f(x) Amber Liu is a Girl IY2 eng subs
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 21 ส.ค. 2024
- All the times Amber was mistaken as a guy, compared to a guy, etc. on Invincible Youth 2
I also put Hyoyeon and Amber wrestling in there :3 let me know if I left anything out.....
eng sub episodes: southkoreaaddic...
+ I DO NOT OWN ANYTHING NO COPYRIGHT INTENDED +
![맥시멀리스트 채정안 집 청소 (브라이언X뱀뱀X채정안) [청소광 브라이언 2화 하이라이트 240820 방송]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IWwmteYMFQ4/mqdefault.jpg)
She's laughing but deep inside it hurts, even if it's a joke
Yeah I can see it in her smile that she’s hurt 😞
Yeah I always feel so bad when people mistake her for a guy
I love you Amber Liu I hope you can see this comment 😢😢😢.
Lots of love 😘😘😘😘❤️❤️❤️🐴🐴😍😍 from me and my horse Banana
Ikr!! That's so shitty asking them if she's a man or woman...🤦♀😭
Don't worry other people keep confusing on tomboy with short hair
A lot of people make jokes but I would pick Amber over any other "feminine" girl. She's down to earth and really beautiful. Plus she's everyone's girl crush. Well at least she's mine :)
i think its right to say everyone huhu amber is so lovable
Mee too 🇧🇪🇧🇪😘😘😘😘🐴🐴
dont worry my dad thought g dragon was a girl
+Kyra Valley WHAT AHAHAH
+DeviL19o4 yea I should him big bang and he asked why a girl was in a group with 4 boys. I asked him who he thought the girl was and he pointed at GD. I couldn't stop laughing for like 10 minutes.
+Kyra Valley LOL was it from the Fantastic Baby MV? XD
'cause like, my brother thought the same when I was showing it to him
0ttoke yesss
Kyra Valley But well that's just because he's beautiful
i think it hurts her when people mistaken her as a boy!!
even if she doesnt attmit it and always smiles i really think that it really hurts her .... and that makes me sad !
yeah, i read in an interview that she said she can't help but be hurt by it.
that really makes me sad :( I was a tomboy growing up and i would always feel self-conscience when people mistook me for a boy so it made me start dressing girlier, even though I'm still a tomboy.
Jamie Lynn Well usually if a girl dresses like a boy they mean to come off as one. Sometimes people are transgender and others will most likely see them as the opposite gender. Amber is just a tomboy. And honestly I've never been or felt bi but she's pretty hot.
+kidimaus1 omg i have that sam pic of pukachu
+kidimaus1 i think it hurts her as well, though she understands why it happens. I hate wearing girly things and at one point i had short hair and would be mistaken for a guy quite often, and every time it happened i would get offended even though i knew that i was consciously dressing more masculine
as someone who dresses and looks lik3 amber. Like I hav3 short hair, and I'm Korean, but I like men's clothes better because their more of a loose fit and less revealing. Cause I grew up in a struck Christian family, we're we never had shorts shorter than our knees or word tank tops out of respect for our elders. I can tell you I dress for comfort, and I don't mind that people mistake me for a guy sometimes cause I don5 blame them. but let me tell you it does hurt a lot sometimes, especially when I'm in the bathroom and people accuse m3 of being a pervert or in the wrong bathroom and make a fuss. or when people assume because I dress more masculine they assume I'm gay or like girls and boys. Like I have no problem with being gay, but I have a problem that the assume I'm gay just based of the way I dress. or if I get scared or do something "girly" people get freaked out and are like I thought you liked bugs or like sport or something stupid. and it's like man just let me live dude. why you gotta assume I don't act girly cause I wear shorts and a t-shirt. Haha. so amber might laugh it off, but I'm sure it hurts a little inside
Amber is a perfect example of an idol who wants to be themselves. She has always been a tomboy, even when she had long hair. In my opinion, I would choose Amber out of any other idols. She's true to herself, funny, caring, and cute ^·^
I find it funny that they always think she's a guy, in America I think that wouldn't happen as much, because Tomboys are far more common, and also in Korea guys are often more "feminine" looking (from a Western standpoint). It's like how a lot of Westerners think guys like Jaejoong are girls, but for those of us who are used to it don't understand how they could think that. XD
I think in Korea they're still more used to "feminine" girls, and Amber's tomboyish-ness is more unusual. I honestly think Amber is really pretty! Just in a tomboyish way. She doesn't look like a guy in that her features are more guy-ish (when she wears makeup and feminine clothes she looks way more feminine!!!), it's just her hair and clothing style.
