Angry Protesters NOT Columbia Students; OUTSIDERS Creating Chaos: Student Journalist
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 27 เม.ย. 2024
- Columbia University student and reporter for the Columbia Spectator Emily Forgash gives first-hand account of what's unfolding on campus grounds as pro-Palestine, pro-Israel protests persist. #protests #columbiauniversity
Originally aired April26, 2024
About Rising:
Rising is a weekday morning show with bipartisan hosts that breaks the mold of morning TV by taking viewers inside the halls of Washington power like never before. The show leans into the day's political cycle with cutting edge analysis from DC insiders who can predict what is going to happen. It also sets the day's political agenda by breaking exclusive news with a team of scoop-driven reporters and demanding answers during interviews with the country's most important political newsmakers.
Follow Rising on social media:
Website: Hill.TV
Facebook: HillTVLive/
Instagram: @HillTVLive
Twitter: @HillTVLive
Basic rules to protesting . No hate speech, vandalism , and violence . Once you cross any of those lines.You've LOST !!!
She was asked: "did you yourself see any violence"? Simple question. Her answer: "uhhhhh, uh...well, uhhhh". We ALL understand. Tak'em to jail and throw away the key.
NOW WE ARE NEGOTIATING WITH TERRORISTS???
I didn't see any Israeli person in a video
Feeling unsafe????? Wow, that's becoming a commonly used excuse to discriminate against someone you don't agree with.
The WOKE need their safe space.
@user-yf6tr2lh1f,
If you're not familiar with 'feeling unsafe' then you are way out of touch to the modern College/University climate.
I'm a Mom of 3 kids, one of who recently graduated.
This whole generation talks about their feelings & how they need "safe spaces"
There are constant discussions about having safe spaces. Unless they go to work in Silicon Valley, which makes sure they have plenty of safe spaces, they're going to have a real shock when they enter the work place.
That's why they call this generation Snowflakes. We're in real trouble when this generation gets older. They are the most entitled generation which has ever existed in the history of the world & it's still not enough. They want to feel victimized.
They are in for a shock. They are not prepared for dealing with the issues of life.
I've tried to toughen my kids up but I don't have much hope for this generation on whole.
Umm.... Like, uh, I totally don't agree with your comment. Therefore you are using violence and, uh, like oppressing me. Censortube is my mommy, so why did she let you into my echo-chamber? The algorithm is supposed to uh, like uh, prevent that 🙄
@@sophiebelle5724 I hope your kids don't ever talk to you ever again
I agree with the suspensions and I think it should go further than that
Tell that to the police that had horrible things said to them when they were just doing their job
Boohoo x
I think the school should think about restraining orders on the ones that are non-students doing this on the campus
What of the genocidal calls against Jews. " River to sea." Etc.. is that accurate?
It is amazing that agitators and aggressor call themselves victims.
If you're not a student, protest outside the campus, as a supplement protest. Learn your laws, and demonstrate peacefully.
💯
Well said!
Except the law says that private entities can control what happens on the campus. They told the crowds to disperse and they havent. That's breaking the law. They are defacing the campus. That's breaking the law.
Your represent Hamas and Quatar, don't give civil rights lessons.
@@alex324ization you're clearly not an American, so don't tell us what to do and think.
It's a shame on US democracy and freedom of speech, I don't believe we can't criticize some countries who are receiving money from American Tax payers
Because, silencing helps them continue to get those funds.
Honestly, its a shame college students spend so much time getting involved in politics yet get into the workforce knowing nothing about how to do their actual job. These kids absolutely have the right to protest, but once a protest blocks anyone from doing their activities they should be arrested.
It seems like they’ve been pretty successfully protesting for months now. So…
@@TheJmac82these are rich kids mostly. They’ll get nepo jobs.
You haven't experience with a war. You heard yourself speak to hate
Permanent criminal records for every protester who stayed when authorities asked people to leave when chaos started to occur.
Camping on private property is very different from a peaceful protest. Some students are not on any side of this and just want to go to their classes.
