kyle stoddart you obviosly have not watched many senators games and are just going off hearsay. if u look at stats and watching his on ice impact he is at all times one of the best defensive players on the ice
Carlos Craigito nobody gets all 84 points just because of his teammate, yes it probably helps but Rantanen is still 21 years old, 84 points at 21 is pretty damn good lol.
Carlos Craigito and 60 points at 21 is a bad thing lol, he helped Mackinnon get his points as well, not anyone can just hop on the ice and get 84 points just because they are playing next to Mackinnon.
This is the first set I’ve disagreed with. Karlsson two higher than Josi??? Don’t agree I think Karlsson is a 89 and Josi should be the same. And the goalies oh dear god. Bob a 91! No way and no chance In hell holtby is a 91. Playoff holtby was amazing, but regular season was dire. Thank god we can edit rosters! ;) Awesome video as always. Great channel
I'd take MacKinnon over Giroux. The Avalanche weren't that good the last few years until last season. If your team is doing bad, don't expect a guy like MacKinnon to perform over the top. MacKinnon probably should be higher.
@@peterkastanas3547 woah slow down there keyboard warrior... yea price is good its just he would be a lot better if he had a better team in front of him
Doughty is better then karlsson not quite the same offensively but he is better defensively and physically, so it makes sense for him to be rated higher then karlsson. He has won 2 Norris trophy’s and the cup. I think he should of been barely a 91
They put shot blocking low for Karlsson. Boost that up and it could have been like a 91 maybe. In my opinion Karlsson is better than Doughty due to how much he does offensively.
As much as I love Bobrovsky, he wasn't as good as Holtby this year. And while Gaudreau is great, 90 overall? Rated higher than Matthews, Laine and especially 102 point Giroux? Same rating as players like Kopitar and Hall and MacKinnon? No way. Tarasenko is arguably 90 overall. I think 89 would be better for him imo. AND WHERE IS PASTRANAK!! He isn't a top 20 player but should at least be top 50. Nice video btw.
No hate or anything, but why do you use similar thumbnail reaction every video, it kinda seems like something Ali-A would do, again not hate just something I picked up
i guess the last 10 players will be malkin, crosby, ovechkin, price, doughty, Kutcherov, Stamkos, McDavid, Klingberg and Hedman, . just my thoughts though
iTzAnTi top 10 in scoring over the last 3 years. Would’ve had 100+ points this year if it weren’t for injury and suspensions. 17 points in 12 games in the playoffs. Had 39 goals last season in 80 games. Marchand has more points this year than gaudreau despite playing 12 less games. What’s your argument?
But remember EA rates them based on how good they are but also their most recent season plays a huge factor as well so that’s why Karlsson is only 90 he had an awful season with the sens
Karlsson had a good season at the end of the season. He wasn't 100% yet so he had to play through some trouble. Other players went through cold streaks and I don't see them getting put down at all.
Faheem D I think Kopitar should have the highest of the three, followed by Hall, and then MacKinnon, this was his first superstar season from a point production perspective
Top 10 tomorrow in some order- McDavid Crosby Ovechkin Malkin Kucherov Stamkos Hedman Doughty Matthews Kane. That's no Eichel, Fleury, Price, Klingberg, Wild Bill, Eric Staal, Gibson, Hellebuyck, Forsberg. Draisaitl, Lundqvist, Forsberg, Larkin, not in the top 50. I'm sure in cold goo for more but it's interesting
@@KyleMazon Price was not injured for the WHOLE season. And where on this planet Earth did you see a person calling Carey Price best player in the leauge? That title belongs to Crosby or Mcdavid. Hes not even the best goalie. I agree that you shouldn't judge a player off of one year, but that doesnt mean ignore this season as a whole. 3.11 GAA and .900 SV is bad. Imo, he's rather top 20 or 30ish than top 10 and should be 88 or 89 overall.
agreed Mcdavid and Crosby are the best but price did play a large portion of the season while he was injured and tactix has called him the best goalie in the world several times. Also braden holtbeys stats are just as bad as prices stats were last year and hes still a 91. not saying price is the player just saying he is the best goalie
@@KyleMazon Holtbys stats as an NHL starter were never as bad as Prices stats this year. Yes, Holtby was mediocre in the regular season but the reason he got 91 overall is because he won the Cup and was a beast in the playoffs. And I'm not a Caps fan. And Price is arguably the best goalie. He's fantastic no doubt, but it's debatable if he's better than guys like Rinne and Vaselevski(not sure if spelled right) and Holtby and Fleury, at least, in my opinion.
