It's only almost 17 minutes but wow, I felt like I was watching a film. For the whole 17min I forgot about everything and was quite taken by the way you act and tell the story. You're amazing. Can't explain how much I enjoy your videos, thank you :') ✨ ( btw please pay to history department, we love Dr. Hilton and it would be quite sad if he quit his job.)
Weird coincidence, I just finished this for the first time the other day and it really struck a chord with me as an undergrad student of creative writing. The way Joyce distills the essence of why we write at the end of the chapter where Stephen watches a girl wading in the water resonated with me unlike few other pieces of writing have.
This is my number one favorite book. I just read it for my third pass. Its amazing to me how this book hit at 16 vs 24 vs 33 as I have grown up. Thanks for the great video!
The true artistic rebellion isn't necessarily following the popular uprising, but to follow your own path, regardless of the consequences. As Stephen Daedalus comes to understand, “Do you know what Ireland is?' asked Stephen with cold violence. 'Ireland is the old sow that eats her farrow.” And so it was for Joyce. Excellent video as always, Robin.
James Joyce fanboy here. Good job dude. Couple notes to help further your analysis: 1) T. S. Elliot's criticism of Ulysses and 'Tradition and the Individual Talent's are both good, short pieces to help further modernism's perspective on the relationship between history, art, and the artist. 2) Ellmanns's biography on Joyce is essential for masters and Ph.D level scholarship on him and I highly recommend. 3) Jung's universal unconscious and archetypes further analysis even more and help provide a framework for Stephen's perception of heroism and rebellion (the original title was 'Stephen Hero,' after all). 4) Joyce's philosophy was heavily influenced by Saint Thomas Aquinas, which then dances with Aristotelian and Platonic aesthetic theories. There so much more... Good job. Again!
We have all sorts of channels with subscriber numbers in the millions. I'm going to keep an eye on the subscriber numbers of this channel - & will view it as a key indicator of how worthwhile it feels to be a part of the English-speaking human race as at 2023. I see this channel as a 'movement' - in watching it I feel as though I'm partaking in a salon of days of olde. Am very honoured to be witnessing this unfold.
I have a story to tell. I was in Dublin for Bloomsday, for the century anniversary of Ulysses. I got a Joyce tattoo, got closer to my wife, and bought a third edition of Portrait of the Artist from 1922. I read Ulysses with a Joyce scholar on a study abroad trip, and saw Barry McGovern read the last two chapters to complete the novel in Dublin on Bloomsday.
Awesome video! This topic is really tough. Finding your own creative space is a process that, sadly, not everyone understands... Like in your example from the beginning. I'm feeling exactly like that, somehow ashamed that it is better to work, have a family, than to make music or photographs. It's like non - prestige lifestyle in the world of work and capitalism. Very insightful video, thank you!
I am a Classical language major. Talking with people about it is so hard. Sometimes I make up another major cause I don’t want to deal with the ridicule.
Thank you for this video! If i haven't watch it, i never would have tought about reading this book. But now i'm going to read it, because the story (and the whole background of the author) interests me :)
This is so interessting. I was just reading how the "german studies" or in my language "Germanistik" started to become a University Discipline. And the parallel beween the "Irish Revival" and the reason why german studies started to become a discipline is fascinating. In both cases the country here Germany and Ireland, wanted to find their own national identity, something that distinguishes themselves. For Ireland it was the distinction from England, for Germany it was the distinction from France and Italy, which both where quite the powerhouses in the 16. century. Italy and France werent just places, they were THE places, where brilliant minds and artists were born, and the world (Europe at that time) was looking up to them. But Germany wanted to find something that makes their culture something special and unique. They wanted to find art and poetry, that makes them an equal player in this geopolitical fight and race of who has the best literature, art, poetry etc. What we can take from that is, that People always try to distinguish themselves from others, not just individually but in groups as well. They try to identify themselves with something that is special and unique to their country/place/group. At the end we just want to have appreciation from others on our own works, we sometimes deny that, but it is all in ourselves. The drive to create something and being respected and honored for that thing, make our mark in History.
