Gotta say I disagree with a lot of your rankings but I absolutely respect how honest you are about the songs you don’t like. A lot of videos of people who love Taylor swift don’t even make any criticism at all. I’m glad to see that you are able to love her music and also criticize things about songs that you don’t quite like.
"Come on girl, you're fifteen, go to class" killed me 🤣🤣🤣 I liked Cold as You but always felt that way in the bridge. Even as a 10 year old listening to that song, I always felt it was a bit much.
I’d like to let you know that you’re the reason why I’m so obsessed with Taylor Swift now. I saw one of your videos on my recommendation page and it sent me into a rabbit hole of Taylor Swift lore. Thank you for your service.
@@theswiftologistOmg, you’re literally ahead of your time “in your Jehovah’s Witness suit, who the f**k was that guy?” 😂 I did subscribe to your channel because of these voodoo stuff ❤✨
THE FACT THAT YOU SAID YOU DONT THINK THIS WAS A MOVIE WILL BE RE-RECORDED AND IT SOUNDS LIKE A FEARLESS TRACK AND NOW SHE RE-RECORDED IT AND THE COVER IS FEARLESS TV 😭😭
thank you for putting betty in “she in the moment”!!!!! i honestly think the storytelling aspect of the song is executed perfectly and just underrated in general. for sure one of my favorites
Wait what?! Daylight?! That song makes me cry every time I listen to it having finally found my other half 3 years ago at 31 after years of depression and bad relationships. It doesn't feel insincere to me 😶🌫️🤯
Okay this was a journeyyyy... and even though I dont agree on it all I respect it because you're also a Speak now Stan. Now were just waiting for All too well (10 minute version) because that will be her best song of all time.
@@theswiftologist Though, we do know the lyrics to the 10 min. version. don't we? she included them in one of the Lover diaries. so don't we know what to expect? I remember the lyrics not being that much overwhelming. I think we should lower our expectations for the 10 minute version.
FINALLY someone who also things august isn't that good!!! sometimes the fandom can be such an echo chamber of the same opinions over and over - i really love your fresh takes and the fact that you give no fucks lmao. your channel and podcast are a blessing to the fandom!! tho your ratings of peace and hoax were borderline criminal... i felt like i heard madeline scream in the distance at hoax lol
Omg yes I never really got the hype around august it seems kinda boring and I like songs that are more upbeat and Folklore and Evermore really weren’t my vibe at all except for Willow😅
The thing about Red and State of Grace is that they work so well off of each other. State of Grace is the perfect opening song and it’s her best opening song period although I would also accept Mine and Fearless as contenders for that spot as well. And Red is like the perfect title track. Back to the point I was trying to make, red and state of Grace work so well together because they both introduce the theme of Red as an album in different ways, with different sounds but similar images that flow through out the album as a whole: traffic, autumn, driving etc. I just love those two songs so much. They are perfect songs to me.
It would work if they weren't 2 of the best songs from red cause aftrr these songs we have all those expectations and are super hyped up but the rest of the album is a let down from the 2 opening tracks (except for treacherous, the last time and some vault tracks)
I’m only up to Fearless, but I’m so happy you’re putting so many Fearless songs in the top 3 tiers. Fearless doesn’t get enough love. Edit: Just finished, and your Evermore rankings are so valid!!!
JUSTICE FOR KING OF MY HEART !!!!!! I know it’s not the greatest on its own but that bridge is the emotional center of the entire album!!!! And the drums go OFF it makes me squirt frankly.
We don’t speak about the ME! gap enough. She let us ROT from March to June. Then she finally handed over YNTCD and we died again until a week before release when she handed over Lover as a single. The Lover album roll out was so incredibly hard.
Miss Americana and no body, no crime ranked as ‘it’s ok’?? How very dare you 😂 I agree with most of your takes though, even (and often especially) the more controversial ones. Where would you have ranked Renegade?
@@theswiftologist lmao you monster, I love that song too 💀 Renegade is a tough one for me to rank though - I really like the lyrics and I love her for taking on a tricky topic (mental health impacting on relationships). It’s definitely a mood song, like, I have to be in the right mood for it, then I’ll replay over and over. And the production kind of ruins the song for me, there’s too much going on. If the instrumentation were simpler, I reckon I’d rank it as a banger at minimum.
43:42 i respectfully disagree, taylor has a HUGE platform her speaking out about her political beliefs is really helpful, only the young may not be her best song but in the midst of my country's election that song really just gives me hope..
I agree with a lot of your opinions. Personally I would put State of Grace and Red in She is the Moment because along with Love Story they are my favourite songs in all of her discography. Order: #1 is Love Story #2 is Red #3 is State of Grace
What people don’t seem to understand, is that even when we harshly critique Taylors songs, as swifties, every song(except for the very bottom tiers) are still better than almost every other artists songs. One of the main things our queen has taught us, is to have high standards, and at this point, we know not to accept less than amazing art. thank you for your time.
