I could imagine room clearing would be a lot easier for the separatists. First send in some b1s to reveal the enemies position, then send in commando units to finish them off.
lol reminds me of something I heard on a Stalingrad documentary a long time ago, it went something like, “The grenade is your friend. You throw them in the room first, wait for them to clear the room, and then go in “
Luckily, for the Munnlist 10 they were very skilled, being caught in between buildings with sniper Droids in all of them firing from all sides with only a down damaged Gunship for cover, most units would have been slaughtered or taken heavy losses, but with Fordo's leadership and their skills, the team only lost one member, the only casualty, besides the piolet, of the operation. And that is why the Munnlist 10 is one of the best infiltration units.
However, as the years went by, I expect them to be slowly but surely declining in numbers, up to the possible point that Fordo might be the only survivor come the Clone Wars' end. Yep, just like Domino Squad from the Alt-universe.
@@michaelandreipalon359 Well, I suppose as long as one survived and got a happy ending after the war then I'll still call it a win. Of course, with what happened after the war, most of the survivors weren't that lucky, so, yeah.
Urban combat would be in favor for the Clone Army because they are more than capable to take on the static droid army, but that doesn’t mean that it would be an easy fight.
Doubt it favors the clone army personally. Droids don't get tired, and the entirety of the droid army are basically walking turrets, one droid can stand guard over a position indefinitely, which is perfect for defense.
So, Stalingrad but on a planetary scale. Sounds like absolute hell; no wonder the Outer Rim sieges were so infamous-even if you win, the meat grinder of urban warfare would have chewed through a few armies’ worth of men by the time it’s over. And unlike Stalingrad you can’t strike at the flanks and encircle the enemy army within the city.
thats why thanks to more military power going to the Fleet commanders and not jedi they rather orbital bombarded the planets back to the stone age rather than dealing with this meatgrinder. you can see why every republic soldier hated jedi with their morality that will produces more casualties on the republic rather than biting the bullet and be ruthless to win
Great video on urban warfare the Battle of Christophsis had a bit of sublety while in the 2003 Clone Wars the Battle of Muunisalist sorry for the misspelling was alot more explosive and intense.
Christophis is a republic world in TCW meanwhile Muunilist is a seperatist world . you can clearly see the republic didnt really care about colletarell damage when it came to CIS worlds
>Trapping civilians in a city as human shields against artillery >Utilizing civilian buildings as military bases I feel like Geetsly's is trying to tell us something... Something relevant to our world.
I had come up with a sci-fi where a government forces towns to be built around Planetary Defense Guns, and you aren’t allowed to bombard military bases in civilian areas due to inaccuracy of shells Thus it restricts orbital bombarding and forces urban combat and dropship deployments
This is why Russia hasn’t been able to conquer Ukraine-all their tanks and heavy artillery is useless when you have to clear the enemy out, street by street and house by house. Ironically, same thing entrapped the Germans at Stalingrad-the Sixth Army was committed to taking the city and the Soviets smashed the flanking armies to encircle it.
Such is the way of war, so I'm not complaining too much... apart from the fact that the good guys haven't done a real life Big Damn Heroes/The Cavalry moment as of now.
Ukraine do let civilians out, Mariupool being an exception because it was surrounded on all sides and blockaded by sea. While using civilian buildings as military bases is mostly Russian propaganda. Fighting in an urban environment is hell, especially if the populace wants you dead.
So basically Urban Warfare is the same no matter WHAT reality an LITERALLY where your fighting it. Cuz it's also the deadliest kinda battlefield to have to fight in in real life too. Even pretty small scale an handfuls of fighters for both sides often tends to lead to quite a mess and brutal, bloody fighting.
thats why many republic/imperial officers didnt really care about civilians especially hostile civilians and instead of sending waves of clone stormtroopers in they rather Surround give one chance for surrender if denied they annihalte the entire city piece by piece with artillery and heavy walkers. at unlike the kid friendly TCW shows only comedy droids the seperatists were really nasty in gurellia tactics especially the organic troops like the nimbus commandos
@@laisphinto6372 yeah least till Palpatine showed his true colors.. an fetish for planet and even Galaxy killing Superweapons an didn't even bother sending in forces, unless, he wanted particular people an the surrounding areas to suffer. An just authorized Base-Delta-Zeroes when he wasn't ordering them. Via Death Stars an SD Battle Groups
Thank you for not posting videos about Kenobi with spoilers in THE THUMBNAIL AND VIDEO TITLES!!! Unlike a certain other Star Wars youtuber. I cant afford Disney+ right now and I had to unsubscribe from his channel just so I can keep the show fresh for me. So really thank you for NOT posting spoilers for Kenobi.
