@@AlMosesPhD Salaam, As per the Birmingham manuscripts of the Quran, which date back to the time of the Prophet Mohammad, there were no Ayraaf in the Quran. When the ayraaf were added?
@@UALIS123 Salam, there are a lot of people who've done good work there. Best to refer to them. The airab do not matter regardless because the text was kept in check by recitation and vice versa
The best answer is , to read surah Younus verse 37 it clearly shows the name ALLAH claiming that he is the one who produced the Quran وَمَا كَانَ هَـٰذَا ٱلْقُرْءَانُ أَن يُفْتَرَىٰ مِن دُونِ ٱللَّهِ وَلَـٰكِن تَصْدِيقَ ٱلَّذِى بَيْنَ يَدَيْهِ وَتَفْصِيلَ ٱلْكِتَـٰبِ لَا رَيْبَ فِيهِ مِن رَّبِّ ٱلْعَـٰلَمِينَ ٣٧
My salutes to you brother Musa. Your reply to Sachwala is very logical and highly well reasoned. You are serving the cause of Al Furqan. May Allah reward you, your parents, siblings, wife and kids with His choicest blessings in both worlds and may He award you all the highest places in Jannat ul Firdous as your perpetual abodes. If I have hurt you with my comments posted earlier, I seek apologies from you and Allah. My utmost love 💕 and regards for you and everyone and everything associated with you. I again seek apologies
Hi Al Moses, thanks for sharing the video, it was thought provoking. I'm still trying to understand whether the companions of the Prophet were responsible for compiling the Quran, and if so, were the same companions not involved in the compilation of hadiths? I get asked this question a lot by my friends. I am a student like you who prefers logical reasoning based on evidence, and I would really appreciate your guidance. Thanks.
The Quran came through the disbelievers, the ashab, the normal lay person. They all heard, saw, read the Quran and passed on. It was ijmaa7, written + verbal. Ahadith though are isolated historical reports whose sources cannot be verified, come from majhool people, often go against the nass of the Quran. Almost none of the ahadith are literal words of the prophet because they have been conveyed by meaning only.
🙏 Quran me jo ham ki zameer hai, shayad “Malaika” including “Ruhul Quds” (Jibrael) ke liye hai. 1 Note:-Allah ki taraf se, jo Bhi santence, Quran me hai, Usme, “Main” ki zameer hai, 2 Note- “Tumhare Rab” Quran me jahan hai, wo Ruhul Quds ka Jumla hai. Ex.Sura Baqra Ayat-30 وَ اِذۡ قَالَ رَبُّکَ لِلۡمَلٰٓئِکَۃِ اِنِّیۡ جَاعِلٌ فِی الۡاَرۡضِ خَلِیۡفَۃً Ex
This video should be uploaded on mufti yaaser nadim al wajidi channel. A beautiful explanation. But it is also fact that. It is not necessary to prove Allah is first person. Because there is no rule that author should be first person.
Thank you. I did talk to Sachwala ji with the same logic but he didn't seem to get it. If Mufti sahib wants to put this video on his channel, then I have no issue with it. Much rather the information gets out compared to who gets the credit
@@Sjk2498 Maybe Allah didn’t follow the rules, which Sachwala ji thinks are set in stone to prove who the author is. First person or third person doesn’t prove or disprove anything. Sachwala ji is only arguing for the sake of argument, with all due respect. He seems to be adamant on setting up a very specific narrative. Seeker of knowledge and truth is supposed to be humble, and flexible. He doesn’t seem to possess any of these qualities.
@@ms4050 ji, you are or may be 100% right regarding your logic that Allah does not follow our rules. Yet, in this physical world , we can't set aside phycal rules made by we human beings ! Possibility / Belief in different kinds of God / Bhagwan / Allah etc. are also being debated by us human beings, based on our individual/ collective reasonings !! What is your logic/reasoning / Opinion 🌸🙏
Janab/ there was a question who wrote the quran but you gave answer who sent the Quran/ Is there any proof or ayah in the quran where Allah himself said He wrote the quran and sent down exactly same written Quran???????
Dear Moses Ham ny tuj py nazil kia,haq k sath. Who is tuj py? To whom Rasool or Nabi is being addressed? We know,what is haq. When there cannot be question mark,that is haq. What u take its meaning? Bcoz,all which is revealed from Allah is *haq*
Hi Moussa Bhai, do you have a truthfull, wisefull and insightfull translation of the verse 5:32 مِنْ أَجْلِ ذَلِكَ كَتَبْنَا عَلَى بَنِي إِسْرَائِيلَ أَنَّهُ مَن قَتَلَ نَفْسًا بِغَيْرِ نَفْسٍ أَوْ فَسَادٍ فِي الْأَرْضِ فَكَأَنَّمَا قَتَلَ النَّاسَ جَمِيعًا وَمَنْ أَحْيَاهَا فَكَأَنَّمَا أَحْيَا النَّاسَ جَمِيعًا وَلَقَدْ جَاءَتْهُمْ رُسُلُنَا بِالْبَيِّنَاتِ ثُمَّ إِنَّ كَثِيرًا مِّنْهُم بَعْدَ ذَلِكَ فِي الْأَرْضِ لَمُسْرِفُونَ many thanks in advance May you have a joyfull and peacefull life thanks to the rahma bringed by the qur'an
It's not just "we, me he" there are other verses which give an impression that some third erson has compiled or written the book. One example: 19:85 The day WE shall gather the righteous to (Allah) Most Graciouslike a band. Who is that WE who is gathering the rightous to ALLAH.
Repeat the Video Same sura 19 v67 says WE created the man Same word in the suran 16 v4 As HE created the Man. Your refering ayah says The Day shall soon come when We (RAHMAN)shall bring together the God-fearing to the RAHMAN, as honoured guests. this is style of Quran unlike human books
Accepting the use "we" for "I" is not very difficult. The problem crops when "we" becomes "he" in some ayats. The use of third person in place of first person introduces some narrator. Who is that that narrator? It is difficult to accept that Allah sometimes uses "he" for himself, and sometimes "we". If you read Genesis or The Gita, you find reported verb followed by reported speech. Reported verb identifies the speaker. If you delete reported verb, as is done in this book, then use of first person pronoun will indicate that reporter is person himself and if third person pronoun is used in reported speech, the reporter is not the person himself. Who is that reporter whom this book does not name
Thanks for a thoughtful comment. Can you give me an example of this? In this video, it's clear that the action of sending is done by God who refers to himself as both He, and We in a different verse. To ignore that, as Sachwala has done, is indefensible
Sir if you want to go through answer according to Quran it is mentioned in Surah 42:51 that there are three ways Allah speaks to a human. Since he himself is not human and is an entity which cannot be explained he uses some medium to speak. 1) he directly sends wahi/inspiration to the recipient in those ayat you will see I/we. 2) He speaks from behind hidden veil 3) He sends a messenger with message and this is the exact way in which ayats are using him in 3rd person And this narrator is nobody except Gibreel and this can be confirmed from chapter 2 verse 97 when he brings the message those ayats are in 3rd person.
@@myqatar2431 jaisa uper 42:51 me likha gaya hai Allah kalam karta hai bashar(humans) se to ye baat clear hai ye har zamane me hota hai hai aur kisi insaan ke saath bhi ho sakta hai.. Quran me kahin bhi nahi likha ke ab Allah kalam nahi karta ye ek eternal book hai to har zamane me applicable hogi. Par afsos traditional islam me isko sirf nabi ya rasool ke liye hi confine kar diya gaya hai jo ki ghalat baat hai. Allah har us insaan se communicate karta hai jo is kitab ko padhne ko koshish karte hai.. Unki zindagi ke wo saare sawaal jo usko success ki taraf le jaa sakte hain aur guidance de sakte hain isi kitab me hai... Bas insaan ko bina biased hue sirf is kitab ko padhna hai phir Allah iske zariye usse kalam karega.
