*Stats Changes - Update 6.2:* Both guns still deal same damage as each other, but now are a 4-7 shot kill. Ribeyrolles is still superior regarding accuracy and stability over the StG 44, making it more viable for longer ranged combat
@@phipschi4255 I'm not good at recoil control so I prefer weapons with lower RoF and higher accuracy LOL. I have grinded the gold plated skins for Ribeyrolles, MP34, and Bren, which could be the 3 slowest RoF automatic weapons. For MMGs however, I think the higher RoF the better as you are in the stationary position and you need this as an advantage to avoid being killed.
The showdown of the century,Germany vs.France ,the revolutionisation of France vs German famed efficiency.The Gallic rooster vs. the eagle. No referee.
I love the STG44 more. It just looks and sounds better than the Ribs + it's a new weapon in BF V & was/is an iconic weapon in real life. Great video Kris!! GG
@@shawnstro7835 stg44 is assault level 13 unlock. The ribeyrolles you have to go to the main menu, then go to company, and then select assault, click on replace weapon and you’ll see it for sale. For some reason you can’t but the guns in game.
@@chrislee3720 Not entirely... Federov shot the 6.5x55 Japanese. Power wise, that's like a hot 7.62x39 in an AK-47 which 7.62x39 and 7.92x33 Kurz in the STG-44 are pretty similar in ballistics. So in short... game balance purposes, it'd perform roughly the same. If they wanted to distinguish it, make it kind of like the AG-42 in the semi auto category. Slightly more damage than the M1 Carbine and take 1 less bullet at all distances compared to it. So, make it do a hair bit more over the standard AR fare and call it good. BAR on the other hand... yeah that's a lot different. And I hope when they add it to the game they DONT make it an LMG. It was never intended to be used in that role.
I think the stg is more powerful because of raw dps and the weapon is easy enough to control plus has more potential due to a bigger magazine. Im interested how the other two assault rifles come in to play compared to these ones.
That ribeyrolles 1918 was a failed firearm. It went through a 71 round test multiple times and had 63 jams, so no military picked it up. Watch forgotten weapons.
The STg is too wild for me w/out specializations. Didn’t have the patience to level it up. The Rib is smooth from jump. I do play a more sniper style though I haven’t been good at cqc on BFV.
I like the ribeyrolles for certain maps like hamada and aerodrome with long sightlines, though I probably prefer to use the stg on most of the other maps, just love it's versatility
I got the saddest ad on this video. So basically, there's this family eating, but the dad's missing. They say he's upstairs and it's his back again. So the next day, there's this meeting at the dad's work, and they ask where is he. One guy says that it's probably his back again. Finally, the next day, the daughter is walking back from school, and sees a paramedic van. So she runs inside, and sees her brother and mother crying and asks "where's dad". The camera moves to the right, and we see the dead dad being fucking wheeled off into the van. Then, the little girl screams DAD!!!!
Bit of history here... based on how we define an "Assault Rifle" as a rifle with select fire, using an intermediate cartridge, and detachable magazine, the Ribeyrolles IS an Assault Rifle, however the STG-44 without question defined that concept and also definitely influenced the modern design of assault rifles to come. For general play, the Ribeyrolles is my preferred choice for accuracy reasons. However, since the nerf to semi autos I've found the STG-44 to be a lot like it was in the beta.. It's not the super OP god gun it was but it's pretty good now. Up close, the STG-44 is likely to beat the Ribeyrolles but at mid range and long range the Ribeyrolles generally holds an advantage. Of course, slapping the STG-44 in semi auto will solve accuracy issues at range but the Ribeyrolles doesnt need to do that in order to hold on target. So while I prefer the Ribeyrolles in general, I've been using the STG-44 a lot lately.
The only reason why people call the STG the first AR is because it was the first mass produced one. I do agree on your view on the STG44 V Ribey. If im on a close range map i use the STG but slap the Ribey on for longer range maps, because bipod.