an "average" taylor swift song is a million times better than anything Katy, B, or Gaga have come up with in years. Not even Bruno mars has come up with a good song in a long time
I mean mid Taylor songs like Jump and Fall or King of my Heart cannot top other artists' best work and that's okay. Grenade? Teenage dream? Just dance? Telephone? They're iconic for a reason and we don't need to pretend every single Taylor song is superior to all other songs@@Holmnielsen-
Please pretty please when Taylor ends the rerecordings you need go do this again with the vault songs and the upgrades and downgrades of the songs ❤️❤️❤️
Hey, friends! Happy New Year! ❤️ My ranking comes with an entire essay that I wrote, LOL. 🤷♀️ To the Content Creator, great list and very comprehensive! I love how we are all drawn to different songs. In college, I set a goal with a friend of mine for each of us to make a list of the “Ten Taylor Songs I’d Save If The Rest Had to Go Away Forever”. 😭 It’s a painful thought for sure and definitely proved to be so for me because I had to “part” with a lot of true favorites, but it was actually a lot of fun to do, in spite of the fact that I procrastinated for like 7 years after we set the goal. 😅 I’m a total Taylor nerd (unapologetically) and I actually started working on this a couple months ago. I’ve been listening to her full catalog a lot lately and on my daily commutes to work I’ve been making and editing my list (and editing again 😅). It’s gone through MANY iterations but I have finally reached a point where I no longer feel like I need to make any adjustments. The choice to put the original albums’ tracks rather than choosing “Taylor’s Versions” was deliberate. I’m very sentimental and I have memories associated with each of her albums, and her voice sounds different in those earlier albums that are especially close to my heart. For me, the fact that her voice sounds more youthful in those earlier albums/tracks is part of their charm, so that’s why I made this choice. I don’t know if you all can relate to this but sometimes I think her music complements her lyrics better than at other times. Like sometimes the good lyrics are a little bit lost to me because of how they are delivered musically via melody and other times the combination of melody and lyrics REALLY pack a punch. That was one of the guiding considerations for my list. I actually got carried away, so I even narrowed down my top 5! 😳. After I finished I decided to rank my top three albums. For background I am a 30-year-old woman (she/her pronouns), so that might account for why I lean in favor of the earlier albums. Themes that I tend to gravitate to when choosing favorites are upbeat, happy-go-lucky sweet love songs on one side of the coin (a la “Our Song” and “Hey Stephen”) and songs about the perils and anxieties associated with love on the other (a la “Treacherous”, “Haunted”, “Death By A Thousand Cuts”, “All Too Well”, and even “Cornelia Street”, which is sentimental while also being about the anxiety that comes with entering a new relationship and those familiar thoughts of “it feels great now, but if it doesn’t work out, I’ll be crushed.” Come to think of it, it also fits into the sweet lovey category. I think that pinpoints why I love that song. It’s like the intersection of my two fave themes! ☺️ Maybe I should have it ranked higher than Number 10. 🤔 😅 I do love a good track from a Taylor who’s been wronged, too (thinking of Picture To Burn and Should’ve Said No”), but ultimately it’s the sad and reflective tracks about lost love that do it for me best. I ❤️ Haunted original and Acoustic about the same. Can’t choose a favorite. And The All Too Well I prefer is the 2012 shorter version. I love talking all about the poet and artist that Taylor is and I think sharing opinions is really fun. Feel free to share as much or as little as you want! I can’t wait to see your lists and hear your thought processes. Much love! ❤️ Enough blabbing, here’s my list: Top 10 (* for Top 5) ________________ *Our Song *Treacherous * Hey Stephen *Haunted ->(Original or Acoustic) *All Too Well You Belong With Me The Best Day Forever & Always Death By A Thousand Cuts Cornelia Street Albums: _______ Fearless Red Speak Now
@@Emma-kw8uv what do you mean? the archer is a perfect track 5, and daylight? literally the best way to close this alvum not to mention that small voice over at the end... *chef-kiss*
Call me old school (been here since 2006) but here’s my Top Five list ❤️ Our Song (Best T Swift song IMO) Hey Stephen Haunted (Acoustic or original 🤷♀️) All Too Well You Belong With Me Honorable Mentions: Death By A Thousand Cuts Getaway Car Forever & Always Clean Favorite album: Fearless (though Speak Now is a close second and has sentimental value bc it’s when I saw her on tour. So YES to “justice for Speak Now” ❤️) Also, anyone else remember how You Belong With Me was 100% a sleeper hit?
I found myself agreeing with most of your rankings except for a few. I love her slower, sadder songs and adore New Years Day because it feels like the calm after the storm. Like she's resting after and saying a sweet goodnight
Omg how can we have almost the same S tier even tho you hate some of my faves and love some of my most heted ones??? Cowboy like me, Gold Rush and Ivy ❤
Can we just take a moment to appreciate the fact that this video came out 2 years before “fortnight” came out and yet Zach somehow made a tier called “I want to kill her” ????? Hello ???
