Totally agree with you ! Every song was perfect for him. His latest performance is super impressive. He was more like a professional performer than a contestant . I won’t be surprised if he wins.
It is amazing that HK people can sing English song with less assent ,he is a real artist on the stage with fully confidence n has a humble attitude, since my maiden name also Ng I feel that he is my brother when he sang ,thanks for made me fell in love again ,I wish you can have a concert in Vancouver in the near future ,God bless you😊
@@kevinlai3861 In his band days, the young people who liked him and others singing in bands did not care about the quality of singing at all. These days, he relied on the nostalgia of people. He sings better than back then, but still he is not good.by any means. Bill Ng e.g. sings much better than him.
Entertaining and enjoyable to watch even though everyone knows the show is scripted..I think TVB have already targeted the ones that they wanted to be in the Top 10 and who they wanted to sign up as contract artistes..
Because he didn't try to copy Humperdinck. Not that i would have any problem if he did unless for every song he sings, he tries to mimic the original singer.
Not even close to Nat Ing Cole, who had a very rich and smooth voice. Ng's voice is much thinner, and has a slight raspiness.They also sing in different keys.
Kevin, we have idiots here, so don't let them bother you. When Sam Hui was with Lotus, he sang only English songs, so that meant he should not be singing? Even Leslie Cheung got his career started singing only English songs.
Why? Granted, the show has rules that may require singing mandarin songs. But why should good singer have to sing songs in particular languages? The name of the show is 中年好聲音 . Where does it say good voice in xxx language?
Thanks and didn't realize he is that good so Paul really hit the nail at the right place, by working as his agent and making.him so successful. I just don't like his singing style but still went ahead to buy his first CD, Sway when it was first released because.Paul endorsed him.
吳大強，這些老人家，拍子，声音，唱字體有進，拍子同身體都做到，完全無自大，他好謙卑，是一位好老人家。
Bill 叔叔係唱得自然又輕鬆，聽歌就係要呢種歌手，令人百聽不厭！
支持吳大強，加油💪💪💪
好喜欢張佳添老師的評語,謝谢分享。
未見過家添老師對吳大強有咁高評價，因為此曲會令人怯場越唱越快的走晒拍子，他年紀大反而唱到入穩陣入到骨髓，條件反射，拉抵支咪都咁好氣，是一本活生生的歌唱教科書，成為中年好聲音的金曲，雄厚清脆利落，以英語歌為主時代氣氛，極爆宇宙潛龍。佢唱完身體都有動感仍數拍子。明明每粒Quando每次唔同音域有用心的佈署，但唔覺得刻意賣弄技巧(揀歌好重要)，佢唔似比賽緊，佢好投入隻歌意墝，反而令觀眾眼前一亮的輕快自然美。好犀利👍，各參賽者表演越來越有星味。
Pj
Bill 哥 唱英文懷舊歌 真系好聽👍👍👍👍
大強哥每首歌都唱得好好聽，稳重声底厚，加油
大强哥真是唱得好听！♥️💐👏
我聽Bill叔叔第一首參賽歌已覺好動聽，參賽到現在超水準表演更加覺得不得了！跟住落嚟最緊要嚴謹選適合自已英文舊歌。繼續享受舞臺邊參賽。😊👏👏
這幾天在公司有個同事，成日哼著 Quando Quando Quando, 真係入屋兼上腦😂😂！ 正
由佢唱第一首時已有晒呢啲感覺..
唱出現今已經冇左既情懷 ...
令不常聽英文歌的人也駐足..
