He revealed a lot. What an interesting way to describe their minor 'industry' funders (3% of $3million?) who are under particular 'threat' (grog, tobacco and sodas). Sounds so innocent, I almost feel sorry for them. Wish it was longer. Thumbs up to Guyon. Well done for the challenge.
The Taxpayers Union needs to extend to Ratepayers, who are getting smashed the the moment with 20% rates increases and councils imposing claims on titles and funding debt off back of value of private property and their ability to use this as security.
For sure, but the "taxpayers union" doesn't support taxpayers. It supports big corporate interests who pay as little tax as possible, certainly a lower % of tax than you do. Also, it's not a union.
@@JamesFactionHave a crack at watching the interview if you want that debunked. To answer the original question, affiliated group “ratepayer’s alliance” is what you’re after.
@@jonnyk5614 I watched the interview. You're talking nonsense. Just because Williams says otherwise doesn't mean he's 100% in the pocket of big business and backed by the Atlas Network. He is not on the side of ratepayers. Nor on the side of 99% of taxpayers. He's on the side of the hyper-rich who want to pay less tax. And still not a Union. None of that was "debunked".
No its not - prove your point please. I can honestly say - they do great work. If you don't like them, don't listen. The negative comments on this come across like Trolls.
@@alman-world I don't like them, and i will listen, because they are an anti-democratic lobby group who threaten the best interests of the majority of New Zealanders. You sound more like a troll than I do, honestly.
@firefox5926 opening up NZ economically with Douglas, making hard decisions with Douglas and Richardson and reducing government debt in the case of Cullen.
@firefox5926 If the government's fiscal position was not so negative and World Economics not was not good at the time, Roger Douglas's ( Thatcher ) thinking would not have become fact. He sold productive assets ( taxpayers /citizens assets), which meant we lost the income streams to pay or contribute to interest on debt. Furthermore we reduced governments ability to influence the market.
Sorry - I fund them, and they are nothing about Tobacco and Oil compared to all their other issues. Guyon thinks he focused on this - but it is only 2 points of dozens.
I'm not on his side but that's harsh bro, Ben Shapiro is a weasel looking zionist fool that people think is smart because he talks fast. This guy only sounds like a weasel.
The taxpayers union members who don’t want to pay tax and support a fair society can each go to desert islands and make their wealth there alone as individuals
here we go, a start towards money and influence in our politics. They say for the tax payers, more like a subsidiary of National/ACT big money/business
So why did David Seymour who like Jordan Williams has a MBA from the Atlas Network in North America flat our lie and scathingly insult and dismiss Mihingaarangi Forbes as a Pizza gate conspiracy theorist when she asked him in an interview earlier this year if he any connections to the Atlas Network ???
Had to ask twice what the atlas network was- people who want to hide something will always spin off on a tangent to obfuscate- he did that again and again ...and again. Good work Guy.
It was neither - just an attack piece. Trying to say Scandinavia was great - left wing high tax. They made their money on OIL production. They have state investment funds !!!!
Because he doesn't want to be look at as the guy whose backing up dodgy big company's especially tobacco. Because that's what his whole job is doing...he literally questions the govt for charging tobacco and alcohol to much tax.
I wasn't sure how fair this would be - then saw Guyon's shirt. I really shouldn't have expected anything fair. Government (more so under Jacinda and Grant) funded we can't expect anything but a view against the centre or right, even if thats the fairly elected Government.
No difference with this guy to the years of trampling on workers rights during the Douglas/Richardson years of corporateising profits and socializing losses. Comparing the economies of NZ and AU is a fatuous exercise where AU is rich in minerals where our country is primarily farming and horticulture.
I thought Williams kept wasting time deflecting with tangents and Espiner has to almost shout to get him back to answering the question. I’d say we see what we want to see.
Follow who donates and who benefits from the policies they espouse and it’s clear who they represent. Just another disingenuous use of language to create smoke and mirrors.
I donate as a private citizen. I benefit by pushing government to reduce ALL spending everywhere. We cannot allow the state an 80% increase in state spending in the last 5-8 years and NO real outcome.
