Well it's not thar obvious when there are members who don't understand English. It's nonsense that people must be excluded merely because they can't speak or understand English.
@@1908-u6t oooh vbs neh. hahaha ist part of the remedial actions that eff must pay back vbs money? how many times does eff appear in the report... ? There is nothing special about afrikans yo bloody racist
There are interpreters for all 11 languages, but when there are as many meetings taking place simultaneously as in these past two weeks there aren't always enough of them to go around.
@@yvonnememela918, not sure, but I'd say it's mainly the problem of the budget allocation to Parliament? Priorities and financial constraints and all that, you know... 🙄 And it's not an explanation, it just is what it is.
On a side note, language services should work properly and i do think more whites should speak African languages (in general all mps should study at least two other languages)
EFF is right on this. This is an African parliament in an African country with African people, so it only makes sense for people in there to speak African languages period. We have never heard any European parliament speaking in African language so why should it be different . Hayi bo abantu abakhulume ulimi lwabo. This shouldn't even be a matter of debate . It should be granted finish and klaar.
Afrikaans is also an African language, in fact, there were books written in Afrikaans in South Africa long before any of those other so-called African languages could even write something in their languages. IN FACT, IF WHITE PEOPLE DIDN"T WRITE DOWN THE WORDS OF THOSE LANGUAGES THEY STILL WOULD NOT BE WRITTEN LANGUAGES.
Lol people speak English because all the engineering, maths,geography, arts etc ..those text books are not in xhosa.. so if you want..then just create your own educational system.. and throw English out the door.. but you clearly need it.. so just shut it...small things amuse small minds.. lol the EFF are a bunch of people who are desperate and the malema takes advantage of your desperation..he wants blacks to take white peoples land so he can give it to the Chinese and british..lol I can tell you facts that will make you understand what scum malema is.. he is against whites but he doesnt tell you who his friends are in Britain haha.. and you lot stand at attention..you should be ashamed for been so foolish.
lorraine nkiwane. Then if you really want to be completely African you should abolish all European gadgets, products, clothing, medicines, education etc and only blacks should pay tax. Nobody else. Business with the West should be done in an African language and hopefully they will understand what you want.
What CHAOS YOU ARE A FOOL LIKE THE REST OF THE eff.What good are the eff to their voters if they are constantly thrown out of meetings and paraliment.SHAME YOU WASTED YOUR VOTE
strong up to the EFF Ladies and that Langues issue the African Language must be echoed right across the Continent of Africa. to hell with those White bullies that wanna abolish the African Language, again strong up to the EFF Ladies, keep embracing the African Languages, great job
Haha , which white person are you blaming that on.. it was black people who set up the interpreters.. you living in an "I hate white" world far removed from reality.
@@positiveimagingcompany4515, When white bullies invade Africa, kill people and take away their Land, colonizer, enslaved and force them to speak their Language, after a while what you think gonna happen?????????????????
@@nattypthegeneral2450 The only "Colonizers" left in the world today are the Chinese ( see Tibet ). Independent democracies, who cannot govern themselves are just sitting ducks for China. So you better learn how to speak Mandarin.
It makes me laugh when EFF fighting for there for their rights actually our rights some people see it as chaos we don't see how important role EFF is playing they this country from Zuma and now they still have to do the same with buffalo!
The media continues to paint freedom fighter as Chaotic and disruptive...Theres nothing chaotic about/and the manner the fighters are pleading for our rights. its been over 20+ years since this "rainbow nation" and yet black people who are the majority are not accommodated. Its Wrong!! Please correct the Title of the video admin.
@graham jones Graham, how come white rights take more Priority to black rights? You must remember ANC are puppet they do not fully represent blacks as a whole in South Africa. If they did we wouldn't have all these other counter black parties. Why I say this? ANC does not prioritize black rights they have been romanticizing black people's needs for the past 25 years and engaging in corruption instead. The Eff ladies are handling this with agencies not chaotically.