繼續發揮 好好揀歌
(*￣з￣) 大家加油
支持添Sir！👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻❤👍🏻❤👍🏻❤👍🏻
我聽過好多次現場joe junior,但吳大強的是很吸引，有魅力。
好認同添Sir講法,由于大强叔唱得咁好所以追住睇中年好声音好正👍
支持大强！心中冠军，没有之一！
大强真係唱得好專業
我都係佢粉絲！👍👍
大強冠軍馬啦
超班好自然韻味好好feel
連聽者都好enjoy, 個仔又靚仔
兩父子都好有market
💐💖支持吳大哥💪💪💪
聽佢唱真係享受，舒服自然，好迷人，原唱者一樣
似原唱吾得架,周生吾比分架！
佢聲底都有幾分似。👍👍
唔怕.周巳当佢偶像.吴又以红越交游广阔.又识食肉姐反.又跟谈老友咁熟轻言笑高放。
。
喜歡聽吳大強唱英文歌,好似聽緊唱片的水準,閉上眼聽,他的英文發音很準確,很專業,也許他年輕時也組過樂隊,做過業餘歌手.
張老師，分析得透徹，這首歌很難唱，也很難掌握得到。
我十分贊同你的第一句評價:「professional !」
跟著大強兄答:「really?」
我在電視機也衝口而出地說:「Yes!」👍💯
我也忘我呢!😄
大强哥次次歌都冇令我们失望👏🏻👏🏻👍🏻👍🏻💪💪
17歲大強先生，真係好叻，好野，好正，謝謝你支持你。
吳大強老師是唱者驚艷表表者香港又創造歌坛美景他們有香港代表風範如吉吉羅金榮龍婷!👏👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍👍🍾🍾🍾🍾
Totally agree with you ! Every song was perfect for him. His latest performance is super impressive. He was more like a professional performer than a contestant . I won’t be surprised if he wins.
👍👍👍✌️
Agree, he is a professional performer!
我覺得大強兄,直頭有佢個市場價值,比如佢出D HIFI 發燒碟 唱番些懷舊英文歌,,佢把聲厚而溫暖,非常正,因為大家都知肯花錢買CD的大都係中年人和HIFI迷!
無錯,佢出既話我一定會買
⁰⁰0
It is amazing that HK people can sing English song with less assent ,he is a real artist on the stage with fully confidence n has a humble attitude, since my maiden name also Ng I feel that he is my brother when he sang ,thanks for made me fell in love again ,I wish you can have a concert in Vancouver in the near future ,God bless you😊
60年代的歌，經典歌，相信就算70後也未必識，歐西歌的風格，貓王，披頭四，再後Paul Anka，Andy WiIIiam，腔口不同廣東歌（70年代港式歌西歌已不同）...今次吳大強復古風帶來驚奇，是神來之筆。
回想70年代尾，此類表演在好多夜總會玩band的歌手也做到此水準，只是已成陳年記憶。
真系好鐘意聽大強唱舊英文歌，佢唱出了歌曲果種韻味呀❤ 令人陶醉！
好想聽到佢唱 the platters d 歌 💕
添sir，期待下届「中年好声音」，我一定要参加💪
👏👏👏👍👍👍🥰🥰🥰
張Sir 是我最欣賞星夢及好聲音評審，肯定參賽者獲益良多，大強哥的表演次次精彩，聽他表演很享受，期待張Sir 對其它參賽者的詳細評語及指導，特別是鮑鮑 👍👍👏👏
大強兄 絕對好識揀歌 所以揀到一首合式唱既歌 是可以起死回生 我估大強歌會揀呢首為下一首歌“Sway”因為呢6O年代歌 好適合佢唱 加油💪💪
Sway 不一定啱佢唱，因為屬於懶洋洋歌，Dean Martin 類型，Easy Listening 不適合比賽唱。
@@jameslu2332 我覺得首歌音樂輕鬆
其實並不易唱，愈輕鬆愈難唱，Michael Buble 唱紅咗，算佢叻，加上比賽評判無一定的標準，吹無定向風。
Suggestion: Sway, 要現今的類似big band版, 如Uncle Bill 能handle到, 一定拍爛手掌. 不過Dean Martin版, 慢咗D, 他不太合適.
我認為Uncle Bill 啱唱D少少輕快, 音樂可以奀奀下 ,就是這首Quando就出得到魅力喇！
🤝🤝非常欣賞張老師的專業評論💐
強哥唱歌感染力好強,近年歌手所欠缺,可以講絕無僅有!希望其他參加者開始抖擻精神,要作戰競賽了,唔再聯誼表演了!
