@@graciasilverio204 I feel betrayed and Slayed!! I also saw a recent clip of her winking! YOU CAN JUST TELL US YOU CAN DO ANYTHING. WE BELIEVE PERFECTION EXIST,MS KANG.
Seulgi the Dancing Bear hahahaha lol i love your humor were the same. Anyways yas! Seulgi is a liar she just want to pretend shes not perfect . Poor seulgi stans unsuspecting souls dont know theyre dealing with the devil 😂
Overall i definitely prefer the final Automatic choreo, but seeing this completely different choreo is so interesting. This one is more smooth and feels more seductive in comparison to the final choreo which is very sharp. It still amazes me how the dance could really change the mood of the song, and how two different people could interpret the same song in differing ways. And reveluvs, hate me all u want but i think this makes it seem even more that yeri wasn’t part of the inital plan for rv. Obviously we cant hear the original audio, so who’s to say it did or didn’t include yeri’s voice, but she isn’t practicing with the rest of the girls despite this being predebut and the dance seems like it was made specifically with four in mind. I love yeri so so much and am so proud of everything they’ve achieved as five, but sometimes videos from before make me think what really was sm’s intial plan for Red Velvet?? My wild conspiracy theory (but not really) is they were planning on doing Automatic after Happiness, but due to some issues (possibly sulli leaving?) they had to add yeri, but they also had to wait for her to reach a certain age due to the new laws that came into place. So they released Be Natural instead (which was probably gonna be part of a velvet album with Automatic) using the choreo that we saw from predebut irene and seulgi. I think they were gonna really commit to the dual concept, like they were planning on releasing full on r&b and soul type of music with choreo such as this that was more alluring and such. But they were also gonna do Red, however I don’t think they would’ve gone down the more “childish” route which we see in Rookie and Power Up. BUT its 3am rn and i should be sleeping so honestly dont mind me. This is all for fun, stan rv❤️
Carol No that happens with grouos sometimes i.e. Twice SM could have had a really cool plan for red velvet but they added Yeri who was 16 throwing the concept off.
S Rogers Thats true, MANY groups stray from their original concept. It’s just with the POSSIBLY unplanned and spontaneous addition of yeri, i wonder if their concept wouldn’t have became as youthful without her addition due to the other four being older and more mature. With twice though i do see it a bit different cause they had sixteen. I agree with those people who say jyp already had an idea of who he wanted in the group and used the show to finalize members and see what the public wanted. So the addition of (if i remember correctly) momo and dahyun (?), was unplanned too i guess. For twice i think they were going for a very flirty kinda girl crush concept like ooh aah, but cause of their huge burst of popularity with cheer up, they decided to stick to that genre of very pop, public friendly and catchy songs. So i guess they too strayed from what i believe to be their original plan, but for me the addition of yeri makes me see things differently when really they might not be that different or as crazy behind the scenes.
Nana Smith despite what I said in my original post, I actually can’t imagine RV w/o Yeri’s voice. She lends so much to their velvet tracks since her voice color(?) is so unique. That comment was so long ago and i was so tired lol. It was mostly just my night time ramblings. RV could definitely still go down the sexy sophisticated route now since their international audience seems to like their velvet tracks more. Unfortunately SM doesn’t give them many opportunities to showcase that side anymore. I would KILL to see them have a full on velvet concert with a live band and with them performing songs like So Good, Light Me Up, Kingdom Come and their feature in Close to Me!!
This is only a guess. I bet they used the pre-debut or original audio in the practice but since it’s not leaked anywhere, the uploader had to use the audio where they already debuted.
open.spotify.com/episode/2jEd15GUa3mp6ve7CovCma?si=ERbwY5CIRSGXU-Va0J-shA&t=2029&dl_branch=1 listen to this podcast! the producers of 'Automatic' told that they made the song after Red Velvet had made dance choreo. They said RV danced to a Janet Jackson's song and SM asked them to make the song for this kind of choreo. They said they saw video with 4 girls in a dance studio... I guess it's this one.