Can we take a moment and give props to the Muunilist 10's first pilot? He knew he wasn't going to survive but he still made sure his passengers survived.
Real life urban warfare is a very time consuming and costly effort. Not to mention, you never know where your enemy could be hiding. And this is made even worse, when the enemy you're fighting are civilians or military soldiers who know the city well.
Urban warfare. Sure beats exoatmosphere, spirit world, jungle, desert, and snow wasteland battlefields, regardless of its sheer brutality and close quarters risks.
Open combat means the enemy can see you farther away. While urban combat isnt fun you have the advantage of a lot more cover and concealment of your movements. But hey I spent nearly 3 years in combat over my career
I know this is comparing apples to oranges but I imagine urban combat would be preferable to random crazy environmental ones like mon cal/dak or Felucia.
That's urban combat in any universe... Though I would probably prefer urban combat due to the fact I have physical limitations as well as several proficiencies that would make me more effective in that environment. In fact, had I joined the military I'd have been a green beret (anyone whom knows much about them will also understand why I would therefore prefer urban combat, especially in a capital city).
Considering how I have lived in Urban cities, I am more familiar, I can protect myself from enemy combats and my chances to escape is much higher compared to open field combat . However, the chances of me dying is still high in Urban quarters because you never know who is the enemy because there is to many civilians around for you to pinpoint exactly who it is so you are constantly having to be in high alert but at the same time, it would be a nightmare for any attacker. I would prefer being the defender in a Urban field, not the attacker lol.
The Darth plagues book suggests that there were many battles on munnilist . Or that after the clone wars is was no longer as beautiful as it one e was .i assume after the clone wars theu rebuild. But the separatists trying to reclaim it and its wealth makes sense
Hey I know this is off topic but I’m trying to get into reading Star Wars comics but I don’t really know where to start, does anybody have any recommendations on where I can best read comics from, and what comic series is best to start with?
The recent Marvel Star Wars comic runs 2015 have been good. Main title Star Wars follows org trilogy heroes are good reading bunch of fine arcs esp when they fight elite stormtroopers special force unit. The Vader title is brutal and deep examination of Vader's activities post prequels full of Imperial politics and Sith intrigue. It is an award winning next level read if you are interested in Vader I would say essential. Enjoy!
Spider Droid
Spider Droid
Does whatever a spider does
Shoots a laser any time
Kills civilians just like flies
Look out!
Here comes the Spider Droid
I could imagine room clearing would be a lot easier for the separatists. First send in some b1s to reveal the enemies position, then send in commando units to finish them off.
They dont have that many Commando droids
God somehow I managed to imagine the room clearing from mw19 but with droids lol
Or use like Heat Vision and just shell the building
@@frozenfire2634 thats why they would use the b1s to soften em up before their deployed.
lol reminds me of something I heard on a Stalingrad documentary a long time ago, it went something like, “The grenade is your friend. You throw them in the room first, wait for them to clear the room, and then go in “
Soilders with the high ground are exactly the kind of people Obi-wan wants in the 212th
Who wouldn’t want them 😂
@@geetslys Anakin. He just doesn't appreciate the art of being on marginally higher terrain then your enemy.
Luckily, for the Munnlist 10 they were very skilled, being caught in between buildings with sniper Droids in all of them firing from all sides with only a down damaged Gunship for cover, most units would have been slaughtered or taken heavy losses, but with Fordo's leadership and their skills, the team only lost one member, the only casualty, besides the piolet, of the operation. And that is why the Munnlist 10 is one of the best infiltration units.
Gunships have two pilots
Also wasn’t it too regular clones that got shot
However, as the years went by, I expect them to be slowly but surely declining in numbers, up to the possible point that Fordo might be the only survivor come the Clone Wars' end.
Yep, just like Domino Squad from the Alt-universe.
@@michaelandreipalon359 Well, I suppose as long as one survived and got a happy ending after the war then I'll still call it a win. Of course, with what happened after the war, most of the survivors weren't that lucky, so, yeah.
Just the pilot, copilot, and one trooper were killed.
For a second, I read that as "Frodo's leadership", and I had questions =p
Urban combat would be in favor for the Clone Army because they are more than capable to take on the static droid army, but that doesn’t mean that it would be an easy fight.
Every building in a city is either a standing ground, or an ambush waiting to be tripped
It’s very deadly
Doubt it favors the clone army personally. Droids don't get tired, and the entirety of the droid army are basically walking turrets, one droid can stand guard over a position indefinitely, which is perfect for defense.