It's literally peaceful
@@dogblessamerica
You must be watching the Liberal Media (90% which is owned b only 6 corporations)
that keeps you in a Bubble & only shows you selective news so you can be manipulated to think what they want you to.
I'm reminded of the George Floyd protests/riots/looting/vandalism where a reporter from CNN, MSDNC stood in front of the Minneapolis Police station while it burned down & called it a "mostly peaceful" protest.
Then you wonder why trust in the corporate media is at an all time low?
Look up the Church Committees & the CIA Project Mockingbird, then tell me how much you trust the news you're getting.
Agent Provocateurs. Happens every just protest
Yep. I have never been involved in a single large ongoing protest where actual provocateurs and simple troublemakers weren't eventually active.
There is always an excuse. We have to many videos and statements made by both students and professors for this to be true. Secret jewish people are not the ones leading the chants, throwing things at people, pushing people out who they do not like, calling people vile racist names. It wasnt provocateurs who tried to protest at the dean of UC Berkeley's personal backyard, it was students. It wasnt provocateurs who said that the Oct. 7 terror attack on Israel was “awesome” and another who boasted “Yes, I’m with Hamas", no that was two different faculty members of Columbia. That is who is there
@@johnwinchester6934 look at Israeli protests right now in Tel Aviv against Netenyahu, the same exact things going on. Where's that same energy?
@@RoutesRootsEthnographics They are not calling for the same things LOL
@@RoutesRootsEthnographics you also cannot block people from getting to class or places they are trying to go.
What is $300 billion? The amount of free aid your governments give to a very small country far away. Where were our taxes spent?
What's it to you? You're not American.
EXACTLY why United States citizens need to RID OURSELVES of ISRAEL hemorrhaging our money!!!!!
So?
Dont think thats tax money. The US gov creates money from thin air. called QE. and the whole world enjoy inflation.
These students are proof that their generation is not falling for the lies that ours fell for. Bravo to these people. they are protestors not terrorists stop brutally arresting them 😘😘
It's always something to behold that anyone believes the US government/Israel after the Iraq war. They are using the same tactics now. "Support the troops" "Weapons of Mass Destruction".... except now they are calling Americans supporters of terrorism to get their way. Fewer people are buying it this time around.
you’re saying that ppl who terrorize and call themselves Hamas are not terrorists
They have fallen for the anti-Western lies their leftist teachers have been inculcating them with since they were toddlers
Which side of the fence are you on?? The side creating the terror? Or with the students who feel terrorized?
I l9ve them for standing with Palestine and anti war. But I wish they realized this when the plandemic rolled out.
The President needs to speak to the American people & explain the reason for his continued support of the war.
He`ll only lie, it`s a thing for him.
Come on, man. 😂 You know the thing.., 🤣
It's NOT a war. Palestine has a militia that is resisting OCCUPATION. The other party does NOT have a right of self defense as the OCCUPIER. Art.51 of the UN.
@@tiberio1352 Would this be the same Militia that went into Israel and killed 1200 people and kidnapped many others? Appears to me that Israel is justified in it's actions.. and has been overly cautious in ways that other nations (like America..) wouldn't have been.
That is a losing proposition. He only cares about votes and not lives.
If that is the real case--then the independent idiots or useful idiots need to stay home and let the cops take care of it. It took the lives of some innocent idiots to end the college riots in Kent State university in the early 70s.
Refunds should be given since the campus is out of control and they are unable to protect all the students.
You have shown your tremendous courage and perseverance! The world is yours and I’m hoping that the country will be great in the more meaningful way
what violence? no burning buildings and no burning cars. the violence seems to be imaginary and baited.
The propaganda is getting pathetic
Then you haven't been paying attention and you do not know the extent of rights. The campus is private property. That means that the administrator/president of the college dictates who and what is allowed there. People do not have unlimited rights to do whatever they wish any place they want to. The administrator/president of the campus has asked them to remove the encampment, the students have not, so it does not matter if it is harming anyone or not, they are in violation.
