Panjim resident #furious over doctor’s protesting in front of Panjim church. Angry resident tells protestors to not use church premises #Goa #GoaNews #resident #protest #Church
please object against tourists taking pics and movies being filmed here too! I’m a Catholic and I feel this protest is perfectly justified as its main sentiment is peace, like you mention. there are plenty of Catholic doctors in the protest too. Please campaign for stoppage of all activity if this noble cause offends you. Don’t be separatist in causes :)
Don't blame this advocate bcoz he has not taken theka to stand every time to speak. Other people also should speak. Church temples are not places to protest. Church is his God house.
There's no problem if they do it for Good cause , Did church priest objected ,who is he then Yes Jesus said don't used church for selling and buying for its God house , they are not selling or buying, Uncle you too should join them to show your support for that girl . Did you spoke for that girl to support, No .
Looks like he has Familial enemity towards doctor.. Cos everyone in his family is doctor.. And he alone is advocate😂 Jani Dushman... This are the same Advocates who will Defend the Culprits in Courts and let them free
Take the doctors to your Gods. These doctors don't care if Goan girls are raped or murdered. Someone has been paid to create this protest for outside state rape case ..CM should take action on these doctors. All politics to brainwash the Goans.
@@CollinFernandes-up5dbThat's right, they didn't care about the Siddhi Naik case. What happened in West Bengal was just ghanttis being ghanttis. Such cases are also eventually bound to happen in Goa also. Demographics is Destiny.
@@ritz7780ghatia when you have seen people entering our churches with bikinis? I think you got this Information from your rss whatsApp university history.
To everyone who thinks this uncle is right, here is what you need to know, One of the most poignant examples of compassion in the Bible is when Jesus showed compassion at the grave of Lazarus. When Jesus saw Lazarus' friends weeping, he wept alongside them (John 11:33-35). Over and over, our Lord Jesus Christ felt compassion on people, healing them and comforting them. Did this uncle show compassion?
These ghantti doctors (check their surnames) don't show compassion for poorer patients in GMC. Even what happened to the lady doctor in West Bengal was Typical Ghantti Behaviour. They've no business obstructing the church entrance for their virtue-signalling show.
Dont add more kerosene to the fair and fear. you can help them. ask for wisdom and knowledge of God to bring PEACE AND HARMONY IN THIS SITUATION. GOD BLESS YOU ALL
😮😮😮😮this protest is for a good cause. A girl lost her life because of someone elses brutality. Is worshipping God without humanity more important? What is a church if people have no feelings for others? What this advicate would have said if the victim doctor was one of his kin? Humanity first...then politics in name of religion.
These protestors didn't care about Siddhi Naik. They just obstructed the church entrance and traffic flow for virtue-signalling. What happened in West Bengal was Typical Ghantti Behaviour. Such incidents will eventually happen in Goa also because of mass immigration of ghanttis. Demographics is Destiny.
@@cg8397 did you or the advocate who is talking about the sanctity of church ever raised your voice against Siddhis murder? I still say that Church is nothing if you don't practice humanity.
Amazing how people like this won't raise their voice against a crime that needs a voice but will sure get offended about things like this and create a scene unnecessarily
Its the perfect place to show solidarity with those who are standing up against such gruesome crime.. ... Its a wonderful thought that the doctors chose this place to protest from... They must have selected this place for two reasons, 1) When you truly worship God you will stand up for humanity, compassion and justice... These are the values that jesus peached .. jesus stood up for the oppressed during his time on earth... He spoke against the injustice that was taking place during his time ... these are the values that christianity stands for ... 2) it is the most visited place and well known through out the country.. they would have thought their message would be heard and seen faster . But in the face of what has happened to the lady doctor, to several other women and to our Siddhi Naik , the place from where you show solidarity with them , would never matter ...
The protestors picked the wrong location. They blocked the church entrance and obstructed road traffic. There were also alternative places they could've chosen. Most of the protestors were also ghanttis, they've no business intruding and obstructing local spaces.
Why the media did not post the whole rally which took place from 9pm onwards ?? Why only few mins of it was posted when half of us hade still not reach the SACRED steps! And why they didn't show that once the uncle started giving his speech we did not argue but just vacate the steps ! Why the main point of protest is not being showcased??? People are trying their beste to demotivate in every wayw possible This scene shown is of just few mins ! The whole protest did not take place here!!!!
We just happened to be there becuz the last thing we thought about was you guys making this a religious issue. As a Christian myself I think we fail to see the bigger picture
Finally we as Goans again failed to prove that humanity is above our beliefs.. it’s sad to see that we are against such protests.. sad to see this video getting public in other states and we arr ashamed of again for our behaviour. Protesting in front of church for me was like - Asking god to be with us in this situation.. I don’t find it wrong in asking help from god
Absolutely correct.. Let the protest at the Azad Maidan, or at the police station, or at the Collectors office. When you go to any government hospital in Goa, these very same doctors have neither sympathy nor humanity in treating our the sick.
Thankyou news channel - by twisting the headline of the news for your own masala diverting the attention of the public from the cause of the protest - that is rape and murder of an innocent woman by multiple men. Moral of the story - in india - people will keep quarrelling among themselves in the name of religion, caste, creed- and forget that every religion preaches harmony, humanity and kindness.
I totally agree with advocate, the church is not a place to protest. I strongly object to this place being used. Protests should be done in front of the GMC hospital. Pls respect, the sanctity of the Church
Rightly said. In front of religious place protest cannot be held. Strict action should be taken all religious places should be respected. In front of temples, mosques or other religious places they will protest to destroy the peace. This is not right, let them protest in Azad maidan or public places where there is no silence required.
