They belong to a German public broadcaster and are therefore to an extent (I don’t know to what extent exactly but I suspect a large extent) financed by fees which you are obliged to pay if you are a resident in Germany and own a device that allows you to receive programs from public broadcasters.
@@raempftl I don't really get the point of not having ads. As long as they are not in the middle of the piece it's fine. It would probably be better if they had ads in my opinion.
@@ConanQT German public broadcasters are (almost) ad free. That’s part of the deal. And since they can’t split between no ads for viewers inside Germany and ads for viewers outside, you have to get the same service as Germans do.
A mighty fortress indeed. The great Lutheran hymn has never had so much meaning to me as in these horrifying days of plague, war and oppression in so many parts of this sad old world and with most of us feeling too powerless to oppose what is so very, very wrong. This is a wonderful symphony-so very grand in nature. This orchestra performs so well under this vital conductor. Thank you very much for the download.
And I'm back, for the 7th or 8th time. And Mendelssohn's 5th is better each time I listen. If ever there was a conductor who brought music to life, it is Orozco-Estrada. He brings it to life because he's LIVING it: the music incarnate! Living it with sheer delight and joy and awe at its transcendent mystery. And he brings the orchestra along with him! How I wish I could travel to Frankfurt and experience this miracle live! Yet another standing ovation from Japan! ¡¡Infinitas gracias, maestro Orozco-Estrada, a usted y a su magnífica orquestra!!
Vielen, vielen Dank an alle Mitwirkenden (auch diejenigen im Hintergrund) an dieser genialen Sinfonie, die ich schon lange tief ins Herz geschlossen habe!
Mendelssohn: 5. Sinfonie (Reformation. - Sinfonie orchester - Andres Orozco-Estrada. They know how to make beautiful music. They are such a talented orchestra together with Conductor Andres Orozco-Estrada. Absolutely enjoyed listening to this music. Thank You very much.
7 years ago, hr-Sinfonieorchester released a recording of this symphony with some of the same musicians, and I found it to be absolutely charming--especially the chorale at the end. Seeing this recording today with the aged musicians and Orozco-Estrada's charismatic conducting was truly touching. This recording also brings out many subtleties of Mendelssohn's music that were more difficult to notice in the recording seven years prior. Bravo and congratulations to this wonderful orchestra and to Mr. Orozco-Estrada!
What a gift to music lovers! This orchestra plays so well. I've appreciated their performances under guest conductors, including Marek Janowski and the late Stanislaw Skrowaczewski. The Frankfurt Radio Symphony must surely be considered one of the great ensembles in the world, as these video recordings testify.
Excellent performance. I'm still moved by Mendelssohn's music every time I hear it, though I've been hearing it for almost half a century. Even the Italian, Wedding March, and Spring Song, to this day move me.
My youth symphony orchestra played this on tour in China in the summer of 2019. It feels so nostalgic hearing this again and it brings back so many memories. Beautiful piece.
The hr-Sinfonieorchester has been a mainstay and fallback during this difficult pandemic period. How often have I listened and watched you perform, and you never failed to uplift me and give me also the courage to believe and to carry on. I am filled with admiration and gratitude (moved to tears actually at times) for your unwavering commitment to great music performed greatly despite all the difficulties that have beset you and all of us this past year and a half. STANDING OVATION FROM JAPAN!
I just adore those seconds of silence after the final bars.... Great symphony, Mendelssohn's Fifth. Really the fourth, because the "second' isn't a sympony. Or the second, chronologically. Unless you count the string symphonies, in which case it's the fifteenth. Or the third, only including the one fully (well, fulLER scored string symphony). Mendelssohn numerology never ceases to be fun.
Madre mía! Menuda interpretación maravillosa la de Andrés Orozco-Estrada y la hr-Sinfonieorchester. La obra es una de mis preferidas. Me lo acaban de recomendar con estas palabras: "Écoute ça, Jorge, une merveille ! La meilleure sonorité et stylistique pour l'Allegro Vivace"
This channel is by far my favorite classical music channel. With conductors like Orozco-Estrada and Järvi, a world class orchestra and top-notch engineering and presentation, I have yet to see a video that did not totally satisfy. Indeed, being able to enjoy all the music for free, and without ads, is a precious gift for which all classical music lovers should be grateful.
Wunderschöne Aufführung dieser romantischen und perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut phrasierten doch perfekt vereinigten Tönen aller Instrumente. Der dritte Satz klingt besonders schön und echt friedlich. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im lebhaften Tempo und mit effektiver Dynamik. Wundervoll!
