Manna Dey Sahab Talks Rafi Sahab.

แชร์
ฝัง
  • เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ต.ค. 2017
  • Support this channel on Ko-Fi at ko-fi.com/yaadein Versatile Genius Manna Dey Sahab's reverence for Rafi Sahab.
    Manna Dey Sahab talks about Mohammed Rafi Sahab.
    In this video, Manna Dey Sahab is in conversation with Farrukh Viqar.
    Prabodh Chandra Dey (1 May 1919 − 24 October 2013), known by his stage name Manna Dey, was an internationally acclaimed Indian playback singer, music director, musician and Indian classical vocalist. As a classical vocalist, he belonged to the Bhendibazaar gharana. He was trained under Ustad Aman Ali Khan. He is considered one of the most versatile and celebrated vocalists of the Hindi film industry.[2][3][4] He was one of the playback singers credited with the success of Indian classical music in Hindi commercial movies.[4] He debuted in the film Tamanna in 1942. After the song "Upar Gagan Bishal" composed by S D Burman he saw success and went on to record more than 4,000 songs till 2013. The Government of India honoured him with the Padma Shri in 1971, the Padma Bhushan in 2005, Padma Vibhusan in 2012[5] and the Dadasaheb Phalke Award in 2007.[6] He also conferred with the foreign awards including Ordre des Arts et des Lettres by the Government of France in 1985.
    Dey sang in all the major regional Indian languages, though primarily in Bengali and Hindi, Dey also sang in Bhojpuri, Magadhi, Maithili, Punjabi, Assamese,[7] Odia, Konkani, Sindhi, Gujarati, Marathi, Kannada, Malayalam, and Nepali. His peak period in Hindi playback singing was from 1953 to 1976. His singing was simple and always had a classical touch.
  • บันเทิง

ความคิดเห็น • 67

  • @arifakhtarofficial
    @arifakhtarofficial 5 ปีที่แล้ว +28

    मन्ना डे साहब आपकी सच्चाई ने दिल जीत लिया रफी साहब तो महान थे ही आप भी महान हो रफी साहब और आप जैसे सिंगर दोबारा पैदा नहीं होते

  • @shantanuchakraborty1336
    @shantanuchakraborty1336 5 ปีที่แล้ว +26

    Manna dey sahab is really the best singer ,matchless singer .....that's his greatness that he praise Rafi sahab respectfully.......really rafi sahab is world's best voice

  • @bharatbhumi101
    @bharatbhumi101 3 ปีที่แล้ว +11

    रफ़ी साहब संसार के अब तक और आगे के लिए भी #सर्वश्रेष्ठ गायक हैं।
    🙏न भूतो न भविष्यति🙏

  • @RahimBahrain
    @RahimBahrain 6 ปีที่แล้ว +58

    "All Rafi songs are LANDMARK songs"....what a tribute. Great Manna Dey never loses an opportunity to express his undying love and respect for Rafi Saab.

    • @mdmustaq9759
      @mdmustaq9759 5 ปีที่แล้ว

      Abdul Rahim Hasan

    • @aliafsar100
      @aliafsar100 ปีที่แล้ว

      manande mahaan gayak aaur sangeet sikhe huve phir bhi rafi saaheb ka mahanta tareef koyi singer nahi kar sakta. kewke kannada her jaansakte hai.

  • @gulamansari7630
    @gulamansari7630 6 ปีที่แล้ว +38

    A legend talking about another legend. ...Wow.....

  • @srinivaspillai4622
    @srinivaspillai4622 5 ปีที่แล้ว +34

    Great unbiased singer manna dey witnessing and admitting that Mohammed Rafi was different and what he could do, we couldn't do, see the humility of this great singer, himself well trained classical singer of repute but considers the other better than him, a great person is he who considers other person great, this is what great manna dey was, unforgettable person, both legends admired each other, no it is you, no it is you, about greatness, lovely gentlemen they were, once in a life time, rest in peace, sirs, God bless your families.