#سوال۔ اللہ کی کتاب کس نے الواح میں لکھی اور کون لوگ اس کو کاغذ پر لائے۔ !!؟ بے شک قرآن بھی کتابت کیا گیا ہے اللہ نے قرآن کو لوح میں کتابت کیا ہے ۔ اللہ جواب دیتا ہے کہ ہم نے لکھا الواح میں جو لوح کی جمع ہے ، پھر تم لوگ اس کو کاغذ پر لائے۔ !! اللہ تعالی فرماتا ہے۔ وَكَتَبْنَا لَهُۥ فِى ٱلْأَلْوَاحِ مِن كُلِّ شَىْءٍ مَّوْعِظَةً وَتَفْصِيلًا لِّكُلِّ شَىْءٍ فَخُذْهَا بِقُوَّةٍ وَأْمُرْ قَوْمَكَ يَأْخُذُوا۟ بِأَحْسَنِهَاۚ سَأُو۟رِيكُمْ دَارَ ٱلْفَٰسِقِينَ اور ہم نے الواح میں ہر قسم کی واعظ اور ہر چیز کی تفصیل ان کو لکھ کر دی، تم ان کو پوری طاقت سے پکڑ لو اور اپنی قوم کو حکم کرو کہ ان کے اچھے اچھے احکام پر عمل کریں، اب بہت جلد تم لوگوں کو ان بے حکموں کا مقام دکھلاتا ہوں۔ 7:145 بَلْ هُوَ قُرْءَانٌ مَّجِيدٌ فِى لَوْحٍ مَّحْفُوظٍۭ بلکہ یہ قرآن ہے بڑی شان واﻻ، لوح محفوظ میں (لکھا ہوا) 85:21/22 وَمَا قَدَرُوا اللّٰهَ حَقَّ قَدۡرِهٖۤ اِذۡ قَالُوۡا مَاۤ اَنۡزَلَ اللّٰهُ عَلٰى بَشَرٍ مِّنۡ شَىۡءٍ ؕ قُلۡ مَنۡ اَنۡزَلَ الۡـكِتٰبَ الَّذِىۡ جَآءَ بِهٖ مُوۡسٰى نُوۡرًا وَّ هُدًى لِّلنَّاسِ تَجۡعَلُوۡنَهٗ قَرَاطِيۡسَ تُبۡدُوۡنَهَا وَتُخۡفُوۡنَ كَثِيۡرًا ۚ وَعُلِّمۡتُمۡ مَّا لَمۡ تَعۡلَمُوۡۤا اَنۡتُمۡ وَلَاۤ اٰبَآؤُكُمۡؕ قُلِ اللّٰهُۙ ثُمَّ ذَرۡهُمۡ فِىۡ خَوۡضِهِمۡ يَلۡعَبُوۡنَ - اور انہوں نے اللہ کی قدر نہیں کی، جیسا کہ اس کی قدر کرنے کا حق تھا، جب کہ انہوں نے کہا کہ اللہ نے کسی بشر پر کوئی شے نازل نہیں کی ۔ کہہ دے ’ کس نے نازل کی وہ کتاب جسے موسیٰ لے کر آئے؟ (اور جو) لوگوں کے لئے نور اور ہدایت ہیں ۔ تم نے اسے کاغذ پر کر دیا۔ (اس میں سے) کچھ کو تو تم ظاہر کرتے ہو اور بہت کچھ چھپاتے ہو۔ اور تم وہ کچھ سکھائے گئے ہو جو تم اور تمہارے آباءنہیں جانتے تھے۔ کہہ دے اللہ نے (وہ کتاب نازل کی) پھر ان کو ان کی بیکار بحثوں کے کھیل میں محو چھوڑ دے۔ 6:91 وَلَوۡ نَزَّلۡنَا عَلَيۡكَ كِتٰبًا فِىۡ قِرۡطَاسٍ فَلَمَسُوۡهُ بِاَيۡدِيۡهِمۡ لَقَالَ الَّذِيۡنَ كَفَرُوۡۤا اِنۡ هٰذَاۤ اِلَّا سِحۡرٌ مُّبِيۡنٌ - اور اگر ہم تجھ پر کاغذ پر تحریر کردہ کتاب نازل کر دیتے، جسے وہ اپنے ہاتھوں سے چھو بھی لیتے تو پھر بھی وہ لوگ جنہوں نے انکار کیا یہی کہتے کہ بے شک یہ تو صریحاً ایک جادو ہی ہے۔ 6:7 إِنَّ عَلَيْنَا جَمْعَهُۥ وَقُرْءَانَهُۥ اس کا جمع کرنا اور پڑھنا ہمارے ذمہ ہے.75:17. th-cam.com/video/x6U_MW4lrE4/w-d-xo.html #سوال۔ اللہ کی کتاب کس نے لکھی؟ m.th-cam.com/video/aEma10vaebU/w-d-xo.html #سوال۔ کیا قرآن کا مصنف اللہ نہیں ہے ۔؟ کیا اللہ نے شروع سے اس کو جمع اور محفوظ نہیں کی ہے۔؟ th-cam.com/video/gYbwos0F1cg/w-d-xo.html
"The Qur'an is kalamullah" is a belief whether based on the Qur'an or Qur'an plus other books. Why would Allah confuse with i, he and we? Is not he royal when 🤙 jg himself he or I?
@@AlMosesPhD the post has covered that Allah has used first person, second person and third person. My question was entirely different. I didn't question your explanation.. I keep understanding various Quran only scholars.
Hello AlMoses PhD, The verse, 12/1 and 12/2, starts with “Alif, Laam, Raa” - there is no reason that there are things in the Quran that has no meaning. Similarly, these words are used in many verses, like “Alif Laam Meem”, “saad”, “Taa Haa” etc. I am also a student, like yourself, and it is explained by Allama Pervez Sb, where he describes these as “abbreviations” - In these verse, the abbreviations, as explained by Allama Pervez, suggests that these are alphabets taken from the attributes of Allah described in Quran - what is your take on this please. Regards
These words has meanings as you you know everything in the quran is meaningful not meaningless. These words are called harof-e-maqtats. Those who reseach about thesewords , meanings also find it. by voice i can clear you
Surah 52. At-Toor - Mount Sinai This is the 52nd Surah of the Qur’an and it has 49 verses. God watched very closely the person, the character, the actions and the Mission of the exalted Messenger. This Surah is a great example of Tasreef, how beautifully the Qur’an displays its Uniform message, repeating its verses from different vantage points and in diverse facets, filling our sight and mind with décor rather than a colorless monotony. With the Glorious Name of God, the Instant and Sustaining Source of all Mercy and Kindness 52:1 Mount Sinai stands witness. [That this Qur’an is a Divine Writ as was the scripture of law bestowed upon Moses] 52:2 And a well-scored Book it is. 52:3 Written on fine parchment, unrolled, open for everyone to read, widely published. [Raqq = Deer skin = Parchment. Right here is the unequivocal negation of many accounts of fabricated Hadith that the Qur’an was written on bones, date-leaves, stones etc. Manshoor = Unfolded, unrolled, available to be seen and read, open to understanding, widely distributed] - Dr Shabbir Ahmed. The Quran as it Explains itself
@@AlMosesPhD history say kesay pata chalay ga Jab nabi ki history ko itni buri tarha khatam kar dia gya To quran kay anay ki history kesay pata chalay gi
@@myqatar2431 Historical documents/manuscripts/oral tradition ko judge karnay kay many different ways hain. Quran ki historicity kay muqablay baqi tarikh ki wuqat buhat kam hay
@@AlMosesPhD r u hre to misguiding muslims? Because when u prove that quran is not revealed from ALLAH on prophet muhammad ( s.a.w) then u proved that ....u dont know anything about quran .....srry to say but this is the truth ....
Al Moses bhai Mera sawal thoda alag hai Najjala alai"Ka ul kitaab.... Alaika" mtlab AAP par hi hota hai agar to yaha aap kaun hai Aur unko ye baat bata kaun Raha hai
It is a bit explanatory…but Quran not only talks about (الكتاب) but (كُتُب)…it also mentions(نصيب من الكتاب) portion of a book.Which kitab is mentioned where we have no idea?Does word “kitab” has only one meaning or different in terms of context ..In single verse word kitab is repeated also… ?No where the word kitab is mentioned with “Taurat” or “Injeel”….So it is overall confusing…. The verses u(Al Moses) referred from Quran uses "انزل" ….and it does not mean to write…. In aayat ko dekh kar lag raha hai ki Allah ne kitab ko naazil kiya….likhne ki baat nahi hai…..haan agar kitab ka lafzi maana liya jaye to phir jo translation is ki “divine writ”ki gayi hai wo sahi hoga lekin usme bhi phir masla hai….ki kya Quran “likhai”hai jo Allah ne khud likha ??ya ki “kalam “hai? ya dono hai…??