Mendelssohn would have surely loved this! Beautifully articulated and implemented performance, a sincere reading of the lyrical score. Excellent audio quality, too! Thanks a lot, once again!
I'm not really sure how Mendelssohn would take performances of this symphony. He had ample time to publish it, after all it is really his 2nd Symphony and not his 5th (not counting the String Symphonies). And he decided not to have it published, just like he never published his 3rd Symphony, the "Italian", even though he revised that one. He deemed it not worthy of being printed and wanted it destroyed, as he wrote in a letter in 1838, nine years after its premiere. The Mendelssohn catalogue is really a mess, caused by him being extremely self-critical and having died early. So many of his famous works were published after his death and without his final approval.
@@Quotenwagnerianer I have read that Mendelssohn was very disappointed in the first performance, mostly brought on by himself by not getting it ready in time for good rehearsing. If he hears this one, he will know that it's a great piece with a great spirit, I think.
Bravo! Excellent; wonderfully played. The flute solo at the beginning of the 4th movement is very interesting. First time I heard it - the other and older versions don’t include it.
Mendelssohn Barholdy ist mit Bach mein absoluter Favorit! Die Reformationssymphonie hat es mir irgendwie besonders angetan und gefällt mir in vielen Variationen; diese von Orozco-Estrada nimmt jedoch einen Sonderplatz ein. Danke für diesen tollen Dirigenten, danke für dieses tolle Orchester! LG aus Nürnberg
Very grateful for this upload. I’ve always tended to underrate Mendelssohn even though I love his overture “Calm Sea and Prosperous Voyage”. Hearing this symphony again after many years has made me re assess my opinion, in the hands of a great orchestra and conductor it comes alive as a great work, thoroughly enjoyable😊
This is a beautiful performance. I would like to raise a question made by another commenter. In performances of this symphony that I have heard, the fourth movement begins with the flute playing Mendelssohn's distillation of the melody of A Mighty Fortress is Our God. In this performance that is preceded by an introductory passage, starting with an additional flute solo followed by another passage for the winds(principally), and only then does the solo rendition of A Mighty Fortress begin. Are these different versions by Mendelssohn? I know he tinkered with the score -- he was often dissatisfied with compositions when he finished them. Or is the introductory passage usually edited out in most performances?
"Sono commosso, tra pochi giorni compio 61 anni... come organista di Mendelssohn ho in repertorio il preludio e fuga in do minore e la 3 Sonata in La... adoro suonare al pianoforte 🎹 lo studio in si bemolle minore op. 104. La Musica è stata la mia sola Sposa 👰♀️ 👰♂️. Grazie!!! Giuseppe Perego Monza 16.2.1962
In 1958, more than 60 years ago!! Charles Munch and the Boston Symphony recorded the best, the far best version of this symphony. I believe Orozco agree with this....
Ich anzusehen aus Japan Vielen Dank für die Bereitstellung eines solchen Programms In Japan gibt es noch kein Orchester, das so viele Inhalte bereitstellt, Paar der Organisation Bereitstellung im Internet. Wenn Sie daran interessiert sind, würde ich mich freuen, wenn Sie es suchen und ansehen könnten.
Is the start of the 4th movement, before the chorale starts, from something else Mendelssohn wrote or did somebody else write it? It’s a beautiful cadenza-like start to the movement regardless!
Oh no, he was always Lutheran. This symphony was for the 3rd. century of Augsburg Confession (1530-1830). He was 21 years old when he composed the symphony!
Der Schluss klingt hier so banal... der Dirigent will alles kontrollieren und lässt die Musik nicht frei - bei Bach wäre das richtig... aber Hallo... das ist Musik der Hochromantik...
With the ridiculous facial expressions of the conductor, no wonder the Vienna Symphony didn't renew his contract......so what does he do?? Takes his 'balll' and goes home.......real mature there, ''Maestro...."
I almost can't believe we can watch and listen to this for free, with no ads interrupting. Thank you for providing us with this!
They belong to a German public broadcaster and are therefore to an extent (I don’t know to what extent exactly but I suspect a large extent) financed by fees which you are obliged to pay if you are a resident in Germany and own a device that allows you to receive programs from public broadcasters.
@@raempftl I don't really get the point of not having ads. As long as they are not in the middle of the piece it's fine. It would probably be better if they had ads in my opinion.
