@@raylee444 I'm not even talking about date or years here 👀 And anyway, I even already knew that too , and my guess is that there's possiblity sm entertainment created Red velvet based on that song , shadow I mean.
Aaaa thanks for releasing this so quick with no annoying long ending music, this song is such a bop, I’m sad they didn’t use the melody in the TT even tho birthday is still good😭
when i heard this for the first time i was SHOCK because HOW could this be a bside 😭 this have far more title track material than birthday 😭 it's catchy, it's easier to listen and to remember and have more 'redvelvet vibe'. I'm literally so confused 😥
This should've been the title track, Idk how ppl in SM could think birthday gives tt vibes instead of this masterpiece here, like really?? Even on my first listen I could immediately tell this was a banger, Birthday and celebrate are on the bottom of my list, while On a ride and zoom are on the top of my list.
Birthday is miles away from Red Velvet, it felt like a bad dream hearing this song as a RV title track. I kind of know why some people say it's "classic rv" but I think they're completely wrong, Red Velvet never made straight up dissonant and noisy music like that. Birthday sounds like someone tried to mix two songs but didn't realize they had to adjust the key of the background vocals with the rest, feels like a bad mashup to me. While other Red Velvet title tracks are masterpieces so no this is not "classic tv tt".
I think this lacks the beat and power that Birthday have, that's why they didn't choose this. It could fit as pre-release song but not tt, that's how it often happens when choosing tt (unless they decide to release a ballad)
the distribution is so perfect, each member got the chance to sing the most memorable line "round and round like a dream: Seulgi, Joy, Wendy, Yeri, then Irene got the last one, DONE ^^
Holy fucking shit this is such a bop!!!!!! also pre-chorus Yerene and yerene harmonizing and joy and seulgi omg im in HEAVEN (not to mention wendy holy f)
@@strawberriel Really you can keep your "my love" if you're saying that they sampled the song with credit you're wrong, there is zero credit for Sub Urban. If you're saying that it sounds the same because they're using the same samples then find the original samples. But even then it's not by simply using the same sample that producers can emulate the entire sound of a track.
I can't say anything cuz this is Queen of Bside song *period *This song mellody sounds like build b*tch and another part like Ariana Grande on 34+35 And I love it 💕💕💕
this shouldve been the title track!! likeeee if ur gonna say no bc birthday just sounds like rv yes i know but rv ALWAYS creates goofy songs but not the birthday kind of goofy song yaknow
*QUEENS OF B-SIDE SOUNDING LIKE TITLE TRACKS 🌈*
App name pls
Purrr
Why they say Oops?
i fell inlove with this as soon as the mood sampler came out
SAME HERE, I thought that mood sampler was the title track
So did I.
And I knew it was not the title track cuz they never do that to mood samplers.
SAME!!! Only the vibe of Red velvet
@@fadhiladhiyaulwafa8389 first rule of stanning RV: Don't trust the teasers
The mood samplers is always the bside except for Joy solo debut because SM gives more than one mood sampler for her solo debut
it’s always b-side songs that hit so hard 🤤🎂
This should have been title track, its so good!
Every Red Velvet album has at LEAST half of it being title track worthy. They’re just that powerful.
@@Sajirah u ste
ate*
Fr
@@Sajirah LMAO purr
This song is so fuuuun, so catchy, so gooood
They’re vocal so cute and beautiful😍
For some reason, the beat reminds me so much of F(x).. 🥲
RV' never disappoints when it comes to their bside tracks. B-side Queens indeed!!
It kinda reminds me of f(x)'s Shadow
@@Hilaeria yes. right! I also thought that the same.
It's shadow.
And tbh , shadow was better given to Red velvet considering both group musical "identity"
@@miptachudin9700 Shadow came out before Red Velvet even debuted
@@raylee444 I'm not even talking about date or years here 👀
And anyway, I even already knew that too , and my guess is that there's possiblity sm entertainment created Red velvet based on that song , shadow I mean.