  • @MonirHossain-zj4qk
    @MonirHossain-zj4qk 5 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    Manna de sahab apne bhi classical sangeet ko jis unchaye tak paunchaya hai uski koi misal nahi milti i salute u dada u are a great singar of classical music

    • @sagar3382
      @sagar3382 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Manna Da aur Rafi sahab to heere the

  • @s.salisworld7577
    @s.salisworld7577 6 ปีที่แล้ว +26

    great Rafi sahab and Manna dey

  • @syedhassan4062
    @syedhassan4062 6 ปีที่แล้ว +35

    True greatness! He is a real legend himself but listen to him talk about Rafi Sahab. Salute to you Dada.

  • @ramlalrout2956
    @ramlalrout2956 5 ปีที่แล้ว +19

    very honest views​ expressed by another great legendary singer about a junior colleague.many salutes.

  • @sksanowar2330
    @sksanowar2330 5 ปีที่แล้ว +13

    rafi Sahab is a greatest all time favorite singer.no one can not reach his vercialite.

  • @yousufkhan4370
    @yousufkhan4370 6 ปีที่แล้ว +23

    Es kay baad konsa Certificate chahye waah What a great Truth Manna Dey

  • @manivelsahayam1317
    @manivelsahayam1317 6 ปีที่แล้ว +44

    Manna Day has great respect for Rafi Saheb.According to him Rafi saheb was the greatest playback singer of India.Even in his own interviews he talked about Rafi Saheb.When he came to Fiji in the 70s he talked not about himself but Rafi saheb.He accepted the fact that Rafi saheb was a greater singer than him although Manna Day was more classically trained than Rafi saheb. Other singers who regarded Rafi saheb as a great singer include SPBalasubramaniyam, Yesudas, Shailendra Singh and many others.Rafi is Rafi -no other singer can take his place.

    • @saziasamir
      @saziasamir 4 ปีที่แล้ว +1

      Strongly agree

  • @a1music930
    @a1music930 6 ปีที่แล้ว +10

    manna day sahab aap ko mera salaam hai yaar itni taarif kya baat hai

  • @location143chanya
    @location143chanya 6 ปีที่แล้ว +28

    WHAT A TRIBUTE IT MAKES MANNA THE GREAT. INSPITE HAVING ICON IN CLASSICAL MUSIC HE IS APPRECIATING RAFIJI

  • @samiruddingamer5574
    @samiruddingamer5574 5 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Mera best song Mohammad Rafi Shine Jab Tak Ye Duniya tab tak Mohammad Rafi Ki Awaz

  • @breakthroughclothing5428
    @breakthroughclothing5428 6 ปีที่แล้ว +17

    Respect Manna Da

  • @latifbutt7526
    @latifbutt7526 4 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    What a tribute by a legend for super legend

  • @hamidzai9386
    @hamidzai9386 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Dada we love you 😥 And we miss you 😥 Rafi sahab...Dada ek Great singer to ap ho hi lekin oron K liye apke dil m kitna piyar h ye koi ap se seekhe ....sache dil se ase hi bola jata h

  • @khalidahmedzameer8054
    @khalidahmedzameer8054 4 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Dada ajj app is dunya ko chod chalte apple mo se Rafi saheb ki tarif sun Kar bahot Acha Lagta tha
    Mara janam 1955 Ka hai
    Maine ap lagaon Ka Pura daur Dekha Hun Rafi Sahab Ka gana chal udja repanchi
    Wo pahela gana tha phir app Ka aye mere piyre watan
    ISI Tarah Mukesh ki Ka
    Saranga Teri Yaad me
    In hi awazazon ko sunte bacpan guzra Jawan huwe aur ajj ham bhi bhude ho chalte
    App sab ki awazaun ne hamri Zindagi aisa aise rang diye jab ham udas huve app ki awaz Ka Sahara liya jab khushyan Mili tab bhi app awaz hamari khushyon me shamil rahi yaun kahun ghalat Nahi Hoga pal pal hamare sath rahi