Sifuna e pheliswe apha e afrika english kwenziwe e referendum ngelenye elwemi esevana ngalo apha south afrika not english not afrikaans.sediniwe zilweme ze colonialism.
They are right because the uneducated can easily follow what parliament is up on, On many occasions. This is a win win actually. Parliament will be useless if the nobles don’t get what they are saying. The other point is the majority of South Africa are these groups who are represented as well. It only makes sense
For the first time, I support honorable Khawula. There is no excuse for lack of translation when parly has a full translation department. The caption is definitely misleading. How is it chaos when our languages are being neglected? And the honorable Khawula, we all know, uses isiZulu.
The apartheid language should never be tolerated in the current parliament. DEMONCRAZY is a slap in the face to the poor oppressed black South Africans.
Hau shaaame poor black south africans what about the poor white, indian and coloured south africans who have become poor through your poor governance and state capture money
This is so misleading... why would you say "causing chaos" when they are raising issues that affect them as representatives? I think its a fair request. I'm proud of these women.
How can the parliment be in short in stuff, yet there are thousands of qualified candidates that need jobs out there. Is the gorvement really focusing on creating jobs or they just preaching for a sake to get votes? This is evident enough that there is a chance of job creation and this is the platform. Pleasae hire people to interprit for all 11 official languages.
In South Africa 2 foreign languages are parliamentary. The other indigenous languages are not even considered. Apartheid parliamentary languages continue to date? Wow!!!
EFF yhink they are talking at home .They dont realise they sre at parliament a place of respect .They wasting time in parliament .All other parties sre not like this .Diguisting and disgraceful😮😮😮😮
@@karaboanswer757 Ah Karabo ... Why not ? First time I see that a party member has to withdraw a comment against a member of the SAME party ! Clearly a MAMPARA ...
Philile Mtetwa. It is childish, toddler mentality. They should be discussing important matters in Parliament like on how to get the country back to being civilized with functional services. Waste of tax payers money.
@Carmen Fox they were demanding that there should be an interpreter since they couldnt hear what the speaker was saying. so i do not see anything wrong with that
There are interpreters for all 11 languages, but when there are as many meetings taking place simultaneously as in these past two weeks there aren't always enough of them to go around.
@@stadleroux the best way to alleviate the challenge of insufficient availability of interpreters is one common language. Because as citizens we demand immediate availability of all 11 languages in all 9 provinces. All official documents must immediately be available in all 11 languages in all 9 provinces. Official signs such as road and office signs in all 11 languages in all 9 provinces.
@@nalankosi, I know that's the policy in some other African countries, but even there practice doesn't always follow theory. There are many people in Namibia, for instance, who still don't understand a word of English. I believe we need a balance between all 11 languages and only English, but it's not an easy target to hit and it won't always be the same target. It could even be a moving target, because language usage is never static. Nationally I believe all 11 languages should be recognised and actively promoted, and they are in Parliament as a rule, but it's not practical or even necessary to have facilities for all 11 in all nine provinces, as not all of them are spoken in all nine provinces. With technology and the right kind of infrastructure the odd person speaking only a language "foreign" to one province could very easily be accommodated by remote linkage to another province where that language is commonly spoken. There's the fourth industrial revolution for you! ;-)
@@stadleroux I believe achieving balance between 11 languages can only happen if everyone speaks all 11 languages. However in situations like SA, 11 languages is a hopeful illusion that often leads to a few languages being dominant (Afrikaans & English) which means nothing has changed from the apartheid regime. In SA we need to agree on 1 business language and people can speak all other languages at home or with their friends.
@@nalankosi, hmmm, no, I was referring to a balance between the unrealistic ideal of all 11 languages being treated absolutely equal everywhere in the country and the expediency, for those who can speak it, and financial sense of only having English as an official language. There are too many people who don't and never will speak English. I can't blame Ms Khawla for not being able to speak English, she probably never had enough exposure to it when growing up. I do blame the politicians for not having the political will to budget for and promote the development of languages. Every year in the debate on the Arts & Culture budget they repeat the same old stories about how important the development of languages is and then nothing happens. Politicians have a lot to say about many things, but in general they don't get a lot done...