“The artist’s task is to save the soul of mankind; and anything less is a dithering while Rome burns. Because of the artists, who are self-selected, for being able to journey into the Other, if the artists cannot find the way, then the way cannot be found.” ― Terence McKenna
I saw that weren't into fantasy and science fiction, but that is because, as with many other genres, they are filled with dumb self indulgent works of juvenile escapism. I would like to recommend some the most poetical and imaginative works that I have come across with original ideas that change your worldview and interesting concepts that make you think. 1) Ghormenghast: this work has the best prose I have ever read and the scenes are like pictures in a book, as if painted by pen, and the characters are vivid and strange, yet very human at the same time. It explores socialism, classes and Tradition and many other themes. 2) Worm Ouroboros: if you enjoyed the epics, you would certainly love this. But it is fantastical and magical and subtly ironic. Prose are poetic and beautiful. Yet it is written in Elizebethan style so it is not an easy read. 3) King of Elflands' daughter: purple prose, but used in the right way. It starts as a classic fairy tale, but explores existentialism and other themes with such great imagination. It is pretty short, but it really makes you think about the world. You have probably already noticed it, English is not my first language
I have this guilty thought lingering in my head. I am an artist(aspiring artist) probably. I saw a friend posting about how everyone's an artist until the rent is due. They say it's about money and rich kids being able to do their heart's desire and not everyone get that chance. It stuck with me heavy for a while. I feel some part of it was right that's why my heart felt heavy for it. But mostly, I'm just pissed:3. Maybe I'm just too pompous to admit that he was right.
Pragmatically, your friend might be right. But history doesn't remember the ones who paid their bills in due time, but the ones who neglect them entirely whilst following higher, more noble pursuits.
I have an exam after a few days and my 1st exam is on *Women's Literature* but now I am writing a comment that I'm watching "A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man" great 🤭 Please hold on to 1984 by Gorge Orwell
A novel I love, always stunned when other bookish people deride it as a failure to do what Ulysses was to do, as if it's a trial run for the later book. I think, well I think "IDIOT". I love Joyce from Chamber Music to FW.
In some way the arts are highly underappreciated in germany. But then again, most people will be highly impressed if you say you´re an artist, classical musician,... . With lawyers, doctors and stuff many people will also be impressed, but very many people will assume the for example lawyer, thinks too high of himself and in a way looks down on the others. It´s like they think just because you studied something academically difficult with a high reputation, you´re elitist or something. But people here do admire creativity and talent.
You are the single most important youtuber that people need to learn from (in my opinion). I mean sure, there's Professor Dave Explains or Kurzgesagt that's super beneficial, but then the range of topics they cover with yours is so different. It's like you're the common person's gateway to deeper ideas. Thanks so much
Stop prefacing every new direction the narrative takes by saying, "In order to do x first we must do y." It slows down the pacing of your videos drastically. Just ask the question and trust that your viewers are along with you for the ride.
Fookin' hell - how utterly talented is this guy! This is my favourite 𝘱𝘩𝘪𝘭𝘰𝘴𝘰𝘱𝘩𝘦𝘳-𝘯𝘢𝘴𝘤𝘦𝘯𝘵𝘦* of this century, as far my World is concerned! (* Yes - I made this expression up just now)
It's only almost 17 minutes but wow, I felt like I was watching a film. For the whole 17min I forgot about everything and was quite taken by the way you act and tell the story. You're amazing. Can't explain how much I enjoy your videos, thank you :') ✨ ( btw please pay to history department, we love Dr. Hilton and it would be quite sad if he quit his job.)
Weird coincidence, I just finished this for the first time the other day and it really struck a chord with me as an undergrad student of creative writing. The way Joyce distills the essence of why we write at the end of the chapter where Stephen watches a girl wading in the water resonated with me unlike few other pieces of writing have.
This video is an absolute piece of art. Don't stop making such essays.
robin i just want to say that you are one of main the reasons why i want to further study literature and dive deeper into analyzing texts.
As an Irishman this video resonates with me
This is my number one favorite book. I just read it for my third pass. Its amazing to me how this book hit at 16 vs 24 vs 33 as I have grown up. Thanks for the great video!
The true artistic rebellion isn't necessarily following the popular uprising, but to follow your own path, regardless of the consequences. As Stephen Daedalus comes to understand, “Do you know what Ireland is?' asked Stephen with cold violence. 'Ireland is the old sow that eats her farrow.” And so it was for Joyce.
Excellent video as always, Robin.
James Joyce fanboy here. Good job dude. Couple notes to help further your analysis: 1) T. S. Elliot's criticism of Ulysses and 'Tradition and the Individual Talent's are both good, short pieces to help further modernism's perspective on the relationship between history, art, and the artist. 2) Ellmanns's biography on Joyce is essential for masters and Ph.D level scholarship on him and I highly recommend. 3) Jung's universal unconscious and archetypes further analysis even more and help provide a framework for Stephen's perception of heroism and rebellion (the original title was 'Stephen Hero,' after all). 4) Joyce's philosophy was heavily influenced by Saint Thomas Aquinas, which then dances with Aristotelian and Platonic aesthetic theories. There so much more... Good job. Again!