Hoi sutlat dista tho , aami churchin , temple kidyak voita . Deva lagi makpak voita aami , aamka pav , family pav , saglyank safe dovar . Ase aami bare magpak voita , Dr.Right to fight cha vatin aasa . Aani Right to fight thaich God always aasa .
No temple's, masjids or churches should be used to protest .. This are holy places and should not be blocked like this .. there are many other places to protest ..
It’s funny how the people of Goa have made this into a religion thing yet again. The Mary Immaculate Conception Church represents Goa in so many ways,I believe that must have been the only reason this place was chosen. If everyone’s sentiments are getting hurt regarding religion, Goa’s tourism shouldn’t be promoted with churches and temples either.
But is publicity and raising awareness for a noble cause such a bad thing? Even if there is a problem with slogans being chanted they were abt bringing justice to someone who was wronged, pls don't divert attention from something that deserves it for personal gain
@@Filo498 Don't talk rubbish! They started their protest from Patto and ended near the church. Barely they were there for 10 minutes. They were doing this for a cause. Doctors are taken for granted. Have you ever tried to find out how many hours each resident doctor works? Please find out and then talk. With people like you at the helm of affairs these things happen.
@@Moneymake-n6sNo, he's correct. None of these ghantti doctors (check out their surnames) were bothered when Siddhi Naik was killed. What happened to the Bengali lady doctor was also Typical Ghantti Behaviour. Ghanttis aren't welcome to Goa, they have to go back.
As A Christian I agree With The Advocate Our Sentiments are Getting Hurt Wherever There is any kind Of Gatherings Happen You'll only find The panaji Church Capital Infront of That Shame On You'll Protester's Go to that Place where that occurred & Protest over there
What this man did was absolutely wrong. He is against Ladies. Jesus brought them there. Jesus loves everyone. Mama Mary loves all children young and old. God forgive this man for what he did. This man spoiled our protest. Jesus please give justice for this Dr. Who was gang raped and killed and also for all others who were killed like this and also our daughter Nidhi Naik . Amen 🙏❤️✝️
Nothing wrong in this matter sir pls forgive them, entire nation shocked this heinous Crime and this is our Mothers Sisters Daughters and our children life safety.God bless us all Amen 🙏
Why forgive? Who forgives? When a doctor faulters are they held accountable or licence suspended in India? Never. Do We have Volunteers system in India for research studies? No. Patients are used like specimens & guinea pigs for research. Anyone aware? To become a Surgeon how do they start on who do they use? Ordinary people. Politicians go to private hospitals as they are aware about what is happening in govt hospitals. Doctors are loosing respect. Money matters. Organ transplantation money matters. IVF, Surrogacy, etc lots more. All About Money 💰💵 Who's Honest?
All those talking in favour of this guy either have no idea what happened or are just trying to look good in front of everyone....... Even the priest there had no problem with the doctors and was even inviting them onto the stairs This guy just trying to get popular. Rapes are happening, women are dying and no one is doing anything, but if someone tries to do something about it ur sentiments get hurt... This was an attempt by the doctors of goa medical college to raise awareness among the masses but apparently no one cares. Very sad that this man and all the uncles and aunties in the comment section got hurt by the protest happening and felt the need to react, but dont even feel the need to think about what is going on in the country.
Uncle, you are welcome to let God help you on the hospital bed🥲, since you say doctors are not really gods... Classic Indian Uncleism!. All doctors.... Please help uncle find god, he doesnt need your help
Even the people who did this crime had the same thought! It's 8th day ,even Nirbhaya case got justice after years ...hum nahi bhulenge! Plz don't demotivate us!
Great Job, turning the protest which was intended to be for a noble cause into something thats meant to dishonor the church, respectfuly uncle you should be seriously reconsidering your stand on this, because it doesn't take much brains to understand what the whole rally was about And to those who consider the holy place to be defiled due to this process, just a notification that the real people of the church were at full support Please don't change this peaceful procession into something that it was never meant to be 🙏
Sir if you would have visited GMC you would know they are protesting there.. The soul motive of this protest was so that people know why it's being done
God is not only in church or temple, god is everywhere, and rape is seen in all kind of setting home, temple and work place. They are at mother Mary's feet to ask for justice.
First of all no protest should be in any of the religious places. N for u , y only the chose to protest infront of church? Y not infront of other religious places?
Who is this guy and if his religious sentiment is getting hurt, has he objected to all the scantily clad tourists who tramp up and down those 77 steps? Hope he adds that in the complaint.
Don't make it about religion. Please 🙏🏻 it was a protest for asking for punishhment of the rapists - so what if it is doctors who are protesting - don't belittle the cause. We are educated people, and no religion supports or promotes rape. ( That is exactly why the priest himself called us to assemble on the chairs- which makes him more religious than any of you using religion as a foul mean to gain attention)
@@akanshamalwa8833 doutor Rui is a gentleman, a father and a vociferous activist. He's old school, he grew up in Portuguese era Goa, where rule of law was strictly enforced. I wager he was upset because requisite permissions weren't taken. May the Almighty bless each and every one of you protestors, for generations to come. Mog asum di 🙏🙏
@@ashadsouza4450 madam but if film shooting is carried out over is that k for many film shooting where carried out blocking traffic blocking any one to enter the Church is this wright ? But if protest done for humanity u fill its wrong
@@kkrnnn6645 Very true dear. This people do not understand what they say. Being educated he failed his education. We are fighting for a cause and this was not political. May God give justice to this Dr. I pray 🙏❤️
Adv. Sir, nobodies sentiments are hurt over here , what happens when all the tourists come and click photos, do selfies, and then sit and drink on the steps, that time where r the sentiments??, where are the church authorities??protest is not done inside the church but outside, on top there are many Christian Doctors too who were there for the protest, and it's a peaceful protest, no church property or anything has been vandalised .
