10 years ago: "Buy scottish salmon instead! as the population of salmon in other countries is decreasing rapidly". Now from Scotland: "We ain't got enough salmon left lads"
@@davidlittle7182 Toxic food. Dioxins from the Baltic in the pellet feed. Do not feed your pet any kind of Salmon food. The Salmon used in pet foods are unfit for human consumption due to dioxin levels.
The Salmon are disappearing due to radioactive contamination of the food chain from the nuclear waste dumping in the seventies and eighties in the Irish sea. The barrel dumping stopped (back when Greenpeace were effective) but only because Sellafield bent the rules and now dump through a pipeline as this is "land based disposal". This is ongoing. Salmon spend most of their life at sea. An excellent examination of this is the documentary called "Radioactive waste: Dumped and Forgotten" here on youtube. Prof Chris Busby was eventually raided by the Police and had all his computers seized. I don't think that documentary was ever broadcast in the UK. Probably to protect the nuclear industry from liability and sanction.
Excellent initiative, thanks for fighting the good fight. A couple of wee notes… It would be pretty challenging to monitor the sea lice in the river. Sea lice fall off their host within a maximum of 48hrs in fresh water. Also quite a lot is known about the migration route. It’s buoyed out in the North Sea. Have a look at the Missing Salmon Project. Keep up the good work !
Hi Duncan, I believe the monitoring is being done in the estuaries :) We'll check out the Missing Salmon Project. If you have some Salmon related projects that you think we should found please shoot me an email! - Cheers, Duarte
Are dams in Scotland equipped with fish ladders? I understand that they can help. It may be time to evaluate the existing dams to determine if they are still needed and find alternative solutions for power generation for the most egregious offenders. Quite a few dams built in the early 20th century have been removed in the US and thus helped repair ancient salmon and other migrating fish runs on both coasts. Scotland is quite obviously in great need of a massive tree planting campaign particularly along water courses.
You can also create river offshoots which allow the salmon to go through a small fraction of diverted river. It's probably worse than the ideal, and makes them more susceptible to predators and more likely to get lost, but better than nothing for sure :)
There is a Salmon ladder at Pitlochry, on the river Tay but I’ve not visited many of the dams so I’m not sure. The Pitlochry ladder is a popular attraction though with a viewing window and Salmon counter.
most dams ive visited in scotland have fish ladders yes i was very surprised when i saw this dam dosent. ive only visited a few dams no where near the amount of dams acctually in scotland so the majority of dams might not have them, but of the dams ive visited myself i would 80% do yes.
It is the marine phase of the Salmons life cycle that is the problem. Nuclear waste dumping in the Irish sea being the main cause of the loss of Salmon.
falling in love with this channel one video at a time very good pacing and the perfect level of information and easy-to-understand problems and realistic solutions. inspires the conservationist in me I never knew I had!
The Atlantic Salmon can spawn several times. Note I say can, because most of them do not survive, but some do. It is the Pacific Salmon that dies after spawning
This chanel should have millions of subscribers and views. Its videos have a very good quality and have crucial information for our generation and how we can help nature
The Sausage Principle states "If you love something, never find out how it's made" This very much applies to farmed salmon. My Father-in-Law hasn't touched the stuff since he worked on a fish-farm over 30 years ago. I cherish my ignorance, because it's tasty
Good on you for your efforts. Here on the Wye and its Welsh tributaries they have declined tragically. The 'Wye Usk Foundation' are doing great work to reverse this. Check them out - they're a veteran foundation. They might have some tips. Peace. Mark
You guys stop at nothing to finding new ways to help out nature, it's delightful to watch & I would love to volunteer with some of your projects ^^ Do you guys ever work in the Netherlands?
The salmon run is one of the most beautiful things in the world, is it true that once the salmons that run up the rivers of Europe, also created loads of extra nutrients for the primeval forests? As what happens in Alaska and the American East Coast?
