You can't simply compare situations like this. A judgment you deem appropriate may not align with existing laws. Unlike a khap panchayat court where instant punishment is handed out, legal proceedings rely on reasoned arguments, counter-logic, and remain bound by a structured legal framework. A judge might deliver a verdict that seems counterintuitive to us, but we lack the intricate knowledge of the law. Furthermore, even when guilt seems evident, a judge may be unable to deliver a fitting verdict due to insufficient evidence.
@@junoonbeatz what's the difference between hearings of sc and hc, don't the both follow same regulations and laws?? Don't the both rely on as you said reasoned arguments ,logic and are bounded by legal structure??
The HC judge's questioning is of a different class than that of CJI who's better at giving empty speeches and pandering to the gallery. Grow a spine will you.
@Trueman571 Yes you are correct yesterday i mentioned this in my comment. Further by the way this hon'ble CJ conducts this case even if we say's thousands of hats off not enough.🫡❤
WE are disappointed at yesterdays ruling because the rebuke was mild, tacit and diplomatic in nature. On a lighter note keeping the spirit of the comment in view , a heavy dose of Vitamin C and D is required .
Can this case again be transferred to the HC, the HC judge is asking better questions than the SC and appears to be less bias in the line of questioning. I watched the SC court session and thought to myself why the CJI was so lenient and didn't push answers for the questions. #WeWantJustice.
The Donations received, spent, beneficiaries and the balance available by all political parties need to be ascertained by audit by CAG and the information made available in the public domain. For a "Clean Democracy" this is a MUST. for public money is involved.
Dear Sir, Can you please clarify why the colleagues of the killed doctor who were present that very night are not yet been interrogated. CBI should update the common person their findings time to time. As of now, it seems to me that CBI is also diverted from the course of investigation our of some unknown reason.
why is the arguments being conducted in this manner were a crowd looking Lawyers are pleading infront of Milords. Can this be done in more disciplined manner..
Absolutely infuriating!! The Indian Judiciary is nothing short of a mockery to the blind lady of Justice who desperately seeks impartial justice delivered swiftly and without any excuses or loopholes. But guess what? That’s a fantasy in India, especially when the Supreme Court steps in and makes it beyond frustrating!
most suspicious people as far i know 1) sandip ghosh :- he litrally said to her parents that your child had done sucide. also he done lot of corruptions in hospital. also tried to harass some hospital staff members in past. 2)sanjay roy: he involved directly in the rape case. 3)moumita debnath's bachmates ;- they didnt reveal there names,( if anyone know reply me) 4)Mr. Sibal - The lawyer mentioned as supporting Sandeep Ghosh. 5)Unidentified Hospital Staff Members - The document mentions that the CBI has been questioning multiple hospital staff members, which implies there may be other individuals within the hospital administration who could be linked to the case or the alleged cover-up. if you guys knew anything let me know . so lets try to investigate here.
The whole murder case is getting misleading now ... the RGKAR Medical collage irregularities is a different matter alltogther .... justice must be centred to the demised intern PG doctor . What the hell is wrong with the system ..??
Did god come and give a verdict? They are in the place of God, that they have the power of God to give judgement. Look at the practical way of human life.
Why the lawyers stand like that without any order, like in a fish market? Why can't other lawyers who are not talking sit in the court? Is it also a colonial practice?
To honor her a law should make in the name of the victim ! Because she will be the reason for the change.. her life should not go in vain she wanted to get a gold medal in her degree , atleast she could have a law in her name ! I hope this idea may cross in their mind too..
Why is the case being heard at both the Hon'ble HC and SC simultaneously? Can someone please enlighten me? I thought the top court would handle ALL hearings, related to this case, as said in the media.
Does the victim get the proper justice according to IPC? I have doubts. There are so many issues have been involved in this case. The culprits are get enough shed to escape. The main issue is gradually diluting.