Mr. Naik. You have gone insane. Lets say the tourist who take selfies are wrong. But these protesters are also wrong in sitting on the footsteps of a temple or church and protesting with big banners. No matter how genuine the cause is. Will you accept these protesters sitting on your door steps, protesting against rape or murder. YOU will tell them, GO AWAY FROM MY HOUSE .... Correct ?
@@AntuFernandes-t6ju hv any idea what do you mean by insane???, and speaking about the protest, this is a genuine cause and it's at the main road square , so people can't even sit on the steps ?? As i said protest is a peaceful 1 and not hurting anybody, evn if they cum at my doorstep and sit in front of my house for the protest specially in this case , I will not say anything to them neither will tell them to get lost, 🙏
For 10 minutes if they come and protest infront of my house I'll join them for this cause. The church authorities didn't object P. S they know what is good for the church and your religion much better than u will ever do. If it was something against Christianity they would have objected. police didn't object. They know law and order better than u. Fakt tuka khaaz😂@@AntuFernandes-t6j
Why protesting infront of any religious place of Worship ? They should protest at Azad Maidan, Bus stop , etc . The interviewer doesn't seem to know anything about Goa or our sentiments. In future if there are rape incidents then will people protest always in front of our church? Find out who asked them to converge infront of the church because it looks like that person is out to exploit this sensitive issue to help his political masters .
When tourist do photo session they are dressed as if they are at a beach or party which is wrong than why didnt this adv didnt take a stand for the right didnt it hurt your sentiments that time and still photo sessions goes on every single day its a holy place,the adv didn't realise what crap he is speaking justice for Dr moumita Debnath
*I am more than JUST a woman* *I am of and FOR the gods* *If you cannot come to me as divine* *Do NOT come to me at all* My heart goes out to each and every person who came out to protest. May your families be blessed for generations to come🙏
I agree doctors arent God, so thats why theyre at Gods feet to ask for Justice but you seem to be more concerned about your personal issues. Instead of just supporting the cause you had to be a diva about it.
uncles religious place isn't defiled when tourists sit and do pda on the stairs. But ofc uncles religious place is defiled when people stand for humanity. It was a peaceful protest done with absolute respect, If the Parish priest accepted us then who tf is uncle. DOCTORS WERE THERE TEMPORARILY FOR BARELY 10 MIN ..after walking from patto, so stfu.
@Myworldisgoa so PDA is better than a peaceful 10 min stand outside the church for a rape victim. not gonna argue with a stone. the fact that religion ( temple church mosque , i dont care) is what you see first speaks volume about your mindset . Stay delusional 👍🏽
@@divyasabnis9311Stop lying again, Marathi ghantti. Locals have objected against ghantti PDA also. This protest was just another similar case of Typical Ghantti Behaviour.
Our heartfelt sympathy to the victim doctor and her family. Why can't they do this protest at Azad Maidan? Why these doctor's did not protest during the rapes in Manipur? Why is the selective protest? A Fauji's wife was raped and murdered some girls were raped there too? All our doctors were silent as if nothing had heard nor noticed in Manipur. Sad but true😢.
This protest was not only because she was raped but also because she was murdered brutally, 1000+ mob came to destroy the hospital, threatened the doctors who were carrying out candle march (docs were hiding , asking for help and sadly this happened on the day of independence)! Pls don't demotivate us !
This proves Humility is been sold in name of Law and British law system of divide and Rule... For your information... Lord Jesus Christ sacrifice himself for people like this...😢💯🥺 Lord Jesus Christ sacrifice for life...🥺💯 Does that daughter WHOM get horrifically tortured and life of her is distroyed in seconds for unwelcome evil thinking😢... And what he have studied through the law which implemented and bought by his ancestors... The British implemented law and our constitution and court order referred from same can't give justice to that innocent girl ...😢 I was not willing to comment on such things, but people like this making to comment.... He calls him Cristian and not following what Jesus Christ massage is... So what left 😢i don't know 😢
I think he shld also have protested when d tourist come there , religious places is nt for clickng pics or selfie n this shld b taught to everyone whthr its any religion 🙏🏼
i think people should go to the designated place and protest as there are some people who want to pray in church and are unable to enter because of the crowd gathered there. and also why people are protesting in goa when there are people already protesting at the right place in calcutta, it makes no sense.
it's about enforcing CPA all over the country. you think women in GMC are safe? also get your facts right the protest wasn't outside the church the doctors stood there for 10 min after taking due respect because we know how symbolic the church is for national coverage protest was from patto
If this is the case with you advocate .y don't u stop the tourist taking pictures in poses n tourist with dress code .if u can't stop this sir I respect u .
The person responsible at the church was asking us to come up instead He even asked us to go up n said u all will get a good picture! And this uncle is just seeking attention!
@@NazarioDsouza-sv4tb so people gathering outside the church for a noble cause that inclines with what Christianity teaches us(not to commit rape and murder) is wrong but tourists who come there for the pictures and to have a good time is okay ? Shame on you sir
@@waldrondesa8287do other religions don't preach that? Why only the church was chosen? To get maximum publicity? This is what rss wanted maximum publicity.
Dotor, ur wrong, actually u should join them in their protest, what if someone near to u had been murdered like her, even in that situation u would have given a speech like this
How exactly are sentiments hurt? Protesting an atrocity is a criminal activity? They are outside the church, if it was offensive than the church authorities will object.
seems like people are so blinded by religion that they forget the main essence of christianity, or infact any religion for that matter. humanity is the greatest religion out there. doing this shor sharaba and yapping away doesnt make you a better christian. it takes being a human, a decent compassionate human at that.
