Where Do Delhiites Stand on The Farmers’ Protests I Delhi I Farm Laws I Farmer Protest
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 19 ม.ค. 2021
- The ongoing farmers’ protests have attracted various shades of opinion since they began last year. Farmers have received an outpouring of support from across the board - from agricultural economists, politicians and lawyers to artists, workers and students. But where does the average citizen of Delhi - the city that denied farmers entry and at whose borders they sit in resistance - stand vis-a-vis the protestors?
As farmers, undeterred by hostilities, cross fifty days of protesting, what do the citizens of Delhi make of the protests? Do they too express solidarity? Or do they view them as an inconvenience? Do they think the farmers are justified in their insistence on a repeal of the three laws? Or do they hope for quick resolution, the arrival at a middle-ground, with the Supreme Court’s intervention? The Wire collects the voices of the people.
Like our work? Click here to support The Wire: thewire.in/support
The founding premise of The Wire is this: if good journalism is to survive and thrive, it can only do so by being both editorially and financially independent. This means relying principally on contributions from readers and concerned citizens who have no interest other than to sustain a space for quality journalism. As a publication, The Wire will be firmly committed to the public interest and democratic values.
We publish in four different languages!
For English, visit www.thewire.in
for Hindi: thewirehindi.com/
for Urdu: thewireurdu.com
for Marathi: marathi.thewire.in
If you are a young writer or a creator, you can submit articles, essays, photos, poetry - anything that’s straight out of your imagination - to LiveWire, The Wire’s portal for the young, by the young. livewire.thewire.in/
You can also follow The Wire’s social media platforms and engage with us.
Facebook
/ thewire
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
Twitter
/ thewire_in
/ thewirehindi
/ thewireurdu
/ thewiremarathi
/ livewire
Instagram
/ thewirein
/ livewirein
Don’t forget to hit the subscribe button to never miss a video from The Wire!
![THE TOYS x NONT TANONT - ดอกไม้ที่รอฝน (spring) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/pPa1d5cC8M4/mqdefault.jpg)
The one who produce meal for India is misguided.
: Said by _The one who throw 10% of food everyday shamelessly_
I want to say a bit about the farmer situation as it seems with this protest, farmers finally getting the much needed attention from the general public to help them out, now I know currently discussion is about the recent bills but I would like to give a little analysis of mine towards the situation of farmers in general and what exactly are the problems they are facing(as you cannot help them as long as you don't know what is the issue)
Now just a side note, I am not a farmer neither belongs to a farming family and therefore I am not qualified to judge anything but as a student in economics, I can certainly give a macro economic analysis of the overall situation. It might be long but if you have time, please read this out.
Farmers in India first of all does not face one issue but several leading to this dire state of them, these are dozens in number and will be very hard to tackle at ones, some of the notable ones includes small scale, consistent exploitation, adverse market forces, issues with distribution and supply chains, lack of access to finances and capital, climatic vulnerability, access to markets, etc just to name a few. As said, difficulties are many but we can broadly categories them to 4-5 core problems as most others just branches out of these core issues
1.SCALE: according to a report, almost 87% of farmers in India are small and marginalised farmers who work on less than 2 hectares of land. It means small farmers because of their scale have to buy the inputs like seeds, fertilisers, etc at retail prices, small scale leads to higher cost of transportation proportion to crops, these farmers mostly don't have the means to store them to themselves so they mostly have to sell them immediately in the market and considering the transportation, they mostly have to sell them at their village itself and also considering almost all other farmers in the village might be doing to same thing so it basically floods the market and well "demand and supply" comes into play making them receive less income and on top of that less bargaining power leads to easier exploitation of them by the middle man, now mandi system makes the last part of selling a bit more safe with government oversight to make sure at least they get somewhat of a fair price but again it doesn't solve the entire issue.
2. Lack of crop diversity and supporting industries: India is a surplus producer of stuff like rice and wheat, we just produce too much of it while we end up importing some other major crops like pulses, now it is somewhat of a "side effect" I can say, as government gives MSP guarantee on rice and wheat in a lot instances which makes it artificially more profitable to grow than other crops even though it should have been the other way round where prices on rice and wheat should have gone down if supply is too high and discourage farmers to grow them and grow something where there is demand for or else it is just a waste of food, money, soil and effort. Now I do know the issue with this as farmers fear leaving a stable and safe source for something where they end up making "less" so I feel government should introduce some sort of a "floating msp system" where msp will be set according to demand and supply
I am surprised that almost no one in India ever bothered improving the RNF sector(Rural Non-Farm Sector) at a national level, these are generally industries that are suited to operate in rural areas, it will help to diversify the rural economy, agriculture products are used in a whole basket of industries as their primary inputs on top of being used as food, so it will help to create additional demand for agricultural crops which means farmers will get more places to sell their crops
Now I would have added a few more points into it but it's already getting long and probably a lot of people might have left it half way through so for the last point which I believe can have a very big impact on agriculture but is never talked about whenever we talk about improving farmers life's and that is....
3. INDUSTRIALIZATION: it may not be agriculture itself but can surely improve the life of a lot of people who were in farming previously as it will create job opportunities for millions to come out of agriculture and shift into comparatively higher value manufacturing as service sector is legendary bad at providing enough job opportunities especially to a population as large as ours (I hope you can relate it to india) and agriculture though extremely important for "LIFE" is very bad as a source of "LIVELIHOOD" so we should focus at trying to improve productivity of a farmer so that less and less farmers can also feed the nation and shift the rest into comparatively higher value manufacturing industry.
You can add a point or two if you want and please make sure to share this to spread awareness if you think it makes sense.
Look how bhakts r reacting, can know them from their modi language.
@Shakila Bano Aap Nehru ki najayaj santan pratit hoti h
Yes only Punjabi are farmers and none others state😂😂
@@manish2991 hahaha lowde
Pta krke likha kr
Maharashtra mai kitni bdi rally hui kisaano ki
Sunaya nhi tuje kisi ne ya sunai nhi deta
Gobr khane wala hai kya🤬🤬🤬
Common people support farmers, because we can't live on digital foods.