Joy ate this, her in the opening of this song, just the first 3 words alone is **chef's kiss**
This would be a perfect title track 🥹
Every rv bside is a title track material
Title tracks need to be able to fit the concept and since birthday fits the concept best, they chose it as the title track
Aaaa thanks for releasing this so quick with no annoying long ending music, this song is such a bop, I’m sad they didn’t use the melody in the TT even tho birthday is still good😭
the bsides are always better than the title tracks tbh
솔직히 이거 비트개지림... 무드샘플러 나왔을때 개쩐다 생각했는데 벌스데이듣고 뒷목잡고 쓰러짐
내말이. 내말이. 내말이!!!!!!!!!!!
Yeri and Irene pre chorus peobably the best part of this song
1:32 is so addictive
joy lines are always so catchy
Joy eats always
Joy eats always
the reverb on that high note really sent me to heaven
The mood sampler omg THE CHORUS HITS HARD
Bruh this is should be their tittle track, whyyyyy 😭😭😭
i think this song is deserve to be a tittle
when i heard this for the first time i was SHOCK because HOW could this be a bside 😭 this have far more title track material than birthday 😭 it's catchy, it's easier to listen and to remember and have more 'redvelvet vibe'. I'm literally so confused 😥
이번 앨범에서 제일 좋아하는 곡❤
This should've been the title track, Idk how ppl in SM could think birthday gives tt vibes instead of this masterpiece here, like really?? Even on my first listen I could immediately tell this was a banger, Birthday and celebrate are on the bottom of my list, while On a ride and zoom are on the top of my list.
Yeah i understand you that this shouldve been the tt but birthday is just a classic rv tt, love it or hate it its just how rv makes their title tracks
Birthday is miles away from Red Velvet, it felt like a bad dream hearing this song as a RV title track. I kind of know why some people say it's "classic rv" but I think they're completely wrong, Red Velvet never made straight up dissonant and noisy music like that. Birthday sounds like someone tried to mix two songs but didn't realize they had to adjust the key of the background vocals with the rest, feels like a bad mashup to me. While other Red Velvet title tracks are masterpieces so no this is not "classic tv tt".
I think this lacks the beat and power that Birthday have, that's why they didn't choose this. It could fit as pre-release song but not tt, that's how it often happens when choosing tt (unless they decide to release a ballad)
The fact that Sassy Me exists and they chose something like Birthday as a title track.
They are red velvet there title won't be easy to hear and accept from the start, it's always out of the box
1:41 2:19 2:34 2:57 are the best parts, especially irenes part
This definitely a title track materiaaal!! Love this so much!
Seulgi and Joy's rap part at 1:23
이걸 타이틀로하지...겨울이랑도 잘어울리고 약간 피카부 밝은버전같아서 음원도 잘됐을거같은데...
the distribution is so perfect, each member got the chance to sing the most memorable line "round and round like a dream: Seulgi, Joy, Wendy, Yeri, then Irene got the last one, DONE ^^
IT’S SO GOOOOOOODDDDDD 😭
I LOVE THIS SONGGGGG, it just screams f(x) and it's something f(x) would release during Pink Tape/Hot Summer era
Holy fucking shit this is such a bop!!!!!! also pre-chorus Yerene and yerene harmonizing and joy and seulgi omg im in HEAVEN (not to mention wendy holy f)
pink tape vibes i loveeeee
Fx vibe
1:32 JOYYY😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
She sounds so good 💚😌
i fell in LOVE with this as soon i heard it 😭
OMG!!! I WANT AN MV FOR THIS TOO! LIKE I DON'T MIND AN EXTENDED VERSION OF THE TEASER! 😭
스엠 뭐해 이걸 타이틀로 했어야지😡 후렴 진짜 좋네
ㅇㅈ티비;;!!
ㅇㅈ
this song deserves a mv
It kinda reminds me of "Build a bitch" by Bella Poarch. Lemme make a mashup of these two!!💖
Some parts of the beat are identical.
i hear it too i would loveee to hear the mashup
THOUGHT IT WAS JUST ME
sample, my love
@@strawberriel Really you can keep your "my love" if you're saying that they sampled the song with credit you're wrong, there is zero credit for Sub Urban.
