Proto ASD Ratcheting Spline Combination Wrenches - MADE IN USA
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 28 ก.ย. 2024
- Click here to get the Proto ASD Ratcheting Spline Combination Wrenches at Amazon --- www.amazon.com/...
For many years I have used ratcheting wrenches, and for many years I have had a love/hate relationship with them. They seemed like a great idea when they first came out & after continual issues with earlier designs (by other manufacturers), they became one of those tools "of last resort".
The problems that arise with many of them is the fact that they do not have directional change switches, and to go from loosening to tightening, you literally had to remove the wrench and flip it over. Easy as that may sound, it is impossible in many cases when there is no clearance to remove the tool (i.e. - tensioner/idler pulleys next to the frame) & what was going to be a 5 minute repair, ends up taking an hour since you got the wrench stuck!
The other big issue I have with other varieties is the fact that many of them are completely flat with no offset on the box end (to accommodate the fact you need to flip the wrench) & you end up scraping your fingers/hands/knuckles on things while working on a car.
Proto has eliminated the issues that I previously have had with ratcheting wrenches, and finally I have a set that I enjoy using! They have the directional switch not only built-in, but also recessed....that way it is not catching on your thumb or anything else while you use it & it wont accidentally switch directions on you.
They gave the boxed end a 15 degree offset from the handle & that allows you to freely move the wrench without "busting your knuckles".
And another huge plus, is the fact that they are "long pattern" aka much longer than standard wrenches & it allows you to gain a lot of additional leverage, and helps break loose stubborn bolts/nuts with a lot less effort.
The sets come in 4 varieties :
JSCV-11SA (SAE - 1/4" - 3/4")
JSCV-18SA (SAE - 1/4" - 1 1/4")
JSCVM-14SA (Metric - 6mm - 19mm)
JSCVM-20SA (Metric - 6mm - 32mm)
Check out the video to see all the features of the Proto ASD Ratcheting Wrenches for yourself!
:)
These wrenches are very aesthetically pleasing. They remind me of the old I-Beam Snap-on. Mac has these same wrenches, of course they are the same parent company as Mac.
BrenticusMaximus1 Yeah the Mac versions are very similar.....I am not sure if they are "the same", but it wouldnt surprise me. You are correct, they are both owned by SBD (Stanley Black & Decker).
You should do a comparison between the Proto ASD and the Wright Grip combination wrenches with the mandrel bolt shearing test.
Marcus Gibons I dont have one in that size....if I get one I will keep that in mind though...thanks!
@@RealToolReviews would be very interested to see that
Those proto wrenches look identical to the MAC Precision Torque Wrenches. I wonder how they differ in price. Almost all of my tools are Matco but I had to have the Mac Precision Torque Wrenches because of the look and fell. Awesome!
Cody Robertson They probably have a very similar design, since both are owned by SBD (Stanley Black & Decker). I have not used the MAC versions though.
They're branded Facom in UK and Europe and proto is owned by Stanley
Will the proto ASD open end break the grade 8 bolt?
This wrench is very similar to Dewalt ratcheting wrenches. I guess Stanley B&D brought Proto design into Dewalt mechanical wrench set.
Mac wrenches are same as well. Mac OWNES Proto and Dewalt.
@@tatoler38 Stanley owns them all
God those are gorgeous.
Did you just call me “those”?
My wife said you should make videos of vegetables. Since I buy most of what you show maybe you would be the person who can convince me to eat better.
Mitsu Busa I told my wife what you wrote & she replied "Tell him that wont work....the only way I get him (me) to eat vegetables is to cover them with cheese" :)
quality demo thanks
Beautiful, well-made wrenches; wish I could afford them (currently, SAE is $250; the metric set is $350, both on Amazon). They may be available for less through another distributor. I bought the next-step-down sets offered by Proto (which are made in Taiwan, are also polished and have conventional 12-pt. ratchet ends).
I wish I was a tech 4 Years ago, master sets are around 1k now and hard to find
Nice set, kudos to proto
Made in USA is becoming a thing of the past. American companies need to wake up to foreign competition
And change some of the ways they do
Business think out of the box
Before they slowly get forced out
Proto and Mac Tools are divisions of Stanley Works.
Fast forward almost 3 years, how are these wrenches holding up? Do you use them often? The price on them has come down significantly so I'm thinking about pulling the trigger on the 14 piece metric set as a birthday gift to myself this year. Thanks!
Fast forward almost 3 years, did you actually pull the trigger on the 14 piece set? Do you use them often? How are these wrenches holding up? Thanks!
@@svtrader lol
at about 6:59 right before you got the wrench on the nut you edited something out and started the clip when the wrench was on the nut. did you have trouble getting the wrench on the nut?
