You Won’t Believe How Obvious This Mistake in the Quran Is 😳
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- 🤩 Contribute to the channel: / friendlyexmuslim
🥰 Other ways to support: friendlyexmusli...
Other interesting videos:
► The great sacrifice of Eid • The great sacrifice of...
► Hajj, where people go to die • Hajj, where people go ...
► What you need to know before converting to Islam • What you need to know ...
► Debunking "Islam is a Feminist Religion" • Debunking "Islam is a ...
My articles:
► Debunking “The One True Islam” Fallacy / the-one-true-islam-fal...
► Muhammad’s false prophecies / muhammads-false-prophe...
Follow me at:
► Twitter: / abdullahadam
► Facebook: / abdullah.sameer.71
Mistakes in the Quran almost never cuts any ice with beievers or cause them to doubt their faith . Because they are told to believe there are no "mistakes" in the Quran, only our mistaken understanding of them . Because Allah is right even when he is "wrong" , as He is above and beyond the comprehension of ordinary human reason and rationality ! And it is very hard for critics to counter such circular logic . 😄
I mean why can't you people actually show where the mistakes are instead of just loudly shouting there are mistakes like autistic morons?
Fun fact. Muhammad was illiterate so he never knew if the stories he had heard ORALLY from others around him had come from the Bible or from apocryphal stories and pseudo-gospels circulating at the time. He sometimes made mistakes in the re-telling. One of his scribes, Abdullah b Sa'd, realised what Muhammad was up to and fled to Mecca saying 'If Muhammad is a prophet I'm half a prophet!' That is why Muhammad had Abdullah's name on a death list when he conquered Mecca. 😁
its more logical than people thinking there is nothing in the hereafter. U can imagine a life after death but you cant possibly imagine nothingness yet they believe they will turn into nothing. very logical indeed 🤣
@@fudayl4380 Sorry, bro. But it is far more 'logical' and 'realistic' not to believe in a life after death. You have seen dead animals, haven't you? There is no afterlife of hell or heaven for them, is there? We love and grieve for our pet cats and dogs, but we don't seriously think they are being punished or rewarded for ever, do we? We tell our kids that Fido has gone to 'doggie heaven' but we don't believe it, do we? 😁
@@davidzack8735 so that's why there is difference between humans and animals
950 years of preaching and yet couldn't even convince his wife and one of his sons. That's pretty poor results.
You're too old to be this stupid.
😅😂😂
Do you think it is easy to convince people??......... Samson(Al Ghazi in Islam) had ZERO follower!!(infact his own wife betrayed him).......... Another best example this "friendly exmuslim" channel!!, The best mistake he can find is about "age" of Noah!!......…. HE "BELIEVE" NOBODY CAN LIVE THAT LONG!!!, Who give a f**k what he BELIEVES!!....... I give you a clue how to find mistake!!...….. eg. In BIBLE mentioned that THE FLOOD covered the entire EARTH and the only humans was "NOAH AND HIS 3 SONS" (Think, how 4 men can reproduced??)........ USE YOUR CRITICAL THINKING, NOT YOUR EMOTIONAL.
Hasan, could you please briefly refute the "prophecies" of the hadiths that the Euphrates will dry up, there will be green meadows, rains, rivers, etc. in Arabia? Muslims refer to them, claiming that the Euphrates dries up and completely dries up (according to researchers) before 2040. Those. after 18-20 years. If you write an article on your blog in a medium, it will be even better. Thank you. I respect you almost like an uncle, you are a very smart and intelligent person.
@@jakakejeb your mom runs dry
Imagine if Tolkien’s works became a religion.
You clearly haven't played D&D
@@svensvenforkedbeard170 Actually I’m not ashamed I was a DM back in college, also if you can comprehend what I’m trying to convey with my comment.
Sameer keep telling people about how wrong the Quran is and watch how some people will be guided through your claims.
lol
@@FriendlyExmuslimSameer u left Islam and still obsessed with it …😂😂.Love or hate Islam but you can’t ignore it..asshole 😂
If you are so convinced he’s guiding people to Islam, please share and repost his videos everywhere.
Christians and Jews believe that theses ages are of honor and not literally there age
Most obivous mistakes in quran is that it is writen in it that its a clear book ,sent down in detail and explenation of everything which is contradicted by the verse which says that some verses are unclear and the fact that there are tafsirs needed in order to explain the verses of quran as well as hadiths to put it into historical context show quran to be a lie,also even tafsirs and hadithjs do not agree with each other on the explenation and the historical context .Another mistake is the verse which states "today i have perfected your religion for you " which would mean that quran is complete and finished nothing is added to it and that verse is that last verse but according to every scholar that was not the last verse of quran and other surahs were added after that verse ,that again shows quran to be a lie....
For Believing Muslims,
Please learn the origins of the fictional Abrahamic god. It all goes back to the fictional Canaanite god El. Also, keep in mind that the Israelites were worshipping this fictional god centuries before Islam came along.
*El, Yahweh, or Jehovah*
Christianity and Islam originated in the Middle East. Any Christian in this area when asked about the Name of God, he will say Allah!
The English Bible starts with:
"In the beginning God created the heaven and Earth."
And the Arabic Bible starts with:
"In the beginning Allah created the heaven and Earth."
The western Christians are unaware of the Name of God of their eastern brothers. Some Christians think that Allah is the idol that the Islamic cult worships! The Office for the Non-Christian Affairs at the Vatican published a document under the title "Orientations for a Dialogue between Christians and Muslims. It is a very important document in that it shows the new position adopted towards Islam. In the third edition of this study (1970), the document stresses this fundamental point in the following terms:
"It would seem pointless to maintain that Allah is not real God, as do certain people in the west!" The Conciliatory document has put the above assertion in its proper place. There is no better way of illustrating Islamic faith in God than by quoting the following extracts from Lumen Gentium, produced by the second Vatican Council (1962-1965):
"The Muslims profess the faith of Abraham and worship with us the sole merciful God, who is the future judge of men on the Day of Reckoning."
Google *"His Name is Allah, History of Truth"*
(The fictional Canaanite god El that the Israelite patriarchs worshipped, later conflated with Yahweh, is the same fictional god of the Muslims)
Watch Professor Christine Hayes who lectures on the Hebrew Bible at Yale University. Watch lecture 7 from 30:00 minutes onwards, lecture 8 from 12:00 to 17:30 minutes and lecture 12 from 34:30 minutes onwards.
Watch *"Pagan Origins of Judaism"* by Sigalius Myricantur and read the description in the video to see the scholarship the video is based on.
Watch *"How Monotheism Evolved"* by Sigalius Myricantur and watch up to at least 21:40.
Watch *"Atheism - A History of God (The Polytheistic Origins of Christianity and Judaism)"*
(By a former theist)
Watch *"The Origins of Yahweh"* by Derreck Bennett at Atheologica.
------------------------------------------------------------------
Also look up the below articles:
*"Jews and Arabs Descended from Canaanites - Biblical Archaeology Society."*
("The study in Cell not only establishes that the ancient Israelites were ***descended from the Canaanites,*** but also establishes that the Canaanite people across the separate city-states of the southern Levant, and over a period of 1,500 years, were a genetically cohesive people.")