@s1 b3 how much food grains are produced by farmers and how much are procured by govt, give actual genuine data. Why support laws which will help private players to stock unlimited quantities and create artificial demand to consumers. This is not only about farmers but also consumers. Better govt should remove Middleman in petroleum products.
@@dipankardas1760 bro dont answer these people they are beyond redemption
I will cultivate on my own land no need for donation. Those who want to donate can collect and give it to them.
Dipankar bhai just wait for little while Digital India becomes JIO India.. With Ambani signing 70 billion dollar deal with Amazon and Facebook to create digital platform in India
@@gladiatorbrar4673if they got the chance they will surely do it, Reliance Jio rising and BSNL drowning, aided by their faithful dog.
People residing in big cities does not know reality.Ultimatly they will suffer.
Rajendra Dhule,, You said it rightly
@@dang909 bilkul sahi
Ye sirf BJP supporters ka point of view hai. Anpadh point of view se seedha pata chalta hai.
Exactly
Exactly
BJP has simple funda - Divide & Rule
Sahi aa pra:)
Agreed
Shutup PAPPU ke chamche
Siddhart pandey eat Gobar do not eat food bjp soon
@@siddharthpandey8841 agaya modi feku la andh bagakt
Most important profession on the earth is farming .
I want to say a bit about the farmer situation as it seems with this protest, farmers finally getting the much needed attention from the general public to help them out, now I know currently discussion is about the recent bills but I would like to give a little analysis of mine towards the situation of farmers in general and what exactly are the problems they are facing(as you cannot help them as long as you don't know what is the issue)
Now just a side note, I am not a farmer neither belongs to a farming family and therefore I am not qualified to judge anything but as a student in economics, I can certainly give a macro economic analysis of the overall situation. It might be long but if you have time, please read this out.
Farmers in India first of all does not face one issue but several leading to this dire state of them, these are dozens in number and will be very hard to tackle at ones, some of the notable ones includes small scale, consistent exploitation, adverse market forces, issues with distribution and supply chains, lack of access to finances and capital, climatic vulnerability, access to markets, etc just to name a few. As said, difficulties are many but we can broadly categories them to 4-5 core problems as most others just branches out of these core issues
1.SCALE: according to a report, almost 87% of farmers in India are small and marginalised farmers who work on less than 2 hectares of land. It means small farmers because of their scale have to buy the inputs like seeds, fertilisers, etc at retail prices, small scale leads to higher cost of transportation proportion to crops, these farmers mostly don't have the means to store them to themselves so they mostly have to sell them immediately in the market and considering the transportation, they mostly have to sell them at their village itself and also considering almost all other farmers in the village might be doing to same thing so it basically floods the market and well "demand and supply" comes into play making them receive less income and on top of that less bargaining power leads to easier exploitation of them by the middle man, now mandi system makes the last part of selling a bit more safe with government oversight to make sure at least they get somewhat of a fair price but again it doesn't solve the entire issue.
2. Lack of crop diversity and supporting industries: India is a surplus producer of stuff like rice and wheat, we just produce too much of it while we end up importing some other major crops like pulses, now it is somewhat of a "side effect" I can say, as government gives MSP guarantee on rice and wheat in a lot instances which makes it artificially more profitable to grow than other crops even though it should have been the other way round where prices on rice and wheat should have gone down if supply is too high and discourage farmers to grow them and grow something where there is demand for or else it is just a waste of food, money, soil and effort. Now I do know the issue with this as farmers fear leaving a stable and safe source for something where they end up making "less" so I feel government should introduce some sort of a "floating msp system" where msp will be set according to demand and supply
I am surprised that almost no one in India ever bothered improving the RNF sector(Rural Non-Farm Sector) at a national level, these are generally industries that are suited to operate in rural areas, it will help to diversify the rural economy, agriculture products are used in a whole basket of industries as their primary inputs on top of being used as food, so it will help to create additional demand for agricultural crops which means farmers will get more places to sell their crops
Now I would have added a few more points into it but it's already getting long and probably a lot of people might have left it half way through so for the last point which I believe can have a very big impact on agriculture but is never talked about whenever we talk about improving farmers life's and that is....
3. INDUSTRIALIZATION: it may not be agriculture itself but can surely improve the life of a lot of people who were in farming previously as it will create job opportunities for millions to come out of agriculture and shift into comparatively higher value manufacturing as service sector is legendary bad at providing enough job opportunities especially to a population as large as ours (I hope you can relate it to india) and agriculture though extremely important for "LIFE" is very bad as a source of "LIVELIHOOD" so we should focus at trying to improve productivity of a farmer so that less and less farmers can also feed the nation and shift the rest into comparatively higher value manufacturing industry.
You can add a point or two if you want and please make sure to share this to spread awareness if you think it makes sense.
@@manmeesarma2413 Every thing is and will be the same like before pluss a free hand for the farmer to decide whom to sell. Cold rooms already exists. With contract farming the buyer will come to thw crop to pick up stuff. Pre sold and farmer can cancell contract anytime. What else they want.
The issues is middle man, I issues is anti modi gang. The issues is kalistanues and wampanties who cant resist growth in Modis rule, cant make farmers beat Chinese and canadian agri market.
Plz follow Sushant Sinha or Nitin Shukla too on youtube. Some of the best ground reporters.
@@manmeesarma2413 why shouldn't govt become middlemen between private player and farmers and you should think about inequality among farmers small and marginal farmers will be exploited
@@Gharwapas Tu kheti kar phir samjhana
@@virendrabijarania3167 mie acche accho ki kheti karta hoon khalistaan mie. Chaho tou ginadoon?
The tragedy of our country is that majority of “city” youth are unaffected by the ground realities of the country. #SupportFarmers
Thats because godi media channel
City youth are unaffected because they are cut off from real life issues. Their parents gave them easy life by fulfilling their needs and demands.
Some of them are misguided by godi media with false, irrelevant , religious hatred issues. Selfish Leaders instigate them with emotional issues which are useless.