What is important is: 1) sincerity 2) work ethic If the ladies have observed both (i.e. not simply being difficult for the sake of it), then their wishes must be respected. Only they will know whether their conscience guides them.
Would you be saying the same thing if everyone at parliament or your work place was speaking in Xhosa And Sotho even though the constitution catered for English... Complaints aren't acted on if the isn't passion or urgency especially in this government ... We have no systems to protect the country against fake news even though it was a problem that was identified ...as a result people on the world stage believe that the is white genocide when the crimes affecting black communities are also starting to affect whites
@@blackeagle5322 as long as one is sincere and has the work ethic (meaning: if you are there collecting a massive salary, and you are fighting for the greater good of our citizens, then you are absolutely right to demand your rights are respected. If you're there to cause chaos despite your +/- R1.2m annual package, with free car and house and subsidised leisure travel, then I believe there is a lack of sincerity and work ethic and one should shut TFU)
@@chambersandson This is about decolonization of our institutions. This women are simply demanding that their languages must be fully recognized .If this ladies had not cause this necessary chaos then they would not have full filled their respective work ethics .They would not have fully grasped the proceedings and consequently not been able to properly represent their constituency.Which is African working class who by the way happen to be excluded linguistically and literally in most government institutions. In-fact this women are voicing out against a relevant and long awaited inequality by means of communication...
@@chambersandsonWhat are you on about? Trying to sound profound? The EFF is making a very simple and reasonable request that doesn't require any explanation.
Facts -there are different people speaking different languages .What do you expect talk afrikaans or English when I may not know the both. Be fair guys
Honourable members - I mean horrible members today in Parliament and in future all meetings in Parliament will be only to discuss the none speaking of Afrikaans in Parliament and not wasting time and tax money on the discussing of what can be done to fix the serious problems of crime, murder, joblessness, failure of health services and other essential necessary services we have to supply for the tax payers in this dumb we created for them in 25 years of glorious reign.
This problem of people wanting to hear the debate in their own language could easily be sorted. Set up a system as in the European Parliament whereby using earphones the members can hear a simultaneous translation into their own language. The Zulu EFF person who has no understanding of the English Language or Afrikaans Language can then easily be facilitated. This parliament wastes an incredible amount of time addressing “points of order” which with some foresight need never arise.
It would seem the problem was more that Afrikaans was specifically catered for, granted it was at the prior request of the Afrikaner cohorts, than it was about not ubderstanding English.
@@michaelkelleher862 would the obvious solution be that Afrikaners relinquish their pursuit of a language that is inextricably a part of a legacy that has disadvantaged and continues to disadvantage the masses,Mr Kelleher? Or is the obvious solution that we enlist several more interpreters at state expense?
@@ofentsejay while I agree with your underlying sentiment, I do hesitate to enforce policy which we should be forced to abandon after a few years of infeasibility. There are far too many African languages in South Africa alone, perhaps if we were to summate the Nguni languages into one cohesive dialect we could, by sheer numbers, force an instantiation of the creation.
![[LIVE] : ONE ลุมพินี 90 | คู่เอก "ก้องไกล vs แอนตาร์"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/VugIvOstzRI/mqdefault.jpg)
This EFF women are right....the parliament should employ people to interpret in all languages...
11 official languages, why English and Afrikaans?
Triple R tv shut white boy
Because of white people
English is the international language of business. it seems obvious
Well it's not thar obvious when there are members who don't understand English. It's nonsense that people must be excluded merely because they can't speak or understand English.
They are not causing chaos this is the truth
EFF... i did not waste my VOTE. im proud...
