Eunchae & Garam singing Sour Grapes live
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 พ.ค. 2022
- ; • [MC석 인터뷰] '슈퍼 루키' 르세라...
#CHAEWON #김채원 #SAKURA #사쿠라 #YUNJIN #허윤진 #KAZUHA #카즈하 #GARAM #김가람 #EUNCHAE #홍은채 #LESSERAFIM #르세라핌 #LE_SSERAFIM
© 2022 HYBE & Source Music Show Champion, All Rights Reserved.
![[4K] LE SSERAFIM 르세라핌 'FEARLESS' 뮤직뱅크 1위 앵콜 직캠 (LE SSERAFIM Encore Fancam) │ @MusicBank 220513](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jlpUcv-_O1E/mqdefault.jpg)
![[4K] LE SSERAFIM 르세라핌 'FEARLESS' 뮤직뱅크 1위 앵콜 직캠 (LE SSERAFIM Encore Fancam) │ @MusicBank 220513](/img/tr.png)
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA GF D1 | Summer | แข่งที่ไทย ต้องใส่ให้สุด](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Jkuf7nCS7jI/mqdefault.jpg)
Eunchae is like Bahiyyih, both are having a stable vocal but having a little line.
Is that why there friends ? 🙂
@@twicekpopbeauty7219 there pretty much besties and thats because there both the younger ones
I mean that’s about to change with garam gone💀
and they're besties :))
And their vocal tones are even similar to each other😭
eunchae is really stable and her voice sounds like heart-warming
what does stable mean? kpop fans always use that word i don’t get it i thought it was used to mean someone who is good at singing and dancing at the same time. but i agree her voice is beautiful
her pitch...i mean she improves
@@fearidescent206well she is also stable while dancing
@@fearidescent206 when someone is "stable" while singing, it means their voice doesn't waver, stays on pitch, they don't sound out of breath, etc
@@fearidescent206 basically Stable means constant, you can see how her pitch doesn't go up and down and there's no shakiness
We cant deny garam has a really good voice and she got us in sour grapes and blue flame
"really good voice" she's literally shaking and off-key the whole time it's honestly not worth HYBE doing all those just to keep her for 5 more weeks in the group. Eunchae easily cleared her
@@nickianasan prolly just bc she nervous and intimidated . She a rookie and a minor.
@@no-db6ft And so is eunchae, your point?
@@nickianasan good voice ≠ good skills. she has a nice tone and vocal colour but yea, her pitch isn’t good
@@no-db6ft not the minor card 💀 how is that even connected to the topic? most minors in the kpop industry can do well
garam has such a beautiful and angelic voice. sour grapes is really hers.
She just literally squeeze her throat and you call that angelic voice? Damn i rather hear some devil's voice then.
@@meedddneeeeeezzz1444 Like you can sing better
@@meedddneeeeeezzz1444 hater
@@meedddneeeeeezzz1444 Garam Fan🤭
@@meedddneeeeeezzz1444 facts
Garam and Eunchae have a such unique and beautiful voices
@@Mmiinngb yes she have a great voice
@@imran-ep4up Yeah, I like Garam's and Chaewon's voices so much!
@@Mmiinngb I said I liked *both* Garam’s and Chaewon’s voice
@@Mmiinngb Garams issues don’t affect her talent in anyway she is extremely talented, yes the things she did were wrong, but that doesn’t stop her from being talented.
@@Mmiinngb wtf is wrong with u bringing that up here? he said something made u feel offended ?
I'm here watching this video one year later and I just wonder how many of these people praising Eunchae's vocals are now the same people saying she can't sing... Sad how people just go along with hate trains.
Girl she did sing a pretty simple part nothing super amazing about
@happiness.is.real. my point is that if this same video was released now people would still hate on her even though there's nothing wrong with her vocals. When people hates you no matter how many good things you do, they will only see your mistakes.
