Jerri was never a villain and she has suffered from her edit a lot but as a character is a top10 character in Survivor history. To me she is the biggest women character in show history and she is underrated as a player
Yeah, she was only a villain through the eyes of certain players. But I actually like that in retrospect as it made her much more memorable to us. At the time, I imagine it sucked for her.
@@OnceUponAnIsland I completely agree. I thought she was a bit dumb when I first saw her in Heroes VS Villains (cause she didn't really do anything strategic) but then I realized that she just didn't want to seem like the "black widow" that she was labeled as. She wasn't a villain--just the popular contestants in Australia often labeled her as such, and then the edit simply honed in on that.
I really appreciate Jerri on this show. She may have been abrasive and rather blunt but that’s what makes her an icon. I bet if the editors showed more of her good/human side in all-stars, she might not have been booed at the reunion.
I loved Jerri and she was an incredible addition this season. Plus, I am glad to see that she was at Heroes vs. Villains (4th Place!)...Wish that she was brought back for Survivor: Game Changers.
In the original seasons the small group of survivor contestants were close with each other to some degree, they were all considered celebrities' and would go to charitable events and other things together so it survivor all-stars was really like a reunion of friends. Lex made the mistake of not separating friendships outside of the game from strategy inside the game. Jerry lost because of that and I don't hold her getting eliminated then against her because it was a stupid move from Lex and Kathy. I don't think she wins if she makes it to merge but I think she has a shot to get to the end she probably makes it to final 5 and who knows after that. When she got boo-ed at the reunion it really was a solidified that survivor was "all grown up" and now more about strategy then friendships which almost no one was prepared for going in.
Exactly right. If Lex is able to get Amber out right before the merge, he couldn’t because Kathy was a stubborn mule and wanted Jerri out, the entire post merge of All-Stars is different. Boston Rob gets nowhere close to the final tribal and I think Jerri, Lex, Rupert or Big Tom win the whole game.
@@OnceUponAnIsland I read a interview with Lex and he talked about the move to try and get Amber out. He campaigned to the other members of Chapera, besides Amber, to send Amber home and keep Jerri.. He couldn’t because Kathy wouldn’t budge because pre-game Rob said he would take her to the end. That was before Boston Rob fell in love with Amber rendering the deal null and void.
It's crazy how they edited it to make it seem like jerri and Colby are still at odds. If you see deleted scenes they have heart to heart convos and behave like friends
When Jerri got revenge on Colby, I thought that was a hero moment. He was awful to her in Outback, even throwing water on her at a challenge. The southern gentleman edit is a lie. Shii-Ann subsequently giving her own revenge vote after Jerri.. hm. Maybe the guy is a jerk Flash forward of even Amanda rolling her eyes at overrated Colby
If anything I don't think Jerri really meant to do any harm in Outback, if anything I saw her as more of an anti-villain. Pretty much it's someone who means well, but their acts end up harming others unintentionally. That kind of happened with Jerri, and as a result Colby did not trust her. If anything Jerri didn't really have any villainous intentions, she literally just wanted to form a basic alliance and have a bit of fun with it.
@@maxlolbits2182 her supposed "villain" plot line was that she wanted their rice rations to be cooked properly. Apparently that's unreasonable if the other contestant is a chef. But also apparently, Colby making much nastier comments about Keith on a personal level was supposedly good and wholesome. Fans back then were kind of weird
@@bc5163 Colby is and always was a self righteous asshole. Hated him then and still do today. And his piece of shit game on Heroes vs Villians was a joke.
Just watched the all stars reunion and the way the audience booed at her at any chance and cheered at her leaving in the break? she was and is an amazing player, sure i wasn't a fan of her in australia but she played the best game she could in all stars despite the circumstances. I really wish she could see the support this channel's audience has for her.
I remember watching The Australian Outback when I was 14 and thinking that Jerri was real and mistreated by the public...I also thought that Elisabeth was insincere and got too much public love. It's good to see that twenty years later, Jerri has had two more chances to prove herself and that public's opinion on her has changed...and Elisabeth has revealed her true colours time and time again on The View, and the public's opinion of her is in the gutter.
