I think for the sake of people who watch these videos to learn which perks they want to use, they are going to be limited on what they have to use. So I think maybe the opposite of what you are proposing? I think most of the time the perks tofu gets are useless anyways. So if he had a none perk slot I think it would be more beneficial for the learners to see him switching out perks rather than adding more in.
But he gets "none" like every video(atleast it feels that way). So often these feel like masochism series when he gets "litrally" zero use out of the perks. At the very least, I'd accept only trading out "none" for "any"
I watched all the way through and I think the fun of it is the utter randomness of all your perks and add ons and seeing how you adjust and adapt your killing style based off the generation, especially against good survivors
Personally, I don't like the idea of a random killer build having a non-random perk. Maybe that's just me. I like seeing it randomized, as it's more entertaining and interesting that way.
We haven't removed it. We just made a toggle for it so that you can hide it. Also, we're planning to come up with better win conditions that will be actually fun...it's proving difficult though so it will take a while. For now, i'll agree that the only fun environment for one to try and complete a win condition is in a custom match with friends where everyone is using a random build.
I love the random aspect of these videos so I personally think it’s much more entertaining to have you just commit to the build that the website generates for you. It’s still super fun and enjoyable to watch even when the random perks don’t go great together, because it’s interesting to see how the game goes when you truly have no control over the build. That’s just my opinion, love all your content Tofu!!!
@@michi3375 I mean, it's all a matter of opinion but I agree with Luke here; I find it more fun to watch Tofu use random builds and perks than him being able to have a white flag to wave twice each video, you know what I'm saying?
To answer the question, if you care mostly about the random aspect of the series then you don't want to change any of the randomly generated perks or addons just to make it usable because that's the point of a random run is to rely purely on your skill as a player (sometimes) to attempt to win a game with or without the use of good synergetic addons. Now I haven't seen much of this series so I gotta ask if the generator you use has a player's choice option added to the list of options you can end up with. If so then that can be used to give more control over the selections when it pops up. If not you can either choose your own perk when presented with the "no perk" option or you can choose your own perk when you are given a duplicate from the previous game (ex. You get Iron Grasp two games in a row, change Iron grasp to a perk of your choice). The answer really depends on how "random" you expect your videos to be.
I think instead of switching it out for any perk, it would be more interesting if you swapped it out for a killer's perk. For example: If you get doctor, you swap out one perk for monitor and abuse.
I love you Tofu, you have the same thought process about the characters you play in terms of "do they feel awful to play against." Top shelf thought process.
And to answer your question: It's up to you. Like you are really good at trying to find synergy amongst random perks and I think that's good to use as an educational opportunity. HOWEVER, if you have a poop build and swap one thing (or your none slot) to a meta perk, it'll likely become a showcase for that perk. If you do decide to do that, I'd like to see you slot in a non-meta perk to try and glue the build together rather than showcase what's already strong. I like the full random as that's the truth of gambling, right? And controlling 25% of the perks takes a lot of oomph out of the randomness. THAT SAID, I think removing the "none" and "any" options is a solid idea. But again, your content, you do what you think is best for you.
I love the idea of switching up a perk because sometimes you get games where you can't get any value from your perks and then it becomes just a killer with no perks at all. Love your content.
Keeping it fully random feels best for a random killer build series. You could start another series where you do builds for perk combos that you don't use or don't see often that could be interesting
I kinda enjoy the complete randomness of it all. It kinda makes you get value out of some interesting perk combos. But I agree sometimes you’re basically perkless and you already have a whole series on that. Whatever you want Tofu. My heart is yours
Keep it random! Though, I do think that the “None” is kind of boring. Maybe “None” could be treated as an “Any.” Or you could have a poll for the community to decide what perk you have to run next time you get a “None.”
@ohtofu what if to swap out your perk, you must give up a decent addon? If not I don't mind you swapping one out. Can you randomize just three and always choose fourth? Either way
For your question, I think being able to switch to literally anything takes away a lot of the randomness. However, I think you could so something where you are allowed to switch a perk to any of the teachables for the killer you are playing. That would let you have a few more options while still sticking to the random theme.