*"The Canaanites weren't annihilated, they just 'moved' to Lebanon - The Times of Israel."*
(A UK-based study of ancient genomes finds ***Canaanites form over 90% of modern Lebanese ancestry, a trait they share with ancient Israelites)***
*"Canaanite Religion - New World Encyclopaedia."*
(Read about Canaanite religion and El the chief or most high god of the Canaanite pantheon and the relationship of Canaanite religion to Israelite religion)
*"Ancient Canaanite religion explained - **everything.explained.today**"*
*"Archeology of the Hebrew Bible - NOVA - PBS"*
("Many scholars now think that *most of the early Israelites were originally Canaanites, displaced Canaanites,* displaced from the lowlands, from the river valleys, displaced geographically and then displaced ideologically.")
*"Origins of Judaism explained - **everything.explained.today**"*
("According to the current academic historical view, the origins of Judaism lie in the Bronze Age amidst polytheistic ancient Semitic religions, ***specifically evolving out of Ancient Canaanite polytheism,*** then co-existing with Babylonian religion, and syncretizing elements of Babylonian belief into the worship of Yahweh as reflected in the early prophetic books of the Hebrew Bible. (The Torah)".
*Refer to the bibliography at the bottom of the page)*
*"Canaanite languages - Britannica"*
("Group of Northern Central or Northwestern Semitic languages including ***Hebrew,*** Moabite, Phoenician, and Punic.")
*"Polytheism and Ancient Israel’s Canaanite Heritage. Part V - theyellowdart"*
("Of course, much of this [i.e., that Israel worshiped El and Asherah alongside YHWH] is really to be expected given that recent syntheses of the archaeological, cultural, and literary data pertaining to the emergence of the nation of Israel in the Levant show that *most of the people who would eventually compose this group were originally Canaanite.")*
*"El - New World Encyclopedia"*
(Refer to the section "El Outside the Bible" and the fact that *most of the ancient Israelites were originally indigenous or displaced Canaanites)*
*"El (deity) explained - **everything.explained.today**"*
(Refer to section "Ugarit and the Levant" and the fact that *most of the ancient Israelites were originally indigenous or displaced Canaanites* and see how El, later conflated with Yahweh (Yahweh-El(ohim)) is fictional)
*"The Gods and Goddesses of Canaan - Essay - The Metropolitan Museum of Art - Heilbrunn Timeline of Art History"*
*"In spite of their differences, Jews, Christians and Muslims worship the same God - The Conversation"*
*"6 Ways The Quran Has A Lot In Common With The Bible - All That's Interesting"*
*"Walking by Moonlight: My Journey Out of Islam - The Ex-Muslim"*
*"Why Islam is False - Atheist Republic"*
*"Rebuttal to Shabir Ally : Its True! The Quran Borrowed Stories From Preexisting Sources"*
*"Scientific Errors in the Quran - WikiIslam"*
Thank you for the in-depth reply and sources 🙏
"And We certainly sent Noah to his people,............., and the flood seized them while they were wrongdoers." from this Sura we can conclude that Noah is a wrongdoer !!🤫
Stop changing thd original meaning. I know you did it cause theres no location of it. People like you is the reason why the bible is changed, you so dirty with everything. Keep that dirt to yourself.
what a brain you've got! unbelievable!😐
You are absolutely right. I am ex muslim. Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩
Cool man :)
Because you want it to be true. Its a lie and a disappointment for you.
@@mhmd_old7 To whom are you responding? 🙄
Noah obviously never existed. If he lived for 950 years and never succeeded in convincing his people for centuries, then he must be a terrible Prophet.
Great video, as always, but the question I keep asking myself, is, after the flood that covered the earth (25 cubits, hardly enough to cover all the mountains) where did that water go?
As stated in the Qur'an, the water was absorbed into Earth , which has near infinite capacity for holding water.
@@hassanjamal4212 Why are there water on earth now, surely it should all be absorbed into the earth already given its 'infinite capacity'. There should not be any oceans too by this logic
@@knossostellel-amarna8502 what are you talking about moron? oceans are part of a different system to groundwater and aquifers . Seriously you people are hopelessly retarded .
@@hassanjamal4212 Near infinite???? Near infinite?????
My topology professor would puke blood at that statement.
As the water came out of an oven, according to the Quran, surely it could just go back in? This is the kind of nonsense you get when you start mixing myths with reality. 😁
There's no way anyone living 1000 years ago, or 10.000 years ago, would be able to reach the very old age of 122: Jeanne Calment (21 February 1875 - 4 August 1997). There have been people in the 18 century who lived to be 100 (I have a facsimile of very old news paper dating back to the late 18th century, reporting about a female who died at the 'blessed age' of 100), but that's extremely rare: most rich people of that time would not live past the age of 70, with most poor people not living past age 45.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_verified_oldest_people
@Christianity and Islam Have NOTHING In Common! It's true because 'The bible says so'? Sorry, but blind faith doesn't count as evidence 😂
@Christianity and Islam Have NOTHING In Common! Genesis 6:3 _"Then the Lord said, “My Spirit shall not abide in[a] man forever, for he is flesh: his days shall be 120 years.”_
Is the maximum age your non-existent god allowed mankind to reach, but Jeanne Calment, who lived to the age of 122, has proven your god wrong 😌
@Christianity and Islam Have NOTHING In Common! Scientists base their conclusions on whatever is being measured (test results), not on whatever some ancient book full of fairy tales is saying: that's a big difference 😂
@Christianity and Islam Have NOTHING In Common! *Quote:* _"If you had used your science- given eyes well, you would have seen where I wrote "average maximum age"_
Isn't god supposed to mean anything excactly as he says it? Which means that god doesn't deal in 'avarages', only absolutes: thou shallest not live beyond 120 years! End of discussion! (else he would break his own word).
*Quote:* _"Noah found grace" "_
That verse can be interpreted in any way you want 😅
@Christianity and Islam Have NOTHING In Common! Enough with the fundamentalistic rant. I don't care for your misrepresentation of Science 😌
Pretty sure the Bible says Noah was 950 years old because in his days they counted a month as a whole year. If you account for that, Noah was 79. 950/12.
I think Mohammad and the Quran say it because they don’t understand the Bible they got it from. Lol.
Do you have a link that explains this?
The Bible doesn't give any explanation of the 950 years figure. There are several different ways that Christians understand the passage that gives the ages of Noah and the various pre-flood characters in his lineage
One is the Young Earth Creationist view that these are literal ages in years, and that reduced human lifespan over that period, and afterwards, is a knock-on effect of the fall. Obviously this view presupposes a world that's quite different in a number of ways to what mainstream science tells us.
One is the one you give that the ages are months, rather than years - though this does mean some of these characters had kids at a very young age.
One is that these are the lifespans of clans named after these individuals, rather than the ages of the individuals themselves.
One is that these numbers are intended to be symbolic, and perhaps have some similar origin to the Sumerian Kings' List, which lists pre-flood kings who reigned for thousands of years.