@@ConanQT German public broadcasters are (almost) ad free. That’s part of the deal.
And since they can’t split between no ads for viewers inside Germany and ads for viewers outside, you have to get the same service as Germans do.
Don't give TH-cam Ideas!
#sponsoredbythepeoplesrepublicofgermany
A mighty fortress indeed. The great Lutheran hymn has never had so much meaning to me as in these horrifying days of plague, war and oppression in so many parts of this sad old world and with most of us feeling too powerless to oppose what is so very, very wrong. This is a wonderful symphony-so very grand in nature. This orchestra performs so well under this vital conductor. Thank you very much for the download.
Orozco-Estrada makes me love this Amazing symphony.
And I'm back, for the 7th or 8th time. And Mendelssohn's 5th is better each time I listen. If ever there was a conductor who brought music to life, it is Orozco-Estrada. He brings it to life because he's LIVING it: the music incarnate! Living it with sheer delight and joy and awe at its transcendent mystery. And he brings the orchestra along with him! How I wish I could travel to Frankfurt and experience this miracle live!
Yet another standing ovation from Japan! ¡¡Infinitas gracias, maestro Orozco-Estrada, a usted y a su magnífica orquestra!!
Vielen, vielen Dank an alle Mitwirkenden (auch diejenigen im Hintergrund) an dieser genialen Sinfonie, die ich schon lange tief ins Herz geschlossen habe!
Mendelssohn: 5. Sinfonie (Reformation. - Sinfonie orchester - Andres Orozco-Estrada.
They know how to make beautiful music. They are such a talented orchestra together with Conductor Andres Orozco-Estrada. Absolutely enjoyed listening to this music. Thank You very much.
)
7 years ago, hr-Sinfonieorchester released a recording of this symphony with some of the same musicians, and I found it to be absolutely charming--especially the chorale at the end. Seeing this recording today with the aged musicians and Orozco-Estrada's charismatic conducting was truly touching. This recording also brings out many subtleties of Mendelssohn's music that were more difficult to notice in the recording seven years prior. Bravo and congratulations to this wonderful orchestra and to Mr. Orozco-Estrada!
Diese Akustik! Wahnsinn...
What a gift to music lovers! This orchestra plays so well. I've appreciated their performances under guest conductors, including Marek Janowski and the late Stanislaw Skrowaczewski. The Frankfurt Radio Symphony must surely be considered one of the great ensembles in the world, as these video recordings testify.
Excellent performance. I'm still moved by Mendelssohn's music every time I hear it, though I've been hearing it for almost half a century. Even the Italian, Wedding March, and Spring Song, to this day move me.
My youth symphony orchestra played this on tour in China in the summer of 2019. It feels so nostalgic hearing this again and it brings back so many memories. Beautiful piece.
This orchestra with Orozco-Estrada has set a new standard.
SUPERB! Proper tempos for Mendelssohn (blazing fast) and sensitive dynamics. The orchestra and Orozco-Estrada can do no wrong. Bravi.
Grande Andrés Orozco Estrada orgullo Latinoamericano
Coincido. Saludos desde México
I felt cozy listening to this fabulous performance with immeasurable skill and unfathomable technique .
From
Tokyo of the Land of the Rising Sun 🇯🇵
E' sempre un piacere poter ascoltare questa sinfonia. Grazie.
Einfach WUNDERSCHÖNE Musik‼
Eine der schönsten Symphonien überhaupt. Man denke an den Schlusssatz und "Ein feste Burg ist unser Gott".
Einfach nur toll! Danke für den Upload!
The hr-Sinfonieorchester has been a mainstay and fallback during this difficult pandemic period. How often have I listened and watched you perform, and you never failed to uplift me and give me also the courage to believe and to carry on. I am filled with admiration and gratitude (moved to tears actually at times) for your unwavering commitment to great music performed greatly despite all the difficulties that have beset you and all of us this past year and a half. STANDING OVATION FROM JAPAN!
I realized the first time ever majestic notes of Mendelssohn 5. Sinfonie. Thank you for your magnificent and plucky performance.
One of my favorite symphonies played by one of the best but definitely the most sympathetic orchestra :) Thank You!
👏 👏 beautiful execution of Mendelssohn 🎼 orchestra and conductor Andres Orozco 👏 Thank you 🙏
I just adore those seconds of silence after the final bars....
