant impact (pun intended) on climate at the end of the last major glaciation, and on the mass extinction of most dinosaurs at the end of the Cretaceous. Given the frequency of such events on the lunar and Martian landscapes, these events are not uncommon on geologic timescales. In the light of all the evidence presented of natural variability in climate, it was very disappointing to hear the theory of dangerous, CO2 driven climate change presented as fact at the end of an otherwise relatively accurate documentary. While CO2 clearly has some effect on temperature, it is unclear how much of recent warming is due to the natural variability of climate presented so effectively throughout the film versus the CO2 forcing theory presented at the end. As presented, the current warming started at the end of the little ice age (1850). More than half of the warming in the last 100 years happened before 1950......that is before rapid increases human generated CO2. Since the 1950's, warming has continued at, on average, the same rate as prior to 1950. In light of all the evidence, it is very unlikely that man-made CO2 is having a dangerously urgent effect on climate. In the unlikely event that it is, a much better way to address the issue is to promote the development of safe, inexpensive, CO2-free, thorium based nuclear power. With unlimited, inexpensive energy from safe molten-salt thorium reactors, carbon sequestration actually become feasible in the unlikely event that it is needed at some point in the future.
+Roy Shirkey Everyone _knows_ that nothing exists until a white man "discovers" it! +Laura Bunyard I'd add the Polynesians in there. It's not even controversial anymore.
This was a great doc, until the end. They showed how warm was good and man prospered. They showed that when it cooled man was fucked. Warm, few storms and everything was good. Cold, violent storms, crops failed and mega storms. How the hell can they, with the doc, come up with the analysis that they did. They admit climate changes. They admit that the Roman period was very warm. They admit the little ice age. This is far better than Mann. How the hell can they say that the warming after the little ice age is caused by man? How the hell can they say warming is bad?
You know what I Ben hearing on the news recently we are living within the 6th mass extinction right now it depends on how much people care about the environment the more people still Pollute the planet after the covid-19 crisis the more we will suffer but no matter what climate/nature will always effect us
35:40 in 1250 AD Lithuania already was from Crimea till Gotland island or from Ruggen island (even later several military campaigns against crusaders were as far as Elbe river and in 1155 AD Lithuanian religion city Arkona/Alkona was exterminated by killing 300 000 Arkona/Alkona city dwellers where one of 3 holly pagan eternal flame places was situated that in Lithuanian language is called Alkas) till Karelia and was fighting against crusaders and mongols at the same time from both sides
It's ridiciolles think, that we can make primar impact on wearher. So both films show, that nature itself change weather on planet in it is sick to think, that NOW people can do something?????
Dear children of Iceland the hardest language to learn echo... May I? hazards and catastrophes. Don't try to scare us. unless you feel you need to I suggest Beethoven...or doomsday....if you live too close to the Arctic circle you will freeze first wurst
It's a pity this video ended with self ridicule and humiliation. After presenting evidence of historical naturally caused disasters of enormous magnitude she trots out the ridiculous man-made climate change b..s. after assuring us that climate change is caused principally by the sun and volcanic activity. This at a time when earth's climate is very benign and stable without a shred of verifiable evidence to suggest any impending disaster. Words, rhetoric, contradictions, and outlandish assumptions do not affect the climate.
whatever you say, as long as we make the maximum number of people to suffer while this worsening of the climate takes place manmade or 'au natural'...like the god you probably think created me in his image I am a vindictive psychopath after all and little kids choking and dying next to a factory or a volcano give me a hard on. No matter if it's carbon or carbon dioxide based.
Harvey Harrison Climate change is accelerated by human activity. Believing or not, there are not enough natural resources on this planet to sustain the overpopulation. Bottom line, too many people!
I am going to be an eternal fan because this is the only climate change video to my knowledge that has admitted that the earths relation to the sun at any given point in time is a pred ominant factor in the wo r lds climate
Many Thanks! We are glad to hear that.
Subscribe to the channel!
Yes. Milankovitch Cycles.
BUT News Media, Democrats, & sadly, some scientists don't want you to know that!
Until the end where they threw in the AGW BS.
Even though I don't like Gaia, it has a few good videos (Gregg Braden) on climate change too.
