Expert Believes New Amelia Earhart Photo Is Not Her
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ก.ค. 2017
- A controversial photo said to show the legendary aviator Amelia Earhart is making headlines around the world, but a leading expert now says that is not the missing pilot. The photo is featured in a forthcoming History Channel documentary, 'Amelia Earhart: The Lost Evidence', which airs Sunday. "This photo is absurd. The claims being made about this photo are irresponsible," Mike Campbell, who is author of 'Amelia Earhart: The Truth At Last', told Inside Edition. #InsideEdition
![CAMPปลิ้น | EP.75[2/2] คุยแบบนี้แล้วจะจบกี่โมงพ่ะย่ะค่ะ!!!](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/N6E8njWH7Zg/mqdefault.jpg)
why is he so offended LMFAO
karla lol I know and the woman looks so uncomfortable interviewing him😂
karla lol he looks like that actor in that movie i dont remember the name but he was the sherif and stayed in this girl kind if frat house like stuff and protected then from some witness protectiin stuff 😂
R Rae I see it, also i like that movie. Tommy Lee Jones (Man of the House) btw
Because it goes against the claims he stated in his book.
ramon in his book he actually says she was captured by the Japanese and didn't crash or became a castaway
guy got all worked up 😲 "no way!" but picture too low resolution to tell for sure however there's is always a possibility.
Tampatec I
he mad now
Welp now I'm sad again😫
The Legendary Wolfpack do not be sad
The Legendary Wolfpack same
Stop playing with my feelings is it her or not please tell me people I've read a million books about her story and so many shows
Natalee Roblox why? Is she related to you or something? What's so important about her faith anyways?
marco guzman no because ive always been upses with her she's a legend
marco guzman she is a legend and she proved that not just men can do things that girls can't do.
Natalee Roblox play roblox with me XD
TheXx1nfinityxX 😒
he said its not amelia, probably because its different from his theory in his book that amelia crash landed on mars lol
blv phn Really that's what his book talks about?!!! Hehe
His book states pretty much the same things the documentary did...He is just refuting that the picture is of AE. and he is right. It was found yesterday to be a pic in a booklet published in 1935 Japan. two years before she disappeared.
@@Uncompletedrecall doc was built in 1936. the photo album was just stamped 1935 by a librarian
@@AL-eu8ro And?
Of course, the History Channel, should've known...
Sad how they don’t appear very reputable anymore.
And the photo has since been debunked. A Japanese researcher found the photo printed in a Japanese book published in 1935, two years before Earhart's flight. So much for the facial recognition experts.
What is the name of this book ?
Well the Japanese really want it known that they captured Amelia and held her prisoner (I'm being facetious) They know the truth but Fred Groener was completely stonewalled when he asked them about Amelia.
It actually wasn't a book. It was a photo album with loose photos in it. So it doesn't debunk anything. Also, something missing from this report...the name of the ship has long been rumored to have been associated with Amelia and you can clearly see the name of the ship and you can see the plane. If I remember correctly, the dock wasn't even built when the "book" claims the photo was taken.
No way to positively identify anyone with their back to the photo. That’s ridiculous.
@@penelopelopez8296 Penelope you're right. But the photo was taken at least two years before she disappeared
*mission failed, we'll get em next time.*
Vendetta Gaming Enh, that doesn't really work here.
SuperSebastian *mission failed, we'll get em next time.*
I'm so watching this on Sunday.
Confused Potato same
Wtf I’m doing the same.....
We know she did amazing things way ahead of her time .I am a 57 year old retired piledriver (male) and to me she is always going to be a hero and pioneer, but we need to honor her by pursuing the truth.
Many people on Saipan saw her being escorted by Japanese soldiers in 1937, and why when American soldiers landed on the island in 1944 did president Roosevelt tell them to look for Amelia Earhart? Why also was Earhart's leather brief case found in a Japanese General safe on Saipan island in 1944?
And now they've found the photo was actually taken in 1935, two years before Amelia even started her around the world flight
*writes one book* trigger starter pack
I agree with the old guy, their is no way to know if that person is a male or female.
Jackson B Yep
Jackson B i think it is a woman i see hips.
Jackson B it could easily be an asian boy or teenager. hard to tell. but the pick of the caucausian male is real. very close to Noonan. i just dont understand how they made it to the Marshall Islands, 1000 miles from Howland. all evidence shows they were pretty much on course for Howland
Jackson B but the hair is tooo long to be a man
Robert Bruce so if the man look like Noonan than it it most likely that Amelia is on that picture since people believes that they survived
why does he sound so mad like he was there 😂 dang
The picture was taking in 1935. Two years before she went missing?
This picture was taken in 1935, 2 years before Earhart's flight, obviously it's not her.