@@raptorcell6633 Not the only reason why. It's also because it's the rifle that literally coined the term. However, once the world agreed on what a characteristics a rifle must have to be an Assault Rifle, historically speaking the idea had been done several times prior.
I would say that the gun you should use entirely depends on the range you are shooting people at, the ribeyrolles is better at slightly longer ranges so it’s good for maps such Rotterdam, however the StG shines in closer range combat in maps such as operation underground. Note that you f you have good recoil control or are crouched/prone, the StG can be pretty damn accurate with the right specialisations
Here you go, the sturmgewer is better at closer range and less controllable and the stg is better for further range and its more steady. The sturmgewer is better if your more aggressive and the stg is the best all-rounder. Your welcome
Stg is very versatile, it can still do quite well against people far away, though the ribeyrolles is superior in that respect, I still prefer the stg though for that slightly quicker TTK in closer ranges
0:34 Ribeyrolles was created in 1918 and was used by french but it was expensive but they have use the weapon . Conclusion it's the first assault rifle *.*
@@Scotlandsworstgamer it really just depends on the person and what you would define as an assault rifle and an intermediate cartridge but for the most part people agree that Germans got it right and working first during their failing camapign in Winter Wonderland
It gets on my nerves that they put in a ww1 prototype weapon that's extremely easy to use, the bloody thing has no recoil and is a laser beam, it's completely noob friendly
It's not the first. Federov Avtomat predates the Ribeyrolles. By definition an Assault Rifle is a rifle firing an intermediate cartridge, detachable box magazine, and is select fire. The Federov meets those requirements. While at the time the 6.5x55 Japanese wasnt considered "intermediate" by ballistics, it is. The thing is, how we define an assault rifle however is all based on the features of the STG-44. And it definitely is the father of modern assault rifles as it really showed what the concept could be with better technology. And even the Federov Avtomat wasnt the first... The Winchester 1907 SLR converted to full auto in the form of the 1907 SF would by definition be an Assault Rifle. So tons of rifles out there can be debated about which is the first assault rifle but considered the very way we define what an assault rifle is stems from the STG-44, credit is due.
@@chrislee3720 In a 20 inch barrel its coming out roughly around 2,500 feet per second around 1,800 ft lbs of energy with a 138gr bullet. .30-30 Winchester in a 20 inch barrel with a 130gr bullet is doing around 2,500 fps at 1,800 ft lbs as well. 7.62x39 in a 16.25 inch barrel with a 123gr bullet is doing around 2,400 fps and 1,600 ft lbs. So, while the 6.5x50 Arisaka IS more powerful, it needs a longer barrel to achieve said performance but it's still in that same ball park of other intermediate calibers. The Ribeyrolles from my understanding used a 180gr bullet pushing 1,900 fps. That would put it around 1,440 ft lbs or so. Not much info is out there on it however. So, the 6.5 has that potential to be more powerful, but in general it fits in with the rest of them. As I said before, for game balance purposes I'd make that minor distinction of doing extra damage at range to make up for the similarities. The AG-42 fires the 6.5x55 Swede which is very close in power to the Arisaka round, yet in the game it does a little more damage over the .30 Carbine which on paper is a significantly weaker round pushing a 110gr bullet around 1,900 fps and around 900 ft lbs. But if they buffed the AG-42 to equal the other semi auto rifles it would be too similar to other existing options and it wouldnt serve much a purpose. It already doesnt have much of a use when stacked against the M1 Carbine outside of those super long range shots. I'd hate to see the same fate befall a weapon like the Federov.