Personally I lean towards the clans explanation.
Islam is unable to stand on its own. It’s why Muslims constantly refer to the Holy Bible because they know the Bible has validity. They wouldn’t refer to it if they truly believed it was corrupt, as they claim.
@@FriendlyExmuslim well, there are different views. But many, many folks don’t take it so literally. That’s my point.
We know men wrote the Bible, inspired by God. They did so in their own contexts. If that’s how they counted years, that’s how they would have written it. The context of the authors and when it was written matters to reading the Bible. People who take it so literally make a mistake. When and where it was written matters for the correct understanding. From what I understand, this distinction isn’t possible with the Quran?
Omg! Then aisha was 72 years old when she married pdfet. Right?
I'm still waiting for confirmation of a pair of penguins walking from Antarctica to the middle East.
The page where it says "He should not be preoccupied with the details of history which the revelation did not highlight or explain, and for which there is no sound proof or Shar'i evidence." that is SO painful to read. I understand the preceding point where it wants you to see the big picture in the lessons, but then we go STRAIGHT INTO just completely discouraging critical thought. That is the same thing as sitting your brain on the couch and feeding it junk food.
People in the comments are saying this isnt actually refering to years as in the one we use, but to moon cycles. So say 900 full lunar cycles will be around 75 years if a single year has 12 moon cycles. Then it no longer becomes an issue with the story being too unrealistic to be true, but rather that it's something that has been lost in translation.
For the real Noah look up Utanapishtim.
Quran author copy paste mistake.
Utnapishtim in the Epic of Gilgamesh is a very different character from Noah in Genesis. The stories share a very vague outline (God/the gods decide to flood the earth - for very different reasons - and somebody avoids being drowned by building a boat). Apart from this broad outline the stories have virtually nothing in common. Whilst it's plausible that both stories were ultimately developed from a common origin, it's extremely implausible that one of them was an adaptation of the other. Mohammed's version was obviously based on what he'd heard about the Biblical story, since the Epic of Gilgamesh had been forgotten for at least a millennium (and possibly two) before he lived.
Ancient people thought history was in a long decline from paradise when people lived much longer.
TAQIYYA is Islam way of life what else you ask them about Aisha is like looking for a missing puzzle kept in jannah by jubril
love you sameer, too calm as lex fridman.❤❤❤
The muzzles also say he was like 100 ft tall or something
*Matthew 26:39 "Going a little farther, Jesus FELL ON HIS FACE and prayed."*
_>Jesus prayed like Muslims. If Jesus is God, why pray/talk to himself?_
*Psalms 22:1 Jesus says: "MY GOD, why have You forsaken Me?*
_>If Jesus is God, how can he have a God?_
*Mark 10:18: "Why call me good?” Jesus said. “No one is good-EXCEPT GOD alone."*
_>Jesus separates himself from God, says only God is good._
*Bible promotes slavery:* Leviticus 25:44-46 "You may buy of the residents among you... they will become your property... you can make them slaves for life."
_>Would God promote slavery?_
*Quran ends slavery:* Quran 90:12-13 "What may let you know the path of righteousness? It is to free a slave."
_>Or would God promote ending slavery?_
*Bible has 100+ contradictions:* Matthew 1:16 "Jacob begot Joseph" - Luke 3:23 "Joseph, son of Heli"
_>Is Joseph the son of Heli or Jacob? Clearly corrupted._
_>Would God send a book of contradictions corrupted by humans? Or one still in its original language and preserved/memorized since revelation (Quran)?_
*>Worship the creator, not the creation! Open your heart, humble yourself to the truth: Islam :)*
Quran 2:255 “God! There is no god but He, the ever-living, all-sustaining. No slumber nor sleep seizes Him. To Him belongs all that is in the heavens and on earth. Who can possibly intercede with Him without His permission? He ˹fully˺ knows ˹everything presently˺ ahead of them and what is before them, but no one can encompass any of His knowledge-except what He wills ˹to reveal˺. His throne extends over the heavens and the earth, and their preservation fatigues Him not. For He is the Most High, the Supreme ˹in glory˺.”
Quran 112:1-4 "Say: He is God, the One and Only; God, the Eternal, Absolute; He begets not, nor is He begotten; And there is nothing comparable to Him."
~Share this if you like :)
34151
Wow. This is serious garbage. Tell me, what did Thomas say to Jesus in John 20:28?
Why did the disciples worship Jesus in Luke 24:52?
Why did Jesus claim that Allah was his Father in John 5?
How could he claim in John 5 that he does everything that Allah does?
Should I go on?
Bro historians cant even agree on an explanation for how the pyramids were built...but you dont deny that they exist, because you can see them with your own eyes. Point being that living your life denying the possibility of anything outside of your own personal experience seems pretty arrogant to me 😂 just my two cents
If Kerala Namboodiris Brahman created RIGHT to LEFT Hebrew, then who created Arabic?
The answer is the same Kerala Namboodiris !
Pythagoras and Plato studied in Kodungallur University of Kerala. Same way several Persian scholars studied Math in Kerala before Jesus was born.
Arabic language was created by Kerala Namboodiris. Their numerals are called Hindu-Arabic even today.
The Persian Mathematician Muhammad ibn Musa al-Khwarizmi studied in Kodungallur University in Kerala.
Fibonacci took his Arabic works to Italy from Bejaya , Algeria.
ALGEBRA is derived from Al-Jabr, one of the two operations he used to solve quadratic equations. Algorism and algorithm stem from Algoritmi, the Latin form of his name.
Al-Biruni was a Sanskrit scholar who learnt Math and astronomy in from Namboodiri professors adept in Sanskrit and Arabic .
While others were killing each other over religious differences, Al-Biruni had a remarkable ability to engage Hindus in peaceful dialogue. Mohammad Yasin puts this dramatically when he says, “The Indica is like a magic island of quiet, impartial research in the midst of a world of clashing swords, burning towns, and burned temples.” (Indica is another name for Al-Biruni’s history of India). (Yasin, 1975, p. 212
ANCIENT ARABS AND GREEKS DO NOT HAVE A SINGLE INVENTION OR DISCOVERY repeat NOT A SINGLE INVENTION OR DISCOVERY , WHICH IS NOT STOLEN FROM INDIA .. . THE GREEK AND ARABIC TRANSLATIONS WERE DONE IN KERALA KODUNGALLUR UNIVERSITY.
Also, given inflation, you would need to be a billionaire to afford 50 years in a good nursing home.
😂
Just because nobody ever lived to 950 years doesn't mean it's impossible. But that still doesn't mean allah and everything the quran says is true either
Maybe there is the possibility that he was a vampire
What is your point , he lived a long life and was a man of God on a mission , so this ex Muslim dude is putting content of no real significance ,....
Bible says that Jesus was crucified and the Quan says that he was not, it was made to appear. According to Islam Jesus (Prophet Isa) is still alive. Why Bible and Quran differed? My explanation is that so that the Christians can not claim that Quran was copied from the Bible.
nonsense
@@esbenm6544 Bring the proof from the Bible and the Quran and see for yourself how they differ with regard to whether or not Jesus was crucified. Quran contains some scientific facts which were unknown during the time of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). What scientific proofs are found in the Bible?