@@imperialtrooper927 yep.
During the Battle of Muunilist, I am pretty sure that the Republic destroyed plenty of buildings and infrastructures with their artileries.
You can see entire city blocks collapsing under the destructive fire of SPHA-Ts
@@yarnickgoovaerts multiple city blocks at once
Sector 4 no longer needs reinforcements
-Fordo, probably
So, Stalingrad but on a planetary scale.
Sounds like absolute hell; no wonder the Outer Rim sieges were so infamous-even if you win, the meat grinder of urban warfare would have chewed through a few armies’ worth of men by the time it’s over. And unlike Stalingrad you can’t strike at the flanks and encircle the enemy army within the city.
thats why thanks to more military power going to the Fleet commanders and not jedi they rather orbital bombarded the planets back to the stone age rather than dealing with this meatgrinder. you can see why every republic soldier hated jedi with their morality that will produces more casualties on the republic rather than biting the bullet and be ruthless to win
Great video on urban warfare the Battle of Christophsis had a bit of sublety while in the 2003 Clone Wars the Battle of Muunisalist sorry for the misspelling was alot more explosive and intense.
Christophis is a republic world in TCW meanwhile Muunilist is a seperatist world .
you can clearly see the republic didnt really care about colletarell damage when it came to CIS worlds
>Trapping civilians in a city as human shields against artillery
>Utilizing civilian buildings as military bases
I feel like Geetsly's is trying to tell us something... Something relevant to our world.
I had come up with a sci-fi where a government forces towns to be built around Planetary Defense Guns, and you aren’t allowed to bombard military bases in civilian areas due to inaccuracy of shells
Thus it restricts orbital bombarding and forces urban combat and dropship deployments
This is why Russia hasn’t been able to conquer Ukraine-all their tanks and heavy artillery is useless when you have to clear the enemy out, street by street and house by house.
Ironically, same thing entrapped the Germans at Stalingrad-the Sixth Army was committed to taking the city and the Soviets smashed the flanking armies to encircle it.
Such is the way of war, so I'm not complaining too much... apart from the fact that the good guys haven't done a real life Big Damn Heroes/The Cavalry moment as of now.
@@warlordofbritannia the minute I saw the title of this video, I was getting Stalingrad vibes.
Ukraine do let civilians out, Mariupool being an exception because it was surrounded on all sides and blockaded by sea. While using civilian buildings as military bases is mostly Russian propaganda. Fighting in an urban environment is hell, especially if the populace wants you dead.
I think it would be cool to have a band of brothers type of Star Wars show during the GCW
isn't that practically the bad batch and the last seasons of clone wars?
@@rustyeyeby read the last part of the comment
@@neofulcrum5013 oof, sorry, was half asleep😅
@@rustyeyeby no worries
Agreed.
I literally commissioned that artwork you used for the thumbnail loool. Glad to see it being used by someone like you :D
So basically Urban Warfare is the same no matter WHAT reality an LITERALLY where your fighting it. Cuz it's also the deadliest kinda battlefield to have to fight in in real life too. Even pretty small scale an handfuls of fighters for both sides often tends to lead to quite a mess and brutal, bloody fighting.
thats why many republic/imperial officers didnt really care about civilians especially hostile civilians and instead of sending waves of clone stormtroopers in they rather Surround give one chance for surrender if denied they annihalte the entire city piece by piece with artillery and heavy walkers. at unlike the kid friendly TCW shows only comedy droids the seperatists were really nasty in gurellia tactics especially the organic troops like the nimbus commandos
@@laisphinto6372 yeah least till Palpatine showed his true colors.. an fetish for planet and even Galaxy killing Superweapons an didn't even bother sending in forces, unless, he wanted particular people an the surrounding areas to suffer. An just authorized Base-Delta-Zeroes when he wasn't ordering them. Via Death Stars an SD Battle Groups
7:50 Another great New Comment of the Week and I appreciate new ones in every Geetsly's video update.
Thank you for not posting videos about Kenobi with spoilers in THE THUMBNAIL AND VIDEO TITLES!!! Unlike a certain other Star Wars youtuber. I cant afford Disney+ right now and I had to unsubscribe from his channel just so I can keep the show fresh for me. So really thank you for NOT posting spoilers for Kenobi.
And then videos with spoilers will pop up in your search results...regardless if you looked up anything related to Star Wars.
Tug of War-style urban battles in a nutshell.
