Victoria... nothing is the same without you. No magical element when you're not five. This song has me crying because it goes to you now, from our hearts.. the queen of shyness, humour and gentleness 💔💓 💓💓💓💔💔💔💔 I love your soulful, sultry voice and miss it so very much 💔
'The times when we would play about, the way we used to scream & shout, we never dreamnt you'd go your own sweet way...' Victoria sang that part, telling the story how Geri left at the sudden when they were on the peak of their worldwide success in 1998. And ironically in 2019, Geri sang that part & of course it means alot since 'Goodbye' was written & dedicated to Geri & she was finally singing this song (with her own solo part replacing Victoria), when Posh Spice herself decided not to be part of the Spiceworld Tour in 2019.
@@jayncalik bcs they different opinion abt their music, Mel B wants to change into R&B, but Geri wants stick with Pop. After Geri left, Spice Girls changes their music more into R&B, you can hear from Good Bye, Holler, Let Love Lead The Way, etc are sounds more R&B, right?
When Geri left the group, I remember being so devastated. She was my favorite SG. I'll never forget seeing them at the Tacoma Dome in WA state when I was in 6th grade. I'm almost 36 and still listen to their music.
Victoria pisou na bola ,,ela so e uma diva conhecida mundialmente por causa das spice girl ,nao porque ela casou se com um jogador de futebol,,,victoria nao seria nada se nao foce as SPICE GIRL dar lhe a fama mundial
Victoria was right to sit this one out. She's been disrespected about her vocals for years. These girls can't hold a melody..there vocals all over the place....Geri doesn't do Victoria's part justice at all.
Well, for a start, she was the engine for other four girls to believe that they could conquer the world with their music. Geri was the one who came up with group's name 'Spice.' And she sold the philosophy of 'girl power' to the Melanies, Emma & Victoria and then, they sold the same philosophy in their first 2 albums. And when she left Spice Girls, the group started to lose its spark before parting ways in the end of 2000. And in 2007, she reunited with the Spice Girls again & it went on in 2019. So yes, she IS the glue that holds the Spice Girls even when Victoria decided to turn off her mic.
@@LeeoGoneWild Sure Jan 🙄. If anything they’re handicapped without her, which is why the third album failed to achieve the same iconic status the first two have. In terms of style and attitude she’s the most iconic. Her Union Jack dress is synonymous with the Spice brand, and she coined Girl Power. Gerri was a driving force behind the girls leaving their original management and finally getting signed to a label. Also it’s hard to deny that she had the most successful solo career.
But Victoria didn't leave, she just didn't want to join them for another reunion; that ain't goodbye that was like 'I've got some living to do, but don't assume I'm gonna be with you...' 😂🤣😂🤣😂
I find it funny how Geri was playing around and realized it was her part in the song and smoothly went into it. Also I love emma but it kinda bugs me that she had to sing along with the only solo part that Geri has when she and Mel b sings half the song. Still love them they look amazing
@@crazyspice3951 exactly. After 13 years old, i think they might be missed some lyric. Cos' in that reunion they singing with no technical voice but feeling into like their back to past again. 😭😭😭
@@damdaung8369 agreed. Goodbye is the saddest song from Spice Girls. Geri's departure from the Spice Girls was heartbreaking to all the fans back then. I was one of the million fans who cried because of it. It sounded as if it was a prayer; subtly asking Geri to come back especially with Mel C's line 'I will be with you everyday....'
Ela fala que aquele é o momento do show que elas ficam emotivas, por lembrarem dos altos e baixos, e da introdução pra Geri falar sobre a saida do grupo. A geri fala da saída e o quanto ela sentiu falta das meninas quando as viu no show em Wemblay em 98. Ela agradece aos fãs por sempre estarem come elas todos esses anos. Fala que goodbye é linda e foi pra ela, e a Mel C dedica a música ao Matt, responsável por essa belíssima música
Well not so much now with the global pandemic of covid-19 since last year. I'm glad they made the reunion of Spiceworld in 2019, even without Posh. Well, it was what it was
Victoria, *EAT YOUR HEART OUT* not showing for this... Vicky was wrong for that. Its a handful of shows. For her adoring fans. She'd be NOWHERE without the Spice Girls and the trove of fans that stayed loyal to a group who's career only peaked for four years...we stayed loyal for decades . Ungrateful slag imo. Its unforgivable. Ugh. She wouldn't have met her husband, or garnered the respectful career if it wasn't for those other four girls and that ad in the paper.