Proud of what you wasted your time and vote on a bunch of useless rebellious idiots in red. PAY BACK THE MONEY ...VBS BANK
@@1908-u6t oooh vbs neh. hahaha ist part of the remedial actions that eff must pay back vbs money? how many times does eff appear in the report... ? There is nothing special about afrikans yo bloody racist
I’m very proud myself
EFF is 100% correct
Ngiyakthanda maXulu omuhle
We even need a Tsonga language in parliament please
u tiyisile hosi ,hi lava ririmi ra manana
We what selobedu in parliament
@@selloemmanuel4551 yes selobedu
Yes correct❤ even khoisan language XaXe qi qo xu😂 yes
This is not England. English can’t be the number one language in our parliament. Our languages must be promoted. All of them.
Agree 💯
Parliament is the 1st institution in the country that must ensure this right.
There are interpreters for all 11 languages, but when there are as many meetings taking place simultaneously as in these past two weeks there aren't always enough of them to go around.
And you're absolutely right.
@@stadlerouxThen whose problem is that? That's not an excuse and it's a poor explanation.
@@yvonnememela918, not sure, but I'd say it's mainly the problem of the budget allocation to Parliament? Priorities and financial constraints and all that, you know... 🙄 And it's not an explanation, it just is what it is.
Yes, we must take back Africa by communicating in our own languages. I love this. If they do not understand us, leave us alone. IAMME UHURU. 🇯🇲.
Almost 34% unemployment and they are arguing over language. The EFF does not care about SA poor
On a side note, language services should work properly and i do think more whites should speak African languages (in general all mps should study at least two other languages)
I also wanted the opportunity to learn Zulu, but it was never granted in schools.
Try with Google Translate.
Honourable mokwele has made a very good point,
Very valid
This language should have been resolved a long time ago. It's embarrassing that we in Africa but we speak and text In foreign language. Nonsense!
you are texting in english kwawena...lokho kusho ukuthi you have been brainwashed
@@stevembhele3949 ohk mhlekazi, ngiza zama ngelinye ilanga ukunga sebenzisi isingisi umangibhala.
Yet you type in English .
@@joshualange3997 papa usaphaphela neh🙋🏾♀️?
@@bhekisibiluane4030 sorry i dont speak idiot . Please answer in an intelligent language
That's the reason why south africa is in the state is in... because of the ignorance of the lawmakers....
Language barrier is not ignorance. .
Lady Mokwele , you are 1000% correct.
EFF is right on this. This is an African parliament in an African country with African people, so it only makes sense for people in there to speak African languages period. We have never heard any European parliament speaking in African language so why should it be different . Hayi bo abantu abakhulume ulimi lwabo. This shouldn't even be a matter of debate . It should be granted finish and klaar.
Afrikaans is also an African language, in fact, there were books written in Afrikaans in South Africa long before any of those other so-called African languages could even write something in their languages. IN FACT, IF WHITE PEOPLE DIDN"T WRITE DOWN THE WORDS OF THOSE LANGUAGES THEY STILL WOULD NOT BE WRITTEN LANGUAGES.
Lol people speak English because all the engineering, maths,geography, arts etc ..those text books are not in xhosa.. so if you want..then just create your own educational system.. and throw English out the door.. but you clearly need it.. so just shut it...small things amuse small minds.. lol the EFF are a bunch of people who are desperate and the malema takes advantage of your desperation..he wants blacks to take white peoples land so he can give it to the Chinese and british..lol I can tell you facts that will make you understand what scum malema is.. he is against whites but he doesnt tell you who his friends are in Britain haha.. and you lot stand at attention..you should be ashamed for been so foolish.
lorraine nkiwane. Then if you really want to be completely African you should abolish all European gadgets, products, clothing, medicines, education etc and only blacks should pay tax. Nobody else. Business with the West should be done in an African language and hopefully they will understand what you want.
@@MrSweetaz so what you are saying our languages are secondhand languages??such ignorance
@@MrSweetazAfrikaans is not an African language! It is a Germanic language, articulately Dutch. So stop the lies.
Raising some valid points the EFF ladies...
Then you more stupid then them..
@M S They ate the profits
@@nicolenmoonsamy6299 you need rinsed up with a big slap.