Jab onion rs 200/- kg hojayenga to city wale gussyenga lekin protest nahi karega
Protest is not cool. The situation will soon change for the better.
They are affected. But only few can have the courage of Bhagat Singh
we pay MRP(Maximum retail price)
they are asking for MSP(minimum support price)
shame on parliament if they don't agree
The govt has given in writing that msp will not be effected
Infact the girl has increased the msp for certain crops in their bill
Msp has never been part of any act. Govt just 'promises' msp and it is still doing that
@@prashantg6958 the way they promise 15 lakh rupees
@@simranjitsingh6047 no point of rhetorics. This govt has been far from good. But things should be seen in a logical light. From a neutral perspective.
@@karthikshinde6739 may no
Hats off to the kind hearted ladies there who appeared more informed and sensitive to farmers cause than their male counterparts...I wish the boys who were interviewed learn from the girls ...respect to all those stand by the farmers..
Support Farm Laws
Support farmers they are fighting for every citizen.
Fake_farmers
@Subhash Chander Madan Let them enjoy democracy 😄
@Subhash Chander Madan yahi to andhbhakto bimari h...lakho kisan baithe..whatsapp ki dunia se bahar nikal kr reality dekho...kisan apna hakk lene aaye..70 saal se har govt loot rhi....krdi na anpado vali bat..kisan kheti chod koi or profession dekhega..to tu apna khana apne ghr ki chatt pr paida krega ya ghar m gamlo m.
@@dhavalpatelp1 aa ja singhu border rpta chal jayega..
@@sukhmindersingh8584 konsi sapne ki duniya me ji rahe ho bhai ya Nasha karke bethe ho, waise bhi sabko pata chal gaya hai ki ye Fake_farmers hai. Kuch bachi kuchi izzat bhi nahi rahi abhi to. Me kyu au udhar, 26th ko jab dande pade ge tab sab bills samj ajayege. MODI tumhari soch se bhi upar nikal Chuka hai.
Even if i have to face inconveinence, i m ready for it...
That man is so true...
I really loved it when he said that.
@@lsinghsonu1136 yess... this should be the spirit of every indian.
Do you understand what the Govt amendment is? Or you just support any one because only they are protesting without understanding either it’s for right concern or not
@@uditkansal1409 yess i understand. Not a bhakt of anyone.
Me too
Supreme Court lost his belief as well as Modi government
*Faith
Modi government is doing only brokerage that’s all
It’s kinda embarrassing to see how half of the people didn’t even know how the farmer bills are affecting the farmers
Your d.p is ghannnnnnnt aww virrr jii 🤗👌
According to republic channel delhi is finished according to them
Yup... It is Finished for Balaatkari Janta Party lol
And your English is Finished.
First learn to write 😂😂
@@gauravkr4857 People supporting the " (a+b)^2 vanar clown" are talking about proficiency in English
@@gauravkr4857 Much better than the Clown who pronounced Doland Trump in Public with 56 inch Man Boobs
i just wonder.. they are living in country's capital yet they are soo blindfolded despite of having common sense and just a little bit of knowledge.. but guys i think they are aware of everything well its just that they still are supporting bjp (cunts) .
All Indians stop buying Ambani adani ramdevs products stop buying Reliance diesel petrol gas
JIO/Airtel bhi use mat karna chutiye
@@vjunloc1 teri vaddi dukhi
@@vjunloc1 thoda ja jubaan sambal k bol......kai vaari aagla tera peo(daddy) v ho skda galla kadan ch
Major part of educated delhites are wise enough to understand the problem of the farmers✌️🏻
Farmers protest is revolutionary and historical.
Ya sure, the place which represents the country our red fort ,the only flag that's supposed to be hosted there is our tiranga. Happy Republic Day, I am ashamed of what happened today this is not how u protest on such an auspicious day.It was painful. I don't know what made u think it's revolutionary but no doubt it's historical,worst Republic Day ever. I felt as if the farmers were not a part of our country "app tirange ka maan na rakh sake dil de taklif hui". App protest karte par ajj nahi ajj kiya bhi to laal kila nahi please🙏 🥺
@@purviiiiii111 khalsa da jhaanda laayea te kisaani da jhanda bhen oh flags v tuhada e aa bagaana koi ni
@@karanpalsingh9756 sorry mujhe punjabi samjh nahi ati hai
@@purviiiiii111 you will never say anything about why bjp sold red fort and for what
@@purviiiiii111 he mean to say that kissan k flag ne kese disrespect ki national flag ki becoz green colour in national flag stand for farmers
People are with the farmers of the country. God keep farmers spirit high. JAI JAWAN JAI KISAN. JAI OUR ANN DATA
Those who are speaking against the farmers they watch only and only t.v.'s bogus news.
Exactly 😂🤷♀
Please watch drishti IAS channel for this issue... Genuine info
@@ankushbhide8450 not at all the government not for once thinking about farmer's welfare. There's a lot to be read between the lines. My dear gentleman government will definitely hire people to speak in its favour be it any government.
N those who r fooled by idiots the same way farmers r also watching tv news blindly...but difference is that they spoke in English n do bla bla which is nothin more then nonsense talk😀😀😀😂😂🤣🤣😀
@@hardlines2671 can u tell me what problem these protesters have with the farm bill....I genuinely want to know
Let’s cut these professionals salaries starting 2022 - let’s see how they would feel. Farmers are asking for basics - if a bag of chips has MSRP why not the food that farmers grow!! 70% of farmers have less than 10 acres - are they sophisticated enough to negotiate with large corporations? How is that fair? India is not suppose to be an authoritarian regime. Support Farmers!
Dude in case you don't know the government already passed labor law which screwed us all working in private sector
@@akbarkhan-nq3xl Very sexist comment - dudette here😃
The Old man there was more aware than many educated young men of today.
I support farmers!! Every sane Indian citizen must stand in solidarity with our farmers!!
I can’t because they are protesting from wrong cause. You may not have understand about law that why you are standing for wrong cause
@@uditkansal1409 samjhni ki zurrrat apko ha unko pta ha voh kiss ka liya protest kar rha !