#prophetnuh
You are practically saying that god, couldn’t make any of his servants to live 950 years, bro bro at least have a real religion that makes sense to debate anything your hindu religion have literally 33 million gods or it doesn’t matter the number, we muslims have one god, you worship deities and some of them have a head of animals, god can do anything and for the sake of the argument, not just noah lived for 950 years in islam we believe that god when hd created Adam, Adam lived for much much longer than Noah and since that time the age of humans decreased gradually. There’s nothing to not believe, that’s not a mistake at all, you are just digging in a dirty mud
😂 this is a very weak argument.
If God wills, then a person can live a long life.
It's logical ie no contradiction.
But can something come from nothing?
This is unbelievable to me.
Something coming from nothing is logic of god.
Who says something come out of noting??? Aother strawman
You are even assuming that "noting" exist
No evidence for God
Also what God Made from. Can mind and personality exist without any object (like brain) ??
You say something can not come out of noting (Abdullah Sameer never said that anyway)
But we also never saw personality and mind existing without brain (or an complex object like brain)
Dude.....Noah is a fictional character. That's the good thing about make believe characters. You get to make believe how long they lived.
So obsessed he is if you left islam what is it that u are doing you wanna make sure that u are not wrong
This is from my biased individual perspective while being Catholic;
In Judeo-Christianity, sin brought death into the world. We forfeited eternal life by not trusting God. Genesis shows that every successive generation had less years of life, as their distance from eternal life increased.
You make the modeling references, which i don’t refute. Judeo-Christians would counter and say that there was no disease, injury, stress back then bc we had not fallen yet, and were sustained by God’s Spirit in a unique way that we don’t have access to currently.
Even with Judeo-Christianity, one doesn’t necessarily have to believe that that section of Genesis is literal, as it could be primarily in nature symbolic.
No such thing as Judeo-Christianity - just Christianity. Rabinnic Jews rejected the Messiah, and follow Satan.
the story is parabolic : simply says that as long as you are in a state of fear and not defend respects loves the one who stands next to you (Adam Eve) you cannot have eternal bliss, Jesus took it to the limit saying that this is also apply for your enemy...
this is the real fall , yours mine everyone, incarnating on earth again and again ,until we learn to love ourselves same as the others ....
Not a muslim, but the ages are symbolic. Check out Inspiringphilosophy's video on that topic. I think he makes a good case that these numbers have a hidden meaning and are not meant to be understood literally.
Well isn't that convenient
@@TheMagnificentGman I'm not affiliated with any of the Abrahamic religions - I don't even consider myself spiritual. I just think he makes a very good case for the symbolic interpretation of the ages. How about actually engaging with the argument before commenting? But no I guess that's too much to ask for...
I've heard this argument where theists were nailed by that silly claim of how earth was made in 6 days (or was it 8?)...
And the apologists are like: those are "G0D Y3AR5" which can be any amount of years as long as it agrees with today's scientific consensus.
Now....... an almighty, all-poweful God, of INFINITE Wisdom and Knowledge and Intellect........... was so dumb to use HIS measurement of "time" (how does a timeless being has his own measurement of time!?) and FAIL to CONVERT it to Mortal human years.
Yeah, no. Man-made stuff. An intelligent God would have known better. If this intelligent divine being really does exist, then these scriptures are an INSULT to him.
@@IvanSensei88 That's not the argument, though; more like a strawman version that clearly shows nothing but ignorance. Hell, not even that. Lol. Oh well - fundamentalist theists and fundamentalist atheists are two sides of the same dogmatic coin, I suppose.
@@noname19816 Well there's another issue with this.
If God says I have created earth in 6 days... but then those ages/days are just symbolic... then God pretty much gave humans an utterly useless piece of information...
He may as well have said "I have bananamangled the earth in 6 tesseractinos"
#ProphetNoah
Humans used to live longer in ancient days of the Adams, Noahs, etc. Thereafter, God decreases human lifespan. In modern days, not many human life goes beyond 120 years. Islam narrations are faretales and false as usual.
i pity u. human was always in wasting except those who believe and worship Allah. You cannot interpret al quran on your own. among those friends of Mohamad, only 18 of them can translate the meaning of al quran. These people are pious people. to study al quran u need to understand the translation or tafsir. scholar spend tenths of years for this and u only suddenly reads and mentioned those that u said wrong is somewhat embarassment to yourself
"it's just not possible, we have fossils" - are you aware of young earth creationism? You should look it up. Miracles, divine intervention, denial of all the evidence. This is all normal for them. No surprise that Muslims can be just as committed to their beliefs as the young earth creationists in the Christian community. I'm surprised you think this is enough to debunk Islam. Any believer can explain this away.
so we gotta point out absurdity of it.
if u dont believe in empirical evidence then u cant argue for historicity of religious beliefs which they all do all the time
@@whydontyoustfu it's not really arguing though, it's more that they just insist it's historical because Allah said so in his book. And how do we know that? Because Allah said so in his book. And how do we know that?.....
Yes, point out the absurdities, but honestly after clicking this title expectantly, this was a real disappointment. Most Christians, and I assume most Muslims, have already rationalised this to themselves. God is a big miracle guy in the sky to them, so of course he can make people live longer, if he can split the moon or make the sun stay in the sky for three days straight etc.
Your voice is so smoothing, almost angelic ❤
Wow, thank you!
950 moon
Besides, as a Muslim, didn't you hear the prophet (SAW) say "my ummah will will live around 70 years" - the point is, even though the life is less, the reward we earn is the same.
Is the claim only noah lived 1000 years or generally people in noah time lived that long?
*The age of a prophet is the life span of his religion, the verse says 'he remained among them' for 950 yrs not his age was 950,it means that the time from Noah to the Prophet Ibrahim, who opened a new age, was 950 yrs*
You're absolutly wrong . There's no even single one verse in the holy book of Qur'an that 's wrong or mistake . You must learn more about Islamic teaching .I do not believe that you' re Ex but Fake.
"So ask them ˹O Prophet˺, which is harder to create: them or other marvels of Our creation?1 Indeed, We created them from a sticky clay" Quran 37:11
Humans are made from clay? Very scientific religion mashallah!!!!!
All supernatural claims are bullshit that violates physics and biology
We never see physics violated today and no reason to assume that it happened in the past
@@killermoon635 It seems miracles stopped happening the day we invented the camera
Another
Jobless person who earn by ex-muslim title 😂😂
Why this topic. Quran by itself is a blunder.
Isn't this topic discussing a part of the qur'an that makes it a blunder? 😁
We are helping people see how religion does not make sense outside of itself.
Christianity and Islam are two sides of the same coin
Christianity is much better, tbh..
I am not a christian but I have read both the Quran and Bibles.. Quran is a joke
To an extend, yes.
Very much.
I mean, Mohammed plagiarized most of what he heard about the bible and put an islamic, more ignorant twist on it, with no regard to actual context or intended meaning. More than two faces of the same coin, I'd say islam is a bafflingly stupid bastardization of Christianity. I'm not religious, but this has seemed to be the case many times over.