She decided to leave her music carrier because that chapter closed along time ago for her and she's just a tad busy with her family and clothing label yknow your just being disrespectful, was it your decision for her to drop everything no so don't tell her what to do and dont namecall people get a life❤️
The hall of fame has a special place waiting for the greatest female group of all time
TLC
🙄
Yes, that would be Destiny's Child or The Supremes. 😎
@@MauriceRivers415 along with Spice Girls.
@@arya_inmydefense Not according to music sales on Billboard Charts, no.
Victoria... nothing is the same without you. No magical element when you're not five. This song has me crying because it goes to you now, from our hearts.. the queen of shyness, humour and gentleness 💔💓 💓💓💓💔💔💔💔 I love your soulful, sultry voice and miss it so very much 💔
Lovely to see Geri restored and honoured, missed Victoria.💜
I can’t imagine the amount of strength it took to record this track 💕💕💕💕💕💕💕
They generally Love one another
FRIENDSHIP NEVER ENDS
'The times when we would play about, the way we used to scream & shout, we never dreamnt you'd go your own sweet way...' Victoria sang that part, telling the story how Geri left at the sudden when they were on the peak of their worldwide success in 1998. And ironically in 2019, Geri sang that part & of course it means alot since 'Goodbye' was written & dedicated to Geri & she was finally singing this song (with her own solo part replacing Victoria), when Posh Spice herself decided not to be part of the Spiceworld Tour in 2019.
A full circle moment!!!
Do you mean Victoria? Why did she decide not to be a part of the Spiceworld Tour 2019 then???
@@petrhaisman8645 she didn't want to be a Spice piece anymore, since Olympic 2012
@@petrhaisman8645 she was focusing on her business commitments
Spice glirs abum spice girls show show show tour fans thank you so much spice glirs best band ❤❤😊😊
Both Mel B n Mel C 's vocal always makes me overwhelmed
Both Mel's have extremely unique and powerful voices. They made the group stand out
@@jenniboo9441 and their names Melanie Jayne Chisholm and Melanie Janine Brown.. MJC and MJB..hahahahah..Like sister.. cute..
Que honra assistir a Geri cantando Goodbye... Essa música mexe comigo demais...
5:33 Melanie B : remember, you left! Geri : well, that's because of you! 🤣😂🤣😂 I love these two ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
Why is it bc of Mel B ?!?
@@jayncalik I hate accusations but maybe Mel b had feelings for geri? I mean...... But who knows anymore just glad they reunited for this moment.
@@jayncalik bcs they different opinion abt their music, Mel B wants to change into R&B, but Geri wants stick with Pop. After Geri left, Spice Girls changes their music more into R&B, you can hear from Good Bye, Holler, Let Love Lead The Way, etc are sounds more R&B, right?
@@jayncalik they were in love.. 💔💓💔💓
Did they say really say that? 😃
When Geri left the group i was 8 years old and I was devastated... Now, 25 years has passed and Im still feel the pain... i still miss them...
Me too
The crowd sound great singing along to this. Great.
The energy between these ladies is truly electric!!
Imagine if posh were there
I love the Posh' solo and I miss it in her voice 😢 🖤
Geri’s version sounds terrible lol
Geri did it justice!
@@LeeoGoneWild Why Geri sang lead on their biggest hit wannabe. Geri's voice sounds nice here, and has gotten better with age. No need to be so bitter
Exactly, i love and miss her voice so very dearly.. It was wonderful seeing a shy woman like her singing
Spice Girls Forever 🇧🇷🇧🇷💝💝
The greatest female group of all time
25 anos de Spice Girls esse ano!!! ❤🇧🇷
Emma is like a Angel.
When Geri left the group, I remember being so devastated. She was my favorite SG. I'll never forget seeing them at the Tacoma Dome in WA state when I was in 6th grade. I'm almost 36 and still listen to their music.