@@mschroed99 They probably had to say that or TH-cam wouldn't have aired this documentary.
Part 1 & part 2 are good videos. The part about witch hunts is particularly important, disgusting, but important.
It’s clear the last guy interviewed did not understand the rest of the documentary
Tks. for this.:) Nice to see the volcano Tambora in 1815 "in the mix"... Crop failures meant horses were dying and in Germany Baron Karl von Drais invented his wooden "running machine" to get around... (think "bicycle") :)
Interesting. I don´t know if everything is so exactly correlated, but an interesting thesis nevertheless.
They don't know for sure so they guess based on the info they currently have
@@Twiztidjuggalo42000 like pretty much everyone does regarding events not personally witnessed
Some rather odd ideas. Warming after 100BC allowed the Romans to conquer Germania (and presumably Gaul). But before 100BC was Rome actually interested in conquering Gaul and Germania? Rome had been involved in conslidating and maintaining their position in the Mediterranean against Carthage until 146BC. In the cold period before 100BC, the Chinese Empire consolidated (221BC) and flourished and built its wall. This is followed immediately by stating that that the Romans built their Linus Germanicus, which appears to suggest contemporaneity with the Great Wall of China! Rome conquered Gaul in 55-52BC and and started on the Germans then, not in 200BC.
A cooling period caused Varus in 9AD to be cleaned up by the Germans and yet only 35 years later Rome expanded in Britain? Seems to invalidate the commentary a bit. The 536 AD Ilipango eruption caused cooling; this would not have lasted more than about 10 years at best and yet the sunspot warming that ended this volcanic cooling event triggered the Moslem expansion into Europe in the 700sAD and the Viking expansion in the late 799sAD? Sunspot cycles last about 11 years. Same sort of jumping around about the great plague of Europe in the 1340s.
The Little Ice Age which began around the early 1300s and is said to have continued to at least 1815 and caused mayhem and utter disaster across Europe also saw massive imperial expansion by Portugal, the Lithuanian-Polish Empire (all the way to Moscow), Spain, France and last but no means least, Britain culminating in around the 1840-50s in India, Burma and China after the north Americas, and Australia and New Zealand.
The Little Ice Age did not curtail European imperial expansion. The desire for spices, and the discovery of coal and development of industry in Britain were the key factors.
The French Revolution? The country had bankrupted itself by 1783 through saving the USA from the brutal, evil, vile, tyrannical and licentious impost of the British taxation system.
And yes, a "few decades" after the 536AD volcanic event dense (oak) forests grew across Europe. How long does it take to fully grow a mature oak forest across Europe? 100 years?
Yes, climate does affect civilisations but this piece is a gross over-simplification if not also a confusion of events. The "music" is horrible.
I too have noticed that the Creator does things His own way, in spite of all the good advice I give Him.
Fire in the sky, in that painting depicting St Mary Magdaline's Floods. Comets, perhaps? July 1342, so summer Taurids?
Я тоже здесь))
Qin emperor wore Manchu costume, that’s funny
Typical of these documentaries being so chronologically out of order it is difficult to understand the sequence of events; talk about one age, skip to another, then back again?
First the Romans could not cross the Alps because of icy conditions. Later the 10 000s of Goths could enter the Empire because the rivers, like the Rhine had frozen. Why couldn't the Roman army, before the warm epoque, have entered Germania on the frozen rivers as well? And if not via the Alps, then from the west, from Gallia which was a Roman province?
🎥🎬👀
😊🍕
This is a * superb * documentary! Well done.
.
Near the end, she said the weather warmed in 1850. I'm wondering if there was cold, rainy weather in Ireland, which started the potato famine.
.
Does anyone know? Ferris Bueller, Ferris Bueller, anyone?
Good question! and thank you so much for your lovely words. We are very happy that you like that documentary.
@Term limits Com the fungi that causes blight has been around for ages.
The problems was that farmers in Ireland (and other parts of Europe) were growing a particular type of potatoes. One type. And when the disease hit it spread like wildfire.
