What I like about the 1994 version when Simba understands Scar murdered Mufasa is that Simba remembers his pouncing lesson from this father and pounces on Scar.
@@ominousvonte that's cause how do you pounce while hanging off a cliff. So I can see logically why it was changed to him biting scar. It was to make it more realistic. But however the animation is leagues better. But that's cause animals expressions are hard to do while keeping it looking natural.
My biggest issue with this scene, aside from the lack of drama in the animation, is Simba's reaction to the confession, it's way too composed. I mean, he's way too composed throughout, but the confession is really egregious. It sounds way too rehearsed, too controlled. In the original, he reacts with the level of shock, rage, and immediate aggression we expect in his voice. In the remake, it sounds more like he found out a day ago and had thought out what to say when confronting him.
@@StoogesFan True, no one asked for it. But it could have been interesting. But no one with seemingly any passion to truly do the original justice was in charge of decision making. It is accurate to say that this film really was a tech demo
I mean Simba had already forgotten about Mufasa, already spoke to Mufasa days ago and reacted as he should for the verdict he would later give Scar... I mean what's the use if he was later gonna say "Run and never look back"
@Caio Da Silva Barreto but the new version JUST wants the style, its ONLY purpose is to look "realistic" and cool and literally absolutely nothing else
It’s crazy how they managed to downgrade every. Single. Aspect. Of the remake. Let’s talk about the original first: the music is extremely powerful. The way the strings staccato at the beginning to emphasize tension REALLY sells the moment. Simba’s dread, and Scar turning the tides with his usual manipulation to sway the lionesses against him. The music is half the battle in his scene. Everything about it is so potent and meaningful; every note, every trill pushes the scene forward. Every character’s expression contributes. There is an OVERFLOW of emotion. And when Simba admits, its all he can even muster to say “I did”... he can’t manage anything else. And this is powerful. Sarabi’s look of despondency as she pleads with her son; begs him to tell her it isn’t true. And we hear that classic Lion King theme; that ridiculously emotional, complex melody. The music is quiet here to emphasize Simba’s lamentation and further acceptance, and it does so brilliantly. And when Scar says “he admits it! Murderer!” The way the music suddenly booms into the foreground followed by that riveting crash of lightning gives me goosebumps every time. It’s simple and so effective. The way Scar circles Simba, berating him all while Simba can’t even defend himself, because he’s convinced his uncle is right. And one thing I especially despise about the remake is the exclusion of the pivotal line “oh, Simba. You’re in trouble again. But this time, daddy isn’t here to save you. And now everyone knows why!” It’s really good writing. The way Scar words this is so demeaning, and it mocks the fact that they’re actually family. ”you’re in trouble again” reminding us of the mistakes Simba made as a kid that supposedly led to his father’s death. And the TIMING. Everything is timed so purposefully, and the cadence and delivery swells with the music as Simba is pushed off the edge of Pride Rock. And then we get that brilliant confession from Scar, and I can’t stress enough how good Jeremy Irons is at making every word leak malice. After his confession, the chilling off-chord that plays as we are flashed back to Mufasa’s death (the visual of him falling into the stampede is so well executed in this version) really rings home this feeling of horror and realization. And the way Simba is then invigorated to LEAP up from the cliff and onto Scar. Not just nibbling his neck fluff, LEAPING up and out of his clutches only to pin him down and gain the upper hand. It’s perfect. All of it is perfect. And then there’s the remake. The first thing I notice is the lazy blocking. Why would Scar lay down at the beginning as he’s talking to Simba? Was there really nothing else they could think of to emphasize nonchalance? The completely BLANK expressions of the characters doesn’t help. The lionesses (who in the original look terrified and uncertain) look like they’re watching a cat toy. It’s awful. And I really hate to knock an actor, but the guy playing Simba is not doing him any favors either. His delivery is bizarre and he’s putting the emphasis in all the wrong places. The way he says “it was me” or whatever (I say whatever because it’s already not as memorable) followed by that weird-ass “I’m sorry” to Sarabi? Why even add that? Why would he say “I’m sorry”? I’m not saying the apologetic sentiment is out of place, but Simba’s body language and what he said in the original already fully conveyed the feeling of remorse and that he felt sorry. So this