Quran word meaning itself have problem .. ikra or al Qura + al Ain means eye ball which is you will take ? There are questions about jinns how much and need Allah need their support .. there thowheed problem .. there are tree god Allah .. union of allahs ahed … even heaven where Allah runs brothel and waiting all Muslims .. there are moral value of Muhammed is big tragedy that is why quran only group coming .. but they still don’t have any idea how many ayaths are in quran .. all are problems of Islam .. the direction of salah and times of prayer .. even the manhood of mariyum
Quran is the same wazan as fuqdan, eudwan, all of which came from their root words. So Quran = something that is read out/a recitation. If you're a real student of knowledge, you can do yourself a service and read the text yourself instead of relying on hearsay
@@AlMosesPhD you will be in great trouble .. because every language is come from one or two language like Arab is come from either Aramaic or Greek words and it is quddassa ransa ( ku. Ran ) which is to recite like it’s word meaning .. then it is not holy book .. there is so many qu. Ran at least seven types of qu. Ran .. which recites on different occasions …..
@@rgap3944 Arabic may very well have come from other languages. It's natural. All languages evolve, borrow, lend words and no one language is special or holy. Key is to understand how a word changes when it enters a new language. Ghaliz in Arabic means strong but in Hindi/Urdi means dirty. An academic sees how the author of a book uses a word in his own book to get its correct meaning (regardless of where that word might have come from)
@@AlMosesPhD iqra is wrong meaning.. as per me I wish it is “eye ball” or other wise al ikrah not al quran there is no word In Arabic qu.ran this is aramaic word as per your meaning
@@rgap3944 sirf wish karnay say to meanings change nahi ho jatay, hain na? Jab aik cheez ka simple answer he, then to prove otherwise, you need to bring daleel
Quran was a writing, a Book, from the very start of its revelation; and it was Mohammad pbuh who managed to keep the revelations in the Book Form constantly as it continued being revealed bit by bit. None other than the Almighty Himself testifies to it. Therefore, all theories about its “jamaa’ and tadween” in the period after Prophet Mohammad, stand invalid. These stories were concocted by enemies to relegate the stature of this Divine revelation. Please see the divine testimony in Quran’s words about its status as a Book (having been written) even when it was still being revealed:- 1. Verse No.80/11-16 No. It indeed is a remembrance/advice; So, whoever may wish, may remember it/take advice from it; it is in exalted pages, lofty in status, written by those who were highly respected scribes. 2. Verse No.85/21-22 BUT, that is an honorable Quran; in a guarded Scripture. 3. Verse No.56/77-80 I do swear by the Galaxies; and had you known it, that ’s a great oath to take; that indeed is a respected Quran; safely placed in a written volume; none may benefit from it except those with the purity of heart and mind; gradually revealed by the Lord of the Worlds. 4. Verse No.25/5 And they say, it is the ancient scriptures that he had got written; and the same is dictated by him mornings and evenings. 5. Verse No.98/2-3 A Messenger from Allah, reciting purified written pages/scriptures, wherein are established laws. 6. Verse No.52/1-3 I swear by the Toor (Quran); and by the Book written in lines, on the widespread pages (Quran)! 7. Verse No.41/41-2 And indeed that is a dominant Book (Quran); Foul does not enter it from front or back (presently or in future); revealed gradually from the Wise and the Praiseworthy.
Qur'an is glad tiding and a warning to all archetypes . Waminan nasi mayaquloo samanna bilallhi wal akhirati , wamahum bi muminoon!(this should be our target group). What's your opinion brother??
Your answer of the question is hidden in this القرآن - سورۃ نمبر 3 آل عمران آیت نمبر 81 أَعـوذُ بِاللهِ مِنَ الشَّيْـطانِ الرَّجيـم بِسْمِ اللّٰهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ وَاِذۡ اَخَذَ اللّٰهُ مِيۡثَاقَ النَّبِيّٖنَ لَمَاۤ اٰتَيۡتُكُمۡ مِّنۡ كِتٰبٍ وَّحِكۡمَةٍ ثُمَّ جَآءَكُمۡ رَسُوۡلٌ مُّصَدِّقٌ لِّمَا مَعَكُمۡ لَـتُؤۡمِنُنَّ بِهٖ وَلَـتَـنۡصُرُنَّهٗ ؕ قَالَ ءَاَقۡرَرۡتُمۡ وَاَخَذۡتُمۡ عَلٰى ذٰ لِكُمۡ اِصۡرِىۡؕ قَالُوۡۤا اَقۡرَرۡنَا ؕ قَالَ فَاشۡهَدُوۡا وَاَنَا مَعَكُمۡ مِّنَ الشّٰهِدِيۡنَ ۞ ترجمہ: اور جب خدا نے پیغمبروں سے عہد لیا کہ جب میں تم کو کتاب اور دانائی عطا کروں پھر تمہارے پاس کوئی پیغمبر آئے جو تمہاری کتاب کی تصدیق کرے تو تمھیں ضرور اس پر ایمان لانا ہوگا اور ضرور اس کی مدد کرنی ہوگی اور (عہد لینے کے بعد) پوچھا کہ بھلا تم نے اقرار کیا اور اس اقرار پر میرا ذمہ لیا (یعنی مجھے ضامن ٹہرایا) انہوں نے کہا (ہاں) ہم نے اقرار کیا (خدا نے) فرمایا کہ تم (اس عہد وپیمان کے) گواہ رہو اور میں بھی تمہارے ساتھ گواہ ہوں
Mein nay aaj tak ants baat karte nahi dekhay :) Issi topic me meri last steam me Stoic se baat huwi thi. Long story stort: in Sulaiman's story, there are no magical djinns, no talking ants, and no queen exposing her legs
Suchwala ji seems to have very logical point, why he is giving so much stress on first person & third person. A book written in frst person is known as Autobiography ( Khuda ka kalaam )..... 2nd & 3rd person indicates BIOGRAPHY only ( NOT A KALAAM OF GOD )
If one has enough sensitivity to sense, he can even hear trees. It is a very common practice among shamans in American Native Indian culture etc. If it is possible to hear trees, why is it impossible to hear ants? It probably seems weird and impossible for an everyday street person, but it is not weird for a spiritual person, who is able to sense the message energetically. it’s just that you haven’t yet reached that level of spirituality to hear makhlooq other than humans ….some people can. And it has nothing to do with Islam.
Slamun aliyekum.....brother only TWO AL-KITAB has been send by AR - REHMAN.......... Torah..........( Moses)AL- QUR AN ( Muhammed rasool Allah SAW)........
میری دانست کے مطابق قرآن مختلف مذاہب کی کتابوں سے مستعار لے کر تیار کیا گیا ہے محمد رسول اللہ سے پہلے اور حضرت عیسٰی علیہ السلام کے درمیان ایک نبی جس کا نام مانی تھا جس کی تعلیمات حضرت محمد صلی اللہ سے ہو بہو ملتی جلتی تھیں معراج کا بیان چار نمازیں خاتم النبیین محمد رسول اللہ کے دعواجات کے مطابق ہیں آپ مانی پیغمبر کو ریسرچ کر کے سامعین کو بتائیں شکریہ
Interesting. Moadaban, mein aap ki rayay say ilmi ikhtilaf rakhta hoon. Agar Quran waqae Mani sahib se lyay gaya hota to hum is mein namaz aur meraaj paatay. Naah he Quran mein 3 ya 4 ya 5 namazain hain, na hi koyi baraaq ke oopar meraj ki kahani he.