@@Dress_up.kat_ lol holding a simple note doesn't make you good at singing esp if being an idol is your job. you have to be GREAT at it
I think they all regressed vocally .. even yunjin had good moments before but now she can't even do well in encore
She's going flat, I don't know what crack are you guys took
garam left the group and took groups vocal stability with her
Nah if Garam stayed they maybe could've get support at coachella 😭🙌💀
she was literally bullied out the group
She's safe
Girl she was in the group for a week😂😂
@@lani746 yeah,but as you can hear her vocals are amazing
She died
Garam would have been such an important vocal part of the group's dynamics... Miss you, queen
right😪
Garam had so much potential. With experience and more practice she could've become one of the best performers of her generation ngl
eunchae is so underrated. her vocals need to be shown more . she deserves more lines omg ???
Ok
@@Lucas-eb6qs ok
unrelated but i love ur pfp:)
@@hi-eb3xc ok
@@Lucas-eb6qs ok
Garam was definitely the visual
OG CENTER,VISUAL
She’s gorgeous
i mean as a fearnot i think all 6 of them are gorgeous visuals
Not when chaewon exists
True.
Garam, you're strong girl!
Real definition of FEARLESS!!
Garam has a nice voice she might have saved the group now i guess
Be serious she sounds more unstable than eunchae
@@thisisboring639 Bro what? She's more stable LOL
@@thisisboring639 umm Idk I just feel like garam did better here....just my opinion 🤗
@@thisisboring639 uh, stop bashing a person's ability esp those who was taken out of opportunity to grow as an idol. you'll never know what garam is capable of.
Wait I don't understand when was sour grapes releases? Because didn't she leave the group?
its ironic how everyone in the comments now are praising garam’s voice here and bashing eunchae but when this was aired and released amidst garam’s issue every one was making fun of garam’s voice saying her voice is cracking and said that eunchae carried instead. i feel so bad for them people just love to jump on hate bandwagons
We can all agree neither are great lol
fr their jobless asses just wanna hate on everyone like girl get a life pls
Came here after hearing their coachella vocals💀
💀💀💀💀💀
I was searching for People after coachella💀
they did pretty good week 2
@@sawjjawl9064The loud ass track was really nice to hide their vocals👍🏼
@@Ratcatcoochits still their voices😹
Garam sounds like an angel
Fallen
@@kpisshine it's giving obsessed 🤭🤭🤭🤭❤️❤️❤️
은채는 못하는 게 뭐지ㅜㅜ
have more lines /joke
@@s4mli lmaooo😭😭😭
은채는 못하는 게 없어요 ㅋㅋㅋ
@@s4mli lmao
@@s4mli NAUUURRR 😭
It’s so interesting seeing the switch up now towards Garam’s vocals now vs back then. She got kicked out and all of a sudden she was an elite vocalist who helped elevate the group. Meanwhile this was what she sounded singing live and it was sub par. Even Eunchae whose vocals y’all drag constantly did better.
People praise her vocal tone.. not her technique. Also think about what was happening with her when she sung this.. was she in a positive, healthy, and comfortable environment and state of mind? No, she was being accused of everything from a bully to a literal sex offender. Not to mention, the constant times where fans blatantly ignored her and such. Do you think she can sing her best when all of this was happening? No.
@@jwoyuriz or she’s just not the vocalist y’all pretend she is.
@@ffion4278 We don’t really know that since she was there for such little time.. This singular video does not determine her vocal abilities.
I see your point, but as a girlgroup stan who always been neutral to this kind of situation, what is better?
Still having a negative opinion towards her based on a false bullying scandal or supporting both equally and complimenting garam's vocal.
People were horrible to her as they did with soojin, but now they can show their support towards a young person who can receive another chance in the industry, so i do not see no wrong.
@@jwoyuriz edited albums don’t determine her vocal abilities either but y’all are convinced she’s the best singer based on that alone.
Garams voice was really stable, so was eunchae but i miss her 🥺
Omg I love Garam's voice sm😭
they should have kept kim garam in le sserafim her voice is very good and the accusations were false!