Ask principal Gosh why he paid 2.5+ Crores for the same medical equipment which his competitive medical institute got for about 60 lacs Rs.as reported by a lawyer in his video interview with an U-tuber. The lawyer also said that he have been victimized by Bengal authorities for exposing the corruptions in Bengal and is facing 9 cases against him for doing right things. Free West Bengal from Mafia queen like CM racking millions through bribes & corruptions through her hired corrupt vagabonds like Gosh.
Probably the fate of the R G K hospital case will be like the D A case of West Bengal. Many old pensioners will left this soil without the blessing of Supreme court but they will not be deprived of the blessing of Supreme LORD.
my LORD saying stop it, it looks the union jack flying in the court, JUST SIR is enough, to convey the statement. It also looks u are in church, as if u are in front of the LORD.
Hc verdict definitely seems more unbiased while supreme court clearly looks like claiming whatever already found like a statement. Like this is a henious crime, crime spot should not be vandalised... doctors should have better facilities... after few days it will be closed with no evidence. SC doesnt seem to take an approprite severe stand for the accused. Lets see if CJI chandrachud takes decision in favour of accused which i feel would be the judgement
We r clear the motive wB cm allowed goons to destroy the Scene of murder.Comon ppl also can understand what is the meaning of this permission to Principal n goons to destroy 😡😡😡😡
Sirs, Long arguments favour and against the case will simply delay in case and at last culprits will be freed mentioning that there is no proper witnesses and evidences. That is the biggest weak point in indian judiciary.
Court should explain when victim is not alive her identity has no harmful effect, if victim is alive we do understand that victims identity should be kept secreat for her future. Criminal did wrong thing and court is busy with death victims identity.
Rubbish what is impact of publishing victims photo on anything? Wasting time on unimp things. What is point in preventing publication of name and photo?
Waha already arrests, transfers, resignations done The culprit is arrested Police incharge who delayed the fir has been transferred Principal and teacher has been sacked by school management Also here CBI demand was from doctors and police irregularities compelled HC to ask for it
Is this a vegetable or a donkey market or court room? Why so many black coats r standing at the same time? No wonder so many crores of cases r pending in the courts, y courts doesn't have system to recognize how many cases they have, and allocate numbers to the lawyers and call them 1 by 1. How does Judges maintain order in the court? Lawyers don't have discipline, etiquettes or public presence.
It is truly shocking to hear about the recent incident and the ongoing law and order issues in West Bengal. TATA once remarked that there are two states in India where it is nearly impossible to start any business: West Bengal and Kerala. Unfortunately, this has proven to be true. It’s deeply troubling that such incidents have occurred under the leadership of a woman Chief Minister, with no significant action being taken. This reflects poorly on Mamata Banerjee’s governance. The fact that this case has now come to light makes one wonder how many other women might have suffered under her administration. It’s disheartening to see that she shows no remorse and continues to play political games. President rule need to be imposed or West Bengal soon become an internal part of Bangladesh
Pl reveal the names of the perpetrator doctors. Minority names are known to everybody. And two doctors are missing till date. They are lovers as well we came to know.
You can't simply compare SC VS HC. A judgment you deem appropriate may not align with existing laws. Unlike a khap panchayat court where instant punishment is handed out, legal proceedings rely on reasoned arguments, counter-logic, and remain bound by a structured legal framework. A judge might deliver a verdict that seems counterintuitive to us, but we lack the intricate knowledge of the law. Furthermore, even when guilt seems evident, a judge may be unable to deliver a fitting verdict due to insufficient evidence.
Therefore I request your honour to simplify the case on the basis of facts and evidences available not on quoting law and orders. If you do this speed justice can be given and other nirbhaya and abhaya and other rape and murder cases solved amicably.
