Amish Church Peanut Butter / Two Recipes!
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 15 ก.ย. 2024
- We had fun doing this video for you guys! And we got to enjoy our Amish church peanut butter that we haven’t made in a while :-)! I hope you find it enjoyable and try out this recipe sometime!
Amish church peanut butter
1/2 cup peanut butter
1/4 cup marshmallow cream
1 cup corn syrup
Mix together thoroughly. Spread on a piece of bread and enjoy with a side of hot mint tea!
PS I would actually go light on the corn syrup.
And here is my healthy version of the Amish church peanut butter! :-)
Approximately 1/2 cup peanut butter
Approximately 1/4 to 1/2 cup of maple syrup
Approximately 1/2 cup whip cream.
Mix and add until it’s the right consistency and the taste is sweet enough!
Please visit us as well at:
www.montanahavenlabradoodles.com
Facebook - Montana Haven
Instagram - Montana_Haven
I grew up in an Amish home, and I knew both of Joas's parents, Ora and Orpha. I very well remember those Amish church meals, especially the peanut butter mix. I remember when I was about 14 years old that I learned that non-Amish people actually ate peanut butter the way it came in the can, which seemed odd to me, since our family only had the mixed type.
We also had pickled beets and pickles at these lunches, but the pickles were always sweet pickles. If there were small pickles us boys would stab them with a fork and dunk them into the peanut butter. YUM ! I never heard of dill pickles until I ate at a restaurant, and to this day I have not acquired a liking for them.
I have been involved with a Country/Gospel music group which has a 3 day music weekend at a local campground, and for Sunday lunch we put up an Amish style lunch with homemade bread, peanut butter, apple butter, and ham and cheese. Our Facebook page is Boardwalk Music Group.
Thanks for sharing! I have heard my dad talk about you in the past! Blessings to you!
Hi, Erv! I think I just made your acquaintance at Ben's Pretzels recently!
@@amandayoder4456 Yes you did. Which reminds me - I forgot to sing "Amanda" like I said I would. Maybe next time.. . .
@@reoguy43 I don't know....depending on what it's about, it might embarrass me...just saying.😂
@@amandayoder4456 Look up that song on TH-cam - Don Williams, Amanda
You would like it.
I get so happy when I see your video's pop up. I love the way you both look at each other so very lovingly. Thanks for sharing more great videos.
Love it;
Good clean, wholesome, family time!
I`m from Ohio. I`m not Amish, but Paula and I loved going to Amish Country in and around Wayne County and eating at Amish(Mennonite) restaurants. We loved the traditional Peanut Spread. Amish cheese, bread, meats, baked goods. Memories.
About 30 years ago, I went to Lancaster County, PA. I ate at a family dining restaurant. It was amazing! We sat with people at a big table that were from everywhere. We are scrapple, fried chicken, mashed potatoes, succotash, homemade bread, shoofly pie, iced tea, and coffee. The Amish people were lovely. I remember the famiily name, Yoder. Funny the things that you remember. I wanted to get a quilt in the worse way. I think the pattern was called corn and beans. Thank you for reminding me of a kinder time in the world.❤️
Thank you for your comment Angela!
Oh mercy! Two of my favorite things Amish peanut butter and meadow tea😊
That was such a nice family bonding. Joas did a good job😊.God Bless your beautiful family.🙏🥰❤️❤️❤️✌️
I liked this video.. You all having family time together.. Bless you all..
We live close to an Amish community and was out yesterday doing some running and they were out and doing chores since it was so pretty and warm. Our neighbor group use horses and buggy. It was so cute to see the little kids all dressed up and riding in the back of the buggy.
I stopped eating Cool Whip years ago when I took a tub out of the freezer and let it set on the counter for a week. I opened it up and nothing changed on it. It's so synthetic.
You can make your own with whipping cream
I'm glad you show healthier version.