You are an idiot. He is amazing defensively. He is the only one on Ottawa that can play well defensively so his plus minus is bad so what. He is still better than you obviously think.
Some of theses ratings are alright but a lot of them are wack...
sooooooo karlssons not a top ten player......
nope shouldn't be offensively maybe the best in hockey defensively he is pure shit
kyle stoddart you obviosly have not watched many senators games and are just going off hearsay. if u look at stats and watching his on ice impact he is at all times one of the best defensive players on the ice
Even though Marchand is not liked by many still filthy and at least in top 20 not mid 40’s
@@kylestoddart apparently you missed the two seasons where he won the *Norris*
Karlsssson is better then. 90 91-92
I’m just wondering where the hell is David Pastrnak
iBrxdleyy E.A. probably bunked his rating like they did to multiple others
iBrxdleyy
Probs an 87. He had one good year.
And before u say it Mackinnon got 97 points, which is why he got a 90 overall
Carlos Craigito Pastrnak has had back to back amazing years i don’t think you know what you’re talking about
Carlos Craigito plus pastrnak’s playoff performance was unreal. 87 would be a complete snub
How is Tarasenko's shot not better? Him Laine and Ovechkin should be above everyone
rantanen?
TheNikez37
He had one good year. And he only got 84 points cuz of Mackinnon. 86 or 87 overall
Carlos Craigito nobody gets all 84 points just because of his teammate, yes it probably helps but Rantanen is still 21 years old, 84 points at 21 is pretty damn good lol.
Braeden’s Broadcasting Channel
Without Mackinnon he would’ve got like 60 points
Carlos Craigito and 60 points at 21 is a bad thing lol, he helped Mackinnon get his points as well, not anyone can just hop on the ice and get 84 points just because they are playing next to Mackinnon.
I would guess Rantanen and Landeskog are around 86 or 87. 85 would be a bit too low IMO.
Why do always have the same pose in every thumbnail lately
I can’t wait to see the overalls change with the roster updates like if Matthews or marner have a breakout year or something
Tavares > Gaudreau
Fuck off johnny should be 91
If Pasta has the same rating as Toews I’m suing
Still wondering how pasta didn’t make to 50
This is the first set I’ve disagreed with. Karlsson two higher than Josi??? Don’t agree I think Karlsson is a 89 and Josi should be the same.
And the goalies oh dear god. Bob a 91! No way and no chance In hell holtby is a 91. Playoff holtby was amazing, but regular season was dire.
Thank god we can edit rosters! ;)
Awesome video as always. Great channel
MacKinnon should be a 91 or 92, hes unbeatable
Hunter Kipp after only one year no giroux should be 90 and mackinnon should be even 89 max
I'd take MacKinnon over Giroux. The Avalanche weren't that good the last few years until last season. If your team is doing bad, don't expect a guy like MacKinnon to perform over the top. MacKinnon probably should be higher.
Why do people think Price is good? He is like 87 overall imo. He is not a game changer.
Hes not on montreal but i reckon if you put him on a team like tampa or Pittsburgh he would be really good
He is good ur just waste
@@peterkastanas3547 woah slow down there keyboard warrior... yea price is good its just he would be a lot better if he had a better team in front of him
@@jaybeagle8726 ok then my bad but he should probably stop calling people a waste over the internet
@@peterkastanas3547 Dude, you don't call somebody a "waste" for simply stating his own views. People these days...
If bernier ain’t in the next one there is going to be some serious problems
karlsson is a better player then doughty hands down and also bergerons face-offs are wack
dont really understand how gaudreau is better than shiefele or wheeler should be same rating at least.
