CGTN Exclusive: Western propaganda on Xinjiang 'camps' rebutted
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.ย. 2024
- China's westernmost Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region is a multi-ethnic and multi-religious region. It's difficult enough to understand its complexity to begin with and Western propaganda didn't make things any easier. CGTN has traveled to the heart of Xinjiang and busted four myths manufactured by Western media regarding Xinjiang and the so-called "re-education camps."
Subscribe to us on TH-cam: goo.gl/lP12gA
Download our APP on Apple Store (iOS): itunes.apple.c...
Download our APP on Google Play (Android): play.google.co...
Follow us on:
Website: www.cgtn.com/
Facebook: / chinaglobaltvnetwork
Instagram: www.instagram....
Twitter: / cgtnofficial
Pinterest: / cgtnofficial
Tumblr: / cctvnews
Weibo: weibo.com/cctvn...
Douyin: v.douyin.com/aB...
![[Live] : ONE 168 วันนี้!! "โจนาธาน vs ซุปเปอร์เล็ก"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0jIN65KgJsI/mqdefault.jpg)
A wise man once said, "Do not reason with your enemies because they're not seeking the truth"
True, besides, mega genocide of indigenous Native Americans, and their population in Continents of America 500 yrs ago was around 15 millions, while European population in Europe was around 20 millions.Today, Natives population at 15 million, while European population, in Continents of America + Europe, at a staggering 'ONE BILLION'! Imagine this scenario, if Native American people cross the Atlantic, invade and Colonize Europe, and slaughter most Europeans, and put the remaining populations in tiny reservations, for 500 long years. How would Europeans feel about it? Think about it. All they need is their beloved motherlands back, the lands that their ancestors forebears had lived through thick and thin, endured through hardships and all for generations. Besides, indigenous Native Americans in Colonized lands of Anglo British, Spaniard and others are more of the same. Kill the indigenous Natives and whoever is left, marginalize them and create artificial poverty, once that poverty becomes crime and drinking, the media points to the poor and blames them to continue to stigmatize the 'other' community, scumbags, etc. Amazing fact that Indigenous Natives had built such great civilizations as Mayan, Inca and Aztec without outside help, and all from the scratch, and all on their own, since they had been cut off from the rest of the world for ten of thousand of years. In other words, they actually are great and proud people. Imagine what would it be like today if Native Americans had possessed some sort of nuclear weapons to defend themselves, and their beloved motherlands from invaders Colonizers? The answer is they would still have their own beloved motherlands, plus their population comparable to that of European population. In my humble opinion, it's about time to decolonize the Colonized lands, and return it to rightful owners Native American people. Remember, notorious global cardinal crime like Slavery & Colonialism had long been over, why on earth is this another notorious Colonization still lingering on? More at, blog.chinadaily.com.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=820652
@@unclechinsyou8555 'Anglos caused most of the world's problems' (David Cameron, British Prime Minister, 2010-2016). In fact, among the five main Anglo countries; Britain, USA, Canada, Australia & New Zealand, all but Britain is looted from others. By the way thanks for, blog.chinadaily.com.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=820652
@@unclechinsyou8555 The problemo is that the CGTN presenters are poorly skilled presenters and debaters even though they own the facts absolutely.
@@bigreba Like I said, Slavery, Colonialism and Colonization are evil things done by evildoers. Moreover, what do Slavery, Colonization, Colonialism, Capitalism, and Imperialism (that The West has practice now and then), have all in common? Because all these tremendously benefit The West. For instance, as in any sports and games one plays, if you are ahead of the game, that you found yourself in a much stronger position, and the others are weaker than you are; then what do you do? Would you play Offensive or Defensive game? Of course, you play Offensive game. That's exactly The West has been doing, playing Offensive game that benefit them the most out of the rest of the poor world, through 'Slavery, Colonization, Colonialism, Capitalism, and Imperialism'. Slavery, Colonialism and Colonization are all evil things done by evildoers. Moreover, I'm curious the fact that Christian Europeans, especially the Anglo West, which is, 'forever the jury, the judge and the policeman of the world' as well as self-acclaimed protector of human rights, has any laws at all for dealing with past and present notorious global cardinal crimes such as Slavery, Colonialism and Colonization of vast bountiful resourceful Continents and landmass, such as North and South America to Australia/New Zealand to Siberia/Far-East? Web site with 3 million views says it all, blog.chinadaily.com.cn/forum.php?mod=viewthread&tid=1795128
thats true
3:17 yes that video from Indonesia..
I'm from Indonesia
Yes, i watched that video last year. Thats from Indonesia.
Thank you for helping us clarify the rumors.
Yup, be ware of western propaganda
Yes, that's video clip is from Indonesia, little bit barbaric I must say, but yeah that's how stupid people treat other people *sorry world*
Maybe there are some false videos circulated. This happens always, and everywhere !!
But what about the reality ones? Where are they being buried. Why are they hidden and going in noticed? DONT ask me to produce them here on TH-cam.. you know very well
Fun fact: the BBC doesn't want you to see this.
Nice pfp
Everyone's seen this propaganda you genocide denier
Ok commie
@@andromedamessier3176 Ok buddy liberal
LOL that video definitely from Indonesia, as you can see those two officers are actually local security officer and military personil. That man got beaten up because he was a thief, that video clearly is a disinformation
Imagine if chinese officers beat a thief in public and a video was sent about it to CNN, the media would claim that the chinese government is suppressing people and that China is a "police state"
The mainstream media lie all the time on China,they distort things,making people believe their lies.
As an educated Chinese, I listened to both the Chinese and Western side and my conclusion is that everyone is safeguarding their own interest. Probably none of their claims are 100% true (even video clips and interviews from both sides can be made up) but the Western ones are def no less propaganda than the Chinese ones. Esp in the context of terrorist attacks in Xinjiang, those attackers can be labelled "terrorists" or "freedom fighters" depending on where you are coming from. Comparing the "camps" in Xinjiang to "concentration camps" of the Nazis only shows ignorance of history, but of course, they might be more than re-education centers. People believe in what they want to believe in and that is just human nature. The reality might be somewhere in between, and it is important to understand the different motives behind.
