LIVE: Supreme Court hears Donald Trump immunity case
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 24 เม.ย. 2024
- Watch live as the Supreme Court hears arguments Thursday over whether Donald Trump is immune from prosecution in a case charging him with plotting to overturn the results of the 2020 presidential election.
#trump #scotus #supremecourt #trumpimmunity #2020presidentialelection #unitedstates #news #donaldtrump
I’m so ashamed that this is what’s become of our highest court.
Thanks to Trump.
Joy , exactly 💯 it's a complete Judiciary Injustice and DemonRats crooked system.👹🧐
@@pedropassament4299nice try Pedro
@@pedropassament4299it's the same it's always been. Our short term bias blinds
It’s not the court, it’s the attorneys who think they have a case. Nice try though.
If a president has complete immunity why bother with impeachment?
SCOTUS and attorneys speaking begins approx at 2:55:00 mark.
Why asking for immunity if you are innocent?…
Because the DC court is saying that regardless if it’s official acts he doesn’t have immunity
Why study for an exam if you are smart?
He is asking for immunity that is due as per law and presidence.
This is more about all future presidents than it is about Trump
Presidential immunity is what keeps our country from becoming a banana Republic. The president has to have immunity for actions taken for conduct or actions taken during their terms. This doesn't mean a president is free to do as they want, the constitution has the remedy for a president who commits a crime during his term. Impeachment and subsequent conviction in the Senate, this removes the president and after his conviction in the senate that immunity is now lost and he can be prosecuted for said crime.
Starts at 2:55:17
Don't expect the high court to uphold the law when comes to Mr trump maga judges will provide protection
3:50:00 KB Jackson nails it.
No, she didn't. When the defense responded, she changed questions. She didn't even challenge it. Go back an re-hear it. She is an intelligant judge and i admire her but she lost that engagement.
Due to what the world has observed, Trump as well as many of his enablers and the hate groups/individuals that he has ennobled and protected ought to have already been serving lengthy sentences. There have been far too many delays and some of the justice systems are plagued by Trump appointees/supporters who even as Trump commits or enables crime after crime would still not let their beliefs in him go. Sigh. ⚖
"[F]or his official acts ..". Since when is attempting to overthrow the government an "official act"? So isn't this "personal conduct"?
Challenging an election is not "attempting to overthrow the government", unless Donald Trump does it.🙄
This is what democracy is. Aren’t you things all about democracy?
And how did he do that?
3:04:25 sotomayor just described every politician in America. Reform the US GOVERNMENT!!!! it’s broken.
We can. Article V Convention of States
This is a positive sign that the scope of SCOTUS needs to be Constitutionally amended. We the People have no say over what happens in this court.
So that's the positive sign?
This isn't a democracy. The people only have rights to a certain extent. Do we really want a bunch of screaming college kids to dictate laws... exactly.
@marypettitt150
We have to vote Blue. Straight down the ticket so we can Impeach!
Redb it postively needs to be done.
what is impeachment? answer that and you will know why a president is not accountable to you, and is only accountable to congress. DUH so you have a problem with the constitution?
John Sauer's arguments remind me of George C. Scott as General Buck Turgidson in Dr. Strangelove, explaining to the President how nuclear weapons were being released without the President's authorization.
Perfect analogy. Dystopian.
Bro argued the president can give away our country
There are checks and balances. Congress has more power over our president than the courts. As it should be.
Thank you AP
what a joke. Trump is making this country the laughing stock. Be done with him already. Send him to jail.
Detestable that they actually considered this question.
I think of Kafka, Sauer is the example of a bureaucrat in its worst form
Associated Press, Subscribed because your videos are always awesome!
Time for Supreme Court Term Limits!!!
Gorsuch ended up being such a clutch supreme court justice pick.
If I had known about all of these scandals, I wouldn't have voted for tRump in 2016. But then, I'm not a magabilly and would never vote for the traitor anyway.
Glad to hear you know about it now.
If Trump had a personality of Obama or FDR, none of you hypocrites would care about the Court cases. Most agree that his First Term was great and Trumps 2nd. term will be even better. Its his personality. JFK, Democrat.