Did they fix last year's crappy ratings back to normal. 87 Taveres 88 Doughty 89 Karlson etc? I never understood why they dropped so much in NHL 18
Doughty is better then karlsson not quite the same offensively but he is better defensively and physically, so it makes sense for him to be rated higher then karlsson. He has won 2 Norris trophy’s and the cup. I think he should of been barely a 91
They put shot blocking low for Karlsson. Boost that up and it could have been like a 91 maybe. In my opinion Karlsson is better than Doughty due to how much he does offensively.
*2 cups
Holtby was a huge draft steal! DAMN
Carlos Craigito He’s a goalie though pretty much a shot in the dark with all of them
Karlsson a 90 overall LOL... ok
The Grande Gamer He wasn’t even trying last year with Ottawa wait until he gets traded
As much as I love Bobrovsky, he wasn't as good as Holtby this year. And while Gaudreau is great, 90 overall? Rated higher than Matthews, Laine and especially 102 point Giroux? Same rating as players like Kopitar and Hall and MacKinnon? No way. Tarasenko is arguably 90 overall. I think 89 would be better for him imo. AND WHERE IS PASTRANAK!! He isn't a top 20 player but should at least be top 50. Nice video btw.
Ea dont base ov of player over only one year that's why
That True
No hate or anything, but why do you use similar thumbnail reaction every video, it kinda seems like something Ali-A would do, again not hate just something I picked up
Love your videos Tact! First one to like and comment for the first time haha wish you all the best in NHL 19
Chris Robinson nobody cares about you being first
@@brianferris7859 👍
i guess the last 10 players will be malkin, crosby, ovechkin, price, doughty, Kutcherov, Stamkos, McDavid, Klingberg and Hedman, . just my thoughts though
Nah Kane
Imagine mcdavid and hall on the same team! They’d be a dynasty but they fucked it up
So that means Couture, Weber, Klingberg, Fleury, Eichel, Huberdeau, Pastrnak, Forsberg are 87 and/or lower.. smh
Pauls Klucis flower is 88 he was there in his previous video
Pauls Klucis and forsberg too I believe
they still can be 88, its top 50, not top 57 if there is 57 players 88 and above
Christopher Gaumond But the ranking started with 87 Toews. That means 49 players are 88 and above
Chum Chum No man, looked it through and there were no Fleury and deffinitely no Forsberg. I would have remembered that
Top 10:
Mcdavid, Crosby, Ovi, Malkin, Stamkos, Doughty, Kucherov, Price, Hedman and?
Price?
Price?
Jack Johnson
Im a habs fan and price dont deserve to be in the top 10 at all. He need to prove himself after being garbage last year
William I agree however since he isn’t between spot 50 and 11 he’s probably in the top 10.
Gaudreau should be 89 because 88 def and bad def last year 100giveway should be 86 def
Nah he shud be 91
Makes sense that big Vasilevskiy and rinne is #88 overall right.... NOPE quick, Dubnyk are both higher than those 2
tarasenko had like 60 pointa last yeat wut
maybe as a member of the 'cover' club he gets a pass.
erik karlsson a 90? OOF
Its weird....both Karlsson and Price had atrocious years and EA still put Price in Top 10???? ._.
Before price was the best so ea knows that he has that in him so that is why he has that rating
Don’t tell me the flower won’t be on the list
How is kopitar only a 90 after last year, selke trophy with 92 points is an offensive output Bergeron has never come close to in a selke winning year
You should get some new faces for the thumbnails, otherwise great vid
Strongly disagree with Karlsson rating. Should be like 93
Marchand is not 2 overall below gaudreau he’s ATLEAST the same rating, I’d put Gaudreau at 89 and Marchand at 90.
Braeden’s Broadcasting Channel no
iTzAnTi top 10 in scoring over the last 3 years. Would’ve had 100+ points this year if it weren’t for injury and suspensions. 17 points in 12 games in the playoffs. Had 39 goals last season in 80 games. Marchand has more points this year than gaudreau despite playing 12 less games. What’s your argument?
Braeden’s Broadcasting Channel Marchand is a dirty player which effects this.
iTzAnTi besides discipline which other stat does this affect?