Please stop masquerading as a Christian... we know you are r s s who do these kind of protests here in Goa , get out of goa Hindus can live in other states Spare goa
Pls inteospect yourself Madam, before being associated with the rastriya swayam sevak sangh and masquerading as goan, leave the state and don't create a mess
Use your voice for something worthwhile.. They are not doing anything wrong... In fact, they are voicing against something done wrong.. I'm a Catholic too...stop yelling and acting weird for a little propaganda...where are you when tourist are taking pics and movies are being shot...isn't the church sanctity affected by those activities?
please object against tourists taking pics and movies being filmed here too! I’m a Catholic and I feel this protest is perfectly justified as its main sentiment is peace, like you mention. there are plenty of Catholic doctors in the protest too. Please campaign for stoppage of all activity if this noble cause offends you. Don’t be separatist in causes :)
I agree with you advocate
But where were yiu when movies are flimed in churches
@@johnnydsouza2276 correct my brother,this fellow must been getting commission from film shooting
The topic here is protest an not filming. Now everybody wants their weddings to be filmed.
@@Myworldisgoa I am talking about movies not wedding filming
Don't blame this advocate bcoz he has not taken theka to stand every time to speak. Other people also should speak. Church temples are not places to protest. Church is his God house.
Do Gods not want their children to be served justice?
There's no problem if they do it for Good cause , Did church priest objected ,who is he then Yes Jesus said don't used church for selling and buying for its God house , they are not selling or buying, Uncle you too should join them to show your support for that girl . Did you spoke for that girl to support, No .
Looks like he has Familial enemity towards doctor.. Cos everyone in his family is doctor.. And he alone is advocate😂 Jani Dushman...
This are the same Advocates who will Defend the Culprits in Courts and let them free
he is bastard
Tourist are sitting on church steps with half naked dress n takes photographs, this is also wrong.,
That he doesn't see
Y infront of church??? Doctor must go to protest infront of hospitals wherever in Goa. Go to Azad maidan or vishwajeet Rane house sattari.
Sir with all due respect do you know why doctors are protesting?
They are only making their presence felt 😅
No. It's a protest against all the rapists in the society. Thankyou. Don't comment if u don't know anything
I know y they are protesting, but u just see this is not place to protest, I also support that doctor. What Modi is doing will see now.
In front of your house right
What about when tourists come and take selfies? Don't our religious sentiments get hurt?
Thr u r
Tourist are not coming there to protest. The issue is holding protest infront of the church.
@@Myworldisgoa u should b have people chose religious place to ask for justice .
For all these time u were sleeping n ur a Catholic Now u are telling Tourist taking selfie. Anyone can take selfie not a big deal
Go ask the Parish Priest@@Myworldisgoa
in that case uncle should visit religious places to heal himself and not come to hospitals
Why are you Hindutva fascists backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
Why are you Hindutva agents backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
Take the doctors to your Gods. These doctors don't care if Goan girls are raped or murdered. Someone has been paid to create this protest for outside state rape case ..CM should take action on these doctors. All politics to brainwash the Goans.
@@CollinFernandes-up5dbThat's right, they didn't care about the Siddhi Naik case. What happened in West Bengal was just ghanttis being ghanttis. Such cases are also eventually bound to happen in Goa also. Demographics is Destiny.
You are absolutely right. They should protest at Azad maiden
True
Very true.. This looks like as if they're protesting against church.
Bikini tourist in church will do for you
@@ritz7780ghatia when you have seen people entering our churches with bikinis? I think you got this Information from your rss whatsApp university history.
@@ritz7780ghatia blady coward deleting my replies.
To everyone who thinks this uncle is right, here is what you need to know, One of the most poignant examples of compassion in the Bible is when Jesus showed compassion at the grave of Lazarus. When Jesus saw Lazarus' friends weeping, he wept alongside them (John 11:33-35). Over and over, our Lord Jesus Christ felt compassion on people, healing them and comforting them. Did this uncle show compassion?
These ghantti doctors (check their surnames) don't show compassion for poorer patients in GMC. Even what happened to the lady doctor in West Bengal was Typical Ghantti Behaviour. They've no business obstructing the church entrance for their virtue-signalling show.
The priest of the church had himself asked us to assemble on the stairs- since he supported the noble cause that we were protesting for
File FIR against all including the Priest who permitted them.
Dont add more kerosene to the fair and fear. you can help them. ask for wisdom and knowledge of God to bring PEACE AND HARMONY IN THIS SITUATION.
GOD BLESS YOU ALL
@@NazarioDsouza-sv4tb police permission ghevun gelle re baba kidem uloita
@@presidasilveira589did police gave you'll permission to organize this protest infront of the church?
@NazarioDsouza-sv4tb should definitely file one against you and your shallow thinking should definitely file one against you and your shallow thinking
😮😮😮😮this protest is for a good cause. A girl lost her life because of someone elses brutality. Is worshipping God without humanity more important? What is a church if people have no feelings for others? What this advicate would have said if the victim doctor was one of his kin? Humanity first...then politics in name of religion.
These protestors didn't care about Siddhi Naik. They just obstructed the church entrance and traffic flow for virtue-signalling. What happened in West Bengal was Typical Ghantti Behaviour. Such incidents will eventually happen in Goa also because of mass immigration of ghanttis. Demographics is Destiny.
@@cg8397 did you or the advocate who is talking about the sanctity of church ever raised your voice against Siddhis murder? I still say that Church is nothing if you don't practice humanity.