@@DaParty3473 Because it is a liberal left wing symbol, and opens any dialogue that the interviewer has a position already. Thats why not. #TakeBackTheRainbow
Let the guest finish his sentences. If he is in favour of Finnish system good. But how is he going to control the quality, and why can't the government do that. Private contracting has led to terrible quality - roads, mental health support for just 2 examples. Free speech - is not freedom to lie, or to publish hate. Speech is different from publication. There is no free speech without informed facts. Very interesting! thanks
Every question tries to be a I gotcha by the interviewer but all fail miserably. This sort of interview is the definition of RNZ. Totally biased with no neutrality whatsoever and the lgtbtv4k tea shirt is the iceing on top.
@nathanbombardo spot the right winger in the comments. There's no bias here, Guyon is trying to get some truth out of the guy while he continuously spouts PR double-speak.
Not really, it affects the profits they make, the price is mostly influenced by supply and demand. Private businesses are incentivized to reduce waste because they get to keep any savings. When Governments run out of money they can just demand more.
Yes, we are one people with 3 languages. Te Reo Maori and Tikanga is part of our country. We can either be racist assholes or celebrate what makes us unique in the world
He revealed a lot. What an interesting way to describe their minor 'industry' funders (3% of $3million?) who are under particular 'threat' (grog, tobacco and sodas). Sounds so innocent, I almost feel sorry for them. Wish it was longer. Thumbs up to Guyon. Well done for the challenge.
Guyon showed himself as an attack dog, with an agenda and no real fair or balanced outcomes.
I think what he's saying there is that 97% of 3million is from individuals
Great interview Guyon Espiner bringing Jordan Williams back on track to answering the Questions
But those questions were silly. It was an attack piece with no basis.
Nah the questions were fine. chill
The Taxpayers Union needs to extend to Ratepayers, who are getting smashed the the moment with 20% rates increases and councils imposing claims on titles and funding debt off back of value of private property and their ability to use this as security.
For sure, but the "taxpayers union" doesn't support taxpayers. It supports big corporate interests who pay as little tax as possible, certainly a lower % of tax than you do. Also, it's not a union.
@@JamesFactionHave a crack at watching the interview if you want that debunked.
To answer the original question, affiliated group “ratepayer’s alliance” is what you’re after.
@@jonnyk5614 I watched the interview. You're talking nonsense. Just because Williams says otherwise doesn't mean he's 100% in the pocket of big business and backed by the Atlas Network. He is not on the side of ratepayers. Nor on the side of 99% of taxpayers. He's on the side of the hyper-rich who want to pay less tax. And still not a Union. None of that was "debunked".
Look at any conflict in the world and you'll find several big think tanks in the mix.
"New Zealand Taxpayers Union". Not in NZ's best interests, not for taxpayers, not a union. Their entire name every word in their name is a lie.
No its not - prove your point please.
I can honestly say - they do great work. If you don't like them, don't listen. The negative comments on this come across like Trolls.
Yep they are absolute foreign grifters out to turn us in to cash cows for their self serving fantasy no one asked for
@@alman-world I don't like them, and i will listen, because they are an anti-democratic lobby group who threaten the best interests of the majority of New Zealanders. You sound more like a troll than I do, honestly.
Atlas network is international @@alman-world
As soon as he said Ruth Richardson I'm like 'nah bro'
The second best Finance Minister after Roger Douglas and before Michael Cullen!
@@morgan_kemp best in what regard?
@firefox5926 opening up NZ economically with Douglas, making hard decisions with Douglas and Richardson and reducing government debt in the case of Cullen.
@firefox5926 If the government's fiscal position was not so negative and World Economics not was not good at the time, Roger Douglas's ( Thatcher ) thinking would not have become fact. He sold productive assets ( taxpayers /citizens assets), which meant we lost the income streams to pay or contribute to interest on debt. Furthermore we reduced governments ability to influence the market.
@@morgan_kempCullen setting up Kiwi Saver and Super Fund.
Tax payers Union aka Atlas Network big tobacco and oil.
Sorry - I fund them, and they are nothing about Tobacco and Oil compared to all their other issues.
Guyon thinks he focused on this - but it is only 2 points of dozens.