@@uditkansal1409 whats wrong in their cause?
This video, particularly the guy at @7:41 minute mark perfectly illustrates why a great many people from Delhi have a reputation of being apolitical and uninformed idiots. The privileged brats who are moaning about the "inconvenience" caused by protests have never stood for anything in their lives, or have stood for all the wrong things.
#jaikisan #inquilabzindabad
When you abolish stock limit a layman can tell prices will be hiked
9:30 aunty proved that age always does not mean being orthodox
Respect ❤❤
Ya right
Completely stand with my farmer brothers and sisters!
They r justified, we common man of India support them cos they r fighting our fight. Thx to farmers.
Everybody should come with kissans because they are fighting for common people majdoor,employees,students,small shopkeepers of India and not for cheaters and lieyer.
Support Farm Laws
Government must listen to farmers. From normal citizen to prime minister everybody is alive due to grains that farmers produce.farmers are real heroes of our nation.
As a Delhite I support farmers. Fact govt tried stopping them to protest raise concerns. Our Republic ll be dead If they keep stripping off civil liberties
th-cam.com/video/nZGUBIdT6PM/w-d-xo.html
It’s already dead
Support Delhi Police
@@siddharthpandey8841 Delhi police the traitors
7:34 He seriously has no idea about the effect of these laws, he is just talking the language of a very much biased person.
Godi media hang over i guess!!
सही कहा।
@@outdothyself5745 it can never be a hangover as hangover happens when they try to wake up, it's a wilful slumber they choose.
I am so surprised that they arent thinking even once that parliament can be wrong, court can be wrong too. Agar law banaya hain to kuch soch kar banaya hoga... OMG!!! Seriously, which world they live in. It’s your prime duty to question every move of the govt you elected to make sure it continues to work in the interest of citizens.
He watch godi media and speak what he heard from them
As a woman living in Delhi, I support the farmers' protest. Jai Jawan Jai Kisan !
9:00 इन अम्मा ने दिल जीत लिया।
नमन है इनको।
Farmers will win👍 Agar farmers hain to hum Hain🙏🙏🙏
ये गरीब वर्ग की रोटी बचाने के लिए आंदोलन है भाई बहनों कृपा करके थोड़ी सी परेशानी तो उठा लो
I want to say a bit about the farmer situation as it seems with this protest, farmers finally getting the much needed attention from the general public to help them out, now I know currently discussion is about the recent bills but I would like to give a little analysis of mine towards the situation of farmers in general and what exactly are the problems they are facing(as you cannot help them as long as you don't know what is the issue)
Now just a side note, I am not a farmer neither belongs to a farming family and therefore I am not qualified to judge anything but as a student in economics, I can certainly give a macro economic analysis of the overall situation. It might be long but if you have time, please read this out.
Farmers in India first of all does not face one issue but several leading to this dire state of them, these are dozens in number and will be very hard to tackle at ones, some of the notable ones includes small scale, consistent exploitation, adverse market forces, issues with distribution and supply chains, lack of access to finances and capital, climatic vulnerability, access to markets, etc just to name a few. As said, difficulties are many but we can broadly categories them to 4-5 core problems as most others just branches out of these core issues
1.SCALE: according to a report, almost 87% of farmers in India are small and marginalised farmers who work on less than 2 hectares of land. It means small farmers because of their scale have to buy the inputs like seeds, fertilisers, etc at retail prices, small scale leads to higher cost of transportation proportion to crops, these farmers mostly don't have the means to store them to themselves so they mostly have to sell them immediately in the market and considering the transportation, they mostly have to sell them at their village itself and also considering almost all other farmers in the village might be doing to same thing so it basically floods the market and well "demand and supply" comes into play making them receive less income and on top of that less bargaining power leads to easier exploitation of them by the middle man, now mandi system makes the last part of selling a bit more safe with government oversight to make sure at least they get somewhat of a fair price but again it doesn't solve the entire issue.
2. Lack of crop diversity and supporting industries: India is a surplus producer of stuff like rice and wheat, we just produce too much of it while we end up importing some other major crops like pulses, now it is somewhat of a "side effect" I can say, as government gives MSP guarantee on rice and wheat in a lot instances which makes it artificially more profitable to grow than other crops even though it should have been the other way round where prices on rice and wheat should have gone down if supply is too high and discourage farmers to grow them and grow something where there is demand for or else it is just a waste of food, money, soil and effort. Now I do know the issue with this as farmers fear leaving a stable and safe source for something where they end up making "less" so I feel government should introduce some sort of a "floating msp system" where msp will be set according to demand and supply
I am surprised that almost no one in India ever bothered improving the RNF sector(Rural Non-Farm Sector) at a national level, these are generally industries that are suited to operate in rural areas, it will help to diversify the rural economy, agriculture products are used in a whole basket of industries as their primary inputs on top of being used as food, so it will help to create additional demand for agricultural crops which means farmers will get more places to sell their crops
Now I would have added a few more points into it but it's already getting long and probably a lot of people might have left it half way through so for the last point which I believe can have a very big impact on agriculture but is never talked about whenever we talk about improving farmers life's and that is....
3. INDUSTRIALIZATION: it may not be agriculture itself but can surely improve the life of a lot of people who were in farming previously as it will create job opportunities for millions to come out of agriculture and shift into comparatively higher value manufacturing as service sector is legendary bad at providing enough job opportunities especially to a population as large as ours (I hope you can relate it to india) and agriculture though extremely important for "LIFE" is very bad as a source of "LIVELIHOOD" so we should focus at trying to improve productivity of a farmer so that less and less farmers can also feed the nation and shift the rest into comparatively higher value manufacturing industry.
You can add a point or two if you want and please make sure to share this to spread awareness if you think it makes sense.
@Subhash Chander Madan mujhe to tumhare comments pad kar je lag rha hai , tameez to tere maa baap ne tumhe nahi di .