But not in front of the Church. That's true of the Advocate. We people object .
@@shalinidsouza8271 name sake christians. First respect humanity.
May God forgive this senior citizen and may there be peace upon them.
Our young doctor has lost her life... Knicking in Church door for Divine justice
Ye christavpon re tugele....shetta advocaate tu
@@anti-modani absolutely correct bro
He is a devil 👿
😂
😂
Amazing how people like this won't raise their voice against a crime that needs a voice but will sure get offended about things like this and create a scene unnecessarily
Why are you Hindutva fascists backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
Why are you Hindutva agents backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
Hi
Can you instead of being backed by R s S return back to your original marastra and protest there
@@mohammedwani6696 how do we know you are not rss linked
The steps are sacred? Everyday half naked tourists are sprawled all over the steps taking photos. Please file your complain against that also.
Well said
Its the perfect place to show solidarity with those who are standing up against such gruesome crime.. ... Its a wonderful thought that the doctors chose this place to protest from... They must have selected this place for two reasons,
1) When you truly worship God you will stand up for humanity, compassion and justice... These are the values that jesus peached .. jesus stood up for the oppressed during his time on earth... He spoke against the injustice that was taking place during his time ... these are the values that christianity stands for ...
2) it is the most visited place and well known through out the country.. they would have thought their message would be heard and seen faster .
But in the face of what has happened to the lady doctor, to several other women and to our Siddhi Naik , the place from where you show solidarity with them , would never matter ...
Advocate uncle fooo.odelare😂
Why are you Hindutva agents backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
If your religious sentiments get hurt because of someone protesting against rape I'm sorry to say u don't understand your religion 🤷
The protestors picked the wrong location. They blocked the church entrance and obstructed road traffic. There were also alternative places they could've chosen. Most of the protestors were also ghanttis, they've no business intruding and obstructing local spaces.
Why the media did not post the whole rally which took place from 9pm onwards ?? Why only few mins of it was posted when half of us hade still not reach the SACRED steps!
And why they didn't show that once the uncle started giving his speech we did not argue but just vacate the steps !
Why the main point of protest is not being showcased???
People are trying their beste to demotivate in every wayw possible
This scene shown is of just few mins ! The whole protest did not take place here!!!!
Absolutely right go to Azad maidan
We just happened to be there becuz the last thing we thought about was you guys making this a religious issue. As a Christian myself I think we fail to see the bigger picture
@@waldrondesa8287 I said go to Azad maidan ,do I said about any religion
@@user-pp5bz7sq5rdid you forget to take your anti-psychotics again Francis?! please have them on time so you don't have to come here and shit
@@waldrondesa8287exactly
Finally we as Goans again failed to prove that humanity is above our beliefs.. it’s sad to see that we are against such protests.. sad to see this video getting public in other states and we arr ashamed of again for our behaviour.
Protesting in front of church for me was like - Asking god to be with us in this situation.. I don’t find it wrong in asking help from god
Y only church they shud hv gone everywhere, in vasco there is a big temple or the mosques. They used the church beciade of the steps architecture.
what's wrong with this uncle , why you are getting religion in between
The protestors had blocked the church entrance, causing inconvenience to the locals.
he is Hitler relative
God is the last Hope. May Our Lady of the Immaculate solve their issue.
Absolutely correct.. Let the protest at the Azad Maidan, or at the police station, or at the Collectors office.
When you go to any government hospital in Goa, these very same doctors have neither sympathy nor humanity in treating our the sick.
Thankyou news channel - by twisting the headline of the news for your own masala diverting the attention of the public from the cause of the protest - that is rape and murder of an innocent woman by multiple men.
Moral of the story - in india - people will keep quarrelling among themselves in the name of religion, caste, creed- and forget that every religion preaches harmony, humanity and kindness.
looks like this advocate criminals, he doesn't have any sympathy to the victim
I totally agree with advocate, the church is not a place to protest. I strongly object to this place being used. Protests should be done in front of the GMC hospital. Pls respect, the sanctity of the Church
ISSUE IS UR BAD REPORTING, LEARN FIRST TO REPORT PROPERLY,U DON'T KNOW HOW TO REPORT
Uncle got the attention he wanted that he failed to get being an advocate .
Rightly said. In front of religious place protest cannot be held. Strict action should be taken all religious places should be respected. In front of temples, mosques or other religious places they will protest to destroy the peace. This is not right, let them protest in Azad maidan or public places where there is no silence required.
This protest is for the cause of humanity, advocate toklen sutla
Hoi sutlat dista tho , aami churchin , temple kidyak voita . Deva lagi makpak voita aami , aamka pav , family pav , saglyank safe dovar . Ase aami bare magpak voita , Dr.Right to fight cha vatin aasa . Aani Right to fight thaich God always aasa .
No temple's, masjids or churches should be used to protest ..
This are holy places and should not be blocked like this .. there are many other places to protest ..
It’s funny how the people of Goa have made this into a religion thing yet again.
The Mary Immaculate Conception Church represents Goa in so many ways,I believe that must have been the only reason this place was chosen.
If everyone’s sentiments are getting hurt regarding religion, Goa’s tourism shouldn’t be promoted with churches and temples either.
This place was chosen to get maximum publicity an that was the main reason to organize it there instead of Azad maiden.
Why are you Hindutva fascists backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
Why are you Hindutva agents backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
But is publicity and raising awareness for a noble cause such a bad thing? Even if there is a problem with slogans being chanted they were abt bringing justice to someone who was wronged, pls don't divert attention from something that deserves it for personal gain
@@dhritikapur3861 a North Indian hindu spotted in Goa
Dear Doctors watch this advocates face properly. If anytime in future he comes for treatment please boycott this fellow. Show him this video.
yes please remember him doctors 🙏
What Advocate said is right. There are so many places you can protest but not in front of the Church.