Shack he means sturmgewher 1-5 wats actually a volksturmgewher 1-5 and was semi only the full auto didnt see much combat if any and they were awefull weapons to use
![TYPE 2A vs SUOMI KP-31 ~ Battlefield 5 Best Gun? [Battlefield V Weapon Versus] (BF5)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/2ysjQLfH15s/mqdefault.jpg)
![STURMGEWEHR 1-5 vs M1907 SF ~ Battlefield 5 Best Gun? [Battlefield V Weapon Versus] BF5/BFV](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/O7CO9LrnVXI/mqdefault.jpg)
![ZH-29 vs SELBSTLADER 1906 ~ Battlefield 5 Best Gun? [Battlefield V Weapon Versus] BF5/BFV](/img/n.gif)
*Stats Changes - Update 6.2:* Both guns still deal same damage as each other, but now are a 4-7 shot kill. Ribeyrolles is still superior regarding accuracy and stability over the StG 44, making it more viable for longer ranged combat
i realize I am pretty off topic but do anybody know of a good site to stream new series online ?
Ribeyrolles is my favourite in BF1 and still the one in BFV. Detachable Mag, bipod, full-auto, high accurate, acceptable RoF. You got every thing.
Tbh I use the Stg44 over the Ribeyrolles just because it has not enough Rof! But that's my opinion
@@phipschi4255 I'm not good at recoil control so I prefer weapons with lower RoF and higher accuracy LOL. I have grinded the gold plated skins for Ribeyrolles, MP34, and Bren, which could be the 3 slowest RoF automatic weapons. For MMGs however, I think the higher RoF the better as you are in the stationary position and you need this as an advantage to avoid being killed.
I actually hated it in BF1 but love it in BFV go figure
Georg Maringer yeah but you don’t need RoF with bullet damage like that. the Ribeyrolles gives more
Damage
StrikerLeecy126 bren is awefull
The showdown of the century,Germany vs.France ,the revolutionisation of France vs German famed efficiency.The Gallic rooster vs. the eagle.
No referee.
I love the STG44 more. It just looks and sounds better than the Ribs + it's a new weapon in BF V & was/is an iconic weapon in real life. Great video Kris!! GG
It was barely used in WWII.
@@CapFlipGaming what it was used a lot
@@CapFlipGaming it was used in large amounts idk what you're talking about
How do you get those guns? I don’t see them in the assault class.
@@shawnstro7835 stg44 is assault level 13 unlock. The ribeyrolles you have to go to the main menu, then go to company, and then select assault, click on replace weapon and you’ll see it for sale. For some reason you can’t but the guns in game.
Federov Avtomat: Am I a Joke to you?
I mean it's not in the game (yet). But it would peform similar to the ribeyrolles
LOL alike BAR, they're battlerifles
@@chrislee3720 Not entirely... Federov shot the 6.5x55 Japanese. Power wise, that's like a hot 7.62x39 in an AK-47 which 7.62x39 and 7.92x33 Kurz in the STG-44 are pretty similar in ballistics. So in short... game balance purposes, it'd perform roughly the same. If they wanted to distinguish it, make it kind of like the AG-42 in the semi auto category. Slightly more damage than the M1 Carbine and take 1 less bullet at all distances compared to it. So, make it do a hair bit more over the standard AR fare and call it good.
BAR on the other hand... yeah that's a lot different. And I hope when they add it to the game they DONT make it an LMG. It was never intended to be used in that role.
Christopher
The Avtomat is a battle rifle which didn’t use an intermediate cartridge and was issued as a squad support weapon like the BAR
@@teamcastro9187 6.5x50SR IS intermediate. I can give you ballistic charts to prove that too. Just refer to statements above.
StG 44 or Ribeyrolles 1918... Which is your weapon of choice?
KriticalKris Ribeyrolles !
Ribeyrolles is my weapon of choice!
Ribeye rifle is way better
Kolibri
I think the stg is more powerful because of raw dps and the weapon is easy enough to control plus has more potential due to a bigger magazine.
Im interested how the other two assault rifles come in to play compared to these ones.
Fun fact: the Ribeyrolles is the only primary weapon that was in the Assault loadout both in BF1 and BFV.
STG44 all day with Chrome skin
All the STG's recoil problems are solved by use of the single fire mode.