Read in NatGeo about a guy who wanted to map every Redwood from N Mexico to Canada and how far back from the sea they ran . While doing it it occurred to him that the trees higher up were as substantial almost as the ones down in the valleys which should have had the edge . As he followed the spawning fish climb the river sometimes the rains could stop a few days that would halt the flow and leave pools where the salmon would be stuck for a while . They would die in there if left too long and bears and other animals got an easy feed , and take it back to their young often berthed below the great roots of the Redwoods . The fish detritus and cubs shit meant the trees right up top were as well fed as the lowest .
@@draphotube4315 He also found out that the bears hate water in their ears , so they'll use their hind legs to kick up the dead fish from the bottom . So he got into the pool with them and got some great pics from about 3 yards away . Everything needs to thrive for this world to work properly , it's called the food chain for a very good reason .
Hi, What do you think about the idea of removing the dams from the streams and creeks etcetra. Reestablishing fish populations, opening up spawning grounds, has been a notable factor enabling dam removal on many rivers in the United States
i think you got one thing wrong. i work with salmon and seatrout. Smolt is only a very short transition just between river and sea. When it reach the sea and color turn blank a few days and its no longer a smolt. Growing ind the sea its not a smolt, only a few days. Its like a getting the first period just an ability that evolves. Actually a very interesting ability to prevent osmosis from drying up the freshwater fish, it makes a process where its organs filter out the salts, like when a whale blows "water" its actually most salt....
In the US, many landowners are working with consultants who select improved native edible tree crops and berry crops to plant alongside riverways. These are gleefully called "riparian buffets" vs. your typical non-edible riparian buffers.
nice channel, just discovered it today, subbed. Also, you should check out the River Runner documentary about the human influence on salmon on the River Lee and the impact on a post-glacial alluvial forrest in the area
I wonder if you're planing to build little side flumes that need very little water. The salmon can travel along a gentle slope from below the dam to above it, and it's simple concrete but naturalized. And in reverse for the parr. :) I know you know salmon only need inches, no more than a decimeter, of running water to travel difficult passages. Its not enough water to affect the dam either.
Perhaps you could get a representative of the British Royal Family to support your projects in Scotland. They are generally very interested in environmental issues and have strong ties to Scotland.
That's probably not a reality over there. Probably the best these guys can hope for is some really heavily managed riparian areas, but that's probably enough to get them back into a fisheries management situation that's markedly better than where they're currently at. It's really important that these guys maintain the genetic integrity of that population and I think rebuilding these spawning watersheds is a crucial first step.
@@420JackG The problem is that the natural hydrology of the river systems is dependent upon tree cover, which no longer exists, since the destruction of the Caledonian forest, and all attempts at re-establishing that forest are thwarted by deer browsing... Wolves may be the answer to the deer problem.
Worth a watch… Search domain m.th-cam.com/video/nAGHUkby2Ish/w-d-xo.htmlttps://m.youtube.com › watch?v=nAGHUkby2Is Restoring the ancient Caledonian Forest Alan Watson ... Nearly 30 years ago, Trees for Life Founder, Alan Watson-Featherstone stood in the Universal Hall and in front of 300 people made a life-long commitment to r...
damn this is sad. Hopefully Scotland won't lose it's salmon populaction like here in Poland (PS: there have been some recent sightings of them, but still super rare)
The irony of a supposedly renewable energy source (which would've been seen as a big pat on the back at the time) having a direct detrimental effect on the ecosystem is a special kind of sad...
Well that's because it wasn't made with them in mind. There are solutions like fish ladders that can allow for the travel of fish or creating new river systems. It just wasn't something that was taken into account
Currently only one project as we have a European team. We collaborate with an organisation in California on Sea Otter research. We might look to expand in North America in the future with a full time person in the US or Canada. However, we still have to grow a bit more for that :) You can see all our projects here mossy.earth/projects/rewilding
I know many people who were employed on the farms in the west coast of Scotland . You could take home 3 fish per week for your self . None of the locals ever took them , only the foreigners come to work there did . I only once tried a grade A wild salmon in its prime , poached from the Leven after 6 weeks , nearly every night , by a mate . He caught one fish and it was on his last night of trying , 1.2 meters long , I forget the weight . But I got two slices . Never had it since of that quality , it was memorable .