Crazy how this documentary ignores how climate influenced settling of the American continents, and the spread of European empires into other parts of the world. It's well known that a major reason for British colonization of America was that the southern states were very good for agriculture while northern states had dense forests perfect for lumber in constructing ships and buildings.
Interesting, though I find the history somewhat distorted
The winners write the histories.
This is vague. When exactly did the cooling of the Roman empire set in? When did the Romans rebel because of food shortage?
solar minimum mate. Sun cycles are the cause of all things here on earth. we are going into a new minimum, watch the changes happen in real tiime
Actually after watching all of it the time line is all over the place
Seriously if you put the words Weather or Climate in any video regardless of content, YT puts that BS "Context Box" up. Everyone send feedback and tell YT that is not the context of this video.
They sort of lost me around the 20-21 minute area. They're talking about the 532 AD eruption, its affect on climate, then the outbreak of bubonic plague, which affected the east, then they're immediately talking about the 14th C plague which affected the west as well. The way it's presented here is like the plague continued for some 900 years instead of disappearing back into the Far East and central Asia during that time period.
I noticed that, too. Not sure if it was a glitch or an editing job. I do know that bubonic plague killed millions of people. It was strange, yet explained so much just to watch this put into perspective.
That is exactly what I was going to mention. Right on point. There is a huge mismatch between the Ilopango eruption (which probably created the conditions for the Justinian plague) and the Black Death which happened almost a millennium after that.
It didn't disappear, it became endemic, and there were outbreaks consistently for around 900 years. Until a Vaccine was developed, and a specific antibiotic was developed as well.
@@maracohen5930 Yes, it was continues to endemic in the east, primarily living in marmots which (like flu in birds) doesn't seem to affect their health. Whether the bacterium mutated to a less lethal variety or simply died out in the west, it didn't continue to annihilate people during that 800 year period, though regular outbreaks continued well after the 14th century. Again what I'm referring to is this video's time treatment.
This video is really interesting 😳 but whether now the planet has already changing I don’t know what will happen to the human population but in this world nature is what I live for 😎 deforestation all that stuff 😞 without the balance of nature and species what will happen only nature has humans fate after all🙂 out of all the life on earth we were are more the half way there until total extinction for all species on this planet 4 billion years to go
That´s so true! We should take climate change more seriously and help the planet heal.
Why is part 2 same as part 1?
We're going to control the climate ??? Did you not watch the video ??
yeah because stopping volcanoes and controlling the Sun's Behavior and the Earth's orbit around it is totally within our power right? I think we will continue to be controlled by the climate.
33:58 warsaw was built as a new capital of Lithuanian-polish commonwealth after 1569 union in the place of one of Lithuanian tribe's (Yotvingi...in earlier history whole Europe north-east of Rhein was called Germania that ended where Europe ended - along the river Don or Tanai) fortress by Lithuanian king who took and polish crown...so Hague and Amsterdam was already some 1000 years old
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Balts#/media/File:Baltic_Tribes_c_1200.svg they were not on the teritory of Warsaw.
Interesting presentation. There is no question that climate has had a significant impact on life on earth and the advancement of humankind. As presented, volcanoes, solar cycles, orbital cycles, and precession have statistically and logically coherent effects on climate. One glaring omission is that they left out the effects of extra-terrestrial impacts. It is very likely, that such impacts had a very significant impact (pun intended) on climate at the end of the last major glaciation, and on the mass extinction of most dinosaurs at the end of the Cretaceous. Given the frequency of such events on the lunar and Martian landscapes, these events are not uncommon on geologic timescales. In the light of all the evidence presented of natural variability in climate, it was very disappointing to hear the theory of dangerous, CO2 driven climate change presented as fact at the end of an otherwise relatively accurate documentary. While CO2 clearly has some effect on temperature, it is unclear how much of recent warming is due to the natural variability of climate presented so effectively throughout the film versus the CO2 forcing theory presented at the end. As presented, the current warming started at the end of the little ice age (1850). More than half of the warming in the last 100 years happened before 1950......that is before rapid increases human generated CO2. Since the 1950's, warming has continued at, on average, the same rate as prior to 1950. In light of all the evidence, it is very unlikely that man-made CO2 is having a dangerously urgent effect on climate. In the unlikely event that it is, a much better way to address the issue is to promote the development of safe, inexpensive, CO2-free, thorium based nuclear power. With unlimited, inexpensive energy from safe molten-salt thorium reactors, carbon sequestration actually become feasible in the unlikely event that it is needed at some point in the future.