This is Men dominated world , Now India is ruled by the adultered men. [ As the removal of adultery law mostly enjoyed by men lawyers men can t able to do complete justice for any women this is a drama they all performing once again and playing with the safety of women in indian society, all the departments of police , law , hospitals, womens protection cell , educated and uneducated people very well know or some where they felt insecurity in women safety all over places due to lack of systematic networks to trace out the culprits before doing crime , in this case culprit before only showed the signs of his psycho traits but soceity , police lawyers doctors network or power is limited to hospital , leaving toxic people free in society
It is such a sad state of affairs... Their pronunciation and attitude in presenting their points and arguments are worse than that of an uneducated person... they can't even read or say things properly... It is such a shame...
When Chandrachud cannot pronounce "premises" properly... Not shame but sad. Also, Sibal was making preposterous statements, and Chandrachud never once asked him to go on record. HC didn't let those types of statements pass last week. Of course, I didn't watch any unedited broadcast, only some edited versions where who knows whether bias was introduced by the editor(s) to present only their viewpoints.
Sirs, Long arguments favour and against the case will simply delay in case and at last culprits will be freed mentioning that there is no proper witnesses and evidences. That is the biggest weak point in indian judiciary.
The high court judgement is much better than the supreme Court
Yes
Dono courts mein ek saath chal raha hai kyaa?
You can't simply compare situations like this. A judgment you deem appropriate may not align with existing laws. Unlike a khap panchayat court where instant punishment is handed out, legal proceedings rely on reasoned arguments, counter-logic, and remain bound by a structured legal framework. A judge might deliver a verdict that seems counterintuitive to us, but we lack the intricate knowledge of the law. Furthermore, even when guilt seems evident, a judge may be unable to deliver a fitting verdict due to insufficient evidence.
@@junoonbeatz what's the difference between hearings of sc and hc, don't the both follow same regulations and laws?? Don't the both rely on as you said reasoned arguments ,logic and are bounded by legal structure??
@@junoonbeatz these cartoons have nothing to do with laws. They want Sc to act as per their d e l u s i o n s
This principal, how much property he owns? Why 20 bouncers? He should be investigated thoroughly. Very corrupt man
The HC judge's questioning is of a different class than that of CJI who's better at giving empty speeches and pandering to the gallery. Grow a spine will you.
CJI trying to act a prophet. Some messiah
@Trueman571
Yes you are correct yesterday i mentioned this in my comment.
Further by the way this hon'ble CJ conducts this case even if we say's thousands of hats off not enough.🫡❤
CJI wants to play to the gallery.
WE are disappointed at yesterdays ruling because the rebuke was mild, tacit and diplomatic in nature. On a lighter note keeping the spirit of the comment in view , a heavy dose of Vitamin C and D is required .
only gas ,, bla bla
CJI should learn from this court judge
This Judge is Humble yet straight forward
CJI has saved MUMTAJ BANO GOVERNMENT
How bro
Yes
@@VidhyaBharathi-pi2uq cJI didn’t question
1. Principal of RG KAR
2. Police chief
3. Health minister
4. Home minister
He saved Mamta in Teacher scam case, municipality recruitment scam case, now this. @@VidhyaBharathi-pi2uq
Very true.I've smell the first day CJI declared to take SC.Its crystal clear SC wants to protect WB CM from this Crime .So it's work urgently
Why do our courts look more like a railway booking counter? Noticed the same in yesterday's videos from Supreme-court
You just said it. XD
The junior lawyers are there to observe and learn. Same as residents standing behind attending physicians during patient rounds and surgeries
Lawyers talk like school kids...keep on repeating MI Lord MI Lord ...poor English diction & grammar
If 10 more persons enter the hall, they will have to stand alongside the judges.
@@mchandrashekhar4043 noticed that as well. Strange culture where lawyers look like slaves begging in front of the judge.
CJI trying to divert case
Very true
Exactly
Can this case again be transferred to the HC, the HC judge is asking better questions than the SC and appears to be less bias in the line of questioning. I watched the SC court session and thought to myself why the CJI was so lenient and didn't push answers for the questions. #WeWantJustice.
