When you say "won" do you mean an outright victory against all the opponents they historically fought, or through clever diplomacy did Bulgaria manage to keep the Ottomans and Romanians from joining in?
@@insignificantgnat9334I would like to see this as a total victory, the diplomacy is kinda boring and would never happen as it involves giving Dobruja to Romania and some Eastern Thracian land to the Ottomans
Idea: what if WWII was a 3 way war (axis vs allies vs Comintern)? Let's say France/UK declared war on the Soviets when they split Poland, and later, Mustacheman declares war on the Soviets when he gets done with France.
What if at the start of the Siberian intervention the Japanese find either Alexieve, installing him as a puppet ruler, or one of his sisters whom is then married into the royal family, to give them enough legitimacy to remain in Siberia?
@@simonnachreiner8380 Near impossible, right? Well, not quite. A lot of people in the United States were actually favoring the Germans because *Britain.* However, choices made by the Germans put on severe odds with the USA. However, however...! I can see Germany offering Canada for USA help... It's not that impossible.
most Americans were neutral, it was a combination of British spy's rigging surveys, and Germans submarine warfare which resulted in the USA joining the allies.
@@ExiledPiasa what if the revolution never happened in the first place and Russia managed to modernize instead? Maybe tsar Nicholas dies early and the regent isn't incompetent
@@ExiledPiasaAs bad as the Soviets were, they certainly did way more modernization then the Autocratic regime would have, as much as I also like the Russian Empire.
A scenario I would like to see is "What if Poland seceded Danzig to Germany and became a economic/Political Puppet" The scenario could be set in 1938 to early 1939, after the Munich Agreement, as the perceived 'weakness' of both France and Britain had a more significant impact on the Polish people, leading to a desire to seek appeasement with Germany. This could be further influenced by France's failure to protect the independence of the Czechoslovak Republic during the Munich Agreement and Germany's eventual occupation of Czechoslovakia in March 1939.
Attempt 21: (Using the Great War Redux again) What if Italy honored the Triple Alliance and eventually joined the Central Powers when WWI comes around?
What if Tecumseh's Confederacy defeated America in 1812? (Independent native state in the Great Lakes region. Alternatively a British dominion and/or expanded to the west all the way to Washington)
To your last point, this is true but also since the Americans aren’t fighting in the pacific more of their resources can go to Europe which could effectively increase the western ally speed to Berlin as well
What if Sweden joined ww1 to take back Finland. Bondetåget (a swedish protest/strike by the farmers) got more support and more people joined it, while arbetartåget got less support from the goverment and less people joined in on it. This would in turn give more power to the conservative’s and the king, while the left got less support. Gustaf the fifth (the king of Sweden from 1907-1950) had politacal power back then so he’d propably create a parliment loyal to him if not taking all the control for him self (probably not the latter as sweden has had it’s riksdag for a very long time and it would probably be somewhat controversial) After the king took control and ww1 started he would join germany to fight russia as a way to take back Finland and the maybe the baltics, but when the russian revolution kicks of I think he would support the whites as he wouldn’t want the communists to take control.
How about the Kingdom of Ethiopia survived the coup and dominates Western Africa? Or, Ireland units to drive out the British and liberates Scotland, uniting Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Cornwall, the Isle of Man, and Brittany under one flag?
What if Germany and Austria was more reaasonable after the assassination of Franz Ferdinand? What if Austria's ultimatum wasn't too harsh? What if instead of immediately declaring war, Germany tried to "pressure" Russia to not intervine?
Which version of Rt56 is he using? Or are there any additional mods beeing used? I play a lot of Hoi but i've never seen that version of Rt56 anywhere else...