@@alman-world you need to do your research! If you find tax payers Union, you’re funding Atlas Network agenda’s.
I’m a member. So thrilled to support the tax payers union. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Why? What work do they do that has value to you?
oh for silly
you need to think a bit more about climate change and how awful this lot is
Ok,Super hard right of the right 😂😂😂
Clear , considered answers Jordon , that’s why I suport Tax Payers Union , another donation coming your way today 😊
Same. Thanks
Shadow Governments.
Good interview. Guyon specialises in trying to catch you out but didn’t succeed.
Really has the Ben Shapiro look down to a T
Great. Ben is a great policy and position supporter.
I'm not on his side but that's harsh bro, Ben Shapiro is a weasel looking zionist fool that people think is smart because he talks fast. This guy only sounds like a weasel.
Hope Guyon provides the same rigour to unions supporting the Labour party, and source of funds for Helen Clark Foundation.
He won't - paid off like the rest of the media. I honestly believe that and follow the money on that issue.
Get him guyon!
The taxpayers union members who don’t want to pay tax and support a fair society can each go to desert islands and make their wealth there alone as individuals
Alcohol, Sugar and Smokes Jordan? All the good BAD Stuff!
here we go, a start towards money and influence in our politics. They say for the tax payers, more like a subsidiary of National/ACT big money/business
Yep, the people who they lobby the govt for are the top end, the ones who actually pay less tax than the rest of us.
THats because Labour, Greens and Te Pati only want higher taxes.
Sounds like a fair position.
So why did David Seymour who like Jordan Williams has a MBA from the Atlas Network in North America flat our lie and scathingly insult and dismiss Mihingaarangi Forbes as a Pizza gate conspiracy theorist when she asked him in an interview earlier this year if he any connections to the Atlas Network ???
Had to ask twice what the atlas network was- people who want to hide something will always spin off on a tangent to obfuscate- he did that again and again ...and again. Good work Guy.
Guyon gave it away - not an interview. It was a debate. The contrast with his style for people he supports is very clear.
And the problem is?
It was neither - just an attack piece.
Trying to say Scandinavia was great - left wing high tax. They made their money on OIL production.
They have state investment funds !!!!
It was an interview, Guyon asked questions, Jordan did his best PR spin in replying to them.
@@alman-world why does it matter where their wealth comes from? They have a high standard of living and high taxation. That's the main point
Does the Taxpayers Union look at private businesses practice to pass on costs without reviewing its expected rate of return in a particular year.
Of course not, they are a straight up govt lobby group only interested in influencing our politics
Ask the Commerce Commission
Oh no, someone called him right wing!! Why is he so ansty about it? Almost as if being right wing is a bad thing...
It is bad it’s about greed brutality and deliberate poverty inflicted on the vulnerable. Equivalent to sanction rape.
Because he doesn't want to be look at as the guy whose backing up dodgy big company's especially tobacco.
Because that's what his whole job is doing...he literally questions the govt for charging tobacco and alcohol to much tax.
It's not a bad thing. Right wing is not bad.
@alman6581 depends who you ask.
As long as:
Overall people benefit > singular person capitalizing
@@numnum5 depends if 'overall' is code for socialism and communism
The lightbulb moment lol THE MONEY!!!!
What an absolute puts. Obviously part of a terrible people club and you can't deny it
TPU IS HARD RIGHT!
What's the maori party?
@@nathanbombardo Good point. TPM are ethno-fascists.
@@nathanbombardo Hard left separatist
What is hard right.................can you define that.
absolutely 💯
Sir R Jones! Does he give free rent to other organizations?
I wasn't sure how fair this would be - then saw Guyon's shirt. I really shouldn't have expected anything fair. Government (more so under Jacinda and Grant) funded we can't expect anything but a view against the centre or right, even if thats the fairly elected Government.
That's so brill right?
No difference with this guy to the years of trampling on workers rights during the Douglas/Richardson years of corporateising profits and socializing losses.
Comparing the economies of NZ and AU is a fatuous exercise where AU is rich in minerals where our country is primarily farming and horticulture.
I wonder how much revenue from royalisties does the Oz government get compared to nz?