@Subhash Chander Madan 2 words english ke aane se tum log Shakespeare ban jate ho . Lekin khopdi tumhari hoti khali ki khali hai . Aur upar se tumhare maa baap vi English ka 1 akshar sun kar itne khus ho jate hai , ki tum jaise logo ko tameez dena vi bhul jate hai .
Aap logo ke sath ki bhot jarurat h farmers ko kyunki modi sakar ghatiya harkto pe uttar aye h please support farmers
ਜੈ kisan ਜੈ jawan ♥️🙏🏻
We stand with farmers❤️ they are fighting their battle with all their bravery, More power to our real heros, our farmers 🙏🏻
People are being misled not the farmers.
Govt attitude is deceitful for farmers I salute those peoples who spot farmers
The government is cruel and insensitive. The process right from the beginning has been shoddy as we have witnessed in the Parliament
Respect to the some of these young and older Delhites for understanding farmers plight. To be honest I was not expecting such response as from this interview. You have given me some faith. God bless you.
If you think farmers are misled and are sitting with their kids and wives and elderly parents in a 2 degree weather because somone mislead them.. you seriously need go outside on a street in a tent and just spend one night in that temperature and then comment back can you somone be misled?
according to ur logic bjp mislead 130 crores people and won.
@@mrtecch not 130 crore on 35% percent voters
@@mrtecch EVM
Give me 10,000 then I will do it
@@fiffyfoo7612 dumass. Missing the point. Do it for free. Government didnt help these people. The farmers all collectivley brought 6 month of food supplies with them. Do it for free.. exactly. Its been over 60 days..125 plus people have died. Modi did not offer one condolenses.. 4 people die in America and Modi goes on Twitter and starts to offer condolenses.
We support farmers head and heart.
I do not know what the background of this girl is: but she said such things as that the elder people could not understand.❤️❤️❤️ ये अभी लोगो को समझ नहीं आ रहा जब लोग 10kg आटा खरीदेंगे तब समझ आएगा। आज 10 kg आटा 260 में मिल जायेगा लेकिन 5 साल बाद 10 आटा 500 में भी नहीं मिलेगा 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Shame on us that we the citizens of indian are not doing anything for farmers.
Dear the wire,
Start asking the right questions to people like:
- why do you think farmers are still sitting in cold when over 100 people have died from cold?
- why do you think farmers don't want to go to supreme Court?
- why is govt forcing the bills when nobody asked for them?
How would you feel if i force something down your throat but you don't want it?
- Delhi's people are suffering? At least they get to go home and sleep in peace. Is Delhi facing more problems than farmers on road?
-why is government doing conferences all over india but not to the farmers in Delhi?
Only 2% farmers are sitting there, how you can be so sure about all weather they need it or not. If something comes by the govt that always be the demand by the people.
@@charanjeetsingh972 Congratulations your account has been credited with 2 rupees for a comment !
What are you trying to say? Articulate it properly
True, the Wire is also asking yes no questions!
Kisan demands just right demand for future of seventy percent of Indian People.
I want to say a bit about the farmer situation as it seems with this protest, farmers finally getting the much needed attention from the general public to help them out, now I know currently discussion is about the recent bills but I would like to give a little analysis of mine towards the situation of farmers in general and what exactly are the problems they are facing(as you cannot help them as long as you don't know what is the issue)
Now just a side note, I am not a farmer neither belongs to a farming family and therefore I am not qualified to judge anything but as a student in economics, I can certainly give a macro economic analysis of the overall situation. It might be long but if you have time, please read this out.
Farmers in India first of all does not face one issue but several leading to this dire state of them, these are dozens in number and will be very hard to tackle at ones, some of the notable ones includes small scale, consistent exploitation, adverse market forces, issues with distribution and supply chains, lack of access to finances and capital, climatic vulnerability, access to markets, etc just to name a few. As said, difficulties are many but we can broadly categories them to 4-5 core problems as most others just branches out of these core issues
1.SCALE: according to a report, almost 87% of farmers in India are small and marginalised farmers who work on less than 2 hectares of land. It means small farmers because of their scale have to buy the inputs like seeds, fertilisers, etc at retail prices, small scale leads to higher cost of transportation proportion to crops, these farmers mostly don't have the means to store them to themselves so they mostly have to sell them immediately in the market and considering the transportation, they mostly have to sell them at their village itself and also considering almost all other farmers in the village might be doing to same thing so it basically floods the market and well "demand and supply" comes into play making them receive less income and on top of that less bargaining power leads to easier exploitation of them by the middle man, now mandi system makes the last part of selling a bit more safe with government oversight to make sure at least they get somewhat of a fair price but again it doesn't solve the entire issue.
2. Lack of crop diversity and supporting industries: India is a surplus producer of stuff like rice and wheat, we just produce too much of it while we end up importing some other major crops like pulses, now it is somewhat of a "side effect" I can say, as government gives MSP guarantee on rice and wheat in a lot instances which makes it artificially more profitable to grow than other crops even though it should have been the other way round where prices on rice and wheat should have gone down if supply is too high and discourage farmers to grow them and grow something where there is demand for or else it is just a waste of food, money, soil and effort. Now I do know the issue with this as farmers fear leaving a stable and safe source for something where they end up making "less" so I feel government should introduce some sort of a "floating msp system" where msp will be set according to demand and supply
I am surprised that almost no one in India ever bothered improving the RNF sector(Rural Non-Farm Sector) at a national level, these are generally industries that are suited to operate in rural areas, it will help to diversify the rural economy, agriculture products are used in a whole basket of industries as their primary inputs on top of being used as food, so it will help to create additional demand for agricultural crops which means farmers will get more places to sell their crops
Now I would have added a few more points into it but it's already getting long and probably a lot of people might have left it half way through so for the last point which I believe can have a very big impact on agriculture but is never talked about whenever we talk about improving farmers life's and that is....
3. INDUSTRIALIZATION: it may not be agriculture itself but can surely improve the life of a lot of people who were in farming previously as it will create job opportunities for millions to come out of agriculture and shift into comparatively higher value manufacturing as service sector is legendary bad at providing enough job opportunities especially to a population as large as ours (I hope you can relate it to india) and agriculture though extremely important for "LIFE" is very bad as a source of "LIVELIHOOD" so we should focus at trying to improve productivity of a farmer so that less and less farmers can also feed the nation and shift the rest into comparatively higher value manufacturing industry.