There have been physical assaults in these protests. Threats have been made against Jewish students... and Jewish students have been prevented from attending class as a result. So what they are doing is actually violating other people's rights... and the threats are illegal. This much has been highlighted on multiple media outlets... and I've seen it myself in random videos of the protest. It's not propaganda if it's true.
Sure, some of it has taken place off campus... but all of these protests have clearly stated that they stand in solidarity with each other. Not a single one of them have denounced any of the bad things that have happened and that have been said. So they have aligned themselves with each other in that way. Guilty by association is a thing in this case. The chants and the banners... they say a lot more than what they say that they want here.
Ultimately, it is the administration of the school's decision and if the students want to stay there, they will have to comply or possibly face being expelled and removed.
So chanting "from the river to the sea" and death to Israel is not violence? You can't pick and chose when language is and isn't violent.
@@drewskij2175 in 1971 Neturei Karta, an Ultra Orthodox Rabbi organization, proposed the internationalization of Palestine and is described in Jerusalem: The Future of the Holy City for Three Monotheisms, the Religious Jews have been against Zionism and establishment of a Jewish state from the beginning. "from the river to the sea" effectively means freedom for Palestine and its inhabitants. yes, the dismantling of the Zionist state from its inception has been the motivation of both Religions Jews (Satmar and Haredi) and the Palestinians themselves.
@@xx_Joker_xx the students are paying customers and have every right to protest. the threats you refer to are imaginary, the actual physical assault is taking place in Gaza and has taken place in Palestine for the last 75 years.
At the moment the camping students are asked to leave and they do not, they are trespassers. Punished by 6 months in the prison.
Easy solution, other than we have to pay to feed them all.
And then and mmm and than and mmmm
Outside violence from the police
Exactly. Whenever the police come in, there is bound to be violence....from them.
I WOULD THINK SO CALLED STUDENTS WOULD CONSCRATE ON LEARNING AND NOT TRYING TO INFLUENCE THE NEWS. THEYLL HAVE THEIR CHANCE WHEN THEY GROW UP
You’ll be okay Rob.
Now I know where ANTIFA went 😮
who is investigating these idiots and who is funding them
thx dems
Arrest and deport!
Absolutely!
College is such a waste of time, money and brain cells
Brainwashing factory. They are no better than TikTok
Yeah but fun parties and ignorant to life's responsibilities. Most can't get it through their head that college is the easy fun part. Once you graduate and get a real job with responsibilities like having kids, they just revert back to being children complaining work is so unfair.
I think my son who graduated from a state university and graduated to a 6 figure job would beg to differ.
@@dmp1962 that's nice but how much do they still owe and don't tell me you didn't fund him at least partially.
@@dmp1962I suspect some contributors to the comments section have a huge chip on their shoulders.
100% Federal Agents
Why police lost their mensch dealing with these pro terrorist?
Are they FBI agents? Asking for a friend, since we have a pattern of that type of behavior by that organization.
I feel bad for Columbia Students. Especially the smart ones and their parents. Those that are not involved in this lunacy are paying nearly $300,000 for a degree that will rapidly be worth used toilet paper if this continues. Go to college to educate yourself!
Hopefully these encampments don’t inspire Americans to adopt the Palestinian approach to illegal immigration
OUTSIDERS, Profesional Protesrers
Tell that to the one person or student that had their I gouged out
The USA brings democracy to the whole world, but there is no democracy in their own country. In 1968, students demonstrated against the Vietnam War. Today they are heroes. The same will be said about today's students
Amerikkka brings death
Not democracy
Everyone saying Palestinians don't support Hamas, they do and always have. This is why there can't be a Gaza and Israel knows as long as there are Palestinians in Gaza, there can't be peace. Israel is watching what is happening here and all these people are doing is showing Israel what needs to be done.
Great show!
Good content
Shame on those protestors.
Consider how history has remembered mass student protests while you decide what side of history you want to be on.
Let us inscribe penance , for each token of solace has been met with impetuous haste. Cast aside an irrevocable notion of "truth" and personify the illusion of "perception." Are contemptuous , wretched outsiders infiltrating our young minds with toxic indignation? Indubitably! Now what is the solution?
the solution is to support free speech, obviously.