addition kinda cheapens it. It just feels off. And of course when Scar says yada yada “he admits it! Wakwkaksa!” there’s NO lightning strike because John Favreau doesn’t think adding drama to a fictional movie about talking lions is realistic. Thanks John. Instead we get bland boring lighting over bland boring lions and SOMEHOW even Zimmer’s chilling score is downgraded. Whether it’s the instruments themselves or the composition, the emotion feels watered down. It’s lessened. Just like the rest of the scene. There’s some new dialogue from Scar during this scene that isn’t completely bad, but at the same time... it’s kind of superfluous. It’s things that don’t really add anything to the scene and are just there to make it feel different. They don’t serve any purpose. And for god’s sake that stupid flash back to hilariously blocked Mufasa falling off the cliff completely saps the tension. It’s literally funny. Simba’s stupid little chipmunk scream is comical. In the original the complete DESPAIR in Simba’s voice destroys me. The delivery is amazing. And so is Mufasa’s terrible scream. But in the new version it’s like “aaaaaaaahhh.....” and Simba’s like “nOOOEE” And it just sucks. It all sucks. The remake sucks. And the original is a masterpiece. Edit: bass-boosting Chiwetel’s voice was an extremely lame choice and it’s super obvious eww- why didn’t they just get Jeremy Irons back? The man literally sounds the same. They brought back wholesome geezer James Earl Jones but wouldn’t bring back arguably the most iconic voice in the movie? Ew Disney. Ew. The scene is so forced omg I can’t believe how bad it is. Why is everyone’s delivery so weird? They don’t even talk like real people. Simba has ZERO emotion in this scene and in the original the emotions are literally through the roof. 1994 Lion King is one of the most emotion-heavy movies I’ve ever seen, yet this shallow remake manages to be one of the most EMOTIONLESS movies I’ve ever seen, how did they even manage that? They managed it by not caring. It was an easy billion for them. That’s all they wanted. To bank on peoples’ nostalgia and fill their own pockets. That’s what Disney is now.
Literally all of this. Thank you. But one point I'd like to elaborate is how stupid Simba's "I'm sorry" sounds. Why does he sound so nonchalant? I've heard actual children apologize with more emotion and sincerity for just breaking dishes, meanwhile Simba is supposed to be apologizing for *the death of his own father* but instead he sounds like he's saying sorry for getting a C on a math quiz or something. How did Jon ever look at any of this and think it was acceptable??!!
@@thelemurofmadagascar9183 RIGHT?!?!?!? I am honestly so shocked at the lack of emotion in the voice-acting. Also the way Scar pauses completely at random for like several seconds during his sentences? Was this......... Chiwetel’s way......... of.... sounding....... evil? Cuz it just... makes him........... hard to listen to. And Donald Glover’s performance is more “waaa boohoo dead daddy check??” As oppose to Mathew Broderick’s utter despair, horror, remorse, etc. Also I wasn’t expecting anyone to read all that LOL and let alone respond, so cheers 🍻
@@shaydilane2172 Lmao the pauses were so annoying. It's not dramatic, it's not evil, it's just awkward and unnatural. Tbh I'm a bit guilty of writing extremely lengthy comments myself, so I don't mind reading other people's mini "essays" either haha
Notice how in the original flashback, it's not just Mufasa's death scene copy pasted with a windows movie maker fade transition; Simba remembers it as something so horrible, so traumatic, and it's reflected in the bright red that also fits the palette of the current scene. In the new version, it clashes so badly with what's currently happening, almost as if Mufasa's death was a happier moment for Simba than hanging from a rock is.
@@wilyserpent And the fact that it zooms in on Simba's eye as opposed to out of it really shows it ingrained in his mind even as an adult just as it did when he was a cub. You can't do the with the remake because they messed up the zoom on that one so bad.
I definitely prefer his reaction in the original. You can tell it was traumatic event for him. Where as 2019. It looks like a cat upset you didn't give him milk or treats!
3:28 Calm down, Disney, Simba going "Nyaaa!!" when his father died already nearly killed me with laughter. You didn't need to deal the finishing blow by making me watch it again in slow mo at the most dramatic and emotionally heavy moment in the movie
@@DonnieTheGent1 That's the point i was trying to make. It feels like it's longer than necessary to the point that it moves much slower and the scenes have no punch to them
I simply love the original scar best his voice acting is on a whole different level and just gives me a certain vibe Im really disappointed they didn't reach out to him so he could reprise his role like mufasa did. He was actually waiting for it but it didn't happen is what I read.