15:13 through to 16:00 (where I paused) I think I would enjoy hearing you say lively "[insert perk name] VALUE BABY!" and if you've got synergy, then all the more chance to have that come up. Though it is a 'random' perk roulette, so it's a little less random, so maybe restrict it to 1 perk per video, or none should you think it's survivable. Also! Love the content, I watch 90% of everything, just sometimes I don't watch the gameplay reviews because IDK, just not as spirited while talking in some of them. I come for the learning and the personality, not just the game and watching you give survivors the el decko with wraith (who I just said on the spot, no reason)
I like the small chance of a perk you might think isn’t gonna work or synergize with the others then it ends up giving value I love it. Keep it random Brotherrrr
Stick with random but treat the "none" perk slot as though it were an "any perk" slot. Sticking with a random build is fun but just outright losing a perk is boring and doesn't make things more interesting.
I really like the idea of the free choose perk - so you can show us nice synergy things as well. I learn so much by watching this random-perk videos, thanks so much Tofu! ~ Esma
Keep it random but I feel like if the slot says none maybe you can slot in something. Having none pop up always once in this video is kinda boring tbh.
5:02 "The spirit mindgame of 'do nothing and get rewarded'" Ugh, this is going to be a hard video to watch, since even Tofu doesn't seem to understand that the survivor pathed like an idiot. Sure, standing still "forced" him to path like that, but in reality, he could have made it to the shack window, punishing the Spirit for standing still, thus extending the chase. If the Spirit WAS phasing, he still would have made it to the window in time unless the Spirit predicts that he's going to go to shack, which would have been you outplaying them. This is partly why I'm so bad at Spirit and why people think she's braindead: because survivors NEVER call your bluff, even the good ones. Every is stuck in this mentality of "oh, she's standing still. She might be phasing. Guess I can't run away, despite me being in a very good position to". I always predict that survivors would do the smart thing in that situation, and they never do, and instead I get dumbasses who vault into me after I've started phasing. It's my firm belief that people hate spirit just because she makes you use your brain, and no DBD player seems to be able to do that. 8:07 I motherfucking can't, you're right. You didn't deserve that hit. However, she deserved to go down right there. There's a difference between "earning" hits and punishing mistakes, and again, NO ONE SEEMS TO FUCKING UNDERSTAND THIS.
Hey Tofu, about your question. I actually agree. That would be really cool, especially when it gives you a no perk option. I almost wonder if when you get a no perk perk slot you should keep it to no perk and trade out a perk that it gives you, but that would definitely be interesting! Hope you have a good day! :D
Yes, Tofu, you should be allowed to switch one perk out for synergy. I like seeing alternatives to the usual meta builds. especially when I'm in the mood to spice things up. For example, there was a Furtive Chase build for Myers that Otz used which was honestly a blast for me to use, even though I typically don't play Myers. Outside the occasional jump scare game, I find him pretty boring and easily defeated. The build was Furtive Chase(Of Course), Nemesis, Dead Man's Switch, and Dark Devotion(Or whatever the plague perk is that hands your terror radius off to the obsession when you smack them). The add-ons were Judith's Journal and the green Mirror Shard.
I think a system kinda like Yahtzee would be lots of fun, so you randomize 4 perks and then you can pick 1 to keep and re-roll the next 3 and then 2 and you’re stuck with the last 1. And your offering and add-ons can be the same way or you can just keep the ones you get at first.
Definitely like that idea! It does sound cool! Because it doesn’t really seem as cool when you have a build that is just useless (that’s what no perks are for). I might do that idea too! Like the randomised perk wheel is great but perks need help sometimes.
To your question, at first I was gonna be like "nah, it's more fun when the build is completely random". But your reasoning does make a lot of sense, there's not much point in getting certain perks if you're not gonna be able to at least do _something_ with them. So maybe switching out up to one perk would be fine? Or maybe disable the option of generating the "None" perk, which might increase the likelyhood of "Any" showing up?