Gun is actually really good if you single tap with it
Sarge_Orbitz Einselfuher?
Ray *Einzelfeuer
Yalishanda Just realized it
It IS bloody op
*M1907 Gang*
*_M1911 Gang_*
*Kolobri Gang*
@@InvAzian *_rage gang_*
*G43 gang*
*welrod gang*
That ribeyrolles 1918 was a failed firearm. It went through a 71 round test multiple times and had 63 jams, so no military picked it up. Watch forgotten weapons.
No wonder it has no recoil, nothing is leaving the barrel
Lol creative licensing its a game not a simulator
The STg is too wild for me w/out specializations. Didn’t have the patience to level it up. The Rib is smooth from jump. I do play a more sniper style though I haven’t been good at cqc on BFV.
You can level any gun up in like an hour or two lol it takes nothing to get to level 4
Just get to level 4 or 3 stg it is so controllable
I like the ribeyrolles for certain maps like hamada and aerodrome with long sightlines, though I probably prefer to use the stg on most of the other maps, just love it's versatility
I got the saddest ad on this video. So basically, there's this family eating, but the dad's missing. They say he's upstairs and it's his back again. So the next day, there's this meeting at the dad's work, and they ask where is he. One guy says that it's probably his back again. Finally, the next day, the daughter is walking back from school, and sees a paramedic van. So she runs inside, and sees her brother and mother crying and asks "where's dad". The camera moves to the right, and we see the dead dad being fucking wheeled off into the van. Then, the little girl screams DAD!!!!
It was a dead dad ad
Oof
What was the add
you should test the PIAT vs the Panzerfaust
WarningGiant the PIAT kinda sucks
BrianHayden 66 it's good agaisnt infantry
WarningGiant but I think of assault as a anti tank kinda class and the PIAT really sucks against tanks
BrianHayden 66 yeah, but it's better on gamemodes like Team Deathmatch and Domination
I was thinking that same thing
Stg by far, no point In a long range auto rifle. Mind as well use a semi auto rifle at that point
Bit of history here... based on how we define an "Assault Rifle" as a rifle with select fire, using an intermediate cartridge, and detachable magazine, the Ribeyrolles IS an Assault Rifle, however the STG-44 without question defined that concept and also definitely influenced the modern design of assault rifles to come.
For general play, the Ribeyrolles is my preferred choice for accuracy reasons. However, since the nerf to semi autos I've found the STG-44 to be a lot like it was in the beta.. It's not the super OP god gun it was but it's pretty good now. Up close, the STG-44 is likely to beat the Ribeyrolles but at mid range and long range the Ribeyrolles generally holds an advantage. Of course, slapping the STG-44 in semi auto will solve accuracy issues at range but the Ribeyrolles doesnt need to do that in order to hold on target.
So while I prefer the Ribeyrolles in general, I've been using the STG-44 a lot lately.
The only reason why people call the STG the first AR is because it was the first mass produced one. I do agree on your view on the STG44 V Ribey. If im on a close range map i use the STG but slap the Ribey on for longer range maps, because bipod.
@@raptorcell6633 Not the only reason why. It's also because it's the rifle that literally coined the term. However, once the world agreed on what a characteristics a rifle must have to be an Assault Rifle, historically speaking the idea had been done several times prior.
Raptor Cell ar dont stand for assualt rifle
I thought the Fedorov Avtomat was the first Assault rifle
not an assault rifle, it was the first battle rifle
I like both. Really hard to choose one. If I had to it would be the stg44 for historical reasons.
yes but I personally use guns for the year they were manafactured(im a really shit sniper tho
Second. So glad you’ve finally made this video
I would say that the gun you should use entirely depends on the range you are shooting people at, the ribeyrolles is better at slightly longer ranges so it’s good for maps such Rotterdam, however the StG shines in closer range combat in maps such as operation underground. Note that you f you have good recoil control or are crouched/prone, the StG can be pretty damn accurate with the right specialisations
Can you do sturmgewer vs stg44
Here you go, the sturmgewer is better at closer range and less controllable and the stg is better for further range and its more steady. The sturmgewer is better if your more aggressive and the stg is the best all-rounder. Your welcome
great straight forward video.