Some say that Jeremy Irons was underacting the whole time, and Andreas Deja managed to animate his expressions with the voice perfectly. If this were true, then I would admire Iron's performance more than Pauly Shore playing Pinocchio.
THAT SCAR IN BOTH ANIMATED AND THE REAL DISNEYS THE LION 🦁 KING, ARE BAD LIONS BUT AT THE END OF THE LION 🦁 KING, THE ANIMATED OF THE LION 🦁 KING AND THE REAL DISNEYS THE LION 🦁 KING, SIMBA BEAT SCAR IN THE REAL DISNEYS THE LION 🦁 KING AND THE ANIMATED ONE TOO
Jesus Christ, ok so ur saying scar was a villain and he was defeated in both films? Did you want him to succeed? How is this Amy relevanc eot the comment?
@@tigrytime658Hey brother, I just wanted to say to you man that Jesus is God and to say His name like that is using God’s name in vain. I just wanted to tell you that brother. I hope all is well with you. Jesus loves you brother and He d*ed on the cross for you and for me and for our sins so that we can live with Him for eternity. Jesus calls us to repent of our sins and to put our faith and trust in Him and be baptized. I know this is coming out of nowhere, but I thought you should know brother. I pray you come home to the Catholic Church friend. God bless you!
@@philippierangeli4412 hey so I probably was a bit excessive with my blasphemy and I apologise but I’m agnostic until the day I die. The fact that the bible is so contradictory and the cruel ways religion has been used in the past means I have no reason to believe in its power or significance
The remake is trying too hard to be a beat-for-beat, line-for-line remake but every line comes across as awkward. Like they could have tried to give it it’s own identity but they weren’t interested in that, they just wanted to scab off nostalgia by making the same film but they somehow did it so much worse.
Which is very odd because I can think of so many scenes from the original that they shortened significantly and one or two didn't even make it in to the remake, yet the 2019 version is half an hour longer!
@@rosssimpson4919 The 2 scenes I hate that didn't make it in was when Timon distracted the Hyenas by doing that dance, and when Rafiki whacks Simba in the head with his stick!
@@aliciacleeland2257 yeah, at least with Timone’s dance, I wasn’t expecting the lifeless “realistic” remake to do exactly that, whatever they did instead must have been really stale because I’ve forgotten about it, but with the stick scene with Simba they removed a PIVOTAL moment for his character development! That one they had no excuse removing it for being unrealistic to have a mandrill carrying a stick the whole time but they LET HIM HAVE IT FOR THE FIGHT!!! What part of the fight was more important to stop being realistic, than one of the most important scenes for Simba’s character????
@@rosssimpson4919 There was nothing realistic about the movie! What Mandrill holds up a cub. Showing him to the pride land. Idk I hated the 2019 version it was super boring.
@@ericwood2062 my mum got into a car accident and was in the hospital, and while we waited my dad wanted to distract me, so he let me watch the lion king on his tablet
My sentiments exactly. This is why I love animated films because you have to really use your vocal muscles to bring forth the performance. The 2019 version is not bad but it's not as awesome as the original 1994 version.
I literally never noticed this until now, but at 1:19 you can see Simba make a “what is he talking about?” face just as Scar starts whispering in his ear. Such attention to detail in expression that’s completely lost in the 2019 remake.
Not only is there emotion in the original but better acting and choreography overall. Ironically it feels more natural and realistic especially with the dialog choices where as the remake, it ends up feeling forced to make up for the lack of emotion. Also that scream mufasa does when he falls in the flash 100% feels like it was taken from the original.
Probably because they usually animate the scenes after they record so they can get the facial expressions to match. Where as the 2019 movie being a bit too realistic makes it impossible for the Lions to exaggerate enough for us to feel the drama.
(I know this isn't the same scene, but close enough ehe) The way Simba reacts to Mufasa's death in 2019 is so funny. He looks like a angry little kitten, and the way it zooms out from him and he is so tiny raging on the cliff made me laugh out loud in the theater (it was just my family, I wouldn't do that in front of other people, I hate when people make a ruckus in the theater) but seriously it looked ridiculous.
That part made me laugh so hard I had to take a deep breath. Then I paused the movie and continued watching after a few months cause I hated it. I pirated it, but I still feel robbed😂
Love the original because the animation is amazing but it shows more emotion, expressions and is like relatable while the live action is like a zoo visit
In the 1994 version, Matthew Broderick uses his slow-to-anger personality as the voice of Adult Simba while Donald Glover throws a hissy fit as the voice of the rightful king of the Pride Lands in the 2019 version.