恭喜老師，已達25,000個訂閱🎉🎉🎉🎉
我都覺得吳大強唱得最好，professional, 穩定，選對歌，歌精舞勁，有自信，期待他唱廣東歌。但張老師，不明白為何不淘汰包包和白衣女郎，因為他倆當日的表現是比被淘汰者差，我的同事們都有很有意見，覺得很不公平，我們都有看中年好聲音。
十分認同張老師對吳大強的表現
的確有水準也令人很投入去聽他的歌。。。Excellent and
good performance
不是說這個比賽嚴禁模妨舊歌原唱方式, 必須超越原唱並"搣"掉原唱者味道麼？怎麼籠門又搬了？？
很期代吳大強叔叔能唱1首粵語歌國語歌可以比較唱英文歌是否同樣咁好聽咁出色😂
唱粵語隨時有可能出局
Respect Uncle Bill👍👍
totally agreed with you Clayton
今次中年好聲音, 大部分都唱得好好, 起碼冇聽到透氣聲, 但係現時好多歌手唱歌都有好大的透氣聲, 聲夢呢班一樣唔得, 唔知點解評判冇提出, 聽歌係要聽得舒服, 而家覺得聽歌好辛苦, 希望做歌手的要注意。
這是個轉廢為能的時代，汽車的廢氣也成為Turbo 引擎的推力。同樣，在歌唱方面，若是處理得當，氣息也可成為襯托音或情感表達的一部份。尤其是唱某類煽情的歌，要唱到如泣如訴，氣息的表達尤其重要。
@Chan, 全對, 透氣声好難頂👎
@@pollytang3234 陳奕迅都好大抖氣聲，但係好受歡迎，抖氣聲好唔好要睇唱咩
現今的新歌的詞太欤密，冇留到换气位，只有在演唱中换气，歌手水平亦都有待進步。
對D專業評判有D失望、應走吾使走、好似內定甘🤨吾太差比最低分、最差既反而可留底？你哋真專業🤭🤭professional 🤨🧐🧐???
又一個超級專業裁判.
中年好聲音真係好好睇❤
好想70同17嘅合唱，兩個偶像。
Me too 😁😁💜💜💜💜
Me 3💜💜💜
大會可試下用抽籤方法選歌，使參賽者唱其他歌曲看看其實力。
有觀眾緣也難得
支持，認同
TVB 中年好聲音👍🙂
張老師多謝你專業的分析，由第一集已覺得Bill哥唱得好自然好好聽，今次唱得更好更自信。
吳大強的表演比人joe junior嘅感覺 真係好驚喜🎉
個人覺得Joe junior 好聽佢好多。
建議大強可以唱“I write the songs”
👍支持你
吳大強
很会自圓其說👍🤭的評判
冇人唱到咁正，整個人，好 瀟灑，冇做作，連個仔，都咁靚仔，迷死女人。阿爸而家都迷人架。
支持張老師，吳大強是唯一真正唱歌，有感覺，其他的都是唱k或唱到個音，酒廊歌手，隻隻一樣，沒靈魂。
不敢苟同
不敢苟同x2
叫佢唱吓國語歌及粵語歌才講啦！英文高級D？
不敢苟同x3
張老師🙋♀️早晨😄大年初十祝你事業十全十美，更上一層樓，心想事成🍾🍾🎊🎊🎉🎉🌺🌺🌺
支持，，，
吾覺得長者比其他人高班一廂情願的評判
張老師都唱得好聽。
有評審問某些比較喜歡唱國語歌的參賽者為何不選唱廣東歌, 然而卻沒人問Bill哥為何只唱英文歌.
問得好,有某些評判是針對人的,唱英文是否高級些呢？
按照個人喜好,不公平不客觀....