Hey did you guys know the Enclave Reborn Redux Mod has gotten like massive changes in the past year, I mean they are on version 10.1.4 now. You can now rescue the USS Constitution, integrate the NCR Air Force, retrofit congress where I think it is now similar to base, Washington as well as Jefferson event, even the IRS (curse those infernal sons of guns), and like crazy new events and some new units. I mean it seems amazing but no one has covered it in ages. I really want to see it since I am unable to do it myself. If stykui does it can he please do the full mutate citizenship because it is hilarious
Actually Stak, I'm a lot more bullish on Nationalist China than you are. Remember, this isn't our Nationalist China that spent the time period from 1937-1945 being utterly incompetent against the Japanese. This is a Nationalist China that in under two years was able to not only fight the Japanese to a stand still, but also liberated Chinese national soil in the form of Manchuria and Taiwan (ignoring the fact that Taiwan was unlikely to be ceded by the Japanese) and was able to liberate their little brother Korea. The amount of prestige the Nationalist Government would've received from this would've been massive. Not that the Communists couldn't have found a way to overcome this, but it is far from likely.
The cult of personality a nationalist victory in the war and also making a land grab would be insane. It's unlikely that the civil war would be reignited at all. Instead the commies would probably suck up to the KMT seizing soft power from ministerial positions. Attempting a military revolution would be impossible since winning the war would basically give the KMT the mandate of heaven in the eye of most of the peasentry.
Really curios what would happen if “Germany” had gotten nuclear weapons before Germany fell perhaps 1944 or 1945, and how the allies might have handled things diplomatically and so on
I'm still trying to figure out the basics of this amazing game and you have been SO ENTERTAINING to watch. I wish i could do a fraction of the work you're putting into these like it's nothing. How do you plan what you're going to use to achieve your end goal? Do you research focus trees or do you just know what all the countries do lol
an alternate possible solution to korea being free before ww2 would be if that pre ww1 war between russia and japan went better for russia resulting in a korea that was in a similar position to what poland was in between ww1 and ww2.
What if instead of invading Korea in 1592 Toyotomi instead sends his army south to capture Taiwan, the Philippines, Borneo and Malaysia? The Jesuits incited rebellions and insurrections, like the Shimabara Rebellion, and took many Japanese women as slaves for the brothels. Let’s say that the Jesuits cause even more of an uproar and Japan decides to remove the jesuits from Asia. The access to large amounts of iron, coal, copper are just incidental…
PLEASE can we get a part 2 focusing on the rise of the CCP in this timeline and how the world responds to the solidifying of communism in Asia Edit: spelling
I'm personally curious what could have happened if the Heavenly Kingdom revolt in China had won, but I have no idea how to best portray that or how probably that even is.
What if under no surcomstances Italy never joined the axis or allied powers, (Actin like Francos Spain sort of) this could be done with political instability if the 2nd Italo Ethiopian war ended in an Ethiopian victory or an Italian one just at great cost.
Ngl this video really isn't about Korea, it's just Chinese play through if everything went better. I may not speak for everyone but... I think we were expecting an impossible scenario where you would play Korea the entirety of the game. But still, good quality
What if Yan Xishan was actually supported by the local gentry in his reforms, and succesfully managed a degree of modernisation before the 2nde Sino-Japanese war.
this is a cool scenario, -but everytime i hear the road to 56 mentioned, i just immediately think of the damn game slowing to a crawl for little reason lol-
Idea: what if Bulgaria won the second Balkan war
YES
impossible but very interesting
Very interesting
When you say "won" do you mean an outright victory against all the opponents they historically fought, or through clever diplomacy did Bulgaria manage to keep the Ottomans and Romanians from joining in?
@@insignificantgnat9334I would like to see this as a total victory, the diplomacy is kinda boring and would never happen as it involves giving Dobruja to Romania and some Eastern Thracian land to the Ottomans
Idea: what if WWII was a 3 way war (axis vs allies vs Comintern)?
Let's say France/UK declared war on the Soviets when they split Poland, and later, Mustacheman declares war on the Soviets when he gets done with France.
That would be even more interesting if the amped up Communist China from this scenario joined the USSR.
What about a 4-way war? (Allies VS Empire of Japan VS Comintern VS European Axis)?
Another youtuber made a video about this called Possible History also that title... Some people may get another idea with that title
What if at the start of the Siberian intervention the Japanese find either Alexieve, installing him as a puppet ruler, or one of his sisters whom is then married into the royal family, to give them enough legitimacy to remain in Siberia?