Honestly I like Matthew Broderick's Adult Simba better than Donald Glover's Adult Simba because Matthew showed real emotion meanwhile Donald just didn't act like he had real emotions.
@@FaraanBabar2616 some scenes were utter shit but some were better than the original so that makes up for it personally I prefer can you feel the love tonight in the more recent version
I would recommend watching the YMS review of the remake, it’ll explain most of why you feel this way about it. It’s only on part 1 right now, but so far it’s explained why every change made was for the worse.
It is funny how many people say that they like the 1994 version more. There are objective reasons why the 1994 is better. They took away everything emotional impactful in the 2019 version. Voice acting is weak, everything is blue, the new music sounds very generic, there are points where the lions look like they are in a 3D environment, there are no expressions at all and there are no characters. I can not believe we live in a world where the 2019 is one of the most successful movies of all time. There is even purpose in the flashback in the 1994 version. While in the 2019 version it is just a slow-mo version of the event. Also the teeth of Mufasa look weird when he falls in the 2019 version.
Holy crap. I didn't realise it after pausing it. When scar put his claws on simbas paws they bleed a bit. Such nice details. I miss these old animated movies..
2019 Scar kinda acts like one of those generic villians added just because they needed an antagonist. He doesn't really stand out and charm the audience like his 1994 counterpart.
I forgot how amazing this scene was in the 1994 version: the score, the lightning strikes, the emotions on the character and Jeremy Irons’s voice performance is absolutely perfect. Probably my favorite voice acting performance ever
jOn was overly excited about star wars, described the scene when the monkey retrieve his staff was his lightsaber. Really show where his head is focuses on.
"Our goal was to make it as real to life as it possibly could be" Well congrats John Favro, you succeed. And it's absoultely horrible because of it. You know what this beautifully animated musical needs? Painfully accurate realism! Paste swilling simpleton.
@@noodles_poodles392 In a way, yes actually. Like it's even more silly to see a photo realistic lion try it's hardest to emote, sing and move like a cartoon than seeing an actual cartoon do it. Though seeing the dinosaur planet thing, I'm honestly convinced this was just a proof of concept to show the technology was possible while casually making 7 figures. Not cause the move itself was any good, but because Lion King is so beloved you'd have to do a theatrical release of a bunch of furries dressed as lions in a fur pile with the Lion King logo slapped on it not to profit well into the billions. And even then it would make money just because the title alone is that damn powerful. For more on this, look into the marketing for Craptain Marvel. Yeah, the 4th wave feminist drivel was there, but it was mostly market as you needed to see it understand what went on to be the most profitable movie in history, Avengers End Game.
The 1994 version: Full of life and emotion, very realistic. The 2019 version: A lifeless husk of the original scene that looks like something out of a budget puppet show
Wow. I've never watched a full scene from the 2019 version until now, and it looks like I was completely correct to avoid it. Disney really demonstrates the principle "just because you can, doesn't mean you should."
The thing I’ve noticed about Scar in the original movie is that he uses the least amount of words to get the most amount of impact when accusing Simba of being a murderer. In the live action, he didn’t need to keep demanding, “Say it!” as he backs Simba down. Maybe for the hyenas, but once would have been enough for Scar if they built up his menacing presence in Be Prepared.
The animation had more PERSONALITY/ CONTINUITY! I love how they BLEND young Simba's NO with the adult Simba - the with a rush of adrenaline jumps on Scar!
Seeing the 2019 live action/cgi version after the 1994 animated classic hurts so much. All the life and personality has been completely sucked dry. People will continue to watch the 1994 animated movie cause it's timeless and anyone can watch it (my nephews love it!), while the 2019 version will fade into obscurity; the only use I could think of it would be to use it in film school as an example on when a remake fails.
the way scar stalks and prances around him whispering thoughts into his head like a muse, the way he verbally trips simba up forcing a half baked confession, the vibrancy and details making it easy to tell which lion is which, a complete masterpiece. Right, the 2019 version, um, very realistic
The Lion King is the first movie I remember seeing in the theaters and having the movie make me _feel_ things, even at 8 years old. It was a defining film experience of my childhood. All these years later and the original animated scene is _still_ giving me chills. Which leads to my question. Who the heck thought that the CGI remake (I refuse to call it live action because it isn't) was a good idea? I feel absolutely nothing at all watching the scene from the remake.