Jerri is one of my favourites despite her antagonizing with almost all her tribemates. her run in All Stars was always on the bottom until Lex saves her and keeps her around over larger targets Colby and Ethan. probably the most infamous moment that All Stars is known for is Lex gambling Jerri off for a deal with Rob to save Amber. it just never made sense as this is a huge risk and Jerri will stay loyal to Lex no matter what. we all knows what happens next. also notably her premenitions about Rupert was true as it shows in future. when she got booed at the reunion I felt really bad for her as this would break down almost anyone in her position. with Lex keeping Jerri a couple ways to see it with Amber out. didn't make a difference and followed actual path as Rob was aligned with everybody separately on Chapera. or makes a huge difference as Lex somehow pulls in his Africa ally Tom and majority switches.
The thing is, even if Lex listened to Jerri and voted out Amber, then Lex Jerri Kathy and Shi-Ann still go into the merge low in numbers. And I think Rob would still be in control of the group and would get Lex and Kathy at least voted out for going against him, being a threat, and also no one have been with them in the game so no ones really going to trust them bc they just met strategically. I’m sure Jerri and Shi-Ann could make it farther and not get pagoned but I’m not sure. Either Rob has total control or not. But Alicia Big Tom and Rupert were super loyal to him.
Big Tom would've switched over to Lex 100%. Especially considering their friendship in Africa was still there plus they didn't have to worry about the whole winner thing anymore
While the hate Jerri got was ridiculous, it always cracks me up to see the audience side with Rupert (who was clearly in the wrong) over Jerri. The edit even sides with Jerri, but she was so despised at the time and Rupert was so loved.
It's possible Lex still loses even with Jerri in the game over Amber, but it would've helped as it would've been 5 to 4, and maybe Big Tom flips, but Boston Rob probably would've twisted his arm to keep him loyal to Chapera.
I think Survivor is a lot about minimizing risks and Lex voting out Jerri over Amber was a massive risk that did not pay off at all. It wasn't guaranteed he wins by keeping Jerri, but it does assure him a much better position.
I think she either lied or had a case of mistaken identity with Kel and the Beef Jerky. David Bloomberg talked about this with Jessica Lewis in their Why Kel Lost video. I highly recommend everyone watching that!
I loved Jerri ever since I watched Australia when it first aired on tv. I never got the hatred for her. She does have an aggressive attitude about her at times, but overall she's not that vicious on the early seasons. I think the beef jerky event is an outlier, and Probst even said before that he agreed with Jerri, thinking that Kel actually did have beef jerky in the game. Source: ew.com/article/2005/02/08/jeff-probst-survivor-seasons-i-loved-and-hated/ I also love how she grew more mature during the years, and she's seriously chill on HvV, being the "calm, sane" member of the Villains alliance during the merge. Overall, I think she's a dynamic character who's misunderstood, complex, and develops very well throughout her three appearances. She's my original "favorite" contestant, and she's still in my top 5 favorite contestants of all time to this day.
@@markjackson6431 Yes, but that doesn't make her good moments anti-heroic. Unlike past anti-heroes, she doesn't actually do anything villainous. It is all perception by others.
The Patrons voted for... Richard Hatch Jerri Manthey Lex van den Berghe Shii Ann Big Tom Rupert Boneham and Rob Mariano. Amber is guaranteed a story because she won and I picked Rob Cesternino because I wanted to talk about his misleading edit.
@@OnceUponAnIsland damn wish I wasn't a college student so I could afford the patron page as I'd love to vote as your content is the best on survivor TH-cam
![[Full] 4 ต่อ 4 Celebrity EP.920 | 3 พ.ย. 67 | one31](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KwiW2M_kAg4/mqdefault.jpg)
Moral of the story: Listen to Jerri.
You may think she’s a villain, but she’s never been wrong 👀
It worked out pretty well for Tina though
Jerri, you are a forever Icon of the game!
Shame on the Fans that harassed you back in the day!