I watched somebody else's ranking of all of her songs and was raging the entire time because of their top songs and what they had in the bottom (no shade) I had to take a deep breath and see if you made one and luckily you did😅 apparently we have the same tastes as far as her music goes, I feel like I can breathe now
I agree with you on everything! a lot of the songs I love most of the fandom hates and the songs I think are overrated are the fandom's favs. 100% about WANEGBT AND IKYWT! swifties give these songs shit b/c it's basic. but they're fun bops. I think we, the swifties and the radio overplayed them so much that they are sick of them. but if you'll listen to them once in a while, they're fun and cute. unlike ME!SS who I see swifties defend this song for being a "fun" song. no, it's not. ME! is a kidz bop song at best. and even as a kidz bop it's bad. ME! shouldn't have been made in the first place. one of the worst songs ever. for some reason I thought you hate 22. and yes! thank you! Mean is childish and too twangy. Sweeter Than Fiction, it's blah. boring!! WTNY and Bad Blood yes. everyone hates them so much, but I don't mind it. thank you about OOTW!!! I agree 100% with you. I like the tour version and the grammy museum versions much better, but the album version is meh. too repetitive. shake it off at a funeral lol I still don't like HYGTG. oh man, my only hearbreak with your ranking was I Know Places and KOMH. I love these song so much... I LOVE Ready For It and I Did Something Bad haha. I would've put End Game in the bottom THANK YOU ABOUT DELICATE. it's so overrated by the fans. as you said, I respect and understand why everyone loves it, but personally I barely listen to it. same with Getaway Car. I would've ranked DWOHT at the bottom as well. never listened to it since the album release week. 100% agree with you about CIWYW AND New Years Day. I think she put New Years Day for the people who hate reputation as a whole because through out all of my reaction to rep watching, everyone who hated the album said New Years is the only good song on rep. We're thinking the same on almost everything! Lover is her worst album imo and I do forget I Forgot That You Existed' is existing. I never listened to it since the album release. so boring. The Archer, The Man, London Boy are so bad and boring. SYGB! THANK YOU! most swifties rank it as their least favorite song b/c it's too difficult to listen, which I understand, as someone who lost his mom to brain tumor exactly a year ago, I relate to this song so much, and the song is so powerful and I love it, it makes me think of my mom and I never skip it. SYGB and marjorie are so good.
the pop version of teardrops has to exist because that was on the radio (the pop channels). She wanted to be pop; country was the foot in the door. She has to make a pop version as an audition. Shania Twain is one of her inspiration. Shania released Up! just a few years earlier. which had two discs. A Red version(pop) and a Green version(country)
THANK YOU for not killing epiphany. I know you don’t like her, and she’s not my favourite either (I’d say respectable bop), but thank you for sparing her life. 😘 In defence of epiphany, I think the song content is a lot more palatable if you consider that it was written at the very beginning of the pandemic. It hasn’t aged well because we’re so bored of hearing about covid. But Taylor was far from the only person making comparisons between soldiers on the front line and healthcare workers at the start of the pandemic, especially in reference to places that were overwhelmed like northern Italy and New York. Although the song is long, I personally find the production quite pretty- it’s appropriate to the subject matter, almost ethereal. Epiphany is not a skip for me, I almost always listen to it all the way through. As such, IMO, folklore is a (and Taylor’s only) skipless album.
@@theswiftologist Would you like another spicy take? ‘The Man’ and YNTCD would have both been much bigger hits had they been singles on 1989 rather than Lover. They would have been the feminist and LGBT anthems she wanted (and expected) them to be. Hear me out. I admit that the arguments Taylor makes in The Man are only valid to a point. Where she loses me is the chorus, where she makes a confused case for how she’d be further along in her career were she a man. I don’t think this is something she can reasonably argue, given that, arguably, she would not have taken off the way she did were she a man. She made her start in the male dominated country genre, and managed to stand out because she was literally the only young woman. She continued to stand out with intense emotional vulnerability in her lyrics, which is palatable to audiences from a woman, because women are stereotypically emotional. Don’t get me wrong, I think if Taylor Swift were a man, I think he would still be a successful recording artist. I just don’t think he’d be as successful as her. However, a lot of the other arguments she makes in the man are cutting and very true. They remind me of the interviews where she called out the sexism of critique around writing breakup songs, when no one says the same of Bruno Mars or Ed Sheeran. We can infer from the Miss Americana doco that she wanted to put out a song like The Man for a long time, but didn’t feel comfortable doing so during the 1989 era, when she was only just getting comfortable with using the word ‘feminist’. I think the main reason The Man didn’t land was the timing. Had it been released in 2014/15 (pre #metoo; 2017), almost all the arguments she made would have been hot takes. It would have captured some of the shock value that ‘If I Were a Boy’ (2008) garnered. By the time Taylor released The Man in 2019, no one really cared about hearing about feminism from a rich white lady anymore, and we definitely didn’t care about double standards, which had been raked over to death by that point. It might not have done as well as Blank Space, a superior song, but The Man would have supported Blank Space for a more complete story of where Taylor was actually coming from. I feel similarly about YNTCD. There’s nothing especially wrong with the lyrics. The gayest thing about that song is the video clip. The main issue is timing. Were Taylor to have released a song and video like this in 2014 (before same sex marriage was legalised across the USA in 2015), I feel her advocacy would have been far more welcome to the LGBT community (and of course, subject to more criticism from conservatives). Again, I think she would have liked to make her stance on gay rights clearer earlier in her career, and I feel sad that she felt she had to wait as long as she did, to the point where her advocacy was not only somewhat unnecessary, but unwanted. Anyway, if anyone’s read this far, I’d love to hear your opinion on this. I’d say ‘follow me for more spicy takes’, but I think I’m all out 😄
The Archer makes sense production wise to me. It's supposed to represent the pull and release of a bow through the building production until it releases at the end.
The other cool thing about teardrops is that liz rose said taylor was getting pressure to change "drew" to "you" but she fought to keep it drew. An early record of her being able to put her foot down and hold her own creatively.