Ye tafseel swachalaya k liye qabil qubool nahi...usko kalamullah me likha chahiye k ye allah ka kalam hai...ye uska auteraz nahi bal k uski jahiliyat aur a ilmi fuqdan ki daleel hai
موسیٰ صاحب معزرت ہے۔ اس وڈیو میں آپ نے اپنے سوال کا جواب تو دیا ہی نہیں کہ قرآن کس نے لکھا۔ اللہ نے تو نہیں لکھا نا۔ اللہ کا کلام کہا جا سکتا ہے لیکن لکھا تو خدا نے نہیں ہے نا۔ آخری سورت سے یہ کیسے پتا چلتا ہے کہ یہ قرآن خدا نے لکھا ہے۔ یہ سورت تو صرف ایک دعویٰ ہے۔
Kitab pe likay alfaz insaan kay hain. Is baat pe behas ka socha bhi nahi ja sakta. Jis ko isay Allah ka kalaam nahi maana, usay koyi force nahi kar sakta
I can understand why you don't agree to Al Moses logical explanation. Truth is you left Islam in hurry thinking everything written is illogical in translation and tafseer. You wanted to become logical person. But u never went in depth with this Book by your own mind. Now when somebody is giving logic you will say I don't believe because it will be against your current position. Dear brother even if 99% muslims are giving wrong interpretation to 99℅ part of this Book but real truth is always logical. The wrong ideology what majority Muslims use to interpret quran with use of other Books you also are falling in same trap. There are many verses in Quran which says this is complete book for your guidance. It is best tafseer of it's own. So explanation of one topic with reference to multiple ayaat is very logical. One more reference I will give from this book, God says when people try to interpret in this Quran by sticking to itself then disbeliever will reject it because Allah puts a veil between the listener and interpreter.
تم جو بھی ہو ، بے قوف ہو ، آپ نے وڈیو میں جو سوال اٹھایا اس کا جواب اللّٰہ کی کتاب سے جواب نہیں دیا آپ کی تنقید غلط ہے ۔اور قرآن اللّٰہ کی کتاب کا صفعاتی نام ہے کوئی علحیدہ کتاب نہیں اور بینا ید ہی کے معنی دو ہاتھوں کے درمیان ۔
Quran was a writing, a Book, from the very start of its revelation; and it was Mohammad pbuh who managed to keep the revelations in the Book Form constantly as it continued being revealed bit by bit. None other than the Almighty Himself testifies to it. Therefore, all theories about its “jamaa’ and tadween” in the period after Prophet Mohammad, stand invalid. These stories were concocted by enemies to relegate the stature of this Divine revelation. Please see the divine testimony in Quran’s words about its status as a Book (having been written) even when it was still being revealed:- 1. Verse No.80/11-16 No. It indeed is a remembrance/advice; So, whoever may wish, may remember it/take advice from it; it is in exalted pages, lofty in status, written by those who were highly respected scribes. 2. Verse No.85/21-22 BUT, that is an honorable Quran; in a guarded Scripture. 3. Verse No.56/77-80 I do swear by the Galaxies; and had you known it, that ’s a great oath to take; that indeed is a respected Quran; safely placed in a written volume; none may benefit from it except those with the purity of heart and mind; gradually revealed by the Lord of the Worlds. 4. Verse No.25/5 And they say, it is the ancient scriptures that he had got written; and the same is dictated by him mornings and evenings. 5. Verse No.98/2-3 A Messenger from Allah, reciting purified written pages/scriptures, wherein are established laws. 6. Verse No.52/1-3 I swear by the Toor (Quran); and by the Book written in lines, on the widespread pages (Quran)! 7. Verse No.41/41-2 And indeed that is a dominant Book (Quran); Foul does not enter it from front or back (presently or in future); revealed gradually from the Wise and the Praiseworthy. ............................................. "...Despite the controversy generated by Islamic historical sources, from a Quranic analysis it appears that the complete Quran was fully transcribed, compiled and committed to writing during the life of the Prophet. From the Quran’s perspective (without question the most reliable historical source contemporaneous to the time of the Prophet), the position that a later copy had to be collated / compiled by the companions of the Prophet seems untenable. If one accepts the testimony of the Quran, all debates surrounding the Quran being committed to writing later by the Caliphs, or the burning of certain copies, or to its insinuated redaction, missing verses, political motives, or the idea of companions writing it on leaves, animals skins or debris parchments become futile..." www.quransmessage.com/.../the%20compilation%20of...
Beautiful and very Logical Explained 👍 Keep it Bro ..... You Deserves More And More views ✌ ~Ahsaas
Appreciated
Bhai Moses Allah aap ki umar daraz karein
Allah aur aasaani faraham karein
@@AlMosesPhD Salaam, As per the Birmingham manuscripts of the Quran, which date back to the time of the Prophet Mohammad, there were no Ayraaf in the Quran. When the ayraaf were added?
@@UALIS123 Salam, there are a lot of people who've done good work there.
Best to refer to them.
The airab do not matter regardless because the text was kept in check by recitation and vice versa
❤#exmuslim sahil
The best answer is , to read surah Younus verse 37 it clearly shows the name ALLAH claiming that he is the one who produced the Quran
وَمَا كَانَ هَـٰذَا ٱلْقُرْءَانُ أَن يُفْتَرَىٰ مِن دُونِ ٱللَّهِ وَلَـٰكِن تَصْدِيقَ ٱلَّذِى بَيْنَ يَدَيْهِ وَتَفْصِيلَ ٱلْكِتَـٰبِ لَا رَيْبَ فِيهِ مِن رَّبِّ ٱلْعَـٰلَمِينَ ٣٧
اللہ آپ کو خوش رکھے۔ آمین ! جب دماغوں میں خلل ہو تو انسان سچ نہی دیکھ سکتا۔ انہوں نے ایسا ہی سوچنا ہے
My salutes to you brother Musa. Your reply to Sachwala is very logical and highly well reasoned. You are serving the cause of Al Furqan. May Allah reward you, your parents, siblings, wife and kids with His choicest blessings in both worlds and may He award you all the highest places in Jannat ul Firdous as your perpetual abodes. If I have hurt you with my comments posted earlier, I seek apologies from you and Allah. My utmost love 💕 and regards for you and everyone and everything associated with you. I again seek apologies
Great service for understanding the real message of the Quran ,
This is an excellent and logical explanation based on a purely linguistic approach. 👌👌👌👌
Shukrya Mughal bhai
اَللّٰهُ نَزَّلَ اَحۡسَنَ الۡحَدِيۡثِ كِتٰبًا مُّتَشَابِهًا مَّثَانِىَ
Hi Al Moses, thanks for sharing the video, it was thought provoking.
I'm still trying to understand whether the companions of the Prophet were responsible for compiling the Quran, and if so, were the same companions not involved in the compilation of hadiths? I get asked this question a lot by my friends.
I am a student like you who prefers logical reasoning based on evidence, and I would really appreciate your guidance. Thanks.
The Quran came through the disbelievers, the ashab, the normal lay person. They all heard, saw, read the Quran and passed on. It was ijmaa7, written + verbal.
Ahadith though are isolated historical reports whose sources cannot be verified, come from majhool people, often go against the nass of the Quran. Almost none of the ahadith are literal words of the prophet because they have been conveyed by meaning only.
🙏 Quran me jo ham ki zameer hai, shayad “Malaika”
including “Ruhul Quds” (Jibrael)
ke liye hai.
1 Note:-Allah ki taraf se, jo Bhi santence, Quran me hai,
Usme, “Main” ki zameer hai,
2 Note- “Tumhare Rab” Quran me jahan hai, wo Ruhul Quds ka Jumla hai.
Ex.Sura Baqra Ayat-30
وَ اِذۡ قَالَ رَبُّکَ لِلۡمَلٰٓئِکَۃِ اِنِّیۡ جَاعِلٌ فِی الۡاَرۡضِ خَلِیۡفَۃً
Ex
your arguments are logical.
It is quite right that the book has been sent down by Allah but the question is how it came into existence and who wrote it?
That's excellent 💖💖
This video should be uploaded on mufti yaaser nadim al wajidi channel.
A beautiful explanation.
But it is also fact that.
It is not necessary to prove Allah is first person.
Because there is no rule that author should be first person.
Thank you. I did talk to Sachwala ji with the same logic but he didn't seem to get it.
If Mufti sahib wants to put this video on his channel, then I have no issue with it. Much rather the information gets out compared to who gets the credit
First person and Third persons are very imporrtant for a book to be called Autobiography or Biography & Suchwala ji seems to have a valid point.
@@Sjk2498 Maybe Allah didn’t follow the rules, which Sachwala ji thinks are set in stone to prove who the author is. First person or third person doesn’t prove or disprove anything. Sachwala ji is only arguing for the sake of argument, with all due respect. He seems to be adamant on setting up a very specific narrative. Seeker of knowledge and truth is supposed to be humble, and flexible. He doesn’t seem to possess any of these qualities.
