ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ก.พ. 2025
- EDITORIAL BOARDS ON PEER REVIEW JOURNALS. This short video by John Bond of Riverwinds Consulting discusses being a member on an Editorial Board.
FIND OUT more about John Bond and his publishing consulting practice at www.RiverwindsConsulting.com
JOHN'S NEW BOOK is “Scholarly Publishing: A Primer”
To find out more about the book: www.booksbyjoh...
Buy it at Amazon:
amzn.to/2jqaLPp
SEND IDEAS for John to discuss on Publishing Defined. Email him at jbond@riverwindsconsulting.com or see www.PublishingD...
CONNECT
Twitter: / johnhbond
LinkedIn: / johnbondnj
Google+: plus.google.co...
Goodreads: / john-bond
TH-cam: / johnbond
TRANSCRIPT
Hi there. I am John Bond from Riverwinds Consulting and this is Publishing Defined.
Today I am going to talk about being an editorial board member on a peer review journal. The editorial board of a journal provides direction, gives insight into new developments in the field, is an advocate for the journal to the community, and, probably most notably, provides peer review for submitted manuscripts. Editorial boards can vary from perhaps a dozen professionals to more than a hundred. They usually cover all areas of interest within the specialty of the publication. Increasingly they come from the global community, unless the publication is geographically limited.
The board is headed up by an editor, or editor in chief, or one of many other titles. Sometimes there might be senior editors or associate editors that help direct the publication and perform the many duties necessary to run the journal.
The editor and editorial board serve at the behest of the publisher or association that runs or owns the journal. In most instances, the board serves in an advisory capacity and is not a voting board.
As I mentioned, the primary duty of editorial board members is to peer review manuscripts. Thankfully this is done via sophisticated online manuscript tracking software. The reviewer can leave detailed comments about the paper and then suggest if the manuscript be accepted, rejected, or sent back for revision. Most reviewers are not asked to edit or rewrite manuscripts, but more to focus on content. A reviewer might be asked to review a few manuscripts a year, or sometimes many more than that. Timeliness of review is important to all publications.
Being on an editorial board is an unpaid position. The position of editor and perhaps some other senior positions usually come with an honorarium.
Most members are asked to join the board as their career reaches prominence. Some are recommended by others on the board. The requirements usually for board membership are: having significant advancement in the field, a track record in writing and perhaps editing, previous reviewing experience perhaps on other journals or committees, and, if an association publication, being a member of the association. Some journals entertain self-nomination to a board.
Sometimes board members will serve a specific term of a few years. Other times, it is at the discretion of the editor. Change on an editorial board is a good thing. It allows new ideas and new perspectives to keep the journal fresh.
Editorial board members are the backbone of the scholarly journal system. They ensure the quality of the content and the integrity of the peer review system. There has been much discussion about this uncompensated work. Stay tuned to see if the industry moves towards a new model for compensation, versus simply career recognition.
Well that’s it. I am a publishing consultant and work with associations, publishers, and individuals on a host of content related challenges. Reach out to me at RiverwindsConsulting.com.
Hit the Like button below if you enjoyed this video. Please subscribe to my TH-cam channel or click on the playlist or more videos about scholarly publishing.
And make comments below. Thank so much and take care.
Thanks for this valuable information. I am a reviewer and an active researcher in my field, as being an editor is an unpaid position, I was wondering what are the benefits of being one.
Thank you for the comment. The benefits are all career advancement. It can raise your profile in your profession.
What does the status "With Editorial Board" mean? Is good or bad news about my article?
Great John, I am working as Chief Editor of Abasyn Journal of Life Sciences. Nice Video Thanks
Thanks for the comment. My pleasure. Best wishes with your work.
We wait for JCER youtube channel
Dear John Bond, first of all thanks for your helpful efforts. Can you make a video class about "compendex"
Dear Saiyd
Thanks for the comment. I will gladly do one. What has been your experience, if any with it? Best wishes.
John
"The Best Student Paper Contest will be held during the conference. Registered and Presented papers will be submitted for inclusion into IEEE Xplore and indexed by EI Compendex" This information from a conference website and we do not understand the indexing process of "Compendex". Thank you
Thanks Saiyd
I will dig in and see if I can do a video on these types of services. Best wishes.
U look more like old James Bond. :)
Ha, ha. Thanks, I guess.