Tiffany and Taeyeon outshines the girl. :^< I was honestly looking forward to how the girl would control the stage, but she didn't really do anything. Sad really. Tae and Tiff did beautiful.
What do you mean she didn't do anything? She had the most lines out of all of them. And she had the most screen time. It's because she lacks charisma and confidence when she sings. And her face is always ._.
확실히 프로사이에 섞인 아마추어느낌이 약간은 나네요. 가창력, 몸짓, 표정 등등.. 그룹에 불안한멤버가 있다고 전부다 그 멤버에 맞춰서 부르는일은 없죠. 그건 같이 무대를 망치자는건데.ㅋㅋㅋ 아연이가 소화할수있는 비교적 적절한 파트를 배분한것같아요. 태연이 기교나 성능을 보면 아연이가 태연파트 소화하기는 좀 벅차보인다는... 티파니도 정말 능숙하게 잘하네요. 티파니가 이정도로 잘하는줄은 몰랐음.
@@onlyforyou6363 I meant it wasn't for me, I didn't meant the note itself wasn't high but how it was on my vocal range, this song is one of the best and she did it amazing as usual, I haven't seen a bad performance of hers (when it comes about vocals)
Que sólo sean un acompañamiento no significa que van a dejar de lucirse... en ese caso hubiesen llamado a otras para que le hicieran de coristas a la niña
Hell ya, you better watch the original singer to understand why is tiffany and taeyeon took the highnote the most. Cos they took Pink and christina part. And baek a yeon took Mya part which is the soft and cute one. This song wouldnt perfect without her cute voice.
Baek Ayeon was a rookie in a competition. She was teamed-up with Lead Vocalist and the Main Vocalist/Leader of Korea's #1 Girls' Group/ #1 K-Pop Group overall (Tiffany and Taeyeon, who each had 5 years of intense professional experience). Taeyeon and Tiffany had performed this song to thousands of people, to overwhelming (and deserved) acclaim. They were comfortable with it---Baek Ayeon had to learn/practice everything according to the competition schedule and the time that Taeny could provide. A tough position for her to be in. This performance had to be put together without interfering with Taeny's many other commitments in a very busy year. Staging decisions had to be quick, practice time was limited, the audience would have naturally expected a great performance from Taeny, and Taeny knew they had to deliver the same. Although the performance was supposed to 'showcase' Baek Ayeon, it would have been a major 'scandal' if Taeny, as not just 'sunbaenim' but the as members of the "The Nation's Girl Group" were given simply equal time/attention, let-alone as supporting/back-up singers to their junior, despite the principle purpose of the stage. While the director and camera operators understandably paid a lot of attention to the rightfully famous 'Taeny', it is clear to me that they did so at Baek Ahyeon's expense----they kept panning or zooming past Baek Ahyeon to Tiffany or Taeyeon when they were all clearly singing together,. Taeny could perform this comfortably ---and they did. Baek Ahyeon could not--she had limited rehearsal and practice, and was in the middle of a major milestone in a competition. Combined with the understandable biases of the director and camera operators, and the other factors mentioned above, this video presents a 'showcase' for Taeny rather than Baek Ahyeon. JYP and Boa however, had a complete experience of the performance, and the extensive personal experience to fully understand the performance, in detail and in context. It's neither Taeny's "fault" , nor Baek Ahyeon's that she appears so overwhelmed and limited. She's a great singer, and with the experience she now has, she could perfom this song again, with Tiffany and Taeyeon, as an equal partner. .
this was so... pretty. and so tame... not at all what lady marmalade is supposed to be. it's so safe and boring. pretty girls. nice voices. but not much else.
at 1:27 that girl said "One more time, Isa pa???" lol I might unclearly heard it but the English of "Isa pa" in tagalog(Philippines) is "One more " also.
![Baek Ayeon With Tiffany & Taeyeon [Lady Marmalade Special] @KPOPSTAR 20120422](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cuBNJNl9iK8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Baek Ayeon With Tiffany & Taeyeon [Lady Marmalade Special] @KPOPSTAR 20120422](/img/tr.png)
![[HD] SNSD (Taeyeon & Tiffany) - Lady Marmalade @ Girls Generation Tour](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/G1VrMq4oUfk/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HOT] HR teacher (Ok Joohyun x Kwon Yuri x Aiki x Soyeon) Performance., 방과후 설렘 211128](/img/n.gif)
괜히 소녀시대가 아니다 진짜...
