Maybe Tzuyu should do that same thing, when Nayeons' birthday comes up this coming fall, no? Since they all "couldn't make it", then that should be her reason as well, "schedule conflict"
@SeliZee Ah, what?. I don't understand your reply. "so sus?" And one other comment as well. I do know that they are busy! But the least they could've done, was made a quick clothes change, after they were done from working and surprised Tzuyu at their dorm/house. Would that read a little better?
It made me tear up that she was expecting the members to surprise her, but they couldn't. She had to be disappointed. I hope she still had a great day!!
@SeliZee You are the naive one, I saw all your comments and you are acting like TWICE doesn't care about Tzuyu, If you been Following TWICE since the start in which I doubt you did, you would know how strong the bond of this girls are. You are very weird.
@@D_Galagaran if there bond is too strong . Why the chewy fans attacking the other members. They cant b 24/7 together . She just wanted someone cuz she dont want yo vlive alone
@@adampilget6158 so why does these Ot8 fans like you also attacked Tzuyu!! Like get a life!! Tzuyu did a solo vlive a lot and she doesn't care if she's alone or not it's just that this time it's her birthday!
@@empressgameplay6150 wow what ot8 stuffs wen . If she wants solo vlive . Why saying that stuff and making herself pitifull. Look at ure chewy stans attackking other members
@SeliZee bro stop being such a parasocial andy. You’ve replied to like 20 different comments. Everything is most likely fine and tzuyu is never going to notice you defending her. Please go outside LOL
I think Twice is preparing for a comeback since I just saw a post where Tzuyu said they are practicing a choreo while Nayeon is signing her album.So they might be very busy because otherwise they are always present or atleast a member in each bday live.
@SeliZeeHere you are just assuming things just from a Vlive, when even Tzuyu herself said in her date with Nayeon that they share a friendship that others will be jealous of. Yeah, it is obvious that some are closer than the others, like Tzuyu seems closer to Dahyun and Chaeyoung but they all still share a tight knit bond..
@SeliZee lol why are u so obsessed with Twice ?they are not that close?who told u that?They literally treat each other like family and u're saying they're not that close?lol just shut up if u don't know anything?u're not even their fan aren't u?
@SeliZee I think you have eyes problem so maybe you should go to doctor.... And actually they are very close with another ... It's just the member are very busy.. because of theirs upcoming comeback, nayeon solo album.... The fact is they are really close with each other ...
the whole time im just kinda sad for tzuyu, seems like she really and i mean was REALLY disappointed that they could not be there, not to blame them of course, just life is sad sometimes
Don't worry, they still celebrated her birthday afterwards . Tzuyu herself has confirmed that they don't have time due to the schedule, and she knows that Twice love Tzuyu as much as she loves their own child
i’m sure that they celebrated tzuyu’s birthday afterwards when all of them are free so don’t assume that “they ingnored tzuyu” COME ON BE MORE MATURED..of course she’s sad but they’ll make it up somehow, let’s just send love to tzuyu and others
@SeliZee they love tzuyu .... You should search and watch "twice love for tzuyu " compilation..... They love tzuyu as tzuyu come to reach her dream at such a young age...
most birthday Vlives they don't make it due to weather or busy schedule, usually during the summer it's easier less hectic schedule more vacation but twice as whole has been getting more and more deals, nearing the end of contract jype probably overbookrd everyone, also so many members keep getting COVID so they are probably told to not all group together unless it's a concert or comeback, millions of other reasons besides, *they ignored Tzuyu* y'all need to chill lol
@SeliZee you are acting like they are not on the same group. They have gc, they have a copy of their schedules, they know each other's schedule (although not all). If they don't care about Tzuyu they didn't call her and watched her vlive even they are in the middle of a schedule. Are you even aware why they called her that time? I guess not.
