Reading some comments I can only see how many people don't understand anything from what they see. The emotions between the two, their impossible try to reach each other, the pain, the sad end- you are here not only to listen to the music, but also understand the act and the message.
I really think Michael Nyman (composer of this wonderful piece of music) deserves a more prominent credit than you have given him. I did eventually manage to find his name right at the bottom...Vanessa's has faithfully copied the performance on the original recording (from 'The Piano' soundtrack album) but the composer should be mentioned in the title sequence. None of this lovely video production would have been possible without his original work.
I read that this song is a Scottish song "Gloomy Winter's Noo Awa" and the title is from a poem by Emily Dickenson but Michael Nyman still deserves credit.
This composition was based on a 19th century Scottish song, Gloomy Winter's Noo Awa. It's on TH-cam. The title is from Emily Dickinson's poem. Still , he made it more melodious and therefore, easier to listen to. The Heart Asks Pleasure First was nominated for original film score but lost to Schindler's List.
As nice as the music and performance art was, I have to say I really appreciated the single shot cinematography work. Captured the different parts of the whole scene quite nicely for us without ever feeling awkward.
The playing was absolutely PHENOMENAL, but I'm not gonna lie--those white-robed, ball/teardrop (?) people caught me off guard, damn-near caused me to crack a rib laughing.
They actually match the scene in the piano where she falls down in her ballooning dress after her finger gets cut off. So it makes sense lol, and the white is for purity she was in a black dress. If you know the symbolism it’s beautiful but if you don’t it’s weird lol
Omg I looked just like this lady as a teen and had a black shift dress like this and this was the first song I ever learned on piano and I wanted it so bad I never learned any other song better! Now I play it on ukulele, my soul instrument lol.
C'était vraiment très beau. La musique et l'interprétation excellentes, la danse sublime, le son parfait et le jeu de carméra très bien calculé. Merci pour ce beau travail.
The heart ask pleasure first.... Composed by Michael Nyman..... Pieza épica de la música de la película The Piano (1993) Dir. Jane Campion... Holly Hunter and Ana Paquin Oscar Winners... Harvey Keitel and Sam Neill.... Brutal drama
Love her interpretation of this piece. The other visuals distract from her beautiful playing. I just want to focus on her playing the piano. That is plenty. No sideshow needed.
Cela pourrait être plus correct de rajouter le compositeur ( Michael Nyman pour le film "La Leçon de piano" a priori) quand bien même ceci est un arrangement, non ?
@@johanturquety1674 Le nom est tellement discrètement rajouté à la toute fin sans vraiment préciser "compositeur" que je ne l'avais pas vu. On est loin de "Music : Vanessa Wagner Choreographer : Yoann Bourgeos Performance : Jean-Yves Phuong & Marie Vaudin" Un truc du style "Music : Vanessa Wagner (arrangement & performer) - Michael Nyman (original composer)" aurait été sans ambiguïté tout en ne retirant rien à personne ;)
Me too I would love one of these floaty swingy things where can we purchase one from let me know if anyone knows. also trying to play this piece sooooooooooooooooooooooo hard but soooooooooooooooooo beautiful thank you Denise linen
This is what happens when too much emotion clouds the mind from achieving better artistic executions, and the 'tear-drop' couple on the inflated balls was just weird and distracting. The heart may ask for pleasure first, but the strange couple teetering back and forth was just out of place for this.
Tbh she is a greaat pianist but i dont think slowing down and getting so fast at some spots are necessarely ment to be played like that. It sounds cool but it loses its magical "flow" to it as this way it gets interrupted all the time. This song is more like a flowing, flying piece, a bit like Fly from Intouchables, and that song would be also ruined if messed with the rythm so hard like here
Pourtant vous avez pris 5 min à regarder. Par ailleurs je trouve que la performance artistique est incroyable et que votre commentaire est impertinent. N’êtes vous pas aussi ridicule à juger avec une telle bassesse d’esprit ? Je crois que le plus ridicule est de juger le travail artistique. L’art n’a aucun but ni forme. Il n’est pas ridicule. Vous en revanche, on dirait bien
@@sweetlovely5758 "Pourtant vous avez pris 5 min à regarder " : e"h bien ça va san,s doute vous étonner mais AVANT de donner mon avis sur ce clip, je l'ai effectivement regardé. Dingue, non ? Vous êtes autant en droit de trouver cette "performance artistique incroyable" que moi de la trouver ridicule. Ca s'appelle ré-a-gir, et l'art que vous voudriez "sans but" est censé, entre autre choses, provoquer des "réactions". Après, tout n'est qu'histoire de goûts et de couleurs, mais vous semblez avoir du mal à accepter qu'on ne partage pas les vôtres. "Le plus ridicule est de juger le travail artistique" ?? Ah ? Pourtant, quand vous dites que vous aimez ce clip, c'est bien ce que vous faites, non ? Vous donnez votre avis, vous "jugez" que c'est "incroyable". Eh bien moi je juge que cette façon d'illustrer la musique de Michael Nyman (car oui, c'est lui le compositeur pas Vanessa Wagner comme le générique le laisse croire) avec ces culbutos est grotesque. Comme l'est votre affirmation selon laquelle "l'art n'a ni but ni forme" (ce clip que vous encensez est lui-même une "forme" illustrant une "forme" musicale)...