태연 티파니 개오진다...... 긁는 소리도 청량하고 진성 고음을 저렇게 시원하게 내버리네...ㄷㄷ 역시는 역시다 뭐가 달라도 달라 진짜...
아 생각나서 오랜만에 보러왔는데 화질이... 이게 최선입니까ㅠㅠ 우리 탱구랑 파니 마멀레이드 고화질로 보고싶어요ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
태연 티파니는 확실히 여유가 보인다... 다들 대단
이 공연하기전엔 안티들이 쟤네가 케이팝스타 나올수있냐, 백아연한테 처발릴거라고 하다가 막상 ㅈㄴ잘하니 배려안해준다고 욕했다고ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Tiffany's swagger and vocals were everything in this performance.
너무 잘해도 문제였던 그때 참..ㅠ 태연지림 ㅠ
다시 봐도 김태연 개쩐다 진짜 스펙트럼 개넓음
안티들 이중성보소ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 분명 이 공연에서 백아연보다 못했으면 태연 티파니 욕했을거면섴ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㄱㅋ 근데 태연 티파니가 백아연보다 잘하니 안봐준다고 욕해ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Tiffany can do everything ...rap and sing also dance and never forget doing high notes perfectly ✊😿 you owned the stage 💜😻
sorry 😅😂😂 for my bad English
Hahahaha.....i know its just a typo but what u said is funny...😂😂😂😂
OMG HAHAHAHAH that was a good one
@Judie Sparks hahahah wooow the expert have talking, yes she was rapping and she doit so so good
YASSSSSSSSS INDEED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
taeyeon's best vocals ever. giving me real beyonce vibes with her adlibs
이때 알앗지 걸그룹들이 그냥 마른게 아니라 운동으로 탄탄하게 날씬한걸
2024년에 이거 보니까 새롭네
어떻게 생각하면 백아연이 티파니나 태연만큼 했으면 우승이지..
그만큼 소녀시대의 리들 보컬은 레벨이 높다 그래서 나는 소녀시대의 영원한 팬이다.......~~~~~~~~~~
Tiffany and Taeyeon outshines the girl. :^< I was honestly looking forward to how the girl would control the stage, but she didn't really do anything. Sad really. Tae and Tiff did beautiful.
What do you mean she didn't do anything? She had the most lines out of all of them. And she had the most screen time. It's because she lacks charisma and confidence when she sings. And her face is always ._.
태연 티파니 진짜 쩐다..
BoA must be so proud of her juniors. 😉
소시콘에서 태연 티파니 둘이서 이 노래 공연했을때보다 훨씬 힘빼고 덜 지른거임...ㅋㅋ
아마추어랑 프로의 차이네요 ㅎㅎ 백아연도 연습많이 한거같아보이는데 아무래도 소시들은 경력이 있으니 무대장악력이 뛰어나네요 ㅋㅋ 어쩔수없는듯.
Taeyeon owned the stage oh mah gawsh
와씨 태연 티파니 무대장악력 보소…ㄷㄷ 진심 ㅈㄴ 잘해…
Poor child due to her lack of stage control and emotion she was outshined by my girls :/ But still great.
Tiffany's High Note😍
확실히 프로사이에 섞인 아마추어느낌이 약간은 나네요.
가창력, 몸짓, 표정 등등..
그룹에 불안한멤버가 있다고 전부다 그 멤버에 맞춰서 부르는일은 없죠.
그건 같이 무대를 망치자는건데.ㅋㅋㅋ
아연이가 소화할수있는 비교적 적절한 파트를 배분한것같아요.
태연이 기교나 성능을 보면 아연이가 태연파트 소화하기는 좀 벅차보인다는...
티파니도 정말 능숙하게 잘하네요. 티파니가 이정도로 잘하는줄은 몰랐음.
팩트
원샷받은시간
백아연 53초 태연 38초 티파니 31초
개인파트시간
백아연 43초 티파니44초(랩포함) 태연37초
심지어 의상은 백아연 혼자만 디자인도 다르고 흰색임 근데 뒤에 미쓰에이랑 이하이가 더 문제있어보이는데;;
ㅋㅋㅋㅋ진짜 이하이 개심각하네진짜
@@ccrru73 ㄹㅇ 혼자 뭐하나 싶었음...
tiffany and taeyeon is perfect :3
Tiffany my everything 🥰🥰🥰
Taeyeon just kill me 😍
Tiffany's Rap and Highnote slay
Love Taeyeon most!!!!!!