@@ms4050 ji, you are or may be 100% right regarding your logic that Allah does not follow our rules.
Yet, in this physical world , we can't set aside phycal rules made by we human beings !
Possibility / Belief in different kinds of God / Bhagwan / Allah etc. are also being debated by us human beings, based on our individual/ collective reasonings !!
What is your logic/reasoning / Opinion 🌸🙏
#exmuslim sahil
Well explained brother may Allah bless you always
Please not words of
Khuda / ALLAH which is right 👍???
Sir I want to talk to you personally I have to tell you something
Assalam alaikum bro Musa, please please explain what is dua and what is the correct way of asking from Allah.
SA one day inshallah
Janab/ there was a question who wrote the quran but you gave answer who sent the Quran/ Is there any proof or ayah in the quran where Allah himself said He wrote the quran and sent down exactly same written Quran???????
Also, can you tell which is the most authentic Quran? Hafs vs. Warsh
Qur'an with 95 unanimity.
There is only one Quran of the masses.
The rest are made up by 'scholars' of qiraa with even weaker asnad than ahadith
#exmuslim sahil
Roze k bare main bhi ik dares lazim Hona chaye
Dear Moses Ham ny tuj py nazil kia,haq k sath.
Who is tuj py?
To whom Rasool or Nabi is being addressed?
We know,what is haq.
When there cannot be question mark,that is haq.
What u take its meaning?
Bcoz,all which is revealed from Allah is *haq*
Ok
Aap ki baatsahi lagi
Is me audio msg ki option hini chahy
how to understand this word haram (حرام ) sacred or forbidden,
masjid wali vid dekhain
Hi Moussa Bhai,
do you have a truthfull, wisefull and insightfull translation of the verse 5:32
مِنْ أَجْلِ ذَلِكَ كَتَبْنَا عَلَى بَنِي إِسْرَائِيلَ أَنَّهُ مَن قَتَلَ نَفْسًا بِغَيْرِ نَفْسٍ أَوْ فَسَادٍ فِي الْأَرْضِ فَكَأَنَّمَا قَتَلَ النَّاسَ جَمِيعًا وَمَنْ أَحْيَاهَا فَكَأَنَّمَا أَحْيَا النَّاسَ جَمِيعًا وَلَقَدْ جَاءَتْهُمْ رُسُلُنَا بِالْبَيِّنَاتِ ثُمَّ إِنَّ كَثِيرًا مِّنْهُم بَعْدَ ذَلِكَ فِي الْأَرْضِ لَمُسْرِفُونَ
many thanks in advance
May you have a joyfull and peacefull life thanks to the rahma bringed by the qur'an
Ham jo Aya ha . Allah mumino ko apny saat shamil Kia . Es leye hum Aya ha.
Bhut khub bhut khub MashaAlla bhut acha explan kiya jazzakalla.
Alhamdulillah
It's not just "we, me he" there are other verses which give an impression that some third erson has compiled or written the book. One example: 19:85 The day WE shall gather the righteous to (Allah) Most Graciouslike a band. Who is that WE who is gathering the rightous to ALLAH.
Repeat the
Video
Same sura 19 v67 says
WE created the man
Same word in the suran 16 v4
As HE created the Man.
Your refering ayah says
The Day shall soon come when We (RAHMAN)shall bring together the God-fearing to the RAHMAN, as honoured guests.
this is style of Quran unlike human books
@@loverofindiaindian626Why insert RAHMAN in bracket and justify an erroneous statement, "how can anyone say I will take you to me"
Good work brother 👍.
I can tell you about my my research about this topic
U are always trying to Pursue the Truth .
Salad ke bare mein bataen salad time karna hai kya padhna hai
La ilahaa illallah
Accepting the use "we" for "I" is not very difficult. The problem crops when "we" becomes "he" in some ayats. The use of third person in place of first person introduces some narrator. Who is that that narrator? It is difficult to accept that Allah sometimes uses "he" for himself, and sometimes "we". If you read Genesis or The Gita, you find reported verb followed by reported speech. Reported verb identifies the speaker. If you delete reported verb, as is done in this book, then use of first person pronoun will indicate that reporter is person himself and if third person pronoun is used in reported speech, the reporter is not the person himself.
Who is that reporter whom this book does not name
Thanks for a thoughtful comment.
Can you give me an example of this?
In this video, it's clear that the action of sending is done by God who refers to himself as both He, and We in a different verse.
To ignore that, as Sachwala has done, is indefensible
Sir if you want to go through answer according to Quran it is mentioned in Surah 42:51 that there are three ways Allah speaks to a human. Since he himself is not human and is an entity which cannot be explained he uses some medium to speak. 1) he directly sends wahi/inspiration to the recipient in those ayat you will see I/we. 2) He speaks from behind hidden veil 3) He sends a messenger with message and this is the exact way in which ayats are using him in 3rd person
And this narrator is nobody except Gibreel and this can be confirmed from chapter 2 verse 97 when he brings the message those ayats are in 3rd person.
@@humanitypropagator5624 but abb kyun nahi aati khuda ki aesi koi communication kisi insaan kay sath
@@myqatar2431 jaisa uper 42:51 me likha gaya hai Allah kalam karta hai bashar(humans) se to ye baat clear hai ye har zamane me hota hai hai aur kisi insaan ke saath bhi ho sakta hai.. Quran me kahin bhi nahi likha ke ab Allah kalam nahi karta ye ek eternal book hai to har zamane me applicable hogi. Par afsos traditional islam me isko sirf nabi ya rasool ke liye hi confine kar diya gaya hai jo ki ghalat baat hai.
Allah har us insaan se communicate karta hai jo is kitab ko padhne ko koshish karte hai.. Unki zindagi ke wo saare sawaal jo usko success ki taraf le jaa sakte hain aur guidance de sakte hain isi kitab me hai... Bas insaan ko bina biased hue sirf is kitab ko padhna hai phir Allah iske zariye usse kalam karega.
#exmuslim sahil Exmuslim Sameer
#سوال۔ اللہ کی کتاب کس نے الواح میں لکھی اور کون لوگ اس کو کاغذ پر لائے۔ !!؟
بے شک قرآن بھی کتابت کیا گیا ہے اللہ نے قرآن کو لوح میں کتابت کیا ہے ۔ اللہ جواب دیتا ہے کہ ہم نے لکھا الواح میں جو لوح کی جمع ہے ، پھر تم لوگ اس کو کاغذ پر لائے۔ !!