You can add a point or two if you want and please make sure to share this to spread awareness if you think it makes sense.
@@manmeesarma2413 copy paste किया h saale tujhe ਪਤਾ भी kya tune kya lika h🤣
@@jagatsihag mai khud likkhke copy paste mar raha hu
@@manmeesarma2413 well analysed. I am from farming background, also I have studied economics. You are pretty much correct from economic point. But any economy is driven by political will and direction. Political will is definitely strong in this government, but the direction as we all know is steeply biased. Most of the economic policies and their implementation has been disastrous, be it Demonetisation, Gst, or the general economic pathways. When the RBI governor of a country is forced to give up for personal benefits by a govt, how can one expect any bill, let alone farmer bills can be of benefit to general public.
The policy of reducing the number of people involved in farming sector is correct on a long term basis. It is a gradual process. Demand is not something which is absolute. It depends on various factors, especially the propensity to consume, and spend. These abrupt economic policy changes is the most important reason of slowing down of economy in the past years before the corona crisis.
Further any big decision on policy front does not just impact the economy but also social, political and cultural structure of a region.
Economy may get back to track later or sooner, but other social elements take a long time to adjust and sometimes may overhaul the entire system and somehow I think India is gradually heading towards it.
@@aakashmalik8966 I appreciate your efforts for the reply
जिन्होंने आजादी की लड़ाई नहीं देखी, वो किसान आंदोलन देख लें। क्योंकि अंग्रेजी हुकूमत ठीक ऐसी ही थी। किसान एकता जिन्दाबाद। इन्कलाब जिन्दाबाद.!!! 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Get out of your comfort zone and face the reality, these farmers are fighting a bigger war not just for themselves but for everyone of us. Lets support them now so we don't regret later on.
Abey jo khud ground water khatam karre hai Punjab ka, pesticides se cancer failare hai, tax se itni subsidy lere hai. Ye selfish log kya ladenge kisi ke liye. Maaf karo hamare liye mat lado apna dekhlo aap.
09:01 that women is savage.....couldn't agree more with her...indeed how can some UNPARR,TADI PARR and run away from wife understand the importance and role of a women...
Hats off to this awesome women...
Jai Hind
Jai kisann
Jai jawan
I know i was dying laughing
@@KD-ds1lp 🤣🤣🤣
Farmers are protesting in a very decent manner without any hindrance to the public.
My dear why don’t you travel from ISBT to Karnal in roadways bus and have a taste of it yourself
When i see persons who do not know the ground reality..i get broken into pieces..i support farmers
When renowned agriculture economists like Ashok Gulati and relevant institution like imf(unlike pop star Rihanna or climate activist Greta thunberg) are backing the reforms then the repeal of law is not justified at all
I heard farmers & government
Conclusion :-
SUPPORTING FARMERS
I'm also with our farmer ❤️
11:36 uncle ji is telling the deepest truths 🙏.
Stand with our farmers 🙏.
मुझे लगता है किसानों से पहले चीन पहुंच जाएगा दिल्ली
*इस अकेले चौकीदार की मेहनत से मुमकिन हुआ कि देश और दुनिया में हम भर्तियों का अन्त में मज़ाक ही बना डाला है*
Aur fir tere naxali friends china ke saath mil kar capture kar lenge delhi
😅सही कहा।
@@vjunloc1 tum apna shorts pehankar dekhte rahogey..?
@@TheRazmatazum 😂😂😂😂ye bat
Farmers are fighting for us
We should co-operate them n favour them.
In which basis you are saying farmer are fighting for us. How law is degrading you?. Kuch bhi likh do buss
@@uditkansal1409 तू ट्रोल है
Pata nahi hum farmer family se hai mere village pata nahi koi kyu nahi gya.
@@uditkansal1409 commodity act prha hai sale gawar
@Lucifer just giving you direction. You are just trying to create wrong environment. Regarding BJP party at central doing good job.
Ask them only when ambani atta rice reaches 2000 rs a kilogram
I support farm laws. Shame on such opposition for insisting fear and violent situation. They haven't read those laws and unnecessarily insisting such activities. I want these laws be implemented ASAP.
34% of india's economy is dependent on farm sector, government want to hand over 34% of indian economy over to big corporates. Those who are in favour in bills, just do some research on bihar agriculture economy. Agri- culture is our(of undivided punjab region) culture, those who shouts all day on television about their culture being in danger without no reason, are trying to destroy our culture, hence we are protesting.
No income tax is being collected from farmers. Those farmers who are earning in crore are not paying tax. We in cities go in over crowded bus and east pesticide mixed vegetables, adulterated milk, polluted air and want to give every thing free to farmers. Let the market decide the price and no government intervention.
Ask government to stop subsidizing billions of dollars for corporates and spend that money on better transportation. We in villages can grow food for over self, but what will you do when stock limit on essential food items will be lifted and corporate will fill its stock and not release until price in market is doubled. Now you buy 10kg ashirwad, patanjali aata for 400 rs , after implementation of these laws , this will be sold at 800rs, and you will be forced to buy at said price. This is not it, corporate can double its selling price 110% every year. What will be rates after 4 years, have you ever considered that. Just dont push your nose in the matter you don't understand. If you can't support us kindly try not opposing our protest against these contagious farm bills.
Pay us fair prices for our produce and collect the income tax from farmers. Government know that farming is not profitable business for small farmers thats why they dont collect taxes from farmer. When there is no income there is no income tax. Increase your knowledge, by reading but not by watching godi media all day.
@@deepakkumr jo oxcizen lata aa vo v kisan ki fasl plants fruit garden and tree se hi aati tumahara city ki gandgi bhari factory se padea nhi hoti
@@deepakkumr
Brdr which country farmer pay income tax
One guy really said well if they are protesting for good cause inconvenience is fine. Like government said while demonetization and gst kuch din ki takleef hai for longer run you’ll see benefits.