Stop the 75 year long of apartheid regime and stop the genocide.
Many thanks to all students for supporting solidarity with Palestine. We appreciated love and care
Solidarity with the Students !!! Free Palestine !!!
Thank a Swamprat.
President Shafik needs to grow a spine and support her students and professors righ and rise against the geoncide israel is committing in Gaza.
Bravo to the Spirit of Columbia, its students and the future leaders of this country leading US into our destiny now
Enrolled not not need this, such a big canvas
😂😂😂but these Students protect these outsiders hence the Students are responsible for Anarchy
Free GAZA ❤free free free GAZA
Soros laughs at them from his throne in heaven.
The same thing Hamas's saying. The Hamas in Qatar said they never wanted to harm Israelis. It was the freedom fighters' ideas, not them. Palestinians said they weren't Hamas and they were peaceful. It's the same nonsense.
And let's say repeat offenders on a compass what's the usual baseball tournament let's say they get arrested three times for not leaving I think go back day after day and the rest of the third time for the same thing at that college they should be banned from the college they should get no college credit and that should go on their permanent record for the next college to try to go to
It would be helpful if there were protesters and supporters vocalizing the difference between supporting Palestinians and supporting Hamas. Big difference between the two!!!
Yet more proof of the deplorable level of university education! A supposed "journalist" saying "your fellow peers"..and note..I noticed that when English is my second language
English is my first language. I admit I am confused what your issue is. “ Fellow Peers” normal usage.
@3:22 lol
Jewish students making Jewish students feel unsafe. That sounds like a great plot for a comedy series
Charlottesville University.
I'm sorry but the college does have the right to get them removed via Police Markham all under trespassing they do not get bailed they do not get no cash bail
Good
All New Yorkers need to join in!
The Hill, I loved this video so much, I had to hit the like button!
There will be choices to be made….I would say, choose for a real human being!
I admire these students. They are pure without fear. The fact that their opinions are not tied to their paychecks allows them to see things from an unbiased perspective. The fact that these kids read, and their parents don’t is the issue. The media is hoping the fear that many adults have because their livelihood is attached to their paychecks, will persuade the majority. Unfortunately the kids are right, we are supporting a genocide!!’
What india has been facing this for over seven decades, US has started facing now! What you were criticising india for, see what are you doing!!!
Seems pro students.
Um...um...um...
Needs a class on public speaking.
Otherwise she did well.
JNU Style😂😂😂😂😂
Hey Jess signed over your family Realestate to the local trade yet to get decolonization started ????
7:11 This Girl Is Hot and Smart. Nice !!!!!!!!!!!
Umm, umm, umm, umm.
Listen to how she answers closely: 1. She’s been coached
2. She’s not very bright
Universities Divest From Arab Funding!
Its Billions!
I am against our involvement in this conflict, Israel at best is making horrible choices. But the hostages are rarely mentioned by either side. And both sides seem to only further alienate each other. Even freedom of speech isn't a real topic. Camping out in public/private spaces seems to be the topic. All losera, no winners.
if youre still equivocating at this point, you should look into the history, ilan pappe and gabor mate are two jewish people who tell the truth. and bring the receipts
Free Gaza
The hard core struck me as being professional grievance protestors or grievers in training. So many people with matching(!) tents and nothing better to do with their time, across dozens of universities at the same time.
When I was in uni close to exams I only had time to eat, sleep, run and study. Mostly study. But for me an my peers, marks and subject matter knowledge mattered.
Students in Critical [fill in the blank] Studies, Middle Eastern Studies and other trash humanities like Anthropology fit in perfectly. MSA, JVP and NION will be spreading this as far as possible with support from reprehensible "academics" from the above noted humanities. Is ANTIFA jumping on the bandwagon?
You act like going to walmart and buying multiple tents for a event that look identical is like new or something. That like saying oh you know what all those smokers have matching(!) vape pens.
Professinal grievance protestors lol where do you get this stuff 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
i hope you didnt support a genocide back when you were a student the way you do now.