Most do not agree... Terrible president. He should not be Immune.
We are arguing if the president is king or not
What an embarrassment. Why is this foolishness even arguable? Trump has set a new low for this country. Just plain ridiculous and everyone knows it. Whether you are Republican or Democrat, this makes no sense.
So you think the government should create a situation where all future presidents can be blackmailed?
@@UnknownMoses let's give this immunity, it will apply to Biden. Let him be our dictator. Hope you enjoy what you wish for.
Can you imagine the direction our Country can go if we make the wrong turn in this determination! 🙏🏽
The spending out of control to win is crazy..
We are hurting so bad..
Trump you’re not making an impact with coming on with your commercials at the end of a media coverage on anything that concerns you you wasting your time and your money
Alito is nuts
Maybe, but he’s often correct
And how do we know you are sane? Hemade it yo the supreme court... you made it to YT to whine and cry. 😔😥😢😭😭
Go ahead SCOTUS. Give presidents unlimited powers above the rules.
Why does the first guy speaking sound like a robot.
So if the president is given advice to something being lawful, but it was later found that it was not legal, the president isn't liable, but the attorney general is?
I hope they give Trump absolute immunity. Cause Dark Brandon has work to do. First he needs to take out his political rivals and anyone who doesn't agree with his world and social views. There are six Supreme Court seats that also qualify for this action. There is also senators and representatives that quality for this action also. Even quality immunity based on what Trump's lawyer describes will give Dark Brandon the power to do all the above. Is that what they really want? Come on people we need a decision fast cause Dark Brandon has work to do.. Now do you really want this? And there is still so much more. Make sure the elections elect Dark Brandon's people for all seats and then Hand the Presidency over to his Vice President without an election. That doesn't sound like a Republic or Democracy. Why did the Supreme Court even take this up?
You don't understand what they're saying at all do you? Presidents have to have immunity for their official actions taken during their term. OFFICIAL is the key word here, arresting or killing political opposition or citizens who disagree with you isn't an official act. The constitution already has a means for addressing rogue presidents, and removing their immunity privileges. This would be impeachment, and subsequent conviction in the senate, this then can be prosecuted in court.
Audio cuts out at 4:25:00 or so… why?
If a policeman is performing an official act as in arresting someone, the policeman is subject to the law, if the arrestee dies in the process of the arrest. It could be due to a mistake or a crime that the arrestee dies in the process of the arrest. The policeman is STILL subject to the law and can go to prison as an ultimate result of performing an official act.
You cannot be greater than that which created you.
The man speaks have three vouces
Sociopaths should never be allowed on a ballot or in a government office
The lawyer from trump has a lot of gall talking about integrity and fear of factions
The attorneys dreaming up charges to prosecute a political opponent that they are afraid they can't beat is who has the "gaul"
@@stephendunn968 we all watched trump break the law and his co conspirators are all being prosecuted for it but somehow he walks free?
If Trump had a personality of Obama or FDR, none of you hypocrites would care about the Court cases. Most agree that his First Term was great and Trumps 2nd. term will be even better. Its his personality. JFK, Democrat.
Sad
5:25:13 can we be done then? This is a waste of tax dollars but then again, when is the US political system NOT wasting tax dollars??!
3:05:18 is Jackson not Kagan
I saw the same thing
3:44:28 fair point it does seem like a false dichotomy which slips the presupposition that the official acts vs private acts is what determines immunity.
Dosent she atomic get money from bond company??
I think the Democrats must to stop The GOP from baseless insults
Prosecutors wouldn't do it, unless you are talking about Trump's first term. Or Biden's first and the defendant was Trump.
I am glad the court took this case. The Supreme Court needs to define presidential immunity. It needs to be a matter of constitutional law or upheld case law rather than political whims.
We know from the Dobbs decision that established case law means nothing to SCOTUS. If they give Trump immunity, they will reverse their decision if Biden or any Democrat does something, then reverse themselves again when a Republic takes office.
I'm just here for all the whining and crying!!!! JUST SAVE SOME TEARS PEOPLE... NOVEMBER IS RIGHT AROUND THE CORNER!!!!!😂😂😂
Jackson BIG mad
Alito: "If the president gets advice from the attorney general, that something is lawful, is that an absolute defense?"