and the doubts were actually so stupid if you know anything about the group's dynamic like... even in the way jeongyeon was talking to her it was clear she was apologetic and was trying to let her down gently but tzuyu was holding onto hope they'd be able to join her real quick. people *LOVE* to assume the worst when it comes to these girls it's very odd
Let's not speculate. They'll celebrate their birthday later I sure, if they don’t like tzuyu, they will not even give her a phone call, onnie just be too busy for comeback I think, dahyun birthday vlive also don’t have other members, come on Ones, just don’t overthinking everything
I'm not sure what type of schedule they have where everyone is busy BUT Tzuyu. I can't imagine they are recording a video or something without her. The only thing I can think of is they are recording songs and Tzuyu is scheduled for later (or she already did it). Regardless, most of the time people don't record all at once so someone could have been there for a time if that's true. (Unless Tzuyu is not at the company or something). I remember I save a stream where I-DLE was recording something but they were all returning to a break room before and afterwards and taking turns on the stream. Also saw Dreamcatcher do something similar. So if Tzuyu was in the building, someone could have stopped by, for sure. SOOO my theory is TWICE are recording something and that Tzuyu is somewhere separate from the studio.
I got info, many said it's because Tzuyu planned the vlive just one day before. So everything was a hurried set-up by the staff, hence the members couldn't really make time for it cuz they already have busy sched. I'm sure if the members had more time, they coul've make more time for the vlive and replan their scheds.
its all a set up. fans would be like theres no way they surprise every member. so chewz is the short straw to "show once" that the surprises are "real". the lives are mostly highly choreographed at this stage of their career. dont get it twisted. off camera theres a different world that once are not aware of. and thats a good thing.
@SeliZee Actually Tzuyu said it herself in that Vlive she told the manager that she want to do the Vlive at last minute and she said she surprise and also grateful that the staff can prepared the decoration so beautiful depsite of her tell it at last mnue
I really feel bad for tzuyu, where's the other members?!!, They should give to all members a free schedule for every birthday of members, they mistreated tzuyu again😥
eu n sei vcs, mas eu realmente fico chateada nas vezes q a tzuyu passa o vliv de aniversário sozinha, eu nem assisti pq tenho certeza q ia ficar mal. ps: ela ficou tão felizinha com as ligações, imagina o quão fd seria se as meninas estivessem em pessoa.... enfim desabafo meu.
Bruh you didn't put it there but Tzuyu legit said "I'm gonna cry" after the call but brushed it off as a joke... I hope the members makes it up to her though, I know they would❤❤
i just hope the antis wouldn't use this incident against our girls. they would literally take this out of context just to drag TWICE. some other "onces" actually are already talking shit about the members just because of this without even taking their sched and responsibilities as an artist into consideration.
@@minaatozakii5211 actually antis already found out abt this and were like "their bond is so weak","my faves would never do this to their members" so damn dramatic
@@stanlegendz lol so true. I've seen several antis on twt saying those things. anyways I've already expected them to be so nosy, so I'm not even surprised.
Tzuyu has always been surprised by the members. Just this year, and not just with Tzuyu, almost all Twice members had to celebrate their birthdays alone. Tzuyu herself has confirmed that they don't have time due to the schedule, and she knows that Twice love Tzuyu as much as they love her own child. I bet with you Twice have celebrated afterwards her birthday
@@mt-hy7hl Okay...like I said I was just guessing because I watched a clip either yesterday or the day before in which she was talking about her Melody Project.
I am tired of people's wild and overactive imagination. This is ONE v-live, do we know what happens behind the scenes? No you don't so try not to make assumptions about a situation you clearly don't know about. Let's state facts, the members had another schedule to attend so they couldn't make it. That's it.
I think a part of it is also ppl not really understanding how scheduling works like... you're not ditching a scheduled event to celebrate the birthday of a member you're gonna see in maximum a day. Like the only thing you can do atp is make it up to that member and hope it's enough. As much as ppl want to think there's so much more freedom now they still have obligations lmao
Guys Tzuyu knew that they had a schedule. Jy said that you know i have schedule right? She might’ve thought it was finished early and they were coming to celebrate Tzuyu’s Birthday. Also if they were really “being mean” to tzuyu then why would they even bother to call her? Also, they can’t just cancel schedules just for them to go on vlive they were probably preparing for comeback and it would be unprofessional to do it.