And Eunchae seems to potentially grow more vocally too if Garam was still in the group. Cause one vocalist more and lesserafim could have some influence or some effort to practice more towards vocals. The line up got really messed-up like a balance got tipped on one side which is dance.
garam and eunchae both have a angelic voice
Yes!!!
¡Yess!
Si pero a Garam la expulsaron
A garam tremendo o tempo todo kkk
@@mev2311 kkkk
Why is nobody tallking about Garam? She's so talented!!! (Eunchae too)
you wrong , in that time everybody talked about Garam, yk
@@milasinfonynot in a good way☠️
@@kami5436 when u looked at the reply..
I think nobody is talking about how talented Eunchae is!! I read like twenty comments, fifteen were about garam
Im gonna talk about Garam [Garam haters just ignore the comment lol..], her voice and Eunchae. Yeah, it may sound shaky and unstable but it probably is because it was on the spot and she had to do it without music or anything. Garam's voice was sang lighter and angelic, whilst Eunchae sang louder. And replying to the comment above me, most garam comments were hate comments, but most people now are talking about eunchae's stable voice. Garam's case doesn't matter, cause she was proven innocent. Anyways, Eunchae had been training for 2 YEARS, whilst Garam only trained for one. So we can tell the difference and prove that practice makes perfect. When Garam sings it just gives off angel vibes, calm and soft. That's why I enjoy her voice. Also, to garam ] eunchae comparing people, they have different voice techniques cause they might sing different styles, so I honestly think both of them are just two different people who shouldn't be compared with each other. For example, BTS and Newjeans [I know its groups but just listen], half would say BTS and the other half Newjeans. You'd say either BTS or Newjeans, some people would say that Newjeans is better at singing and dancing, whilst BTS is better at visuals and raps. [ you can reply and make a statement but not to make a fuss about mine.]
[ DISCLAIMER:
⚠= I don't dislike any of the mentioned names here, I love them all as a multi-group stan sooooo :3]
Garam sings so well.. wow..
I miss garam 😢 I hope she's doing well
Garam :( 💖 love u and miss u girl
You should be a joke dude
@@mshnaz Girl- do ur research
I miss garam CANT WAIT FOR HER ACTRESS DEBUT!
Garaaaam is justttttt amazing my bias
She is not in the group but Don't need to be in it i love her from the beginning
Coming here to check on Eunchae’s actual vocals after her terrible performance at Coachella
She regressed so badly 😭
Sthu twink
@@stantxtstraykidsandseventeen Nah, she has always been flat.
@@1uveriii its true eunchae vocals are not good
I miss hearing garam voice, she has such a good tone
Garam saved herself 😭😭
😭😭
miss u garam🥺💗
who miss garam 😢😢
me ;(
WOOOAHH GARAMS VOICE SOUNDS SO DAMMNN SMOOTHH!!!!! LIKE DAYUMMM~😩😭😭😭😭💘💘💘💗💗💗
가람이와은채 넘 예쁘고 음색 좋아
I love garams voice it's the best I miss her
Makes me wonder how the current group would looks like if she's still in the group.
Probably the same except they would be nowhere near as successful as they are now.
@@ffion4278yeah cuz garam would’ve outshine them
@@isaac-yout4b Not even close considering she is the sole reason they tanked during the fearless era.
Eunchae def killed it !!
Hope in their next comeback Eunchae will have more lines because I can really see a potential in her !!
And she still young so I’m excited for her future
Why did Eunchae get very little lines?!?!?
Ikr why
We dont no
Because originally she wasn't supposed to be in the lineup, they added her last
@@juno1765 eunchae and garam were about to debut in new jeans but hybe add them last to the group
@@salmaoussama7444 wait what ? What are you talking about
eunchae's voice is so pretty aaaaa
OK we gett ittt woooahhh😂 like why yall still sour and hating on Garam?? 😹 likee get ur sour ass outta heree lol 💩💩💩
they lost a legend it sucks that garam has left the group she was like the cherry on top of their songs 😢
The only clip we will ever get of Garam singing sour grapes live!! Sadly it was not the iconic part
Eunchae's voice is just perfect, she deserves way more.