Both sides post fake news
It is for the race. Really everyone thinks they know everything...
@@krichenboi Please look up ETIM
@@jimmydean3961 what?
@@krichenboi East Turkistan Independence Movement
@@jimmydean3961 And?
@3:17 he said: ampun pak it's mean dont hurt me i'm give up in bahasa (indonesia language) damn i hate west propaganda
They dont specify where that video come from or is it aprovate individuals or news outlet is the spreader of the video
Where are the organs coming from, out of thin air?
@@blockchainmusic8697 Out of the ass of US politicians cause its a lie to incite negative relations with China.
@@blockchainmusic8697 Out of the falun gong ass... lol
th-cam.com/video/xU_w5UzdZEs/w-d-xo.html
China does not want extremist Islam to propagate religious terrorism. Chinese education camps wants to educate Uighur's on human values and compassion
Western propaganda exists look it up please before commenting. I have been in China for a total of 5 years and I meet Muslims around my region and they live in total harmony with the rest. I never heard bigotry during these 5 years, but in Australia where I lived for 5 years and a half I heard bigotry against Muslims Chinese Indian on a daily basis. I was always anxious going out in Australia, I was mugged in 2009 by some white Kids calling me curry muncher, the police didn’t care really. The ambulance refused to take me to the hospital and I paid for the hospital bill. Thanks for nothing Australia
This is propaganda from the chinese government. Don't be naive
your mainstream media is a propaganda apparatus
@@toddpacker4683 feet lover
@@toddpacker4683 lol you discredit someone’s personal experiences without giving a second thought, that’s really sad
@@Xyniss do you discredit all the uhgyur Muslims who say they were brutally abused by China?
I feel like i need to take a holiday there to know the truth. I really hope this is the reality. Media is so full of shit these days.
Minorities in China are very privileged, hell if minorities in the US were as privileged as minorities in China then you will see people like Ben shapiro whining and claiming about how the government is racist towards white Americans. Should be noted that minorities are protected by the constitution in China and that they were excluded from the one child policy China had
@@velcranoxofficials9970 so was that just propaganda when Africans were being rounded up at the start of covid and being blamed for it?
Legitimate question to you.
It is very hard to know what is real or not in this age of disinformation and psychological warfare.
@@hcr32slider I have some criticism of this claim that Africans in China are being blamed for the virus, i have researched into the topic and have found out that alot of these videos/photos weren't even taken in China or during the pandemic, a popular video showing an African getting beaten by "chinese" in the streets wasn't even taken in China or during the pandemic, the origins can be traced back all the way to 2016 or even further back of Malaysians i believe beating a thief in public. Another video showing a supposed Asian group fighting against an African group was found out to be a street fight in New York. Don't say "rounded up", you make it seem like this is a nationwide program taking place in china, now the story of Africans being kicked out of their homes in china can be traced to a couple of Africans in Guangzhou getting evicted because they were in the country illegally and were fugitives in China, their visa status as visitors were expired and so had to leave, although I disagree with this action I think this was the most appropriate step for a governing body to take since in the US they would send in ICE or a swat team. Hopefully this clears up this misconception that Africans in China are getting kicked out of their homes by China, it is important to also note that China has good relations with African countries, the Chinese Ambassador assured Kenya of the safety of its citizens, saying China has zero tolerance for discrimination of foreigners but that also that Africans in China have to follow the laws. Also think about it, the story of China blaming Africans doesn't make sense since China has good relations with africa and why would they just blame Africans? And also why is Africa first in line to get vaccines from China? There is alot of questions when these kinds of stories come up, western media always tries to paint China as this evil dictatorships who prosecutes and kills people for no reason, its important that when these stories do come up don't just believe everything the media says about it, importantly if its about China or American enemies
Why would you belive a state owned channel
@@emmanuellehmann9836 then do you watch the bbc or any American news channels for your information on Uyghurs?
I don't know who should I trust anymore..
Everyone lies to protect their interest.
Understand what we know that being the Chinese regime has three colonies Tibet,East Turkistan and now Hong Kong
The secret is to not trust anyone. Only trust urself
Back to FOX
@@ihk2421 Those three regions have been parts of China for thousands of years. Hongkong was taken from China by the brittish.
@@alaxanshark9438 thats right. You have to see both points of view and make your own conclusion. We all know that western news is completely bias towards China. So anything they say has to be taken with a grain of salt.
This guy was crying out in Indonesian language. I am a Malaysian and I understand.
Are you part of PKI member ?
_I'm a Malaysian Chinese, _*_CGTN is controlled by CCP_*
Berita ini mahu menutup kekejaman china terhadap muslim ughui.. muslim d seluruh dunia juga malaysia tak pernah buat macam tu (siksa) terhadap cina d malaysia.. fikirkan la
He was corrected... shortly after
@@ScubaShark--8964 And you control by Malay nationalist Gorvenment
This is propaganda if you did not know.
I can't even share this link on Facebook anymore cause it doesn't fit their "community standard" cause they think it's "mis-information". America has freedom of speech? LOL
Could you ask the CCP to stop censoring the internet in China? China is cheap copy of Russian communism
@@pandemonic66 and that comunism is still better than imperialism !! 😅😅😅 !! love and support from asia go on china ! ♥️♥️♥️♥️
Freedom of expression does not apply to private businesses.
Yea bcos this is rubbish payed by whinnue the pooh
@@pandemonic66 ur very based
"We, the government, reached out to the government… to defend the government."
At least Chinese state media doesn't push information authored by Nazi apologists like Adrian Zenz, unlike Western media.
This is your brain on Western propaganda
That is a tourist destination, why don't you go to one of the ethnic cleansing prisons? MORE Chinese Propaganda!
🤫
So pls listen to our anti-chinese, BIAS FREE western medias and arabic influencers instead of listening to the country itself 😂
The guy said, "ampun Pak"
That's indonesian language
I'm from indonesia
The western media tried their best....