Everyones on short vacation except Nayeon. And Tzuyu cant go home cause she lives in Taiwan. Theyre taking a break after US tour. Nayeon has scheds for her solo debut
@@mekayaka Yup because of the schedule that the company gave to them. It's unfortunate that its on the same day with her birthday. I just hope that the company atleast give it some consideration, but sadly no
@@robyn7415 in this year Dahyun also have none of them, even thought in previous years always there were at least one member on her birthday, you need to understand that they're ocupated and not write shit of them
@@caabj7651 i'm pretty sure that twice members celebrated dahyun's bd this year during dance practice or smth, but you are right we can't talk shit abt other members just because they can't be there
Tzuyu's birthday last year, other members also appeared in vlive to celebrate her birthday. As a result, Tzuyu fans hated other members appeared in tzuyu birthday's vlive. This year, as Tzuyu fans wished, only Tzuyu was broadcast live alone, and Tzuyu fans were unhappy again. Tzuyu fans began to feel that other members were bullying Tzuyu again because other members did not appear live to celebrate tzuyu's birthday. Some Tzuyu fans, do you have a problem with your brain?🙄🙄🙄
I think there's a problem with yours. You're literally just looking for petty, nitpicky excuses to insult her fans. They could easily do the same to you.
you're 100% right however i'd say it's her akgaes, not her fans. it's people who genuinely don't like the other members and are looking for anything that could somehow prove the members don't care about tzuyu when everything points to the contrary. you never see this behavior in actual onces who have her as their biases because they care enough to understand their bond
When she said she expecting the members come is really sad and broke my heart . In dahyun birthday the member suprise her . But tzuyu? I dont blame them but sometimes im just thinking about that
Tzuyu has always been surprised by the members. Just this year, and not just with Tzuyu, almost all Twice members had to celebrate their birthdays alone. Tzuyu herself has confirmed that they don't have time due to the schedule, and she knows that Twice love Tzuyu as much as they love their own child. And I bet with you they celebrate afterwards her birthday
@SeliZee now let's not base how close their relationship based on a mere incident, where the members literally said they have schedules. Stop being overdramatic
I know it's tzuyu's birthday. But I have a wish. The only wish. God. If you exist, and you love me. Plz join my life with her life... Let this girl enter in my life.
@@shaileshrawat6527 competition me mere tumhare Sath lakho log hai. 😂😂😂.. And "I KNOW I AM ONE IN MILLION". SAME thing for everyone. " You are one in a million".
last year, there were 4 members who suprised her during her bday vlive. also, there were other members who also did their bday vlive alone in the past, not just tzuyu. they all have their own responsibilities, that include tzuyu. she probably finished early as the staff said this was a last minute decision of hers to do a bday vlive. don't create drama here
@@stanyoojeongyeonforworldpeace idk why people are being very dramatic, like this is the first time that it happened. Like as you've said there are members who did a birthday vlive who doesn't have any member visit or didn't got a call from the other members like what Nayeon, Jeongyeon, and Dahyun did here, but that wasn't a big deal.
Sorry for the mistake. It's Sana and not Nayeon in 0:57. I just confused because of the laugh of Nayeon 😅
Nayeon's laugh is too powerful 😂
Of course it's Sana, she said it's her favorite person
Feel so bad for Tzuyu
They did that for Dubu
Dont feel sad ok
Is not Sana it's nayeon compare to that two 😊
it's nayeon
It's okay because ONCE is always there for you
Tzuyu has such a cute, tiny voice
she's still a baby, how can someone be?
she's so precious.
Our maknae is so cute but sadly they can't come for her birthday
All of them had schedules ?🥲
@@shubhrajitparida6399 yea
Maybe Tzuyu should do that same thing, when Nayeons' birthday comes up this coming fall, no?
Since they all "couldn't make it", then that should be her reason as well, "schedule conflict"
@SeliZee
Ah, what?. I don't understand your reply. "so sus?" And one other comment as well. I do know that they are busy! But the least they could've done, was made a quick clothes change, after they were done from working and surprised Tzuyu at their dorm/house. Would that read a little better?
@SeliZee wdym? she's obviously aware of their schedules. tzuyu herself is busy and have schedules, she just found time to have a short bday vlive
Tzuyu speaking english so freely, very cute. Tzuyu not fooled Twice will be right over and bring some cake and singing
It made me tear up that she was expecting the members to surprise her, but they couldn't. She had to be disappointed. I hope she still had a great day!!
I'm pretty sure Tzuyu's next birthday will be celebrated within the whole JYP building
@SeliZee You are the naive one, I saw all your comments and you are acting like TWICE doesn't care about Tzuyu, If you been Following TWICE since the start in which I doubt you did, you would know how strong the bond of this girls are.