Well I found it hard to believe that shes a girl I mean I wouldve at least thought she was a girl if she sounded like one she really sounds like a guy too 0_0 but I agree that she would look prettier with long hair and girly clothes^^
Roger Rabbit I didn't mean that she looks prettier in girly clothes, just that she looks more feminine. I think she's really pretty just the way she is. :) A girl doesn't have to have long hair and dress "girly" to be beautiful. ^^ I also don't think her voice is like a guys. In America lots of girls have slightly lower voices, so to my ears she sounds normal. Although this is just my opinion! As I said, it honestly just depends on where you are from. :)
ForeverCellist yep I guess you're right^^ but I also dont think I'm wrong either since that was just my opinion^^
Roger Rabbit I never said you were wrong! ^^ You're entitled to your own opinion. :)
Yup yup I agree! :)
For me, this is not funny 'cause I'm one of a big fan of amber and I think they're hurting her feelings
+Alysha Mempin same here
Yub!
+Alysha Mempin Its actually sad :(. She tries to smile but shes hurt...
same here
I feel like she's just an awkward potato like me, tbh. When I had shorter hair, and was younger (as in without any boobs) I was constantly asked if I was male or female xD
After Amber's solo I hope people will stop doing this to her. She said that she used to be picked on a lot and it really hurt her feelings. Amber is beautiful inside and out! She is whatever she identify herself as.
Is not funny... they are hurting Amber...
korean grandmas dont care about her feelings
I love how she breaks the entire cute/sexy/super girly style from the kpop industry! She is so cool! Love you Amber!
i feel really sad for amber. when those awkward moments when trying to say that 'I AM A GIRL'. it is her own style and after all these teasing amber still didnt like change her style to more girly, i feel so proud of her :D AMBER MY BIAS
the thing i don't get is that a lot of male idols look feminine and it's okay, but if it's the other way around, it's not :( i don't think anyone would mistaken amber for a guy if she was living in america
lilx0dummie Why do you think that? I'm a girl and people have mistaken me as a boy just because I wore a hoodie and covered my head. Btw this took place in America.
+lilx0dummie amber is a tomboy from America and is mistaken for a boy while here many of the feminine k-pop boys do get mistaken for being a girl. The only reason I do not mistake the really feminine ones anymore is the fact that bands are all one gender so if there is one androgynous if you can tell everyone else gender the androgynous will have the gender of the others.
A lot of you are saying how you'd be offended if constantly mistaken as a boy, and I can see where you're coming from. But Amber has even said that she does not blame anyone for making that assumption. Although she does get offended when people antagonize or don't believe her.
I remember Ella Chen when I think of Amber. Ella Chen's sexuality has been in question a few times because she does not conform to the barbie girl image of a female pop star and has a deep voice (deeper than Amber's in my opinion). I am glad Amber is in kpop to show everyone that being your own beautiful self is never a bad thing even if it defies the dictated standard of the society. She's talented, sweet, funny, and just lovable. She looks perfectly fine and really PRETTY even if she dresses up like a boy. I love that she's not trying to be those idols with too much made-up swag...she has a right amount of natural swag and that makes her cooler.
I love Ella Chen, though it pained me when in the Taiwanese adaptation of Hana kimi, the fans said she looked too much like a boy and was ugly. The main story itself was about a Tomboy who fell in love but couldnt tell the guy sje loved that she was a girl....anyway basically they watched the korean version, and went on to make noise...about how ella chen looked.
When i saw the comments I overlooked it. then i watched it and ella was adorable XD
zekegul3150 Despite the fact that Ella defies the beauty standards set by the showbiz world, she is gorgeous in her own skin. She's a tomboy and embraces her not-girly self. She nailed Hana Kimi and in my opinion, TTBY was not at par to it. Don't get me wrong, I like Sulli a lot and I think she did well but Ella is too convincing that it's too hard to dettach her from the character after many years. I really wish Amber and Ella can do a collab, that'd be wonderful! Or f(x) and SHE. That's gonna be daebak!