  • @sanjeevmehndiratta5753
    @sanjeevmehndiratta5753 3 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Swar Samrat Sangeet ki ek Duniya apne saath le kar chale gaye ab is Duniya mein kabhi bhi kisi bhi yug mein Doosra Mohammed Rafi Paida nahi hoga Duniya ki Sabse khoobsurat Aawaj Suro ke Shenshah Aawaj ke Jadugar Voice of God Long live the memory of Manna Dey ji & Mohammed Rafi Sahab

  • @KingKhan-cd5nv
    @KingKhan-cd5nv 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Aap BahuT MaHaN Singer The Mannadey SaHaB Aur Aapka Badappan Hai ye Ki Aap RaFi SaHaB ko Apne Se Jyada MaHaN Bataya
    Allah bless you

  • @KingKhan-cd5nv
    @KingKhan-cd5nv 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    RaFi SaHaB Mahan The Par Aap Mannadey SaHaB Aap Bhi Mahan The Aap Jaise Log Ab es duniya me Paida Nahi hote

  • @sushildhiman41
    @sushildhiman41 6 ปีที่แล้ว +15

    Sir rafi sahab ko aur spacial aap ko bhi mera salute

  • @lallitasingh616
    @lallitasingh616 5 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Rafi sahab one of the best Legendary Singer in the whole world....Jai ho Rafi Sahab wah wah ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @srinivaspillai4622
    @srinivaspillai4622 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Be humble, like manna da sahab, a great person is who makes other person great, love manna da sahab and Mohammed rafi sahab, love both, thanks.

  • @munafismail1148
    @munafismail1148 6 ปีที่แล้ว +9

    Old is gold.

  • @amarjeetamar9556
    @amarjeetamar9556 4 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Great Great Great

  • @KhanSahab-ko6vz
    @KhanSahab-ko6vz 5 ปีที่แล้ว +6

    Great Rafi sb

  • @arsalansiddiqui7505
    @arsalansiddiqui7505 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Rafi sb ki singing ko sbse ziada mannaday g behtreen defined krte they hmesha..agr rafi sb nhi hotay to classical me mannaday g jaisa koi na tha

  • @cpmshaheer5584
    @cpmshaheer5584 4 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    When and where would Such Great Singers Come Back to the STAGE.

  • @mikethompson2979
    @mikethompson2979 6 ปีที่แล้ว +26

    Rafi sahab didn't need classical training...he was Beyond a day above classical.ragas

    • @yobro6198
      @yobro6198 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

      Bro, it's of kishore kumar that he never learn classical training

    • @chanchalbiswas7404
      @chanchalbiswas7404 ปีที่แล้ว

      Rafi sahab classical sikha tha...

  • @user-iv7py2ij3n
    @user-iv7py2ij3n 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    Rafi the legend singer and manna dey ji BEST FERENAD

  • @azizamnunna2503
    @azizamnunna2503 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    I think such praise and appreciation for Rafi from such a towering singer is enough to disregard the views of Rafi's critics.

  • @mubarakahmed7687
    @mubarakahmed7687 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    This shows how Great a Human Being was Manna De himself.

  • @asifsab1725
    @asifsab1725 2 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Rafi sb great singer ever

  • @rehanakhan5128
    @rehanakhan5128 2 หลายเดือนก่อน +1

    Everyone loves Rafi saheb
    Mannade ji is very decent person

  • @yashanksharma7898
    @yashanksharma7898 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    both are Legend

  • @manikdey7012
    @manikdey7012 3 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    The Two Gandharva : Rafi sahab and Manna DEY ji . Mesmerising singers .

  • @waseefahmadg
    @waseefahmadg 5 ปีที่แล้ว +3

    respect

  • @kuldeepkherakhera219
    @kuldeepkherakhera219 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Jai Rafi sahab jai Manna dae ji jai Mukesh ji.

