When following an imam leading congregational ṣalāh (ritual prayer), there shouldn’t be a great distance, remoteness or obstacle between the imam and followers, such as a public street, a river and or a bridge. (see Fatāwā Al-Hindīyyah) The above is according to the Ḥanafī school of jurisprudence. In the Shāf’īe school, it is stated that if there is a worshiper following the imam leading ṣalāh from outside the masjid, a gap of more than three hundred dhirā’a (arms length distance) should not exist, nor a closed door between them. In the Ḥanbalī school, the condition for the validity of such a prayer, is that it must be possible for the worshiper to see the imam or at least see the worshipers standing right behind the imam. The Mālikī school’s verdict is that if, at such a distance one is able to grasp the movements and actions of the imam, the prayer would be valid. (see Al Fiqh ‘Alā Madhāhib Al-Arba’ah)
Salam brother everyone has their own school of thought that they follow so it’s best for everyone to do their research but thank you for sharing knowledge.
@Abehorton 7224 He didn't make it up. It's what some scholars have said. Although I wouldn't be comfortable praying at the hotel if Allah grants me the opportunity . I think it is the work of shaytan to pray in your hotel out of laziness
@AllPraisebetoAllah60 I am at Hajj this year.. my hotel is far away.. bus shuttle services are are arduous..imagine hujjaj with health issues, May Allah make it easy and give equal ajar to those far away from Haram.. Also note that when one arrives in haram you are moved and directed by security ...so it's not that one can straight away walk inside Haram. ALLAH KNOWS best.
@@SuperOlives May Allah accept your hajj, and make it easy for you. May Allah grant me a hajj next year. If you are not able for health reasons, yes I understand but for the rest of us, we should pray with the public. I know the heat and the difficulty of hajj, alhamdulillah for that. That's part of hajj. We have it easier now compared to the people before us
![SAFEPLANET - ดาวเคราะห์ [ THE PLANET ]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4X1XL3I_k3c/mqdefault.jpg)
Very useful & helpful information.
Shokran kathiran ya akhi.
Jazak’Allah Khair😊
When following an imam leading congregational ṣalāh (ritual prayer), there shouldn’t be a great distance, remoteness or obstacle between the imam and followers, such as a public street, a river and or a bridge. (see Fatāwā Al-Hindīyyah)
The above is according to the Ḥanafī school of jurisprudence. In the Shāf’īe school, it is stated that if there is a worshiper following the imam leading ṣalāh from outside the masjid, a gap of more than three hundred dhirā’a (arms length distance) should not exist, nor a closed door between them. In the Ḥanbalī school, the condition for the validity of such a prayer, is that it must be possible for the worshiper to see the imam or at least see the worshipers standing right behind the imam. The Mālikī school’s verdict is that if, at such a distance one is able to grasp the movements and actions of the imam, the prayer would be valid. (see Al Fiqh ‘Alā Madhāhib Al-Arba’ah)
Salam brother everyone has their own school of thought that they follow so it’s best for everyone to do their research but thank you for sharing knowledge.
Jzk
Hope this helped ☺️
No this is misleading, it has to be in masjid al haram.
Is your answer different to the scholar?
Hotel is not masjidul haram.
This is not true. Misleading.
How so🤔
@@Pilgrimsocial most scholars don’t permit . There cannot be a barrier completely enclosing you between you and the imam.
@Abehorton 7224 He didn't make it up. It's what some scholars have said. Although I wouldn't be comfortable praying at the hotel if Allah grants me the opportunity . I think it is the work of shaytan to pray in your hotel out of laziness
@AllPraisebetoAllah60 I am at Hajj this year.. my hotel is far away.. bus shuttle services are are arduous..imagine hujjaj with health issues, May Allah make it easy and give equal ajar to those far away from Haram.. Also note that when one arrives in haram you are moved and directed by security ...so it's not that one can straight away walk inside Haram. ALLAH KNOWS best.
@@SuperOlives May Allah accept your hajj, and make it easy for you. May Allah grant me a hajj next year. If you are not able for health reasons, yes I understand but for the rest of us, we should pray with the public. I know the heat and the difficulty of hajj, alhamdulillah for that. That's part of hajj. We have it easier now compared to the people before us