To answer the question, i'll say this: some sort of compromise is nice. From having seen countless shitty loadouts get generated as i tested for bugs (and so did Alpha for that matter), it feels bad sometimes. Like you'll head into a match and have no chance bcs the randomization gods hate you. Hell, this doesn't feel as punishing now but imagine with MMR on (if it's actually gonna work lmao) So, as a compromise: what my friends and I have done is a second chance rule. You get your first randomization and have the option to randomize again if you don't like the first. We are pairing that with "if you randomize a second time, you HAVE to use the second set" but that may be worse than the first...which has happened. I'd say, for the purpose of keeping the gameplay part fun for you, use this rule but scrap the part about HAVING to use the second randomization if you do choose to ignore the first. So you'd basically get 2 randomizations and choose whichever you like more. Not much of a compromise but i don't want to suggest something that just defies the purpose of the randomizer which is why i disagree with the option to swap out a perk for another "Any" perk that would create synergy. I guess, i'd only agree with that if you pick the perk slot that you'll swap out (if you do end up going forward with a swap) before you actually randomize so that there is some risk of you possibly swapping out the best perk you get.
Good on you Tofu for still posting up vids that are entertaining. I haven't had the motivation to jump on an play these last few days due to this patch..
I like the idea of the guarenteed switch out perk, to make some kind of synergy work. Especially when you get a "none" or "any" perk in the randomizer.
Great video! Regarding your question, I think you should try to commit to the randomness of the perkwheel but, when you have for example "serrated jaws" (addon) and "sloppy butcher" (perk) with no synergy then you can make a change but not as you would like but random again. So when you get dumb shit you roll again. Keep it random! :D
I like the idea of you replacing one of the random perks with one that has better synergy with another perk! Also, love these videos, please keep doing them!
I like the idea of replacing a perk slot, but only if you'd get like 4 dog perks that have 0 synergy. Just to keep the game interesting :) Also, I LOVED the Beginner Trapper video, I super hope you make one for all of the killers. It's good content to watch amd great for newer players joining our community!
To the synergy Question: that doesn’t sound like a bad idea, some perks do require some synergy to work so if you’re down to do it the go ahead Or you can count the “None” perk slot as an “Any” if you want to
Whatever you think would be more fun tofu. What I enjoy the most about it is just how random it is and seeing you make it work. I would prefer you just keep the perks given but I also think you should do what’s more fun for you
Just started watching this particular series of yours, but I definitely think you should be able to swap a perk out or find some method to make it a little more enjoyable for you.. especially if you’re pulling killers/perks that you don’t like lol.. would certainly help you stay interested in keeping these particular videos coming, I’d think!
Having the "None" be the wild card slot sounds good to me. It would also let you build synergy. Now the "bankrupt" idea: if you roll NOED, you get to choose the rest of the perks, but all of them need to be specific to the end game, such as blood warden
About the questiom for switching out the perk, I think that's a fun idea! However, only if you switch up the perks you add, not just adding something like barbeque or whispers (just examples) every game.
Keep stuff random, but allow yourself to re-randomize a *single* perk per video (so one across two builds). And that's not "pick whatever perk you want", the replacement perk still has to be randomized.
I think if you're going to do any kind of perk-swapping after rolling a random, you have to pre-choose a slot that can be changed before the roll. That way you can't just cheese out of swapping a None slot like it's an Any slot.
I think changing should be fine if you require something else. Like undying needs a hex, so if you don’t have a hex, you can get one or switch it out. The none should also prob be filled in with something whether random or chosen :)
personal question. the fake trapping of the pallet is basically the same as standing still in the pallet isnt it? youre showing an animation of one thing while doing something else to get an easy and cheap hit on a survivor who lost a 50/50 on what youre really doing. its just spirits works before the pallet goes down
I like the idea of having the chance to switch out one perk, so long as the new perk is one that is synergistic with another, instead of you just grabbing the best perk for the killer
I like seeing interesting synergies but i don't know if taking away from the randomness is good. The "none" perks are pretty boring though so maybe you could treat them as "any" perks?