اللہ تعالی فرماتا ہے۔
وَكَتَبْنَا لَهُۥ فِى ٱلْأَلْوَاحِ مِن كُلِّ شَىْءٍ مَّوْعِظَةً وَتَفْصِيلًا لِّكُلِّ شَىْءٍ فَخُذْهَا بِقُوَّةٍ وَأْمُرْ قَوْمَكَ يَأْخُذُوا۟ بِأَحْسَنِهَاۚ سَأُو۟رِيكُمْ دَارَ ٱلْفَٰسِقِينَ
اور ہم نے الواح میں ہر قسم کی واعظ اور ہر چیز کی تفصیل ان کو لکھ کر دی، تم ان کو پوری طاقت سے پکڑ لو اور اپنی قوم کو حکم کرو کہ ان کے اچھے اچھے احکام پر عمل کریں، اب بہت جلد تم لوگوں کو ان بے حکموں کا مقام دکھلاتا ہوں۔ 7:145
بَلْ هُوَ قُرْءَانٌ مَّجِيدٌ فِى لَوْحٍ مَّحْفُوظٍۭ
بلکہ یہ قرآن ہے بڑی شان واﻻ، لوح محفوظ میں (لکھا ہوا) 85:21/22
وَمَا قَدَرُوا اللّٰهَ حَقَّ قَدۡرِهٖۤ اِذۡ قَالُوۡا مَاۤ اَنۡزَلَ اللّٰهُ عَلٰى بَشَرٍ مِّنۡ شَىۡءٍ ؕ قُلۡ مَنۡ اَنۡزَلَ الۡـكِتٰبَ الَّذِىۡ جَآءَ بِهٖ مُوۡسٰى نُوۡرًا وَّ هُدًى لِّلنَّاسِ تَجۡعَلُوۡنَهٗ قَرَاطِيۡسَ تُبۡدُوۡنَهَا وَتُخۡفُوۡنَ كَثِيۡرًا ۚ وَعُلِّمۡتُمۡ مَّا لَمۡ تَعۡلَمُوۡۤا اَنۡتُمۡ وَلَاۤ اٰبَآؤُكُمۡؕ قُلِ اللّٰهُۙ ثُمَّ ذَرۡهُمۡ فِىۡ خَوۡضِهِمۡ يَلۡعَبُوۡنَ -
اور انہوں نے اللہ کی قدر نہیں کی، جیسا کہ اس کی قدر کرنے کا حق تھا، جب کہ انہوں نے کہا کہ اللہ نے کسی بشر پر کوئی شے نازل نہیں کی ۔ کہہ دے ’ کس نے نازل کی وہ کتاب جسے موسیٰ لے کر آئے؟ (اور جو) لوگوں کے لئے نور اور ہدایت ہیں ۔ تم نے اسے کاغذ پر کر دیا۔ (اس میں سے) کچھ کو تو تم ظاہر کرتے ہو اور بہت کچھ چھپاتے ہو۔ اور تم وہ کچھ سکھائے گئے ہو جو تم اور تمہارے آباءنہیں جانتے تھے۔ کہہ دے اللہ نے (وہ کتاب نازل کی) پھر ان کو ان کی بیکار بحثوں کے کھیل میں محو چھوڑ دے۔ 6:91
وَلَوۡ نَزَّلۡنَا عَلَيۡكَ كِتٰبًا فِىۡ قِرۡطَاسٍ فَلَمَسُوۡهُ بِاَيۡدِيۡهِمۡ لَقَالَ الَّذِيۡنَ كَفَرُوۡۤا اِنۡ هٰذَاۤ اِلَّا سِحۡرٌ مُّبِيۡنٌ -
اور اگر ہم تجھ پر کاغذ پر تحریر کردہ کتاب نازل کر دیتے، جسے وہ اپنے ہاتھوں سے چھو بھی لیتے تو پھر بھی وہ لوگ جنہوں نے انکار کیا یہی کہتے کہ بے شک یہ تو صریحاً ایک جادو ہی ہے۔ 6:7
إِنَّ عَلَيْنَا جَمْعَهُۥ وَقُرْءَانَهُۥ
اس کا جمع کرنا اور پڑھنا ہمارے ذمہ ہے.75:17.
th-cam.com/video/x6U_MW4lrE4/w-d-xo.html
#سوال۔ اللہ کی کتاب کس نے لکھی؟
m.th-cam.com/video/aEma10vaebU/w-d-xo.html
#سوال۔ کیا قرآن کا مصنف اللہ نہیں ہے ۔؟ کیا اللہ نے شروع سے اس کو جمع اور محفوظ نہیں کی ہے۔؟
th-cam.com/video/gYbwos0F1cg/w-d-xo.html
Sachwala knows every thing.. He wants to create problems by asking such Question
موسی صاحب اپکا ترجمہ کیا ھوا قران بمعہ تفسیر مجھے چاھیے ۔
Sorry, na mein nay tarjama kya hay, na hi koyi filhal irada hay
Hum aur Woh equal kaise
Watch my latest video.
"The Qur'an is kalamullah" is a belief whether based on the Qur'an or Qur'an plus other books.
Why would Allah confuse with i, he and we? Is not he royal when 🤙 jg himself he or I?
If you wish to learn, that question has already been covered here
@@AlMosesPhD the post has covered that Allah has used first person, second person and third person. My question was entirely different. I didn't question your explanation.. I keep understanding various Quran only scholars.
awaz teek nahe ha
Hello AlMoses PhD,
The verse, 12/1 and 12/2, starts with “Alif, Laam, Raa” - there is no reason that there are things in the Quran that has no meaning.
Similarly, these words are used in many verses, like “Alif Laam Meem”, “saad”, “Taa Haa” etc.
I am also a student, like yourself, and it is explained by Allama Pervez Sb, where he describes these as “abbreviations” -
In these verse, the abbreviations, as explained by Allama Pervez, suggests that these are alphabets taken from the attributes of Allah described in Quran - what is your take on this please.
Regards
I am still to research this properly.
These words has meanings as you you know everything in the quran is meaningful not meaningless.
These words are called harof-e-maqtats. Those who reseach about thesewords , meanings also find it.
by voice i can clear you
@@ezzah1670 Many people said these are abbreviation after attributes of Muhammed
lIKE in surah Bakarah,alif lam meem,here alif ameen k liye,laam laan-Ul-qalb or meem Muhammad k liye istemal kr k nabi ko mukhatib kia ja rha h
Surah 52. At-Toor - Mount Sinai
This is the 52nd Surah of the Qur’an and it has 49 verses. God watched very closely the person, the character, the actions and the Mission of the exalted Messenger. This Surah is a great example of Tasreef, how beautifully the Qur’an displays its Uniform message, repeating its verses from different vantage points and in diverse facets, filling our sight and mind with décor rather than a colorless monotony.
With the Glorious Name of God, the Instant and Sustaining Source of all Mercy and Kindness
52:1 Mount Sinai stands witness.
[That this Qur’an is a Divine Writ as was the scripture of law bestowed upon Moses]
52:2 And a well-scored Book it is.
52:3 Written on fine parchment, unrolled, open for everyone to read, widely published.
[Raqq = Deer skin = Parchment. Right here is the unequivocal negation of many accounts of fabricated Hadith that the Qur’an was written on bones, date-leaves, stones etc. Manshoor = Unfolded, unrolled, available to be seen and read, open to understanding, widely distributed]
- Dr Shabbir Ahmed. The Quran as it Explains itself
Is it really 'Mount' of 'Sinai'?
جب عیسٰی علیہ سلام ماں کی گود میں کہے رہا تھا کے میں نبی بنا کر بھیجا گیا ہوں اور صاحبِ کتاب بھی ہوں کیا اس وقت عیسٰی علیہ سلام کے ہاتھ میں کتاب تھی ؟
کون جواب دے گا 😂 کتب اور الکتاب میں فرق تو ہے نا
میں۔ اور۔ ہم میں فرق کیا ان کے ذہن کا ظن نہیں؟
Qur'an kay anay ka source kia tha . Yeh aya kesay kis tarha
Aik historical document kay lyay us ki history dekhni parti hay.
Through history.
@@AlMosesPhD history say kesay pata chalay ga
Jab nabi ki history ko itni buri tarha khatam kar dia gya
To quran kay anay ki history kesay pata chalay gi
@@myqatar2431 Historical documents/manuscripts/oral tradition ko judge karnay kay many different ways hain.
Quran ki historicity kay muqablay baqi tarikh ki wuqat buhat kam hay
#exmuslim sahil
Salamun alekum
Al Moses bhai aapne ye nahi bataya ke Quran ko kisne "Likha hai??
Najil kiya bheja Allah hai isme koi doubt nahi hai lekin likha kisne hai.
Insan nay likha.
Chappi chappayi kitab aasman say nahi aayi thi
@@AlMosesPhD r u hre to misguiding muslims? Because when u prove that quran is not revealed from ALLAH on prophet muhammad ( s.a.w) then u proved that ....u dont know anything about quran .....srry to say but this is the truth ....
Al Moses bhai
Mera sawal thoda alag hai
Najjala alai"Ka ul kitaab....
Alaika" mtlab AAP par hi hota hai agar to yaha aap kaun hai
Aur unko ye baat bata kaun Raha hai
Good explains
It is a bit explanatory…but Quran not only talks about (الكتاب) but (كُتُب)…it also mentions(نصيب من الكتاب) portion of a book.Which kitab is mentioned where we have no idea?Does word “kitab” has only one meaning or different in terms of context ..In single verse word kitab is repeated also… ?No where the word kitab is mentioned with “Taurat” or “Injeel”….So it is overall confusing….
The verses u(Al Moses) referred from Quran uses "انزل" ….and it does not mean to write….