Only thing I like about the remake is how we see Simba get up the ledge. I didn’t really like how in the original Simba magically just finds a footing to propel himself so drastically.
You have a point about that, but its execution lacks the impact like in the original. The way Simba lunges at Scar is full of energy and shows his rage while the remake undercuts it with a quick and weak looking bite.
The new lion king is not realistic..you cannot feel the way that they spoke..sounds like their reading script..compare to 1994 lion king, every that the spoke you can feel their feeiling
Everyone is focusing on one or two lines of dialogue and saying "Oh the 2019 version is great it alters the lines" sure if it was the same and just altered the lines it would be fine, but it doesn't. Notice as Scar accuses him the difference in body language and emphasis on tone and words. Scar circles him in the original, his words stabbing at Simba. In the Live Action "Scar" just shouts at him while laying down then moves towards him. The way Scar pauses and places a claw to his chin in feigned contemplation of trying to remember why the scene is familiar to the dull and lifeless version of "Scar" standing over "Simba" and then just bouncing to claw him. The realization showing in Simba's face is shown through expression and his anger is palpable, compared to the "Rawr I bit you and will now shout at you".
In the original 1994 movie, Simba comes determined to confront Scar, and when Scar accuses Simba of Murder, he respects the punishment looks on lionesses's faces(because obviously, he thought that the lionesses would be disappointed in him by telling them)and is trying to reason the cause of his actions, by saying things like "It was an accident! I'm not a murderer!" In 2019 version, he looks more like a scared little kitty.
2:53 in this part it’s really hard to tell his emotion of being mischievous and looks more like he’s angry which is giving the wrong idea to the audience
1994:Piece of art of love 2019: just because it’s realistic doesn’t mean it books good! Scar doesn’t look like a thing like him then he did in 1994! Neither did Mufasa
When you realize they said 'kill' in old Disney properties, but now we get "I HAVE SOME CHILDREN I NEED TO MAKE INTO *CORPSES!!!!!"* (I love that quote from Bill Cipher by the way)
I like how in the 2019 version Scar gets exposed by Sarabi by asking how he would have known the look in Mufasa’s eyes if he hadn’t gotten to the gorge in time instead of being strangled into admitting it
I've watched both of them, 1994 impacted me way more than the 2019 and I was able to see that one in theaters It's just something about the original that is just so much better
The original had so much more emotion in it, I feel like if they used realistic versions of the original characters instead of straight up realistic lions it would’ve been better
I rlly liked liked '' I can't wait to be king'' for example because it was so colorful, funny and I love the expressions of Zazoo being so done with the cubs. The songs are very good and nostalgic. I really don' t wanna imagine what they did in the life action with that after I have seen this bland shit in such a scene where there needs to be emotion and drama. The 1994 version made me feel stuff and cry every time Mufasa died even after 20 times. The life remake is just nothing imo. Glad i did not watch it
I find the "yOu GuYs ArE mIsSiNg ThE pOiNt" crowd hilarious. The live action remake used the original's existence as a selling point. You can't just handwave the animated version away just because this is a separate movie. They knew what they were doing in the marketing and the filming. It tried to tell the same story, keeping many of the same lines and having similar shots, but that's it.
in the animated version the scene feels better represented plus the shocking music and the way Scar surrounds Simba in circles.. and the line "Simba, you're in trouble again, but this time daddy isn't here to save you" catches me because of how Scar says it... although in live action the new lines are also fine when Scar, to put the lionesses against Simba, begins by saying: should we believe the son who causes the death of a king? A son who abandons his mother? and that also begins to denigrate him saying: you're what? are you the king? pushing him back to the edge of saying that he is nothing..and the way Simba remembers his father's death after Scar confesses the truth in the animated version is much better, because you can feel his pain and anger that his father was taken from him by Scar
The money they had spent on a live action, they could have spent it on another 2D animated movie. 😭 Which they dont make anymore. 3D is the new way to go, but Id LOVE to see a handdrawn animation again... In the style of 101 dalmations for examplehe
But she's never happy with her family, she's all serious and even an incompetent queen who nearly drove her own pride to starvation just because she refuse to leave her native home and think to the memories of the one she loves instead of the other lives. Sure I liked that Sarabi got more screen-time but unfortunately she doesn't serve the plot very well and Mufasa, Rafiki, Timon and Pumbaa and Nala already served the plot very well so there was no need of that. Also in the original there's was no need of someone pointing out Scar was liying all this while because after his confession of Mufasa's death it was already enough Simba forcing him to admit the truth to the pride by pinning him down and leaving him terrified for his life.