I went back and watched that part.....many times as I record clips, things are repeated between scenes (same wording).....it was to remove redundant wording, not because of issues with the wrench. Thanks for asking!
is proto blackhawk?
great report friend and proto its great tools
amjad amj Thanks!
Are these the same thing as the mac ratchet wrenches they have on promo in their current flier? They're called precision torque.
I always just use a 1/4" impact for stuff like that.
How are those Proto wrenches holding up ?
Why didn't you try to break the bolt like the Wright and Snap On did?
Bill Bailey At the time I made this video I had ruined that mandrel by drilling out sheared off bolts.....also, this set is metric & that grade 8 bolt was 9/16".
At that price, they are more expensive than the snap on equivalent flank drive plus with reversible ratcheting box ends right? Are they better
+Seth Jones They are not more expensive.....especially considering the Snap on set is a 10-pc set & these have 14 wrenches. Better would boil down to personal preference, some people would like these better & some would like Snap on more.
+Real Tool Reviews I don't think snapon makes very many sizes in the flank drive reversible. no 7/32 and nothing above 3/4 if the website is right. Btw I think snapon's tools are amazing. I have many, but their website needs work.
Looks a lot like Mac precision torque design
Proto and Mac are both made by Stanley Black&Decker. Mac and Proto share many products, like these wrenches, some sockets I believe, soft grip screwdrivers, and 90 tooth ratchets.
Matt Mork Thanks, trying to learn the tool truck alternatives. Tired of spending ridiculous $$$
@@50calprepper most companies industrial brands share products with the truck brand. Also look for tool truck rebrands. I think garage journal has a thread on tool truck rebrands.
Are those wrenches the same length as the Snap On?
+turbobuick33 I dont have any ratcheting Snap-on wrenches, so I couldnt say either way.
Do these come in non spline?
Not that I know of.
The Proto non spline ratcheting wrenches are made in Taiwan. Still high quality
Yes, can get in 6 or 12 point
These look like the Macs
Stanley Black and Decker own both Mac and Proto. In fact these wrenches along with Protos new ratchets are sold on the tool truck under the Mac name. Only differences I've seen in the ratchets are the knurled handles only available with Proto.
They look like Mac
Texas Slinger They are....Proto & Mac are both owned by SBD (Stanley Black and Decker).....not exactly the same, but similar.
600 bucks for a set of those......... jesus.......
Richard Cowtails Maybe retail.....check around online, they go for much less than that.
+Real Tool Reviews $375+$7 shipping on amazon, still ridiculous...
Wow! I like that, but damn.........I found a 13pc. set (sans the 6mm), part # JSCVMT-13S for $334.39! Too rich for my sometimey ass. I need to turn MORE wrench to pay for that!
I own three "PROTO" torque wrenches (1/4",3/8"and1/2"),that I bought back in late 1990's."PROTO" is first class quality.I will upgrade my toolbox with more "PROTO" sockets and wrenches.Most of my stuff is basic "CRAFTSMAN","HAZET","WESTWARD",and some "PROTO".
Hazet is the German Snap-On though.
We have some proto wrenches at work. They just got them I broke one and stretch another one. I have no faith in them. I got a wrench from my box one was Craftsman, the other Armstrong both had no problem doing the job. I do not know what going on with Proto tool. I learned this just after ordering a full set of impact sockets from them. Hope they are better.
Have them 1” - 1-1/4” and theyre nothing short of phenomenal. Only USA made wrenches I can find that go that large and offer a reverse switch
I bought these wrenches when they came out, they are great. My only issue is that in certain cases the ratcheting end is pretty fat and won't fit in some spaces. They are quite $pendy too.
Good review, Sir! However, I'm afraid I have to call shenanigans on you. When demonstrating the splined end of the Proto wrench vs the Craftsman between the 6:30 and 7:00 minute marks in the video you try to continue to tighten the bolt with the Craftsman wrench saying that it won't remove it. You then take the Proto attach it to the bolt and actually turn in the correct direction to remove it. Now, if you were merely showing that the bolt was rounded that's one thing, but you give the impression that the Craftsman would not be able to remove the bolt when clearly at one point when reversing direction ever so briefly the Craftsman actually does appear to bite the bolt. Please forward your address and I will be by with my broom to dispense some Irish justice upon you! Thank you for uploading!
Robert Johnson The point of that was to prove that the bolt was rounded....and the the Proto would remove damaged bolts. It wasnt to do any shenanigans I assure you.
How has this set held up over the years I'm on the fence between the proto and snap on
Just tried to buy these. Proto has unfortunately discontinued this made in USA set.