Not sure if being able to swap in the random series is something that I would like haha. You could just make a new one for just that idea, of using the entity given and killers own perks.
Changing a perk would be really cool! Plus if you got an empty perk space (Like you did on trapper) you could swap that one to try and get a 4th perk? Just a thought!
I just realized, from the second game where the David killed himself on the basement hook, the hook ui is busted. It’s meant to operate as a hook indicator (letting you know how many people you physically put on a hook) but it just keeps track of hook states, not actual hook counts.
smh didn't say "brutal strength value baby" after kicking all those pallets and doors
Didn't say "Iron Grasp Value Baby!" Either smdh
sweet sweet succulent*
I like the idea of committing to the perks you get, unless you get a "none", then you can pick something that has synergy
This is the best idea, I feel he gets "none" more than any other perk. Probability and statistics are annoyong...
Theres an option in the randomizer to disable "none"
@@zenlavin34 oh... that shit should've been disabled light years ago!
I agree with this. The none slot is annoying.
I think for the sake of people who watch these videos to learn which perks they want to use, they are going to be limited on what they have to use. So I think maybe the opposite of what you are proposing? I think most of the time the perks tofu gets are useless anyways. So if he had a none perk slot I think it would be more beneficial for the learners to see him switching out perks rather than adding more in.
Spirit with NOED.
Tofu: "Welp, looks like no one is having fun today."
NOED? More like no one escapes spirit
Spirit has built in NOED. Its called DC'ing
Keep the perks random. Isn’t there a chance for a “Any Perk” slot showing up just like the “None” shows up?
Yes. He got Any Perk 1 or 2 videos ago in this series
But he gets "none" like every video(atleast it feels that way).
So often these feel like masochism series when he gets "litrally" zero use out of the perks. At the very least, I'd accept only trading out "none" for "any"
There's a big difference, though. The Any Perk slot has potential to be interesting. The None slot is fucking BORING.
I watched all the way through and I think the fun of it is the utter randomness of all your perks and add ons and seeing how you adjust and adapt your killing style based off the generation, especially against good survivors
Ah yes my favorite Spirit counterplay.
*Teabag while standing in the middle of shack*
It's the new meta! Everyone's doing it
I think they thought either 2 things, 1. Spirit is faking again, just teabag in front of them for lulz. 2. Fuck it im dead no matter what.
@@tysongamerful If it was thing number 2 then I have immense respect for the survivor. If it is thing 1, I have respect, but not immense respect.
@@tysongamerful
Yeah regardless it's the only move :P
I dont love the idea of changing the rando build, but I suggest disabling the "none" option.
Tofu: makes trapper guide
Tofu’s the next day: not hitting the guy that got trap teched to apply sloppy
I'm glad I'm not the only one that noticed that lmao
His add-on for the traps already apply hemorrhaging
He had the hemmorhage add on so didnt matter...
You're still missing on Mangled which increases healing time.
@@shreygupta2108 Yes but sloppy also gives mangled and the addon doesn't so he still should have m1'ed.
Personally, I don't like the idea of a random killer build having a non-random perk. Maybe that's just me. I like seeing it randomized, as it's more entertaining and interesting that way.
I love the fact that they removed "Win Condition" from the site.
He doesnt like it
We haven't removed it. We just made a toggle for it so that you can hide it.
Also, we're planning to come up with better win conditions that will be actually fun...it's proving difficult though so it will take a while. For now, i'll agree that the only fun environment for one to try and complete a win condition is in a custom match with friends where everyone is using a random build.
I would definitely say having the "none" possibility be replaced with "any" whenever you get it would be better for synergy.
I love the random aspect of these videos so I personally think it’s much more entertaining to have you just commit to the build that the website generates for you. It’s still super fun and enjoyable to watch even when the random perks don’t go great together, because it’s interesting to see how the game goes when you truly have no control over the build. That’s just my opinion, love all your content Tofu!!!