Not at all. Christianity came with forgiveness. Islam came with duties.
Noah is actually a plant, some trees actually have a verified 1000 years lifespan. This book predicted evolution being a scientific fact. Amazing !
Adam was said to be larger than dinosaurs, so you have something here...
So Attack on Titan was real...
Therefore Isayama is a prophet!
Hes not a plant. He was a prophet of Islam, if you got nothing nice to say, then dont say it.
@@mhmd_old7 I've spent a significant part of my life looking for answers to my questions and concerns in the holy books of Islam, including hadith like every good "سنّي مالكي" would do. So I'm fully aware of Noah's story. He's also one of the main characters in Judeo-Christian literature, awesome guy. Anyway, what do you mean by "nice"?
@@mhmd_old7 just following how in the quran, allah calls kafirs the worst of creation. The largest chapter, surah al-kafirun on how disbelievers will be tortured in jahanam for eternity. So if you have nothing nice to say, just follow the qurans example & go all out
Replace “years” with “moon cycle” and it all makes a lot more sense.
Ha ha, he probably looked like an Egyptian mummy walking around - like the dude in the movie The Mummy!
😂 😂 😂
I like watching your vids for the calm. There's not that hectic feeling of urgency with you.
I also like what you have to say.
Thanks for this video. I just wanted to say that the killing of the four Muslim gentlemen in Albuquerque, NM is horrible. If this or these are hate crimes then I condemn those actions. I hope the perpetrators of those crimes (and any crime) are caught and brought to justice.
I don't know WTF is going on in Albuquerque for that to happen but they'd better get it straightened out..........
@Hannah did you even read what the OP said? Muslims were slaughtered, they are DEAD. They wouldn't be the ones charged tried or sentenced.
How is it a hate crime when another Muslim killed them?
@@msid7748 well the guys name only came out today, and we don’t know his motivation yet. It’s possible that he isn’t a Muslim, just because his name is Muhammad doesn’t mean he is a Muslim. I also think some people were originally assuming the other guy in Albuquerque who tried to kill a Hispanic man was responsible for this (although me personally knowing a lot of details about both cases I didn’t assume this because the cars don’t match). And you know, we aren’t 100% sure this guy actually did it yet, he just drives the same car and they think his weapons might match, it might turn out to not be him.
You also can’t blame people for assuming this type of stuff when we have an unfortunately large number of people in this country who openly talk about how they want to kill Muslims.
@Hannah “do not behave like muslims” lol are you really saying that? Most Muslims are lovely people, especially here in America where more Muslims support LGBT rights for examples than Conservative Evangelical Christians in states like my state Arkansas. You know most people don’t take their religions that seriously unless they are fundamentalists, the problem with religion arises when people take all of this stuff literally and try to apply obviously ancient customs and morals to the modern day. But you know religion can be good for some people too. There is a quote by Karl Marx that is often misinterpreted by his critics and followers a like “religion is the opiate of the people, (here is the part usually left out) the SIGH of the oppressed” essentially what this quote is saying is people turn to religion because they have hard lives and need something bigger than themselves that makes them feel safe to believe in. That’s part of why I became a Muslim. I don’t even read the Quran, I still eat pork and I drink beer occasionally, but I pray now and listen to a dude who sings the Quran (in Arabic which I don’t speak) on my computer because it makes me feel better, and I try to be good to people and be honest, that’s all there is to it. And to be even more honest a large part of why I became a Muslim is so my future wife can go visit her parents back in Iran when we marry, her parents don’t care what religion I am but their government does.
Btw I basically agree with this video, this story is obviously made up, I thought that when I was a Christian and when I was an atheist too. No one should really be surprised that a myth from ancient Sumeria is in the Abrahamic religions if they know history. It’s weird little myth like every culture has, many Americans don’t recognize what some of our own myths are yet.
Mr. Sameer how is your voice so calming I'm gonna fail the second session of an exam tomorrow but i feel at peace 🕊️
Nope, I prefer listening to Sam Gerrans
Sameer is just sure of what he is saying, such a person is calm in presenting his arguments.
Allah gave him superior ability to live that long 😏 say Mashallah 🤩😂😂😂 شي عجيب
He slayed the virgin Mary concept as well.
Something that baffles me is how the legendary stories of Dhulkhanain and 7 sleepers became divine revelations in Islam ☪️
@@iribilangbosahayy7158 Yes, funny and sad at the same time
Also the Creator of the Universe seems to think his Sun which he apparently created to Orbit around the Milky Way Galaxy.... has a stopping point, a rising PLACE, and a setting PLACE... and when it sets (even though it's ALWAYS rising AND setting at the same time at different parts of the earth), needs to prostrate to him and ask for permission to rise again... like what the actual ****
So Attack on Titan was real...
Therefore Isayama is a prophet!
Why does the sun have to ask permission to rise since the day-night alternation is due to the rotation of the Earth on itself? The God of the Universe should have taught us that it is the Earth who must ask God to continue to turn on itself instead. And continuously since this is how the sun rises on the globe.
@@peacefullypeaceful3120 They don't ask crap, they just do, they have no mouths, they are just fusion reactors running pn physical laws, lmao.
950 years of efforts and still failed..
His message of Islam got through. Islam is the fastest growing religion and will be at above christianity by 2050 or smh
@@mhmd_old7 amen to that ...lol
@@mhmd_old7 Fastest collapsing by apostasy rates, growth only by birth & that slowing
Prophets job is only to convey the message and he did a wonderful job at that. People accepting the message or not isn't the concern.
@@asifanwar2057then why Allah ordered the prophet to fight with Meccans? If you say prophet job is so simple.
Surah toba how did they treat mushriks to spread islam through sword
who said that noah was a human ?!! hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
Quran full of fairy tales.
I am a muslim from Malaysia but now no more bye bye Islam
Noah drank too much wine🍷🧙♂️🍾😂 to live that long
@angelmakersweetrolls Noah's teeth fell out shortly after being on Ark because they forgot to bring Toothbrushes and Toothpaste. Toilet paper was also scarce 🤤🧙♂️👍
Shut up. He was a great guy
He built a ship as huge as uss Carl Vinson. 😄
Just kidding, dude haha
Brilliant Sameer , u found the mistake that Muslims were looking for . Brilliant
😂
(1). For some people such a long life is inconceivable.
(2). But in this world of God, strange happenings are not rare. Wherever one may look, one will see extraordinary manifestations of His power.
(3). The occurrence of certain events and things in a usual form and manner is no proof that the event or thing cannot happen in an unusual and extraordinary way. To break these assumptions, there exists a long list of unusual events and things that have taken place in every kind of creation in every part of the universe.
(4). In particular, the person who has a clear concept of God’s being All- Powerful, cannot be involved in the misunderstanding that it is not possible for God, Who is the Creator of life and death, to grant a life of a thousand years or so to any man. The fact is that man of his own will and wish cannot live even for a moment, but if Allah wills, He can make him live for as long as He pleases.