Growing up in the Lancaster County area, and having my closest girlfriend Amish, I have attended home church with her many times. We too ate these foods, but we also had Lebanon Bologna and pickled eggs with the red beets. We loved it.
I loved this video, you and your family are awesome 🙏🏼
The traditional kind 😖all that corn syrup ! 😅 so glad for a healthy version ! I did not grow up Amish so never knew what it was until some of our children married off spring of Amish backgrounds.
Thank you for sharing a little of your family life here. I always enjoy your videos.
We always mixed our peanut butter with Rogers Golden Syrup when I was a kid...I just introduced it to my husband and he loves it. I never knew that others ate sweet peanut butter as well.
I love pickled beets. We made peanut butter and marshmallow fluff sandwiches growing up. We also loved peanut butter and banana sandwiches.
I love peanut butter, banana and celery sandwiches ;)
We I grew up our school would mix peanut butter in Bob White table syrup. It was a darker syrup and it was so good. The cafeteria would always serve these sandwiches with a bowl of vegetable soup. I still make it now days. I love this stuff. Thanks for sharing! Brought back memories!,
Thank you again for sharing. I'm going to have to try these recipes with my grandchildren. We live in Ohio and take trips to our Amish Country as often as we're able. It's the only place we really love to go. I always buy the sweet beets and once in awhile the Amish peanut butter. What a treat!!! I love wholesome things and wholesome families. ❤
God bless you and yours.
Love watching your videos. Such a breath of fresh air to see such a strong family that loves God and each other. Hard to find such wholesome tv or TH-cam videos to watch these days. And so much useful information on so many different topics! Keep doing what you do! You are a blessing! ❤️
So much fun... I miss country church dinners. So many unusual dishes
Thanks, for sharing. I will be making the "healthy version" with organic peanut butter. I spent several yrs. in a Beachy Mennonite church(it's a break away from the Amish church). I never liked all of the gloop and glop church meals. Often the ladies would be at the dent store a few days earlier getting stuff for the sunday meals ;(
My husband grew up in Zanesville Ohio and I grew up in California. My 1st time to Amish country Holmes County was in 1974 and absolutely fell in love with everything, especially the wonderful food. I'm gonna have to make this peanut butter bread. I need to look in You're videos and see if you have made a chocolate will be pie . I need to find a great recipe for that period is my dream to make those from my grandkids. I love your channel. Your kids are so cute. Hugs from Utah
Our family grew up eating the Karo mix. My parents grew up Amish, and we ate many of the traditional foods of the Amish. Love it!!
Loved this!! And the bloopers :D.
Loved this video - so awesome so fun and very educational. Informative. God Bless You all
very interesting - I am again amazed how well we immigrants adapted to what was available in our new homeland. Peanut butter was available in Germany in the early 1960, but only in the most exotic specialty shops, it was just not as common as it is in the US.
Mom went to the TN school for the deaf in the Depression. They received government peanut butter and maple syrup. The lunch ladies mixed the two and gave it to the kids as a treat. In the 50s Mom did the same for us.
I can’t wait to try both these
Mom made it with marshmallow creme and split corn syrup half with maple syrup. Only Peter Pan and if needed Jif.
We always had bologna and ham with Swiss cheese and Colby. Dill and bread and butter pickles, sometimes beets and a bread soup. This was all laid out on the bench tables on the old school lunch trays.🍱 Also there was white or wheat bread.
The best combo on the peanut butter was bologna Swiss cheese and bread and butter pickles.
i just love you two..i have learned so much about the Amish culture...i love your family...your you tube channel has gotten me hooked. i am a 62 yer old widow from Illinois and i just love you guys
Carbs and sugar all the way! Looks good-will be fun to try! I also like butter and peanut butter mixed together. Thank you for this charming video on a Sunday night!! God Bless all of you.
My mom used to put brown sugar butter maple flavoring n water in a pan n boil it until caramel then let cool down n added peanut butter n marshmallow cream oh it was soooo good
That sounds really good! I don’t think we ever made it that way.