In aayat ko dekh kar lag raha hai ki Allah ne kitab ko naazil kiya….likhne ki baat nahi hai…..haan agar kitab ka lafzi maana liya jaye to phir jo translation is ki “divine writ”ki gayi hai wo sahi hoga lekin usme bhi phir masla hai….ki kya Quran “likhai”hai jo Allah ne khud likha ??ya ki “kalam “hai? ya dono hai…??
you could try watching the 'quran is not al-kitab' vid here
آپ سورہ محمد کی آیت نمبر 19 کیوں پیش نہیں کرتے جس سے واضح ہوتا ہے کہ اس کتاب کو بھیجنے والا اللہ ہے ۔
Aisi koyi baat nahi us aya mein
فَٱعْلَمْ أَنَّهُۥ لَآ إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا ٱللَّهُ وَٱسْتَغْفِرْ لِذَنۢبِكَ وَلِلْمُؤْمِنِينَ وَٱلْمُؤْمِنَٰتِ ۗ وَٱللَّهُ يَعْلَمُ مُتَقَلَّبَكُمْ وَمَثْوَىٰكُمْ ﴿١٩﴾
مٹی سے بنایا اور نطفہ سے بنایا جو مٹی سے بنا وہ اور ہے جو نطفہ سے بنا وہ اور ہے ؟
Quran word meaning itself have problem .. ikra or al Qura + al Ain means eye ball which is you will take ? There are questions about jinns how much and need Allah need their support .. there thowheed problem .. there are tree god Allah .. union of allahs ahed … even heaven where Allah runs brothel and waiting all Muslims .. there are moral value of Muhammed is big tragedy that is why quran only group coming .. but they still don’t have any idea how many ayaths are in quran .. all are problems of Islam .. the direction of salah and times of prayer .. even the manhood of mariyum
Quran is the same wazan as fuqdan, eudwan, all of which came from their root words. So Quran = something that is read out/a recitation.
If you're a real student of knowledge, you can do yourself a service and read the text yourself instead of relying on hearsay
@@AlMosesPhD you will be in great trouble .. because every language is come from one or two language like Arab is come from either Aramaic or Greek words and it is quddassa ransa ( ku. Ran ) which is to recite like it’s word meaning .. then it is not holy book .. there is so many qu. Ran at least seven types of qu. Ran .. which recites on different occasions …..
@@rgap3944 Arabic may very well have come from other languages. It's natural. All languages evolve, borrow, lend words and no one language is special or holy.
Key is to understand how a word changes when it enters a new language. Ghaliz in Arabic means strong but in Hindi/Urdi means dirty.
An academic sees how the author of a book uses a word in his own book to get its correct meaning (regardless of where that word might have come from)
@@AlMosesPhD iqra is wrong meaning.. as per me I wish it is “eye ball” or other wise al ikrah not al quran there is no word In Arabic qu.ran this is aramaic word as per your meaning
@@rgap3944 sirf wish karnay say to meanings change nahi ho jatay, hain na?
Jab aik cheez ka simple answer he, then to prove otherwise, you need to bring daleel
Awr peghambar per wahe ke dawran ye huwa ha ke Allah jab wahe Kar Raha ta to peghambar ko saat Mela Kar baat ke .ke en logo se kahu
Quran was a writing, a Book, from the very start of its revelation; and it was Mohammad pbuh who managed to keep the revelations in the Book Form constantly as it continued being revealed bit by bit. None other than the Almighty Himself testifies to it. Therefore, all theories about its “jamaa’ and tadween” in the period after Prophet Mohammad, stand invalid. These stories were concocted by enemies to relegate the stature of this Divine revelation.
Please see the divine testimony in Quran’s words about its status as a Book (having been written) even when it was still being revealed:-
1. Verse No.80/11-16
No. It indeed is a remembrance/advice; So, whoever may wish, may remember it/take advice from it; it is in exalted pages, lofty in status, written by those who were highly respected scribes.
2. Verse No.85/21-22
BUT, that is an honorable Quran; in a guarded Scripture.
3. Verse No.56/77-80
I do swear by the Galaxies; and had you known it, that ’s a great oath to take; that indeed is a respected Quran; safely placed in a written volume; none may benefit from it except those with the purity of heart and mind; gradually revealed by the Lord of the Worlds.
4. Verse No.25/5
And they say, it is the ancient scriptures that he had got written; and the same is dictated by him mornings and evenings.
5. Verse No.98/2-3
A Messenger from Allah, reciting purified written pages/scriptures, wherein are established laws.
6. Verse No.52/1-3
I swear by the Toor (Quran); and by the Book written in lines, on the widespread pages (Quran)!
7. Verse No.41/41-2
And indeed that is a dominant Book (Quran); Foul does not enter it from front or back (presently or in future); revealed gradually from the Wise and the Praiseworthy.
Zabardast sir
bhai quran kagj me kitab ki skl me likhi hui kb aai.kya insan ki paidais ke phle ya bad me.
Yeh rasool ke zamanay mein kitab ki shakal mein jama kya gaya
Qur'an is glad tiding and a warning to all archetypes .
Waminan nasi mayaquloo samanna bilallhi wal akhirati , wamahum bi muminoon!(this should be our target group).
What's your opinion brother??
'...to all archetypes.'
Nicely put.
Quran promotes rationality
Can u explain revelation within this parameter
आपकी आवाज बहुत ही स्वीट है।
मगर सच कड़वा होता है पर सच सच होता है।
ओर जुठ कितना भी मीठा क्यो ना हो जुठ हमेसा जुठ ही होता है।
Aap ne video dekhi?
Sachwala sahib ka aitraz ghalat hay.
Quran ko kis NY likha much samjh nahi aya sat lafzoon ma btao
Your answer of the question is hidden in this
القرآن - سورۃ نمبر 3 آل عمران
آیت نمبر 81
أَعـوذُ بِاللهِ مِنَ الشَّيْـطانِ الرَّجيـم
بِسْمِ اللّٰهِ الرَّحْمٰنِ الرَّحِيْمِ
وَاِذۡ اَخَذَ اللّٰهُ مِيۡثَاقَ النَّبِيّٖنَ لَمَاۤ اٰتَيۡتُكُمۡ مِّنۡ كِتٰبٍ وَّحِكۡمَةٍ ثُمَّ جَآءَكُمۡ رَسُوۡلٌ مُّصَدِّقٌ لِّمَا مَعَكُمۡ لَـتُؤۡمِنُنَّ بِهٖ وَلَـتَـنۡصُرُنَّهٗ ؕ قَالَ ءَاَقۡرَرۡتُمۡ وَاَخَذۡتُمۡ عَلٰى ذٰ لِكُمۡ اِصۡرِىۡؕ قَالُوۡۤا اَقۡرَرۡنَا ؕ قَالَ فَاشۡهَدُوۡا وَاَنَا مَعَكُمۡ مِّنَ الشّٰهِدِيۡنَ ۞
ترجمہ:
اور جب خدا نے پیغمبروں سے عہد لیا کہ جب میں تم کو کتاب اور دانائی عطا کروں پھر تمہارے پاس کوئی پیغمبر آئے جو تمہاری کتاب کی تصدیق کرے تو تمھیں ضرور اس پر ایمان لانا ہوگا اور ضرور اس کی مدد کرنی ہوگی اور (عہد لینے کے بعد) پوچھا کہ بھلا تم نے اقرار کیا اور اس اقرار پر میرا ذمہ لیا (یعنی مجھے ضامن ٹہرایا) انہوں نے کہا (ہاں) ہم نے اقرار کیا (خدا نے) فرمایا کہ تم (اس عہد وپیمان کے) گواہ رہو اور میں بھی تمہارے ساتھ گواہ ہوں
اللہ نزل احسن الحدیث کتابا متشابھا
39/22
Aur is kitab mien likha k King soliman k zamney ki ants batein kia karti thein
Mein nay aaj tak ants baat karte nahi dekhay :) Issi topic me meri last steam me Stoic se baat huwi thi. Long story stort: in Sulaiman's story, there are no magical djinns, no talking ants, and no queen exposing her legs
Suchwala ji seems to have very logical point, why he is giving so much stress on first person & third person.