A USA economist has shown that since the mid 80s production gains have been passed on to employees at lower % than when unionized workforce existed.
It's the decisions we make, we have a lot of minerals we refuse to dig up. Singapore is also rich with a similar population and no natural resources.
The NZ First MP they talked about could the police minister. Being part of HOBSON pledge and the Taxpayers Union suggests she stong views in a direct.
Terrible interviewer. Constantly shouting over mr Williams
Exactly
I thought Williams kept wasting time deflecting with tangents and Espiner has to almost shout to get him back to answering the question. I’d say we see what we want to see.
Follow who donates and who benefits from the policies they espouse and it’s clear who they represent. Just another disingenuous use of language to create smoke and mirrors.
I donate as a private citizen. I benefit by pushing government to reduce ALL spending everywhere.
We cannot allow the state an 80% increase in state spending in the last 5-8 years and NO real outcome.
Why is Guyon wearing rainbow?
Why not?
@DaParty3473 so it would ok for Jordon to wear Maga cap too?
@@andrewking9435he is wearing one though!
@@DaParty3473
Because it is a liberal left wing symbol, and opens any dialogue that the interviewer has a position already.
Thats why not.
#TakeBackTheRainbow
@@fumikoisadog3023 And the issue with that?
All hands
Atlas Network and proud lol
Yep
Taxpayers = ATLAS
Wearing a suit can create dominance compared to t-shirts.
News flash- it’s now 2024. 🤣
Funny its called a union with views antithetical to socialism
Yeah - but a Union is a 'Union' a grouping for supporting the views of a group. It does exactly that
Let the guest finish his sentences. If he is in favour of Finnish system good. But how is he going to control the quality, and why can't the government do that. Private contracting has led to terrible quality - roads, mental health support for just 2 examples.
Free speech - is not freedom to lie, or to publish hate. Speech is different from publication. There is no free speech without informed facts.
Very interesting! thanks
He is not a guest. He is being interviewed.
@@kathyvoyles Don't you have a lollipop to turn? With apologies to the lollipop workers who would make far more intelligent remarks than yours.
I have no doubt that I'm intellectually honest. What a pile of crock.
14:00 mmm about that and how are we defining poverty here ? and how many of those billion people are living in say china ?
Lol Williams trying to sell us on How Wonderful, helpful and TRUSTWORTHY, the ATLAS NETWORK are.....
..no thanks.
Free rent?
Out of Bob's kind heart.
Ha ha ha
Yep - exactly because he supports these viewpoints.
1st question
what is the taxpayers union trying to achieve?
answer..protection of the albino snail 😂
sounds like the treaty principles bill
See this guy is not wearing a tie! Government ministers have stopped wearing ties in many interviews . They are changing the image !
Who actually cares about ties?
And the point is?
Maybe a better name Union sounds left wing, maybe Tax Payers action Community TPAC
Espinners obvious bias against business success and obvious bias to socialism is apparent. How about balance.
Every question tries to be a I gotcha by the interviewer but all fail miserably. This sort of interview is the definition of RNZ. Totally biased with no neutrality whatsoever and the lgtbtv4k tea shirt is the iceing on top.
Sorry, Where's the Bias?
cry harder
@@NathanOrmsbyKCOG womp womp
@nathanbombardo spot the right winger in the comments. There's no bias here, Guyon is trying to get some truth out of the guy while he continuously spouts PR double-speak.
They didn't fail at all...optics.....actions speak louder than words
What waste happens in private businesses? It affects the price people pay.
Not really, it affects the profits they make, the price is mostly influenced by supply and demand. Private businesses are incentivized to reduce waste because they get to keep any savings. When Governments run out of money they can just demand more.
so working in food rescue. We waste 30 % of all food in NZ
Lyin'luxon n his tobacco lobbyist goons
Lying about what exactly?
Forget about you Maori introduction we are one people one country
Bye
Haere ra!
Yes, we are one people with 3 languages. Te Reo Maori and Tikanga is part of our country. We can either be racist assholes or celebrate what makes us unique in the world
Exactly - Marxism is Intersectionality
@@JamesFaction No 0 a ot more than 3x languages. But many many more cultures. No one should get preference.