Zee Taylor I concur, still rewatch ella's version of hana kimi till date
zekegul3150 I think I rewatched the whole series more than four times. I still have a copy of the series stored in my PC. 😁 It's one of the very few series I can really watch all over again and have the same feeling like it was the first time. Ella and Wu Chun plus the comical skills of Jiro Wang with the sprinkle of Danson Tang's fab self made Hana Kimi one of the best manga-to-live-action series across Asia. I think I am gonna rewatch it, too. 😄😁
Though I would like a sequel/season 2 **sigh**
aww, amber . I can tell she is not happy and trying to laugh so hard :(
This is so rude. Can I everyone get off her freaking beautiul feminine back? She's clearly a girl. If she wants to dress androgynous ly its her choice.
amber always mistaken as a guy because she doesn't look like a girl.. they felt weird with a girl who looks like a guy, but they usually adore a guy who looks like a girl.. sometimes koreans are just weird regarding gender thing.. hahaa
I don't get why people think she's a dude! She clearly looks like a girl with soft features.
exactly I always show people her picture and ask: Is she a guy or a girl? 9/10 they say boy, but I get confused because the first time I saw her I knew she was a girl.
because often asian males do have soft features and look very much like girls. that's why crossdressing isn't that uncommon in asia
At first I thought she was a male, as korean males look very feminine. I never stated it out loud though, I just kept it to myself. She's one of my top favorite artists now.
That smile has a lot of pain hidden......u can see that clearly
Poor Amber... I know how she feels....
when they said that amber was the one who's jealous (sumthing like that) at suzy because all men likes her, i was like what the H xDD i probably think that more men likes amber noona :PP she has more fanboys :P
i love yah amber liu ♡♥♡ :D
i think they assume that guy she has the boy look to her when in reality she has a hugh fan fallowing cause shes sexy to both male and female and sher confidence is on point
she's the one her male friends can openly admit they like her even in a platonic way. most guys can't say they like a girl as a friend without being misunderstood and stuff
Lol hyoyeon! Touching Amber's butt! And the caption "Do you like it?" xD
I wish I could pull off short hair the way amber does, even if I were mistaken for a boy. Long hair is a bitch >:(
I feel you
You know what I love about Amber the most. The fact that people tease her about or falsely assume her gender, yet not once does she determine to dress differently or act any different. That's why we love Amber. She's beautiful and follows her passion in life. I am very tomboyish, and I allow others to control how I dress, but Amber makes me want to fight that and become the tomboy girl that I am. That's beautiful.
It happened too much to be coincidental on this show alone but especially when you take other shows Amber was on into account. I think people were told by SM before a show started that it was ok to use that as a gag whenever they wanted, because SM always played on her androgynous clothes & hair style from the moment she was put in f(x). Years later Amber did say outright that it always bothered her when anyone knew she was a woman but still made "jokes" or comments that she was a guy, looked like a guy, was binding her chest to look like a guy, or counted as a guy in games because she was athletic. She said she understood strangers making a mistake, but once informed then the subject should be dropped. The show went through that whole introduction to the town, where they met most of them. Everyone knew the show would only have female singers cause that was the point of the show. It wouldn't be funny if boys came to learn about farming & fishing & such. Yet at least 1 person out of every visitor group just HAD to mistake her for a guy, despite that she's not the only one with small enough breasts that her shape was hidden by those baggy work clothes & winter coats? No, it wasn't a coincidence.
Lmao hyoyeon expression when she touched amber's butt xp
That whole wrestling part seriously cracked me up XD
realindream hyoyeon get premium to touch Amber's booty 😂
Iam glad she stayed true to herself
she is amazing just the way she is. She is so special, unique, kind-hearted, warm, and adorable, genius and she is really pretty(I'm not even joking, she is really pretty inside and outside, that's why I love her) she is perfect
Amber don't Change for anybody
💙💜
Damn that was a lot of times on just one show. But i know how she feels when people mistake her for a boy. Happens to me all the time. I just got used to it and don't correct people especially if i know we will never see each other again.