It’s more entertaining if you stick with the random build no trafing
Is it tho
Is it really
@@michi3375 I mean, it's all a matter of opinion but I agree with Luke here; I find it more fun to watch Tofu use random builds and perks than him being able to have a white flag to wave twice each video, you know what I'm saying?
To answer the question, if you care mostly about the random aspect of the series then you don't want to change any of the randomly generated perks or addons just to make it usable because that's the point of a random run is to rely purely on your skill as a player (sometimes) to attempt to win a game with or without the use of good synergetic addons. Now I haven't seen much of this series so I gotta ask if the generator you use has a player's choice option added to the list of options you can end up with. If so then that can be used to give more control over the selections when it pops up. If not you can either choose your own perk when presented with the "no perk" option or you can choose your own perk when you are given a duplicate from the previous game (ex. You get Iron Grasp two games in a row, change Iron grasp to a perk of your choice). The answer really depends on how "random" you expect your videos to be.
I think instead of switching it out for any perk, it would be more interesting if you swapped it out for a killer's perk.
For example: If you get doctor, you swap out one perk for monitor and abuse.
Check this out Tofu this is pretty cool
This is an awesome idea. It helps out tofu and makes each killer roulette a little more unique
Yeah I like this concept a lot
That’s a great idea!
This is a good idea. Swap out a bad perk for a killer's teachable perk.
That idea you mentioned in between games could be super interesting and a cool way to show off some interesting synergies
I honestly like the randomness I feel like it’s kind of cheating if you trade it out, But it’s your videos we are here to follow.
They didn't make spirit harder they just made sounds worse
This
Yeah so they did indirectly make her harder
@@A52-s5g Doing that they also made all of the other killers equally worse too
@@berrycade not equally, spirit is fully hearing dependend, other just get little benefit.
@@adrianpeikert8677 You are correct that doesn't matter as much considering she is still comparable to a professional nurse
Dont need to kick pallets with spirit? Dude. Have you tried her out on the new gideon yet?
That's just the map
I love you Tofu, you have the same thought process about the characters you play in terms of "do they feel awful to play against."
Top shelf thought process.
And to answer your question: It's up to you. Like you are really good at trying to find synergy amongst random perks and I think that's good to use as an educational opportunity. HOWEVER, if you have a poop build and swap one thing (or your none slot) to a meta perk, it'll likely become a showcase for that perk. If you do decide to do that, I'd like to see you slot in a non-meta perk to try and glue the build together rather than showcase what's already strong.
I like the full random as that's the truth of gambling, right? And controlling 25% of the perks takes a lot of oomph out of the randomness. THAT SAID, I think removing the "none" and "any" options is a solid idea. But again, your content, you do what you think is best for you.
Actually, a "re-randomize" for specifically the "none" could be entertaining.
1st roll:
1) monitor
2) ruin
3) none
4) bbq
Reroll
1) doesnt matter (DM)
2) DM
3) brutal strength
4) DM
Play with:
1) monitot
2) ruin
3) brutal str
4) bbq
Etc.
This is an interesting idea
I love the idea of switching up a perk because sometimes you get games where you can't get any value from your perks and then it becomes just a killer with no perks at all. Love your content.
Keeping it fully random feels best for a random killer build series. You could start another series where you do builds for perk combos that you don't use or don't see often that could be interesting
3:39
Tofu: *I like to talk, I never shut the f**#ck** up*
Me: "oh really? i don't believe you" lol
15:35 in my opinion i would like to see builds that are totally RANDOM that the site gives you, i think that's the fun part of that episodes
I kinda enjoy the complete randomness of it all. It kinda makes you get value out of some interesting perk combos. But I agree sometimes you’re basically perkless and you already have a whole series on that. Whatever you want Tofu. My heart is yours
I blinked here in 17 minutes just for you tofu😉
Oh my gosh its senpai Sally...