Somehow I miss garamm hope she's doing well
Wish they’ve improved 😢😢 came from after their Coachella…..😢😢
Garam not even in the group no more so what are you yapping about? You don’t even stan those girls so why do you gaf?
@@Yeonkimin_ you have to stan someone to know about their short comings?
@@setuser777 maybe you’re just jobless then cause I won’t watch ppl I don’t care about
@@Yeonkimin_ im jobless cause i hear news circling around on the *world wide web* ?? come on now.
@@setuser777 yes bc this clip is totally news circulating rn 🥴
I miss Garam ❤ she had such a great voice and talent, it was false for what she did. I didnt believe it didn’t even sound like her what a rumour! 😭💔
We miss you, Garam 🫶
Yall hating on garam really show your true colors don't yall??? .
my color is pink
@@porcelain_hearttt Hahahah
@@porcelain_hearttt oh mine's green
garams voice is literally good.. you dont have to support her (even though she was proven innocent 😭) but there's no point in pretending she sucks when she's one of the stronger vocalists of the group
im not pretending, her voice is shaky af despite of her just standing there. Also she's supposed to be stable bc thats the point of training.
@@porcelain_hearttt a little shakiness is common in delicate voices like hers.. not to mention she was just suddenly put on the spot. you sound like you know nothing about singing, 'that's the point of training' okay then how did she debut.. if you ask any other 4th gen idol to sing on the spot i guarantee you 90% of them are going to be shakier than this and definitely won't sound as good. she's 16 and doing fine, give her a break
@@porcelain_hearttt true, training goes to waste.
앵콜 안 보심? 김가람 노래 못하는데
@@Diveandbunnis6369 garam wasn't even that bad in the encore.. eunchae chaewon and kazuha did a lot worse so if u think garam cant sing, they all must be terrible singers to you
GARAM I WILL NEVER FORGET WHAT K-POP STANS DID TO YOU LOVE YOU FOREVER!
garam & eunchaes voice are so calming!
miss garam TT
Same freaking level as the other girls but ya’ll somehow convinced urselves she had such a good voice with her 15 seconds.. goofy. Like not Eunchae having more support in this lil clip 😭
Kim garam saved her ass
u stretching it
Garam is so pretty and she has a pleasant sounding voice/tone
Garam and Eunchae have such honey sweet voices
A year ago but these comments get me mad abt garam. Like she was nervous :/
Nervous!? , She looked hella scared here , no one even clapped for her during the wrong scandals . Such a young idol didn't deserve this type of hate 😢
Fr she looks like she's about to tear up during this.
Garamie please back 💔😞
great job hybe, almost a year ago YOU took a young beautiful innocent girl dream
EUNCHAE CLEARED👏 what an all rounder she is
HELP
@@piraateeboa2288 the other gurl was so off pitch and trying hard with her voice while eunchae sounded like the studio vers
@@bonchaemanchaeBYE saying eunchae can sing is like the most delusional statement ever
@@lasnorche5777she can sing lmao
@@bonchaemanchaegaram ate ;-;
Garam is so beautiful, so is eunchae.
never lol
@@kpisshine Hm? Never what?
@@tangerines5822 their just insecure and hateful 😕
@@sullysubliminal LOL right! Someone's jealous.
Came here to see if netizens still bully Garam. Yup. Kpop fans really are the biggest bullies.
fr
You can say that again, with all the hate towards le Sserafim and hybe groups in general.
My dear garam is go..o..o..o..o..o..o.oooone.😢
I miss u garam ❤
GARAM&EUNCHAE ❤ THE MAKNAEz DUO ✨✨🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻 and their vocals is really amazing
GARAMS VOICE IS SO GOOD. SHES SO PRETTYYYYYYY
Their voices are so calm!