The caption is wrong, people when they are speaking truth become chaos 💔💔
Amen to that
That's how whites treat us black Americans when we speak up we thugs creating chaos in Congress.
Hey dear,
How are you today and how's the weather over there
My view as well... the caption is wrong
There is no shortage chairperson, one person can do more than one language, ANC must stop undermining our rights.
Eff will teach this parliament a lot
What CHAOS YOU ARE A FOOL LIKE THE REST OF THE eff.What good are the eff to their voters if they are constantly thrown out of meetings and paraliment.SHAME YOU WASTED YOUR VOTE
This business is not usual.. Legendary line ✊🏾 viva EFF
Mrs khawula is a straight talker straight
Mrs Khawula is a CLANGING CYMBAL JUST AN EMPTY NOISE
strong up to the EFF Ladies and that Langues issue the African Language must be echoed right across the Continent of Africa. to hell with those White bullies that wanna abolish the African Language, again strong up to the EFF Ladies, keep embracing the African Languages, great job
Haha , which white person are you blaming that on.. it was black people who set up the interpreters.. you living in an "I hate white" world far removed from reality.
Who wants to abolish any language ?
@@positiveimagingcompany4515, When white bullies invade Africa, kill people and take away their Land, colonizer, enslaved and force them to speak their Language, after a while what you think gonna happen?????????????????
@@nattypthegeneral2450 The only "Colonizers" left in the world today are the Chinese
( see Tibet ). Independent democracies, who cannot govern themselves are just sitting ducks for China.
So you better learn how to speak Mandarin.
Soon none of you are going to understand nothing. Better start giving Mandarin some attention. What a big joke.
It makes me laugh when EFF fighting for there for their rights actually our rights some people see it as chaos we don't see how important role EFF is playing they this country from Zuma and now they still have to do the same with buffalo!
@graham jones if it wasn't EFF ubaba Ka duduzane and the Gupta's they would still chawing our tax money chief
@@tsokho_shumba You mean the white people's tax money for they are the majority tax payers.
@@juliusmaehlich3138 wa nya if you understand!
..@@tsokho_shumba. It is not a matter whether some one sucks, it is a matter whether someone like you can handle the truth when it is spoken.
'EFF demanding to have the interpreter' would be the fair caption than this... It is really sad.
Malema is so blessed to have this iron ladies, they soldier for us. i made a good vote.
You Dont Even Know What Chaos Mean! Whew!!
Can’t believe this language is still allowed in our country
I am not a fan of politics but today the eff ladies are very correct
Exactly!
Chaos Hee banna who wrote this nonsense, fighting for the right of black people it is called chaos 🤔🤭
Don't mind them
Imagine
This caption was written by a bought sellout. These days when you are fighting for black South Africans, you are labeled as chaotic.
Prisoners of war I’m thankful if y’all fighting for our narrative
💯
All the languages n we demand them👌
Hello dear,
How are you doing today and how's the weather over there
The media continues to paint freedom fighter as Chaotic and disruptive...Theres nothing chaotic about/and the manner the fighters are pleading for our rights. its been over 20+ years since this "rainbow nation" and yet black people who are the majority are not accommodated. Its Wrong!! Please correct the Title of the video admin.
@graham jones Graham, how come white rights take more Priority to black rights?
You must remember ANC are puppet they do not fully represent blacks as a whole in South Africa. If they did we wouldn't have all these other counter black parties.
Why I say this? ANC does not prioritize black rights they have been romanticizing black people's needs for the past 25 years and engaging in corruption instead.
The Eff ladies are handling this with agencies not chaotically.
Shortage of staff but we are sitting at home with diplomas n degrees
And the headline is wrong change it . These ladies are fighting for black right
You want to kill us..😂😂😂
Sifuna e pheliswe apha e afrika english kwenziwe e referendum ngelenye elwemi esevana ngalo apha south afrika not english not afrikaans.sediniwe zilweme ze colonialism.