Really nice and clear video 👍 how can you afford so many expensive skins though
The ribe with that 3x scope and bi pod. fucking deadly.
where do you get the muzzle velocity information?
I think reibeyrolles is better but stg44 is so god damn good looking
Stg is better my dude when it is level 4
I need to know the name of the song that starts at about 2mins45 ! I've been looking for it all over the internet and I can't find it
It’s from the bf1 campaign / menu music
Good comparison
My favorite Versus so far, I use these guns all the time
Stg44 Obviously. It looks way better, useful at close and mid-range battles, and also it looks sick with the cinder skin so :p.
I like the Ribeyrolles 1918 more, sure it was in BF1, but I tend to make myself a challenge, it's very effective in cqc too.
good comparison
Stg is very versatile, it can still do quite well against people far away, though the ribeyrolles is superior in that respect, I still prefer the stg though for that slightly quicker TTK in closer ranges
2:07 all guns are deadly
Anybody remember his dying light vids?
I lose about all my up close fights. So I prefer the reb for the accuracy and it’s glorious iron sights
talk about the sights on the videos
Stg44 for cqc ribey for mid long range 🙂
stg is not good close. Storm for close, stg for mid, rib for long
0:34 Ribeyrolles was created in 1918 and was used by french but it was expensive but they have use the weapon . Conclusion it's the first assault rifle *.*
i'd say the StG is the best gun in the game myself.
Was it not the Fedorov Avtomat first AR
@@naruto97kyubi cant really argue with that lol
@@Scotlandsworstgamer it really just depends on the person and what you would define as an assault rifle and an intermediate cartridge but for the most part people agree that Germans got it right and working first during their failing camapign in Winter Wonderland
The reason the stg is considered the first assualt rifle is because its the first assualt rifle to be massed produced
STG with Chrome and Gold looks so beautiful. I play on Ps4 does anybody want to play? I'll add you leave your ID
Comradebignibba
I like both guns - stg has a lower ttk but the rubeyrolles is a laser beam !!
Can we just have 3x scopes for Mp's? 🦍
Or mmg
I use the ribeyrolles all the time, the stg however, not much since the beta
It gets on my nerves that they put in a ww1 prototype weapon that's extremely easy to use, the bloody thing has no recoil and is a laser beam, it's completely noob friendly
Hello young man
Should I get BF5?
Yes
Yes it’s even better than bf1
It's lacking content atm, but definitely underrated, I think it'll be a great game in the future too when more maps come along
It's 50% off on origin rn, so if you play on pc, yes.
Thanks y’all!
Rib eye roll is a bad boy gun, all gold with iron sights 👌
oh and I'm 1st :)
I thought this channel may not be affected by cancer
I stand corrected
Try ou all gold except for the handguard as mint and a chromed stock it's gorgeous xD
I always stand for STG44 for sure.
I like the STG-44 the best
Ribey. More reliable and controllable. It just feels better imo.
Hmm I’ve been playing more with the STG recently, and it might be better. It is filthy.
I love both guns.
Stg 44 made me love bf5 again
Ribeyrolles is the first gun fires intermedium cartridges, but StG is the father of modern gas - operated assault rifles.
It's not the first. Federov Avtomat predates the Ribeyrolles. By definition an Assault Rifle is a rifle firing an intermediate cartridge, detachable box magazine, and is select fire. The Federov meets those requirements. While at the time the 6.5x55 Japanese wasnt considered "intermediate" by ballistics, it is. The thing is, how we define an assault rifle however is all based on the features of the STG-44. And it definitely is the father of modern assault rifles as it really showed what the concept could be with better technology.