God your cringy
👁️👄👁️
@@bradlindsey5049 boo hoo
@@mellomay6425 honesty that wasn't even cringy
Website doesn't work sadly :(
With the two movement add-ons on top of Play With Your Food makes you a *b u l l e t*
Survivors: press E to outplay
Spirit: do nothing to outplay
Keep it random! Though, I do think that the “None” is kind of boring. Maybe “None” could be treated as an “Any.” Or you could have a poll for the community to decide what perk you have to run next time you get a “None.”
@ohtofu what if to swap out your perk, you must give up a decent addon? If not I don't mind you swapping one out. Can you randomize just three and always choose fourth? Either way
Just turn off the “none” slot; the “any” slot would be good for synergy
I like the idea of having 1 perk slot be the "synergy" slot, where you pick a perk that is supposed to support the 3 randoms.
keep it random! now that the masochism series is over this is our only opportunity to enjoy your suffering!
For your question, I think being able to switch to literally anything takes away a lot of the randomness. However, I think you could so something where you are allowed to switch a perk to any of the teachables for the killer you are playing. That would let you have a few more options while still sticking to the random theme.
If you get a “none” perk you should treat it like an “any” perk
15:13 through to 16:00 (where I paused) I think I would enjoy hearing you say lively "[insert perk name] VALUE BABY!" and if you've got synergy, then all the more chance to have that come up. Though it is a 'random' perk roulette, so it's a little less random, so maybe restrict it to 1 perk per video, or none should you think it's survivable.
Also! Love the content, I watch 90% of everything, just sometimes I don't watch the gameplay reviews because IDK, just not as spirited while talking in some of them. I come for the learning and the personality, not just the game and watching you give survivors the el decko with wraith (who I just said on the spot, no reason)
I would still say go full random, i feel like thats the whole point :D
I like the small chance of a perk you might think isn’t gonna work or synergize with the others then it ends up giving value I love it. Keep it random Brotherrrr
I say keep the perks how they show up so it’s truly random :0
I like the idea of being able to change a perk. The fun part of random builds are the unexpected synergies but those rarely happen.
But Tofu didn't hit the David in the trap, so he didn't get the extra sloppy value ;-;
I like the idea of running the build as given. Fun seeing you make them work.
Stick with random but treat the "none" perk slot as though it were an "any perk" slot. Sticking with a random build is fun but just outright losing a perk is boring and doesn't make things more interesting.
I really like the idea of the free choose perk - so you can show us nice synergy things as well. I learn so much by watching this random-perk videos, thanks so much Tofu! ~ Esma
anyone realize they removed the win condition?
They actually didn't remove it. They added an option to hide it.
@@OhTofu ohh haha i thought they removed it
I like the thought of random perks with one for synergy. Like it how it is as well.
Keep it random but I feel like if the slot says none maybe you can slot in something. Having none pop up always once in this video is kinda boring tbh.
Love the synergy idea, that would make the time a lot more fun I'm sure.
Tofu: (gets sloppy)
Also Tofu: SUCCESSFUL BUILD!
5:02
"The spirit mindgame of 'do nothing and get rewarded'"
Ugh, this is going to be a hard video to watch, since even Tofu doesn't seem to understand that the survivor pathed like an idiot. Sure, standing still "forced" him to path like that, but in reality, he could have made it to the shack window, punishing the Spirit for standing still, thus extending the chase. If the Spirit WAS phasing, he still would have made it to the window in time unless the Spirit predicts that he's going to go to shack, which would have been you outplaying them.
This is partly why I'm so bad at Spirit and why people think she's braindead: because survivors NEVER call your bluff, even the good ones. Every is stuck in this mentality of "oh, she's standing still. She might be phasing. Guess I can't run away, despite me being in a very good position to". I always predict that survivors would do the smart thing in that situation, and they never do, and instead I get dumbasses who vault into me after I've started phasing.
It's my firm belief that people hate spirit just because she makes you use your brain, and no DBD player seems to be able to do that.
8:07
I motherfucking can't, you're right. You didn't deserve that hit. However, she deserved to go down right there. There's a difference between "earning" hits and punishing mistakes, and again, NO ONE SEEMS TO FUCKING UNDERSTAND THIS.