You are very weird.
@@D_Galagaran if there bond is too strong . Why the chewy fans attacking the other members. They cant b 24/7 together . She just wanted someone cuz she dont want yo vlive alone
@@adampilget6158 so why does these Ot8 fans like you also attacked Tzuyu!! Like get a life!! Tzuyu did a solo vlive a lot and she doesn't care if she's alone or not it's just that this time it's her birthday!
@@empressgameplay6150 wow what ot8 stuffs wen . If she wants solo vlive . Why saying that stuff and making herself pitifull. Look at ure chewy stans attackking other members
@SeliZee bro stop being such a parasocial andy. You’ve replied to like 20 different comments. Everything is most likely fine and tzuyu is never going to notice you defending her. Please go outside LOL
I think Twice is preparing for a comeback since I just saw a post where Tzuyu said they are practicing a choreo while Nayeon is signing her album.So they might be very busy because otherwise they are always present or atleast a member in each bday live.
the managers should make sure there is no schedules during the girls` birthday :D
@@Winter3033 we can't do anything about it 😭
Yeah they can't especially if it's about work related stuff.
@SeliZee it’s never that deep
@SeliZeeHere you are just assuming things just from a Vlive, when even Tzuyu herself said in her date with Nayeon that they share a friendship that others will be jealous of. Yeah, it is obvious that some are closer than the others, like Tzuyu seems closer to Dahyun and Chaeyoung but they all still share a tight knit bond..
"I was talking"😭😭😭 i love her so much
My poor princess 🥺🥺🥺she is so cuteeeee and sweet
It's like babies expecting their parents to show up and give a surprise on their Birthday😦
@SeliZee lol why are u so obsessed with Twice ?they are not that close?who told u that?They literally treat each other like family and u're saying they're not that close?lol just shut up if u don't know anything?u're not even their fan aren't u?
@SeliZee I think you have eyes problem so maybe you should go to doctor.... And actually they are very close with another ... It's just the member are very busy.. because of theirs upcoming comeback, nayeon solo album.... The fact is they are really close with each other ...
@SeliZee keep barking hater
Don't be sad baby tzu I'm here for you ❤ 💕 😊
I think the one who is talking at 0:58 is Nayeon. Nayeon, Jeongyeon and Dahyun were together when they called Tzuyu according to Nayeon's bubble.
I'm so honored to have the same birthday as her
I know right? One more reason to get excited for our birthday. Belated happy birthday to us!
I have the same birthday as Jihyo :D
Ja sa pripájam tiež ku všetkým gratulantom 🎂💐💘
Tzuyu zlata nech ťa smola obchádza a šťastie stretáva 💋💐💓🤗
the whole time im just kinda sad for tzuyu, seems like she really and i mean was REALLY disappointed that they could not be there, not to blame them of course, just life is sad sometimes
Don't worry, they still celebrated her birthday afterwards . Tzuyu herself has confirmed that they don't have time due to the schedule, and she knows that Twice love Tzuyu as much as she loves their own child
They will celebrate her birthday soon... Maybe not in camera .. maybe it's just 9 of them
They celebrated her birthday while recording Talk that talk MV 😊
My beautiful Princess ❤️❤️
i’m sure that they celebrated tzuyu’s birthday afterwards when all of them are free so don’t assume that “they ingnored tzuyu” COME ON BE MORE MATURED..of course she’s sad but they’ll make it up somehow, let’s just send love to tzuyu and others
@SeliZee alright bro ☠️☠️
@SeliZee they love tzuyu .... You should search and watch "twice love for tzuyu " compilation..... They love tzuyu as tzuyu come to reach her dream at such a young age...
@SeliZee nayeon and tzuyu are awkward cuz they never go outside only two of them ... So it's awkward... The fact is they close with each other
@SeliZee they said they never hang out only the two of them they usually hang out with 3 or 4 that mean they never go out with the two of them
@SeliZee how would you know 💀. I've seen them adoring tzuyu and caring for her they love tzuyu alot.
most birthday Vlives they don't make it due to weather or busy schedule, usually during the summer it's easier less hectic schedule more vacation but twice as whole has been getting more and more deals, nearing the end of contract jype probably overbookrd everyone, also so many members keep getting COVID so they are probably told to not all group together unless it's a concert or comeback, millions of other reasons besides, *they ignored Tzuyu* y'all need to chill lol
@SeliZee Tzuyu said herself she decided last minute to do a live stop spreading all these lies
@SeliZee you are acting like they are not on the same group. They have gc, they have a copy of their schedules, they know each other's schedule (although not all). If they don't care about Tzuyu they didn't call her and watched her vlive even they are in the middle of a schedule. Are you even aware why they called her that time? I guess not.