I miss Garam💔
It’s ironic how people calling out her singing voice bcs of her scandal💀💀if there was no scandal people be like “she is rookie” “she was nervous”
Y’all are funny
fr
nah i was garam biased up until she left them group and ik shes innocent but she did not hit a single note, it was very breathy (bad breath control) and her voice was very shaky. its not like this was the one and only time shed ever been on a music show either, shed sang live on tv a few times before filming this so its not like its completely new to her so the nervous thing only makes sense if it was her first or second stage but it wasnt and yeah she was a rookie but eunchae was too and she was SO much more stable and actually hit every note. garam has a pretty voice but she clearly didnt have enough training
@@inimmz eunchae did NOT hit every note 😭 both of them were flat. the breathiness is definitely a stylistic choice though.
garam honey vocals
i miss garam
Garam and eunchae voices are so pretty. Both have stunning visuals. ❤❤
GARAM MISS UUU OMG
Beautiful voices
Eunchae's voice and Garam's voice is heaven
Garam reminds me of jin!
loved their voices
eunchae’s voice
Eunchae sounded so good!!
Eunchae and Garam have such a beautiful voice
GARAM OUR ACE
garams vocals are so soft, i'm literally gonna melt! meanwhile eunchaes vocals, it's so full and stable, i can't get enough of it
Garam's song
if there is no bullying thing with Garam. She will be famous right now like my baby Kahuza.
Kazuha*
if Kazuha is your baby, what kinds of food do you feed her?
@@Bluespirit3434 wut
Garam stood out for me during their debut, too bad the bullying issue came so I'll just move on. Thanks to Kazuha, she's the reason I'm still holding on to their group
@@Bluespirit3434 lmaoo
Most memorable thing ever with garam 🥺
Im gonna talk about Garam [Garam haters just ignore the comment lol..], her voice and Eunchae. Yeah, it may sound shaky and unstable but it probably is because it was on the spot and she had to do it without music or anything. Garam's voice was sang lighter and angelic, whilst Eunchae sang louder. And replying to the comment above me, most garam comments were hate comments, but most people now are talking about eunchae's stable voice. Garam's case doesn't matter, cause she was proven innocent. Anyways, Eunchae had been training for 2 YEARS, whilst Garam only trained for one. So we can tell the difference and prove that practice makes perfect. When Garam sings it just gives off angel vibes, calm and soft. That's why I enjoy her voice. Also, to garam ] eunchae comparing people, they have different voice techniques cause they might sing different styles, so I honestly think both of them are just two different people who shouldn't be compared with each other. For example, BTS and Newjeans [I know its groups but just listen], half would say BTS and the other half Newjeans. You'd say either BTS or Newjeans, some people would say that Newjeans is better at singing and dancing, whilst BTS is better at visuals and raps. [ you can reply and make a statement but not to make a fuss about mine.]
[ DISCLAIMER:
⚠= I don't dislike any of the mentioned names here, I love them all as a multi-group stan sooooo :3]
Garam + Eunchae = PERFECTION ❤❤💖💖💥💥
I miss u Garam 🤍
Garam, Soojin, Jimin...
How many people falsely accused of bullying will have to be kicked out of their groups for netizens to learn to wait evidence from BOTH sides??? If rumors like this happen again with any idol just KEEP YOUR FINGERS TO YOURSELVES FOR GOODNESS SAKE
Sour grapes is kim garams song I miss her so much 🥺
I love so much Eunchae voice, it is sad that she having à little line
After watching this I cannot help but feel bad for Garam. Even though it's not confirmed it's not our right to judge people for their past. If she did that, she's wrong. But then again, her life was ruined over something that could be managed. Like she is 17 that is the sad part of it. As I'm writing this, I hope that she keeps a good mentality with people who are judging her for her actions, yet they are doing the same thing.
this sweet voice of Garam...❤
love them
Garam we miss u baby :c
I missed her😢
Eunchae voice is so beautiful 🥰
ガラムの歌声愛してる
Eunchae’s vocals