Taking one perk and changing it would be super cool because, I like it when you pair two things together to get synergy throughout the game.
Keep them 100% random, trading a perk in removes the random aspect. much love Tofu
Im happy that there is a killer main in the community that feels this way
Hey Tofu, about your question. I actually agree. That would be really cool, especially when it gives you a no perk option. I almost wonder if when you get a no perk perk slot you should keep it to no perk and trade out a perk that it gives you, but that would definitely be interesting! Hope you have a good day! :D
Yes, Tofu, you should be allowed to switch one perk out for synergy. I like seeing alternatives to the usual meta builds. especially when I'm in the mood to spice things up. For example, there was a Furtive Chase build for Myers that Otz used which was honestly a blast for me to use, even though I typically don't play Myers. Outside the occasional jump scare game, I find him pretty boring and easily defeated.
The build was Furtive Chase(Of Course), Nemesis, Dead Man's Switch, and Dark Devotion(Or whatever the plague perk is that hands your terror radius off to the obsession when you smack them). The add-ons were Judith's Journal and the green Mirror Shard.
You gotta love watching Tofu play Spirit. 😄👍👍
I think a system kinda like Yahtzee would be lots of fun, so you randomize 4 perks and then you can pick 1 to keep and re-roll the next 3 and then 2 and you’re stuck with the last 1. And your offering and add-ons can be the same way or you can just keep the ones you get at first.
Definitely like that idea! It does sound cool! Because it doesn’t really seem as cool when you have a build that is just useless (that’s what no perks are for). I might do that idea too! Like the randomised perk wheel is great but perks need help sometimes.
To your question, at first I was gonna be like "nah, it's more fun when the build is completely random". But your reasoning does make a lot of sense, there's not much point in getting certain perks if you're not gonna be able to at least do _something_ with them. So maybe switching out up to one perk would be fine? Or maybe disable the option of generating the "None" perk, which might increase the likelyhood of "Any" showing up?
I like what you're doing now. I like the randomness of getting good perks and bad. Seeing how you play around the bad perks. Etc
To answer the question, i'll say this: some sort of compromise is nice. From having seen countless shitty loadouts get generated as i tested for bugs (and so did Alpha for that matter), it feels bad sometimes. Like you'll head into a match and have no chance bcs the randomization gods hate you. Hell, this doesn't feel as punishing now but imagine with MMR on (if it's actually gonna work lmao)
So, as a compromise: what my friends and I have done is a second chance rule. You get your first randomization and have the option to randomize again if you don't like the first. We are pairing that with "if you randomize a second time, you HAVE to use the second set" but that may be worse than the first...which has happened. I'd say, for the purpose of keeping the gameplay part fun for you, use this rule but scrap the part about HAVING to use the second randomization if you do choose to ignore the first. So you'd basically get 2 randomizations and choose whichever you like more.
Not much of a compromise but i don't want to suggest something that just defies the purpose of the randomizer which is why i disagree with the option to swap out a perk for another "Any" perk that would create synergy. I guess, i'd only agree with that if you pick the perk slot that you'll swap out (if you do end up going forward with a swap) before you actually randomize so that there is some risk of you possibly swapping out the best perk you get.
Good on you Tofu for still posting up vids that are entertaining. I haven't had the motivation to jump on an play these last few days due to this patch..
I like the idea of the guarenteed switch out perk, to make some kind of synergy work. Especially when you get a "none" or "any" perk in the randomizer.
Great video! Regarding your question, I think you should try to commit to the randomness of the perkwheel but, when you have for example "serrated jaws" (addon) and "sloppy butcher" (perk) with no synergy then you can make a change but not as you would like but random again. So when you get dumb shit you roll again. Keep it random! :D
I like the idea of you replacing one of the random perks with one that has better synergy with another perk! Also, love these videos, please keep doing them!
I like the idea of keeping the perks complete random. But you do whatever you want to do, Tofu.
