I'm surprised that despite this huge change in the lore, the show ended with the same 4 finalists. There are canonical events that cannot be changed ☠️
Lol just by seeing pngs of the characters and some texts I'm already imagining the whole series that way, I even got excited and cried a lot, I loved it 🎩🎉
I honestly might prefer this over the original elimination order (aside from TD) and might even prefer the teams! good job and you did well on this video.
But there's one thing I'll like to say, I think TD would get eliminated instead of Pencil, Pencil was a very liked character and was a very good character, also the reason Rocky got out was due to being bland, so I think TD would get eliminated for the same thing, but I can see Pencil getting eliminated.
@@V0ided-v1f That's because they probably thought they could survive against Rocky and/or because Flower was voted by the viewers, not the writers. They would likely give more bias to Spongy because he rejoined because the writers wrote him back.
Firey being alliance with bubble is a menace like two really good finalists 💀💀💀 also this changes are really good i kinda like this better than the cannon one. The only thing I don't like is spongy being eliminated after he rejoined, viewer's will not likely vote a contestant just rejoined. Lastly, leafy definitely steal dream island without any remorse. Since leafy give her immunity to firey and just firey to take side on bubble.
5:11 I hate how everyone says “spongy is useless” like bro he isn’t, he actually did the challenges, he did well, he was used as a boat. People voted him for either thinking that or the more likely option that he is fat
actually by BFDI 2 in this universe his only contribution was trying to get past the obstacle course and failing, he wasn’t even used as a boat since his team didn’t throw him overboard, he never even went on a boat actually
I actually think Rocky would win over Spongy in that bread contest. Rocky would vomit bread like he did the maroon balls. And I think Rocky would survive for longer than Spongy did in this scenario.
19:14 I don't think Match has ever called Needle "Needy" as well. There was an episode where Pencil called her "Needy," and Match said to not slap her since she said, "Needle." I guess it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things, though.
You should’ve made needle get like a middle of the bunch score so she isn’t so far ahead of everyone, the writers would probably do something that has the announcer sabotage her
When it's leafy turn crossed,tb and gb choose flower,but there something I want tell... Tb is my 1st favorite,flower is my 2nd favorite and gb is my 3rd favorite😮😮😮
I'm surprised that despite this huge change in the lore, the show ended with the same 4 finalists. There are canonical events that cannot be changed ☠️
A verified again?
FR IM LIKE 👀
👄
Lol just by seeing pngs of the characters and some texts I'm already imagining the whole series that way, I even got excited and cried a lot, I loved it 🎩🎉
I honestly might prefer this over the original elimination order (aside from TD) and might even prefer the teams! good job and you did well on this video.
But there's one thing I'll like to say, I think TD would get eliminated instead of Pencil, Pencil was a very liked character and was a very good character, also the reason Rocky got out was due to being bland, so I think TD would get eliminated for the same thing, but I can see Pencil getting eliminated.
The writers would not put Spongy up for elimination in the episode he rejoins against more liked contestants, they're smart enough to realize that.
He shouldnt rejoin at all
Thats not true at all 😭. Flower rejoined and she ended up being up for elimination in the same episode lol
@@V0ided-v1f That's because they probably thought they could survive against Rocky and/or because Flower was voted by the viewers, not the writers. They would likely give more bias to Spongy because he rejoined because the writers wrote him back.
@@ProCyborgXi feel like they gave him a chance
I like how you're saying "the writers" when it was just cary and/or Michael lol
The fact that it still ends in the original top 4 is crazy
I love how Firey defends Bubble in BFDI 23.
honestly this is a very realistic alternate timeline for this show. it’s pretty cool.
BFDI what ifs in 2030: “BFDI: What if Coiny and Firey were friends?”
That isn't a bad idea, though.
@@goodboi7026I mean, it sorta negates their whole personalities.
that kinda explains the bfdi 25 part where firey and coiny hug
who is gonna tell him
@@zgui2763 what?