A book written in frst person is known as Autobiography ( Khuda ka kalaam )..... 2nd & 3rd person indicates BIOGRAPHY only ( NOT A KALAAM OF GOD )
If one has enough sensitivity to sense, he can even hear trees. It is a very common practice among shamans in American Native Indian culture etc. If it is possible to hear trees, why is it impossible to hear ants? It probably seems weird and impossible for an everyday street person, but it is not weird for a spiritual person, who is able to sense the message energetically. it’s just that you haven’t yet reached that level of spirituality to hear makhlooq other than humans ….some people can. And it has nothing to do with Islam.
@M S In the time of salmon ants used to converse with each other incorporating the sense of time?
@@stormpilot7477 ji, your sense of humour is also par excellent 🌸🙏
Sachwala sahabka jawab kya hai
Ye sachwala sahab kon hain
Slamun aliyekum.....brother only TWO AL-KITAB has been send by AR - REHMAN.......... Torah..........( Moses)AL- QUR AN ( Muhammed rasool Allah SAW)........
SA, I have a diff understanding
I've talked about al-kitab in an Urdu video
Only one kitab no other books Torah sifati Naam hai kitab ka kitab ek hi hai Shuru se (6:83 to 89)
میری دانست کے مطابق
قرآن مختلف مذاہب کی کتابوں سے مستعار لے کر تیار کیا گیا ہے محمد رسول اللہ سے پہلے اور حضرت عیسٰی علیہ السلام کے درمیان ایک نبی جس کا نام مانی تھا جس کی تعلیمات حضرت محمد صلی اللہ سے ہو بہو ملتی جلتی تھیں معراج کا بیان چار نمازیں خاتم النبیین محمد رسول اللہ کے دعواجات کے مطابق ہیں آپ مانی پیغمبر کو ریسرچ کر کے سامعین کو بتائیں شکریہ
Interesting.
Moadaban, mein aap ki rayay say ilmi ikhtilaf rakhta hoon. Agar Quran waqae Mani sahib se lyay gaya hota to hum is mein namaz aur meraaj paatay. Naah he Quran mein 3 ya 4 ya 5 namazain hain, na hi koyi baraaq ke oopar meraj ki kahani he.
Ye tafseel swachalaya k liye qabil qubool nahi...usko kalamullah me likha chahiye k ye allah ka kalam hai...ye uska auteraz nahi bal k uski jahiliyat aur a ilmi fuqdan ki daleel hai
Aik point ke baad, insan ko pata chal jaata hay jab doosra insaan koyi bhi daleel mannay kay mood mein nahin.
موسیٰ صاحب معزرت ہے۔ اس وڈیو میں آپ نے اپنے سوال کا جواب تو دیا ہی نہیں کہ قرآن کس نے لکھا۔ اللہ نے تو نہیں لکھا نا۔ اللہ کا کلام کہا جا سکتا ہے لیکن لکھا تو خدا نے نہیں ہے نا۔
آخری سورت سے یہ کیسے پتا چلتا ہے کہ یہ قرآن خدا نے لکھا ہے۔ یہ سورت تو صرف ایک دعویٰ ہے۔
Kitab pe likay alfaz insaan kay hain. Is baat pe behas ka socha bhi nahi ja sakta.
Jis ko isay Allah ka kalaam nahi maana, usay koyi force nahi kar sakta
Hum ne bhaija iss mein bhaija kahan hay
تنزيل اور إنزال کا مطلب بھیجنا نہیں ہے
I totally disagree with you
Ye sachwala to gumrah hindo ha
I don't agree with your explanation. Musa
woh aap ka haq he. Koyi khaas baat thi jis pe aap ko aitraz tha?
I can understand why you don't agree to Al Moses logical explanation. Truth is you left Islam in hurry thinking everything written is illogical in translation and tafseer. You wanted to become logical person. But u never went in depth with this Book by your own mind. Now when somebody is giving logic you will say I don't believe because it will be against your current position. Dear brother even if 99% muslims are giving wrong interpretation to 99℅ part of this Book but real truth is always logical.
The wrong ideology what majority Muslims use to interpret quran with use of other Books you also are falling in same trap. There are many verses in Quran which says this is complete book for your guidance. It is best tafseer of it's own. So explanation of one topic with reference to multiple ayaat is very logical.
One more reference I will give from this book, God says when people try to interpret in this Quran by sticking to itself then disbeliever will reject it because Allah puts a veil between the listener and interpreter.
He has his own reservations...besides he only criticizes the things and never gives an alternative or a solution...
اللہ نزل احسن الحدیث کتابا والی آ یت آپکے علم میں نہیں کیا۔۔۔۔۔۔یہی آ یت جھوٹے سچوالیکو بتانا تھی نا
Jhoot wala ji ko ALLAH HIDAYAT DE
Is jahil ki misal un bani Israel k logo jaisi h jinhone musa(as) se kaha tha k jab tak ham alllah ko dekh nhi lete ham nahi manege 😁😁
السلام علیکم
موسیٰ بہائ توریت اور انجیل کا مطلب بتایں۔
SA, mujhay aur tafakur karna hay
@@AlMosesPhD aap ke is tahqeeq ka intezar karunga
#exmuslim sahil
If A understands B and B understands C, does it mean A understands C?
خدا لفظ فارسی ہے
Masha Allah bhai🥀
Shukrya
Don't agree.
A=B but B Not equal to C.
सच वाला है ठीक हैं तुम झूठे
हो जाकर बात करो यहाँ किसको बता रहा हैं
मोहम्मद ने 6 साल की आएसा से शादी क्यु की
बात खत्म
th-cam.com/video/VCLHVn_xU-Q/w-d-xo.html
تم جو بھی ہو ، بے قوف ہو ، آپ نے وڈیو میں جو سوال اٹھایا اس کا جواب اللّٰہ کی کتاب سے جواب نہیں دیا آپ کی تنقید غلط ہے ۔اور قرآن اللّٰہ کی کتاب کا صفعاتی نام ہے کوئی علحیدہ کتاب نہیں اور بینا ید ہی کے معنی دو ہاتھوں کے درمیان ۔
Ap koyi ilmi daleel say baat karni ho, to most welcome.
Otherwise, aap ki marzi jo chahay maanay.
Iipc channel you tube Muhammad shaikh
Quran was a writing, a Book, from the very start of its revelation; and it was Mohammad pbuh who managed to keep the revelations in the Book Form constantly as it continued being revealed bit by bit. None other than the Almighty Himself testifies to it. Therefore, all theories about its “jamaa’ and tadween” in the period after Prophet Mohammad, stand invalid. These stories were concocted by enemies to relegate the stature of this Divine revelation.
Please see the divine testimony in Quran’s words about its status as a Book (having been written) even when it was still being revealed:-
1. Verse No.80/11-16
No. It indeed is a remembrance/advice; So, whoever may wish, may remember it/take advice from it; it is in exalted pages, lofty in status, written by those who were highly respected scribes.
2. Verse No.85/21-22
BUT, that is an honorable Quran; in a guarded Scripture.
3. Verse No.56/77-80
I do swear by the Galaxies; and had you known it, that ’s a great oath to take; that indeed is a respected Quran; safely placed in a written volume; none may benefit from it except those with the purity of heart and mind; gradually revealed by the Lord of the Worlds.
4. Verse No.25/5
And they say, it is the ancient scriptures that he had got written; and the same is dictated by him mornings and evenings.
5. Verse No.98/2-3
A Messenger from Allah, reciting purified written pages/scriptures, wherein are established laws.
6. Verse No.52/1-3
I swear by the Toor (Quran); and by the Book written in lines, on the widespread pages (Quran)!
7. Verse No.41/41-2
And indeed that is a dominant Book (Quran); Foul does not enter it from front or back (presently or in future); revealed gradually from the Wise and the Praiseworthy.
.............................................
"...Despite the controversy generated by Islamic historical sources, from a Quranic analysis it appears that the complete Quran was fully transcribed, compiled and committed to writing during the life of the Prophet.
From the Quran’s perspective (without question the most reliable historical source contemporaneous to the time of the Prophet), the position that a later copy had to be collated / compiled by the companions of the Prophet seems untenable.
If one accepts the testimony of the Quran, all debates surrounding the Quran being committed to writing later by the Caliphs, or the burning of certain copies, or to its insinuated redaction, missing verses, political motives, or the idea of companions writing it on leaves, animals skins or debris parchments become futile..."
www.quransmessage.com/.../the%20compilation%20of...