Jerri was never a villain and she has suffered from her edit a lot but as a character is a top10 character in Survivor history. To me she is the biggest women character in show history and she is underrated as a player
Yeah, she was only a villain through the eyes of certain players. But I actually like that in retrospect as it made her much more memorable to us. At the time, I imagine it sucked for her.
This channel showed me that If Colby Apologized even once to Jerri he wins Australia.
@@CheefChaos Colby was simply owning his game and being humble at final tribal from winning it all.
@@OnceUponAnIsland I completely agree. I thought she was a bit dumb when I first saw her in Heroes VS Villains (cause she didn't really do anything strategic) but then I realized that she just didn't want to seem like the "black widow" that she was labeled as. She wasn't a villain--just the popular contestants in Australia often labeled her as such, and then the edit simply honed in on that.
I think parvati is the biggest woman character in the shows history and an actual villain lol
I really appreciate Jerri on this show. She may have been abrasive and rather blunt but that’s what makes her an icon. I bet if the editors showed more of her good/human side in all-stars, she might not have been booed at the reunion.
I loved Jerri and she was an incredible addition this season. Plus, I am glad to see that she was at Heroes vs. Villains (4th Place!)...Wish that she was brought back for Survivor: Game Changers.
She said she won’t come back
@@andrecanton7591 That's sad. Jerri is one of my all-time favorite Survivor castaways!
In the original seasons the small group of survivor contestants were close with each other to some degree, they were all considered celebrities' and would go to charitable events and other things together so it survivor all-stars was really like a reunion of friends. Lex made the mistake of not separating friendships outside of the game from strategy inside the game. Jerry lost because of that and I don't hold her getting eliminated then against her because it was a stupid move from Lex and Kathy. I don't think she wins if she makes it to merge but I think she has a shot to get to the end she probably makes it to final 5 and who knows after that.
When she got boo-ed at the reunion it really was a solidified that survivor was "all grown up" and now more about strategy then friendships which almost no one was prepared for going in.
Like many of the early seasons, it really shaped how future Survivor seasons would be approached by returnees.
Exactly right. If Lex is able to get Amber out right before the merge, he couldn’t because Kathy was a stubborn mule and wanted Jerri out, the entire post merge of All-Stars is different. Boston Rob gets nowhere close to the final tribal and I think Jerri, Lex, Rupert or Big Tom win the whole game.
@@NickWuebker Lex did say he wanted to exploit Boston Rob with the favor he thought he would be owed by him. It wasn't just Kathy.
@@OnceUponAnIsland I read a interview with Lex and he talked about the move to try and get Amber out. He campaigned to the other members of Chapera, besides Amber, to send Amber home and keep Jerri.. He couldn’t because Kathy wouldn’t budge because pre-game Rob said he would take her to the end. That was before Boston Rob fell in love with Amber rendering the deal null and void.
@@NickWuebker regardless of falling in love with amber, rob wouldn’t have taken kathy far because he’s the biggest liar survivor has ever seen
It's crazy how they edited it to make it seem like jerri and Colby are still at odds. If you see deleted scenes they have heart to heart convos and behave like friends
Are you referring to All-Stars or HvV?
Altough Colby was my fav in Australia and her nr.2, her smile and promo after Colby voted out was the best moment of All Stars. That was gold TV
When Jerri got revenge on Colby, I thought that was a hero moment. He was awful to her in Outback, even throwing water on her at a challenge. The southern gentleman edit is a lie. Shii-Ann subsequently giving her own revenge vote after Jerri.. hm. Maybe the guy is a jerk
Flash forward of even Amanda rolling her eyes at overrated Colby
If anything I don't think Jerri really meant to do any harm in Outback, if anything I saw her as more of an anti-villain. Pretty much it's someone who means well, but their acts end up harming others unintentionally. That kind of happened with Jerri, and as a result Colby did not trust her. If anything Jerri didn't really have any villainous intentions, she literally just wanted to form a basic alliance and have a bit of fun with it.