Hi beautiful happy birthday to you happy birthday to you happy birthday Dear tzuyu happy birthday to you and many many more.
I love her so much my baby
i think its sana but the one whos laughing is nayeon
Jihyo: "i called bc i know you're on vlive and wouldn't say much" LMAO
*JEONGYEON not Jihyo
Tzuyu Tzuyu 💙💙💙
This was how my 20th birthday went I thought it was going to be fun but my family forgot it was my birthday so we ended up not celebrating
They're grown women. They have jobs smh why people attacking the members who didn't come? do you even know twice? They're like family.
Why am I crying
It's not Nayeon. That is Sana
I'm pretty sure when she said "ehhh"😂😂
It's Nayeon, the reason she said eh is because she's learning japanese from Momo
It's Nayeon
it's clearly nayeon
@@astridl.247
And from Sana.
They live together.
Noooo I'm not crying- ☹️☹️☹️☹️
IM CRYING RN, POOR TZUYU
3 months later, and now we know that they were shooting the mv. Meanwhile there is people in the comments doubting about what happened
and the doubts were actually so stupid if you know anything about the group's dynamic like... even in the way jeongyeon was talking to her it was clear she was apologetic and was trying to let her down gently but tzuyu was holding onto hope they'd be able to join her real quick. people *LOVE* to assume the worst when it comes to these girls it's very odd
yj: "tzuyu, don't expect us"... tz "i'm still expecting".. oh poor tzuyu 😢
頭罩擋住子瑜的仙貌
Let's not speculate. They'll celebrate their birthday later I sure, if they don’t like tzuyu, they will not even give her a phone call, onnie just be too busy for comeback I think, dahyun birthday vlive also don’t have other members, come on Ones, just don’t overthinking everything
I'm not sure what type of schedule they have where everyone is busy BUT Tzuyu. I can't imagine they are recording a video or something without her. The only thing I can think of is they are recording songs and Tzuyu is scheduled for later (or she already did it). Regardless, most of the time people don't record all at once so someone could have been there for a time if that's true. (Unless Tzuyu is not at the company or something). I remember I save a stream where I-DLE was recording something but they were all returning to a break room before and afterwards and taking turns on the stream. Also saw Dreamcatcher do something similar. So if Tzuyu was in the building, someone could have stopped by, for sure. SOOO my theory is TWICE are recording something and that Tzuyu is somewhere separate from the studio.
I think they are on vacation after the US tour and everyone went home and took time away except for Nayeon who has solo debut coming up.
I got info, many said it's because Tzuyu planned the vlive just one day before. So everything was a hurried set-up by the staff, hence the members couldn't really make time for it cuz they already have busy sched. I'm sure if the members had more time, they coul've make more time for the vlive and replan their scheds.
its all a set up. fans would be like theres no way they surprise every member. so chewz is the short straw to "show once" that the surprises are "real". the lives are mostly highly choreographed at this stage of their career. dont get it twisted. off camera theres a different world that once are not aware of. and thats a good thing.
My theory is that you need to touch grass
@SeliZee Actually Tzuyu said it herself in that Vlive she told the manager that she want to do the Vlive at last minute and she said she surprise and also grateful that the staff can prepared the decoration so beautiful depsite of her tell it at last mnue
I mean who knows what's happening off cam, maybe they can celebrate it after their Vlive 😅☺️
JEONGYEONN AWHHHH TT
I think Tzuyu was not in their dormitory to celebrate her birthday,so other members couldn’t come to join the birthday party.
Baby birthday
I feel sad 4 tzuyu 😔 tzuyu love u.