Hey, i wanna ask. Is whisper still on when theres a hooked survivor? I kinda confuse about it
I like the idea of replacing a perk slot, but only if you'd get like 4 dog perks that have 0 synergy. Just to keep the game interesting :)
Also, I LOVED the Beginner Trapper video, I super hope you make one for all of the killers. It's good content to watch amd great for newer players joining our community!
I like the perk swap idea, plenty of people do the straight up random builds so at minimum you'll be doing something different.
I vote keeping the builds completely random, I enjoy the chaos! This is my favorite series BTW.
To the synergy Question: that doesn’t sound like a bad idea, some perks do require some synergy to work so if you’re down to do it the go ahead
Or you can count the “None” perk slot as an “Any” if you want to
Whatever you think would be more fun tofu. What I enjoy the most about it is just how random it is and seeing you make it work. I would prefer you just keep the perks given but I also think you should do what’s more fun for you
Tofu has so much energy in these vids... I love it
Just started watching this particular series of yours, but I definitely think you should be able to swap a perk out or find some method to make it a little more enjoyable for you.. especially if you’re pulling killers/perks that you don’t like lol.. would certainly help you stay interested in keeping these particular videos coming, I’d think!
Having the "None" be the wild card slot sounds good to me. It would also let you build synergy.
Now the "bankrupt" idea: if you roll NOED, you get to choose the rest of the perks, but all of them need to be specific to the end game, such as blood warden
About the questiom for switching out the perk, I think that's a fun idea! However, only if you switch up the perks you add, not just adding something like barbeque or whispers (just examples) every game.
The perk swap is a very good idea, I like it, I feel like Perks Roulette has a lot of games which is basically perkless killer games.
Im in for the idea of replacing perks to add a little synergy. Perhaps the option for replacement can be the killer's teachable?
I wouldn't mind you switching out one perk. -always here to watch! ✨
Keep stuff random, but allow yourself to re-randomize a *single* perk per video (so one across two builds). And that's not "pick whatever perk you want", the replacement perk still has to be randomized.
Love the Yui teabagging the spirit husk 😂
It’s cool that they brought back vacuum pallets, kinda nostalgic even
I think you have a lot of educational videos on perks, this is nice for some fun!
I think if you're going to do any kind of perk-swapping after rolling a random, you have to pre-choose a slot that can be changed before the roll. That way you can't just cheese out of swapping a None slot like it's an Any slot.
I think changing should be fine if you require something else. Like undying needs a hex, so if you don’t have a hex, you can get one or switch it out. The none should also prob be filled in with something whether random or chosen :)
Almost every survivor agaist spirit : *just nod and smile*
I like the idea of you having the ability to change one of your perks to an any perk, for synergy.
personal question. the fake trapping of the pallet is basically the same as standing still in the pallet isnt it? youre showing an animation of one thing while doing something else to get an easy and cheap hit on a survivor who lost a 50/50 on what youre really doing. its just spirits works before the pallet goes down
The one perk of choice idea sounds like it could spice things up for sure
Hey Tofu, when you want tu pick up a trap and you end up kicking a pallet you can spam space to pick up the trap to avoid trapping yourself
I really like the idea of swapping one perk for synergy. As long as you don't abuse or cheese that rule :) Love the vids :)
i love that idea, it makes it so much more entertaining.
I like the idea of having the chance to switch out one perk, so long as the new perk is one that is synergistic with another, instead of you just grabbing the best perk for the killer
I like seeing interesting synergies but i don't know if taking away from the randomness is good. The "none" perks are pretty boring though so maybe you could treat them as "any" perks?
A "None" perk is part of the randomizer, I feel like adding a perk you want kinda ruins the idea. Love this series btw ♥️
Not sure if being able to swap in the random series is something that I would like haha. You could just make a new one for just that idea, of using the entity given and killers own perks.
Changing a perk would be really cool! Plus if you got an empty perk space (Like you did on trapper) you could swap that one to try and get a 4th perk? Just a thought!
I just realized, from the second game where the David killed himself on the basement hook, the hook ui is busted. It’s meant to operate as a hook indicator (letting you know how many people you physically put on a hook) but it just keeps track of hook states, not actual hook counts.