Justice mr.Sivaganam will give justice to the victim
Is that the name of the Honorable Chief Justice of Kolkata High Court?
Yeah @@ArindamKumar_2002
Yeah@@ArindamKumar_2002
DRUG AÑD NARCOTIC Buro ALSO MUST IÑVESTIGATE
liked the high court hearing rather than supreme court ..
The Donations received, spent, beneficiaries and the balance available by all political parties need to be ascertained by audit by CAG and the information made available in the public domain. For a "Clean Democracy" this is a MUST. for public money is involved.
Dear Sir, Can you please clarify why the colleagues of the killed doctor who were present that very night are not yet been interrogated. CBI should update the common person their findings time to time. As of now, it seems to me that CBI is also diverted from the course of investigation our of some unknown reason.
I too feel d same
Chief Justice of the High Court, thank you for trying.
Indian Democracy is bucket with holes, the system needs to be fixed at root levels.
why is the arguments being conducted in this manner were a crowd looking Lawyers are pleading infront of Milords. Can this be done in more disciplined manner..
Absolutely infuriating!! The Indian Judiciary is nothing short of a mockery to the blind lady of Justice who desperately seeks impartial justice delivered swiftly and without any excuses or loopholes. But guess what? That’s a fantasy in India, especially when the Supreme Court steps in and makes it beyond frustrating!
Taxpayers must demand transparency from Judiciary .
Law Chakra, cool content dude
Momta wanted to safeguard principal by taking him to custody in finance crime.
Now since central ED is in picture..begum lost the game
Now didi asking justice to didi. What is going on in west bengal.
The Learned Chief Justice is a fine and sympathetic Judge.
Now I am a great fan of CJ High court
psychoanalysis test must be taken entire hospital authorities.
Yes
Please, I request all serving in the CBI, ED, do honestly so that we have confidence and people get the TRUTH. We are watching
most suspicious people as far i know
1) sandip ghosh :- he litrally said to her parents that your child had done sucide. also he done lot of corruptions in hospital. also tried to harass some hospital staff members in past.
2)sanjay roy: he involved directly in the rape case.
3)moumita debnath's bachmates ;- they didnt reveal there names,( if anyone know reply me)
4)Mr. Sibal - The lawyer mentioned as supporting Sandeep Ghosh.
5)Unidentified Hospital Staff Members - The document mentions that the CBI has been questioning multiple hospital staff members, which implies there may be other individuals within the hospital administration who could be linked to the case or the alleged cover-up.
if you guys knew anything let me know . so lets try to investigate here.
The reason why court has so many pending cases is cos every sentence has milord mentioned 3-5 times. This makes the case time 2 X of required time
The whole murder case is getting misleading now ... the RGKAR Medical collage irregularities is a different matter alltogther .... justice must be centred to the demised intern PG doctor . What the hell is wrong with the system ..??
WHY say my lord my lord??? Judges are NOT God!!! They should be called Justice x,Justice y,Chief justice..thats it!!!
Complete agree this whole culture of chmachagiri must end
Have same feelings.
Did god come and give a verdict? They are in the place of God, that they have the power of God to give judgement.
Look at the practical way of human life.
Our courts didn’t changed after the british left and thus the pathetic conditions
Why the lawyers stand like that without any order, like in a fish market? Why can't other lawyers who are not talking sit in the court? Is it also a colonial practice?
HIGH COURT MUCH BETTER THAN SUPREME COURT JUDGES
We have very less hope seeing the way things are going on and the way this case is being handled.
To honor her a law should make in the name of the victim ! Because she will be the reason for the change.. her life should not go in vain she wanted to get a gold medal in her degree , atleast she could have a law in her name ! I hope this idea may cross in their mind too..
Very good..... already started"tarikh pe tarikh" god knows about"justice"...... justice is just a joke..... Nothing will happen.....