@@sethsuleiman4419 Please present examples we can verify with scientific examination.
@@HeLpLOstGOdAny1 Quran 29:14 says noah preached for 950 years. Noah's such age is unconceivable and yes, it has not been scientifically proven yet.
Quran 10:92 says pharaoh's drowned body will preserved. Yes, this has been scientifically proven. As a starter, this 4min youtube video could be useful
th-cam.com/video/HT3HgSmF1lo/w-d-xo.html
Yeah, the Noah story is the stamp of approval that the Quran is the work of human beings!
Lol, well clicked on the video even tho I dislike paid trolls as yourself, however I was not disappointed. As always the anti-Islam side brings up something that is hard to belive and calls it nonfactual...
There are no contradictions in the word of the Almighty.
If there were you would be the first to boast about it, but since you don't even you have to admit that there are none...
Peace!
Who is paying him?
If there are no contradictions, how do you explain Quran 37:11? Humans are made from clay?
"So ask them ˹O Prophet˺, which is harder to create: them or other marvels of Our creation?1 Indeed, We created them from a sticky clay"
@@msid7748 Where is the contradiction there?
Here are some definitions of contradiction:
1) "to assert the contrary of."
2) "a combination of statements, ideas, or features which are opposed to one another."
3) "the statement of a position opposite to one already made."
Here is one example:
"I was born in New York, Germany."
Now go ahead and try to find one in the Quran.
@@tally3018 Humans are not made from clay. The Quran claims they are. Now that's a basic contradiction right there if you had basic reading skills.
@@msid7748 Lol!
I tried giving you the definitions, I even gave you an example...
It would have been a contradiction if the Quran both said that they were made from clay, and that they definitely were NOT made from clay.
What you got here is a statement you disagree with.
(Very very different from a contradiction).
@@tally3018 Are you dumb or something? Are humans in real life made from clay? Is that not a contradiction with science or what?
Muslims would say its a miracle and god can do miracles. Even so, what is interesting to know is where this number comes from. In the bible noah and others live so long because the author is copying the sumerian king list, which has huge pre deluge lifespans and short ones afterward. So the quran is copying something a human copied from sumerian mythologt
Noah is a fictional character. You can make up different life spans for made-up fictional characters. It's not a problem. I believe Jor-El lived for nine hundred years. At least that's my story.
I here the Noah ark story was true then turned into legend.
@@Remake5182 it's a variation on the story of Utnapishtim. For a look at what happened closer to reality read Plato.
For 1000 years Noah could have build an empire or wrote a lot books.. wth
Not gonna lie, but even as an exmuslim, I don’t know how this disproves Islam. Muslims will just say it’s a miracle and disproving that is just unfalsifiable 🤷♀️
@angelmakersweetrolls In case you didn't know the author of Harry Potter is a Christian and said if someone knew the gospel they would know how Harry Potter would end.
All the issues add up. Plus this isn't claimed as a miracle. Just how long he lived, like everyone else at the time lol
@@FriendlyExmuslim The bible says that everyone did at the time, but not the Quran iirc. It just says Noah.
@angelmakersweetrolls It's interesting that I've seen some used Harry Potter as an example as a complete fiction when the author who is a Christian based it on what she sees as a history, the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ.
The resurrection of Jesus Christ impacted history.
Agree. Saying "it is impossible for a person to live 950 years" is not a good objection to Islam or Christianity or Judaism. Because, the condition during the pre-flood era could have been much different from the current world.
For example: Under lower radiation conditions (coupled with complementary biochemical adjustments - lesser genetic defects, Increased Oxygen, diet , larger gene pool) life spans of up to 900 years might have been possible.
The Quran says earth is FLAT and used ALL Arabic words that can mean flat, isn't that enough? Quran says mountains were ADDED to earth to stabilise it from swaying. Quran says the heart is the centre of thinking and not once mentioned the brain. my friend the Quran has hundreds if not thousands of mistakes
Fun fact. The Old Testament is a collection of myths and legends and laws and songs and prayers and histories of the Jewish people written down over thousands of years. The New Testament contains four gospels which are four different accounts of the life and teachings of Jesus Christ. You are merely discussing the supposed age of a mythical person whose Biblical story Muhamnad heard and put into his Quran. Every school child in England is taught the difference between myth and legend and history. Noah is myth, obviously. Though the 7th century Muhammad obviously thought Noah was real, bless him. 😁
I am an atheist and certainly not a believer in any holy book but I feel this argument is a poor one.
Firstly, the opinions of other men are irrelevant, no matter how revered they may be. As in your video's title, we must focus on what the book tells us.
Any follower of the Abrahamic faiths will tell you that people in those days lived longer and it was only after the flood that the life span of men began to reduce. We might think that this is nonsense but we cannot prove it.
If we make a positive statement, such as the Quran is mistaken, the burden of proof lies with us. Therefore, this criticism founders in the face of someone saying "if you can't prove Noah didn't live that long, you cannot prove the Quran is mistaken".
This may not be the best example of a mistake (as you can make several arguments), however, biologically this is simply very unlikely - what suddenly changed in the way our cells work that life spans were cut to 10% of what they used to be? Also, the flood is a regional myths, did people all over the Earth suddenly live shorter? Such a drastic change cannot be explained biologically. Evolution in humans takes tens of thousands of years to show up, and is very slow and gradual, as it is in other species, so this does not fit an evolutionary model.
There are many other mistakes which are simpler. For example in one verse Allah says that all living things have been made in pairs (the tafsirs explain that this means male and female). We know however that many species reproduce via different asexual mechanism and don't have a pair. So, that is an easy one to argue.
It's a Mistake since it doesn't align with reality. Biologically speaking humans can't live that long.
claiming that it was a miracle/magic isn't a good argument out of it. Since there's no such thing as a miracle, everything that happens obeys the laws of the universe.
The burden of proof here isn't on us, it's on them to prove that the impossible happened. And since all miracles apparently happened thousands of years ago and aren't happening anymore they can't prove the existence of miracles.
@@theastronomer5800 Everything you say is, of course, accurate. However, my point was not to argue that the Quran is true but to show that this particular argument is a poor one because we cannot 'prove' it is a mistake.
We may legitimately demand that Islam prove its assertions but once we make positive statements of our own, such as the Quran is mistaken the burden of proof switches to us.
@angelmakersweetrolls In my mind, utterly ridiculous, but can I prove it didn't split and was repaired by Allah?
If I make a positive statement that it never happened, I must support my assertion with evidence.
@@scheimaa172 Thank you for your reply.
The issue here is not whether religious claims are accurate it is about the difference between saying "I do not believe, show me your evidence" and stating, "This is wrong/impossible".
My point wasn't that it could be true. I don't believe it any more than you. But saying we do not believe and demanding evidence to support a religious claim is different from stating outright that something did not happen.
if we make a positive statement that it definitely did not happen, we have the burden of proof and Muslims can answer by claiming a miracle.
If we make a second positive statement that miracles are impossible, we have the same problem.