Just gonna ask why does the dams not have fish leaders that allow the salmon and other fish get in and out of the area this is just because I don’t really know if anyone one knows I would like too know
There was a law in England in the middle ages that stated you could not feed your 'workers' Salom more than three times a week!! It was that plentiful in England! how things change
People love or hate the idea of the European Bison reintroduction now imagine if we placed Bears back in Scotland, think that would be a lot more controversial, hence why people shouldn't worry about "giant beasts" bison are super chill, bears would be something to REALLY worry about
At around 4:30 in the video there is a mention that a significant thread comes from deforrestation and climate change. The effect of deforrestation is explained in the video as the trees near the river cool the river but the climate change effect was left without explanation. So I'm asking here, what is the significant thread to Scottish salmon from climate change?
@@rcr76 it is every estuary in the UK and I suspect that it is a plan to attract great white sharks and other apex preditors to these shores ,... an oceanagraphic study boat will be monitoring British waters this year
@@johnstockburn6396 not sure it’s a plan to attract them .i suspect they are already here from time to time certainly orcas are .I know the amount of seals in Ne Scotland is very large and shooting of them is controversial as people only see the seal and not the returning salmon -sea trout .Also loads of dolphin and porpoise and at the same time next to no salmon netting .i know they are putting deer feet into the rivers far upstream to replace nutrients from spawned fish .islander outdoors does some great videos about uk sharks .think he’s on Isle of Man
That woman was so desperately trying to tie it to climate change when it was obviously deforestation. Even going as far to only admit they needed more trees for their carbon, not the reason for the entire video.
10 years ago: "Buy scottish salmon instead! as the population of salmon in other countries is decreasing rapidly". Now from Scotland: "We ain't got enough salmon left lads"
It was farmed stuff they were selling
@@davidlittle7182 Toxic food. Dioxins from the Baltic in the pellet feed. Do not feed your pet any kind of Salmon food. The Salmon used in pet foods are unfit for human consumption due to dioxin levels.
The Salmon are disappearing due to radioactive contamination of the food chain from the nuclear waste dumping in the seventies and eighties in the Irish sea. The barrel dumping stopped (back when Greenpeace were effective) but only because Sellafield bent the rules and now dump through a pipeline as this is "land based disposal". This is ongoing. Salmon spend most of their life at sea. An excellent examination of this is the documentary called "Radioactive waste: Dumped and Forgotten" here on youtube. Prof Chris Busby was eventually raided by the Police and had all his computers seized. I don't think that documentary was ever broadcast in the UK. Probably to protect the nuclear industry from liability and sanction.
Excellent initiative, thanks for fighting the good fight. A couple of wee notes… It would be pretty challenging to monitor the sea lice in the river. Sea lice fall off their host within a maximum of 48hrs in fresh water. Also quite a lot is known about the migration route. It’s buoyed out in the North Sea. Have a look at the Missing Salmon Project. Keep up the good work !
Hi Duncan, I believe the monitoring is being done in the estuaries :) We'll check out the Missing Salmon Project. If you have some Salmon related projects that you think we should found please shoot me an email! - Cheers, Duarte
Are dams in Scotland equipped with fish ladders? I understand that they can help. It may be time to evaluate the existing dams to determine if they are still needed and find alternative solutions for power generation for the most egregious offenders. Quite a few dams built in the early 20th century have been removed in the US and thus helped repair ancient salmon and other migrating fish runs on both coasts. Scotland is quite obviously in great need of a massive tree planting campaign particularly along water courses.