Your should fix your caption...they are raising serious issues
Eff saying as it is. Articulate to ensure indigenous languages are promoted. Good stuff
We can't continue 🤣🤣🤣 power to the EFF women ✊🏿
More strength to you 🔥✊️
Mxm wena admin, this is not chaos .. these EFF ladies are raising important points
Our beautiful and strong women ✊
CHINESE IS GOING TO EAT THEM ALL UP !!!!!
Who is them? 😂
Deon Gunter. Good for the Chinese.
"Uyaphapha, you are phapharing" hola MamKhawula
They are right because the uneducated can easily follow what parliament is up on,
On many occasions.
This is a win win actually.
Parliament will be useless if the nobles don’t get what they are saying.
The other point is the majority of South Africa are these groups who are represented as well. It only makes sense
For the first time, I support honorable Khawula. There is no excuse for lack of translation when parly has a full translation department. The caption is definitely misleading. How is it chaos when our languages are being neglected? And the honorable Khawula, we all know, uses isiZulu.
Re kopa all the 11 official language.. Re a kopa hle
The poster of this Video doesn't know what chaos mean.
This is shameful. take their salaries and give it to humans that want to work to improving the country's healing and growth
Whoever is the admin of this channel. PLEASE CORRECT YOUR HEADLINE. Those ladies did not disturb!!!!
They are disturbing and disruptive !!!
@@lizstapelberg6803 Are you the admin of this channel?
@@lizstapelberg6803If you don't have anything sensible to say, don't say anything.
"Nize ngama vote abantu la njengoba nifuna iEnglish." ✊✊✊
In this one I fully agree with the eff parliament must recognize our language s
I have never been disappointed by EFF.
After 20+ years, our languages a not represented, kant ANC beyenzan!!!
The apartheid language should never be tolerated in the current parliament.
DEMONCRAZY is a slap in the face to the poor oppressed black South Africans.
Hau shaaame poor black south africans what about the poor white, indian and coloured south africans who have become poor through your poor governance and state capture money
Apartheid language =language of intelligence , prosperity , peace and happiness
FUNNY!!!!!!! CIRCUS!!
This is so misleading... why would you say "causing chaos" when they are raising issues that affect them as representatives? I think its a fair request. I'm proud of these women.
Respect is a two way street to Speaker of Paarliament.
ANC disgusting revolution party yamasimba.🤮🤮🤮🤮
Anc will always stand by white people
They Fucked us up with them kissing European asses, us learning bullshit at school, TV,... Now we are Cowards weak, colonized and still defeated.
Seriously , I hate anc
The ANC is very useless
I'm watching from KENYA. RSA is a great country indeed. God bless Khawula, Malema, and their party EFF. Sometimes you make laugh to tears 🤣😅😂
😂😂😂 MK n EFF will be a very strong forces in our parliament 😂😂😂😂
This is incredibly incredible ,, no words
Lol ai
It's not chaos... it is the Truth...
All language must speak in parliament
You can't say they causing chaos when the chair is trying to marginalize a whole parliamentarian. that is not a joke
How can the parliment be in short in stuff, yet there are thousands of qualified candidates that need jobs out there. Is the gorvement really focusing on creating jobs or they just preaching for a sake to get votes? This is evident enough that there is a chance of job creation and this is the platform. Pleasae hire people to interprit for all 11 official languages.
Hello dear,
How are you doing today and how's the weather over there
Mokwele✊✊
Mama Makhawula😍😍😍...
Hello dear,
How are you doing today and how's the weather over there
In South Africa 2 foreign languages are parliamentary. The other indigenous languages are not even considered. Apartheid parliamentary languages continue to date? Wow!!!
True to the core Josephine
EFF yhink they are talking at home .They dont realise they sre at parliament a place of respect .They wasting time in parliament .All other parties sre not like this .Diguisting and disgraceful😮😮😮😮
"Ngok'khulu ukuhlonipha.......njengomuntu ozihloniphelayo sdalwa"
sthandwa not sdalwa..sdalwa cant be parliamentary
@@jethrowmathekela4388"S'dalwa" (by nature)...
