Nirmala Sitharaman spars with Mallikarjun Kharge over his 'weak women' remark in Rajya Sabha
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 18 ก.ย. 2023
- Rajya Sabha, in its first sitting in the new Parliament building, witnessed sparring between Mallikarjun Kharge and Nirmala Sitharaman after the former’s remarks that political parties picked “weak women” as candidates and “won't choose those who're educated and can fight.” “Largely, ladies from backward and scheduled castes are not that literate. Their literacy rate is low, because of which all political parties have a habit of nominating weak women,” Kharge, who is Leader of Opposition in the Upper House, said. Reacting to Kharge's remarks, Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman, on behalf of her party, the BJP registered a strong protest stating that Kharge’s “sweeping statement” was “absolutely unacceptable.”
► Subscribe to The Economic Times for the latest video updates. It's free! - th-cam.com/users/TheEconomicTi...
► More Videos @ ETTV - economictimes.indiatimes.com/TV
► EconomicTimes.com
► For business news on the go, download ET app:
etapp.onelink.me/tOvY/Economi...
Follow ET on:
► Facebook - / economictimes
► Twitter - / economictimes
► LinkedIn - / economictimes
► Instagram - / the_economic_times
► Flipboard - flipboard.com/@economictimes
#news #latestnews #economictimes #ET #TheEconomicTimes #businessnews
You can give them a new buildings with state-of-the-art technology, but you cannot teach these MPs civility in debate and discourse, and working for the people. Such a shame!
So, kharge himself accepted that italian mummy/ Italian granny sonia Gandy isn't an deserving women. She was the president of Congress for 20 years .😂😂😂
And she was essentially the prime minister of India for 10 years😅
Italian pasta 🍝🍝🍝😂
Wahi toh 😂😂😂
@@vasusingh5046We were ruled by Britishers till 1947 and by Italian mommy from 1991 to 2014.
Congress never thought of a tribal man or woman to be the top of the constitution.😂
I want to be a DALIT like Mallikarjun Kharge. Atleast I can own 50000 crore assets.
His net worth is not 50k crores
@@meghanath5045 Yes it is. Everyone in Karnataka knows Kharge and DK Shiva Kumar are Congress money bags for Antonio Maino.
Rich SC ST is the biggest privilege in India...
Reservation+Victim card
@@meghanath5045 what is his net worth?
@@user-uu8uk2qj1l😂 Idot, Iam from Karnataka SC, and my father income is above creamy layers and according to laws we are not entitled for any SC benefits.
They had given reservation to EBC as well
The real cast politics have been dont by Modi when he said he will give reservation to Lingayats and not to Muslims in Karnataka.
kharge ji showing the reality of his party in the name of all party does it... 😂😂😂😂😂
It is projection
atleast he has guts to speaking the truth
Kharge as usual a right man in the right party.. Can't expect any thing better than this😢
The building looks stunning.They should allow for conferences and tourist visits when parliament not in session so that one could meditate in silence😊😊😊
Same thugs. New building. No change.
@@akhileshmagalwhy do u vote for thugs ?
@@akhileshmagal For 75 years it used to be new thugs, same building but now it is other way round!!
Kharge can't think beyond caste politics. He is a dinosaur whose politics and policies belong to the 1960s.
Yes n now they want to break hindu on caste n take sc st pn their side
He looks like a dinosaur too 🤣
@@ImJayrajD0⁰⁹
Reservation is just crap. And these chappreees want to divide people again and again based on caste and create a rift.
From birth till death caste plays major role in india
This party ruled for almost 65 years but they were not able to pass this Legislation now they r accusing i thing worst political party ever is Congress party
COMMUNAL ' khaan ' GRACE.
Satyamvadami2770: do your maths properly before commenting. India got independence in 2014 as per you blind supporters. So how did the 65 years derived?
So if you are not a bakth, did you knew about Mr. Morarji Desai, Mr. Vajpayee,...... what happened to their periods? Not everyone reading your message are mindless bakth’s. Be responsible when commenting
Yes sati will also come back😅
And the irony is when Congress brought this bill in loksabha, their own ally Samajwadi Party and RJD opposed it and it couldn't pass.
@@leethewsie8384
We will start from your
HOUSE only.
What else can you expect from Pappu's Disgraceful Congress 😕
Nothing 😑😥
Only shame and corruption
Nonsense
Karghe is shame for Karnataka
Dharge just knows one woman we all know who’s 😂 that
CAMBRIDGE'S BAR DANCER
🤣😆😂😅😁
Italian mommy
1. Karge is less educated than any avg women from any cast.
2. He is weaker than any women from any cast.
3. According to karge, sonia is the ideal women who never completed schooling.
Wahi to.......