When the victim is not survived, whay is wrong in publishing the name and other details.?
Why is the case being heard at both the Hon'ble HC and SC simultaneously? Can someone please enlighten me? I thought the top court would handle ALL hearings, related to this case, as said in the media.
Does the victim get the proper justice according to IPC? I have doubts. There are so many issues have been involved in this case. The culprits are get enough shed to escape. The main issue is gradually diluting.
Ask principal Gosh why he paid 2.5+ Crores for the same medical equipment which his competitive medical institute got for about 60 lacs Rs.as reported by a lawyer in his video interview with an U-tuber. The lawyer also said that he have been victimized by Bengal authorities for exposing the corruptions in Bengal and is facing 9 cases against him for doing right things.
Free West Bengal from Mafia queen like CM racking millions through bribes & corruptions through her hired corrupt vagabonds like Gosh.
Probably the fate of the R G K hospital case will be like the D A case of West Bengal. Many old pensioners will left this soil without the blessing of Supreme court but they will not be deprived of the blessing of Supreme LORD.
Sirs, your arguments are o.k.
But what about true justice to victim and her family and also to general public.
my LORD saying stop it, it looks the union jack flying in the court, JUST SIR is enough, to convey the statement. It also looks u are in church, as if u are in front of the LORD.
We want Justice...
Why are they all standing and crowding? Are there no chairs available in the room?
Now Pandora box will be opened. My sincere condolences to the bereaved family of the victim and she has to get justice.
Vineet Kumar Goyal who has reputation of completely botched up kamdhini case
Hc verdict definitely seems more unbiased while supreme court clearly looks like claiming whatever already found like a statement. Like this is a henious crime, crime spot should not be vandalised... doctors should have better facilities... after few days it will be closed with no evidence. SC doesnt seem to take an approprite severe stand for the accused. Lets see if CJI chandrachud takes decision in favour of accused which i feel would be the judgement
Supreme court has given directions. Now Vigilance deptt WB OR ED can investigate
We r clear the motive wB cm allowed goons to destroy the Scene of murder.Comon ppl also can understand what is the meaning of this permission to Principal n goons to destroy 😡😡😡😡
Sirs,
Long arguments favour and against the case will simply delay in case and at last culprits will be freed mentioning that there is no proper witnesses and evidences. That is the biggest weak point in indian judiciary.
Court should explain when victim is not alive her identity has no harmful effect, if victim is alive we do understand that victims identity should be kept secreat for her future. Criminal did wrong thing and court is busy with death victims identity.
I know right? There are so many things that are still unanswered.. But judges are still pondering on basic stuffs ..
Rubbish what is impact of publishing victims photo on anything? Wasting time on unimp things. What is point in preventing publication of name and photo?
Sandep Ghosh related to Mamata and she trying to protect him. She must go to jail.
Why are the lawyers so crowded in the front.?
Maharashtra may ED aur CBI kab jayegi minor assault case may....
Rahul gandhi ko jane ke bath
Waha already arrests, transfers, resignations done
The culprit is arrested
Police incharge who delayed the fir has been transferred
Principal and teacher has been sacked by school management
Also here CBI demand was from doctors and police irregularities compelled HC to ask for it
super HC
HC ki value is finished by SUPREME COURT. They just take HC as time pass .
Is this a vegetable or a donkey market or court room? Why so many black coats r standing at the same time? No wonder so many crores of cases r pending in the courts, y courts doesn't have system to recognize how many cases they have, and allocate numbers to the lawyers and call them 1 by 1. How does Judges maintain order in the court? Lawyers don't have discipline, etiquettes or public presence.
It is truly shocking to hear about the recent incident and the ongoing law and order issues in West Bengal. TATA once remarked that there are two states in India where it is nearly impossible to start any business: West Bengal and Kerala. Unfortunately, this has proven to be true.