Lmao what? Tye original choreo is WAYYYY more classier than this... This is such a basic choreo with moves that feel like they're just flexing how well rv can dance the original choreo moves along with the rythym with the song unlike this
This was amazing!! Look at how in sync and fluid they were! Wendy really needs to give herself more credit as a dancer. Joy was sensual as a dancer even back then and Seulgi and Irene both look like main dancers!! I wonder what they would've been like as OT4, but glad they added Yeri later on. Thanks to whoever leaked this!!
I feel like Wendy can definitely be a great dancer if she's being trained longer in dancing. she seems really good in some basic hiphop movements and her angles and energy are always on point. She just needs to continue working on her fluidity. (which seems she does improve since Bad Boy)
I absolutely agree! Wendy in FMR showed that she's definitely improved with being more fluid with her movements. I'm so impressed with her dancing even back then and even more so today.
the dance kinda weird because the video use an audio from the current automatic song. if the video use the actual audio the dance will be fit. I guess automatic maybe a follow up after happiness era to introduce their velvet side but SM change their plan and use be natural instead.
Hope the next come back they will show this vibe again. Btw I think Irene is main dancer along with Seulgi in group, not just a lead dancer. Recently her face expression may not be as good as Seulgi but she still dance very strong and neat
I bet they used the pre-debut or original audio in the practice but since it’s not leaked anywhere, the uploader had to use the audio where they already debuted. Only my guess.
Please don't hate me but I think the video and audio are different, I mean we really don't know if they dance to automatic ot5 or (ot4) version, maybe the real uploader edit the video so we can't hear the ot4/demo version. If you look at it again, on 1.16 it's yeri's voice but the one that dancing was irene. Well that's my thoughts
I only know bangtan sonedon I don't think so because in 0.27 when yeri's voice was coming out, no one danced differently (took her part). And the dance pattern in the 1st and 2nd bridge were the same, Irene - Joy - together.
Nope because of YERI LACKING SKILLS they changed the hardness of the choreography lower :( If yeri wasn't added rv would have been powerful for their performance
Ppl are saying they love the new chore and so do I, it’s because Yeri really changed the mood of Red Velvet and I love her so much you can tell she was always suppose to be in the group you can hear her!!! 💜
![[KPOP IN PUBLIC] Red Velvet Automatic Dance Cover by JUST](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qRYSa3Bv_GE/mqdefault.jpg)
![[KPOP IN PUBLIC] Red Velvet Automatic Dance Cover by JUST](/img/tr.png)
the iconic sm cloud background
b--bu--but seulgi you can't split. shookt
Seulgi the Dancing Bear
We have been lied . Our life is a lie she can split ! Deym
Seulgi...how dare you😢😠
@@graciasilverio204 I feel betrayed and Slayed!! I also saw a recent clip of her winking! YOU CAN JUST TELL US YOU CAN DO ANYTHING. WE BELIEVE PERFECTION EXIST,MS KANG.
@@secretgirl3931 But I've thinking, she knows how to make the devil cry so this shouldn't be impossible.
Seulgi the Dancing Bear hahahaha lol i love your humor were the same. Anyways yas! Seulgi is a liar she just want to pretend shes not perfect . Poor seulgi stans unsuspecting souls dont know theyre dealing with the devil 😂
It took more than 4 yrs for it to be shown in public. This is great leg work and harmonized movements. ❤ red velvet
Seulgi can do a split 😂😭😭
@blackvelvet I also noticed it since I keep on replaying that portion, but damns she’s so good 💕💕
@blvckvelvet actually she once said that she can do it but now she lost the split
when did she do the splits? i didnt see it
BLACKPINK_InYourArea/ IsTheRevolution it was at 0:55 she is the one at the back 🤣
@@Chrislittlememory when did she say that?