@@patrickclaux2684 En l'occurrence, ce n'est pas l'oeuvre que je commente - du bon Nyman, même s'il a composé des choses plus aventureuses (écoutez son cycle de mélodies "Acts of Beauty", par exemple) - ni l'interprétation - Vanessa Wagner est une pianiste remarquable - mais l'accompagnement "chorégraphique" que je trouve ridicule.
@@pierrebrv7736 ""L'oeuvre" c'est le tout cela aurait du vous faire fuir dès le début je rejoins le commentaire précédent..Quant à moi il n'y en aura pas d'autre.Amicalement
Reading some comments I can only see how many people don't understand anything from what they see. The emotions between the two, their impossible try to reach each other, the pain, the sad end- you are here not only to listen to the music, but also understand the act and the message.
Absolutely beautiful, loved the choreography of the two artists, and so thought provoking to see the man on the escalator going nowhere.
I really think Michael Nyman (composer of this wonderful piece of music) deserves a more prominent credit than you have given him. I did eventually manage to find his name right at the bottom...Vanessa's has faithfully copied the performance on the original recording (from 'The Piano' soundtrack album) but the composer should be mentioned in the title sequence. None of this lovely video production would have been possible without his original work.
Nit picking this is super famous and not hard to find.
everyone knows this song dude
I read that this song is a Scottish song "Gloomy Winter's Noo Awa" and the title is from a poem by Emily Dickenson but Michael Nyman still deserves credit.
This composition was based on a 19th century Scottish song, Gloomy Winter's Noo Awa. It's on TH-cam. The title is from Emily Dickinson's poem. Still , he made it more melodious and therefore, easier to listen to. The Heart Asks Pleasure First was nominated for original film score but lost to Schindler's List.
Perhaps you missed the guy walking up the down escalator @ 2:23
Beautifully sensitive rendition of this classic.
Passion and heart felt for this version. Love the style as well.
beautiful and heart-wrenching
What a lovely way to start the morning
Superbe pour les yeux et les oreilles
This was such a pleasure to listen to.
So bealtifull and so emotional.
A heart-touching art piece!
この曲が好きなのでお勧めに出てきました。ピアノも素晴らしい。回転する男女、空港のアングル、エスカレーターを登る男性。すべて計算された美しさ。構図が素晴らしい。
I want such a bubble swingy thing whatever you'd call them
Thank you, this is so touching...
wonderful.
As nice as the music and performance art was, I have to say I really appreciated the single shot cinematography work. Captured the different parts of the whole scene quite nicely for us without ever feeling awkward.
oh wow I didn't notice the single shot at first - so cool!
The playing was absolutely PHENOMENAL, but I'm not gonna lie--those white-robed, ball/teardrop (?) people caught me off guard, damn-near caused me to crack a rib laughing.
They actually match the scene in the piano where she falls down in her ballooning dress after her finger gets cut off. So it makes sense lol, and the white is for purity she was in a black dress. If you know the symbolism it’s beautiful but if you don’t it’s weird lol
Omg I looked just like this lady as a teen and had a black shift dress like this and this was the first song I ever learned on piano and I wanted it so bad I never learned any other song better! Now I play it on ukulele, my soul instrument lol.
I was a red head with that cut and everything omg I was so beautiful as a teen, lol none of the boys caught on
Very beautiful
Que lindo😍
this was special, and a life saver. Thank you
Amazing
C'était vraiment très beau. La musique et l'interprétation excellentes, la danse sublime, le son parfait et le jeu de carméra très bien calculé. Merci pour ce beau travail.
The heart ask pleasure first.... Composed by Michael Nyman..... Pieza épica de la música de la película The Piano (1993) Dir. Jane Campion... Holly Hunter and Ana Paquin Oscar Winners... Harvey Keitel and Sam Neill.... Brutal drama
Beautiful music
Amazing interpretation but…..
Give me the ocean view anytime
Thunderous waves sea spray grey clouds rolling 🖤
WoW... 👍👏👏👏
Das ist wahrlich Kunst.
❤' liche Grüße, Moni von Ede. 😍❤❤❤
Lindo!🙏❤️💐👏👏👏🇧🇷🖖
I don't know what this was but I liked it.
Wow
The yanni song "reflection of passion" also suitable for this type of art.
Guy at 2:30 is literally going nowhere on that escalator
I think he is trying to go up the down escalator 😂😂😂
At 2:39...the right side escalator is going down😂😂😂
Weebles wobble but they don't fall down!