@@Filo498 Don't talk rubbish! They started their protest from Patto and ended near the church. Barely they were there for 10 minutes. They were doing this for a cause. Doctors are taken for granted. Have you ever tried to find out how many hours each resident doctor works? Please find out and then talk. With people like you at the helm of affairs these things happen.
I fully agree with you advocate
Humanity failed
Why not stand with the doctors rather than being against in the name of religion.
God would have been proud.
Their are several hesitation in past addressed from this church step
Where were this Advocate that time?
Give examples. In this case the church entrance was blocked completely.
Let them protest in Public maidan or in front of Vidhan Sabha
Very well said valor bab tuka
The house of god should always be open for those who come to seek for help. Uncle you shame the catholic community with your behaviour.
Precisely
This uncle is cyco
@@Moneymake-n6sNo, he's correct. None of these ghantti doctors (check out their surnames) were bothered when Siddhi Naik was killed. What happened to the Bengali lady doctor was also Typical Ghantti Behaviour. Ghanttis aren't welcome to Goa, they have to go back.
You are supposed to strike at Azad Maidan , not Infront of the church.its a shame.
What has the parish priest of Pananji church Fr. Walter has to say against this mad advocate
As A Christian I agree With The Advocate Our Sentiments are Getting Hurt Wherever There is any kind Of Gatherings Happen You'll only find The panaji Church Capital Infront of That Shame On You'll Protester's Go to that Place where that occurred & Protest over there
What this man did was absolutely wrong. He is against Ladies. Jesus brought them there. Jesus loves everyone. Mama Mary loves all children young and old. God forgive this man for what he did. This man spoiled our protest. Jesus please give justice for this Dr. Who was gang raped and killed and also for all others who were killed like this and also our daughter Nidhi Naik . Amen 🙏❤️✝️
Nothing wrong in this matter sir pls forgive them, entire nation shocked this heinous Crime and this is our Mothers Sisters Daughters and our children life safety.God bless us all Amen 🙏
What about about Manipur when rape of Christians girls happened on daily basis?
Why forgive? Who forgives?
When a doctor faulters are they held accountable or licence suspended in India? Never.
Do We have Volunteers system in India for research studies? No.
Patients are used like specimens & guinea pigs for research.
Anyone aware?
To become a Surgeon how do they start on who do they use? Ordinary people.
Politicians go to private hospitals as they are aware about what is happening in govt hospitals.
Doctors are loosing respect.
Money matters.
Organ transplantation money matters.
IVF, Surrogacy, etc lots more.
All About Money 💰💵
Who's Honest?
@@Myworldisgoa Ghatya, get out from Goa and go back to your lamani land.
@@miguelgonsalves8634 what about Manipur when Christian girls were raped on daily basis?
@@Myworldisgoa Ghatya, you go to Manipur to save your anti-national Christian sisters.
Well. Said. Why. Protest. In. Front. Of. The. Church. Go. To. Health. Minister. House. Or. C. M. House.
All those talking in favour of this guy either have no idea what happened or are just trying to look good in front of everyone.......
Even the priest there had no problem with the doctors and was even inviting them onto the stairs
This guy just trying to get popular.
Rapes are happening, women are dying and no one is doing anything, but if someone tries to do something about it ur sentiments get hurt...
This was an attempt by the doctors of goa medical college to raise awareness among the masses but apparently no one cares.
Very sad that this man and all the uncles and aunties in the comment section got hurt by the protest happening and felt the need to react, but dont even feel the need to think about what is going on in the country.
Uncle, you are welcome to let God help you on the hospital bed🥲, since you say doctors are not really gods... Classic Indian Uncleism!. All doctors.... Please help uncle find god, he doesnt need your help
Very well said. Valor tuca.
These people can protest on Azad Maidan, Campal ground, National Park etc Protests in front of religious structures is not a good idea.
Nothing will happen doing protest after few days everyone will forget everything
Even the people who did this crime had the same thought!
It's 8th day ,even Nirbhaya case got justice after years ...hum nahi bhulenge! Plz don't demotivate us!
There’s nothing to gain except a bad image for yourself by demotivating people trying to make a positive change for women’s safety in the workplace
Great Job, turning the protest which was intended to be for a noble cause into something thats meant to dishonor the church, respectfuly uncle you should be seriously reconsidering your stand on this, because it doesn't take much brains to understand what the whole rally was about
And to those who consider the holy place to be defiled due to this process, just a notification that the real people of the church were at full support
Please don't change this peaceful procession into something that it was never meant to be 🙏
Why are you Hindutva fascists backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
Stop lying again, Malayali ghantti. Permissions weren't taken, and they made it difficult for locals to enter to pray.
Go and protest outside parliament house or CM house or Health minsters house or azad maidan
Dotor Rui Bab, this peaceful protest by Medicos is unavoidable at Short Notices. So we have to be Tolerant for exceptions to the Rules
There are so many places to protest not to be use near the church this must be done in front of the hospital and not infront of the church
Sir if you would have visited GMC you would know they are protesting there.. The soul motive of this protest was so that people know why it's being done
We people don't care about doctors till we become unwell... It's shame on us😢
@@waldrondesa8287 oh my bad🥲
Wrong motive
Why are you Hindutva agents backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
God is not only in church or temple, god is everywhere, and rape is seen in all kind of setting home, temple and work place. They are at mother Mary's feet to ask for justice.
Absolutely right who is these advokate shouting don't do divide and rule policy
Now tell me why they never protested infront of the temple an mosque? Why only they choose the church?