You can also create river offshoots which allow the salmon to go through a small fraction of diverted river. It's probably worse than the ideal, and makes them more susceptible to predators and more likely to get lost, but better than nothing for sure :)
There is a Salmon ladder at Pitlochry, on the river Tay but I’ve not visited many of the dams so I’m not sure. The Pitlochry ladder is a popular attraction though with a viewing window and Salmon counter.
most dams ive visited in scotland have fish ladders yes i was very surprised when i saw this dam dosent. ive only visited a few dams no where near the amount of dams acctually in scotland so the majority of dams might not have them, but of the dams ive visited myself i would 80% do yes.
Yes they are
It is the marine phase of the Salmons life cycle that is the problem. Nuclear waste dumping in the Irish sea being the main cause of the loss of Salmon.
falling in love with this channel one video at a time very good pacing and the perfect level of information and easy-to-understand problems and realistic solutions. inspires the conservationist in me I never knew I had!
The Atlantic Salmon can spawn several times. Note I say can, because most of them do not survive, but some do. It is the Pacific Salmon that dies after spawning
Yes, but Kelts look pretty rough - which is what I think they were trying to depict.
Wonder what percentage of the run spawns multiple times.
This chanel should have millions of subscribers and views. Its videos have a very good quality and have crucial information for our generation and how we can help nature
Brilliant work. The wild of Scotland needs some care and attention. Good to see your inspiring commitment.
The Sausage Principle states "If you love something, never find out how it's made"
This very much applies to farmed salmon. My Father-in-Law hasn't touched the stuff since he worked on a fish-farm over 30 years ago. I cherish my ignorance, because it's tasty
Aye, but wild salmon is much better.
Wild sausage too, or so I'm told.
Thanks!
We need your help with a project like this in Ireland
Good on you for your efforts. Here on the Wye and its Welsh tributaries they have declined tragically. The 'Wye Usk Foundation' are doing great work to reverse this. Check them out - they're a veteran foundation. They might have some tips. Peace. Mark
That was really interesting :) Amazing project
Thank you Jules! and as always super stoked to have you as a member 🙌 - Cheers, Duarte
They know the connection between Forrest and sea in Japan, that's why they have great fishing and as lot of forests
Thank you for caring and doing
You guys stop at nothing to finding new ways to help out nature, it's delightful to watch & I would love to volunteer with some of your projects ^^
Do you guys ever work in the Netherlands?
Not yet, the netherlands has a LOT of rewilding projects though so you should be able to find a worthy one to help out :) - Cheers, Duarte
I really like the salmon thumbnail art!
The salmon run is one of the most beautiful things in the world, is it true that once the salmons that run up the rivers of Europe, also created loads of extra nutrients for the primeval forests? As what happens in Alaska and the American East Coast?
I couldn't agree more! My understanding is that yes, there used to be a proper Salmon run but it has been gone for a very long time. - Cheers, Duarte
Read in NatGeo about a guy who wanted to map every Redwood from N Mexico to Canada and how far back from the sea they ran . While doing it it occurred to him that the trees higher up were as substantial almost as the ones down in the valleys which should have had the edge . As he followed the spawning fish climb the river sometimes the rains could stop a few days that would halt the flow and leave pools where the salmon would be stuck for a while . They would die in there if left too long and bears and other animals got an easy feed , and take it back to their young often berthed below the great roots of the Redwoods . The fish detritus and cubs shit meant the trees right up top were as well fed as the lowest .
@@laurencesmith2199 I heard about this as well, it's indeed amazing how the salmon basically build those temperate rainforests
@@draphotube4315
He also found out that the bears hate water in their ears , so they'll use their hind legs to kick up the dead fish from the bottom . So he got into the pool with them and got some great pics from about 3 yards away .
Everything needs to thrive for this world to work properly , it's called the food chain for a very good reason .
Hi,
What do you think about the idea of removing the dams from the streams and creeks etcetra. Reestablishing fish populations, opening up spawning grounds, has been a notable factor enabling dam removal on many rivers in the United States
How long does the aspen tree take to grow so that it can provide sufficient shade to river banks?