Low key feel robbed but i also really like the new choreo 😭
I want to see Red velvet to do more velvet concepts with these sort of dances
Irene dances really well when she doesn't have to wear heels. I wish that they could perform in flats so she could show her full potential as a dancer
i’m still inlove with thick joy
you know
JOYYYYYY SHE'S ALREADY HAVE SEXY VIBE BEFORE HER DEBUT
Sexy dynamite even before debut😍💚
Overall i definitely prefer the final Automatic choreo, but seeing this completely different choreo is so interesting. This one is more smooth and feels more seductive in comparison to the final choreo which is very sharp. It still amazes me how the dance could really change the mood of the song, and how two different people could interpret the same song in differing ways. And reveluvs, hate me all u want but i think this makes it seem even more that yeri wasn’t part of the inital plan for rv. Obviously we cant hear the original audio, so who’s to say it did or didn’t include yeri’s voice, but she isn’t practicing with the rest of the girls despite this being predebut and the dance seems like it was made specifically with four in mind. I love yeri so so much and am so proud of everything they’ve achieved as five, but sometimes videos from before make me think what really was sm’s intial plan for Red Velvet?? My wild conspiracy theory (but not really) is they were planning on doing Automatic after Happiness, but due to some issues (possibly sulli leaving?) they had to add yeri, but they also had to wait for her to reach a certain age due to the new laws that came into place. So they released Be Natural instead (which was probably gonna be part of a velvet album with Automatic) using the choreo that we saw from predebut irene and seulgi. I think they were gonna really commit to the dual concept, like they were planning on releasing full on r&b and soul type of music with choreo such as this that was more alluring and such. But they were also gonna do Red, however I don’t think they would’ve gone down the more “childish” route which we see in Rookie and Power Up. BUT its 3am rn and i should be sleeping so honestly dont mind me. This is all for fun, stan rv❤️
Carol No that happens with grouos sometimes i.e. Twice
SM could have had a really cool plan for red velvet but they added Yeri who was 16 throwing the concept off.
S Rogers Thats true, MANY groups stray from their original concept. It’s just with the POSSIBLY unplanned and spontaneous addition of yeri, i wonder if their concept wouldn’t have became as youthful without her addition due to the other four being older and more mature. With twice though i do see it a bit different cause they had sixteen. I agree with those people who say jyp already had an idea of who he wanted in the group and used the show to finalize members and see what the public wanted. So the addition of (if i remember correctly) momo and dahyun (?), was unplanned too i guess. For twice i think they were going for a very flirty kinda girl crush concept like ooh aah, but cause of their huge burst of popularity with cheer up, they decided to stick to that genre of very pop, public friendly and catchy songs. So i guess they too strayed from what i believe to be their original plan, but for me the addition of yeri makes me see things differently when really they might not be that different or as crazy behind the scenes.
@@restinplace1464 or it could be that Yeri wasn't in here because she was at school
Nana Smith despite what I said in my original post, I actually can’t imagine RV w/o Yeri’s voice. She lends so much to their velvet tracks since her voice color(?) is so unique. That comment was so long ago and i was so tired lol. It was mostly just my night time ramblings. RV could definitely still go down the sexy sophisticated route now since their international audience seems to like their velvet tracks more. Unfortunately SM doesn’t give them many opportunities to showcase that side anymore. I would KILL to see them have a full on velvet concert with a live band and with them performing songs like So Good, Light Me Up, Kingdom Come and their feature in Close to Me!!
Well i think there is 2 theory
1.SM will added 1 member every comeback
2.a sub unit concept just like NCT
This is only a guess. I bet they used the pre-debut or original audio in the practice but since it’s not leaked anywhere, the uploader had to use the audio where they already debuted.
👍
The real song on this video is be natural.
EVISUS if u actually read their lips, they’re singing along to the automatic lines.
@@lowqualitypepero well its actually not the deal
open.spotify.com/episode/2jEd15GUa3mp6ve7CovCma?si=ERbwY5CIRSGXU-Va0J-shA&t=2029&dl_branch=1
listen to this podcast! the producers of 'Automatic' told that they made the song after Red Velvet had made dance choreo. They said RV danced to a Janet Jackson's song and SM asked them to make the song for this kind of choreo. They said they saw video with 4 girls in a dance studio... I guess it's this one.
Watching this in the year 2020, and there's one thing I've noticed.
Their choreography here is much more like the S.E.S type of dance
Same
Automatic's final choreo imo is much better. Nonetheless, this was nice to see.
Who would have guessed that they were actually dancing to a Janet Jackson song or that Automatic was written for this choreography!!!
Truee they were dancing to her song Got til it's gone. It's really an amazing fact!