First of all no protest should be in any of the religious places. N for u , y only the chose to protest infront of church? Y not infront of other religious places?
U Dont hv b..ls to ask MLA tis kind of stupid questions....the Catholic brother explained u everything...
Who is this guy and if his religious sentiment is getting hurt, has he objected to all the scantily clad tourists who tramp up and down those 77 steps? Hope he adds that in the complaint.
Dotor it’s silent protest , no need to make big issue unnecessary,Gods lives in pure hearts,forgive & forget God bless👍
Don't make it about religion. Please 🙏🏻 it was a protest for asking for punishhment of the rapists - so what if it is doctors who are protesting - don't belittle the cause.
We are educated people, and no religion supports or promotes rape.
( That is exactly why the priest himself called us to assemble on the chairs- which makes him more religious than any of you using religion as a foul mean to gain attention)
Wr all support the cause..but dont use the church..there r grounds where you can protest.. church is a house of god where we worship
@@akanshamalwa8833 doutor Rui is a gentleman, a father and a vociferous activist. He's old school, he grew up in Portuguese era Goa, where rule of law was strictly enforced. I wager he was upset because requisite permissions weren't taken. May the Almighty bless each and every one of you protestors, for generations to come. Mog asum di 🙏🙏
@@ashadsouza4450 madam but if film shooting is carried out over is that k for many film shooting where carried out blocking traffic blocking any one to enter the Church is this wright ? But if protest done for humanity u fill its wrong
@@kkrnnn6645
Very true dear. This people do not understand what they say. Being educated he failed his education. We are fighting for a cause and this was not political. May God give justice to this Dr. I pray 🙏❤️
@@chrisfernandes3353 All permissions were taken re baba why u think police and collector was there
Adv. Sir, nobodies sentiments are hurt over here , what happens when all the tourists come and click photos, do selfies, and then sit and drink on the steps, that time where r the sentiments??, where are the church authorities??protest is not done inside the church but outside, on top there are many Christian Doctors too who were there for the protest, and it's a peaceful protest, no church property or anything has been vandalised .
Good answer for advocate
Do tourists come there to protest? When you have seen tourists drinking there on the church steps? Are you from panjim?
Mr. Naik. You have gone insane. Lets say the tourist who take selfies are wrong. But these protesters are also wrong in sitting on the footsteps of a temple or church and protesting with big banners. No matter how genuine the cause is. Will you accept these protesters sitting on your door steps, protesting against rape or murder. YOU will tell them, GO AWAY FROM MY HOUSE .... Correct ?
@@AntuFernandes-t6ju hv any idea what do you mean by insane???, and speaking about the protest, this is a genuine cause and it's at the main road square , so people can't even sit on the steps ?? As i said protest is a peaceful 1 and not hurting anybody, evn if they cum at my doorstep and sit in front of my house for the protest specially in this case , I will not say anything to them neither will tell them to get lost, 🙏
For 10 minutes if they come and protest infront of my house I'll join them for this cause. The church authorities didn't object P. S they know what is good for the church and your religion much better than u will ever do. If it was something against Christianity they would have objected. police didn't object. They know law and order better than u. Fakt tuka khaaz😂@@AntuFernandes-t6j
Why protesting infront of any religious place of Worship ? They should protest at Azad Maidan, Bus stop , etc . The interviewer doesn't seem to know anything about Goa or our sentiments.
In future if there are rape incidents then will people protest always in front of our church?
Find out who asked them to converge infront of the church because it looks like that person is out to exploit this sensitive issue to help his political masters
.
When tourist do photo session they are dressed as if they are at a beach or party which is wrong than why didnt this adv didnt take a stand for the right didnt it hurt your sentiments that time and still photo sessions goes on every single day its a holy place,the adv didn't realise what crap he is speaking justice for Dr moumita Debnath
*I am more than JUST a woman*
*I am of and FOR the gods*
*If you cannot come to me as divine*
*Do NOT come to me at all*
My heart goes out to each and every person who came out to protest. May your families be blessed for generations to come🙏
That is very well and aptly said.
Tight re
I agree doctors arent God, so thats why theyre at Gods feet to ask for Justice but you seem to be more concerned about your personal issues. Instead of just supporting the cause you had to be a diva about it.
uncles religious place isn't defiled when tourists sit and do pda on the stairs. But ofc uncles religious place is defiled when people stand for humanity. It was a peaceful protest done with absolute respect, If the Parish priest accepted us then who tf is uncle.
DOCTORS WERE THERE TEMPORARILY FOR BARELY 10 MIN ..after walking from patto, so stfu.
Tourist don't come there to protest? Now can you tell me why they assembled only infront of the church? Why not at Azad maidan or the nearby temple.
@Myworldisgoa so PDA is better than a peaceful 10 min stand outside the church for a rape victim. not gonna argue with a stone. the fact that religion ( temple church mosque , i dont care) is what you see first speaks volume about your mindset . Stay delusional 👍🏽
@@divyasabnis9311Stop lying again, Marathi ghantti. Locals have objected against ghantti PDA also. This protest was just another similar case of Typical Ghantti Behaviour.
Arre stupid even tourist should not be permitted to take selfies here . Tomorrow if they do the same thing in Shantadurga will you be happy
Our heartfelt sympathy to the victim doctor and her family.
Why can't they do this protest at Azad Maidan?
Why these doctor's did not protest during the rapes in Manipur?
Why is the selective protest?
A Fauji's wife was raped and murdered some girls were raped there too? All our doctors were silent as if nothing had heard nor noticed in Manipur.
Sad but true😢.