Desh ke farmers ke lia itna bhi nai kar sakte.
Let’s not loose the point inconvenience is created by failure of government by not handling situation well. They could have resolved this issues when farmers protest were limited to states. Government and media can’t always blame citizens for everything. It’s high time we make government accountable.
True
I want to say a bit about the farmer situation as it seems with this protest, farmers finally getting the much needed attention from the general public to help them out, now I know currently discussion is about the recent bills but I would like to give a little analysis of mine towards the situation of farmers in general and what exactly are the problems they are facing(as you cannot help them as long as you don't know what is the issue)
Now just a side note, I am not a farmer neither belongs to a farming family and therefore I am not qualified to judge anything but as a student in economics, I can certainly give a macro economic analysis of the overall situation. It might be long but if you have time, please read this out.
Farmers in India first of all does not face one issue but several leading to this dire state of them, these are dozens in number and will be very hard to tackle at ones, some of the notable ones includes small scale, consistent exploitation, adverse market forces, issues with distribution and supply chains, lack of access to finances and capital, climatic vulnerability, access to markets, etc just to name a few. As said, difficulties are many but we can broadly categories them to 4-5 core problems as most others just branches out of these core issues
1.SCALE: according to a report, almost 87% of farmers in India are small and marginalised farmers who work on less than 2 hectares of land. It means small farmers because of their scale have to buy the inputs like seeds, fertilisers, etc at retail prices, small scale leads to higher cost of transportation proportion to crops, these farmers mostly don't have the means to store them to themselves so they mostly have to sell them immediately in the market and considering the transportation, they mostly have to sell them at their village itself and also considering almost all other farmers in the village might be doing to same thing so it basically floods the market and well "demand and supply" comes into play making them receive less income and on top of that less bargaining power leads to easier exploitation of them by the middle man, now mandi system makes the last part of selling a bit more safe with government oversight to make sure at least they get somewhat of a fair price but again it doesn't solve the entire issue.
2. Lack of crop diversity and supporting industries: India is a surplus producer of stuff like rice and wheat, we just produce too much of it while we end up importing some other major crops like pulses, now it is somewhat of a "side effect" I can say, as government gives MSP guarantee on rice and wheat in a lot instances which makes it artificially more profitable to grow than other crops even though it should have been the other way round where prices on rice and wheat should have gone down if supply is too high and discourage farmers to grow them and grow something where there is demand for or else it is just a waste of food, money, soil and effort. Now I do know the issue with this as farmers fear leaving a stable and safe source for something where they end up making "less" so I feel government should introduce some sort of a "floating msp system" where msp will be set according to demand and supply
I am surprised that almost no one in India ever bothered improving the RNF sector(Rural Non-Farm Sector) at a national level, these are generally industries that are suited to operate in rural areas, it will help to diversify the rural economy, agriculture products are used in a whole basket of industries as their primary inputs on top of being used as food, so it will help to create additional demand for agricultural crops which means farmers will get more places to sell their crops
Now I would have added a few more points into it but it's already getting long and probably a lot of people might have left it half way through so for the last point which I believe can have a very big impact on agriculture but is never talked about whenever we talk about improving farmers life's and that is....
3. INDUSTRIALIZATION: it may not be agriculture itself but can surely improve the life of a lot of people who were in farming previously as it will create job opportunities for millions to come out of agriculture and shift into comparatively higher value manufacturing as service sector is legendary bad at providing enough job opportunities especially to a population as large as ours (I hope you can relate it to india) and agriculture though extremely important for "LIFE" is very bad as a source of "LIVELIHOOD" so we should focus at trying to improve productivity of a farmer so that less and less farmers can also feed the nation and shift the rest into comparatively higher value manufacturing industry.
You can add a point or two if you want and please make sure to share this to spread awareness if you think it makes sense.
Problem yaha ye hai ki farmers agriculture reform chate hi nahi hai sidha bol rahe hai kanun hato
Democracy is in "Danger"...Full support to Farmers 👍🏻
More than 80% population is dependent on agriculture
8:10 Ask butcher of Gujarat to carry out voting in upper house of Parliament and then say it is passed by parliament.
Jitega Kisan jitega hindustan 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🏻
Bhai pakka जीतेगा 🥳👍👍
Hn kisaan shyd jeet jaye bt 26 ko hindustan to har gya
@@proton5402 u r right., just imagine farmers anger🤯
@@anmolvyas2394 u are still calling them farmers no man thy were not jinhone yh kiya hh vo kisaan nai hh vo vhn farmer protest k support me nai SFJ ki support me unke favour me aaye thy
@@proton5402 if you don't know anything about them then don't say anything commenting about them laying on bed is easy but can you sleep on roads in that cold better make sure what you are saying next time.
Thanks everyone spotting farmers
That is absolutely true, Amnesh.
Deep thinking.
किसान आन्दोलन का समर्थन करो, अन्न दाता ठंड मे सडक पर क्यो है ।सरकार को झुकना पड़े गा ।
Could you please elaborate what the concern in law. Please elaborate in details.
@@uditkansal1409 You Can get Copies of 5 Laws from Internet.
@@uditkansal1409 first and the foremost point is that central govt can not make any law related to agriculture .so this law is totally unconstitutional.secondly govt said that they made this law for trade and commerce then why farmers cannot got to court if company will do any fraud with them .how a single farmer can do fight with multinational companies . Then govt said that we will do amendment in this law and farmers can go to court .But every one know how govt companies are sell to big corporates and after some years govt can still amendment these laws according to their Malik like ambani adani.so we just want this law to reappel And suspended . Kisan ekta jindabad
@@paramzira8174 now to come to the point. Yes, In new amendment farmer should have right to go to court. As you mentioned central Govt is ready to put in this amendment. Also Govt need to publish standards template which can only me used to agreement between farmer and company. Which project farmer for any unwanted clause in agreement. Also one more point tax for apmc and company should be same. As of now for company no tax and for apmc we have some tax. One more point those who want to do any agreement they should registered himself in govt organizations it should not be the case any PAN card holder can deal with farmer. Other than these new farmer amendment is good I would say very good for farmer. I believe farmer should only ask for change not for repeal. @Param if you have any other point which are against the farmer please correct me.