Thank you for speaking up about King of my Heart, i have had a problem with that song since day one!! I can’t stand her!! And also i love that your fave is Holy Ground cause its mine too:))
I LOVE your honesty, but babes…King of my heart? What did that song do too you? That song is in my top 3 and you gave it the electric chair? Anyway great ranking other than that ❤️
Ok I’ve never commented on your videos but this was one of my fave rankings ever, lemme tell you I was CRACKING UP. When you put I know places into the kill tier with no explanation, I felt that. I don’t even hate that song the way you do but I love your audaciousness. So many are afraid to shit on some Taylor songs but considering the range of her discography, it’d be weird to not have a few songs that you can’t stand. Also thank you for righteous disdain for New Year’s Day like wtf was that song doing on reputation?? When I first listened to the album I was so mad that it ended on such a lame note. LWYDM supremacy Only major issue I had was picture to burn bc that song IS the moment & I desperately need the homophobic version for the re-record. Please and ty
the fact that he said that "if this was a movie" sounds like a fearless track rather than a speak now and now its been re recorded as a fearless tv track..
re: innocent i kinda wish i never knew what it was about. bc out of context it speaks to me about reckoning with regret as you grow up but still having that glowing child part of you
hold the crap on bc he said that he thought that if this was a movie wasnt gonna get rerecorded, then bam it gets rerecorded. Then! he says that he felt like it was off of fearless and was given to speak now! omg 😱 future predictions over here
Speak Now (the song) is the cute little sister of I Write Sins and Not Tragedies, you can see the roots and foreshadowing of that professional relationship with Brendon Urie lol
this video is two years old and im withim the first 4 minutes of watching it, but a place in this world is one of my fav debut songs.. i will not stand for it being killed
I will not REST until the other side of the door is gIVEN the GODDAMN RESPECT THAT SHE DESERVES she IS THE UNDISCOVERED SUPERMODEL
I’ll support you on your journey
Thanks king - also thanks for making me feel slightly less insane for stanning today is a fairytale to the extent that I do
the other side of the door is one of the most underrated songs on fearless
@@meridith7137you did not compare tosotd to that monstrosity
Gotta say I disagree with a lot of your rankings but I absolutely respect how honest you are about the songs you don’t like. A lot of videos of people who love Taylor swift don’t even make any criticism at all. I’m glad to see that you are able to love her music and also criticize things about songs that you don’t quite like.
@Paul46723oh no really?!?! 😱😱
@The2000smusicfanreading comprehension
"Come on girl, you're fifteen, go to class" killed me 🤣🤣🤣 I liked Cold as You but always felt that way in the bridge. Even as a 10 year old listening to that song, I always felt it was a bit much.
cannot wait to watch this, thank you for deliberately making your intro song my all time favourite taylor song
omg thanks for watching queen I love ur channel !!!
Omg I keep finding ur comments everywhere heyyy- I love Taylor sm
My two fav youtubers
Hi ally you 2 are such great YTS YOU ARE MY FAVS
Omggggg
I’d like to let you know that you’re the reason why I’m so obsessed with Taylor Swift now. I saw one of your videos on my recommendation page and it sent me into a rabbit hole of Taylor Swift lore. Thank you for your service.
omg I’m like a Jehovah’s Witness
@@theswiftologist PLSSSS NOT JW😭😭😭😭
@@theswiftologistJehovas witness suit💀
@@theswiftologistOmg, you’re literally ahead of your time “in your Jehovah’s Witness suit, who the f**k was that guy?” 😂
I did subscribe to your channel because of these voodoo stuff ❤✨
@@Marielisrouf3i bet taylor is stalking the comments and found this ❤
THE FACT THAT YOU SAID YOU DONT THINK THIS WAS A MOVIE WILL BE RE-RECORDED AND IT SOUNDS LIKE A FEARLESS TRACK AND NOW SHE RE-RECORDED IT AND THE COVER IS FEARLESS TV 😭😭
thank you for putting betty in “she in the moment”!!!!! i honestly think the storytelling aspect of the song is executed perfectly and just underrated in general. for sure one of my favorites
tea!!
18:16 not you predicting the illegal treatment If This Was a Movie got with the re-recordings 😭
the fact that most of my favorite songs ever are in the lowest categories hurts my heart
I'm genuinely upset about daylight which is absurd 😂😂
How right you were about If This was a Movie being a Fearless Vault track given to Speak Now is amazing omg
I love the way you left out Superman (Or maybe I missed it in the video)💀
sir you are SICK for putting i'm only me when i'm with you so low???
I immediately thought of you when I saw that hahaha
My fav from debut
I can't say I agree with you but I admire your bravery
Wait what?! Daylight?! That song makes me cry every time I listen to it having finally found my other half 3 years ago at 31 after years of depression and bad relationships. It doesn't feel insincere to me 😶🌫️🤯
Okay this was a journeyyyy... and even though I dont agree on it all I respect it because you're also a Speak now Stan.
Now were just waiting for All too well (10 minute version) because that will be her best song of all time.
we will SEE about that!!! I'm cautiously optimistic
@@theswiftologist Though, we do know the lyrics to the 10 min. version. don't we? she included them in one of the Lover diaries. so don't we know what to expect? I remember the lyrics not being that much overwhelming. I think we should lower our expectations for the 10 minute version.
FINALLY someone who also things august isn't that good!!! sometimes the fandom can be such an echo chamber of the same opinions over and over - i really love your fresh takes and the fact that you give no fucks lmao. your channel and podcast are a blessing to the fandom!! tho your ratings of peace and hoax were borderline criminal... i felt like i heard madeline scream in the distance at hoax lol
Madeline doesn't watch my videos and I think that is for the best
Omg yes I never really got the hype around august it seems kinda boring and I like songs that are more upbeat and Folklore and Evermore really weren’t my vibe at all except for Willow😅
the absolute most controversial TS song ranking ive ever witnessed!!!!
and i respect it bestie
The thing about Red and State of Grace is that they work so well off of each other. State of Grace is the perfect opening song and it’s her best opening song period although I would also accept Mine and Fearless as contenders for that spot as well.