@@maxlolbits2182 her supposed "villain" plot line was that she wanted their rice rations to be cooked properly. Apparently that's unreasonable if the other contestant is a chef. But also apparently, Colby making much nastier comments about Keith on a personal level was supposedly good and wholesome. Fans back then were kind of weird
@@bc5163 Colby shat on Keith so much in Season 2, poor guy was just a chef.
@@bc5163 Colby is and always was a self righteous asshole. Hated him then and still do today. And his piece of shit game on Heroes vs Villians was a joke.
Really fantastic series, my friend. Keep up the great work!
Just watched the all stars reunion and the way the audience booed at her at any chance and cheered at her leaving in the break? she was and is an amazing player, sure i wasn't a fan of her in australia but she played the best game she could in all stars despite the circumstances. I really wish she could see the support this channel's audience has for her.
Was waiting for Rupert's log cabin to show up. 😹😹
Me too. It was the real star of All-Stars. 🤣🤣 J/K
I am loving for all this Jerri love right here. Seeing that black on AS (I was like 7-8) is a vivid memory of mine. My first ever favorite.
I remember watching The Australian Outback when I was 14 and thinking that Jerri was real and mistreated by the public...I also thought that Elisabeth was insincere and got too much public love. It's good to see that twenty years later, Jerri has had two more chances to prove herself and that public's opinion on her has changed...and Elisabeth has revealed her true colours time and time again on The View, and the public's opinion of her is in the gutter.
I Hated Tina n Elisabeth
One of my all-time faves! Hope she’s back someday !
These get better and better
Jerri is one of my favourites despite her antagonizing with almost all her tribemates. her run in All Stars was always on the bottom until Lex saves her and keeps her around over larger targets Colby and Ethan. probably the most infamous moment that All Stars is known for is Lex gambling Jerri off for a deal with Rob to save Amber. it just never made sense as this is a huge risk and Jerri will stay loyal to Lex no matter what. we all knows what happens next. also notably her premenitions about Rupert was true as it shows in future. when she got booed at the reunion I felt really bad for her as this would break down almost anyone in her position. with Lex keeping Jerri a couple ways to see it with Amber out. didn't make a difference and followed actual path as Rob was aligned with everybody separately on Chapera. or makes a huge difference as Lex somehow pulls in his Africa ally Tom and majority switches.
Jerri’s a hero in my heart
Same❤😊
Jerri used to be someone I loved to hate but now she’s someone I love to love
The thing is, even if Lex listened to Jerri and voted out Amber, then Lex Jerri Kathy and Shi-Ann still go into the merge low in numbers. And I think Rob would still be in control of the group and would get Lex and Kathy at least voted out for going against him, being a threat, and also no one have been with them in the game so no ones really going to trust them bc they just met strategically. I’m sure Jerri and Shi-Ann could make it farther and not get pagoned but I’m not sure. Either Rob has total control or not. But Alicia Big Tom and Rupert were super loyal to him.
Big Tom would have jumped ship.
Big Tom would've switched over to Lex 100%. Especially considering their friendship in Africa was still there plus they didn't have to worry about the whole winner thing anymore
While the hate Jerri got was ridiculous, it always cracks me up to see the audience side with Rupert (who was clearly in the wrong) over Jerri. The edit even sides with Jerri, but she was so despised at the time and Rupert was so loved.
It's possible Lex still loses even with Jerri in the game over Amber, but it would've helped as it would've been 5 to 4, and maybe Big Tom flips, but Boston Rob probably would've twisted his arm to keep him loyal to Chapera.
I think Survivor is a lot about minimizing risks and Lex voting out Jerri over Amber was a massive risk that did not pay off at all. It wasn't guaranteed he wins by keeping Jerri, but it does assure him a much better position.
@@OnceUponAnIsland At the very least, Lex could've taken out Rob's closest ally.
What do you think about the original Black Widow, Jerri Manthey?
I think she either lied or had a case of mistaken identity with Kel and the Beef Jerky. David Bloomberg talked about this with Jessica Lewis in their Why Kel Lost video. I highly recommend everyone watching that!