Victoria pisou na bola ,,ela so e uma diva conhecida mundialmente por causa das spice girl ,nao porque ela casou se com um jogador de futebol,,,victoria nao seria nada se nao foce as SPICE GIRL dar lhe a fama mundial
The song is great with an amazing voice and beautiful melody. I like it very much. Thanks
4:19 The Victoria's solo ♥♥♥♥♥♥
wala naman dito si victoria
@@lawrenceyap7460 are you blind? Victoria is there but no posh spice
Crying again... And the tears are falling down on the ground...
Spice Girls forever❤️❤️❤️
Absolutely beautiful xxxxxx
Love her's voices
The vocals 😍😍😍
Victoria was right to sit this one out. She's been disrespected about her vocals for years. These girls can't hold a melody..there vocals all over the place....Geri doesn't do Victoria's part justice at all.
+1
I love how Gerri seems to be the glue that holds this altogether and keeps the group going after all these years.
Well, for a start, she was the engine for other four girls to believe that they could conquer the world with their music. Geri was the one who came up with group's name 'Spice.' And she sold the philosophy of 'girl power' to the Melanies, Emma & Victoria and then, they sold the same philosophy in their first 2 albums. And when she left Spice Girls, the group started to lose its spark before parting ways in the end of 2000. And in 2007, she reunited with the Spice Girls again & it went on in 2019. So yes, she IS the glue that holds the Spice Girls even when Victoria decided to turn off her mic.
No, she really isn’t, she is such a handicap, vocally and dance ability
@@LeeoGoneWild Sure Jan 🙄. If anything they’re handicapped without her, which is why the third album failed to achieve the same iconic status the first two have. In terms of style and attitude she’s the most iconic. Her Union Jack dress is synonymous with the Spice brand, and she coined Girl Power. Gerri was a driving force behind the girls leaving their original management and finally getting signed to a label. Also it’s hard to deny that she had the most successful solo career.
@@justschr you’re so delusional, it’s hilarious.
@@LeeoGoneWild Cool story bro
When everyone in the audiance started to sing I got goosbumbs
Beautiful
When we can watch great concert like this again?? 😭😭 #F*cCovid19
Obrigada pelo vídeo maravilhoso😊😍🤩🥰
I very love spice girls
Song turns to be for from Geri to Victoria lol
My thoughts. Kisses dear!
But Victoria didn't leave, she just didn't want to join them for another reunion; that ain't goodbye that was like 'I've got some living to do, but don't assume I'm gonna be with you...' 😂🤣😂🤣😂
@@crazyspice3951 LOL the Love Thing reference I love it!!! ❤️❤️❤️
Emma has the most underrated once in music
You mean the least interesting soloist
@@musicislife.2602 her voice is amazing tho
@@owtsideperspective3588 Mel C anyday
@@musicislife.2602 Emma >>>
@@SUPERNATURALeternalsunshine Bunton the most boring Spice.
I find it funny how Geri was playing around and realized it was her part in the song and smoothly went into it. Also I love emma but it kinda bugs me that she had to sing along with the only solo part that Geri has when she and Mel b sings half the song. Still love them they look amazing
Bcs in original part Victoria sing along with Emma
amazing😍😭
That's my haaaat! Mel c took my hat. 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
July 2021 xxxxxx
Fairies on stage ♥️♥️
Go Geraldine!
Where is victoria?
Caracaaaaaaaaaa Geri Ficou melhor que vick no solo😱🤩
Still five spice world bleesed 5
I LOVE you girls. Love how Victoria shows up when she wants hahahaha I love you
Why mel c is not singing her awesome part?
Wait where’s Victoria?
Mel b sang the wrong lyrics in the second verse?
Well, that's just proved that they do sing live, right? 😂
@@crazyspice3951 exactly. After 13 years old, i think they might be missed some lyric. Cos' in that reunion they singing with no technical voice but feeling into like their back to past again. 😭😭😭
Yes it's the lyrics for the first verse
You can tell Victorias vocals are missing.
That's why it sounded so nice :)
@@retrofun1479 no❤️
You should've been there VB!!!
Without Victoria they seem hard to do the melody.
They still sound good
Nessa turnê achei a Geri tão perdida no palco...
Aquí se puede apreciar mejor que nunca que Victoria y Geri eran relleno en la agrupación. El talento vocal recaía en Mel C, Mel B y Emma.