I was questioning how'd they know if it was Amelia on the last video of her. I guess we think alike
Okay, but y does he seem so offended?
Why is this thing bothering everyone
Amar Ahmed Pftt, Muslims.
Confused Potato Pfft edgy emos
Where's the bleach? Coming from where's the bleach.
People love unsolved mysteries.
Confused Potato Just because his name is middle eastern, it doesn't mean that he is muslim. I'm...
Rest In Peace Amelia Earhart:(. We miss you very much! 😞
That pic is too blurry, honestly.
The case for those figures in the photo being Earhart & Noonan, is extremely thin.
And the case for their *not* being Earhart & Noonan, is equally thin.
The claims of "photo experts" cannot change the fact that this photo is so horribly indistinct, that there simply *is* no way to confirm or deny their identification with Earhart & Noonan.
Case at 80 yrs, 8 days: Still open.
Aw c'mon, it has to be her. There's waaaaaay too much evidence for this to be fake.
It is proven that this picture was taken two or three years before she even attempted the flight because it was in a Japanese photo album
The guy got so angry, Chill out dude it was Just a mistake
I think that it is her in the photo ... but we will never really know for sure. It makes me more sad to think that she might have died at the hands of the Japanese, in an internment camp, than if she had died instantly in a plane crash. She, most likely, suffered more in their hands. Amelia Earhart is one of my most beloved heroines. I got my pilot's license because of her. Rest in Peace, Amelia.✈
Jean Louise Finch the photo was taken two years before she disappeared...
Do some real research please. The photo was debunked shortly after its release.
I love how he adamantly says: @0:40 "There's nobody in this picture that even remotely resembles Amelia Earhart ..." REALLY, Bumbo? NO ONE!? Compared to a Japanese Sumo Wrestler ... the figure on the dock looks a helluva lot like Amelia Earhart.
I believe she died in Saipan and not the Marshall Islands like most people believe. There was witnesses describing her, the place where the Japanese threw her belongings like her red handkerchief (which said items were found there), and the fact there was an American man being tugged by the Japanese around the island with her.
Well I can see why he doesn't like it because it takes attention away from his book.
HOW THE HELL DO YOU KNOW?!?! IT'S LITERALLY PIXELS!
Someone sounds... TRIGGERED
It was irresponsible to use the word "authentic" as they did and it struck me so at the time. They should have said "unaltered", and then went back to looking for an original print to attempt to determine (accurately) who/when etc (1935).
I didn't read his book but the History Channel documentary was pretty convincing. Also, being from the region of her death; The stories of the elder generation about seeing her on Saipan is very believable.
Japan controlled the area in question (except Guam), for 30 years (around 1914-1944). At that time, Japan was a very secretive and brutal regime. It is believable that the former assistant director of the FBI and the experts he gathered found Amelia Earhart and Fred Noonan's final resting place.
The book is actually a lot more convincing and the result of years of research.
Apparently that photo was put in a Japanese book years before she even went over there.
The photo is from 35 and she disappeared in 37
That photo convincing as it is is not her because it was taken from a book published in 35
This guy doesn't want people to know the truth
So now they're saying that the picture is from a Japanese book printed 2 years before in 1935. OK fine, what book ? what title? what page ? who is the author ? Shouldn't be that hard to track down ?
Actually this photo was taken in a Japanese book in 1935 two years before she went missing your welcome
I always thought Mike Campbell said she was captured by the Japanese and didn't crash in the sea or was a castaway. Would this photo not prove his point? He wasn't scooped
Absolutely right Paul.
only Two people know what happened her and him that's it's 🤔😢 R.I.P Amelia
That is her. WOW HE SEEMS MAD I WONDER WHY!
he sounds like hes scared of something
how many videos do you upload a week?
help me get 100,000 subscribers good luck on 100k
It's the news... they upload everything
That picture was in a Japanese book in 1935
0:40 - 0:44 where is your proof
It does fit the descriptions of the old witness video.
You can tell that Guy won't even take a second to listen lol. He got all mad
The people that say “everything” in an argument you already lost. You have no facts behind it.
This photo was taken in 1935!
NEWER evidence reveals that travelogue was reprinted with the photo undated and the power lines could only be after 1935. Picture still in play.
Ridiculous.
I agree! If her fuel was low how did she make it to those islands. It doesnt make sense to me.
Yes, the picture may be genuine but it is NOT Amelia !
He literally never showed evidence saying that it was fake just because he wrote a book doesn’t mean he can assume something’s fake...
Eric Youdontneedtoknow photo=real. Amelia Earhart in photo=not real. The picture was debunked months ago.
I don't think it's her. That hair style was very popular, and even men could have shoulders like that.
Why can that guy just have faith instead of acting like he was there and new everything like come on
LOL, he's soooo losing this one.