Great symphony, Mendelssohn's Fifth. Really the fourth, because the "second' isn't a sympony. Or the second, chronologically. Unless you count the string symphonies, in which case it's the fifteenth. Or the third, only including the one fully (well, fulLER scored string symphony). Mendelssohn numerology never ceases to be fun.
I remember listening this symphonie without any special emotion but today it seems very touching to me. hr S Orchester with Orozco Estrada effect
Madre mía! Menuda interpretación maravillosa la de Andrés Orozco-Estrada y la hr-Sinfonieorchester. La obra es una de mis preferidas. Me lo acaban de recomendar con estas palabras: "Écoute ça, Jorge, une merveille ! La meilleure sonorité et stylistique pour l'Allegro Vivace"
Gerade sehe ich, dass die Aufführung an meinem Geburtstag stattgefunden hat. Ein wunderbares Geschenk für mich. Danke!
A brilliant interpretation, thank you.
What a lovely symphony really is... What a gorgeous Orchestra and brilliant conductor
This channel is by far my favorite classical music channel. With conductors like Orozco-Estrada and Järvi, a world class orchestra and top-notch engineering and presentation, I have yet to see a video that did not totally satisfy. Indeed, being able to enjoy all the music for free, and without ads, is a precious gift for which all classical music lovers should be grateful.
incredible as always, frankfurt symphony orchestra is undoubtedly my favourite orchestra
Orozco is so happy. It is nice to see :)
Wunderschöne Aufführung dieser romantischen und perfekt komponierten Sinfonie mit gut phrasierten doch perfekt vereinigten Tönen aller Instrumente. Der dritte Satz klingt besonders schön und echt friedlich. Der intelligente und geniale Dirigent leitet das ausgezeichnete Orchester im lebhaften Tempo und mit effektiver Dynamik. Wundervoll!
この曲の理想的な名演奏。素晴らしい。
Immer wieder wunderschön!
Mendelssohn would have surely loved this! Beautifully articulated and implemented performance, a sincere reading of the lyrical score. Excellent audio quality, too! Thanks a lot, once again!
I'm not really sure how Mendelssohn would take performances of this symphony. He had ample time to publish it, after all it is really his 2nd Symphony and not his 5th (not counting the String Symphonies). And he decided not to have it published, just like he never published his 3rd Symphony, the "Italian", even though he revised that one.
He deemed it not worthy of being printed and wanted it destroyed, as he wrote in a letter in 1838, nine years after its premiere.
The Mendelssohn catalogue is really a mess, caused by him being extremely self-critical and having died early. So many of his famous works were published after his death and without his final approval.
@@Quotenwagnerianer Well putted informative reply, thanks!
@@Quotenwagnerianer I have read that Mendelssohn was very disappointed in the first performance, mostly brought on by himself by not getting it ready in time for good rehearsing. If he hears this one, he will know that it's a great piece with a great spirit, I think.
Lovely use of Dresden Amen.
Eine wunderbare Darbietung
Meravigliosa e struggente esecuzione...
Bravo! Excellent; wonderfully played. The flute solo at the beginning of the 4th movement is very interesting. First time I heard it - the other and older versions don’t include it.
Dios mio que hermosa es esta musica
The BEST orchestra on TH-cam for classical music!
Mendelssohn Barholdy ist mit Bach mein absoluter Favorit! Die Reformationssymphonie hat es mir irgendwie besonders angetan und gefällt mir in vielen Variationen; diese von Orozco-Estrada nimmt jedoch einen Sonderplatz ein. Danke für diesen tollen Dirigenten, danke für dieses tolle Orchester! LG aus Nürnberg
Very grateful for this upload. I’ve always tended to underrate Mendelssohn even though I love his overture “Calm Sea and Prosperous Voyage”. Hearing this symphony again after many years has made me re assess my opinion, in the hands of a great orchestra and conductor it comes alive as a great work, thoroughly enjoyable😊
Remind yourself of his violin conc, superb.
Mr. Estrada and the Sinfonieorchester ,are almost perfct .
Yes, it is because “perfection dasn’t exist” 😀
@@mariaesperanza6548 , I agree with you ,that's why I said almost .
Excelente interpretacion, Felicidades!
So love this orchestra and Maestro A O-E. A thrill for this old Lutheran! Wonderful venue!
absolutely gorgeous...all of it..I keep coming back TO LISTEN TO IT..AND FREE..NO COMERCIALS..!!
And yet another excellent recording for all to watch and listen! Thank you once again!
I find this piece so moving. And this performance is wonderful!