I really feel bad for tzuyu, where's the other members?!!, They should give to all members a free schedule for every birthday of members, they mistreated tzuyu again😥
then they celebrate together is most likely
Cutey
awww
eu n sei vcs, mas eu realmente fico chateada nas vezes q a tzuyu passa o vliv de aniversário sozinha, eu nem assisti pq tenho certeza q ia ficar mal.
ps: ela ficou tão felizinha com as ligações, imagina o quão fd seria se as meninas estivessem em pessoa.... enfim desabafo meu.
it's ok Tzuyu
i think last year ppl came on her bd? that's why she's kinda expecting lol
Hey my birthday also June 14🙋♂️
Bruh you didn't put it there but Tzuyu legit said "I'm gonna cry" after the call but brushed it off as a joke... I hope the members makes it up to her though, I know they would❤❤
i just hope the antis wouldn't use this incident against our girls. they would literally take this out of context just to drag TWICE. some other "onces" actually are already talking shit about the members just because of this without even taking their sched and responsibilities as an artist into consideration.
@@minaatozakii5211 actually antis already found out abt this and were like "their bond is so weak","my faves would never do this to their members" so damn dramatic
@@stanlegendz lol so true. I've seen several antis on twt saying those things. anyways I've already expected them to be so nosy, so I'm not even surprised.
I'm cry they are not attend Tzuyu Birthday. I think they are surprise her at the dormitory/residential area.
What the hell did you just say? Haha
@@archi6083 , sorry about that my wrong spelling but your word "hell".....
Tzuyu has always been surprised by the members. Just this year, and not just with Tzuyu, almost all Twice members had to celebrate their birthdays alone. Tzuyu herself has confirmed that they don't have time due to the schedule, and she knows that Twice love Tzuyu as much as they love her own child. I bet with you Twice have celebrated afterwards her birthday
@@sweetbachiri8572 , Yes I knew its but really feel sad.
Do you have a second channel called minaribear by any chance?
Aww 🥺
Jeongyeon...has...a...schedule...
What is this?
Just guessing, but Jeongyeon did mention something about a Melody Project.
Wow, that would be highly anticipated. 'Cause if that so, that would be her first melody project. But no pressure for her tho.
@@musicman2846 it is not for melody project. She said she can't do it this year due to busy schedules. Also said that she will try to do it next year
@@mt-hy7hl Okay...like I said I was just guessing because I watched a clip either yesterday or the day before in which she was talking about her Melody Project.
Either way, whatever it is that she'll do. I will support.
I am tired of people's wild and overactive imagination. This is ONE v-live, do we know what happens behind the scenes? No you don't so try not to make assumptions about a situation you clearly don't know about. Let's state facts, the members had another schedule to attend so they couldn't make it. That's it.
I think a part of it is also ppl not really understanding how scheduling works like... you're not ditching a scheduled event to celebrate the birthday of a member you're gonna see in maximum a day. Like the only thing you can do atp is make it up to that member and hope it's enough. As much as ppl want to think there's so much more freedom now they still have obligations lmao
Guys Tzuyu knew that they had a schedule. Jy said that you know i have schedule right? She might’ve thought it was finished early and they were coming to celebrate Tzuyu’s Birthday.
Also if they were really “being mean” to tzuyu then why would they even bother to call her?
Also, they can’t just cancel schedules just for them to go on vlive they were probably preparing for comeback and it would be unprofessional to do it.
people *love* to speculate negatively about the girls' bond bc they're just that close and they can't fathom it, it gets incredibly weird sometimes
Tzuyu v what 😏🤫🤭😧😳
She is alone :(
why...!!!???!!!
變得神秘美了
It was this year the video?
What if mina arrived alone!????
does Tzuyu has new hair!!!???
Nqyeon
But why they can't come on her birthday?
Oo
@@natrahell this is really accurate, i feel bad for tzuyu:((
@@natrahell have you maybe tried thinking its bc it was her birthday 🤓🤓
Everyones on short vacation except Nayeon. And Tzuyu cant go home cause she lives in Taiwan. Theyre taking a break after US tour. Nayeon has scheds for her solo debut
@@natrahell she probably finished early. I heard somewhere that it was a last minute decision of tzuyu to do a bday vlive
Hello.... Chit Thu lay. New Today. Very beautiful. Tzuyu. I Love you. Happy birthday. Par.good luck.
So any of the members arrived??