SEULGI CAN SPLIT OMG :')
when they did the split i think i stopped breathing for a minute. the new choreo does not do this song justice
Lol wayment the OFFICIAL choreo is miles superior than this
Lmao what? Tye original choreo is WAYYYY more classier than this... This is such a basic choreo with moves that feel like they're just flexing how well rv can dance the original choreo moves along with the rythym with the song unlike this
Taehyung's BUTCHEEKS yes i agree p e r i o d
This was amazing!! Look at how in sync and fluid they were! Wendy really needs to give herself more credit as a dancer. Joy was sensual as a dancer even back then and Seulgi and Irene both look like main dancers!!
I wonder what they would've been like as OT4, but glad they added Yeri later on.
Thanks to whoever leaked this!!
I feel like Wendy can definitely be a great dancer if she's being trained longer in dancing. she seems really good in some basic hiphop movements and her angles and energy are always on point. She just needs to continue working on her fluidity. (which seems she does improve since Bad Boy)
I absolutely agree! Wendy in FMR showed that she's definitely improved with being more fluid with her movements. I'm so impressed with her dancing even back then and even more so today.
This video can prove that RV can dance. They're so talented
I really like this version...almost a bit better. And when Joy was still chubby -- cute!
I've been waiting for this for years...it was pure torture only seeing pics of this😭💗
Holy shittt... Irene!!!!!
Yeah Irene's dance was so good & smooth here. So satisfying to see. My eyes are blessed. 😍💓
This is a whole different choreography compared to the final ones, props to them for not messing up the choreography while performing it
The original owner (someone who leaked this changed the audio to automatic with yeri but the real audio on this video is just the aumatic demo ver)
i’m the mic on the ground it’s so relatable
the moves are so beautiful
the dance kinda weird because the video use an audio from the current automatic song. if the video use the actual audio the dance will be fit. I guess automatic maybe a follow up after happiness era to introduce their velvet side but SM change their plan and use be natural instead.
Jinyoung and Mark i wonder how the demo Automatic sounds
Man this choreo is way better plz do this one with yeri
1:32 Irene and Wendy prolly holding their laughs
i'm so shookt at irene.. mean, she's all out here😳 dances so well💯
Park soo Young 😍😍😍
Fetus Velvet 😭😭
i prefer this choreo than the final because it has much more sultry vibe
JUST LOOK AT MY QUEENS.
Idk but for me they are sync. Maybe because they are red velvet
Thisshows their perfect timing and syncing. Love this! Wish others would appreciate their dance more than they do. 💚💙💛💖💜
Omygod I love that part in 2:18!
can we all appreciate how toned wendys lower body
Gracias por subirlo!!! ♥️
wig has been snatched.
darn those hair flip gurl!
This song is so nostalgic💖
thank u for uploading this, really. bless u
they are so in sync
The fact that they did front splits which is such a hard thing to do amazes me.
감사합니다ㅠㅠ 안무 유출해주셔서ㅠㅠ
Thank you for leaking our choreography
Hopefully, they will perform the full choreography with 5 members in the future.
I prefer ot4 Automatic better so when they are performing Automatic later they should exempt Yeri for the stage
th-cam.com/video/VQkyltFHIfM/w-d-xo.html
Present for you!!!!
They practiced this song even before Yeri joined and even when Yeri joined she still captivated with her presence.
ATTA GIRL KIM YERIM! 👏
I don't think it's the song. I'm pretty sure it was put over it. Cause you can hear Yeri's voice in the video.
honestly i prefer this choreo wtf sm
I got so scared that someone would trip on the mic
I love the split part tho
omg so they were actually dancing to Janet Jackson’s Got Til It’s Gone here….
I like this dance BETTER tbh😍
Hope the next come back they will show this vibe again. Btw I think Irene is main dancer along with Seulgi in group, not just a lead dancer. Recently her face expression may not be as good as Seulgi but she still dance very strong and neat
Seulgi! I thought you can’t split!
Irene's moves is sooo clean
Okay i must wendy looks bomb as hell 🔥🔥
I swear if they dont perform automatic with this choreo, i’ll be SO ANGRY
Our bear can do split😭😭🐻
SEULGI DID SPLITS‼️ SHES BEEN HIDING HER TALENT WEVE BEEN BAMBOOZLED
Aug 2019 everyone?? Mga panahong kaya pang magsplit ng ganyan ni Seul HAHAHAHAHAHHA
The fact that we can hear yeri's voice proves that she was meant to debut with with red velvet
I bet they used the pre-debut or original audio in the practice but since it’s not leaked anywhere, the uploader had to use the audio where they already debuted. Only my guess.