問得好👍
為甚周國豐主觀提議他以後只唱英文,評審們是否一面倒主觀,一個歌者是可以唱中英日及其他歌曲如；梅X芳,許冠傑,林子祥陳百强,陳奕迅等才是真正的歌者🎶🎤🎼💯👍🎧👏,不要太吹捧某一個人啦。特別當晚電视台突出；介紹他是電視台藝員的爸爸重點不公。個人風格是否只唱英文👎
問左我想問但又吾敢問嘅問題。
唱英文似原唱叫＂活CD＂，唱國語似鄧麗君叫冇自我！真的吹漲！
👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
對，中年好聲音很好睇，正如夏韶聲Danny summer 講過一些歌後生嘅人係唱唔出個種味道感覺，因為佢地沒有經過個種人生經歷
大強兄這水平，感覺就像Joe Junior 在唱歌👍✨
That is not a compliment. Joe Jr's singing is very pedestrian. His range is narrow, and his voice is thin.
@@dadama925 假假地，他也算是位香港有名氣的歌手，我喜歡他的歌。😄
@@kevinlai3861 In his band days, the young people who liked him and others singing in bands did not care about the quality of singing at all. These days, he relied on the nostalgia of people. He sings better than back then, but still he is not good.by any means. Bill Ng e.g. sings much better than him.
@@dadama925 我是憑感覺說出來的，並非是甚麼專業音樂人。無論如何，Joe Junior 在我心中是位出色的歌手，他的歌陪伴我的青春歲月，那首''Sealed with a kiss''仍在耳邊迴響。
在此也感謝您提供資料，擴闊了我的眼界🙏
都有啲似丁馬卡度
❤️❤️❤️
其實吳大強唱第一首才叫好，這首係贏在音樂好，我覺得唱第一首好過呢首多多
也觉。不会人云亦云。
Entertaining and enjoyable to watch even though everyone knows the show is scripted..I think TVB have already targeted the ones that they wanted to be in the Top 10 and who they wanted to sign up as contract artistes..
同意
💯💯💯
D人話大強只係識唱英文歌好悶，咁其他人夠只係識唱中文歌啦，比賽更係選自己強嘅嚟唱㗎啦，其他人連自己適合唱咩歌都未知，這個是中年好聲音，唔係中文好聲音呀😅
👍🏻👍🏻🤩
真心好....好....聽
同唱卡啦ok一樣冇分別 平淡 平凡 唱英文歌就高分
👍👍👍👍👍
How about Frank Sinatra or Tony Bennett songs? Something stupid or My way or Stranger in the Night ?
I left my heart in SF?
但係上一次就覺得好唔公平，記憶中從未見過歌唱比賽嘅參賽者甩咀走音忘記歌詞，竟然可以留低⁉️⁉️⁉️其實嘉賓評判好似玩玩下咁，一啲都唔專業😰
呢个系遊戲規則 我非常讚同你所講 包大人不應留低 是他自己揀錯歌
你唔明個遊戲規則點玩法 因為有人比佢仲低分.
明眼的人睇整個比賽有人佈局，搵藝員個老豆去參加，兩父子都有威勢，睇市場價值做主導，不平就當然少不了。
大強哥係就係好正，但只獨沽一味唱英文歌，希望佢多元化啲唱吓廣東歌啦。
周國豐又無話吳大強模仿 Engelbert Humperdinck
Because he didn't try to copy Humperdinck. Not that i would have any problem if he did unless for every song he sings, he tries to mimic the original singer.
唔知大強哥個仔（偉豪）有冇𠄘傳到父親的唱歌咁好的DNA呢？
我覺得佢都可以試唱下Tom Jones d 歌,應該都啱佢唱☺️
本來好欣賞你嘅，但你今次夾埋造馬foul區俊傑救鮑聖光真係好肉酸
我比佢14分喎😂
你想我比幾多？🤔
@@claytonmusic 好，怪錯添sir啦😂
個人覺得強哥把聲幾似Nat King Cole。反而想聽佢唱中文歌。
Not even close to Nat Ing Cole, who had a very rich and smooth voice. Ng's voice is much thinner, and has a slight raspiness.They also sing in different keys.
