Yeah I had an idea of doing a similar scenario, but you really killed it with this upload. The music was on point, the memes were really entertaining, overall a great job! I'm glad I didn't make a video on this, as yours is simply better! Keep it up!
Good video, but here are some mistakes i've found Germany was on its way to get defeated, they just didn't simply surrender, the 100 days offensive was a military offensive in northern france that pushed the germans back and were on their way to retake Belgium. Poland would have never taken pomerania, and historically poland only wanted to take south prussia and silesia (Google 1920 east prussia and silesia plebiscite) and would have never called its self poland-prussia or something like that. Regardless of that, its a fun and entertaining video to watch, so thumbs up
I do know about the 100 days offensive and it does reflect on the map it's just that in this scenario Germany is better internally so maybe they don't collapse. Regarding Poland-Prussia yhe that's not historical it's more of a cursed map type of thing. I like to do those things because by the end of the scenario things have changed a lot and the timeline wold begin to stop resembling ours. Also I had Poland-Prussia in one of my hoi mods so I wanted to put that in a video.
@@Porphyrios.History As someone who is equal part Polish and German, the imperial German borders of 1914 are too good to mess with. If I was in charge of drawing the map of Europe, that would be Germany, and Poland would receive much of their PLC glory day lands.
Great scenario! I’m excited about part 2 of the initial scenario. The first few minutes feel too edited, but the rest is nice and comfortable to watch :)
The Habsburg could still rule over Austria if they would join Germany, the German Empire was a federal monarchy with multiple kings, since it also is a federal country since the very beginning, each king being basically a prime minister of their state like Wittelsbach or Wettin. If it wasn't like this, Germany wouldn't have unified, and that's why the Kaiser is called German Kaiser and not Kaiser of Germany, since the Kaiser wasn't the king of every German state. Alternative histories never go that deep into this detail of the German politics and that would make a big difference. Like who would think that if Austria would join the German Empire, that the Habsburg would be replaced by someone else, like which other royal family would rule over Austria that is Austrian? Especially since Hungary already had and always had their own king that is not Habsburg. Also a conditional surrender would be the only fair and righteous thing to do and the thing that would prevent a war like ww2, only the vile and evil nations would not want to negotiate peace. So the first presented timeline is a good one. I would prefer that Elsaß would go to Germany and Lothringen, even if it has majority German, can be given to France as compromise if the rights of Germans living there gonna be guaranteed.
As far as I know the ottomans had a large enough army for what they were facing. Maybe a better economy and industry would have helped more. I will defiantly do more Ottoman empire in the future however.
I assume he might since I am giving Germany the benefit of the doubt but honestly I haven't thought about it or the colonies since it was not a decisive part of the war.
If the german high command foresaw the results of world war 1 back in the 1880s, i think they'd drop austria-hungary and try to get russia as an ally first thing😂😂😂😂
@@Porphyrios.History At the start of the video, you said that France had the Soviets as an ally, which is strange because the Soviet Union didn't exist at that time. I know you meant the Russian Empire though.
![ILLSLICK X YOUNGOHM - We're The same [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/yUJNkobYR0E/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Live] : ONE FIGHT NIGHT 26 วันนี้!! “คริสเตียน vs อาลิเบก”](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/UlIiZ3t8nHQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Surely the Kaiserreich will rise and defeat the entente in this scenario right?….right?
I mean maybe
No but the Badenreich will dominate
Sure?
@@laisphinto6372lol
They will land in London uk will join the empire and France will fall
Yeah I had an idea of doing a similar scenario, but you really killed it with this upload. The music was on point, the memes were really entertaining, overall a great job! I'm glad I didn't make a video on this, as yours is simply better! Keep it up!
Thank you so much! It does mean a lot coming from a professional!
"I didn't hear no bell"- Germany 1918
Good video, but here are some mistakes i've found
Germany was on its way to get defeated, they just didn't simply surrender, the 100 days offensive was a military offensive in northern france that pushed the germans back and were on their way to retake Belgium.
Poland would have never taken pomerania, and historically poland only wanted to take south prussia and silesia (Google 1920 east prussia and silesia plebiscite) and would have never called its self poland-prussia or something like that.