Who gives a fuck if she looks a little boyish?? I love that about her. She's one of the female idols that looks hella good looking like that. And it may look like she's laughing but I know from experience that it hurts.
amber is like haruhi from ouran high school host club. many thinks she's a guy but if she wears something girly, she will be the cutest/prettiest girl everr d:
Amber breaking gender roles since forever! we stan a real queen that made a real change❤️
I dress comfortably by just wearing a shirt, jeans and sneakers and even used to have very short hair and people assumed I'm a lesbian. People need to know that being a tomboy and lesbian are two different people although you can be both but being a tomboy doesn't mean you're always going to be a lesbian.
If I was Amber id be offended
I don't think it's that big of a deal and I dont think she takes it too seriously. When I was younger I was a super tom boy. And even during family reunions aunts and uncles would say to my mum "I didn't know you have another son??". Being mistaken for a boy didn't hurt me, but being made fun of for being mistaken for a boy hurt me. These people are just unknowingly mistaking Amber for a boy, which I never found a offensive.
if just I have a friend like her, my life will not be this boring. she is moodbuster
LOL taeyeon's byun-ness is spreading to everyone over at SNSD
This happens to me too... So Amber you're not alone 💜
Great compilation !! I love Amber.
I really like tomboyish girls because I m also a Tomboy and I want more tomboy friends
I really just do not understand how anyone can take one look at Amber and think she's a boy. Everything about her says "female" to me. She's so cute and funny and talented and sweet. To me, she's the sexiest girl in K-Pop right now
I feel like she went thru too much with this non-sense bs of making fun of her & teasing her that they think she’s a man!! Smfh!! I’m sure she feels so low & little from this..
No offense but those older people were just being rude
This is actually heartbreaking.
I’m still here in 2022 simping for amber still
I want Amber to go on Running Man so bad!!
***** Yes! I know! I can't wait!...Is that enough exclamation marks! ;)
She is still so unique
It's 12 am and I'm laughing so haaarrrrddd the part when Amber say "She touched my butt" 😂😂😂😂
It hurts to feel like Amber sometimes, always got misunderstood. But it's alright Amber, just like ur song "Borders" - "Stand Up, Fall down, Up Again! Up against, the pressure I'm in". We love you being yourself despite what other people say about you. xoxo
Amber is beautiful with an awesome personality, can it get better?
I totally related to Amber on this. Yeah, it can be annoying but all that she can do is laughing and act like it's nothing though actually sometimes it feels like you want to hit that person or at least tell them in sarcastic way that you're a damn girl. :p
I love how she tricks older Korean people into believing she's a guy without her having to do or say anything.
I feel bad for her, but at the same time I love her! :D Amber, fighting!
Wait, her name is Eunyeong in Korean??
tbh i'm not f(x) fan but i do love Amber.. such a cool girl..
"She touched my butt!" she is so cute!! :3
i can feel how sad she is when she is a girl and they think she is boy . don't worry unnie we love you .^^ just the way u are
"Amber Liu rocks"
My mom, siblings ,cousins says jimin is a girl 😅
Omg I'm not a crazy fan or anything but I am so much like Amber. I'm a HUGE tomboy, with an unusually deep voice for a girl : )
Luv her
Same with me
in my situation if people mistaken that im a guy a just smile to the people .. if people make me fun i just smile but actually i dont like it .. if i was in the situation of amber when hyoyeon and her wrestled i dont want anybody touches my private parts of my body too that would be awkward and uncomfortable i really know what amber feels xD
Amber's cute the way she is. I think she looks appealing, but who cares about looks? If she identifies as a girl, she's a girl, in this video some of the jokes were just playful, but I think it's insensitive to assume she's a guy. (Don't hate, just my opinion on what's right.)
I don't think this hurts her feelings. I think she knows that she is androgynous and I think she knows that being androgynous is pretty. I think this confirms to her, her androgynous beauty and I think she likes being androgynous. If she wouldn't like being androgynous she would have tried to look more feminine.