  • @deepakshindesir3062
    @deepakshindesir3062 4 ปีที่แล้ว +2

    Very fine

  • @samiruddingamer5574
    @samiruddingamer5574 5 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Md Rafi dard bhari Awaz sangeet ke Badshah Mohammad Rafi Saheb

  • @khalid4455
    @khalid4455 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Nice 👍

  • @trilokchandjain7343
    @trilokchandjain7343 3 ปีที่แล้ว

    Mannaday ji and Rafisahab is a greatest singer

  • @shamikdutta4199
    @shamikdutta4199 6 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    Bich bich main conversation cut Ku Kia gia

  • @Asad.warsi.7007
    @Asad.warsi.7007 4 ปีที่แล้ว +4

    रफी साहब खुद को दोहरा दो रफी से फिर

  • @gopeshkumar2327
    @gopeshkumar2327 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Sunao koi asha ji ko

  • @atehacooper6595
    @atehacooper6595 2 ปีที่แล้ว +1

    Both Manna de ji and Rafi ji were god of classical...but Kishore was rocking for bollywood trendy songs...he left trained singers behind...

  • @AshwaniKumar-jo5zs
    @AshwaniKumar-jo5zs ปีที่แล้ว

    Mana day is not equivalent to rafi sahib may be to some extent better in classical. But honest person classical person number one classical singer gave certificate than there is no value of anybody

  • @shabnamarif3139
    @shabnamarif3139 ปีที่แล้ว

    Anchor sahab ne kaha ki Ye BADAPPAN HAI APKA BADAPPAN,,,,,,, are bhai samne wala ho bhi to Rafi Sahab jesa tareefein lootne wala vyaktitvaa. Har chalte firte ki kon bhala tareef karta hai, ab khud hi ko dekh lo jab Manna da Rafi Sahab qabliyaton ke bare mein bata rhe hain ki wo kyun aur kin wajaho se Rafi Sahab ka itna samman karte hain to khud aap hi ko bardasht nhi ho rha, baar baar bat ka rukh Badappan hai apka dada, is vakya ki or modne lag jate ho, bhai kyun tumse Rafi Sahab ki tareef bardasht nhi ho rhi? Unki Tareef karne ke liye kisi ko Badappan ya jigar ki nhi sangeet ki barikiyon ki samajh honi chahiye. Manna da bhali bhanti jante the Rafi Sahab ki qabliyat ko isliye wo inke kayal the, na ki yahan unke badappan aur samne wale ke chhotappn ka koi competition ho rha tha. Wo dono sangeet jagat ke diggaj the naki ek dusre ke samne kisi akhaade mein khade the.....to aage se apne shabdon pe niyantran rakhein aur soch samajh ke bolein. Aur fir Rafi Sahab ne kabhi kisi se zabardasti to nhi kaha ki unki tareef ki jaye, jisne unko samjha wo khud hi unka kayal ho gya.......

  • @MajidKhan-wl4tm
    @MajidKhan-wl4tm 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Yah baat asha Bhosle ki samajhne kya aaegi asha Bhosle to Rafi Sahab ko gayak Manta nahin

  • @khalid4455
    @khalid4455 2 ปีที่แล้ว

    Nice 👍

  • @shabnamarif3139
    @shabnamarif3139 ปีที่แล้ว

    Anchor sahab ne kaha ki Ye BADAPPAN HAI APKA BADAPPAN,,,,,,, are bhai samne wala ho bhi to Rafi Sahab jesa tareefein lootne wala vyaktitvaa. Har chalte firte ki kon bhala tareef karta hai, ab khud hi ko dekh lo jab Manna da Rafi Sahab qabliyaton ke bare mein bata rhe hain ki wo kyun aur kin wajaho se Rafi Sahab ka itna samman karte hain to khud aap hi ko bardasht nhi ho rha, baar baar bat ka rukh Badappan hai apka dada, is vakya ki or modne lag jate ho, bhai kyun tumse Rafi Sahab ki tareef bardasht nhi ho rhi? Unki Tareef karne ke liye kisi ko Badappan ya jigar ki nhi sangeet ki barikiyon ki samajh honi chahiye. Manna da bhali bhanti jante the Rafi Sahab ki qabliyat ko isliye wo inke kayal the, na ki yahan unke badappan aur samne wale ke chhotappn ka koi competition ho rha tha. Wo dono sangeet jagat ke diggaj the naki ek dusre ke samne kisi akhaade mein khade the.....to aage se apne shabdon pe niyantran rakhein aur soch samajh ke bolein. Aur fir Rafi Sahab ne kabhi kisi se zabardasti to nhi kaha ki unki tareef ki jaye, jisne unko samjha wo khud hi unka kayal ho gya.......