What about Manipuri Catholics rap ing Manipuri Hindu women. That time Catholics are silent.
This protest was not only because she was raped but also because she was murdered brutally, 1000+ mob came to destroy the hospital, threatened the doctors who were carrying out candle march (docs were hiding , asking for help and sadly this happened on the day of independence)! Pls don't demotivate us !
@@VivaDukorsdukra ghatia from where you got this Information? From your rss whatsApp university history? Dukra.
@@Myworldisgoapls visit IPHB tomorrow, they'll know what to do with you. don't worry
@@pppppoooooooopppppkie-89i think iphb will also be at a loss of words
Boro na kide uncle tu evrytime religion this is about women girls safety
I would ask the gentleman ,if it was your relative or a friend who was raped ,would he say the same ? May "GOD" bless us all.
God said to fight for the truth
ANM?
I guess this uncle has also filed case against Singham 2 producers for hurting his sentiments by filming a similar protest outside this church..
Yes
This proves Humility is been sold in name of Law and British law system of divide and Rule...
For your information...
Lord Jesus Christ sacrifice himself for people like this...😢💯🥺
Lord Jesus Christ sacrifice for life...🥺💯
Does that daughter WHOM get horrifically tortured and life of her is distroyed in seconds for unwelcome evil thinking😢...
And what he have studied through the law which implemented and bought by his ancestors...
The British implemented law and our constitution and court order referred from same can't give justice to that innocent girl ...😢
I was not willing to comment on such things, but people like this making to comment....
He calls him Cristian and not following what Jesus Christ massage is... So what left 😢i don't know 😢
Haak tu advocate....
Very poor mentality shame on you advocate
Saiba bogos please forgive him for he knows not what he is saying.
God forgive him.
Humanity failed once again. Here so many crimes are happening and uncle is still into dividing things on religion.
@@alienel4545 this uncle is over smart uncle
He says he is a lawyer
So I want to tell him give justice to the lady doctor
Why are you Hindutva fascists backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
Because of lawyers like him, justice gets served to criminals like him after several years. Shame
Why are you Hindutva agents backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
@@akanshamalwa8833 A hindu agent spotted
What a tool!
I think he shld also have protested when d tourist come there , religious places is nt for clickng pics or selfie n this shld b taught to everyone whthr its any religion 🙏🏼
Goans have already objected against them. But ghanttis keep showing their genetic 77 IQ and turn up anyway.
This is true my brother what spoke to midia
This is Portugese man and he is not from goa
Uncle your wrong
i think people should go to the designated place and protest as there are some people who want to pray in church and are unable to enter because of the crowd gathered there. and also why people are protesting in goa when there are people already protesting at the right place in calcutta, it makes no sense.
it's about enforcing CPA all over the country. you think women in GMC are safe?
also get your facts right the protest wasn't outside the church
the doctors stood there for 10 min after taking due respect because we know how symbolic the church is for national coverage
protest was from patto
If this is the case with you advocate .y don't u stop the tourist taking pictures in poses n tourist with dress code .if u can't stop this sir I respect u .
Uncle toklean sutla
Than the authorities should put a sign
Which ghanttis will ignore like the sign in Old Goa.
@@cg8397u seem to be more illiterate than alleged ghantis lol.
The person responsible at the church was asking us to come up instead
He even asked us to go up n said u all will get a good picture!
And this uncle is just seeking attention!
He is frustrated because BJP is in power. I guess, by next term, again when BJP gets re-elected, he would flee Goa on a Portuguese passport.
🤣🤣🤣
What is the name of the Priest? Identify him.
@@NazarioDsouza-sv4tb so people gathering outside the church for a noble cause that inclines with what Christianity teaches us(not to commit rape and murder) is wrong but tourists who come there for the pictures and to have a good time is okay ? Shame on you sir
@@waldrondesa8287do other religions don't preach that? Why only the church was chosen? To get maximum publicity? This is what rss wanted maximum publicity.
@@Myworldisgoaare you dense? I’m a Christian myself. do you even know what we are protesting for? And what is the connection to rss 😂😂
Dotor, ur wrong, actually u should join them in their protest, what if someone near to u had been murdered like her, even in that situation u would have given a speech like this
Then panaji everyver. Don't to do protest. Stop immediately at that time and claim complained it's your motto.
Asssu re dotor bab ,may God help the person in pain .
How exactly are sentiments hurt? Protesting an atrocity is a criminal activity? They are outside the church, if it was offensive than the church authorities will object.
seems like people are so blinded by religion that they forget the main essence of christianity, or infact any religion for that matter. humanity is the greatest religion out there. doing this shor sharaba and yapping away doesnt make you a better christian. it takes being a human, a decent compassionate human at that.
Why are you Hindutva fascists backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
Why are you Hindutva agents backed by RSS protesting near a very holy Church ? Choose a nearby temple instead. All are fators and not dotors.
Please stop masquerading as a Christian... we know you are r s s who do these kind of protests here in Goa , get out of goa
Hindus can live in other states
Spare goa
Pls inteospect yourself Madam, before being associated with the rastriya swayam sevak sangh and masquerading as goan, leave the state and don't create a mess
@@mohammedwani6696 ok boomer mr know it all
See if can file a complain on movie producers filming horrible scenes in the church .n file a case on this . I will support u sir .
Use your voice for something worthwhile.. They are not doing anything wrong...
In fact, they are voicing against something done wrong..
I'm a Catholic too...stop yelling and acting weird for a little propaganda...where are you when tourist are taking pics and movies are being shot...isn't the church sanctity affected by those activities?
Faltur tu manis
Yes the Advocate is correct
And understand the main message they want to portray mr advocate please don't mess this with ur misunderstanding.