And even the Federov Avtomat wasnt the first... The Winchester 1907 SLR converted to full auto in the form of the 1907 SF would by definition be an Assault Rifle. So tons of rifles out there can be debated about which is the first assault rifle but considered the very way we define what an assault rifle is stems from the STG-44, credit is due.
@@Predalien195 Oh, I always thought that 6.5JPN is a full power cartridge thou in true power it's not. Thx for the info anyway.
@@chrislee3720 In a 20 inch barrel its coming out roughly around 2,500 feet per second around 1,800 ft lbs of energy with a 138gr bullet. .30-30 Winchester in a 20 inch barrel with a 130gr bullet is doing around 2,500 fps at 1,800 ft lbs as well. 7.62x39 in a 16.25 inch barrel with a 123gr bullet is doing around 2,400 fps and 1,600 ft lbs.
So, while the 6.5x50 Arisaka IS more powerful, it needs a longer barrel to achieve said performance but it's still in that same ball park of other intermediate calibers. The Ribeyrolles from my understanding used a 180gr bullet pushing 1,900 fps. That would put it around 1,440 ft lbs or so. Not much info is out there on it however.
So, the 6.5 has that potential to be more powerful, but in general it fits in with the rest of them. As I said before, for game balance purposes I'd make that minor distinction of doing extra damage at range to make up for the similarities. The AG-42 fires the 6.5x55 Swede which is very close in power to the Arisaka round, yet in the game it does a little more damage over the .30 Carbine which on paper is a significantly weaker round pushing a 110gr bullet around 1,900 fps and around 900 ft lbs. But if they buffed the AG-42 to equal the other semi auto rifles it would be too similar to other existing options and it wouldnt serve much a purpose. It already doesnt have much of a use when stacked against the M1 Carbine outside of those super long range shots. I'd hate to see the same fate befall a weapon like the Federov.
StG looks cooler thus Stg wins
I would love to play in your squad.
oke cool ! how can u slide like that ?!!
1:18
There's multiple comments that say first 😂
For axis I use the stg44, allies ribeyrolles
Eddie Lombera *when you take the game too seriously *
@@OneSandMan what's the problem? Keeps a nice amount of weapons viable if you use them based on the factions
Hi Krissy boi
What’s worse, Battlefield V or Battlefield 1.
V hands down 1 is very well made imo
BF1
@@akaron5498 BF1 is nowhere near perfect
@@OnTheSpaceShip
Preach
Bf5 i tried to get into this game but it's just not as fun as bf1 but thats just for me
ribyrolles is good gun especially with yellow dot sight
3x way better honestly, still good for close q
The stg in game feels like it fires a lot faster than in real life. I remember shooting one a couple years Ago and it did not fire nearly that fast
Maybe it's the recoil spring gets slackened
A lot of firearms change their rof over years
550 rpm vs the 600 of bfv.
Chris Lee yeah
Nameless King : ~500-600 rounds/min is the rof of the stg44
Mate the biggest question is stg44 or sturmgewerh.
Stg=sturmgewehr
Shack he means sturmgewher 1-5 wats actually a volksturmgewher 1-5 and was semi only the full auto didnt see much combat if any and they were awefull weapons to use
stg 44 is a beast on the mercury map
so is the rib honestly I prefer the stg for mid ranged maps
Both is good
Stg 44 with single shot fire is almost like a Gewhr 43 high damage.
RIBEYROLLES 4 THE WIN!
Stg44
#TeamRibeyrolles1918
Stg 44 Is like ak 47
AK was based off of its design
Ribeyrolles 1918 wins
False stg, in my opinion when its at level 4 its just better in all ways it can kill someone alot faster
Real life stg 44 is like 3 x better in every way
true, why? the ribeyrolles was a fucking prototype
Rib eye steak
Ross Jones I thought I was the only one
Rib gang forever. It’s way more controllable than the sputtery Sturmgewehr.
Stg is better by far
I don't really like both
first
First