This reminds me of the sandwiches my gran would make us, peanut butter and marshmallow fluff. :D It was thrilling for a kid! :D Even now I love the combination of chocolate, peanut butter, and marshmallow. Fun video, guys!! I love when you show us snippets of your old life.
We call them fluffer nutters and sometimes add a sliced banana. They are so good.
@@carly7693 Mmm, I bet they're awesome with banana.
@@elofamily7241 yes they are 😋
My childhood favorite!!! My Amish great-grandmother used Honey/peanut butter or Karo/Peanut Butter AND when she made homemade Chokecherry syrup she used that and peanut butter! I remember during Holiday's she would make homemade whip cream to add to the mixture. Of course, we didn't have sliced bread... we had homemade fresh bread and buns and OH SO GOOD!!!!! Thank you for sharing an old Amish fav.
I so enjoy watching your videos sharing your family’s life stories. I grew up on a spread of peanut butter, butter and honey. No measurements, just guessed and stirred until smooth. Delicious on celery.
When I was young I loved eating peanut butter and honey sandwiches, also peanut butter and sweet pickle relish sandwiches. My mom taught me to always use butter too so that the peanut butter didnt stick to my mouth.
Love you all. You're such a blessing!
Thank you for the video & recipe looks yummy 😍
This brings back some great memories of when some Amish friends invited me to their church recently. The pickled beets were really good. And I think I had four slices of bread with the Amish peanut butter! Of course, now that I know the ingredients, I think I'll be making your healthy recipe instead!
❤️. Love the video. Thank you so much. I love to know about different customs. Such simple custom and yet such love and togetherness
Never heard of this but it looks delicious. Gonna try this
I have had the Amish peanut butter when I visit my sister in Ohio (near Holmes County). I tried to make it one time after a visit, but it didn't taste the same because I didn't know all that was in it. Thank you for the recipe. I think I will try Priscilla's recipe it sounds better to me. I love your family and really enjoy your videos.
I'm going to try Priscilla's peanut spread. God bless 💖💖
Really fun video! You all do seem so natural and normal, I love it. The sweet peanut butter on bread after church...great! Thank you so much for sharing your time with us. 😉
I'm not Amish, but I remember my Grandma made this for us grandkids at her house. We did live by Amish people. Maybe she learned that from them. I remember it was so sweet and yummy. We also had miracle whip sandwiches.
I’m trying these recipes!!! I love traditions and wonderful family time. God bless your family.
My husband's family does this type of meal (with the meat n cheese ) occasionally at family reunions when they get asked to serve the Sunday meal. It s a treat...although probably not the healthiest meal ever!😁My mom almost always fixes this peanut butter mixture for dinner rolls at her house on holidays n special occasions! I want to try the healthy version. Loved the family evening snack time! Its a little more rare to have everyone together at our house these days with our children ranging in ages 22 to 12(3 sons n 2 daughters just like you😊
I just found you bc the Amish Potato shared this recipe. I was obsessed w Amish Living when I was growing up lol. I'm 45 now. But I still adore the Amish/&Mennonite Communities. I also have 2 daughters that Live In Montana! My Youngest is getting married in July (lives in Missoula) & my oldest lives about an hour away from her sister in Kalispell, MT. We have a 3 yr old Grandson and are considering moving from Middletown, Delaware to Montana. I enjoyed seeing some videos. But I want to make this both ways. We all have to live a little dangerous sometimes lol
Welcome to Montana! Kalispell is our closest big town.
The second peanut butter you made Priscilla reminds me of applesauce and peanut butter mixed. I remember being told at the Sunday meals about sweet peanut butter. Thank you for sharing.
Such a precious family
Love you both! Jonas you cracked me up measuring your ingredients & saying a waste of time! Just be like me and guesstimate! 😂 Then not messing extra dishes. Priscilla you go girl! You guesstimated.Love you both,such a big inspiration!!! And your sweet children!