Yeah, they're actually Indonesian 😂
@@kaiyang5426 i see why they say they're good at being racist... Can't tell an "Indonesian" (generalizing) from a "Chinese".... Trully the greatest! Number 1!
Caught that one on first glance before he even mention it.
Damn, I cringe so bad to see that tweet.
I wanted to share this on insta but i can’t cuz it’s violating the guidelines.........
Censorship!
Yes it’s called curbing disinformation
The big tech _thought police_ don't want you to see this because it threatens their anti-Chinese narrative.
I’m a little confused, did u mean Instagram restrained u to send the link, or is it the cgtn that restrained u?
Well simply put if you censor our free speech we will censor your free speech it’s called fighting fire with fire
Fun fact: This video cannot be shared on Facebook. Facebook has blocked it.
Why?
@@audriiiiroberts3030 Because Western countries do not want the world to hear China's side of the story.
If you don't believe me you can try sharing the link to this video on Facebook. It will be blocked right away.
@@gabriellechow4440 "china's side of the story" is just about the most stupid thing you could post. This is not China's "side of the story" this is China attempting to rewrite the story to fit what they please. And what you're saying isn't even true. I've seen posts by the Chinese government about this exact issue.
@@Very_Silly_Individual How many dollars have you been paid by the crybabies from CIA?
@@agitohd 0 dollars and 0 cents honey. I'm not a puppet of any government. But you clearly are, considering the fact you're willingly on the side of a genocidal government.
Western and US are dreaming and in their own fantasy. 😂
Racist.
@@wolfgangfierce9559 Do you know what "racist" even means?
You're denigrating a whole race of people, ie. "the West", how could it not be racism?
@@wolfgangfierce9559 That at best could be described as a generalisation not racism, are you an idiot?
maybe they smoke too much weed and opium
Meanwhile, we (Indonesian) are gathering funds for this fake allegation 🤦♂️
yudhisr
You are not evet Indonesian
@@masmavigokyuzu4036 He is Indonesian and you have no clue...
@@masmavigokyuzu4036 I think he is...
If it walks like a duck, and quacks like a duck, its probably a Chinese concentration camp.
--- BBC.
😂
I don't mean to doubt this, but this is posted from a Chinese news source. This could very well be propaganda itself. It's hard to say what is real or not.
It definetely is propaganda
@@luxuri5515 Just like fox news, cnn, msnbc and many others.
@@ChrisAFigaro Just because they are ‘propaganda’ doesn’t mean my point is any less valid. Also are you a wumao may i ask?
@@luxuri5515 No, it just means that you're biased and brainwashed. And no, I'm not paid by China, lol.
I just prefer authenticity and truth. Not fakeness, lies and propaganda that the west is highly known for. Not even you can deny that.
Remember to judge based on results and actions. You choose.
@@luxuri5515 do you not see the sources they give to you? Your western media doesn't give you sources they give assumed opinions which is completely different than source so do your own research and maybe sometimes this news channel gives propaganda too but you can't say this specific news is fake when they have given proper evidences which your western media had failed to provide
P.S. imagine calling an Indonesien prsioner Chinese while he's on an Indonesien prison lmao, do some research brother open your blind eyes
Why are all accusations made by Western countries while Muslim countries have all been silent? It's a genuine question. 🤔
I don't know man,this is owned by the Chinese government so take that with a grain of salt
What media outlet isn’t owned by a powerful entity?
@@thomaszhang3101 none, that's why I don't trust big media
The worst are US online troll armies shouting against you still.
This comment section isn't exception too.
They're basically forcing you to accept their new religion: Liberalism.
Actually this is the ccp channel aimed at western audiences to promote their propaganda
So, let the people in Xinjiang have their passports back and allow them to contact their missing family members.
Is this a monopoly game to you?
lol where did u get this info idiots?
Many are in Syria paid to fight for the US against the Syrian Army. Thousands were killed in the battle, so the US claimed they were killed in Xinjiang. Of course, when they were bombed by Russia and Syrian warplanes, their bodies were torn into pieces, again the US claimed they were missing in Xinjiang.
Krishna Pillai it’s not your country to obey your rule and thts their right you keep focusing on ur own country where million of beggar ,slum , poor are starving !!!
This is hilarious. Can’t believe people in the comments are falling for this scripted charade
you're on CGTN. Every comment here is going to blindly worship China and believe every lie the CCP tells them.
@nredmaster oh so where's your evidence of the mass genocide? Oh the bbc news reports? Wait then how did those people get out of the "execution" camps? Oh wait. Search up autonomous region rights and how the ethnic communities are protected and work
I served in Irish Army Range Wing aka Sciathán Fiannóglaigh an Airm as a tech sergeant for 3 years. I had several humanitarian aid joint operations with White Helmet in Damascus. I have seen a dark side of White Helmet. Since then, I never trusted any kind of propaganda,never trusted any news.
Ireland is one of the few western nations that garners any respect.
@@xerogue because they still live with the effects of being colonized unlike many in Europe who still have a nation
Yeah. 😔
I'm an American of Irish descent, whose trying to reconnect with the culture.
I can't imagine, that sounds horrible.
"We questioned local government officials" is the least convincing way to debunk something. This would be hilarious if it wasn't so fucking evil
CGTN is owned by the government as well.
What these guys are saying is mostly the truth but presented in a bad way by government associated people, the very reason people don't trust the US claims about camps (the wiki article being written by CIA affiliates) is happening here. Basically these guys are morons and made the truth seem like propaganda. I have not seen an unbiased video on this topic yet and I doubt I ever will unless I make one myself.
Interviewing individuals you say they are actors from CCP, interviewing council officers you say hilarious. So what do you want?
@@playrasputin3457 don’t forget government is a positive word, unlike your government even a dog can be elected to be your governor.