Whilst miracles are, by definition, a suspension of the laws of physics, we cannot absolutely prove that they do not happen, only that their likelihood is highly implausible. For example, we cannot truly know that what we perceive as physical laws are indeed universal, because we have no idea how big the universe is or that the laws apply equally everywhere.
A better way to refute any religion is to highlight where an infallible holy book makes opposing claims or statements. There are plenty to choose from. For example, the Quran gives two different versions of how long God's day lasts in human terms.
Surah 22.47 states that it is 1,000 years but Surah 70.4 states 50,000. Both cannot be correct.
The best way, of course, is to simply say, "show me your evidence".
As someone rather aptly said -the Quran takes silly Bible stories and makes them even sillier!So so true.
False. The bible was corrupted by humans over time, thays why there is only 1 quran and more than 1 bible. The Quran doesnt take the mistakes from the bible.
@@mhmd_old7 The Quran is the very essence of corruption -a ragbag arranged merely according to length of the suras,boring,c grade as literature,repetitive and with threats of violence on every page.And there are dozens of versions starting with the copies that Uthman destroyed!
Any Muslim's can defend this ? How about Farid 🤣
It's metaphysical.
Its lies and I already explained why, go search for the commemt yourself
The way of getting more views, to feed your children!
But there was never a flood or an Ark anyway.
Polar bears could not exist at the height of Mount Everest their lungs wouldn’t work that high above sea level, they would suffocate.
3rd possibly: ALIENS
Okay, this isn't a slam dunk at all. I think you will find the Hebrew also has some construction like a thousand minus fifty, or similar. It doesn't have hindu Arabic numerals saying 950 like in modern translations, numerical expressions were more problematic to express prior to Hindu Arabic numerals being adopted, especially for high numbers.
And I can't speak for others, but as I understand it the idea is that back in those days people lived longer because they were closer to the time of purity and Eden, declining in years until God ordained that our span would be three score and ten years, which is another example of how awkward it was to even express the number 70 back then.
There was a whole line of them living hundreds of years. I used to have a book from the jehovah's witnesses showing them all on a chart with their ages expressed as heights on the chart. Methuselah is well known for living nearly a thousand years as well.
I actually think when the bible says people lived for eg 120 years, they may be counting six months as a year. In the levant there is a spring harvest and an autumn harvest, and because it is between the tropics, there are two points in the year where it gets hotter and then cooler (rather than just one "summer" each year like in higher or lower latitudes than 23 degrees north or south).
It is a slam dunk when you take into account your points actually. If someone in the Bible lived "950 years" by lunar cycles, etc then Noah living as long as he did in the Qur'an is wrong as the Islamic accounts don't ever seem to take into account Hebrew traditions and often translate something literally. So Islam means they literally lived that long
@@svensvenforkedbeard170 hmm, sounds like, I forget the word, that thing where you insist on your own definitions for others' words.
I don't know if the two harvests = two years thing is a real thing, I've not heard anybody else saying this. Maybe Judaism doesn't accept this. It makes sense to me of people living 120 or 130 years but I think the 900 and 600 year spans in Genesis are just exaggeration with generational retelling. It might be related to the idea that "in those days there were giants" (Gen 6:4), with the idea being that these were giants as men, not literally in size.
But anyway, though we know the quran is supposed to be taken literally and that backs it into a corner over and again, if this sort of thing were really a slam dunk then there would be no Muslims left by now.
@@integrationalpolytheism From a Biblical perspective we understand that the giants/nephilim were not exceptional in that they were super human beyond human stature but that they were taller than the average humans of the time. We know this is perfectly possible in human nature that some ethnic groups are taller than others. It is believed that they were just a taller ethnic group than the Jews after they left Egypt.
@@svensvenforkedbeard170 it may be believed by you, however there are several possible interpretations.
As far as physical size, the tallest man on record, Robert Wadlow, was nearly nine feet tall. Around eight feet tall, the human heart starts to struggle to circulate properly. It seems unlikely that there were giants living in the middle East only a few thousand years ago, considering this. And where is the archaeological evidence for that anyway?
Meh, according to the theory of punctuated equilibrium is it possible to have drastic evolutionary changes in a very short span of time.
The biggest mistake in the Quran is the fact that it validates Jesus of the whose teaching is way more morale and spiritual than Islam. He follows none of them.
Ex-muslim here, but I don't see this as an "obvious mistake". If there was truly an omnipotent God, then it would absolutely not be impossible for him to temporarily suspend physical laws and grant Noah more years to his life compared to other humans.
As a revert muslim, strongly appreciate your fair analysis of this video. May Allah guide you and remove any obstacles from your path.
@AAEraA no im pretty sure Satan doesn't want to call people to monotheism and worshiping God alone with no partners. That's God's relgions, islam (:
Yeah, but we evolved from monkeys but I bet you wouldn't doubt such theories as long as it comes from an atheist right?
Scientifically impossible but once there are miracles, it makes it possible. But what makes it false is that , God cannot give different ages on one person.
❤️
In the Bible the ages are to be understood as symbolic ages. Even though no western nation understand that symbolism, we must admit, that by the time the story was written, symbolic ages were common and understood by the readers. So, sorry, the "age" of Noah was an information about his life and character and importance, to those who know arithmantik. I don't.
Just one note to mention : there are some ancient records of kings that ruled for 24000 years or 15000 years in the ancient civilizations like Babylonians or before them which really indicated that their way of counting of the time was different ( like : one week may be = 100 years or something like that ) . CHECK IT UP
Here also there are fables, the commoners often did not see their king and did not quite know when the heirs took the throne... Unless there be a conflict. There is nothing that can make 15 or 30 15000
In one of his video, aronra showed that you can convert those numbers to our normal numbers and turned out just fine, the double zero could be disregarded and then the numbers divided by 12 or something.
@@Napoleonic_S are other ages in the books mentioned in the same way? Say the age of other personalities mentioned? If no, then we have no reason to convert one and leave the others. If yes, then this is a potential remedy.
@@ankitanandy6076
Not in the bible but the bible was a compilation of books written by different groups of people in different times. But if we're talking about ancient sumerian king list here then yes all the ages were written like that.
Some proposed the idea that the age of the first characters in the bibles were written in the same style as the ancient sumerian king list...
Dunno why the quran still copy that but it just further prove that both books were men made.
A better mistake that Allah does is claiming that Christians believe that the Trinity is Mary, Jesus and the Father. No Christian has ever belived this. It is Mohammeds mistake in the "perfect" quran.
Isnt the father alread jesus and also the holy ghost at the same time so wouldnt it technically be a holy singularity as their all the same person?
If their the same person then why is it a trinity and not a singlurarity?
@@youtubestudiosucks978 1 single “essence” in 3 “persons”. Tri theism would be 3 essences in 3 persons. So there is 1 god in Christianity
@@joygibbons5482 now you're making up excuses of why you cant count. Their the same person so that makes it 1 which is singular and not 3 as you people keep describing it.
Learn to count
@@joygibbons5482humanity has one essence and separate persons.. that doesn’t make us one being
Yeah. If their stand point was; Quaran is a wise, teaching book, where you can get much inspiration and encouragement from - yeah, it would be enough good for all practical purposes. But when they say, everything in Quaran is literally true because its dictated by God Himself, and thus, non changeable and not possible to critique and barely to discuss - such passages become awkward to the credibility...