@@fuckalldisneyremakesorigin5560Ok so we wants to live in a world where everything sucks or we want to see something good in the things who has sucked a bit
@@mregggentlepartner1046 sorry but it's so undeniable that if Simba didn't return to reclaim his throne, the pride would have been starved to death. Also what she told Nala is pointless, because Nala didn't learn nothing from those words and did actually the right choice to leave the Pride Rock to find help otherwise would have starve. This Sarabi is stupid, selfish, incompetent and insignificant, she's a terribly written character.
@@fuckalldisneyremakesorigin5560 O k you've right is only that I got sick to people who thinks that everything of new is horrible!!!! In fact found only one of the Fandom that say that present things are worst the
When I was a child, me and my dad would watch Lion king very often because I loved it so much and we were both crying our eyes out. My name is Simon and even today many years later he calls me Simba
I hate the pacing of the remake in this scene it's so BAD. "It's true I'm sorry" there's no emotion in this performance. Vs in the original, the lionesses look shocked at learning this lie that Scar stated, that Simba is responsible for Mufasa's death. Then Sarabi faces her son, begging him to tell her that it isn't true, Simba can't even look her in the eyes. "It's true." this is said haltingly like he can't even get the words out. THEN Scar pounces on the moment. In the remake it's just "It's true I'm sorry" there's no moment to breathe, no moment of Sarabi begging her son to tell her he isn't responsible for his father's death it's just ALL. WRONG. I understand the intent of Simba not facing Sarabi, the intent is that he can't face her, but it's more powerful for Sarabi to try and look at her son in the eye while she gets the truth, and he unable to. Scar circling Simba is so much more of an impactful image then Simba just HAPPENING to be forced to the ledge. Scar's whole speech isn't as impactful either. THE ENTIRE POINT OF THE SCENE IS THAT HE IS KILLING SIMBA WITH THE GUILT OF CAUSING HIS FATHER'S DEATH. "Ohhhh Simba, you're in trouble again. Only this time, DADDY isn't here to save you. And now everyone KNOWS. WHY." Bam lightning strike. The editing the pacing, the line delivery, the camerawork it all compliments the moment. Why would Scar hammer home the fact that Simba killed the king he just said this it would be better for Scar to eat at Simba's guilt.
2019 lion king When scar is asking question to cimba he seated and looks like relaxing..😂..unlike the original he is walking around to cimba to pressure him..even the accent of scar more pressure to me, and I think if Im in the cimba's situation I would say "ah no, yes ,no, i mean it was an accident" 😆
@Kejser Yusuf Genghis Ali Demun Easy there, buddy. That’s not what I meant. I meant that in the newest lion king, you can’t see the fear in his eyes because all of the characters are completely expressionless.
The way remake Simba says "It's true, I'm sorry." makes it sound more like he's confessing to stealing money from his moms purse than accidentally causing someone's death lmao
I will say that I do like the dialogue's build up a bit more in the 2019 version, where the lionnesses realize Scar was lying from what he told Simba before he realizes Scar killed him. Scar tries to brush off his screw up by trying to pretend Simba was theatening him. Though the delivery was better in 1994 with better voice acting, 2019's scar has some moments.
![The Lion Guard Battle For The Pridelands - Kion Defeats Scar & Ushari’s Death Scene [HD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vE2A1RPJxvs/mqdefault.jpg)
![The Lion Guard Battle For The Pridelands - Kion Defeats Scar & Ushari’s Death Scene [HD]](/img/tr.png)
What I like about the 1994 version when Simba understands Scar murdered Mufasa is that Simba remembers his pouncing lesson from this father and pounces on Scar.
Awwwwww I never put that together! The remake changing it to a bite really takes that symbolism out of it, way worse imo.
That’s reaching tbh
@@ominousvonte that's cause how do you pounce while hanging off a cliff. So I can see logically why it was changed to him biting scar. It was to make it more realistic. But however the animation is leagues better. But that's cause animals expressions are hard to do while keeping it looking natural.
@@thefisherman0074 it’s not
High school level analysis
1994: The wonderfully animated piece of art movie
2019: The free to watch TH-cam Movie
2019, watch for free and now I want my money back.
@@bloodysimile4893 🤣🤣🤣facts!!