Its not worse then western propaganda
I tried posting this video on Facebook, but it was rejected because it goes "against the guidelines"... suspiciously it's a Norman Finkelstein FB page, who tries to confuse the real human rights violations of Israel with that of Xinjiang China.
Disappointed in the lack of integrity in Western news media.
Come on we need to have a filter and in china media all can only post what the government wants, how can we believe in news that are controlled by the government?
my boy looks dead inside must be the effects of working for the CCP.
1. Uighurs in China ( as well as other ethnic minorities of China ) enjoy free education for 12 years, free healthcare, free from any taxes, free from the 2 child policy and they even get extra points in the exams to enter the university.
2. Xinjiang"s life expectancy increased from around 30 in 1949 to around 73 years old, nowadays. The Uighur"s population in China is doubled from the last decades, reaching more than 12 million people.
3. Before the existence of re-education schools in XinJiang, XiNjiang was one of the most dangerous places in Asia ( like HK before the implementation of the HK Security Law ). Most Uighurs in China are living very well except for ter(ror)ists ( Islamic extremists ). China prefers to re-educate terr(oris)ts instead of jailing them as most western countries do. Instead, the US prefers to invade countries such as Afghanistan to solve terr(oris)m. See the difference?
4. China has 39000 mosques compared to the 2100 the US has. Even per capita, China has more mosques than most western countries and 3x that of the US by muslims.
5. Only around 22 western non-islamic hypocrit countries criticize China for the measures taken on Uighurs. 54 countries ( most of them muslim majority countries ) support China measures in Xinjiang. Only Turkey ( member of NATO and supporter of Xinjiang independence, I mean they literally claim Xinjiang as part of Turkey, they call Xinjiang " East Turkestan ") condemns China.
Please forward/share/retweet this comment to inform more the people about the real situation of Xinjiang and Uighurs
will you please create a google docs and put this in it? For some reason I cannot copy this comment.
3:17 yah thats video from indonesia, they guy who got beaten say "ampun pak" means mercy sir
hmmmm......Since when the Uighurs learn to speak Bahasa Indonesia?
@@Dragon-gl1rw maybe 1 of them can
@@happyalltheday2275 Chinese police wear Indonesian police uniform?
Ha3, ampun Pak... I’m Indonesian, too.
th-cam.com/video/xU_w5UzdZEs/w-d-xo.html
The guy who wrote the report is a Christian, therefore there cannot be Uyghur prisoners in Xinjiang? What kind of argument is that?
Who commented below here actually lived in China besides me?
How do you all sleep at night while lying like this? Few months back I was living in Beijing and matched with a few Uighur girls on Tinder/tantan. One fled from Xinjiang cuz the police came to her house everyday just stood outside her window to harass her family. And in Beijing she still got checked on the street everyday. The other came to Beijing to study but shes even afraid to go out on the street to go hang out because the police stops her to check the ID all the time. She is even scared to further talk about this subject on WeChat because it is censored.
Yes, we believe a CIA paid operative like you since WikiLeaks exposed 30 million such operatives employed by CIA world-wide and that got Assange in trouble.
What you said don't make sense. If the uighur girls were afraid of police, why did they go to Beijing, the capital of China? They chose to live 3000km from home and live in an environment which hates them?
@@mingguo4884 郭明， read carefully of what I said.
1. One girl was afraid of the actions of police checking her ID. I never said she was afraid of the police.
2. "Hate" is strong word, never have I used the word "hate" or has either of the girl said to me they felt like they are "hated", if anything is related to "hate", it's this platform CCTV and CGTN (or whatever it is called) is promoting extreme hatred speech and extreme Chinese Nationalism. Read the comments and you know why we Chinese say people 没素质，and unfortunately mainland not only exports a 没素质 culture, it is also exporting a "Love the Communism China, Hate the first world countries" culture.
I believe many of the comments here are sponsored by Communism Chinese government and therefore does not have any validities, yet unfortunately TH-cam is not able to detect them.
If any of these contents/comments are truthful, real, or at least partially reprsent what the people who are really involved i.e. 中国人民（包括新疆维族人，藏族, etc.）it will reflect an very different outcome.
Ask yourself why don't we see a fair represtation of 人民的声音 people's voice, we all know it's because within China comments are forbidden, deleted, attacked while accounts are blocked on 微博. And TH-cam, Reddit, anything promotes a platform for freedom of expression is blocked.
It is okay that Chinese government does not believe in Democratic values, does not believe in humanity values. And you have the authority to block these values. But launching a full propaganda campaign both domestically and abroad on producing extreme nationalism while attacking first world countries and democratic values?
Sorry, you can't do that and I see a Nazi China.
Hope TH-cam never recommend any of these contents to me.
@@rogerfaint499 I'm pretty sure at least CIA pays much higher than your Communism government fifty cents 😂😂😂
Just curious, why doesn't the Chinese government just allow all news reporters to go there freely. Wouldn't this put an end to all this debate?
They do, in fact, you can literally book a flight to Xinjiang right now (seriously take a look at flights)
The question is if those news outlets will even bother reporting the truth.
We investigated ourselves and found that we did nothing wrong!
Like nearly all things, I think the truth lies somewhere in between. It seems to me like there is some arbitrary detention and torture going on, and their standard of what constitutes a person being rehabilited may be out of line.
But it is painfully obvious that they aren’t physically capable of holding 1-3 million people in a region of 12 million without satellites picking up massive encampments. The majority of people probably are really being given vocational training and a better opportunity to integrate. Which, objectively, is superior to the American strategy of indiscriminate bombing
May be China reporter need to use the propoganda term more frequent on western media as the west does to China n those countries the west targeted.
Crackdown on those Western media or NGOs who vomit lies in China.
We don’t fall to the lows of the West
@@jackshen5093 ha ha ha
Its too bad you are not able to see all the news in the west, you may have a different outlook.
@@squidsoup9509 true, since western media is more about nationalism and entertainment than actual solid journalism
@@jackshen5093 yeah. The Chinese government isn’t as low as western media. They just don’t allow free speech and press and arrest criticizers. Not that bad🙄
⚖️ Well spoken truth. China is widely known that, from the ancient years till now, had the most wise leaders of this world. That is the meaning of Chinese wisdom of bringing peace and prosperity to the people. The wisdom always was laying and being sought by the travelers in the far East.