What would you recommend the proto or sk x frame ratchet wrenched
Both, there is a need for straight and off set wrenches
Proto is really into those ratcheting box wrenches now, but I like my classic Proto Professional combination wrenches. They don’t seem to make that line anymore.
Proto use to be cheep crap tool....but go usa. Gear wrench and most cornwell tiwan and china..I'll give them another look......still like sk
those are nice looking wrenches
Came up on a set of these double sided ratcheting Proto wrenches at a pawn shop for $5. Just a set of 3 in new condition, so fortunate cause i saw the same set on ebay for $50 to $70. Good stuff i cant wait to use them!
Can you recommend a website to order the rebuild kits for ratchet wrenches?
why not just use a ratchet?
Clearance is my usual reason
does regular proto standard rench have life time too?
Yes.....all of their hand tools (except torque wrenches) have a lifetime warranty.
Wow! They look amazing! I think I finally found the set of wrenches that I want to get! Thanks for the review!
How much?
Or u can use a socket
Take my money!
hey bro.
which wrench would u say is your favorite or the best. as far as made in the U.S.
Can you do a comparison of the proto asd and gearwrench surface drive plus please? I know the gearwrench wont break the bolt head off, but will the proto? Im looking for a non ratcheting set but can't decide which set...
efjiongco This set is metric & the demo setup I have with the grade 8 bolt is 9/16".....I think the open ends look similar between the two, but the Proto's absolutely do a better job gripping on and removing damaged fasteners where the cheaper wrenches always have looser tolerances (wider opening) and they just do not grip the same way. For everyday use, the Gearwrench is fine....but for those tight situations and/or damaged fasteners the Proto wrenches will work better.
These wrenches are priced as high as Snap On!!! Holy shit!!! $360.00! No thank you...
MoneyMarcMes Ha.....no way......these are $360 for 14 wrenches (6mm-19mm).....the Snap-on's are over $400 for 10 wrenches (10mm-19mm)
you should have compared it to the gearwrench ratcheting wrench. they have something that's similar
Emin HVAC Sadly too many people go nuts when I do any sort of tool comparison.....I personally like these the best out of any ratcheting wrenches that I have ever used.
dmcguinn1 they are nice. I like the polished chrome. The review was great. However I just would like to see the comparison with another ratcheting wrench as a pose to a regular box end spanner. Again the review was great. Hey can you do a review on a good 45 degree angle long nose pliers
Emin HVAC Any specific brands you are looking at with the pliers? Oh, and I appreciate the suggestion on the ratcheting wrenches....I will incorporate that into the next review I do like this....thanks!
Proto J241G
Emin HVAC I put it on my amazon wishlist....hopefully I will review it sooner than later ;) Thanks!
Hello I like them. Are they still made in the US. Texas ? They sound loud like they need oiling. They should have a small hole for oiling.
Yes they are still made in Texas
will they break the he'd off a grade 8 bolt
Would you go proto or snapon?
Proto, every time
How does the spline side grip better?
Thanks for correcting me you know your tools what is the price on that set of ratcheting wrenches and also you do some great vids I always watch your tool reviews before I go out and buy what your reviewing
Jody Wheeler Thanks Jody I appreciate it :)
its a nice ratcheting wrench.
mac...proto...same thing. but if you want the mac logo just pay 200 more.
+pleco652 Good observation!
was that a Honda prelude in the video?
how long you've been a mechanic? Australians have been using this long time ago
Adriano Vergara About 10 years......I have had ratcheting wrenches for a long time, but I definitely think the Proto versions are top quality.
Can you compare the Proto to the SK
Hello Mr. Real Tools
I saw the review on garage journal where you review the black protos, are these any nicer, I see the black ones go for 2bills right now
Thanks and love your videos
Brown Bear The main difference between the black & chrome versions (other than color) is that the chrome ones are Made in the USA & the black ones are made in Taiwan. The feel/finish/operation of them is pretty much the same. I have reviews for the black locking flex-heads & stubby flex-heads coming up soon also. Either way you go, they are going to have a lifetime warranty & they are going to great wrenches for you. I am glad you like the videos! Thanks for commenting :)
How are they doing
Any recommendations on where to purchase? I could google, but what's your choice of vendors for this awesome set. I think this would be a great tool to keep in the box.
Amazon, duh
Zoro would be the best option
Does Proto has flexible ratcheting on one end while the other side has flexible crowfoot?
angelisone Not that I know of.
Real Tool Reviews Wish someone would make for pro uses. Thank you for replying back.
That's a Facom wrench, just rebranded. Asia made
Made in the USA pal
These aren't Facom (French owned company) and made in Italy. The Proto's are USA made. Although even if they where made in Taiwan it wouldn't discourage me from buying them. Taiwan can make quality tools.