Gotta give bro respect for mentioning Sam 💀
David getting visualized before Sam is ludicrous
“We’ll just say Pin pushed Leafy off before she could complain” If that happened the entirety of Battle For Dream Island wouldn’t have
i love how you include sam
Firey being alliance with bubble is a menace like two really good finalists 💀💀💀 also this changes are really good i kinda like this better than the cannon one. The only thing I don't like is spongy being eliminated after he rejoined, viewer's will not likely vote a contestant just rejoined. Lastly, leafy definitely steal dream island without any remorse. Since leafy give her immunity to firey and just firey to take side on bubble.
5:11 I hate how everyone says “spongy is useless” like bro he isn’t, he actually did the challenges, he did well, he was used as a boat. People voted him for either thinking that or the more likely option that he is fat
actually by BFDI 2 in this universe his only contribution was trying to get past the obstacle course and failing, he wasn’t even used as a boat since his team didn’t throw him overboard, he never even went on a boat actually
This was my favourite what if to watch, it was amazing!
37:35 HELP THE MUSIC GOES PERFECTLY WITH NEEDLE GOING BACK 😭🙏
Outside of spongy elimination, everything seems pretty good
I wish your video gets millions of views because you have great content. Try running ads for your channel using some kind of system.
Leafy: this makes no sense
pin:cry about it
Who knew such a little thing could change the whole contest
Idea: What if the “Contestants not present may not compete” rule didn’t exist?
That's actually a good idea
I actually think Rocky would win over Spongy in that bread contest. Rocky would vomit bread like he did the maroon balls. And I think Rocky would survive for longer than Spongy did in this scenario.
19:14 I don't think Match has ever called Needle "Needy" as well. There was an episode where Pencil called her "Needy," and Match said to not slap her since she said, "Needle." I guess it doesn't matter in the grand scheme of things, though.
This makes sense because Pin won the Rock Paper Scissors game.
Alt title If Coiny And Pins Friendship Begin Eariler
You should’ve made needle get like a middle of the bunch score so she isn’t so far ahead of everyone, the writers would probably do something that has the announcer sabotage her
Snowball needs to be on the same team as his friends! Leafy loves Firey!
canon will always be my fav but this is still a good au!
I like the golf ball png like watching flower LOL
Why does the alliance match? (Pencil is patting bubble but bubbles concerned about whatever match is doing.)
What if pen and tv were in bfdia install of golfball and gelatin
Yeah, this makes more sense because pin won the rock paper scissors
BFDI what ifs in 2050 be like: *_what if Firey's asset didn't have an animation?_*
Nice video
I would love to see a BFDIA version
and people dont worry about the tiny things
Not Spongy getting the TDI Eva treatment
Genuine question, what is the song you used whenever a character is eliminated, I really like it
@@NovaAzurite HOME - We’re finally landing
@@bruhmomentum_ tysm
14:37 home - resonance
When it's leafy turn crossed,tb and gb choose flower,but there something I want tell...
Tb is my 1st favorite,flower is my 2nd favorite and gb is my 3rd favorite😮😮😮
match looks like she wants to eat the text lol
So basically what if the cherrys switch places with grapes
43:56 ruined this video for me. I'm sorry but I can't be having this
How would Teardrop advocate for Needle? I think Pencil would be picked next and needle would go onto Leafys team
pointing, also just having that happen would mean the teams stay basically the same, which is kinda boring
Can you do if pin had her bfdia personalits in bfdi?
butterfly effect is crazy lmao
Pin would pick Coiny, needle, or Td
what if gelatin,yellow face and puffball were in bfdi???
All the others songs that are not made by HOME was made by Kevin MacLeod, not YOYLECAKE
holy crap thanks for telling me I was half asleep when I posted this, I fixed it now, thanks again!
Please make a part 2
nice!
How do you get all of this just from pin picking first-
Coolio
I would choose Needle to leave over blocky as needy would just continue to get more hate
pin did win rock paper scissors tho
"TD advocates for needle"
With what words?
pointing
I Think Snowball And Woody Would Switch
Needle wasn't athletic in BFDI
butterfly effect
Than pin would win the island if pin pushed off leafy
why does pencil vote leafy for who they want to win when pencil could've voted bubble or firey.
because in canon she switched to leafy after everyone threatened to slap her
@@bruhmomentum_ oh mb
And sam
why no crying contest
33rd like!😅
like get 4 views
Yeah, this makes more sense because pin won the rock paper scissors