This is CGTN and is funded my Chinese government
There is propaganda all over the world. Is Chinese propaganda somehow less deceptive than 'Western' propaganda?
@Philip Harding are you questioning facts presented here? if you doubt this go to the Grayzone and find out from a Western source. your comment is typical lazy brainwashed passive acceptance. go and see Max Blumenthal's reports on this very subject, properly researched actual journalism.
Do keep the same level of skepticism when you watch the western propagandas. At least you can do that much.
Western media supports LGBT ...we Eastern not just media but peoples should know how different it were from west and east.
Western news so evil
edward tay ...geez ur private name seems so ...G??
@Edward Tay 作为一名爱国的男同，我真的觉得很遗憾
@Edward Tay you know they have lied many times but you choose to believe in them like always. Stupid? Ignorant? Or hatred has blind your brain?
based on your views...western news isn't the only news that's evil
Don't believe in his lies
Facebook banned this link as "spam"
Talk about censorship!
Western prisons also have classrooms for vocational training, but they're still prisons. Is there any reason, at all, why the Chinese government won't allow the Uyghurs to talk to the international press, or the outside world? The detainees at Guantanamo Bay have more freedom than this
Let independent journalists to visit the camps and see for themselves the situation if China thinks every thing is all right.
Holy shi*t someone thinking for themselves? 😳😳😳 What a Chad
But journalists aren't allowed in for some reason. Hmm, wonder why... Could it be because the Chinese government is sterilizing Uighur Muslims?
independent journalists? How to find the camps? If a million independent journalists want to visit, then the camp will accept and treat them a million times? Is your suggestion operability?
Reality check for you: there is not a single "independent" journalist in the world, everyone has at least some amount of bias. Independence doesn't exist.
Why is Xinjiang not open for journalists? This is lie!
It is you dummy. How did they get the footage of some facilities in China? You're the lie/r
在这个艾迪尕尔清真寺旁边的青旅住过一个半月，每周五都有无数穆斯林在这个广场上做礼拜。我还在这个采访背景的一家炸鸡店吃过。这里除了安检严格以外，并无太多不同。另外喀什大部分是维吾尔族，汉语普及度水比较差。我带着两个韩国朋友在这边和当地人交流一脸茫然。做车还碰到热情的维吾尔族大叔和我说，不要误会我们，我们也很为难（由于乌鲁木齐75事件等），他的孩子还和我用维吾尔语打招呼。
I stayed in the youth hostel next to the Aidi Gaer Mosque for a month and a half, and countless Muslims worship in this square every Friday. I also ate at a fried chicken restaurant in the context of this interview. Apart from strict security checks, there is not much difference here. In addition, most of Kashgar is Uyghur, and the popularity of Chinese is relatively poor. I took two Korean friends here to communicate with the locals, looking at a loss. The enthusiastic Uyghur uncle who was working in the car told me, don’t get us wrong, we are also very embarrassed (due to the Urumqi 75 incident, etc.), and his child greeted me in Uyghur.
China invited more than 30+ countries to examine the camps themselves, but many rejected and the invitation is still open to this day
can you send the link where u found that as proof please
Could you please share any source that proves what you've just said? I do not think countries would refuse an invitation to investigate.
@@Chouchou4001
This was a joint statement written by 54 nations that visited.
id.china-embassy.org/eng/jrzg/t1711859.htm
@@StarEreny The biggest propaganda news is from china.....Its famous
well.... nobody has yet to get that invite but maybe thats what your news is telling you
"CGTN is funded in whole or in part by the Chinese government."
This is all you need to know about the "rebutting" in this video.
Well, the western media ain't any better. Better look at both perspectives than just one.
And all western media owned by government are tagged as public broadcasters.
I'm Muslim, and I support China and the Chinese government.
Yeah ur definitely not Muslim
I've had to explain this to peoples well over 100 times and they still disbelieve the facts
@Ian Is based Wrong, they receive funds much like how the PBS (Public Broadcasting Service) received funds from the US government and BBC received funds form the British government. There is no ownership, but the banner on top sure is worded in just a way to make you believe that, right? How slimy
@@burnoutcollectivist4660 ur making it seem like every western newspaper is state owned. literally every newspaper in China has government ownership or at least supervision. Has even 1 chinese newspaper criticized the government in a meaningful way?
@@beneyweneys Bruh you clearly either didn't read my comment or chose not to understand it, because my entire point is that public funds =/= public ownership, which is why I used PBS as an example, which exposes the blatent bias surrounding western media in how they portray China, in this example how TH-cam's banner makes it seem like CGTN is owned by the government when it's actually independent and only receives public funds like PBS does, entirely due to slimy politiciany phrasing like "funded in part or whole", because when you phrase it like that you mislead people who will cling to "whole" when the reality is closer to "part".
@@burnoutcollectivist4660 public funds means that the company has the incentive to report in favor of the government. Some western media is publicly funded but many arent.
@@burnoutcollectivist4660 oh pa-leese. You honestly think the ccp doesn't have it's grubby fingies all over this? Bit naive in't it?
I'm a Muslim form North Africa and I love China
Terrorists should be eliminated
We’ve always been at war with Eurasia
Same as white helmet.
Kong Wee Peh 👍
Anni Hillateyutube Yeah . He has fallen from the roof I think. But, it was CIA behind this.
As westerner I agree its hard to watch western propaganda news ( fox etc) but, it is equally hard to watch/listen to eastern propaganda news (CGTN)
I find western propaganda news easy to recognize /avoid but, as I turn to the eastern side of things i wonder...... do eastern people recognise the eastern propaganda white wash?
th-cam.com/video/f00V9MQBhg8/w-d-xo.html
keep an open mind
CGTN is a state-owned broadcast. 👀
Okay and? Something funded by the Chinese people is bad apparently 😂
actually terrifying how many people including myself, had believed this to be true for so long.