It’s not true tell me it’s not true
🤣🤣🤣🤣😭😭Damn! I cracked up!🤣🤣
for real
My biggest issue with this scene, aside from the lack of drama in the animation, is Simba's reaction to the confession, it's way too composed. I mean, he's way too composed throughout, but the confession is really egregious. It sounds way too rehearsed, too controlled. In the original, he reacts with the level of shock, rage, and immediate aggression we expect in his voice. In the remake, it sounds more like he found out a day ago and had thought out what to say when confronting him.
The voice actors got dealt bad cards from start when they had to match their tone with the monotous expressions of the CGI animals
The problem with the 2019 version as a whole is trying to make it as "realistic" as possible. Nobody asked for a "realistic" version of the Lion King
@@StoogesFan True, no one asked for it. But it could have been interesting. But no one with seemingly any passion to truly do the original justice was in charge of decision making. It is accurate to say that this film really was a tech demo
And when was the last time you watched the 94 version
I mean Simba had already forgotten about Mufasa, already spoke to Mufasa days ago and reacted as he should for the verdict he would later give Scar... I mean what's the use if he was later gonna say "Run and never look back"
The 1994 version is the embodiment of quality over quantity. Just because the 2019 version looks realistic, doesn't mean it's a good watch.
And honestly, just like the Jungle Book remake, it’s looking less realistic every year, so eventually it won’t even really have that going for it
i don't think the phrase "quality over quantity" makes much sense in this situation lol
maybe "substance over style"?
What quantity?
@@andreadamon2197 literally watching this scene i was like "why was people hyping this animation as much ? "
@Caio Da Silva Barreto but the new version JUST wants the style, its ONLY purpose is to look "realistic" and cool and literally absolutely nothing else
1994 was so much more dramatic
True 👍
that is true
True 👍🏾
because the 2019 one must be made realistic...
1994 was better but I like 2019
1994: Simba finds out the truth and in rage jumps at his uncle Scar
2019: Simba finds out the truth and bites his uncle Scar
👍
What if mufasa did the same when scar was about to murder him???
Both are stilll the same awesome way and suitable
@@omarnur5525 It wouldn't interesting
@@terror904 what are you talking about? That would be awesome. And I can't even lie.
It’s crazy how they managed to downgrade every. Single. Aspect. Of the remake. Let’s talk about the original first: the music is extremely powerful. The way the strings staccato at the beginning to emphasize tension REALLY sells the moment. Simba’s dread, and Scar turning the tides with his usual manipulation to sway the lionesses against him. The music is half the battle in his scene. Everything about it is so potent and meaningful; every note, every trill pushes the scene forward. Every character’s expression contributes. There is an OVERFLOW of emotion. And when Simba admits, its all he can even muster to say “I did”... he can’t manage anything else. And this is powerful. Sarabi’s look of despondency as she pleads with her son; begs him to tell her it isn’t true. And we hear that classic Lion King theme; that ridiculously emotional, complex melody. The music is quiet here to emphasize Simba’s lamentation and further acceptance, and it does so brilliantly. And when Scar says “he admits it! Murderer!” The way the music suddenly booms into the foreground followed by that riveting crash of lightning gives me goosebumps every time. It’s simple and so effective. The way Scar circles Simba, berating him all while Simba can’t even defend himself, because he’s convinced his uncle is right. And one thing I especially despise about the remake is the exclusion of the pivotal line “oh, Simba. You’re in trouble again. But this time, daddy isn’t here to save you. And now everyone knows why!” It’s really good writing. The way Scar words this is so demeaning, and it mocks the fact that they’re actually family. ”you’re in trouble again” reminding us of the mistakes Simba made as a kid that supposedly led to his father’s death. And the TIMING. Everything is timed so purposefully, and the cadence and delivery swells with the music as Simba is pushed off the edge of Pride Rock. And then we get that brilliant confession from Scar, and I can’t stress enough how good Jeremy Irons is at making every word leak malice. After his confession, the chilling off-chord that plays as we are flashed back to Mufasa’s death (the visual of him falling into the stampede is so well executed in this version) really rings home this feeling of horror and realization. And the way Simba is then invigorated to LEAP up from the cliff and onto Scar. Not just nibbling his neck fluff, LEAPING up and out of his clutches only to pin him down and gain the upper hand. It’s perfect. All of it is perfect.