I have something to say, THAT PICTURE GOT TOOK BEFORE SHE WAS STRANDED THAT PHOTO WAS TOOK IN 1935 NOT 1937
You know you can never be such an expert to just know everything about your "profession "
Amelia was a badass why can't we just except that and respect her for being amazing
you definitely can't tell who is in that picture
Its probably not Amelia Earhart. Wanting it to be Amelia, doesn't it mean it is her.
Wow they're solving this almost 100 year old mystery yet they aren't giving as much effort in the MH370 mystery...
(I still respect that they're solving the older mystery though)
It honestly could have been anyone 🤔.
Well, almost; I'm sure it isn't me.
Jeez dude chill, it's just a photo calm down XD
LOL
Someone didn’t do their research.
if you watch the documentery the expert says that it is likely to be her he didnt say definitively that it was her and fred but said that it was likely that it was them and their plane
Ugh, that dude needs to get a grip. He seems too unbalanced to be the reliable "expert" opinion.
Mike tends towards attack. If he allowed himself to "look", the answers would fall into his lap.
ok, first of all, it's so hard to tell, nobody will ever know, comparing top analysts to an expert on Amelia Earhart.
Nick Ritona: Unless whoever took the photo is still alive.....he / she could confirm when it was taken.
The way she sits slightly crouched?
Guy Harvey - Hey from friends on Riley Street!!!
He isn’t giving the actual evidence like GIVE ME A REASON
You don't need to be an expert to see that the photo is fake !
Coming from "the History Channel" lends it little credence.
Picture printed in Japanese book in 1935. Date of photo unknown, as yet.
I live on and island with so much historical richness. She was impriosoned here in Saipan. There should be some sort of marking in prisoned that she might have left behind.
How can he say "no way"? And why is he so angry?
There is a resemblance to her. The Noonan photo is even more convincing.
I believe it could very well be our true American hero Miss Amelia Earhart and her navigator. Very cool history. If nothing else, it reopens the interest in her life story and will touch young people that may have never heard of her accomplishments. To me, that is awesome.
This photo "may, or may not" be her.
From high school I followed this saga reading all the books. My fascination with her Lockheed led me to my own book (another subject). I feel the dock image has been debunked. Also just wonder how people can explain her calls for help (from the Electra) if she was captured. I ask this respectfully, just trying to see if someone here has some thoughtful insights.
If we look at the small sailing boat on our right as we look at the photo, right in the center of the boat, we can see Bigfoot sitting and playing cards. My point? That's not Bigfoot and that's not Amelia or Fred either. The distress calls were hoaxes, The plane crashed north of Howland Island into the ocean when they ran out of full. Ballard will find the plane or at least the engines there.
She wasn’t captured. She ran out of fuel and crashed into the ocean.
This guy needs to settle down. Dang...just answer the questions. Only a person with something to lose would deny with such vigor. Crazy
Doesn't prove anything
He doesn't want people to stop buying his books that's why he's making these claims
Even if you doubt whether that person is Earhart, there can be much less doubt that the Caucasian man on the left is Noonan and that the ship behind them is the Japanese Navy survey ship Koshu.
Amelia Earhart was only 5' 7", and that's the upper torso of a tall person with a "V" shape and broad shoulders. Compare to the people in the foreground (which should actually make them appear larger).
VANITY, VANITY, VANITY... of the Human Heart's Desire to be the FIRST, and to be FAMOUS or WEALTHY... God had saved Amelia Earhart so many times from air disaster and navigational failure, but she kept on pushing so hard of gambling/risking her own life to break the records of being the FIRST...Gambling desire of all sorts is a VICE, an addiction like drugs, alcohol, and smoking, that once taken and loved, is hard to get rid of...
That was what happened to Amelia Earhart, after breaking the female aviation record after records, she can no longer LEARN how to stop, and acknowledge to herself, enough is enough... She never takes time to see, that God had already given her many SIGNS (Premonitions) that Life has a limit... Facts and Truth of Life...
This photo was completely debunked.
I believe anything is possible.
the picture was snapped in 1935. she was lost in 1937
this isn't her.. this is from a japanese coffee-table book from 1935, 2 years before her disappearance
Lmao being from that part of the world. I believe it's her. No local looks like that
It’s not her this was taking 3 years ago before she was missing
Well the plane has gotta be SOMEWHERE or parts of it... we will find out later
There's always those people that don't believe anything unless it is 100% guaranteed to be true
Doesn't sound as if the guy watched the explanation provided in the documentary. I hear nothing from him about why he doesn't think it's Ms Earhart. The documentary does a pretty good job of establishing an scientific base for their claims about the photo. I agree with the journalist's probing comment that there is professional jealousy going on because he's been scooped.
Wow
It's not that photo was take 3 years earlier and is in a book