Dreeben: “yes”
Alito: “Wouldn’t the President just pick an AG who’ll let him do whatever he wants?”
Dreeben looked stunned
Apparently the AG can provide absolute immunity, but the President who is his boss can’t.
4:30:10 BINGO.
Shame on you, Trump.
These conservative justices need to stop interrupting Dreeben. RUDE!!
Really? Sotomayor does it more than anyone
Super could use a lozenger
Better be a king not the president
Why hasn't Thomas refused himself? He needs to be impeached. The only way to do it is to vote BLUE!
you mean recuse?
@@a.woodworth5182 🤦🏽♀️😂
What a clown - Michael Dreeben - what a joke this man is.
SCOTUS being involved with this is in itself a crime
If Trump had a personality of Obama or FDR, none of you hypocrites would care about the Court cases. Most agree that his First Term was great and Trumps 2nd. term will be even better. Its his personality. JFK, Democrat.
This isn't about personality. Never was. NOONE IS ABOVE THE LAW.
USA you guys are so young as a country...so funny to watch because you lot think you figured it all out.
🇺🇲UNION JOE✊️2024🇺🇲
Vote Blue for America, America!
🇺🇲BIDEN/HARRIS🦅2024🇺🇸
🇺🇲Liberal & Progressive Blue Wave too🇺🇲
The best ruling would be full immunity while in office and zero immunity after they leave office...
And hopefully impeachment and removal will actyally work
The Court would do well to consider the examples of public versus private acts of the executive discussed in Eric Foner's brilliant book The Second Founding.
Foner truly is brilliant. What's The Second Founding about ? I've only read his book on Reconstruction
All official acts are core acts.
They all got little Peckers in there?
Ketani youre gettingg on my nerves!!! Remember which side youre on!!!!!!!!! You are causing confusion!
I understood her well. Sorry if she goes over your head.
Why do judges have sides?
If that is the case .... where the hack does that leave the country? It is all just political
@@reallysomebody do you know what you can do with your words?
@@marylovemyname7910 I can't try to overturn an election with my words without being criminally prosecuted
This is so important for future presidents to come . This is not about Trump anymore .
Wow, Trump's lawyer is on fire. Great job quoting Benjamin Franklin!!
trumps lawyer is a joke 😂
@HUNDREDACREWOOD. okay, you are entitled to your opinion!!
Imagine thinking Trump is going to jail. LOL!
imagine thinking that he’s innocent of all of the 83 Federal Charges !
imagine thinking that he’s gonna be president again after 83 Federal Charges !
😂😂😂
Or Biden or his son!
@@HUNDREDACREWOOD.we will see how well this ages 🤣
Jackson is more an activist. She doesn’t understand much of the big picture. Nobody says the president can do anything. Notice her getting excited when she thought she had him.
The attorney for trump is saying exactly that.
You are pretending to be ignorant? That is EXACTLY what Sauer is arguing for tRump.
@@redbarchetta8782 what is he arguing, I’ll wait.
Trumps lawyer said exactly that in the first 15 minutes. He directly stated the president could order a hit on his opponent and it would be immune to prosecution. You should pay more attention to the facts.
Ketani youre fired!!!
Nah she’s gonna be there decades longer after Alito/Thomas die. 🎉
@@AdNauseamart She?
@@jourdinthedragon
yes, Ketanji Brown is a woman…
try to keep up.
No, YOURE fired, genius.
@@HUNDREDACREWOOD. What is a woman? Ketanji couldn't answer that so how am I supposed to know?
Sotomayor had to rescue Alito. 7:14. Sauer has a great memory, but needs lozenges.
He seemed to stump some judges.
The lefty judges just wanted to manufacture a way to deny the appeal with their “hypotheticals”.
Sauer for SCOTUS.
SCOTUS, "T R U M P 2 0 2 4 !!!"
President Trump 2024!
YOURE KIDDING YOURSELF 😂
Jackson doesn't even know what a woman is... NO WONDER SHE'S CONFUSED 😂😂😂😂😂😂