It is
@@ksang2121 so true that not a single muslim majority nation in the middle east is saying a word about it
Thank you CGTN,the Truth always win.
Thank you CGTN, from New Zealand
As a Turkish i don't know which side to believe... there is so much propaganda in Turkey about Uyghurs that it hurts our hearts
Perhaps you should visit China to see it for yourself. I have many foreign friends who only realize the lies of western propaganda after they visit China. China welcomes you.
看了一眼评论，真心觉得大陆媒体做的这个厘清事实的采访是不被认可的，别人首先一句话’你这个是官媒‘就否定所有的事实。所以话语权被西方掌握真的很极端
Are you saying that, the Chinese government, with one of the most advanced security systems in the world, is unable to find people because their names were misspelled?
or perhaps they don't even exist to begin with.
there are 1.4 billion people in China and they are fighting a propaganda war perpetrated by the West and particularly the US. you should watch this to get an idea of what is really happening. John Pilger's film, the Coming War on China th-cam.com/video/IC_HEl4iwlA/w-d-xo.html
where is my brother？
In 1953, Uyghurs numbered 3.6 million. In 2018, that number grew to 12 million. If this was supposed to be a "genocide", it'd be the most spectacular failure in history.
Except that figure is wrong
@@destdrom I am calling your bullshit. Provide the statistics.
@@destdrom I also call your BS. Provide the statistics.
@@electrotricity7203 search up Uyghur population decline….
"Western narrative on Xinjiang and the so-called re-education camps."
U know that's the word the Chinese gov use, right?
Chinese govt call them the re-education centres, not camps
How many independent foreign journalists have had the same access? What are their names and what networks or news outlets do they work for?
non
you mean what the chinese gov said is not thue, the CCP said is not true?
They let BBC and Vice into the vocational centers and they desperately tried to spin it. It's not fucking Area 51
@@uexkeru But it was on one or just a few decided (by Beijing) days. Some abuses in western prison came into public because anyone can do an interview at anytime and prisoners can speak freely.
@@yukidaruma4768 They have journalistic credentials. It would be illegal and an international scandal to refuse them acsess, and they've turned down invitations before. What they do is go around filming freely, get in people's faces and then make a big deal when a guy shoves his hand in the camera
We need these camps where I live
😂😂😂
First of all foreigners are not allowed inside xingjiang without a handler or ccp agents who monitors your every step inside xingjiang
Unfortunately, Canada had residential schools for our native people. Across Canada, at these now closed residential schools, the children (native) was forced to convert to Christianity, sexual abused, forgo their language and cultural background and, in some cases, murdered. As a Canadian, I am ashamed. I remain, Ronald Cooney.
CGTN, formerly known as CCTV-9 and CCTV News, is an international English-language news channel based in Beijing owned by China Central Television, a state-controlled broadcaster. It has been referred to as a mouthpiece of Chinese government.
yes, this isn't something they hide, it literally says it right under the video
I feel like even though theyre already peace in xinjiang, Han chinese and uighurs are just like civil to each other. They are not that close but not that enemy. I mind my own business, you mind your own business then we're peace.
How do you know? Do you live there or visited? I am genuinely asking? It’s not a debate.
@@ahmedsalim5552 I'm from Xinjiang, the Uyghurs are fine where they are! Its also kind of funny how they are more privileged due to their ethnicity and most are now out of poverty due to government initiatives.
@@electrotricity7203 you chinese puppet.
@@ihatetay either the puppeteer is doing a horrible job, or the audience is watching the wrong show
@@electrotricity7203 what are you talking about dawg
1 million Muslim Uyghurs troops to support Northern Alliance.
Funded by the Chinese government.... yeah I'm sure yall will tell the truth 😆🤣 Got some social credit?
imagine believing CIA instead and thinking ur not being propagandised 😭
@@siyae1507 CGTN is owned by China
@@duckey6806 and? yall will say falsified statements ab china and they arent even allowed to defend themselves? caucasity is through the roof.
@@siyae1507 wumao America is a democracy ,They have free press and they critcize their own country All day unlike china.
@@slayer6078 people in America can criticise their government
Wow! This is so convincing. Hmmm, I was in Kashgar five years ago and armed Chinese troops were running up and down the stairs of our hotel, tanks were in the streets, and everyone had to go through heavy security clearance to go shopping at the supermarket. Nothing wrong with that picture?
There was a terrorist attack, what u expect? What about right after 9/11, they even start a war for it. what about the BLM movement getting suppressed by the national guard? The list goes on, and nothing wrong with that picture?
Wow double standard👏
@@AZetorA BLM movement suppressed by the national guard? How? There were protests in just about every city in the country. National Guard wasn't even sent when protestors occupied a section of Seattle. So what on earth are you talking about?
There was something wrong happening in Xinjiang, but we dont know what it is, we have no idea on the scale and extent to it, and western media keeps feeding people with doubtful and unbacked claims and accusations, and Chinese media would not expose any issues they have.
How those media are able to tell such lies without being punished!
CCP sponsored media
@@willthix3822 western media is extremely biased on china. make your mind from there
wow! my reply has been deleted!
it did go on about CTGN and other CCP sponsored media deliberate misinformation.
western media working to source truth (sometimes making a mistake but usually correct)
CCP message to china and the chinese is not getting it right and chinese rate their local govt (CCP) with 10% approval rating. 90% don't approve.
The international community is hoping that chinese people can survive the CCP regime. (tibetenese, uyghurs, inner mongolians, hong kongese) and the misinformation about taking back Taiwan. (it was never in CCP control) still under control of legitimate government.
So talking bias, the CCPmedia is all about the CCP not china or the chinese. Western media looks at each story and focuses on the CCP. just truth not bias.
lets see if this post gets deleted
@@SpongeBobbin34 CCP is biased in favor of itself. Western media does not have any obligation to the government so why would it need to advance the “national interest”?