Sorry to break your imagination, but danced to the demo version for this dance practice,
@@kathmaessiyes you are right
@@kathmaessi I thought that, I'm just an ot5 trash😂
@@5690라뤂리 it's not that deep, you don't have to be rude
Omg THE SKY BACKGROUND
their hair were so healthy😢
Seulgi😘😘😘
Yall saying something about seulgi's split. Im just here cuz i wanna see rv in that old sm background
In the same room Shinee practiced and danced 😢
It's SM one of the famous practice room..
Clouds Room
redvelvet 😭
so intersting to see them (specially Irene) with their hair so long. Also, wheres Seulgi doing the slipts?? I can't find it...
ALIV 0:55
Seulgi bear? Seriously she can do a split
How much hair do you want
Red velvet: YES
Woah. There was a mic on the floor the whole time
Even back then their Queens showed XD
We can hear Katy part..😭😭💗💗
Anyway, I like this coreo than the finish coreo
This coreo so lit
Sorry my English
Please don't hate me but I think the video and audio are different, I mean we really don't know if they dance to automatic ot5 or (ot4) version, maybe the real uploader edit the video so we can't hear the ot4/demo version. If you look at it again, on 1.16 it's yeri's voice but the one that dancing was irene. Well that's my thoughts
I agree,,its possible different too,,or maybe they used demo version at that time,,,who know
If yeri was there, she would be beside irene dancing with her. But she wasn't so irene had to do her part.
I only know bangtan sonedon I don't think so because in 0.27 when yeri's voice was coming out, no one danced differently (took her part). And the dance pattern in the 1st and 2nd bridge were the same, Irene - Joy - together.
@@aiyendiei2394 she just has to just dance with them, i mean it was only 3 seconds of her singing so she didnt have much of a part
SEULGI💛
The choreography of this version looks as hard as the ot5 version.
Nope because of YERI LACKING SKILLS they changed the hardness of the choreography lower :( If yeri wasn't added rv would have been powerful for their performance
Finally the bear's split😂
This choreo is so sexy aaaaaah and the slpit part tho :( I wish they keep thos choreo
Just in case anyone didn't know.
Those clouds block the actual mirrors lul. You can sweep that up.
Seulgi can split???my whole life is a lie
Predebut but featuring Yeri's vocals😂😂
I hear Yeri's voice. And the split shocked me! Seulgi can do it lol
omg i didn't know this dance practice exists
This gives me hard taemin-move dance vibes love ittt
i wish this song wasn’t so underrated
joy looks so cute here i miss her maknae days
WHO SAID WENDY WASNT GOOD AT DANCING
Wendy is my favorite dancer. People are blind asf when it comes to Wendy's dancing.
Ppl are saying they love the new chore and so do I, it’s because Yeri really changed the mood of Red Velvet and I love her so much you can tell she was always suppose to be in the group you can hear her!!! 💜
It wasn't for automatic. I'm pretty sure it was an unleased song. The original video had a different song
1:51 poor mic, lying on the ground with 4 sexy ladies...so lucky yet so poor xDDD
The mic just keeps creeping me out haha
Wow
Irenneee oh sht
I think ot5 version is the best 💜💜
Joy has been sexy dynamite since debut🔥
4인 오토매틱안무영상 어디서 유출해왔음ㅋㅋㅋ 레게노네 ㅋㅋ
I'm your 100th sub
I just realize yeri's voice in this song, that means yeri was record the song before her debut
Of course the ot5 ver was recorded before Yerimie's debut, but I guess they had ot4 version before taking the solution about adding new member
No, the audio was edited by op. The song was ot4
IS THAT THE REAL SEULGI?? I MEAN, SHE CAN DO SPLIT DURING HER PRE-DEBUT DAYS??
Seulgi você prometeu que não sabia fazer espacate
The time when Irene was the main dancer
And Wendy is the Visual