We have all sorts of channels with subscriber numbers in the millions.
I'm going to keep an eye on the subscriber numbers of this channel - & will view it as a key indicator of how worthwhile it feels to be a part of the English-speaking human race as at 2023.
I see this channel as a 'movement' - in watching it I feel as though I'm partaking in a salon of days of olde. Am very honoured to be witnessing this unfold.
Yea I need to reread it. Wasn’t easy, but was quite taken it with it. Can easily see why it’s yours or anyones favorite.
This video was a breath of fresh air! The format and execution of this video is pure ART (no pun intended) ❤
Silence, exile, and cunning. I’ll have to add that to my personal arsenal! Great video, thanks.
Beautiful and very witty.
This is the kind of videos that make me launch youtube everyday. Love your work Robin.
I really appreciate the effort you put into making this video and find it utterly interesting. Time to get back to Joyce ^^
You leave Chopin alone 😊💙. Beautiful video 🙌🏾
If only you were my professor. You just single-handedly made me want to re-read the whole thing.
Great video I'm Irish and love Joyce, good concise summary of Irish Revival movement
Dr. Hilton at his best. Guess I do have to pay him.
So creative as is the book itself! Good job.
Love this. Awesome! Encore! Longer! More creative analysis!
The intro is gold
It is impossible to not like this guy.
I have a story to tell. I was in Dublin for Bloomsday, for the century anniversary of Ulysses. I got a Joyce tattoo, got closer to my wife, and bought a third edition of Portrait of the Artist from 1922. I read Ulysses with a Joyce scholar on a study abroad trip, and saw Barry McGovern read the last two chapters to complete the novel in Dublin on Bloomsday.
Is your wife called Joyce?
@@drts6955 nah, but my family works in an office on Joyce Blvd.
The art of storytelling indeed! Your vid is so great!
Your channel is my safe place 😊
Brother I have an exam on Joyce in half an hour thank you I'm so screwed
Thank you, Robin, for this video that is as interesting as artistic. Keep going!
Loved this video. 🤣 Now, to read the book. IMHO, we need more artists now. The sooner the better. Time is ripe for them.
Your contents are so amazing!
I wish I would find you sooner, on my 2nd year of grad at least.
Awesome video! This topic is really tough. Finding your own creative space is a process that, sadly, not everyone understands... Like in your example from the beginning. I'm feeling exactly like that, somehow ashamed that it is better to work, have a family, than to make music or photographs. It's like non - prestige lifestyle in the world of work and capitalism. Very insightful video, thank you!
I kind of felt the introduction. I study law but I wanna be a writer
I am a Classical language major. Talking with people about it is so hard. Sometimes I make up another major cause I don’t want to deal with the ridicule.
Thanks, this was fun and inspiring.
Thank you for this video! If i haven't watch it, i never would have tought about reading this book. But now i'm going to read it, because the story (and the whole background of the author) interests me :)
Enjoy the ride. :)
I absolutely loved this video. 🧡
This is so interessting. I was just reading how the "german studies" or in my language "Germanistik" started to become a University Discipline. And the parallel beween the "Irish Revival" and the reason why german studies started to become a discipline is fascinating. In both cases the country here Germany and Ireland, wanted to find their own national identity, something that distinguishes themselves. For Ireland it was the distinction from England, for Germany it was the distinction from France and Italy, which both where quite the powerhouses in the 16. century. Italy and France werent just places, they were THE places, where brilliant minds and artists were born, and the world (Europe at that time) was looking up to them. But Germany wanted to find something that makes their culture something special and unique. They wanted to find art and poetry, that makes them an equal player in this geopolitical fight and race of who has the best literature, art, poetry etc.
What we can take from that is, that People always try to distinguish themselves from others, not just individually but in groups as well. They try to identify themselves with something that is special and unique to their country/place/group. At the end we just want to have appreciation from others on our own works, we sometimes deny that, but it is all in ourselves. The drive to create something and being respected and honored for that thing, make our mark in History.
This must have taken such a long time to do, but gosh do I appreciate it. This video has been beautifully done, how impressively lovely!
Great video man
So inspiring 💜
showing support c: keep up the artsy work c:
You're good at piano!!!
Great video always.
Amazing essay 👏👏👏
Amazing video !!
“The artist’s task is to save the soul of mankind; and anything less is a dithering while Rome burns. Because of the artists, who are self-selected, for being able to journey into the Other, if the artists cannot find the way, then the way cannot be found.”