When my sisters and I were growing up we always put sweet pickles on our PB sandwiches, and Joeus, I love pickled beets too, YUM!!
Wow how interesting!!
Shew I could try the peanut butters but I couldn’t even go there with the tea, pickles and beets 😳. Lol
So glad to see you posted. I love peanut butter and honey mixed up thinly and on fresh hot homemade buns out of the oven. So so good.......that reminds me of high school days after church we went to the big dining room and that was one of the beginnings along with eggs or oatmeal for a big breakfast before the day of school. I used to work in the scullery and wash those big kettles and oh my they were huge. The peanut butter and honey mixed together and spread was soooooo delicious however. I as well love pickled beets. I could eat them every meal if I could. So so delicious. They are also good with a good scoop of cottage cheese. Now I am hungry. LOL
Thank you for sharing..........cute video and always enjoy watching you. Wondering if Priscilla made her green dress.......it's lovely!
Blessings
Thank you for your comment Mary! No I did not make my dress. I believe I got it in a Ross! :-) Blessings!
5:37 "I just can't help to help him" that's a good thing. It means your mama and grammys and aunties taught you well about being a proper helpmeet.
I agree!!!!
Everyone is making comments about the sugar content of the traditional but jam and jelly has a lot of sugar also and no one thinks about that because it’s our traditional. I think sugar is good within limits and so glad y’all shared this. I can tell when you share a part of your heritage that you have many fond memories. It was a beautiful video and a fun time with your children. I came from a large family and we used to see who could eat ten soda crackers and whistle first. It made a huge mess but my mom loved watching us giggle and have fun together. 🌻☀️💛👩🌾
I absolutely love watching your videos~such a sweet family!!
I LOVE peanut butter! I never buy marshmallow cream, but i had some left over from another recipe that was going to waste, so i made this. I didn't have Karo, so i used a mixture of honey and maple syrup. It was SSOOO delicious. I served it with apple slices. Thanks for the recipe idea! ❤
You are wonderful and blessed... hope to be able to keep running Into your wonderful family stores and Information..thank you so much
I love peanut butter and pickle sandwiches. When I took that to work one day everyone was unbelieving ....they’d never heard of such. ...and I couldn’t believe no one had heard of it or tried it....so good!
I'm going to make this for my grand babies thk you!! Love y'all so much have a beautiful evening..💜🌟💜🙏🖐
The peanut butter and pickles brings back memories, glad to see you honoring your amish heritage.
I really really enjoyed this type of video; the preparing, and tastes-testing as a Family.
Blessings, love and prayers for all, from Israel 🇮🇱.
Glad you enjoyed it!
Thanks for sharing this. It was fun watching the children do the taste test!!
This is amazing, and a great reminder of my childhood. We would have peanut butter and Karo syrup only on toast and dunk it in hot tea and also for lunch we would have peanut butter, and marshmallow cream sandwiches. And my dad would eat Karo syrup mixed with peanut butter on his pancakes. And you are right, it was wonderful! Sweet Memories! And every meal at my house we have pickled beets and cottage cheese.
I have heard of Amish peanut better fluff, but have never seen it made or ate it. I never buy Cool Whip it has a bad after taste to me. The one made with whip cream would get my vote. If I eat peanut butter sandwich I mix it with honey but most of the time just plain peanut butter. Thank you for the informative and fun video.
Aw, that was so much fun. I was anxious to see the end result. This was brand new to me. It was fun watching the mixing and everyone enjoying the mixtures. All the yum's😊. I wonder also where this came from. Mr. Kellogg of Kellogg brand cereal was the one who invented peanutbutter. He wanted people without teeth to be able to enjoy the wonderful flavor of peanuts.