(But the piano performance is lovely)
Vanessa Wagner feat. The Salt Shakers
Sehr ästhetisch! DAS ist Kunst!
Balance
Love her interpretation of this piece. The other visuals distract from her beautiful playing. I just want to focus on her playing the piano. That is plenty. No sideshow needed.
GOOD FEELING
Cela pourrait être plus correct de rajouter le compositeur ( Michael Nyman pour le film "La Leçon de piano" a priori) quand bien même ceci est un arrangement, non ?
C'est précisé dans la description de la vidéo !
@@johanturquety1674 Le nom est tellement discrètement rajouté à la toute fin sans vraiment préciser "compositeur" que je ne l'avais pas vu.
On est loin de "Music : Vanessa Wagner
Choreographer : Yoann Bourgeos
Performance : Jean-Yves Phuong & Marie Vaudin"
Un truc du style "Music : Vanessa Wagner (arrangement & performer) - Michael Nyman (original composer)" aurait été sans ambiguïté tout en ne retirant rien à personne ;)
Tout pour le compositeur rien sur le chorégraphe, est ce cela ,?
Gorgeous piano. WTF is up with the human bowling pins though?🤣🤣
"Mother wanted me to give this to Mr Bains. I thought it might not be the proper thing to do."
Oof. This is good.
Kate Ellen Flanagan xx
do me a favour amd link that notes
Me too I would love one of these floaty swingy things where can we purchase one from let me know if anyone knows. also trying to play this piece sooooooooooooooooooooooo hard but soooooooooooooooooo beautiful thank you Denise linen
この起き上がりこぼしが非常に要らない！
Weebles wobble but they don't fall down. Google it.
How much do bop bag people get paid per hour? Asking for a friend
Want to see more ? Subscribe ! bit.ly/SubBlogo
LOLOLOL
This is what happens when too much emotion clouds the mind from achieving better artistic executions, and the 'tear-drop' couple on the inflated balls was just weird and distracting. The heart may ask for pleasure first, but the strange couple teetering back and forth was just out of place for this.
😂😂😂😂
It sounds feeble😢
No
Tbh she is a greaat pianist but i dont think slowing down and getting so fast at some spots are necessarely ment to be played like that. It sounds cool but it loses its magical "flow" to it as this way it gets interrupted all the time. This song is more like a flowing, flying piece, a bit like Fly from Intouchables, and that song would be also ruined if messed with the rythm so hard like here
Bon sang, le ridicule ne tue pas...
Pourtant vous avez pris 5 min à regarder. Par ailleurs je trouve que la performance artistique est incroyable et que votre commentaire est impertinent. N’êtes vous pas aussi ridicule à juger avec une telle bassesse d’esprit ? Je crois que le plus ridicule est de juger le travail artistique. L’art n’a aucun but ni forme. Il n’est pas ridicule. Vous en revanche, on dirait bien
@@sweetlovely5758 "Pourtant vous avez pris 5 min à regarder " : e"h bien ça va san,s doute vous étonner mais AVANT de donner mon avis sur ce clip, je l'ai effectivement regardé. Dingue, non ?
Vous êtes autant en droit de trouver cette "performance artistique incroyable" que moi de la trouver ridicule. Ca s'appelle ré-a-gir, et l'art que vous voudriez "sans but" est censé, entre autre choses, provoquer des "réactions". Après, tout n'est qu'histoire de goûts et de couleurs, mais vous semblez avoir du mal à accepter qu'on ne partage pas les vôtres.
"Le plus ridicule est de juger le travail artistique" ?? Ah ? Pourtant, quand vous dites que vous aimez ce clip, c'est bien ce que vous faites, non ? Vous donnez votre avis, vous "jugez" que c'est "incroyable". Eh bien moi je juge que cette façon d'illustrer la musique de Michael Nyman (car oui, c'est lui le compositeur pas Vanessa Wagner comme le générique le laisse croire) avec ces culbutos est grotesque. Comme l'est votre affirmation selon laquelle "l'art n'a ni but ni forme" (ce clip que vous encensez est lui-même une "forme" illustrant une "forme" musicale)...
ce genre de commentaire en général en dit plus sur la personne que sur l'oeuvre.Amicalement
@@patrickclaux2684 En l'occurrence, ce n'est pas l'oeuvre que je commente - du bon Nyman, même s'il a composé des choses plus aventureuses (écoutez son cycle de mélodies "Acts of Beauty", par exemple) - ni l'interprétation - Vanessa Wagner est une pianiste remarquable - mais l'accompagnement "chorégraphique" que je trouve ridicule.
@@pierrebrv7736 ""L'oeuvre" c'est le tout cela aurait du vous faire fuir dès le début je rejoins le commentaire précédent..Quant à moi il n'y en aura pas d'autre.Amicalement
Amazing
Wow