It’s deeply troubling that such incidents have occurred under the leadership of a woman Chief Minister, with no significant action being taken. This reflects poorly on Mamata Banerjee’s governance. The fact that this case has now come to light makes one wonder how many other women might have suffered under her administration. It’s disheartening to see that she shows no remorse and continues to play political games. President rule need to be imposed or West Bengal soon become an internal part of Bangladesh
This judge is far more just than CJI
All the hard works of HC will finally go in vain by SC. Previously we already witnessed same in different cases.
Pl reveal the names of the perpetrator doctors. Minority names are known to everybody. And two doctors are missing till date. They are lovers as well we came to know.
Why do they keep on saying 'my lord' and 'lordship' so many times ?
You can't simply compare SC VS HC. A judgment you deem appropriate may not align with existing laws. Unlike a khap panchayat court where instant punishment is handed out, legal proceedings rely on reasoned arguments, counter-logic, and remain bound by a structured legal framework. A judge might deliver a verdict that seems counterintuitive to us, but we lack the intricate knowledge of the law. Furthermore, even when guilt seems evident, a judge may be unable to deliver a fitting verdict due to insufficient evidence.
Med students failed,& harassed by Principal,taken money by ex principal,is degrading humanity,& med profession.😮
Is High court still listening this case . Will there not be conflict of interest with supreme court listening
I have less hope with india court amd govt to
Now the whole of bengal know the names of perpetrators. Why you are not revealing their names?
High court judge is better than supreme court judge
ED, knows about much of laundering
Therefore I request your honour to simplify the case on the basis of facts and evidences available not on quoting law and orders. If you do this speed justice can be given and other nirbhaya and abhaya and other rape and murder cases solved amicably.
Sushant singh rajpoot case repeat ho ra..jhaant kuch ni hoga
OH PLEASE😂😂😂
THEY HAVE LET THE SONS OF MPS AND MLAS RUN AWAY TO ANOTHER COUNTRY 😂😂😂
Sandip is yet another scapegoat and the public has no idea🥲🥲🤣🤣🤣🤣
Sandip is not a scapegoat but ofcourse a lesser evil. Atleast he should taste justice. But, alas, SC will not allow this to happen.
Truth
Why SC wont allow it to happen.can u explain whats happening in court? I did not understand @@sumanpaulchowdhury8333
This is Men dominated world , Now India is ruled by the adultered men. [ As the removal of adultery law mostly enjoyed by men lawyers men can t able to do complete justice for any women this is a drama they all performing once again and playing with the safety of women in indian society, all the departments of police , law , hospitals, womens protection cell , educated and uneducated people very well know or some where they felt insecurity in women safety all over places due to lack of systematic networks to trace out the culprits before doing crime , in this case culprit before only showed the signs of his psycho traits but soceity , police lawyers doctors network or power is limited to hospital , leaving toxic people free in society
Lord is Lord.. Justice is with the Lord. 🙏👍
ED or blackmailing department😃
Don't be stupid.
Try to understand the sensitivity of the matter
@@onlytruth9321 yes the matter is sensitive for people not for opposition.
@@bharatrajshetty5582 Huh? If yes, then you are one of them.
There is ghotala ,mareej from bangladesh so there is financial irregularities
IrregulaDiDi😂
It is such a sad state of affairs... Their pronunciation and attitude in presenting their points and arguments are worse than that of an uneducated person... they can't even read or say things properly... It is such a shame...
When Chandrachud cannot pronounce "premises" properly... Not shame but sad. Also, Sibal was making preposterous statements, and Chandrachud never once asked him to go on record. HC didn't let those types of statements pass last week. Of course, I didn't watch any unedited broadcast, only some edited versions where who knows whether bias was introduced by the editor(s) to present only their viewpoints.
Sirs,
Long arguments favour and against the case will simply delay in case and at last culprits will be freed mentioning that there is no proper witnesses and evidences. That is the biggest weak point in indian judiciary.