LOL..Did you guys notice that the sweater Amber is wearing at :19 was the same one Sandeul from B1A4 wore during one of their performance of Beautiful Target.
It really bothers me how much they tease and pick at her. I hope she doesn't let it get to her because she's first in our hearts
i think people mistaken her as a boy bcuz she is part of kpop and just a kpoper can say that who is boy or girl in kpop and she is always with boys, but i think llama is kpop sexiest girl :))))
Mini Donghae :)
they are so rude, poor Amber, you are a very pretty girl. don't be sad. there is few girl like you in korea, so they are misunderstand you. there are many boy style girls in us and taiwan. it not strange. everyone has their right to choose what they want to be.
I really like her style makes her look even cuter
If it looks like a duck, walks like a duck and sounds like a duck, is it a platypus?
Just stop.
people are so rude sometimes
just honest
OMG, Amber and Hyoyeon, my two ultimate girl biases together! I'm actually really happy :)
Amber is really pretty and she's a beautiful girl ♡♡♡♡
"What could I do to appeal myself more to boys like Suzy?"
"Who's problem could it be?"
"언영!"
I'm like, "Amber has all them pretty boys wrapped around her fingers. Duh!"
🤣🤣 Yeah, the men immediately guessed Amber, but all the other girls knew it wasn't her because she had (& still has) guys flocking around her all the time & had already been proposed to at least once in person that was caught on camera (almost 2 years earlier @ the age of 17 during f(x)'s trip to Africa). Plus she was constantly having guys as well as girls online in the comments section of videos ask her out/ask her to marry them.
At least she doesn't get offended by it lol
i love amber ♥ ^^ she's so cute and funny ♥♥
If it looks like a duck, sounds like a duck and acts like a duck, then it must be a duck. Or could it be a platypus is disguise?
This really really hurt me 😭💜
Amber has the best smile. It's just kind of unfortunate (hilarious, but unfortunate) that she kept having to use it in response to people thinking she was a dude. XD
awww... there must be sadness behind Amber's laughter when others called her a boy... though it can be normal for ppl to wonder if she's a boy or girl if u don't know her, but that's offensive and can be insulting for her :(
Amber..the coolest gurl!!
She was so cool and fun in every part of this video but the last one honestly i didn't expected amber to...😑😔
i hate this tbfh. too offensive for her. why don't they ask her nicely .
I love the old guy talking english! Like Oh escuse! Or his way pronoucing Wait! MDR
That's her korean name. Tiffany, Jessica (SNSD), Krystal (f(x)) & Nicole (Kara) also have a Korean name
because amber is too handsome for a girl. :))))
"do you like it" :'''''DDDDD
I loved when Tae Jin-ah defended Ambers girlhood.
Eunyeong is just a name her Korean American friends gave her back in LA :)
I think it's because Korean guys look more feminine
Ok that’s heartbreaking
Amber's so cute lol. She makes a cute boy when dressed boyish but also makes a sexy girl when she's dolled up.
Isn't it disrespectful for people to say that to her? Aren't we developed enough to know what's right and what's wrong to say?
LMAO I WONDER WHAT ARE THEIR REACTIONS TO JEONGHAN BEFORE
LOL poor Amber. I love her, she's super cute.
I think.. If one day she wears a dress.. She'll be the most beautiful girl in KPOP :3
Amber and Jeongyeon are honestly the strongest people in the kpop industry. They just feel more comfortable with shorter hair and comfy clothes. What's so hard about that
lmao, Hyoyeon is making trouble to Amber. xD
I'm sorry i feel so ashamed its because i didnt know if amber was a girl or boy at first either but i could kinda tell she was a girl because of her eyes and it confused me more because she was hanging out with girls and boys (i know its okay for a girl to be friends with boys) but she is the first female that i know that hangs out with boys because some girls do but its usually 1-4 friends that are boys and she has way more friends that are boys than 4 but i feel bad that she gets thought of as a boy
At least here we don't have a seperate calling for woman and man
Who hates it when someone calls you a boy cuz you have short hair? I have short hair and people say I look like a guy with kinda a same name as me like I'm not him.
'She touched my butt,' ahahaha oh Amber, so shy and adorable!!! Saranghae unnie!