And Red is like the perfect title track. Back to the point I was trying to make, red and state of Grace work so well together because they both introduce the theme of Red as an album in different ways, with different sounds but similar images that flow through out the album as a whole: traffic, autumn, driving etc.
I just love those two songs so much. They are perfect songs to me.
State of Grace is literally the most incredible song I've ever heard. Takes me to places that I've never been. No other song feels the same to me.
It would work if they weren't 2 of the best songs from red cause aftrr these songs we have all those expectations and are super hyped up but the rest of the album is a let down from the 2 opening tracks (except for treacherous, the last time and some vault tracks)
Welcome to New York and Lavender Haze would like to talk
@@eros9939 Exactly what I was gonna say lol Welcome to New York is SOOO underrated for an opener
I’m only up to Fearless, but I’m so happy you’re putting so many Fearless songs in the top 3 tiers. Fearless doesn’t get enough love.
Edit: Just finished, and your Evermore rankings are so valid!!!
it’s peace for me 😫 - she’s my fave taylor song. your god tier is SO SUPERIOR though. (our thoughts on evermore are so aligned, love us intellectuals)
love that for us
Thank you for loving “Gorgeous”!!! I don’t understand why people hate this! It’s great!
It's top Tier for me!!
JUSTICE FOR KING OF MY HEART !!!!!! I know it’s not the greatest on its own but that bridge is the emotional center of the entire album!!!! And the drums go OFF it makes me squirt frankly.
The bridge! that bloody bridge is *chef's kiss*
Fr, the bridge is serving, its one of my favorites from rep
Some embarrassing lyrics but this song BANGS, I actually think she is the moment.
haha hearing you talk about itwam in that way ist so funny to me knowing that it is rerecorded and on fearless now
You got what you asked for if this was a movie is now a fearless song in Taylor’s eyes 😂
I just want to know why you hate so much on jack antonoff, he literally has a hand in creating the greatest hits of our generation
We don’t speak about the ME! gap enough. She let us ROT from March to June. Then she finally handed over YNTCD and we died again until a week before release when she handed over Lover as a single. The Lover album roll out was so incredibly hard.
I knew from the first second you were going to kill I Know Places and I still wasn’t ready for it 😭😭
I have a lot of unpopular opinions but this might be the worst one
Miss Americana and no body, no crime ranked as ‘it’s ok’?? How very dare you 😂 I agree with most of your takes though, even (and often especially) the more controversial ones.
Where would you have ranked Renegade?
Oh gewd question …. Probably in it’s okay. LOL
@@theswiftologist lmao you monster, I love that song too 💀
Renegade is a tough one for me to rank though - I really like the lyrics and I love her for taking on a tricky topic (mental health impacting on relationships). It’s definitely a mood song, like, I have to be in the right mood for it, then I’ll replay over and over. And the production kind of ruins the song for me, there’s too much going on. If the instrumentation were simpler, I reckon I’d rank it as a banger at minimum.
the gasp i let out when you put King of my Heart in the lowest category
SAAAAAME. I died inside ngl
Okay, y’all but I’m only me when I’m with you Taylor’s version will sound so amazing. Like the POWER in her vocals when she sings it will be amazing.
If you say so.......
43:42 i respectfully disagree, taylor has a HUGE platform her speaking out about her political beliefs is really helpful, only the young may not be her best song but in the midst of my country's election that song really just gives me hope..
COMPLETELY AGREE major celebrities bringing attention to topics like that is so important
REAL
It would be helpful if she didnt pick and choose when to be politically correct
Nooooooooo Daylight is my all-time favorite 😭😭 BUT I thoroughly enjoyed this video!!
I agree with a lot of your opinions. Personally I would put State of Grace and Red in She is the Moment because along with Love Story they are my favourite songs in all of her discography.
Order:
#1 is Love Story
#2 is Red
#3 is State of Grace
What people don’t seem to understand, is that even when we harshly critique Taylors songs, as swifties, every song(except for the very bottom tiers) are still better than almost every other artists songs. One of the main things our queen has taught us, is to have high standards, and at this point, we know not to accept less than amazing art. thank you for your time.
an "average" taylor swift song is a million times better than anything Katy, B, or Gaga have come up with in years. Not even Bruno mars has come up with a good song in a long time
@@Holmnielsen- okay we swifties can still acknowledge good songs from other artists chill.
I mean mid Taylor songs like Jump and Fall or King of my Heart cannot top other artists' best work and that's okay. Grenade? Teenage dream? Just dance? Telephone? They're iconic for a reason and we don't need to pretend every single Taylor song is superior to all other songs@@Holmnielsen-
Please pretty please when Taylor ends the rerecordings you need go do this again with the vault songs and the upgrades and downgrades of the songs ❤️❤️❤️
i really enjoy watching you you’re so entertaining 🥰 !!!
😘😘😘
Too harsh with reputation:,D
Btw good video! I agree on almost all your selections 😂
28:22 Just because you said that i am now requesting shake it off at my funeral
daaaamn treacherous is one of my favorites off red! but ur right about the surprisingly sexy lyrics!