Thank you for your feedback.
Don't forget to subscribe.
The sky is falling! The sky is falling!
Columbus did really find nothing he was last at it all
First the Native people. Then the Vikings. Then the Chinese. Then Christoper Columbus.
+Roy Shirkey
Everyone _knows_ that nothing exists until a white man "discovers" it!
+Laura Bunyard
I'd add the Polynesians in there. It's not even controversial anymore.
+Wotan will awake
Oh. Semitic people are white now?
+Wotan will awake
I thought it was a simple question. I'll rephrase to clarify. Are Jews, Arabs, Kurds and Turks all white people?
@@Nmethyltransferase no reply, he must have crawled back inside his hole
This was a great doc, until the end. They showed how warm was good and man prospered. They showed that when it cooled man was fucked. Warm, few storms and everything was good. Cold, violent storms, crops failed and mega storms. How the hell can they, with the doc, come up with the analysis that they did. They admit climate changes. They admit that the Roman period was very warm. They admit the little ice age. This is far better than Mann. How the hell can they say that the warming after the little ice age is caused by man? How the hell can they say warming is bad?
You know what I Ben hearing on the news recently we are living within the 6th mass extinction right now it depends on how much people care about the environment the more people still Pollute the planet after the covid-19 crisis the more we will suffer but no matter what climate/nature will always effect us
Volcano 300AD black death 1300AD. Narration seems to put the two events together at the same time bit confusing
The Truth About Climate Change - Dr. Patrick Moore - Greenpeace Co-Founder
35:40 in 1250 AD Lithuania already was from Crimea till Gotland island or from Ruggen island (even later several military campaigns against crusaders were as far as Elbe river and in 1155 AD Lithuanian religion city Arkona/Alkona was exterminated by killing 300 000 Arkona/Alkona city dwellers where one of 3 holly pagan eternal flame places was situated that in Lithuanian language is called Alkas) till Karelia and was fighting against crusaders and mongols at the same time from both sides
The sun does not its output every 11 years.
It's ridiciolles think, that we can make primar impact on wearher. So both films show, that nature itself change weather on planet in it is sick to think, that NOW people can do something?????
Humans, as any Apex Predator impact the environment by sheer mass numbers and activities. Cause? No. Exacerbate? Yes.
see what I mean??
yeah I agree- this series jumped the shark- no detail in script, and stock footage library.. maybe good for small children. 8-10 yo
Lets pray Yellowstone erupts soon and we can cool down again.
Dear children of Iceland
the hardest language to learn
echo...
May I?
hazards and catastrophes. Don't try to scare us.
unless you feel you need to
I suggest Beethoven...or
doomsday....if you live too close to the Arctic circle
you will freeze first
wurst
It's a pity this video ended with self ridicule and humiliation. After presenting evidence of historical naturally caused disasters of enormous magnitude she trots out the ridiculous man-made climate change b..s. after assuring us that climate change is caused principally by the sun and volcanic activity. This at a time when earth's climate is very benign and stable without a shred of verifiable evidence to suggest any impending disaster. Words, rhetoric, contradictions, and outlandish assumptions do not affect the climate.
...putting lots of carbon in the atmosohere on the other hand...
Human activity is accelerating the rate of change more than what the sun and volcanoes do by themselves.
Sven, CO2 is not carbon. Soot, smoke, coal, oil, etc are carbon. If these people can't even get the terminology right, what credibility do they have?
whatever you say, as long as we make the maximum number of people to suffer while this worsening of the climate takes place manmade or 'au natural'...like the god you probably think created me in his image I am a vindictive psychopath after all and little kids choking and dying next to a factory or a volcano give me a hard on. No matter if it's carbon or carbon dioxide based.
Harvey Harrison Climate change is accelerated by human activity. Believing or not, there are not enough natural resources on this planet to sustain the overpopulation. Bottom line, too many people!
xenophobia