Regardless of that, its a fun and entertaining video to watch, so thumbs up
I do know about the 100 days offensive and it does reflect on the map it's just that in this scenario Germany is better internally so maybe they don't collapse. Regarding Poland-Prussia yhe that's not historical it's more of a cursed map type of thing. I like to do those things because by the end of the scenario things have changed a lot and the timeline wold begin to stop resembling ours. Also I had Poland-Prussia in one of my hoi mods so I wanted to put that in a video.
@@Porphyrios.History Poland Prussia does seem kinda cursed but at the same time funny. Also the editing is very nice.
@@flateric-man5759 Glad you enjoyed because from what I have see a lot of people get angry when Poland gets German territory
@@Porphyrios.History As someone who is equal part Polish and German, the imperial German borders of 1914 are too good to mess with. If I was in charge of drawing the map of Europe, that would be Germany, and Poland would receive much of their PLC glory day lands.
@@nathanbean8763 yeah, Germany intact and Poland got Lithuania, Latvia and parts of Ukraine and Belarus and it would be perfect.
Now I’m really hoping for a what if the German high command traveled from the future
It's coming some day
Great scenario! I’m excited about part 2 of the initial scenario. The first few minutes feel too edited, but the rest is nice and comfortable to watch :)
I didn't know there was such a thing as too much editing lol
"'Hey That's My Flag"' 💀
"Hey Frackreich! Ich habe keine Glocke nicht gehört!"
Really good editing improvements but make it less cartoony and more textured good luck becoming a big TH-camr bro 👍
Do you mean the video or the thumbnail also you are suggesting I add texture to the map?
I thought it was fine on its own tbh@@Porphyrios.History
now i definitely want a part 2
dared to make the joke about France having a white flag during the war where Germany surrendered:)
The Habsburg could still rule over Austria if they would join Germany, the German Empire was a federal monarchy with multiple kings, since it also is a federal country since the very beginning, each king being basically a prime minister of their state like Wittelsbach or Wettin. If it wasn't like this, Germany wouldn't have unified, and that's why the Kaiser is called German Kaiser and not Kaiser of Germany, since the Kaiser wasn't the king of every German state.
Alternative histories never go that deep into this detail of the German politics and that would make a big difference. Like who would think that if Austria would join the German Empire, that the Habsburg would be replaced by someone else, like which other royal family would rule over Austria that is Austrian? Especially since Hungary already had and always had their own king that is not Habsburg.
Also a conditional surrender would be the only fair and righteous thing to do and the thing that would prevent a war like ww2, only the vile and evil nations would not want to negotiate peace. So the first presented timeline is a good one.
I would prefer that Elsaß would go to Germany and Lothringen, even if it has majority German, can be given to France as compromise if the rights of Germans living there gonna be guaranteed.
What if the Ottoman Empire had enough troops to win World War I?
As far as I know the ottomans had a large enough army for what they were facing. Maybe a better economy and industry would have helped more. I will defiantly do more Ottoman empire in the future however.
Nice video
Thanks!
Excellent video, new subscriber and anyone who dares to say it isn't as good as it is have to deal with me From now on
You are going to be my mercenary!
Would von lettow vorbeck still be tying the british down in Tanganika? Last german unit to surrender
I assume he might since I am giving Germany the benefit of the doubt but honestly I haven't thought about it or the colonies since it was not a decisive part of the war.
@@Porphyrios.History I like to think so as well
Amazing work, But the map could have some more texture.
What kind of textures would you like?
Cool Video🧀
🐁
If the german high command foresaw the results of world war 1 back in the 1880s, i think they'd drop austria-hungary and try to get russia as an ally first thing😂😂😂😂
you sound indian. I am now considering sending this to my grandpa and saying "see? they are even taking over the internet to!" (I live in canada)
Damn I am not sure how I should take this. I am Bulgarian do you think I should work on my accent?
@@Porphyrios.History bro honestly you should just work on a indian accent you are closer to that then a bulgar accent
@@Ziafiz Maybe I should start making more India althis videos lol
i dont know, he sounds kinda eastern european to me.
Wonderful channel! Christ bless.
Thank you! You too!
Get your facts right
So much wrong information
A Soviet ally?
?
@@Porphyrios.History At the start of the video, you said that France had the Soviets as an ally, which is strange because the Soviet Union didn't exist at that time. I know you meant the Russian Empire though.
@@BradleyDantzer-x4m If you are referring to 00:12 I say they become a soviet ally by the end of the video
@@Porphyrios.History Oh, my bad
It's fine the comment helps out with the algorithm anyways 😅
cool