😅😅😅😅
A women reservation is not about SC OR ST but choose efficient women who can speak about issues, who could talk or identify solutions. It is more important to choose efficient women leader rather a women from any particular category.
The basis of this bill is to 'represent', not just women, but women of all sections
Mr Kharge should clarify why education n literacy is less in OBC/SC/ST? Why didn't Congress try to uplift those women during their regime?
Mallikarjun Kharge is unfit to be in Parliament for his derogatory remarks against women. He is learning from Rahul, so we cannot expect minimum etiquette from these type of mediocre leaders
Remember when women's minister once said in the parliament on the issue of flying kiss by calling " such misogynist men" . Is it not against men? Are you anti men??
kharge and people from his caste don’t respect women
Does Kharge is telling indirectly that Antonia Maino is weak ?
Yes
Kharge is discriminating against indigenous women of Bharat. The term backward people should be removed from Bharats dictionary the term backward is derogatory
Also remove reservation if you're not backward then you don't need it now, do you?
@@Kushagra.j every human is equal regardless of race colour or religious beliefs colonial instituted reservations should be abolished. Reservations for native Americans still exist in USA . Government control of temples should be given back to the people. This colonial law still exists in India which is discriminatory and suppresses the voice of the Hindu nation Christian and Islamic institutions are not controlled by Indian government
How can they then play victim card and get all reservation and still act as victim.
@@Kushagra.jI absolutely agree with you but it's not easy at all. People won't give away free benefits just like that.
Wo khud dalit hai wo bol sakta hai
congress selected him instead of Tharoor. what do you expect
Because kharge will remain like a pet dog at the feet of Gandhi family whereas tharoor an educated man takes decisions according to his conscience which is not acceptable in Congress party
Yes
They want puppies not competition
Shashi Tharoor would be the best choice for a party leader....this man is a wrong choice.....
Kharge isn't 1% educated as Nirmala ji😂
For your kind information, Mallikarjun kharge sir is a law graduate and he was the assistant of former SC justice, shivraj Patil...
@@Adv.ehtesham well Nirmala ji has way more qualifications but I was talking about being educated.
@truegod... with all due respect to Nirmala ji, she is not even an ant in front of a Stalwart like kharge Ji. Stop talking things which you don't any idea about.
@@itachisensei3306 that's an opinion 😂😂 give facts
@truegod... That's fact. You may go ask modi Ji. And he will tell you better. Lol
Kharge is one of the few politicians in india who has his say across party line.
Here, he literally exposed parties how they only choose sc, st, and obc people who don't have any say on the ground so that these people can fall in line.
Kharge was talking about his own party and he should be ashamed of his party that such things happen in his party for sure. Big salute to Nirmalaji
INC could not even get a woman to debate on this point. Wah!
Also get better points too guys. Ucould have easily countered her with "which election did u win (empowered woman) Nirmala ji?" Baat khatam.
That would have been a bad counterargument. Glad that Congress party did not resort to such cheap personal attacks!
The reason that is a bad argument is, this bill of reservation for women does not apply to Rajya Sabha members. It is only applicable for Lok Sabha. Minister Nirmala Sitaraman is a Rajya Sabha member.
That would be a disaster.....then BJP would have attacked MMS....he was a non elected PM for 10yeras!!
@@sumanpaulchowdhury8333 mms and women's bill?
@@Sameer_S_Kulkarni Exactly. The reason y Nirmala ji was speaking was because she was inducted to rs unlike how she said she was empowered. Her point fails.
@@surejreginald Not related to women bill but if Congress countered Sitharaman with the question you suggested then BJP would have counter that with the MMS logic, because parties are not going to counter on a very logical way but will exploit any situation as per their convenience and that would not be a good thing to do.... personal attack
Congress always break the country. They make religion vs religion, brother vs brother, now caste vs caste. And now WOMEN vs WOMEN. such a shameless party thu......
I have known kharge for long time his knowledge is as a 5 year old don't know why PM give him so much respect
Wah re congress....😂😂
Khadge ji now becoming senior pappu
Absolutely
It's Kharge, not Khadge
Birds of the same feather
With an asset of 5000 cr a man complains about discrimination 😂 seriously, want to be dalit like kharge in my next life. Wearing garments of Louis Vuitton and claiming himself as a representative of backward class. Only one card in India , you can use as much as you can and that's what kharge is using since 80's. And till now it is as loaded as before.