Alexie LIVES ALexie LIVES we draw closer to midnight
This is good
Love the alternate histories! How about "What if Mongolia tried to gain more influence in China?"
at what point in time is this to happen? because after the yuan dynasty it was basically a rump state
Been waiting for this, now for Korea to liberate itself from Japanese suppression
"What if the United States joined the Central Powers?"
...about that.
@@simonnachreiner8380 Near impossible, right? Well, not quite.
A lot of people in the United States were actually favoring the Germans because *Britain.*
However, choices made by the Germans put on severe odds with the USA.
However, however...! I can see Germany offering Canada for USA help... It's not that impossible.
most Americans were neutral, it was a combination of British spy's rigging surveys, and Germans submarine warfare which resulted in the USA joining the allies.
@@henriquemachado9941 don't forget the huge German and Irish community in america
Impossible
Byzantium sequel: what would a remaining Byzantine empire do in WW2?
what if the carlists won the spanish civil war?
What if the Tsarists beat the Communist and were in a stronger position at the start of WW2?
@@ExiledPiasa what if the revolution never happened in the first place and Russia managed to modernize instead? Maybe tsar Nicholas dies early and the regent isn't incompetent
@@ExiledPiasaAs bad as the Soviets were, they certainly did way more modernization then the Autocratic regime would have, as much as I also like the Russian Empire.
This, I like this
A scenario I would like to see is "What if Poland seceded Danzig to Germany and became a economic/Political Puppet"
The scenario could be set in 1938 to early 1939, after the Munich Agreement, as the perceived 'weakness' of both France and Britain had a more significant impact on the Polish people, leading to a desire to seek appeasement with Germany. This could be further influenced by France's failure to protect the independence of the Czechoslovak Republic during the Munich Agreement and Germany's eventual occupation of Czechoslovakia in March 1939.
R56 actually has a sub tree for that.
would love to see "What if India revolted against British rule in the leadup to WW2?"
Yes
Attempt 21: (Using the Great War Redux again) What if Italy honored the Triple Alliance and eventually joined the Central Powers when WWI comes around?
Get this man into the poll and actually have him win this time.
Idea: what if Yugoslavia didn't have a coup and joined the axis
What if the Irish Civil War was won by the anti-treaty side in late 20s
Great idea
We need a EAW path for the entire family, not cameos but actual path
(Video 37) What if the United Arab Republic was a success? (Egypt/Cold War mod)
What if Greece achieved Megali Idea?
this scenario he already covered
What if Tecumseh's Confederacy defeated America in 1812?
(Independent native state in the Great Lakes region. Alternatively a British dominion and/or expanded to the west all the way to Washington)
What if the Netherlands joined World War I?
To your last point, this is true but also since the Americans aren’t fighting in the pacific more of their resources can go to Europe which could effectively increase the western ally speed to Berlin as well
what if the germans allied with Britain and Russia during ww1?
And France, Spain, Italy, and Austria-Hungary form the “Central” Powers?
what if kaiser didn't build up a navy and britain, fearing russia and its historical rival france allied with germany and thus joined central powers
what if Germany failed to invade Poland
What would have happened if the Soviet Union invader Poland before Germany. What would the Allies respond and how would Germany be affected?
I can answer that one!
The treaty signed with Britain and France specifically mentioned invasion by Germany, so Poland is somehow even more screwed.
What if Sweden joined ww1 to take back Finland.
Bondetåget (a swedish protest/strike by the farmers) got more support and more people joined it, while arbetartåget got less support from the goverment and less people joined in on it. This would in turn give more power to the conservative’s and the king, while the left got less support. Gustaf the fifth (the king of Sweden from 1907-1950) had politacal power back then so he’d propably create a parliment loyal to him if not taking all the control for him self (probably not the latter as sweden has had it’s riksdag for a very long time and it would probably be somewhat controversial)
After the king took control and ww1 started he would join germany to fight russia as a way to take back Finland and the maybe the baltics, but when the russian revolution kicks of I think he would support the whites as he wouldn’t want the communists to take control.