― Terence McKenna
I saw that weren't into fantasy and science fiction, but that is because, as with many other genres, they are filled with dumb self indulgent works of juvenile escapism. I would like to recommend some the most poetical and imaginative works that I have come across with original ideas that change your worldview and interesting concepts that make you think.
1) Ghormenghast: this work has the best prose I have ever read and the scenes are like pictures in a book, as if painted by pen, and the characters are vivid and strange, yet very human at the same time. It explores socialism, classes and Tradition and many other themes.
2) Worm Ouroboros: if you enjoyed the epics, you would certainly love this. But it is fantastical and magical and subtly ironic. Prose are poetic and beautiful. Yet it is written in Elizebethan style so it is not an easy read.
3) King of Elflands' daughter: purple prose, but used in the right way. It starts as a classic fairy tale, but explores existentialism and other themes with such great imagination. It is pretty short, but it really makes you think about the world.
You have probably already noticed it, English is not my first language
Omg I saw you in readings the other day!!
Next time say hi!
The sketch in the beginning has me rolling😂
the opening gotta be an American Psycho reference
Finally someone picked it up.
Dr. Hilton got me rolling in the aisles
te quiero mucho, Robin.
howd you get those art chapter break things? they look so cool, plus which software do you use?
thanks
Artist whatever the medium maybe, always seem to serve as timestamps for their era
Whenever I give up on my studies I come here. And maybe watch some tiktok compilations.
Omg James Joyce, I love him!
1:08 Op. 9 No. 1 by Chopin, if anyone’s wondering. Good choice, btw
I have this guilty thought lingering in my head. I am an artist(aspiring artist) probably. I saw a friend posting about how everyone's an artist until the rent is due. They say it's about money and rich kids being able to do their heart's desire and not everyone get that chance. It stuck with me heavy for a while. I feel some part of it was right that's why my heart felt heavy for it. But mostly, I'm just pissed:3. Maybe I'm just too pompous to admit that he was right.
Pragmatically, your friend might be right. But history doesn't remember the ones who paid their bills in due time, but the ones who neglect them entirely whilst following higher, more noble pursuits.
@@lagmion4061I'm not sure history's memory matters, except that enough people noticed someone's work enough to get a footnote. 😂😂😂
I have an exam after a few days and my 1st exam is on *Women's Literature* but now I am writing a comment that I'm watching "A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man" great 🤭
Please hold on to 1984 by Gorge Orwell
A novel I love, always stunned when other bookish people deride it as a failure to do what Ulysses was to do, as if it's a trial run for the later book. I think, well I think "IDIOT". I love Joyce from Chamber Music to FW.
Hi Bro, what APPS did you used now for second brain? are you still using ONENOTE?
I switched to Notion and it’s a game changer.
@@RCWaldun yes absolute! Notion is all in one :)
In some way the arts are highly underappreciated in germany. But then again, most people will be highly impressed if you say you´re an artist, classical musician,... . With lawyers, doctors and stuff many people will also be impressed, but very many people will assume the for example lawyer, thinks too high of himself and in a way looks down on the others. It´s like they think just because you studied something academically difficult with a high reputation, you´re elitist or something. But people here do admire creativity and talent.
the beginning was almost like a classical parody of American Psycho lmao
but... read this book in HS, nothing but "artistic" elitism really
Nice begining of the video 😂😂
You are the single most important youtuber that people need to learn from (in my opinion). I mean sure, there's Professor Dave Explains or Kurzgesagt that's super beneficial, but then the range of topics they cover with yours is so different. It's like you're the common person's gateway to deeper ideas. Thanks so much
❤
Is no one gonna talk about the American Psycho bit???
Is Jenny’s dad, Tom Sachs? 😊
Please tell me that there are more than one people working on this video.
Unfortunately it was all me.
@@RCWaldun not doubting you or anything, just kinda wondering how some people can just casually become an entire TV studio.
@@cosmobane6995 Thanks man! Hope you loved the video as well as the production quality. :)
They should just give you tenure right now. Seriously.
Eleventh
Stop prefacing every new direction the narrative takes by saying, "In order to do x first we must do y." It slows down the pacing of your videos drastically. Just ask the question and trust that your viewers are along with you for the ride.
Third
nahh my friend called robin a “dark academia twink”
First. Sorry, I had to.
Fookin' hell - how utterly talented is this guy! This is my favourite 𝘱𝘩𝘪𝘭𝘰𝘴𝘰𝘱𝘩𝘦𝘳-𝘯𝘢𝘴𝘤𝘦𝘯𝘵𝘦* of this century, as far my World is concerned!
(* Yes - I made this expression up just now)