Gearwrench and proto tools are made by the same company apex tools
That is incorrect. Proto is made by SBD (Stanley Black & Decker), but it is a completely separate company that is owned by them. They also own many other brands such as DeWalt, Bostich, Stanley, Black & Decker, Mac, etc. Gearwrench is owned by Apex, which owns many other companies.
SBD might own Proto now but proto has been a top notch tool manufacturer for a very long time. Like Lisle, they make stuff for a lot of others, including Mac Tools. Way before SBD time.
price?
Do you get a commission of reviewing tools?
+sancho closet Check out our disclosure....it explains everything very well...thanks for watching! ---> www.realtoolreviews.com/disclosure/
What happened to your finger? It's cut
You should have seen the other guy....
Shit
Mac Tools. Same.
Yup, looks like they use the Mac Precision Torque non ratcheting shank and add a ratcheting box end. Same parent company
Your videos are like big commercials, but I still watch them all haha..
David G Haha....well, I try and go over the different features of things ;) I am glad you like them!
these are the worst wrench set ever i have had 5 of them break on me in 18 months of owning this set
First complaint I have heard....sorry to hear that. They have a lifetime warranty, so I am sure Proto will resolve this for you.
i warranty two 3/4 two 9/16 and one 1 1/8
Wtf were you doing?
Riggin up a 6ft snipe on a defenseless 9/16th?
no you clown i have never broken a ratchet wrench before its funny you picked out the 9/16 what do you have to say about the 1 1/8 that fell apart I make 90 grand a year as an industrial mechanic I know how to use my tools
Had to ask cuz u the only nigga complaining. Haha!
Seriously though, how'd the break because I just bought a set.
Umm, does anyone not notice when he is using the Craftsman wrench he is actually trying to tighten the faster then uses the Proto to loosen it?
*DUDE!!!!* You rotated the Craftsmen wrench clockwise, (tightening) and rotated the Proto counter-clockwise (loosening)... I don't doubt that the proto *MAY* be better, but this video comparison is totally *worthless* since you didn't provide an equal testing procedure.. It almost looks as if you did it on purpose too.. Why??? *Why???*
This is Whats for Dinner I was showing that the bolt was rounded off....I did not attempt to remove it with the craftsman since I wanted to show the Proto ASD's ability to remove a rounded off bolt. As I am sure you saw from the video, it was a review of the Proto, not a comparison of the Craftsman VS Proto.
Real Tool Reviews Please don't get me wrong, cuz I love your videos.. I'm also a mechanic, and I just can't see wanting to buy a NEW tool that doesn't prove to be better than a standard design.. If you showed the standard craftsmen losing grip, and the proto biting in, both in the same direction, I'd be more inclined to think it's good, and want to buy it. But at this point, there's no proof a regular plain wrench can't remove that fastener.. Sorry to be a downer, but I want to see new tools being put to the test, against the typical tools we ALL have already. And why this new stuff is better.. Just my two cents, but that's why I even started watching your channel.. THE TRUTH, cuz I am definitely not a rich mechanic.. None of us are.
This is Whats for Dinner I will keep that in mind for future videos....as I am sure you can understand, it is very hard to continually come up with new & valid video clips to show these tools actually being used. I am sure that I could have done things differently in this video, but its a learning curve....thanks for the suggestions & for watching! I try and make them as entertaining and informative as I can.
Real Tool Reviews Your a kickass guy, and very, well, diplomatic.. Your a smart fella, and yes, keeping things new and coming up with new content is not always easy.. I too do videos, obviously about food, and not all ideas are winners...lol.. I appreciate you not taking offense to my suggestions, and actually responding very positive. Whether you wanted to tell me to fuk off or not, you didn't, and you actually were very professional.. I respect that.. I'll be watching alot more of your videos. Thank you sir
This is Whats for Dinner with as easy as that 12pt box end on the craftsmen wrench turned on that rounded bolt, there is no way it would have bit in enough to loosen it even if he wasn't turning it the wrong way. If you notice with the proto when the bolt does come loose there was some energy on that wrench, he put some effort into loosening that bolt. As much as it sucks to say wrenches like these are way better than what most of us have and can afford to have.
Would be nice to put prices in your comment section I realize that it may vary but a ball park figure would be good
Jacob Gibson Yeah, I used to....but the prices on tools seem to change with the wind. I considered putting "retail price", but every seller changes that, so now I just normally put an amazon link to keep things simple.
Hate to tell you fella but stanley tools make most of the proto product in Taiwan these days and have done so since buying the brand.
Not true at all
False