Yes it’s ALWAYS western media blah blah propaganda but NEVER do we talk about our own. Lol also these people have given up their head scarves and caps for western looking hats, and their heads have been shaved. Muslim women don’t shave their heads. Now they are “re-educated” freely I guess and chose to shave heads. Is that what it means to be chinese?
I wonder if the guy in the video knows that giving one example of a Uyghur flourishing does not imply that other Uyghurs aren't being mistreated. Debunking 1 random twitter video does not undermine all the personal survivor stories that have come out by Uyghurs. Attacking 1 study for it's sample size does not undermine all the other journalistic studies that have been conducted. And using an Ad Hominem attack on the supposed "origin" of the leak does not count as a substantive criticism of the argument itself...
Well what are you expecting lol
This is originally a Chinese channel and this guy is very obviously Chinese .....
This is a propaganda channel of China made to debunk “western lies “
cgtn is state owned
As a Muslim, I am used to the media lying about my religion and my people, sadly many Muslims don't spot when the press lie about others. I hope this is true.. May Allah help us all.
Hope my Muslim brothers and sisters don't fall into the same trap again. The same people that has used the gullibles among us to get rid of Saddam and Gaddafi who refused to be their stooges any longer, to destabilised and plunder the oil rich Mid East, to break up Yugoslavia and also cause trouble in Chechnya and Dagestan in their effort to bleed Russia. Way before that, they used the Taliban to bleed the Soviet Union (USSR), to give USSR it's own Vietnam. Once that was achieved and Soviet collapse, they cut ties/get rid of Taliban, smearing them and branding them terrorists. But they failed to break up Dagestan and Chechnya from Russia. In Syria, they throw all sorts of lies to get Assad out. They stage chemical attack through their minions (the White Helmets) and blame it on Assad. This follows the same tactic they use to legitimise Iraq invasion (the WMD lies). And now whistleblowers from OPCW (Organization for Prevention of Chemical Warfare) have come out to claim those chemical attack never took place, it was simply a lie, just like those Iraq WMD claims. Yet at the height of their propaganda, all sorts of fake videos, testimony and images were spread and disseminated to get people to believe Assad launch a chemical attack against his own people, oppressive, etc. They fail to plant a dagger into China using the gullibles among Hong Kong youth, and now they want to use the gullibles among us to do their dirty work against China. Don't be taken for a ride. Remember what happen to those who took them for allies: once they are no longer useful, they were discarded, either killed, silenced or turned into persona non grata and left to fend for themselves. They never fight using their own people or on their own homeland, instead they get others to fight and die for them. Saddam, Gaddafi, Assad, Taliban, Al-Qaeda, the Kurdish forces and countless other jihadist groups all used to be their allies. But look what happen to them once they stop following orders, refuse to bow down, wants independence, and/or are no longer useful: they are either killed/hanged, branded dictator/terrorist, and so on. Also, remember that WMD claim which form the basis for the so called 'War on Terror'. Turns out it's a lie and they don't even bother to apologise. Yet millions die because of that bogus war. But look what happen to Chechnya and Dagestan today. Both have become stable regions, their socio-economic condition improve, they even produce world class champion like Khabib. While Albania and Kosovo which was once part of Yugoslavia, has become no man's lands. Everyone wants to get out, either because of corruption, poverty or institutional collapse. Same with Libya, Iraq and Afghanistan. China isn't Myanmar, where millions of Rohingya Muslims wanted to escape from due to the real persecution that's happening there. Hence we see the symptoms of those persecution: millions of Rohingya refugees stranded in Bangladesh and the neighbouring countries. But with China, we don't see that flow of Chinese Muslims refugees out of China. Wake up and learn from history.
Washington and the western MSM care so much about the plight of Muslims. They worried about the treatments of Muslims in China, Russia, Libya, Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Syria, Iran, and so on and so forth. But don't you dare mention Israel. Don't you dare mention about the treatment of Muslims under Israel. Don't you dare mention what's happening to Gaza and the Israeli government treatment towards the Palestinians. Don't you dare mention the billion of aid the US government channel annually towards Israel military that ends up killing countless innocent Muslims and creating millions of Muslims refugees over decades long policy of uprooting the Palestinians natives. Don't you mention about the arm supplies they provide towards Saudi governments and the subsequent use of those weapons in the war against the innocent Yemeni population which resulted in a huge humanitarian crisis and refugees outflow from Yemen.
China is lying, everything western say about the concentration camps in Xingjiang is true, family of my friend is still in camp, its not actually a camp its a prison
almost all the mosques in Xingjiang are closed and most are ruined, Xingjiang is a huge ghetto for muslims
China isn't Myanmar or Israel, where millions of Rohingya Muslims wanted to escape from due to the real persecution that's happening there. Hence we see the symptoms of those persecution: millions of Rohingya refugees stranded in Bangladesh and Palestinians Muslims refugees in Jordan and the neighbouring countries. But with China, we don't see that flow of Chinese Muslims refugees out of China. Wake up and learn from history.
When I put these words into the search window on TH-cam, "supa Uighur home" because I wanted to get an idea of how Uighur's live at home and see a home interior, I got about two dozen anti-Chinese videos before spotting this one as a rebuttal to the Western propaganda. A basic effort to search for knowledge on Uighur culture brought forth nothing but propaganda from the algorithm used by TH-cam, with the exception of this video to counter propaganda. I'd still like to know a bit about uighur culture and homelife.
there is a youtube from xinjiang that posts ab uighur culture but i forgot her name :( sorry
Dont worry china we PAKISTANIS are with u. All muslims will be with u when we were with u and we are with u. Long live CHINA PAKISTAN FRIENDSHIP 🇨🇳❤🇵🇰
how dare you speak on behalf of all Pakistanis shame on you.
You can never wake up those people who are biased.
It is really sad. The reality of brainwashed people are right in front of our eyes. Denial in everything against their opinion and insults anyone who disagrees. Freedom of speech never existed in the first place.