Ohh the president of india is sc st community ❤
She is from tribal community
After winning karnataka elections this Nehru-Italian Gandhi Family Slave Kharge is barking to much people to know to elect & kick out also
Congress is shame for our country…I wish we get some good opposition🙏🙏🙏
Sure in 2024 u will see bjp as good opposition 😊😊😊😊😊Bharath zindabad
@@aejazahmedu901 Bhai comedy kr rahe ho tum toh😂
@@aejazahmedu901😂😂😂 ek aur joke suna joker
Probably he refers to Raghul,'s selection of "weak" (!) ladies.
But look at Nirmalaji, a bold lady selected by BJP.
Khargeji has lost his mind...what has he done so many years..
Whether in new parliament or old people are the same till election arrives. This kind inhuman screaming willc continue till then honestly seperate tutioning necessary for these so far elected representatives. Govt can bring about a law that will take steps to teach these legislatures about respecting each other inside the house
Boycott congress from bharat...
Shame shame congress still they are doing politics...
Since he is around such a woman he can't think beyond
Kharge has become mad. He is the best example of what he said.
Leaders should "Be informed, keep updated". Speeches show their knowledge. Ohh God!
Karge is one of bog drama person for authority not country
Even he doesn't know his Religion.he is talking about women in this country..
arre wah....sansad me lcd lag gaya he....ab dokhega kon stapler phekta he kon paper stand phek raha
The Italian mummy is who😊
I have seen in Maharashtra mostly those women's are given tickets whose husband is politician and the seats had been reserved for them.
Kharge is like frog in well, and the well is organised by Sonia
What about Sonia Gandhi?
Why she will not speak anything in parliament?
Even about women reservation bill 🤔🧐
I think after my comment next day sonia Gandhi spoke
I have seen that she was struggling to speak in Hindi
I think a South Indian who is learning Hindi can speak more better
But still she did her best , but not enough
Malli sir has to admit that only his party has weak women not all parties
I guess M. Kharge is talking about his own party nominating Prathiba Patil for President in the past.
Is it more important to choose correct, efficient women or choose tribal women.
Nirmaja ji is telling this demon kharge that president of Bharat is an sc women and according to this demon kharge only chamaras are scs and not tribals
Now our MPs sre sitting freely in the Parliament
So convert Italian mummy to quota category
K the most good for nothing evil in an evil group
🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🙏VijayHO JaiBharath VijayHO DeshBhakths Sanathanas VijayHO SengholRakshak NayaNamoBharath YughMahaVishwaGuru VijayHO BJP VijayHO AMSIR🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳
Congress ke harne ka ek reason Kharge bhi hai😂😂😂😂
Kharge is cementing BJP's majority in upcoming elections
1:15 good to see marshals beside speaker wearing "Mysuru peta"
Sonia Gandhi is from PVTG in remote forest of Jharkhand..
IT and ED must now probe Khadge’s 5000 cr property mystery .
MALLIKARJUN KHARGE IS DALIT AND SONIA IS REPRESENTING UNEMPOWERD WOMEN. 😂
What happens to leaders of opposition in India??.. Pappu is a title that should be given to the leader of opposition of India...perhaps like Pappu The Second "Kharge"..The should start looking for "Papu Tye Third" now..they have weak candidate to represent them..
Kharge ne ek bhason main apne apko Ravan ki bansaj kahatha. Today he proves its. Thank you sir
Agin started
Love the new furnishing. Looks more like Incredible India.❤
No politician in india who is more jativadi than kharge,
Horrible behaviour from the ruling party. They are not even letting the opposition talk!
Dude, he sounds like that villain politician from Sarkar. Get this chap into Bollywood.
They should have bill to remove all reservations by 2029 or 2034•
Not this regressive idea of introducing bills•
Another thing that needs to be done is women across hindu communities and Shudra across country are treated as equal when it comes to learning anything religious from vedas or doing any sansakaars•
Plus all the notions of women getting married and moving into man s house be made flexible, let them decide who move where• man should be allowed to take gotra of woman etc marriage be treated more of equal partnership•
That will solve most of the social discriminiation•
No reservation will be required•
India has become land of reservations unfortunately rather creating an ecosystem where reservations are not required•
Kharge has 2 faces brahmans and (open) kshatriya should leave india and other is this one .
Karge is 9 time mla and two time MP from Gulbarga which is still considered as one of the backward district in terms of HDI and literacy rates.. And his son Priyank using his dad name 3 time mla and currently minister in karnataka government.. Where is the effort from these guys to uplift people from poverty.. Illiteracy.. 🤔🤔🤔
Dhankar bhi like :- Fr kucch bhi bol diya isne 😂😂🤦🏽♂️
I dont understand why reservation?
These are important jobs only most talented should be appointed independend of gender.
Congress just knows how to play caste or religion politics.. no progressive thoughts.. And this guy is just speaking randomly.. first he tells all parties choose weak women.. then he says no represention of women from SC/ST community.. what rubbish..