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ백아연이 코러스 댄서 된거같앜ㅋㅋㅋ태연 티파니 들이 심사보는거같앜ㅋㅋㅋ
소녀시대가 더 못했으면 백아연한명 한테 발렸다고 ㅈㄹ할꺼고...; 잘하니까 백아연무대인데 왜이렇게 실력뽐내냐고 ㅈㄹ;;
8년 지났는데 잘지내는중?
@@깡깡-e6h님은 살아계세요?
@@user-fuckhell ㅇㅇ ㅎㅇ
TaeNy's #1
Taeyeon
태연티파니는 노래를잘해도 욕을 머는구나ㅎ
6년같이 한 우물 파신거 존경 합니다 진짜
Taeyeon
다 잘하네.. 나도 노래 잘하고싶다ㅠㅡㅠ
tae's voice omggg!!!❤
I did totally not scream at Taeyeons high note. nope
Amy why? Btw, your grammar was wrong
It wasn't that high LOL
Maria Delgado haters HAHAHAHHA
@@mariadelgado5614 it's high. Every above C5 it's higher..
@@onlyforyou6363 I meant it wasn't for me, I didn't meant the note itself wasn't high but how it was on my vocal range, this song is one of the best and she did it amazing as usual, I haven't seen a bad performance of hers (when it comes about vocals)
best version of lady marmalade
Hanna Gracee nah. Sorry I do not believe you can beat the original but yeah my bae❤️ the best Tae killed it with Tiffany
Hahaha even compared to Christina Aguilera's version?
Queen Taeyeon !!!
Taeyeon ! 👸🏼👑
저때 백아연 오디션보는중임 그러니까 당연히 자기가 연습해야할 곡이있는거고 그걸 준비해야지 특별무대에 신경쓸시간이없겠지 그러니 백아연 파트가 적을수밖에없고
백아연 파트가 젤 많음
Taeyeon💓
2:39 3:03 태연이 진짜 개 쩌는게 이 애드립들 들으면 정말 무슨 여자 스파이 영화 한 장면이 스쳐 지나감 진짜 개쩌는 보컬 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
근데 태연 티파니 노래잘하긴하네..
태연♥♥♥♥♥
자꾸 백아연 파트 없다고 그러는데 그럼 백아연이 태연이나 티파니 파트를 대신 부른다고 치면 고음이나 이런거 저렇게 소화할 수 있을줄알고 그러는거냐? 역랑이 안되니까 못하는거지ㅋ
적어도 센터는 백아연을 확실히 밀어주고 있음
파트야 백아연도 같이 짰을거 아님?
본인이 소화할 수 있을만큼만 확보했겠지 거따대고 태연이나 티파니가 하지말라 그랬겠음?
원샷이야 카메라감독이 잡은건데 이걸 태연이랑 티파니 욕해버리네;
이때 태연이랑 티파니가 너무 잘해서 애네밖에 기억안남
Bien sûr... mostly Tae she's my favourite idol in the world. Frenchies will understand
Ouais
taeyeon: Tiff.... jajajaj
I think they must given the highlight part to the contestant... Just saying...
Years go by and this is still amazing!
Miss A as well.
Que sólo sean un acompañamiento no significa que van a dejar de lucirse... en ese caso hubiesen llamado a otras para que le hicieran de coristas a la niña
멋있다
All has such a beautiful voice
티파니가 젤 멋있네
노래 파트를 도데체 누가 나눈거얔ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
파트랑 의상 등등 분배 잘 했는데 태연티파니가 넘사벽이라 센터 백아연이 딸렸음...
Baek Ayeon - Now a refined singer in JYP with many No. 1 hits
Lee Hi - Now a soulful singer in YG, also with countless No. 1 hits
Jyp's reaction when Miss A was performing was so precious 😭💜
Lady marmalade sweet version. 👏
소녀시대 메보 태연, 리보 티파니
-설명 끝-
더 이상의 설명따윈 필요없지
Tiffany!!!!!
This is the best cover
Tiffany😍😍❤️
애초에 콜라보 무대가 그냥 프로랑 아마추어들 무대하는거 그 이상 이하 의미도 아닌데 괜히 확대해석해서 누구 파트 많네 적네 그지랄하는거 존나 꼴불견,.. 그냥 콜라보 무대 자체가 없어져야됨ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
That child in the first performance was so dead compared to her k-pop star counterparts, they out shined her in Lady Marmalade
Te amo Taeyeon, pero sinceramente te falta para igualar la potencia de voz de Christina Aguilera
taeyeon outsings christina anytime
they sing better than me and I'm shy to sing in public I love their versions of songs ♡♡♡♡
보아 : 흐믓^^~이겼군
Ayeon has an amazing voice but she didn't have charm
Hell ya, you better watch the original singer to understand why is tiffany and taeyeon took the highnote the most. Cos they took Pink and christina part. And baek a yeon took Mya part which is the soft and cute one. This song wouldnt perfect without her cute voice.