Loved your video! Growing up in Georgia, we had something just like your sweet peanut butter. We just called it “peanut butter/butter and syrup”. Our grandmother, we called Big Mama, would stir together peanut butter, AlaGa syrup (Cane syrup), and butter till it was creamy. We spread it on bread just like you did 🥰
We still eat it to this day using maple syrup instead of AlaGa.
It was fun watching you all taste test. I'm going to try the healthy one. Thanks for sharing.
I love watching your videos. You two are so cute and very sweet to each other. This is truly a blessing to others!
What a fun taste test! Your church traditions sound wonderful.
Okay, it doesn't sound too bad until you mention adding the pickle. This is a great sandwich as well...soft white bread. Spread peanut butter on a slice. Add mayonnaise over p.butter, then add rai sins ontop of mayo. Other slice of bread ontop. I will try yours, and you try mine. Yum!
I’ll be doing this taste test with my grandkids!
I enjoy watching the all cooking
I have made a similar recipe for Amish peanut. I really like it.
That brings so many memories back thank you for showing that.
I love peanut butter and pickles.
I enjoyed watching this cute, light-hearted video. Both recipes are kinda like a "dessert" peanut butter! I think either one would taste yummy on vanilla wafers. Your children are well-behaved, a reflection of your good parenting.
Looking forward to trying these. Thankyou!
I loved this video! My dad used to make something like this and my sisters and I called it “daddy’s peanut butter “. Didn’t realize it probably came from his Amish heritage! His parents were married and had their three oldest children before they left the Amish church. My dad was the youngest of 6 siblings. I bet grandma made this because the older children remembered it from Amish church. ❤️🙂
The peanut butter looks wonderful. Your videos are so up-lifting ,such a great Family .
I have never had this kind of peanut butter before . They both sound delicious. I will definitely be making this to try . Loved this kind of video also. Thanks for sharing.
I love watching you guys interact with each other. I need to try that church peanut butter. Growing up I ate peanut butter and pickle sandwiches often.
Good episode. I live in the Elkhart-Lagrange County, Indiana area near Shipshewana. Shipshewana is a big tourist area for people interested in the Amish. I like some of the Amish style restaurants. I have tried the peanut butter. Apple butter and the church peanut butter are on the table sometimes. I suppose my favorite food from Amish restaurants and bakeries are the pies. Raspberry cream pie is great.
The peanut butter is too intensely sweet for me but I suppose I would have liked it at the age of your children. Apple butter is more my speed. You have cute kids.
Yum raising my family they loved this treat when I would make it. Thanks for sharing and love hearing the stories associated with your videos. God bless you & yours.
You guys seem like one very great family ! Nice going guys 💖
I love pickled beets and bread and butter pickles!
I love pickled beets too ! My favorite is the peanut butter made with maple syrup because it tastes good and is healthy.
I remember those days and really like it. We still make some here at home quite a bit. Great video.
Thank you Steve!
My favorite is a hamburger on a bun with a slice of bacon and organic peanut butter. Yum. Love you all.
Wow that sounds interesting! I need to try that! :-)
My mom would mix peanut butter and maple syrup when I was growing up and I loved it I've never had it with whip cream but I think I'm going to make some looks so good
I just made your healthy version of Amish peanut butter. It was delicious! Thank you for sharing.
Awesome!
Thank you for sharing, I appreciate your family and fun 🤩
That was a lot of fun to watch! Bless you all!
You have such a beautiful family. There is so much love just radiating from all of you. God Bless and 💘
Both look yummy. Love your sweet family
I had a blast watching you, but I guess I was never Amish enough to enjoy sweet peanut butter.☺ I don't miss it at all.
Here in Amish country, Indiana, you can actually buy the stuff in stores or ask for it in restaurants! Pretty amazing!
I grew up in Michigan near Amish communities and my family and I would go to Amish church and they would have this. We would make it at our church too and we would dip apples in it.
Yes, I love that"Traditional" peanutbutter very much, but would like to try the other version too and see how it tastes. Thank you for sharing,,😉💙