If you're saying that it sounds the same because they're using the same samples then find the original samples. But even then it's not by simply using the same sample that producers can emulate the entire sound of a track.
2:18 that's why she is the queen of brige..
It is so good that i repeat it a million times
irene in 2:48 - 2:55 is chef's kiss
I think this comeback is joy era rap and vocal are insane
Go create a petition for this B-side to have an MV
I really hope this is their title track
I wish this was the title track 😭 this is what they used for one of the teasers i really expected it to sound like this ansns
this song is so good 😩
1:23 Seulgi, Joy
1:27 Wendy + Joy
It’s always hard to tell which member owns a certain song when they all slay so fucking hard 😩 I’m personally picking Yeri for this song though
This song better than title track !
This song just slaps so hard
I hope 0:55 - 0:57 is little bit longer before going to the next part, i found that part so catchy coz it's so fit with the beat
Omg this would go viral if it was the title track
This should have been the title song with an MV!
BEST SONG ON THE ALBUM
STRAIGHT FROM PINK TAPE'S FAULT I LOVE IT HEREEEE
1:27 i think its wendy and joy
I IMMEDIATELY FALL IN LOVE WITH THIS SONG 🎵 😍
One of my favs!!!
Da da da da da da da da da da da😭😭😭 so good!!!!
idk if it's just me but this song and the whole vibes reminds me of f(x)😭💗
bro i'm in love with this song
Seulgi rap wow
Omg i'm addicted
i want this as a title track 😖
I love Birthday too but I feel like the public prefer this alot more
1:32
their best b-side song !!
이노래가 타이틀감이잖아요.
훨 힙한데..
5명 다 고음 싸비 맡는데 다 좋네
1:41 i'm on my knees, irene
1:32 GIRL CHILL
SUCH A BOP
The beat really had no business going so hard
This is better than birthday for me
i swear irene sounds like wendy sometimes
My fav bside from this album!! Other bside also good!! Make me hard to choose at first hehehe!
타이틀로 해도 손색 없었을 듯
This is way better then the title track. Red Velvet needs to go back to having a title song that Velvet. There's alot of Red lately.
just imagine this is the title track the concept photos would fit so much (peek a boo twin sister)
We want MV for this Song SM 🤟🤟😩😩
At timestamp 1:17 the transition from Yeri to Irene is not clean.. I think the producer made a mistake there.
I can't say anything cuz this is Queen of Bside song *period
*This song mellody sounds like build b*tch and another part like Ariana Grande on 34+35
And I love it 💕💕💕
이건 명백한 타이틀곡 미스임
The rap on top
This is so Title Track material
00:58 sounds like one of Haechans parts in 7 Days by NCT Dream! catchy!
비트 미쳤다
2:51 This Irene part makes me want BJH1 to make happen asap
rapper joy back in this album
the "da da la da da" is ADDICTING
벌스데이보다 훨 좋음😂😂😂 이미 지난 일이지만....
this shouldve been the title track!! likeeee if ur gonna say no bc birthday just sounds like rv yes i know but rv ALWAYS creates goofy songs but not the birthday kind of goofy song yaknow
EXACTLY. birthday sounds like nct/aespa song especially the chorus and its not addictive enough
omg i love this
The outro feels like it was sang by Irene and Yeri.
On a ride >>>>>>>> Birthday
Where is the music video of them tearing up the house??? 😭
Bside favorite di red velvet now
Joy sounds good in this song. Though I still love Seulgi and Seulgi's voice the most. This song is my fave in the album.
0:56 Tell me this part doesn't remind you of Bella Poarch Build a B*tch?!
The song is fire thoo
can we have a special mv for this song pls??
Park Sooyoung is on fire!!!!! 🔥
Raise your hand if this song somehow reminds you of Shadow by by f(x). Is it just me?
이게 타이틀같은데 뭐지..
이걸 타이틀도 했어야지😢😢
왜 이게 타이틀곡이 아니지!? 이 노래가 훨씬 좋아!!!!
So much better than the title track