  • @shabnamarif3139
    @shabnamarif3139 ปีที่แล้ว

    Anchor sahab ne kaha ki Ye BADAPPAN HAI APKA BADAPPAN,,,,,,, are bhai samne wala ho bhi to Rafi Sahab jesa tareefein lootne wala vyaktitvaa. Har chalte firte ki kon bhala tareef karta hai, ab khud hi ko dekh lo jab Manna da Rafi Sahab qabliyaton ke bare mein bata rhe hain ki wo kyun aur kin wajaho se Rafi Sahab ka itna samman karte hain to khud aap hi ko bardasht nhi ho rha, baar baar bat ka rukh Badappan hai apka dada, is vakya ki or modne lag jate ho, bhai kyun tumse Rafi Sahab ki tareef bardasht nhi ho rhi? Unki Tareef karne ke liye kisi ko Badappan ya jigar ki nhi sangeet ki barikiyon ki samajh honi chahiye. Manna da bhali bhanti jante the Rafi Sahab ki qabliyat ko isliye wo inke kayal the, na ki yahan unke badappan aur samne wale ke chhotappn ka koi competition ho rha tha. Wo dono sangeet jagat ke diggaj the naki ek dusre ke samne kisi akhaade mein khade the.....to aage se apne shabdon pe niyantran rakhein aur soch samajh ke bolein. Aur fir Rafi Sahab ne kabhi kisi se zabardasti to nhi kaha ki unki tareef ki jaye, jisne unko samjha wo khud hi unka kayal ho gya.......

  • @shabnamarif3139
    @shabnamarif3139 ปีที่แล้ว

    Anchor sahab ne kaha ki Ye BADAPPAN HAI APKA BADAPPAN,,,,,,, are bhai samne wala ho bhi to Rafi Sahab jesa tareefein lootne wala vyaktitvaa. Har chalte firte ki kon bhala tareef karta hai, ab khud hi ko dekh lo jab Manna da Rafi Sahab qabliyaton ke bare mein bata rhe hain ki wo kyun aur kin wajaho se Rafi Sahab ka itna samman karte hain to khud aap hi ko bardasht nhi ho rha, baar baar bat ka rukh Badappan hai apka dada, is vakya ki or modne lag jate ho, bhai kyun tumse Rafi Sahab ki tareef bardasht nhi ho rhi? Unki Tareef karne ke liye kisi ko Badappan ya jigar ki nhi sangeet ki barikiyon ki samajh honi chahiye. Manna da bhali bhanti jante the Rafi Sahab ki qabliyat ko isliye wo inke kayal the, na ki yahan unke badappan aur samne wale ke chhotappn ka koi competition ho rha tha. Wo dono sangeet jagat ke diggaj the naki ek dusre ke samne kisi akhaade mein khade the.....to aage se apne shabdon pe niyantran rakhein aur soch samajh ke bolein. Aur fir Rafi Sahab ne kabhi kisi se zabardasti to nhi kaha ki unki tareef ki jaye, jisne unko samjha wo khud hi unka kayal ho gya.......