I wish she was in blood vs water, if they ever so legends she needs a return, great TV honestly
QUEEN
I loved Jerri ever since I watched Australia when it first aired on tv. I never got the hatred for her. She does have an aggressive attitude about her at times, but overall she's not that vicious on the early seasons. I think the beef jerky event is an outlier, and Probst even said before that he agreed with Jerri, thinking that Kel actually did have beef jerky in the game. Source: ew.com/article/2005/02/08/jeff-probst-survivor-seasons-i-loved-and-hated/
I also love how she grew more mature during the years, and she's seriously chill on HvV, being the "calm, sane" member of the Villains alliance during the merge. Overall, I think she's a dynamic character who's misunderstood, complex, and develops very well throughout her three appearances. She's my original "favorite" contestant, and she's still in my top 5 favorite contestants of all time to this day.
@@giovanniorellana2200 She didn’t lie, other players later confirmed she was telling the truth. As they witnessed it at other times/locations.
so why didn’t Jerri get anti hero/villain character moments like Hatch, Sandra, and Fairplay did
Why should she be considered an anti-hero?
@@OnceUponAnIsland because she was considered as a huge villain prior to HvV
@@markjackson6431 Yes, but that doesn't make her good moments anti-heroic. Unlike past anti-heroes, she doesn't actually do anything villainous. It is all perception by others.
I love the title. It made me laugh
Thanks! I debated between it and being Lex'd, but I decided Boston Robbed sounded better.
i really liked jerri. i don't get the villian angle, she was playing the game.
That's the way the show painted her.
Sue: "I WAS VIOLATED, HUMILIATED, DEHUMANIZED AND TOTALLY SPENT"
OUAI: "oh no. anyway."
Not really relevant to Jerri's story, but I do look at it much closer in Rich's.
@@OnceUponAnIsland Oh I know. It was just a funny editing moment. ✌
You deserve 1 mill not gonna lie
Thanks! Sharing on Reddit/Discord/Etc. really helps spread the word :)
I’ll try my best to spread the word because I’m serious it’s really good!
@@Averiel73 That would be amazing! I hope to crack 10k subs soon :)
This is when I started liking her cuz I hated her on Australian outback cuz I was a Colby fan
Jerri: I'm going to eat some chocolate. = D U M B
viewers were the villain
23:40 Is there a compilation of akward zoom in moments in Survivor? Because that one should be on it.
5:20 - Living without water remark while it is pouring buckets of water!
THE QUEEN OF SURVIVOR TIED WITH DANNI AND SANDRA
With? I’m confused..
tied with what?
Ohhhhh I get it now. Getting screwed by Boston Rob.
No Kim or Parvati?
@@jacobymatt1767 how is sandra screwed by rob?
Ethan: we have the mom, the nice guy, the military guy, the hot chic.
Jenna Louis: am I a joke to you
I guess we're not getting Colby. A shame as I really liked Colby this season. I mean I liked Colby every season but still great content
The Patrons voted for...
Richard Hatch
Jerri Manthey
Lex van den Berghe
Shii Ann
Big Tom
Rupert Boneham
and Rob Mariano.
Amber is guaranteed a story because she won and I picked Rob Cesternino because I wanted to talk about his misleading edit.
@@OnceUponAnIsland damn wish I wasn't a college student so I could afford the patron page as I'd love to vote as your content is the best on survivor TH-cam
Out of curiosity how many are u doing for this season
15 overall videos, 9 are story videos.
I saw you do a video on Nick Idanza, is there anyway you would do a video on Michelle Dougan? Or just her tribe swap kill on Ben?
01:34
Can you make one of these for Cirie Fields?
01:34
Currently on a rewatch of AO.
Awesome! I made a video previously about how truthful was her villainous edit that season. I highly recommend checking it out.
@@OnceUponAnIsland for sure! I think I’m going to watch all Jerri seasons in a row to complete her arc
We're Ethan and Jenna m already dating during all stars?
I believe so
Amazing how many poor moves Lex made during this game.
STOP ALL REALITY TELEVISION