high note tiffany
omg her high notes killed me!!!! she's slaying
YASSSS T-T I STANNNN
여기 소시 욕하던거 다~지워진게 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ잘 살고 있냐 악플러들
Let’s pretend this girl represent twice and well SNSD IS just being the QUEEN S THEY ARE💁🏻♀️
백아연 파트 여기서 더 늘렸으면 백아연 순위 떨어졌음
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ근데 팩트..
참고로 타 프로에서 다비치가 참가자보다 못해서... 개 까였는데.. 여긴 잘했다고 까임 ㅋㅋㅋ
Tremenda joyita 💅
Kiss&Cry's cover of this is still the best.
อายะ เด่นสุด
Baek Ayeon was a rookie in a competition.
She was teamed-up with Lead Vocalist and the Main Vocalist/Leader of Korea's #1 Girls' Group/ #1 K-Pop Group overall (Tiffany and Taeyeon, who each had 5 years of intense professional experience).
Taeyeon and Tiffany had performed this song to thousands of people, to overwhelming (and deserved) acclaim.
They were comfortable with it---Baek Ayeon had to learn/practice everything according to the competition schedule and the time that Taeny could provide. A tough position for her to be in.
This performance had to be put together without interfering with Taeny's many other commitments in a very busy year.
Staging decisions had to be quick, practice time was limited, the audience would have naturally expected a great performance from Taeny, and Taeny knew they had to deliver the same.
Although the performance was supposed to 'showcase' Baek Ayeon, it would have been a major 'scandal' if Taeny, as not just 'sunbaenim' but the as members of the "The Nation's Girl Group" were given simply equal time/attention, let-alone as supporting/back-up singers to their junior, despite the principle purpose of the stage.
While the director and camera operators understandably paid a lot of attention to the rightfully famous 'Taeny', it is clear to me that they did so at Baek Ahyeon's expense----they kept panning or zooming past Baek Ahyeon to Tiffany or Taeyeon when they were all clearly singing together,.
Taeny could perform this comfortably ---and they did. Baek Ahyeon could not--she had limited rehearsal and practice, and was in the middle of a major milestone in a competition. Combined with the understandable biases of the director and camera operators, and the other factors mentioned above, this video presents a 'showcase' for Taeny rather than Baek Ahyeon.
JYP and Boa however, had a complete experience of the performance, and the extensive personal experience to fully understand the performance, in detail and in context.
It's neither Taeny's "fault" , nor Baek Ahyeon's that she appears so overwhelmed and limited.
She's a great singer, and with the experience she now has, she could perfom this song again, with Tiffany and Taeyeon, as an equal partner.
.
Taeyeon, Tiffany - Lady Marmalade
Vocal Range G3 ~ G5
Supported Range G3 ~ C5
백아연 기죽은거 같아ㅋㅋ
It's difficult to be on same stage as SNSD
I think it's just not ayeon style. She's so good with calm and slow or cute song.
That happen when you want to be a singer and get a lead and main vocalist as your partner...
this was so... pretty. and so tame... not at all what lady marmalade is supposed to be. it's so safe and boring. pretty girls. nice voices. but not much else.
Wait who was the other girl and why was she with them? She has a cute voice
It's from KPOP star (season 4 i think?), a singing competition, she was performing with them as part of the live portion.
She had literally no expression
is good
Yoona Seohyun sama Irwan
Esta bien cool
I’m I crazy does Tiffany and Taeyeon look like twins
4:40 no one was talking about it but jyp looked very proud to miss a and the girl performing with them
It was LEE HI
Snsd y Miss A
Que épocas :')
미쓰에이 나오니까 박진영 표정 밝아진 거 봐 아ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
ㄹㅇ 해맑음ㅋㅋㅌㅌㅌㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
2:24 that fucking strong note of Taeyeon
at 1:27 that girl said "One more time, Isa pa???" lol I might unclearly heard it but the English of "Isa pa" in tagalog(Philippines) is "One more " also.
oh she said one more time, cmon
잘한다 ...근데 어린애한테 꼭 이런 곡을 시켜야핬는지
어느정도 상의했겠지 시키긴 누가 시켜
비하인드 보면 백아연이 이 곡 하고 싶다고 먼저 제안함