Mohammed came out of a cave with changes to gods word, and said I was told this and this with no witnesses why would God have revelation with only 1 witness sounds like a dreamer of dreams to me.
DUTIRONIMY 13:1Everything I command you that you shall be careful to do it. You shall neither add to it, nor subtract from it.2If there will arise among you a prophet, or a dreamer of a dream, and he gives you a sign or a wonder,3and the sign or the wonder of which he spoke to you happens, [and he] says, "Let us go after other gods which you have not known, and let us worship them,"4you shall not heed the words of that prophet, or that dreamer of a dream; for the Lord, your God, is testing you, to know whether you really love the Lord, your God, with all your heart and with all your soul.
(Both Christianity and Islam made changes to the laws of kosher)
This is all you got? So now you believed in science because of that? Not knowing there is a bunch of mistakes in sciences
To be fair, Christian and Jews believe that poeple could live 900+ years in the old times. I was taught that and I believed it once. Archaeology and biological anthropology made me realize that was a non-sense... My point is, many people will tell you "oh but the bible says and the quran says... so both agree in that, therefore it's true". 😂
If those age spans were correct, it would have been noticed in non-Jewish sources.
To be quite honest, this is a pretty weak mistake. Even in 600AD it was known people don't live that long, and it was just as easy for believers back then to say "Well, it was a miracle. God is all powerful"
Your theory is absolutely ridiculous! Comparing how long man lives today and how man lived before the Great Flood is pointless and without foundation! And why, if the Bible says something similar, are you singling out the Qur'an? That shows that, as a former Muslim, you are on a mission to solely disprove the Qur'an and ignore anything else! God commanded Noah to build the ark when Noah was 500 years old in Genesis 5:32 and Noah was 600 years old when the flood came (Genesis 7:6). Yet it says in Genesis 6:3: "Then the LORD said, “My Spirit shall not strive with man forever, because he also is flesh; nevertheless his days shall be one hundred and twenty years.” Why are you not pointing out that contradiction?
You call this an "obvious mistake"?!? It's just you not believing that Noah and those before him lived that long. The Bible records that pre-Flood lifespans were much longer than post-Flood. So we have to ask why and not just pooh-pah it away. And just because you find it hard to believe does not make it an "obvious mistake". There are mistakes in the Qur'an which are obvious but this is not one of them.
At this time, scientist is researching about ageing and biology behind it. Scientist is very optimistic that they could theoretically extend human lifetime, by programming our dna. Well at least until 180 years (3 decade + 150 years). But if the science progression is at a constant rate (or exponentially), they will able to extend the human live even longer more than that, As we will gain more access to the knowledge of human biology.
If human is very optimistic about their research. Then how could God cannot do what our scientist is currently doing?
Isn't god created human and the whole universe?
You're using the wrong interpretation methodology, I know they're are many translations of Quran all based on the 1 Original book and those translations are copy and paste from generations before us who understood what they thought what versus of Quran meant and today they might tweek it here or there ( but not original) just the translations that is
Quran declares it self as a Book with anchoring principles within it , so you don't really need to rely upon other peoples translations based upon other peoples opinions, and " so called attributing sayings of the messenger of Allah" knowing that we do not even have the original books of Hadith of the purported authors there are gaps of 100, 150 years in most cases, like all knowledge, you need to know the fundamentals , in this case it would be language,grammer, syntax, past literature or any language records to understand use of language and it's prime understanding according to the source, in this case it would be time of revelation and general life experiences, trials and tribulations also not forgetting willingness to learn, (Zabuur)= keys to unlock/ uncover, which our "translator's" have translated as Psalms, why? Because they clearly borrowed what they thought it meant from the Bible and Torah, even though the Quran is explicit in saying that those scriptures have been corrupted and it's contents are not reliable, but NO our so called scholar's injected that understanding because they obviously didn't understand Arabic Abstract concept's, so the Quranic verse reveals what the story was about, David was given the keys to unlock the presant scriptures ( Torah)
So he was given knowledge, willingness to understand the book , not Psalms as if it was a part of the original book
Same explanation of Jesus Story, all borrowed from Bible because they couldn't unlock the Abstract concept's i.e Jesus brought the dead back to life doesn't mean literally he helped transform people who were dead figuratively those who lost hope
He healed the born blind and leper, same again not literally, he helped those that were born blind in my opinion are those who were born into unfavorable circumstances in this case environment ( people around them ) has had a detrimental effect and they're completely lost
The leper is part of the people who were subjected to discrimination and accusations that they were born in such away because it was a curse from God , and he Jesus reminded those inflicted with anytype of handicap that it was a test from God and it in no way was a curse but maybe for the people who didn't help, more like hadicapp people are a test upon the healthy?
So you can see Quran reminds us how the previous books got corrupted, they took abstract concepts out the equation, when that's the heart of all divine books, you have to extract the meaning it's not a 4 th grade book
Hadith say the messenger split the moon literally
and they attribute this to a Quranic verse:- Surah al Qamar
And when the moon splits the time of the hour is near
And when the sun is at it's most radiance
And when the moon >follows< ,
'follows' is incorrect should be > recite <
How can the moon recite after the sun?
Know what was the locution of Abraham?
Quran explicitly states the Quran has been constructed in his locution style
I.e the sun 🌞 = the scripture or messenger or both,
Moon 🌝 = a prophet, they reflect the message I e interpret the scriptures, explain to people the contents
So the moon splitting indicates end of Prophethood to the Jews because not only was Muhammad a messenger he was the seal of Prophethood for the Jews, the tearing of the contract so to speak, and dosent a contract reflect? by the way 😀
Hence Jews were sent prophet after prophet to explain the Torah
In Arabic the root of Torah is T-W-R means concealment, and also described In Quran as the thorny tree all indicating a book who's contents were hard to extract the true meanings, that's why they were sent prophets one after another, that's why I said in the beginning Quran has a methodology within to extract it's contents and has anchoring principles, whereas Torah it's anchoring principles are above the book Indicating prophets needed
So, according his logic (which is probable estimation based on the human that live today) if we produce a mathematical model that shows human could have lived longer in past then he will re-embrace islam, post an apology towards God and muslims, and delete all of his videos. (This is possible bcz we are dealing in mathematical estimations for example just increase the size of red blood cell whole human anatomy will change not observable scientific Facts)
Bible and quran both agree and state that Noah lived 950 years...theres no mistake in quran and it is a message from God to all ...read quran...your attempt to disprove God's word is silly, you do not have even have enough wisdom to number the hair on your head but you dare to explain God's message...read quran and meditate on it...
Well, how would a religious book _need_ any facts to back it up? If allah wants him to be 1000 y/o, he will be. Like the dudes sleeping in the cave for way too long to be alive. Who needs logic when you have the skymonster to keep you company! :D
This is lazy. I could point the story of the people who slept in the cave to protect their faith. When they woke they're in a different era. Add that to your list.