Fancy doing anything on Ireland, especially because we have a whole mythology about Salmon
i think you got one thing wrong. i work with salmon and seatrout. Smolt is only a very short transition just between river and sea. When it reach the sea and color turn blank a few days and its no longer a smolt. Growing ind the sea its not a smolt, only a few days. Its like a getting the first period just an ability that evolves. Actually a very interesting ability to prevent osmosis from drying up the freshwater fish, it makes a process where its organs filter out the salts, like when a whale blows "water" its actually most salt....
My grandpa always say, if you take the pig from it job, you have to do the pig's job, i guess we have busy things to do.
In the US, many landowners are working with consultants who select improved native edible tree crops and berry crops to plant alongside riverways. These are gleefully called "riparian buffets" vs. your typical non-edible riparian buffers.
The Magic School Bus taught me about salmon 😂
We all know that show was dope!
It was such a great show! - Cheers, Duarte
nice channel, just discovered it today, subbed. Also, you should check out the River Runner documentary about the human influence on salmon on the River Lee and the impact on a post-glacial alluvial forrest in the area
Thank you! It has been added to the viewing list :) - Cheers, Duarte
The average woman from guatamala should be the official measurement unit of everything.
indeed 😂
Very cool project!
Thank you Moritz :) - Cheers, Duarte
Its the forests that rely on the nutrition brought by the salmon
Fantastic video!
Thank you Vlad!
I wonder if you're planing to build little side flumes that need very little water. The salmon can travel along a gentle slope from below the dam to above it, and it's simple concrete but naturalized. And in reverse for the parr. :) I know you know salmon only need inches, no more than a decimeter, of running water to travel difficult passages. Its not enough water to affect the dam either.
2:22 almost 40%of their body is just head, I wonder how smart they are
Perhaps you could get a representative of the British Royal Family to support your projects in Scotland. They are generally very interested in environmental issues and have strong ties to Scotland.
Step one: Reintroduce wolves.
There's no point in planting trees that will be eaten by deer.
That's probably not a reality over there. Probably the best these guys can hope for is some really heavily managed riparian areas, but that's probably enough to get them back into a fisheries management situation that's markedly better than where they're currently at. It's really important that these guys maintain the genetic integrity of that population and I think rebuilding these spawning watersheds is a crucial first step.
@@420JackG The problem is that the natural hydrology of the river systems is dependent upon tree cover, which no longer exists, since the destruction of the Caledonian forest, and all attempts at re-establishing that forest are thwarted by deer browsing...
Wolves may be the answer to the deer problem.
Worth a watch…
Search domain m.th-cam.com/video/nAGHUkby2Ish/w-d-xo.htmlttps://m.youtube.com › watch?v=nAGHUkby2Is
Restoring the ancient Caledonian Forest Alan Watson ...
Nearly 30 years ago, Trees for Life Founder, Alan Watson-Featherstone stood in the Universal Hall and in front of 300 people made a life-long commitment to r...
damn this is sad. Hopefully Scotland won't lose it's salmon populaction like here in Poland (PS: there have been some recent sightings of them, but still super rare)
The irony of a supposedly renewable energy source (which would've been seen as a big pat on the back at the time) having a direct detrimental effect on the ecosystem is a special kind of sad...
Well that's because it wasn't made with them in mind. There are solutions like fish ladders that can allow for the travel of fish or creating new river systems. It just wasn't something that was taken into account
Good work
do you guys have any projects going on in North America?
Currently only one project as we have a European team. We collaborate with an organisation in California on Sea Otter research. We might look to expand in North America in the future with a full time person in the US or Canada. However, we still have to grow a bit more for that :) You can see all our projects here mossy.earth/projects/rewilding
The sad thing with knowledge from studies is that the results are also used to benefit some. Not knowing where the salmon go to sea is a good thing
Beavers provide essential ecosystem recovery for rivers and fish.
Salmons can be described as 80% salt water and 20% fresh water fish.
A fascinating wild fish that is unique on its own right but also is deeply interwoven into our history and culture 🙂!