LOL ! 3:33 ... Just LOVE how Mampara Mokwele is owning her own party member ... Hilarious !
@@karaboanswer757 Ah Karabo ... Why not ? First time I see that a party member has to withdraw a comment against a member of the SAME party ! Clearly a MAMPARA ...
MaKhawula is back 💃💃💃💃
EFF ALL MEMBERS ARE GENIUS ,THEY ARE NOT IN PARLIAMENT TO TAKE NOTES
I just love when Mam'Khahula is speaking in that language 😂😂❤
Can not call them ladies..hooligans yes!!!???😂
there is nothing 'chaotic' lana hau they are enforcing their right to language as guaranteed in the Constitution.
Philile Mtetwa. It is childish, toddler mentality. They should be discussing important matters in Parliament like on how to get the country back to being civilized with functional services. Waste of tax payers money.
@Carmen Fox they were demanding that there should be an interpreter since they couldnt hear what the speaker was saying. so i do not see anything wrong with that
@@juliusmaehlich3138 I agree with you entirely. But they just wanted to hear what the speaker was saying so thst they can work as well
I SALUTE basadi ba👊👊👊👊
Hello dear,
How are you doing today and how's the weather over there
What have I done???250 MB is wasted
Good point Mam'Khawula! How about 11 official languages? Does 11 official languages =English & Afrikaans? In SA we should just go English
There are interpreters for all 11 languages, but when there are as many meetings taking place simultaneously as in these past two weeks there aren't always enough of them to go around.
@@stadleroux the best way to alleviate the challenge of insufficient availability of interpreters is one common language. Because as citizens we demand immediate availability of all 11 languages in all 9 provinces. All official documents must immediately be available in all 11 languages in all 9 provinces. Official signs such as road and office signs in all 11 languages in all 9 provinces.
@@nalankosi, I know that's the policy in some other African countries, but even there practice doesn't always follow theory. There are many people in Namibia, for instance, who still don't understand a word of English.
I believe we need a balance between all 11 languages and only English, but it's not an easy target to hit and it won't always be the same target. It could even be a moving target, because language usage is never static. Nationally I believe all 11 languages should be recognised and actively promoted, and they are in Parliament as a rule, but it's not practical or even necessary to have facilities for all 11 in all nine provinces, as not all of them are spoken in all nine provinces.
With technology and the right kind of infrastructure the odd person speaking only a language "foreign" to one province could very easily be accommodated by remote linkage to another province where that language is commonly spoken. There's the fourth industrial revolution for you! ;-)
@@stadleroux I believe achieving balance between 11 languages can only happen if everyone speaks all 11 languages. However in situations like SA, 11 languages is a hopeful illusion that often leads to a few languages being dominant (Afrikaans & English) which means nothing has changed from the apartheid regime. In SA we need to agree on 1 business language and people can speak all other languages at home or with their friends.
@@nalankosi, hmmm, no, I was referring to a balance between the unrealistic ideal of all 11 languages being treated absolutely equal everywhere in the country and the expediency, for those who can speak it, and financial sense of only having English as an official language. There are too many people who don't and never will speak English. I can't blame Ms Khawla for not being able to speak English, she probably never had enough exposure to it when growing up.
I do blame the politicians for not having the political will to budget for and promote the development of languages. Every year in the debate on the Arts & Culture budget they repeat the same old stories about how important the development of languages is and then nothing happens. Politicians have a lot to say about many things, but in general they don't get a lot done...
Only fools undermine EFF intelligence
VIVA EFF, VIVA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿✊🏿
Sifuna isixhosa😂🤣🤣👏👏
Ugogo wakho umshiye kowenu😂😂😂😂😂
Ndingenemnyango😂😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣 Mamu khawula kodwa. Abelungu abamnyama pho.