@@uditkansal1409 we know everything but after sometime govt will change these laws then what will farmers do and if modi govt want to help farmers then they should pass reports of swami Nathan and pass rule of MSP not just guarantee by their party
*BJP = Congress.*
*Support AAP, CPI.*
*Save nation.*
BJP isn't really Congress. Congress is more so BJP lite minus the ego.
Lol.. Aap is Secret Party of BJP
Shame on that people who don’t support farmers
Yes, i support farmers proudly
Aur saalo jisko clarification chahiye ki kya h law m.
Aajao
चीफ जस्टिस नहीं घंटा जस्टिस है जिसे मोदी जब चाहे बजा देता है,
✌️💯💯
Baat to shi hai😂😂
OK bhai
😂bilkul
Shi kha apne
This is how we can now assumed that y The bloody BJP was thrown away from DELHI...
When the Delhi people will pay the four times for food, they'll realise
what they were ignoring.(farmer protest)
जागो देश वासियों जागो, अंदोलन केवल किसानों का नहीं,
किसान तो अपने लिए अपने गुजारे के लिए अनाज उगा लेगा, मुशकिलें महगा खरीद कर खाने वालों के लिए होंगी, कैसे अपने परिवार का भरणपोषण करेगा, जरा सोचिए...... कहीं ऐसा न हो देरी हो जाये, फिर पछताने का भी समय न मिले, दोस्तों सहमत हो तो लाईक और शेयर करें
Farm Law should be suspended till there is a agreement with the farmers
The Supreme court did that a few days ago.
repealed should be right way to go. Then form a new commite to draft a new one as per farmer needs
Citizens of Delhi should go and bring the farmers inside Delhi
The day this happens India will truly be on its way to becoming a most progressive nation
The extent of biasness in this video... Hats off.....
(Also they thought it could not be seen by including 1 or 2 people of opposing opinion but they could not have the screen for complete 10 seconds even.. just brilliant work
dada ji at 8:40 is a informed responsible citizen, we need more people like him in our families.
Desh sirf Delhi walon ka nahin hei, desh rajdhani Delhi hei tho, desh ka log apna mang kahne ke liye Delhi mein hi ayenge. Delhi kisi ki baap ki jagir nahin.... I support farmers, mera Annadatha ki Jai ho.
ਕਿਸਾਨ ਮਜ਼ਦੂਰ ਏਕਤਾ ਜਿੰਦਾਬਾਦ
ਪੰਜਾਬ ਪੰਜਾਬੀ ਪੰਜਾਬੀਅਤ ਜਿੰਦਾਬਾਦ
Hindi??
Kisan Mazdood Ekta Zindabad
Punjabi Punjabi Punjabiyat Zindabad
Mazdoor*
I always stand with farmers...Hatss off to all supporters...and remaining Bhagwaan unko sadbudhi de....
5:44 thank you for your support. Level headed people like you are a ray of hope for the country
We should boycott Adani & Ambani at all levels till our last breath; every invader having eyes to our land must get the lesson, so others planning to invade must refrain for even thinking about it!
If we respect the government, it doesn't mean we are afraid. The causes listed on different decisions by the government are manipulated and even manufactured, and we must reject such behaviour of the government.
On January 20, 2021, we mark the first milestone and soon there will be a stone plaque of farmers victory.
We achieved all this by rebut; we still did not retaliate although different state machinery and biased media-channels are used to silence our voices. It did not happen, it will never happen, not today, not tomorrow, not ever. We prevailed, here we stand just after three black-laws were imposed on us.
#boycott_adani #boycott_ambani #boycott_jio #boycott_reliance #farmersprotest #boycott_godimedia #boycott_capitaltv
One lady said, govt. is for the people. FYI miss, this govt. is NOT for people
Lol keep crying 👍👍👍😂😂
@@ujjwalkachhwah1118 lmao keep licking
@@Jassatera lol
It's really great to see such a wonderful spirit of our Fellow Nationals
Its a high time to support farmers...they are fighting for our survival and we should be ashamed of ourselves if we are not doing anything to support farmers protest
Hi
some of the people do not have their facts straight. like young man who says, 'parliament ki nahin maan rahe'!
Godi effect
He might be a bhakt...
Voh lok gobar khaane ki adat se majboor hai
Idiot person doesn't know anything
bhai uska dimag hila walamujhe
The Farmers are fully cognizant of the implications of the draconian farm laws thrust upon them without a debate/ consultation. Thanks for starting the conversation with Delhites.
Thank you Delhi ... Love from Punjab ❤
We are all connected to the farmers through food.
Without Farmers No Food.
55 days of kisaan strike ,sitting in chilling cold with their families it's high time that central govt should listen to farmers mann ki baat and scrap 3 farm bills!
7:38
*andbhakat*
modi da chela😅
@@sindavlogger1391
*Sahi keha g*
Pata kuj hai nai bhakata nu
Aa jnde gyaan den
🤣🤣 *sarkaar kr rahi ta wdia hi aa*
@@sindavlogger1391 thanks g.. 😊 district sangrur..
@@sindavlogger1391 intro Ne Dekhi tuc ?
@@harinderkaurCookingchannel tuc insta chlonde ooo..
Farmers are grate, they are fighting for every citizen of the India.👍👍👍👍
I am with farmers
But people should understand one thing that everyone has their own opinion .. different opinions create healthy environment and forces every individual to question himself.
why to trust supreme court? former chief justice ranjan gogoi has joined rajya sabha after his service.
He's the only judge to do that.
Unite, Speak up against Injustice, Unemployment, rights. Save Democracy Save Constitution. Live for Humanity Help needy. Jai Bharat Jai HindThankyou very much for showing on ground reality of Governance. Request government to build more Hospitals for better Health System. 🙏
Proud to be a part of farmers protest
11:32 He spoke the truth..