This was amazing! Actually, anytime I hear that jingle at the beginning of the video I know it’s going to be good!
Beautiful music!
Wow!!
absolutely fantastic. amazing orchestra.
Fantastic symphony
My favorite conductor!
perfection!
the conductor is so good he can conduct the orchestra while he plays clarinet 29:52
참 좋습니다!
Prachtig! De inzet dwarsfluit 22:00
Bravo!!!!!!!!!!!
Timestamp, you're welcome.
Andante - Allegro con fuoco 0:06
Allegro Vivace 11:42
Andante 17:23
Choral: Ein feste Burg ist unser Gott. Andante con moto - Allegro Vivace - Allegro Maestoso 20:31
This is a beautiful performance. I would like to raise a question made by another commenter. In performances of this symphony that I have heard, the fourth movement begins with the flute playing Mendelssohn's distillation of the melody of A Mighty Fortress is Our God. In this performance that is preceded by an introductory passage, starting with an additional flute solo followed by another passage for the winds(principally), and only then does the solo rendition of A Mighty Fortress begin. Are these different versions by Mendelssohn? I know he tinkered with the score -- he was often dissatisfied with compositions when he finished them. Or is the introductory passage usually edited out in most performances?
They're playing from the first version which he later scratched out!! ❤
..magnificent!!
"Sono commosso, tra pochi giorni compio 61 anni... come organista di Mendelssohn ho in repertorio il preludio e fuga in do minore e la 3 Sonata in La... adoro suonare al pianoforte 🎹 lo studio in si bemolle minore op. 104. La Musica è stata la mia sola Sposa 👰♀️ 👰♂️. Grazie!!! Giuseppe Perego Monza 16.2.1962
The best and most beaufiful bride you could ever have ! 👍
Glorious experience 🎉
Absolutely love this orchestra and the channel! Keep up the great work!
Great orchestral sound :)
In 1958, more than 60 years ago!! Charles Munch and the Boston Symphony recorded the best, the far best version of this symphony. I believe Orozco agree with this....
excellent
Ich anzusehen aus Japan
Vielen Dank für die Bereitstellung eines solchen Programms
In Japan gibt es noch kein Orchester, das so viele Inhalte bereitstellt, Paar der Organisation Bereitstellung im Internet.
Wenn Sie daran interessiert sind, würde ich mich freuen, wenn Sie es suchen und ansehen könnten.
とっても・いいね！33分を超えるミュージックだね！Worldだ！
The start of the 2nd movement is very close to the 2nd mov. of Beethoven piano sonata #29
Is the start of the 4th movement, before the chorale starts, from something else Mendelssohn wrote or did somebody else write it? It’s a beautiful cadenza-like start to the movement regardless!
En esos tiempos, Mendelsson a QUE REFORMA SE REFERIA, que era lo que querían reconstruir?
❤
11:42 2nd movement |
17:30 Did Shostakovich steal this from Mendelssohn?! :D
That’s possible!
👏👏👏👏
🙏🙏🇧🇷
This is another version than the one they usually play, right? The original?
Mendelssohn's conversion?
Oh no, he was always Lutheran. This symphony was for the 3rd. century of Augsburg Confession (1530-1830). He was 21 years old when he composed the symphony!
Just found my own graveyard yesterday. Then I think of the one in Berlin which is Moses', his grandfather. This shall be my requiem. Felt blessed.
🇧🇷
Çok iyi
Himmlisch
Martin Anthony Jackson Carol Martinez Dorothy
Obwohl RW die Juden nicht mochte hat er bei Mendelssohn ganz schön abgeschrieben !
Imo not at the level of Mendelssohn's Scottish Symphony yet worth a listen.
Der Schluss klingt hier so banal... der Dirigent will alles kontrollieren und lässt die Musik nicht frei - bei Bach wäre das richtig... aber Hallo... das ist Musik der Hochromantik...
With the ridiculous facial expressions of the conductor, no wonder the Vienna Symphony didn't renew his contract......so what does he do?? Takes his 'balll' and goes home.......real mature there, ''Maestro...."
Uhm ... What are you getting at? And what is your claim to fame?
@@georgedebruin6111 Be an adult........for starters. Act like a professional....
@@stevenj9970- oh, cry me a river.
@@georgedebruin6111 *KISSES*
@@stevenj9970, no thank you.
The start of the 2nd movement is very close to the 2nd mov. of Beethoven piano sonata #29