There's no doubt that there are geopolitical interests behind the western media's focus on what's going in Xinjiang. There's no doubt that the 1-2 million number is based off of dubious investigations by US interest groups. HOWEVER, for so many testimonials to come out (there are way more than 8) this issue is worth looking into. There needs to be an objective international investigation into this and China needs to let this happen. Not allowing this to happen makes things look suspicious. Although I agree with most of what this video is saying you have to also remember that this is Chinese state television, literally the source of propoganda.
You spoke for me sir
Xinjiang is open to the world for and the truth can be easy to find if you are unbiased.
Not true. The camps are 15 hours away from the popular tourist sites.
@@HockeyVictory66 wheres your source? westoid
@@2moro_jdm ADV China. Check out their TH-cam channel. These two gentlemen lived in China for 10 years and are also married to Chinese women. They had to leave China because their videos were telling truths that Xi did not like and the Chinese government was trying to imprison them. They now live near me in California. They traveled extensively throughout China and have many contacts there still. They are more reliable than any government or journalists. Obviously, you are a member of the 50 cent army or you definitely act like one. Is Westoid some lame Chinese term.
@@HockeyVictory66 "ADV China" oh you mean that CIA funded media?
@@2moro_jdm Get a life dude. I don’t argue with ignorant people.
This is another propaganda. Who comes up with these ideas.
@@navinasimoes what did india do in kashmir?
#LongliveChina
Long live Tibet!
@@davecharlie3504 It is a part of China, so your message is pointless.
You guys Don't allow free media or foreign media in China, of course everything is so normal in China 😂
Longeu life ouighour. I am turk is my race . ..i love my race. Yaşasin canlarim. .
This is the definition of propaganda
1:33 1/3 are under criminal investigation.
Yeah that's the point 😂
What is the crime?
We ask The Creator of the Heavens and Earth for untold prosperity and security for Australia 🇦🇺 👍🏾 😎
Extremism, links with terror groups, radicalism --- those are the crimes they are accused with
@Carissa Wu sheesh not wanting to die is so extremist.
What should be noted is that as Xinjiang has lots of resources, and it is an autonomous region in China. It is also the place where America funds terrorist groups, mostly Islamic fundamentalists. This is why China has put up such an extensive security apparatus there, to avoid getting mcnuked by angry American funded Islamists. These centers are there to "re-educate", not unlike the ones in Sweden teaching Middle Eastern immigrants how to respect women in this society because cases of rape rose when they moved to Sweden. It's all security measures taken to stop terrorists, a bit like what the US does. What should also be noted is that Islamic fundamentalist nations, such as Saudi Arabia or Iran, don't believe there is a genocide in Xinjiang. As we all know, Saudi Arabia is US aligned, but despite this it does not claim that what China is doing is a genocide. These people return to their communities, still very much Muslim, but now they don't want to create a Taliban-esque nation. The reason why the demographics have shifted is because as the economy grew, Han Chinese people started going to Xinjiang's growing economy to work in new jobs which opened up, which were mostly manufacturing jobs like mining or engineering. This has resulted in a demographic change, but this isn't a replacement, just like how just because immigrants are immigrating to your nation doesn't mean you're being replaced.
China's social credit system also isn't on a national scale, instead it's being tested on a local level by a few local authorities, although they are trying to make it that way, it's not going to happen in the near future. This system mostly targets companies, and was made to address local corruption by companies. The Social credit system also won't result in you getting murdered if you go into the negatives. Rather, your internet will be slowed and you won't be able to fly(these are the punishments for individuals), but this very rarely happens to individuals. At the moment, your score in these certain local areas are only dropped because of serious crimes committed, but you'll be too worried about jail time to care that you have a slower internet, but don't worry, your lawyer will have fast internet to access the documents he needs to help you defend yourself in court!
My view of China is that while it's a more better force than the USA, it still does have its flaws. For example, thousands are executed yearly in China, the highest in the world. While it has a relatively low prison population, (even when adding everyone in the re-education centers onto the list), this doesn't excuse China having 46 different crimes punishable by death. It also doesn't excuse China cracking down on trans people(what China calls feminine boys), trying to stomp out their voices. It also doesn't excuse China having "White Monkeys" do jigs, just like Black people who were locked up in human zoos in America. It doesn't excuse the child labour, or the slavery problem. While China is on the clear on race and religion, and mostly clear on sexuality, it is not in the clear in terms of gender. However, there is progress being made. Gay people are starting to get more rights and visibility, and China is alleviating poverty and cracking down on slavery. It even put a cap on how many hours a day a person in China can work(8 hours per day). So in Conclusion, while China is better than the USA, it isn't all sunshine and rainbows
Where is Rahile Dawut? Where are so many other intellectuals? Interview them too.
Correction, its not indonesian police beating local thief, but Indonesian local security beating up local thief,
Chinese propaganda.
Thanks You!! A person with common sense!!
Agreed
I tired posting this on FB. Not only can I not post, fb automatically throws me out of the website.
dirty westerners media platform fb..insta !!! imperialism at its best ! freedom of speech lol
@@basantarai8618 lol but you love this western platform!
Freedom of expression does not apply to private businesses.
I am just laughing and I am also extremely worried about the people who got brainwashed by western media. Shame that they can't go to China and visit some people .
Fake media? th-cam.com/video/2Shla50pRxA/w-d-xo.html
why wont Chinese gov't allow journalist in there?
i am from pakistan ive study in chifeng univeristy of inner mongolia ive traveled many times from china to pakistan by road even 6 times because it was cheaper for me than plane tickets so be honestly i met many ppl in china even uygurs there .i didnt see any kind of brutality there in muslim majority province xinjiang . iwent to urmqi,tulufan,turpan ,kashi and tahskurgan .believe me i love that place its really peaceful ,uygurs historical places are safe there and uygurs ppl are so friendly i recommend every foreigner traveler to visit these places .And dont watch western news channels and FOX news its propaganda against china .ive questrion in USA black ppl has no equal rights so how can they talk about justice all around the world . I am muslim also .