This man is so communal and mad. He should be stripped down from power
kharge is absolutely right in saying this. we often see women as head in gram panchayat but all the power lies in the hands of her husband.
Such a shame Matlab kuch bhi kar k galat ko bhi sahi karna hai nai. And you have audacity to called other bhakts
@@kazuma2060 sorry yaar ...
I'm very political incorrect person.
Mujhe andhbhakt, jihadi,chamche saare tag se dikkat hai .
I don't tag anyone with this.
What I said exactly what often we see in our society.
I mean ,if your wife is an chieftain, municipal corporation heads , MLA or anything.
Then,why the hell you're getting involve in their business?
If you are giving a ticket or choosing a public representatives make sure he/she is capable of taking decision in public interest.
Did I say that women can't be decision makers?
No , I'm just against puppet women candidates.if you are giving that opportunity to women based upon reservation then select women who are efficient and independent.
Truth is Harsh:so you shout……😅
New building, new technology, same old grumpy people fighting like dogs and cats. I wish they could argue in a civilized way🙄
What Kharge said is absolutely right. Parties choose such men and women both who will not raise more question for power and few popular politicians can rule .
And women will be more prone to such.
Why is there castism even existing
Kaun hai
How many women clear IAS ,IPS ...etc give opportunity to educated .
Why congress always want dommy candidate.Hooo Bcs Rahul uneducated unfit candidate.😮😡😡😡
Onion minister 😂😂😂😂😂
So he is saying they made Indira Gandhi PM because she was not capable of it? What is he saying? My 13 year old son brought this up when he heard it. We need more informative leaders even in opposition party.
Parliment Business Airtel?
Classic example of Congress's caste politics.
What a Shame.
Proud of you nirmala sitaraman ❤️
Well why isn't government passing the law for all caste women . And what he said is true , only power women are given the posts .
Nirmala and smrithi both need a class to learn good manners
Even those who are tribal or so could become MLA OR MP If she is efficient enough. See our president maam.
Seriously congress has gone completely mad
खडगे जी जरा home work किया कीजिये, आप women की छोडो आप अपनी बात कीजिये OBC कहलाते हैं कितनी property है आप की
Honourable FM, when u say our president represent tribal women & we have empowered women's, then tell me why your party haven't invited president new parliament opening.
Whr is your sengol???
Wonder what he calls his mother ....
This is such a shame that these people still have this type of thinking about women in 21st century.
If you don't understand don't speak here... Barking everywhere with no valid point
@@sochankadeori2952 isnt it a shame abdulla, how he downgraded the women
@@watanabe00738 go get some education before speaking here...
Aap har dam ladies ko gents banana hi chahte hain..😅😅😅
They are not asking for reservations for all women that's the whole point of the Debate. How often have we seen empowered honorable Rastrapati Draupadi Murmu jee take a stand on anything? There have been numerous instances where she could have. To make things worse, the ruling party did away with the power of the honorable President of India to head the armed forces and appointed CDS instead. What kind of empowerment is that? A leader representative from a backward community is chosen for a rubberstamp position to disguise the reluctance of the government towards the women and minority and backward class representatives.
Congress as a party has lost its mind and dignity. They have been insulting India / Bharat, the people of the country and now even their very own leaders like Ex-PM Indira Gandhi and Ex-CM Sheila Dixit. When Congress party people talk about backward section women let me remind Congress and their allies had voted against now President of India Srimati Droupadi Murmur and instead voted for Yashwant Sinha.
First giving one after another reservation and then we talk about gender equality😂😂😂😂
Mr kharge ji you right here because most of the parties in India give seats to sc,st women only because of reservation seat but don't give authority to take decision,so they are always in trouble that next time this party will not give me seet to contest election. Mr kharge ji knows the problem which issued here. It's right that circumstances of Dalits are severe in that case.
Now bring also men lower class , lower tribes reservation also.
So do you say all men candidates are capable of working properly, is it all of them are intelligent? Does it mean Congress party selects such persons?
Then why did congress give money to women of Karnataka
He is talking about his party Madam. Not about you or BJP. Congress is going to get the wives and daughters of their leaders who don't have any credentials for contesting in elections. That is what he means.
Parlement naya harkate wahi
It just goes to show that INC operates on dynastic loyalties and not on merit. There are capable people in INC, but they will not be allowed to rise. Get rid of the family, and this party will give a strong and sensible opposition to the BJP, which is ABSOLUTELY NEEDED in a functioning democracy. A weak opposition is not good for the country, and then they create greater weaknesses with alliances like I.N.D.I.A!!!
a weak finance minister made kharge to tremble with fear🤣