I love getting my Star Wars info from you
Any excuse to show off Frodo and the boys' skills😏
I didn't know Fordo was a hobbit...
if the civiliens was also going aigenst the attackers it would be a even worse nightmare or parts of the civilien population
Can we take a moment and give props to the Muunilist 10's first pilot? He knew he wasn't going to survive but he still made sure his passengers survived.
Love your content sir! Keep it up!
Real life urban warfare is a very time consuming and costly effort. Not to mention, you never know where your enemy could be hiding. And this is made even worse, when the enemy you're fighting are civilians or military soldiers who know the city well.
urban warfare is where morality is a bad idea to hold up
1:31 A-Wings fighting in the Clone Wars, nice.
R-22 Spearheads existed at the time. So not entirely inaccurate lol
1:44-1:55
Everybody: Playing 2D chess
Palpatine: Playing 3D chess
Revan: Playing 4D chess plus checkers and Uno
(cue maul cutting a swathe through Republic forces)
Urban warfare. Sure beats exoatmosphere, spirit world, jungle, desert, and snow wasteland battlefields, regardless of its sheer brutality and close quarters risks.
Video idea: Did Palpatine have the knowledge and capability to build his own starforge?
No that was lost knowledge but cool idea explaining why it's lost etc
Open combat means the enemy can see you farther away. While urban combat isnt fun you have the advantage of a lot more cover and concealment of your movements. But hey I spent nearly 3 years in combat over my career
So your prefer enemies that could see you farther away than enemies that have more cover and concealment for their movements?
@@imperialtrooper927 yes
@@imperialtrooper927 I mean just imagine having to deal with snipers in urban combat where they can hide anywhere compared to open combat.
God are all of star wars tactics dog shiet?
I know this is comparing apples to oranges but I imagine urban combat would be preferable to random crazy environmental ones like mon cal/dak or Felucia.
Love the images you're sharing but the comics I'm not familiar with so thanks .
This is a really cool video topic and I really enjoyed it but will we still get the other lightsaber forms ? Please? Lol
Taco Bell 🔔
I would definitely fight with a mobile high-ground jet pack
1st like lol 🤩😎
you dont have to worry about urban combat if you wipe that pathetic planet from the face of the galaxy
Base Delta Zero is your lucky code
The ARC troopers of Muunilinst 10 sure did a great job at the Battle of Muuilinst.
That's urban combat in any universe... Though I would probably prefer urban combat due to the fact I have physical limitations as well as several proficiencies that would make me more effective in that environment. In fact, had I joined the military I'd have been a green beret (anyone whom knows much about them will also understand why I would therefore prefer urban combat, especially in a capital city).
🤔 . . . Urban Warfare. I’m actually pretty good at it, IRL…
Considering how I have lived in Urban cities, I am more familiar, I can protect myself from enemy combats and my chances to escape is much higher compared to open field combat . However, the chances of me dying is still high in Urban quarters because you never know who is the enemy because there is to many civilians around for you to pinpoint exactly who it is so you are constantly having to be in high alert but at the same time, it would be a nightmare for any attacker. I would prefer being the defender in a Urban field, not the attacker lol.
Where's the Niman and Vapaad videos?
They’re coming, just be patient
@@teleportedbreadfor3days Where?! Where have you been sending it?!
niman yey
Why was urban warfare a lot more brutal than mf's realise
The Darth plagues book suggests that there were many battles on munnilist . Or that after the clone wars is was no longer as beautiful as it one e was .i assume after the clone wars theu rebuild. But the separatists trying to reclaim it and its wealth makes sense
I wonder what Geetsly would think of Vraks.
The Senate was EVEN more brutal.
Urban, I'm more familiar with it.
For the republic.
Beautiful video!!!
Hm, interesting.
Imagine the Clone Wars (or Mandalorian Wars) version of the Ukraine war
About Ukraine, I'm thinking what Qui-Gon Jinn says: "There's no logic in this invasion".
3rd
Hey I know this is off topic but I’m trying to get into reading Star Wars comics but I don’t really know where to start, does anybody have any recommendations on where I can best read comics from, and what comic series is best to start with?
The recent Marvel Star Wars comic runs 2015 have been good. Main title Star Wars follows org trilogy heroes are good reading bunch of fine arcs esp when they fight elite stormtroopers special force unit. The Vader title is brutal and deep examination of Vader's activities post prequels full of Imperial politics and Sith intrigue. It is an award winning next level read if you are interested in Vader I would say essential. Enjoy!
@@TwilightParasites thank you so much, I’ll definitely read those.
*Stalingrad intensifies*