Here is my idea: What if the Yugoslav Wars had occurred during World War 2?
What if Kasier Wilhelm II kept Otto Von Bismarck as a advisor and listened to him about making a alliance with the Russians 🇷🇺 before WW1?
Idea; What if Brazil joined the second world war?
How about the Kingdom of Ethiopia survived the coup and dominates Western Africa? Or, Ireland units to drive out the British and liberates Scotland, uniting Ireland, Scotland, Wales, Cornwall, the Isle of Man, and Brittany under one flag?
What if Poland successfully defended itself against the German invasion in September of 1939?
What if Germany and Austria was more reaasonable after the assassination of Franz Ferdinand? What if Austria's ultimatum wasn't too harsh? What if instead of immediately declaring war, Germany tried to "pressure" Russia to not intervine?
What if Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania were never invaded by the Soviet Union in 1940?
alright i gotta say it "what if Italy was nicer more and joined the allies? "
Nice. How about Italy, Greece, and Spain ally against France and Germany?
@@ExiledPiasa does that have a historical background or you just made it up?
what if italy joined central powers
Which version of Rt56 is he using? Or are there any additional mods beeing used? I play a lot of Hoi but i've never seen that version of Rt56 anywhere else...
Why did yt gatkeep this from me for 13 seconds 💀 also idea what if Yugoslavia didn't have a coup and joined the axis
Thank you so much sir im so happy
Hey did you guys know the Enclave Reborn Redux Mod has gotten like massive changes in the past year, I mean they are on version 10.1.4 now. You can now rescue the USS Constitution, integrate the NCR Air Force, retrofit congress where I think it is now similar to base, Washington as well as Jefferson event, even the IRS (curse those infernal sons of guns), and like crazy new events and some new units. I mean it seems amazing but no one has covered it in ages. I really want to see it since I am unable to do it myself. If stykui does it can he please do the full mutate citizenship because it is hilarious
Would love to see a followup where the scenario you describe at the end happens!
Actually Stak, I'm a lot more bullish on Nationalist China than you are.
Remember, this isn't our Nationalist China that spent the time period from 1937-1945 being utterly incompetent against the Japanese. This is a Nationalist China that in under two years was able to not only fight the Japanese to a stand still, but also liberated Chinese national soil in the form of Manchuria and Taiwan (ignoring the fact that Taiwan was unlikely to be ceded by the Japanese) and was able to liberate their little brother Korea.
The amount of prestige the Nationalist Government would've received from this would've been massive.
Not that the Communists couldn't have found a way to overcome this, but it is far from likely.
The cult of personality a nationalist victory in the war and also making a land grab would be insane. It's unlikely that the civil war would be reignited at all. Instead the commies would probably suck up to the KMT seizing soft power from ministerial positions. Attempting a military revolution would be impossible since winning the war would basically give the KMT the mandate of heaven in the eye of most of the peasentry.
What if Atomic weapons were developed sooner and used before, during or after the Normandy Landings of 1944?
😅 just a random thought, but we have seen extreme speed, super medical, overwhelming offense, but was or is their any unbreakable shield 😅
What is Peter II of Yugoslavia's coup failed, and Yugoslavia joined the axis?
Idea, what if Greece joined the central powers rather than the entente
Idea: what if Japan won the war in the pacific.
What if the Tsar was overthrown earlier?
You owe us a stellaris game Stakuyi. We want to see the space cat.
Really curios what would happen if “Germany” had gotten nuclear weapons before Germany fell perhaps 1944 or 1945, and how the allies might have handled things diplomatically and so on
I'm still trying to figure out the basics of this amazing game and you have been SO ENTERTAINING to watch. I wish i could do a fraction of the work you're putting into these like it's nothing.