Hey, friends! Happy New Year! ❤️
My ranking comes with an entire essay that I wrote, LOL. 🤷♀️
To the Content Creator, great list and very comprehensive! I love how we are all drawn to different songs.
In college, I set a goal with a friend of mine for each of us to make a list of the “Ten Taylor Songs I’d Save If The Rest Had to Go Away Forever”. 😭 It’s a painful thought for sure and definitely proved to be so for me because I had to “part” with a lot of true favorites, but it was actually a lot of fun to do, in spite of the fact that I procrastinated for like 7 years after we set the goal. 😅 I’m a total Taylor nerd (unapologetically) and I actually started working on this a couple months ago. I’ve been listening to her full catalog a lot lately and on my daily commutes to work I’ve been making and editing my list (and editing again 😅). It’s gone through MANY iterations but I have finally reached a point where I no longer feel like I need to make any adjustments.
The choice to put the original albums’ tracks rather than choosing “Taylor’s Versions” was deliberate. I’m very sentimental and I have memories associated with each of her albums, and her voice sounds different in those earlier albums that are especially close to my heart. For me, the fact that her voice sounds more youthful in those earlier albums/tracks is part of their charm, so that’s why I made this choice.
I don’t know if you all can relate to this but sometimes I think her music complements her lyrics better than at other times. Like sometimes the good lyrics are a little bit lost to me because of how they are delivered musically via melody and other times the combination of melody and lyrics REALLY pack a punch.
That was one of the guiding considerations for my list.
I actually got carried away, so I even narrowed down my top 5! 😳. After I finished I decided to rank my top three albums.
For background I am a 30-year-old woman (she/her pronouns), so that might account for why I lean in favor of the earlier albums.
Themes that I tend to gravitate to when choosing favorites are upbeat, happy-go-lucky sweet love songs on one side of the coin (a la “Our Song” and “Hey Stephen”) and songs about the perils and anxieties associated with love on the other (a la “Treacherous”, “Haunted”, “Death By A Thousand Cuts”, “All Too Well”, and even “Cornelia Street”, which is sentimental while also being about the anxiety that comes with entering a new relationship and those familiar thoughts of “it feels great now, but if it doesn’t work out, I’ll be crushed.” Come to think of it, it also fits into the sweet lovey category. I think that pinpoints why I love that song. It’s like the intersection of my two fave themes! ☺️ Maybe I should have it ranked higher than Number 10. 🤔 😅
I do love a good track from a Taylor who’s been wronged, too (thinking of Picture To Burn and Should’ve Said No”), but ultimately it’s the sad and reflective tracks about lost love that do it for me best.
I ❤️ Haunted original and Acoustic about the same. Can’t choose a favorite. And The All Too Well I prefer is the 2012 shorter version.
I love talking all about the poet and artist that Taylor is and I think sharing opinions is really fun. Feel free to share as much or as little as you want! I can’t wait to see your lists and hear your thought processes. Much love! ❤️
Enough blabbing, here’s my list:
Top 10 (* for Top 5)
________________
*Our Song
*Treacherous
* Hey Stephen
*Haunted ->(Original or Acoustic)
*All Too Well
You Belong With Me
The Best Day
Forever & Always
Death By A Thousand Cuts
Cornelia Street
Albums:
_______
Fearless
Red
Speak Now
August IN IT’S OKK??? I’m hurt
“Would you call the Bible a banger? No, because it’s a Moment.” 😂😂😂 Absolutely, I have zero arguments.
what can I say? I spit facts
who is annoyed by the amount of slander that Lover (album) gets
Me-e-e...
@@Emma-kw8uv what do you mean? the archer is a perfect track 5, and daylight? literally the best way to close this alvum not to mention that small voice over at the end... *chef-kiss*
probably because of how bad some of the songs are. IFTYE, Me! 🤡 you need to calm down, the man… this was her politics moment and she did NOT need it
I'm surprised you didn't make a lower tier below "I Want to Kill Her' just titled 'ME!'
I thought about it......
don’t blame me did not deserve that.
other than that love the video
LMFAO
I screamed at “ weddings, funerals, graduation”😭😭
Omg predicting the future with saying how “If This Was A Movie” should have been on Fearless!
You should do this again with midnights ❤️❤️
I'm so glad you brought up the overdone high school metaphor, I've thought this for ages
Call me old school (been here since 2006) but here’s my Top Five list ❤️
Our Song (Best T Swift song IMO)
Hey Stephen
Haunted (Acoustic or original 🤷♀️)
All Too Well
You Belong With Me
Honorable Mentions:
Death By A Thousand Cuts
Getaway Car
Forever & Always
Clean
Favorite album: Fearless (though Speak Now is a close second and has sentimental value bc it’s when I saw her on tour. So YES to “justice for Speak Now” ❤️)
Also, anyone else remember how
You Belong With Me was 100% a sleeper hit?
omg i love you this is a slay ranking
omg 10/5/2021 13:14 "wondering when taylor was going to ever say '(maybe) i'm the problem'" 10/21/2022 "IT'S ME HI I'M THE PROBLEM IT'S ME"
This is going to be interesting me and my signed fearless TV and folklore CDs are waiting
hope I won't disappoint ur blessed signed albums
Thanks a bunch for putting my absolute fave RIGHT WHERE YOU LEFT ME on you She Is The Moment category. ❤❤❤❤❤
I was doing fine until King Of My Heart happened. HOWWWW. I LOOOOVEE THAT SONG. i gasped lmaoooo
I found myself agreeing with most of your rankings except for a few. I love her slower, sadder songs and adore New Years Day because it feels like the calm after the storm. Like she's resting after and saying a sweet goodnight
NOT YOU PREDICTING IF THIS WAS A MOVIE BEING FEARLESS
Omg how can we have almost the same S tier even tho you hate some of my faves and love some of my most heted ones???