Nice
91= Too high for Holtby. Phillip Grubauer played better last season
The fact that Price is higher than Bobrovsky doesn’t make sense
Bmess55 price>bobrovsky
hey, does anybody know when they will reveal top 10 finally?
Where’s Barzal and Klingberg
So price is the best goalie again
What mode are these rating even for?
Kane wya👀
Karlsson should be a 92, minimum.
But remember EA rates them based on how good they are but also their most recent season plays a huge factor as well so that’s why Karlsson is only 90 he had an awful season with the sens
NHL Legend11 the explain price
Oooooh got em
We dont even know if price is in the top 10
Karlsson had a good season at the end of the season. He wasn't 100% yet so he had to play through some trouble. Other players went through cold streaks and I don't see them getting put down at all.
@TylerRobertson alright lol, I forgot about that u got me, yeah then the Karlsson one makes no sense
Karlsson is underated
Shouldn’t Hall have a one up on Kopitar and MacKinnon cause he won it and they were just nominees????
MacKinnon actually should have won so no
Faheem D I think Kopitar should have the highest of the three, followed by Hall, and then MacKinnon, this was his first superstar season from a point production perspective
@@jaybeagle8726 He played on a good line consisting of two 50 pointers, it was a superstar line because the Superstar on the line was McKinnon
Top 10 tomorrow in some order-
McDavid
Crosby
Ovechkin
Malkin
Kucherov
Stamkos
Hedman
Doughty
Matthews
Kane.
That's no Eichel, Fleury, Price, Klingberg, Wild Bill, Eric Staal, Gibson, Hellebuyck, Forsberg. Draisaitl, Lundqvist, Forsberg, Larkin, not in the top 50. I'm sure in cold goo for more but it's interesting
Matthews has already been revealed, he's an 89. Price will be in the top 10 (Check part 3)
Shane Smith Matthews already was shown an 89 so it’s price
That's probably true, could maybe be Eichel but I doubt it
@@shanesmith6632 No Klingberg
yeah eichel might be an 88, price got a terrible season but I dont see him being an 88 and I also can't see him being #1 goalie again.
Yoooooooooooooooooooo Patty Kane in the top 10 I likey
Gaudreau overrated. Lots of sub 90s who are way more impactful players. Laine or Matthews are both a lot better
Matthews is overrated
No way lol he's either number 1or top 3 in goals/game, goals/60 and 5on5 goals. If healthy he should score 50 next year
OMG 92 overall price
Holtby is too high
karlsson is a top 3 player in the league ge is so dominent
yessssss price is still the best
Ridiculous I know right
first of all why is he ranked best in the league then and also you can not judge a player form a year he was injured for almost the whole season
@@KyleMazon Price was not injured for the WHOLE season. And where on this planet Earth did you see a person calling Carey Price best player in the leauge? That title belongs to Crosby or Mcdavid. Hes not even the best goalie. I agree that you shouldn't judge a player off of one year, but that doesnt mean ignore this season as a whole. 3.11 GAA and .900 SV is bad. Imo, he's rather top 20 or 30ish than top 10 and should be 88 or 89 overall.
agreed Mcdavid and Crosby are the best but price did play a large portion of the season while he was injured and tactix has called him the best goalie in the world several times. Also braden holtbeys stats are just as bad as prices stats were last year and hes still a 91. not saying price is the player just saying he is the best goalie
@@KyleMazon Holtbys stats as an NHL starter were never as bad as Prices stats this year. Yes, Holtby was mediocre in the regular season but the reason he got 91 overall is because he won the Cup and was a beast in the playoffs. And I'm not a Caps fan. And Price is arguably the best goalie. He's fantastic no doubt, but it's debatable if he's better than guys like Rinne and Vaselevski(not sure if spelled right) and Holtby and Fleury, at least, in my opinion.
Shirts to say first
Karlsson is overrated... he ain’t that good defensively... he’s like a RW basically
You are an idiot. He is amazing defensively. He is the only one on Ottawa that can play well defensively so his plus minus is bad so what. He is still better than you obviously think.
Karlsson overrated ?????????????????????????????????
Oof
Matthews>Tavares