但喺佢只懂唱英文歌，大會應該要佢唱廣東歌或國語歌，試睇下佢嘅好聲音是否真正好聲音囉！一把靚聲應該多元化，都能唱廣東歌或國語歌，不能只齋唱英文歌。
佢唔係唱左，今消多珍重咩。
@@soSO-jf8tx 喺大合唱，不是獨唱整首歌。
建議唱埋埃及文，如果唔係都無實力
@@chingfong155 吓，冇人懂聽啊！
認同
其實吳大強唱老舊歌表現真是不差, 但實際情況, 他個人表演時只懂唱“好舊”英文歌, 才拿到90分以上, 但這也是鐵一般的事實,雖然這是他強項, 但次次這樣就有點枯燥乏味了, 而其他對手評審們都對他們有好多好多建議, 他們都作了不單一的歌路去作出更多嘗試改變令歌路濶一些, 娛樂性可觀性提高一點, 好似評審話齋唔需要多, 作出少少改變件事就唔同左, 大家都明白和理解到吳先生的年紀, 期望吳大強在六強比賽, 大胆些試唱七八十年代的舊廣東話或國語歌去挑戰自己, 以寬些少歌路去拿下冠軍, 咁節目就精彩好睇好多
同意 好正
想請教一下，若果Andy Williams 只識唱英文歌，是否不應做歌星？😅
Kevin, we have idiots here, so don't let them bother you. When Sam Hui was with Lotus, he sang only English songs, so that meant he should not be singing? Even Leslie Cheung got his career started singing only English songs.
@Kevin Lai👍😄
佢唱下中文歌先講啦。
Why? Granted, the show has rules that may require singing mandarin songs. But why should good singer have to sing songs in particular languages? The name of the show is 中年好聲音 . Where does it say good voice in xxx language?
但如佢唱中文歌可能有落差
－唱中文歌就搞吾惦啦！若比佢總冠軍就吾全面！好悶
喜欢你的点评！第一集吴大强开声就压倒场声音非常好听！冠军🏆
只是擅長唱英文歌，看來未必是冠軍人選
中文歌唱得好听！我心目中的人选！多谢你！
@@carmenchan3089 無其他似第-一相。
但係佢只識得唱英文老歌！ 唱一生何求就乜哂beat 及歌詞都冇out ！ 評判都吾中肯比佢留低！ 技巧不全面！ －唱中文歌就吾惦
Only English songs?
BILL哥哥呢次出呢3把關刀,果然厲害😁
👍🌺
其實好似AGT，BGT有些長者都有好高水準
個人覺得老舊歌比較易唱，無論英文歌或中文歌都係！
一D唔昜，唱得好就唔昜，以前D歌，而家後生唱唔到味道出來。
廣東歌比國語及英文歌難唱，這些見解很多音樂人也說過
老舊歌唱系吾難，個音好多人都唱到，但難系難在個韻味！ 呢樣就吾系個個唱得到。
全能歌手應該係周深❤ 其係好勁
中
Mr Bill, well done and keep it up !
希望吳大強，下次唱 敲三下
Bill Ng= Hong Kong Michael Bible
希望佢去參加America Got Talent ,佢絕對有國際市場嘅條件。
冲去香港
Michael Buble 有 Paul Anka 扶持，本身唱功一般
Micheal buble
成功係因為佢一把令人聽得舒服放鬆的歌聲。雖然大部分都係口水歌（翻唱別人作品），但是唱出自己的特色。
Bill Ng 就有呢個特點。
其實聽歌但求可以聽得投入、放鬆、開心。
開心就是那麼簡單❤
他的特色是一聽就知道是他在唱，但欠缺驚喜，合唱則更平淡。加拿大出好歌星，Paul Anka, Don McLean, 到 Celine Dion (巳成絶晌) ，到吳大強 (一笑)
@@jameslu2332 lol. Michael Buble is 10 times the singer Paul Anka was. I am not even a fan of Buble and i know that.
Thanks and didn't realize he is that good so Paul really hit the nail at the right place, by working as his agent and making.him so successful. I just don't like his singing style but still went ahead to buy his first CD, Sway when it was first released because.Paul endorsed him.