None of them, it was really shitty of them to leave her by herself for her stream. All the others have others join them
Maybe they’re busy
@@mekayaka Yup because of the schedule that the company gave to them. It's unfortunate that its on the same day with her birthday. I just hope that the company atleast give it some consideration, but sadly no
@@robyn7415 in this year Dahyun also have none of them, even thought in previous years always there were at least one member on her birthday, you need to understand that they're ocupated and not write shit of them
@@caabj7651 i'm pretty sure that twice members celebrated dahyun's bd this year during dance practice or smth, but you are right we can't talk shit abt other members just because they can't be there
arent they in the same house?
No maybe they all live alone
The vlive is not in their house, plus they are all out on schedule. Dahyun, Chaeyoung & Tzuyu stay in the same apartment.
@@dubu007 yeah true
miss,,you,,,princessa,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
She's 24 or 23?
Tzuyu's birthday last year, other members also appeared in vlive to celebrate her birthday. As a result, Tzuyu fans hated other members appeared in tzuyu birthday's vlive. This year, as Tzuyu fans wished, only Tzuyu was broadcast live alone, and Tzuyu fans were unhappy again. Tzuyu fans began to feel that other members were bullying Tzuyu again because other members did not appear live to celebrate tzuyu's birthday. Some Tzuyu fans, do you have a problem with your brain?🙄🙄🙄
I think there's a problem with yours. You're literally just looking for petty, nitpicky excuses to insult her fans. They could easily do the same to you.
you're 100% right however i'd say it's her akgaes, not her fans. it's people who genuinely don't like the other members and are looking for anything that could somehow prove the members don't care about tzuyu when everything points to the contrary. you never see this behavior in actual onces who have her as their biases because they care enough to understand their bond
Está claro que no la quieren, porque al debut de Nayeon si fueron y con Tzuyu solo dijeron que no podían, ah pero son muy unidas
Altho am not a fan of twice but u can clear hear taht , that is sana not nayeon just saying
Jeongyeons singing💀
When she said she expecting the members come is really sad and broke my heart . In dahyun birthday the member suprise her . But tzuyu? I dont blame them but sometimes im just thinking about that
Tzuyu has always been surprised by the members. Just this year, and not just with Tzuyu, almost all Twice members had to celebrate their birthdays alone. Tzuyu herself has confirmed that they don't have time due to the schedule, and she knows that Twice love Tzuyu as much as they love their own child. And I bet with you they celebrate afterwards her birthday
Go outside, take a deep breath and while you are at it touch some grass as well
@@ffff-cw6rk ikr? this clown sounds so pathetic just lime their mom. it’s not that deep.
@SeliZee now let's not base how close their relationship based on a mere incident, where the members literally said they have schedules. Stop being overdramatic
@SeliZee
What is wrong with you?
Seriously.
I know it's tzuyu's birthday.
But I have a wish. The only wish.
God. If you exist, and you love me.
Plz join my life with her life... Let this girl enter in my life.
Nope, he doesn't love you.
@@archi6083 yeap. That's what I feel. 😂😂.
Bhai mere, ye wish to meri hai. Pichle 4 saalo se😂😂
@@shaileshrawat6527 competition me mere tumhare Sath lakho log hai. 😂😂😂..
And "I KNOW I AM ONE IN MILLION".
SAME thing for everyone.
" You are one in a million".
@@rajkumarraj2263 bhai competiton me crore log hai. And i am one in a billion😂😂🤣.
She know that nayekn is speaking she is doing overacting
Legend says that they are still lying.
come on she has no family here, 7 years of friendship they say?
they have different schedule that time, but she can meet her unnie's later for birthday party 🥳🎉
last year, there were 4 members who suprised her during her bday vlive. also, there were other members who also did their bday vlive alone in the past, not just tzuyu. they all have their own responsibilities, that include tzuyu. she probably finished early as the staff said this was a last minute decision of hers to do a bday vlive. don't create drama here
@@stanyoojeongyeonforworldpeace very true
@@stanyoojeongyeonforworldpeace 👏👏
@@stanyoojeongyeonforworldpeace idk why people are being very dramatic, like this is the first time that it happened. Like as you've said there are members who did a birthday vlive who doesn't have any member visit or didn't got a call from the other members like what Nayeon, Jeongyeon, and Dahyun did here, but that wasn't a big deal.