Cowboy like me, Gold Rush and Ivy ❤
Can we just take a moment to appreciate the fact that this video came out 2 years before “fortnight” came out and yet Zach somehow made a tier called “I want to kill her” ????? Hello ???
I was so hurt by the archer being ranked so low💀💀
HOLY GROUND!!!! The appreciation we love to see
omg the fact the last tier is a line from fortnight 💀😭
That what I thought too!!
I LOVE HOW YOU PUT SPEAK NOW IN IDK HER BYT THEN IN THE TV VERSION YOU PUT IT IN THE HIGHEST TIER
I watched somebody else's ranking of all of her songs and was raging the entire time because of their top songs and what they had in the bottom (no shade)
I had to take a deep breath and see if you made one and luckily you did😅 apparently we have the same tastes as far as her music goes, I feel like I can breathe now
I’m so glad I found this channel, great video for us Swifties!
Stay Stay Stay is amazing and I wont take the slander it gets for no reason.
NO WHAT I LOVE PAPER RINGS SO MUCH
FINALLY SOME RESPECT ON SPEAK NOW
Dang your thoughts on If This Was a Movie aged quite well. Taylor heard when you said it feels like a Fearless track and said “ok bet”
I agree with you on everything! a lot of the songs I love most of the fandom hates and the songs I think are overrated are the fandom's favs. 100% about WANEGBT AND IKYWT! swifties give these songs shit b/c it's basic. but they're fun bops. I think we, the swifties and the radio overplayed them so much that they are sick of them. but if you'll listen to them once in a while, they're fun and cute. unlike ME!SS who I see swifties defend this song for being a "fun" song. no, it's not. ME! is a kidz bop song at best. and even as a kidz bop it's bad. ME! shouldn't have been made in the first place. one of the worst songs ever. for some reason I thought you hate 22. and yes! thank you! Mean is childish and too twangy. Sweeter Than Fiction, it's blah. boring!! WTNY and Bad Blood yes. everyone hates them so much, but I don't mind it. thank you about OOTW!!! I agree 100% with you. I like the tour version and the grammy museum versions much better, but the album version is meh. too repetitive. shake it off at a funeral lol
I still don't like HYGTG. oh man, my only hearbreak with your ranking was I Know Places and KOMH. I love these song so much...
I LOVE Ready For It and I Did Something Bad haha. I would've put End Game in the bottom
THANK YOU ABOUT DELICATE. it's so overrated by the fans. as you said, I respect and understand why everyone loves it, but personally I barely listen to it. same with Getaway Car. I would've ranked DWOHT at the bottom as well. never listened to it since the album release week.
100% agree with you about CIWYW AND New Years Day. I think she put New Years Day for the people who hate reputation as a whole because through out all of my reaction to rep watching, everyone who hated the album said New Years is the only good song on rep.
We're thinking the same on almost everything! Lover is her worst album imo and I do forget I Forgot That You Existed' is existing. I never listened to it since the album release. so boring. The Archer, The Man, London Boy are so bad and boring.
SYGB! THANK YOU! most swifties rank it as their least favorite song b/c it's too difficult to listen, which I understand, as someone who lost his mom to brain tumor exactly a year ago, I relate to this song so much, and the song is so powerful and I love it, it makes me think of my mom and I never skip it. SYGB and marjorie are so good.
♥️♥️♥️ thanks for ur comment and I’m so sorry to hear about your mom, sending u a hug
the pop version of teardrops has to exist because that was on the radio (the pop channels). She wanted to be pop; country was the foot in the door. She has to make a pop version as an audition.
Shania Twain is one of her inspiration. Shania released Up! just a few years earlier. which had two discs. A Red version(pop) and a Green version(country)
Speak now is my favorite album to ever exist and TV will be out in July 7, I can't handle it !💜
THANK YOU for not killing epiphany. I know you don’t like her, and she’s not my favourite either (I’d say respectable bop), but thank you for sparing her life. 😘
In defence of epiphany, I think the song content is a lot more palatable if you consider that it was written at the very beginning of the pandemic. It hasn’t aged well because we’re so bored of hearing about covid. But Taylor was far from the only person making comparisons between soldiers on the front line and healthcare workers at the start of the pandemic, especially in reference to places that were overwhelmed like northern Italy and New York. Although the song is long, I personally find the production quite pretty- it’s appropriate to the subject matter, almost ethereal. Epiphany is not a skip for me, I almost always listen to it all the way through. As such, IMO, folklore is a (and Taylor’s only) skipless album.
WOW that is such a spicy take. my opinion is that Taylor truly does not have a skinless album which is totally fine by me
@@theswiftologist I’d be fine with her not having a skipless album too… if it were true 😜
@@theswiftologist Would you like another spicy take? ‘The Man’ and YNTCD would have both been much bigger hits had they been singles on 1989 rather than Lover. They would have been the feminist and LGBT anthems she wanted (and expected) them to be. Hear me out.