BLACK IS BLACK I WANT MY BABY BACK
This English of yours 😁
What is important is:
1) sincerity
2) work ethic
If the ladies have observed both (i.e. not simply being difficult for the sake of it), then their wishes must be respected. Only they will know whether their conscience guides them.
Would you be saying the same thing if everyone at parliament or your work place was speaking in Xhosa And Sotho even though the constitution catered for English... Complaints aren't acted on if the isn't passion or urgency especially in this government ... We have no systems to protect the country against fake news even though it was a problem that was identified ...as a result people on the world stage believe that the is white genocide when the crimes affecting black communities are also starting to affect whites
@@blackeagle5322 as long as one is sincere and has the work ethic (meaning: if you are there collecting a massive salary, and you are fighting for the greater good of our citizens, then you are absolutely right to demand your rights are respected. If you're there to cause chaos despite your +/- R1.2m annual package, with free car and house and subsidised leisure travel, then I believe there is a lack of sincerity and work ethic and one should shut TFU)
@@chambersandson This is about decolonization of our institutions. This women are simply demanding that their languages must be fully recognized .If this ladies had not cause this necessary chaos then they would not have full filled their respective work ethics .They would not have fully grasped the proceedings and consequently not been able to properly represent their constituency.Which is African working class who by the way happen to be excluded linguistically and literally in most government institutions. In-fact this women are voicing out against a relevant and long awaited inequality by means of communication...
@@mzwakhengubeni8693 I am aware of the points you have raised and we are in agreement.
@@chambersandsonWhat are you on about? Trying to sound profound? The EFF is making a very simple and reasonable request that doesn't require any explanation.
Facts -there are different people speaking different languages .What do you expect talk afrikaans or English when I may not know the both. Be fair guys
Unbelievable what a shame
It's a shame because a black woman demand her language
Omg fighting about language instead of concentrating on real life issues
Honourable member, order, order, honourable member, order, order....is this for real?
Yes she wants her right to be translated in Isizulu.
Honourable members - I mean horrible members today in Parliament and in future all meetings in Parliament will be only to discuss the none speaking of Afrikaans in Parliament and not wasting time and tax money on the discussing of what can be done to fix the serious problems of crime, murder, joblessness, failure of health services and other essential necessary services we have to supply for the tax payers in this dumb we created for them in 25 years of glorious reign.
This is not chaos the EFF is telling the truth
Big up to eff. They speak facts
Your caption is problematic, chief.
Thanks for saying that
Washa mama khawula ngiyabonga ngoba usekhona up EFF
I lv this party eff
It's a big shame for our S.A..forward EFF asijiki
This problem of people wanting to hear the debate in their own language could easily be sorted. Set up a system as in the European Parliament whereby using earphones the members can hear a simultaneous translation into their own language. The Zulu EFF person who has no understanding of the English Language or Afrikaans Language can then easily be facilitated. This parliament wastes an incredible amount of time addressing “points of order” which with some foresight need never arise.
It would seem the problem was more that Afrikaans was specifically catered for, granted it was at the prior request of the Afrikaner cohorts, than it was about not ubderstanding English.
@@shafiyaalgiquadra1105 whatever the reason is. Translation issue must be fixed and it isnt something that should be discussed
CaRa Raah yes but the problem has an obvious solution. South Africa is brilliant at articulating problems but falls short on solutions!!!!
@@michaelkelleher862 would the obvious solution be that Afrikaners relinquish their pursuit of a language that is inextricably a part of a legacy that has disadvantaged and continues to disadvantage the masses,Mr Kelleher? Or is the obvious solution that we enlist several more interpreters at state expense?
@@ofentsejay while I agree with your underlying sentiment, I do hesitate to enforce policy which we should be forced to abandon after a few years of infeasibility.
There are far too many African languages in South Africa alone, perhaps if we were to summate the Nguni languages into one cohesive dialect we could, by sheer numbers, force an instantiation of the creation.
😂😂😂😂😂😂I love EFF
Honorable Sonti😂😂
Go get em EFF and I don't regret voting for EFF.