How do you plan what you're going to use to achieve your end goal? Do you research focus trees or do you just know what all the countries do lol
Idea: What if the confederacy won in the US Civil War
HERE TO SAY 4th, In all seriousness this is the earliest Ive been to a Stayuki video
What if Japan joined the central powers
Better idea here: What if Kurdistan broke free from Iraq, Syria, Iran and turkey?🫡 or from any other nation from the past😮💨
What if Spain fully joined the Axis (military and all)
what if texas declared independence in the great depression
an alternate possible solution to korea being free before ww2 would be if that pre ww1 war between russia and japan went better for russia resulting in a korea that was in a similar position to what poland was in between ww1 and ww2.
What if the Portuguese monarchy did not fall even after the king's assassination?
What if Brazil Overthrew Getulio vargas before WW2?
What if instead of invading Korea in 1592 Toyotomi instead sends his army south to capture Taiwan, the Philippines, Borneo and Malaysia?
The Jesuits incited rebellions and insurrections, like the Shimabara Rebellion, and took many Japanese women as slaves for the brothels. Let’s say that the Jesuits cause even more of an uproar and Japan decides to remove the jesuits from Asia.
The access to large amounts of iron, coal, copper are just incidental…
What if Qing China participated in WW1 as a major power.
What if the July 20 plot succeded
What if Prussia survived WW1
PLEASE can we get a part 2 focusing on the rise of the CCP in this timeline and how the world responds to the solidifying of communism in Asia
Edit: spelling
What if Japan joined the Cental Powers
Always thought this one was kind of good. What if the German wonder Waffen’s work?
What if Mongolia broke free from the Soviet Union and reformed the Mongol Empire? Because I know you love playing the Mongols.
What if PLC (Polish Lithuanian comenwealth) or GDL (Grand duchy of lithuania) survived?
I'm personally curious what could have happened if the Heavenly Kingdom revolt in China had won, but I have no idea how to best portray that or how probably that even is.
What If the British Raj gained independence before ww2
What if under no surcomstances Italy never joined the axis or allied powers, (Actin like Francos Spain sort of) this could be done with political instability if the 2nd Italo Ethiopian war ended in an Ethiopian victory or an Italian one just at great cost.
What if the Soviet Union became democratic before World War II?
What is this mod? Doesn't look like standard rt56
What if Britain and France carved up the Middle East differently
What if Italy joined Central powers in WW1?
What if Belgium let Germany through in ww1
What if Greece achieved Megali Idea in WW1?
You’re killing me so many long weeks without you 😅
Yo what mod is that?
What og the allies invaded Norway instead of germany
What if britain won the battle of singapore
What if Argentina joined the Axis after expansion
Argentina expanding into near countries, taking nearby navy and joining the Axis once England declars on Germany
I missed these ❤❤❤
What if Hungary won the spring war? The war after ww1?
What if Australia had gotten indipendance before WW1
Idea: waht if the white army won the russian civil war
What if big boss was in ww2
Aka snake
What if Patton had to live long enough to be the commander of forces in the Korean war?
Ngl this video really isn't about Korea, it's just Chinese play through if everything went better. I may not speak for everyone but... I think we were expecting an impossible scenario where you would play Korea the entirety of the game. But still, good quality
What if the Soviets attacked first on the eastern front
What if Yan Xishan was actually supported by the local gentry in his reforms, and succesfully managed a degree of modernisation before the 2nde Sino-Japanese war.
What if stakuyi's next video was Millennium Dawn?
Yay, a Stakuyi vid
Ur first
@@ChipFPE123okay, cool ig
Idea: what if the allies landed in Greece instead of Italy? (Yalta Conference was a lot weaker for the postwar borders specifically)
this is a cool scenario, -but everytime i hear the road to 56 mentioned, i just immediately think of the damn game slowing to a crawl for little reason lol-
idea what if Paris was destoryed (meteor, fire, earthquake ect)
I have no idea how this would work in a Paradox game, but what if Sun Yat-sen stayed in power before WW2?
What if France never fell?
What if the Italian Navy had been lead by the aggressive admirals at the beginning of WW2
What if Brazil joined the axis?
Idea: What if Germany didn’t break the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact?
what if the checks resisted the germans ?
What if we had a “Civ 2 More Peaceful” India in WW2