Jajajaja verdaaaaad
4:26 ❤️
With out that song there is no return of geri to the group
You're right, this is not a goodbye song, this is the reunited song between Geri & Spice girls
@@damdaung8369 agreed. Goodbye is the saddest song from Spice Girls. Geri's departure from the Spice Girls was heartbreaking to all the fans back then. I was one of the million fans who cried because of it. It sounded as if it was a prayer; subtly asking Geri to come back especially with Mel C's line 'I will be with you everyday....'
O que a mel c fala da geri no minuto 0:32?
Ela fala que aquele é o momento do show que elas ficam emotivas, por lembrarem dos altos e baixos, e da introdução pra Geri falar sobre a saida do grupo.
A geri fala da saída e o quanto ela sentiu falta das meninas quando as viu no show em Wemblay em 98. Ela agradece aos fãs por sempre estarem come elas todos esses anos.
Fala que goodbye é linda e foi pra ela, e a Mel C dedica a música ao Matt, responsável por essa belíssima música
A versão original de Goodbye também estava sendo escrita pela Geri, após a sua saída, a música ganhou uma nova versão.
where is Victoria Beckham ?
Being a stuck up prick somewhere.
she hasn't wanted to be a Spice Girls anymore since Olympic 2012
3:30 Mel rejects Geri’s hand 😝😝
Lol she didn't see her.
😅😅😅😅
Victoria couldn't make it as she's a fashion designer and a mother
Well not so much now with the global pandemic of covid-19 since last year. I'm glad they made the reunion of Spiceworld in 2019, even without Posh. Well, it was what it was
Victoria, *EAT YOUR HEART OUT*
not showing for this...
Vicky was wrong for that. Its a handful of shows. For her adoring fans. She'd be NOWHERE without the Spice Girls and the trove of fans that stayed loyal to a group who's career only peaked for four years...we stayed loyal for decades . Ungrateful slag imo.
Its unforgivable. Ugh. She wouldn't have met her husband, or garnered the respectful career if it wasn't for those other four girls and that ad in the paper.
She decided to leave her music carrier because that chapter closed along time ago for her and she's just a tad busy with her family and clothing label yknow your just being disrespectful, was it your decision for her to drop everything no so don't tell her what to do and dont namecall people get a life❤️
And unforgivable did geri not LEAVE the group to begin with and that when the group started to deteriorate because of her like jesus
Victoria will be back when her fashion line bankrupts Spice Girls will always be a money fountain for all five of them
@@arial8black soon then 😂
You almost said ungrateful child , 😅 😂🥰
❤❤❤❤
Sad Victoria wasn’t there… but this was beautiful none the less
❤
I miss it when Victoria is with them before 😞
The harmony on Mel B's part.. that was Sung by Mel C and victoria.. 🥺 but Emma had to do it because Geri can't
APAAANN... TUUHHH......
🥰🥰🥰🥰
Jos and Toady 😀TV
Victoria meesed in world
Est ce que certaines ont fait du botox ? J ai l impression que hormis mel c les autres peuvent difficilement avoir les yeux ouverts
Someone to explain this song shotly
🥰
Victoria Beckrram só Play back
When Victoria rejoin, I want her to sing her part with Geri
😍🇯🇵
no one seems to notice Geri hair is ginger here
Her hair was always ginger. Hence the nickname ginger spice. Duh.
@@danielledewitt1 no her hair was really brown she dyed it ginger
@@davidcrazyrides Looked ginger to me back in the day.
@@danielledewitt1 she admitted she just use to dye it on Life stories
@@davidcrazyrides Still looks ginger in the wannabe video.
😘🥰
They're missing a spice! where's Posh?
Busy and got stuck with her fashion designer career at that time.
Still five to do
Victoria Nem Canta Fake Puro cadê Ela?
😍😍😍😍😍
This really confirmed how bad Geri’s vocal skills are… her doing the climax literally kills the song. Miss Victoria so much.
At least Geris voice has character.
Geri’s vocal skills are great. You need a hearing test.
@@danielledewitt1 her vocal skills were nonexistent
@@danielledewitt1 oh please lol she can't sing! Victoria was missing here, she's the glue of the group
@@SailorSpears Liar. She can sing.
Kkk
Geri sounds better than Victoria at her part
Hell no. Although I adore Geri too
They can’t sing same like recording .. auto tune works magic
❤️