  • @shabnamarif3139
    @shabnamarif3139 ปีที่แล้ว

    Anchor sahab ne kaha ki Ye BADAPPAN HAI APKA BADAPPAN,,,,,,, are bhai samne wala ho bhi to Rafi Sahab jesa tareefein lootne wala vyaktitvaa. Har chalte firte ki kon bhala tareef karta hai, ab khud hi ko dekh lo jab Manna da Rafi Sahab qabliyaton ke bare mein bata rhe hain ki wo kyun aur kin wajaho se Rafi Sahab ka itna samman karte hain to khud aap hi ko bardasht nhi ho rha, baar baar bat ka rukh Badappan hai apka dada, is vakya ki or modne lag jate ho, bhai kyun tumse Rafi Sahab ki tareef bardasht nhi ho rhi? Unki Tareef karne ke liye kisi ko Badappan ya jigar ki nhi sangeet ki barikiyon ki samajh honi chahiye. Manna da bhali bhanti jante the Rafi Sahab ki qabliyat ko isliye wo inke kayal the, na ki yahan unke badappan aur samne wale ke chhotappn ka koi competition ho rha tha. Wo dono sangeet jagat ke diggaj the naki ek dusre ke samne kisi akhaade mein khade the.....to aage se apne shabdon pe niyantran rakhein aur soch samajh ke bolein. Aur fir Rafi Sahab ne kabhi kisi se zabardasti to nhi kaha ki unki tareef ki jaye, jisne unko samjha wo khud hi unka kayal ho gya.......

  • @shabnamarif3139
    @shabnamarif3139 ปีที่แล้ว

    Anchor sahab ne kaha ki Ye BADAPPAN HAI APKA BADAPPAN,,,,,,, are bhai samne wala ho bhi to Rafi Sahab jesa tareefein lootne wala vyaktitvaa. Har chalte firte ki kon bhala tareef karta hai, ab khud hi ko dekh lo jab Manna da Rafi Sahab qabliyaton ke bare mein bata rhe hain ki wo kyun aur kin wajaho se Rafi Sahab ka itna samman karte hain to khud aap hi ko bardasht nhi ho rha, baar baar bat ka rukh Badappan hai apka dada, is vakya ki or modne lag jate ho, bhai kyun tumse Rafi Sahab ki tareef bardasht nhi ho rhi? Unki Tareef karne ke liye kisi ko Badappan ya jigar ki nhi sangeet ki barikiyon ki samajh honi chahiye. Manna da bhali bhanti jante the Rafi Sahab ki qabliyat ko isliye wo inke kayal the, na ki yahan unke badappan aur samne wale ke chhotappn ka koi competition ho rha tha. Wo dono sangeet jagat ke diggaj the naki ek dusre ke samne kisi akhaade mein khade the.....to aage se apne shabdon pe niyantran rakhein aur soch samajh ke bolein. Aur fir Rafi Sahab ne kabhi kisi se zabardasti to nhi kaha ki unki tareef ki jaye, jisne unko samjha wo khud hi unka kayal ho gya.......

  • @shabnamarif3139
    @shabnamarif3139 ปีที่แล้ว

    Anchor sahab ne kaha ki Ye BADAPPAN HAI APKA BADAPPAN,,,,,,, are bhai samne wala ho bhi to Rafi Sahab jesa tareefein lootne wala vyaktitvaa. Har chalte firte ki kon bhala tareef karta hai, ab khud hi ko dekh lo jab Manna da Rafi Sahab qabliyaton ke bare mein bata rhe hain ki wo kyun aur kin wajaho se Rafi Sahab ka itna samman karte hain to khud aap hi ko bardasht nhi ho rha, baar baar bat ka rukh Badappan hai apka dada, is vakya ki or modne lag jate ho, bhai kyun tumse Rafi Sahab ki tareef bardasht nhi ho rhi? Unki Tareef karne ke liye kisi ko Badappan ya jigar ki nhi sangeet ki barikiyon ki samajh honi chahiye. Manna da bhali bhanti jante the Rafi Sahab ki qabliyat ko isliye wo inke kayal the, na ki yahan unke badappan aur samne wale ke chhotappn ka koi competition ho rha tha. Wo dono sangeet jagat ke diggaj the naki ek dusre ke samne kisi akhaade mein khade the.....to aage se apne shabdon pe niyantran rakhein aur soch samajh ke bolein. Aur fir Rafi Sahab ne kabhi kisi se zabardasti to nhi kaha ki unki tareef ki jaye, jisne unko samjha wo khud hi unka kayal ho gya........