I admit that the arguments Taylor makes in The Man are only valid to a point. Where she loses me is the chorus, where she makes a confused case for how she’d be further along in her career were she a man. I don’t think this is something she can reasonably argue, given that, arguably, she would not have taken off the way she did were she a man. She made her start in the male dominated country genre, and managed to stand out because she was literally the only young woman. She continued to stand out with intense emotional vulnerability in her lyrics, which is palatable to audiences from a woman, because women are stereotypically emotional. Don’t get me wrong, I think if Taylor Swift were a man, I think he would still be a successful recording artist. I just don’t think he’d be as successful as her.
However, a lot of the other arguments she makes in the man are cutting and very true. They remind me of the interviews where she called out the sexism of critique around writing breakup songs, when no one says the same of Bruno Mars or Ed Sheeran. We can infer from the Miss Americana doco that she wanted to put out a song like The Man for a long time, but didn’t feel comfortable doing so during the 1989 era, when she was only just getting comfortable with using the word ‘feminist’.
I think the main reason The Man didn’t land was the timing. Had it been released in 2014/15 (pre #metoo; 2017), almost all the arguments she made would have been hot takes. It would have captured some of the shock value that ‘If I Were a Boy’ (2008) garnered. By the time Taylor released The Man in 2019, no one really cared about hearing about feminism from a rich white lady anymore, and we definitely didn’t care about double standards, which had been raked over to death by that point. It might not have done as well as Blank Space, a superior song, but The Man would have supported Blank Space for a more complete story of where Taylor was actually coming from.
I feel similarly about YNTCD. There’s nothing especially wrong with the lyrics. The gayest thing about that song is the video clip. The main issue is timing. Were Taylor to have released a song and video like this in 2014 (before same sex marriage was legalised across the USA in 2015), I feel her advocacy would have been far more welcome to the LGBT community (and of course, subject to more criticism from conservatives). Again, I think she would have liked to make her stance on gay rights clearer earlier in her career, and I feel sad that she felt she had to wait as long as she did, to the point where her advocacy was not only somewhat unnecessary, but unwanted.
Anyway, if anyone’s read this far, I’d love to hear your opinion on this. I’d say ‘follow me for more spicy takes’, but I think I’m all out 😄
can we talk about how he literally predicted fortnight?????? "I want to kill her" as a tier????
I rly enjoy when people rank taylor swift on a tier list, and I respect all of your opinions
finally someone recognise ayhtdws's worth 😭😭😭
The Archer makes sense production wise to me. It's supposed to represent the pull and release of a bow through the building production until it releases at the end.
Pleeease you’ve got to do an updated version of this video soon! Maybe after Tortured Poets and Rep TV
The other cool thing about teardrops is that liz rose said taylor was getting pressure to change "drew" to "you" but she fought to keep it drew. An early record of her being able to put her foot down and hold her own creatively.
my mouth dropped when you killed marys song :O
Beautiful Ghosts is the one good thing that came from Cats but that's not saying much.
LMAO
Thank you for speaking up about King of my Heart, i have had a problem with that song since day one!! I can’t stand her!! And also i love that your fave is Holy Ground cause its mine too:))
I LOVE your honesty, but babes…King of my heart? What did that song do too you? That song is in my top 3 and you gave it the electric chair? Anyway great ranking other than that ❤️
Ok I’ve never commented on your videos but this was one of my fave rankings ever, lemme tell you I was CRACKING UP. When you put I know places into the kill tier with no explanation, I felt that. I don’t even hate that song the way you do but I love your audaciousness.
So many are afraid to shit on some Taylor songs but considering the range of her discography, it’d be weird to not have a few songs that you can’t stand.
Also thank you for righteous disdain for New Year’s Day like wtf was that song doing on reputation?? When I first listened to the album I was so mad that it ended on such a lame note. LWYDM supremacy
Only major issue I had was picture to burn bc that song IS the moment & I desperately need the homophobic version for the re-record. Please and ty
the fact that he said that "if this was a movie" sounds like a fearless track rather than a speak now and now its been re recorded as a fearless tv track..
august being in the same category as peace and hoax is giving me a brain aneurysm
re: innocent i kinda wish i never knew what it was about. bc out of context it speaks to me about reckoning with regret as you grow up but still having that glowing child part of you
not the King Of My Heart slander 😭
Couldn’t be happier hearing Zach stan All You Had To Do Was Stay🥰!!!! One of the best songs period…fucking end!!!! Love her!!!!
hold the crap on bc he said that he thought that if this was a movie wasnt gonna get rerecorded, then bam it gets rerecorded. Then! he says that he felt like it was off of fearless and was given to speak now! omg 😱 future predictions over here
Speak Now (the song) is the cute little sister of I Write Sins and Not Tragedies, you can see the roots and foreshadowing of that professional relationship with Brendon Urie lol
You predicted fortnight😮
as a i know places stan i’m dead
this video is two years old and im withim the first 4 minutes of watching it, but a place in this world is one of my fav debut songs.. i will not stand for it being killed
I agree with you about the vault tracks from Fearless (Taylor’s Version) apart from the We Were Happy bridge
i can't believe you stood up for london boy. shocked & upset
I was genuinely shocked that "If This Was A Movie" got the rerecord. SO happy :D
I was waiting for this for so longgg
Hope it didn’t disappoint !
You didn't I haven't finish it yet but a few of my favorite ones were not so good to you and I was 💔
When you put everything has changed into i don't know her, i had to take a moment to myself.
Kendrick is the only good thing about bad blood 😂. And champagne problems is a masterpiece
THE WAY YOU PREDICTED THE IF THIS WAS A MOVIE FEARLESS SWITCH