That’s a very long-winded way of saying Gen Z can manage their time and prioritize the important things better than you did 😂
so having career goal of becoming a diplomat or working as staffer for foreign affairs official is a bad thing?
I can tell that this girl in the middle is on the side of the Palestine she has so many facial tics so many ways she's doing stuff with her head the way she's doing stuff with her eyes that tell you this
Where do you come up with that stuff?! Facial tick...and that's your proof of something nefarious. GIVE ME A BREAK!!! 😂😂😂
Thanks to Joe, we are now in a Banana Democracy.
These students are proof that their generation is not falling for the lies that ours fell for. Bravo to these people
Sounds like propagada
“I would say is LARGELY peaceful “ so there was some danger present?
from Israel supporting students deliberately brushing into flags and pretending they had been attacked.
It's not like January 6th,2020!
What website does this chick report for? What’s it called? The observer?
Nice try trying to flip the narrative, don't drive the attention away from Gaza,
Bunch of Jewish outfits e.g.Hilel, all decrying outsiders coming onto campus. All this whilst they themselves were pressurizing University Admin.
Tiring scene
When did encampments become free speech? Most of the conversation seems to be about the protest/encampments and he said/she said and very little about palestinians. The organizers gave up their message for theatrics.
If you notice these smart young people always bring it back around to topic.
The encampments are in solidarity, so it is a form of protest. Just like if you were to boycott something, in solidarity with the oppressed, that is a form of protest. Not all protest is making signs and chanting rhymes.
No the students belong there,
NOT MIKE JOHNSON, students arrested not for trespassing why so? They are students there. Jewish Voices for Peace arrested.
Students get No Due PROCESS
What's with Jessica's new look?
Yes, aside from the fact that she's a great intellect and journalist, and that I find myself always on her side of the debate, I've allowed myself, from time to time, almost unavoidably, to digress and reflect on the peculiar frequency with which she changes her appearance. I mean, this is sort of a trivial, inconsequential reflection in the midst of all this madness, and she is a beautiful woman anyway, in any form, but one cannot help but notice it.
None of these students have no clue why they are protesting? Pick up your books and go learn something.
You're ignorance is clearly demonstrated. Many know exactly what they are protesting about!!! Why does Israel deserve a "homeland" but the Palestinians don't?! Answer that one Know It All!!! You should learn something yourself. Read the, "Balfour Agreement", you too may learn something!!!
@@user-fc6im1fj8f Most or 3/4 are protesting just cause there friends are. Nobody cares.. Everybody deserves a Homeland, Not just you. The Balfour Agreement, don't match the Country boy Agreement. You attack us, We attack back.
You have anymore questions, I'm here to help you.
Making demands and taking over sections of the campus has nothing to do with freedom of speech. Sounds more like children throwing a tantrum. Treat them as such.
I have an idea, why don't we make Colombia University an Islamic university? This will solve all the problems.
Being anti genocide has nothing to do with religion.
The correct answer is. No terrorism exist prior to the 70 years of occupation. Shame to see people like you trying to coverup for the apartheid regime and genocide. Peace
Go students 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 ❤❤❤❤ greetings 🇹🇷🇹🇷🇹🇷❤️🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Help Rafah (did I spell that wrong)
I argue that if any laws are broken it fails to be “peaceful”. Can’t break the law and infringe on others rights in the name of your own rights. Do things the right way. Get permits. Alert the cops of your presence so it’s not a surprise. People act differently when surprised. I know you want to protest and its your right. But what about the right of the entire university to have a safe peaceful place to learn. These things always do more harm than good.
Vote for jill stein, please promote her. Free us from those two monsters. We can do it if we unite behind one
Applauding the police. Who do those ... think they are?
Hallo the students are very young and have no experience to protest about the palestinians
what age do israel conscript people into the army, to police the west bank?
Give back power to the people! These young adults are standing up to oppression. I am very proud of them, they give hope to the future.
Sorry, i couldn't fully listen, this reporter's cold dead eyes sent a shiver down my spine, like immediately after this video she's gonna start feeding on the blood of an innocent....😧
😂 omg 😆
🤣🤣
They all must be arrested!