Some thrive and spawn as freshwater landlocked salmon as well.
@2:56 What specific salmon do you mean? 🤔
You need to put up a deer fence or those trees will never make it
Some trees are not eaten by deer.
I know many people who were employed on the farms in the west coast of Scotland . You could take home 3 fish per week for your self . None of the locals ever took them , only the foreigners come to work there did .
I only once tried a grade A wild salmon in its prime , poached from the Leven after 6 weeks , nearly every night , by a mate . He caught one fish and it was on his last night of trying , 1.2 meters long , I forget the weight . But I got two slices . Never had it since of that quality , it was memorable .
Bravo.
Just gonna ask why does the dams not have fish leaders that allow the salmon and other fish get in and out of the area this is just because I don’t really know if anyone one knows I would like too know
Many do have fish ladders
None of the fish ladders actually work they way we hoped they would.
Awesome.
Thank you Chris! - Cheers, Duarte
We do not need to reforest just for the salmon we need to do this for the whole eco system
I pretty much like this. Not sarcastic or something. I didin't realized that there are red salmon!
never knew about these salmon
There was a law in England in the middle ages that stated you could not feed your 'workers' Salom more than three times a week!! It was that plentiful in England! how things change
People love or hate the idea of the European Bison reintroduction now imagine if we placed Bears back in Scotland, think that would be a lot more controversial, hence why people shouldn't worry about "giant beasts" bison are super chill, bears would be something to REALLY worry about
Better deer management, more trees.
Yep that is how it works :) - Cheers, Duarte
I hope you could place proper English captions eventually. The accent was charming, but it drove the autosubs insane.
excellent
Meanwhile me playing salmon run in splatoon 2 and destroing the salmanoids: Yes
😂
Yes and not forrests for harvest as plantations cause acidification and silt
As the upturn clay soils
You also changed the tumbnail here, this one is nice but idk if it's better than the previous
Lets see what the algorithm thinks :)
@@MossyEarth I never new the tumbnail affected algorithm
@@MossyEarth Ok, you won this, it affected the algorithm
Aren’t there fish ladders?
At around 4:30 in the video there is a mention that a significant thread comes from deforrestation and climate change. The effect of deforrestation is explained in the video as the trees near the river cool the river but the climate change effect was left without explanation. So I'm asking here, what is the significant thread to Scottish salmon from climate change?
It is the same issue. Increases in the average temperature of the water reduces the ability of the salmon to spawn. - Cheers, Duarte
Start culling the seals and that will save thousands of salmon
Been scrolling down looking for this comment.seals are bloody everywhere
@@rcr76 it is every estuary in the UK and I suspect that it is a plan to attract great white sharks and other apex preditors to these shores ,... an oceanagraphic study boat will be monitoring British waters this year
@@johnstockburn6396 not sure it’s a plan to attract them .i suspect they are already here from time to time certainly orcas are .I know the amount of seals in Ne Scotland is very large and shooting of them is controversial as people only see the seal and not the returning salmon -sea trout .Also loads of dolphin and porpoise and at the same time next to no salmon netting .i know they are putting deer feet into the rivers far upstream to replace nutrients from spawned fish .islander outdoors does some great videos about uk sharks .think he’s on Isle of Man
Yeah right!
Silly Salmon!!!
I thought salmons live one year only😂😂😂😂😂😂
That woman was so desperately trying to tie it to climate change when it was obviously deforestation. Even going as far to only admit they needed more trees for their carbon, not the reason for the entire video.
So bring back wolves and bears would be the best thing to do
0:05 "Salmon" are not a species. There are several species of salmon among two genera. Even your own documentary recognizes this later on.
Fix the captioning.
How's the salmon were everywhere a 100 years ago with out this ????
🇮🇪🏴
Up the Celts.
Mention of climate change is the turn-off signal for me.
+
Wegen millions of Irish humans died that was karma for destroying everything
Trees are good but ye are bull ing !