And then there’s the remake. The first thing I notice is the lazy blocking. Why would Scar lay down at the beginning as he’s talking to Simba? Was there really nothing else they could think of to emphasize nonchalance? The completely BLANK expressions of the characters doesn’t help. The lionesses (who in the original look terrified and uncertain) look like they’re watching a cat toy. It’s awful. And I really hate to knock an actor, but the guy playing Simba is not doing him any favors either. His delivery is bizarre and he’s putting the emphasis in all the wrong places. The way he says “it was me” or whatever (I say whatever because it’s already not as memorable) followed by that weird-ass “I’m sorry” to Sarabi? Why even add that? Why would he say “I’m sorry”? I’m not saying the apologetic sentiment is out of place, but Simba’s body language and what he said in the original already fully conveyed the feeling of remorse and that he felt sorry. So this addition kinda cheapens it. It just feels off. And of course when Scar says yada yada “he admits it! Wakwkaksa!” there’s NO lightning strike because John Favreau doesn’t think adding drama to a fictional movie about talking lions is realistic. Thanks John. Instead we get bland boring lighting over bland boring lions and SOMEHOW even Zimmer’s chilling score is downgraded. Whether it’s the instruments themselves or the composition, the emotion feels watered down. It’s lessened. Just like the rest of the scene. There’s some new dialogue from Scar during this scene that isn’t completely bad, but at the same time... it’s kind of superfluous. It’s things that don’t really add anything to the scene and are just there to make it feel different. They don’t serve any purpose. And for god’s sake that stupid flash back to hilariously blocked Mufasa falling off the cliff completely saps the tension. It’s literally funny. Simba’s stupid little chipmunk scream is comical. In the original the complete DESPAIR in Simba’s voice destroys me. The delivery is amazing. And so is Mufasa’s terrible scream. But in the new version it’s like “aaaaaaaahhh.....” and Simba’s like “nOOOEE” And it just sucks. It all sucks. The remake sucks. And the original is a masterpiece.
Edit: bass-boosting Chiwetel’s voice was an extremely lame choice and it’s super obvious eww- why didn’t they just get Jeremy Irons back? The man literally sounds the same. They brought back wholesome geezer James Earl Jones but wouldn’t bring back arguably the most iconic voice in the movie? Ew Disney. Ew. The scene is so forced omg I can’t believe how bad it is. Why is everyone’s delivery so weird? They don’t even talk like real people. Simba has ZERO emotion in this scene and in the original the emotions are literally through the roof. 1994 Lion King is one of the most emotion-heavy movies I’ve ever seen, yet this shallow remake manages to be one of the most EMOTIONLESS movies I’ve ever seen, how did they even manage that? They managed it by not caring. It was an easy billion for them. That’s all they wanted. To bank on peoples’ nostalgia and fill their own pockets. That’s what Disney is now.
Literally all of this. Thank you. But one point I'd like to elaborate is how stupid Simba's "I'm sorry" sounds. Why does he sound so nonchalant? I've heard actual children apologize with more emotion and sincerity for just breaking dishes, meanwhile Simba is supposed to be apologizing for *the death of his own father* but instead he sounds like he's saying sorry for getting a C on a math quiz or something. How did Jon ever look at any of this and think it was acceptable??!!
@@thelemurofmadagascar9183 RIGHT?!?!?!? I am honestly so shocked at the lack of emotion in the voice-acting. Also the way Scar pauses completely at random for like several seconds during his sentences? Was this......... Chiwetel’s way......... of.... sounding....... evil? Cuz it just... makes him........... hard to listen to. And Donald Glover’s performance is more “waaa boohoo dead daddy check??” As oppose to Mathew Broderick’s utter despair, horror, remorse, etc.
Also I wasn’t expecting anyone to read all that LOL and let alone respond, so cheers 🍻
@@shaydilane2172 Lmao the pauses were so annoying. It's not dramatic, it's not evil, it's just awkward and unnatural.
Tbh I'm a bit guilty of writing extremely lengthy comments myself, so I don't mind reading other people's mini "essays" either haha
@@thelemurofmadagascar9183 agreed! And yeah, sometimes writing these comments is worth it cuz u get to rant with others 😂
I can't add anything to this comment, it's so well written. I agree with you.
Notice how in the original flashback, it's not just Mufasa's death scene copy pasted with a windows movie maker fade transition; Simba remembers it as something so horrible, so traumatic, and it's reflected in the bright red that also fits the palette of the current scene. In the new version, it clashes so badly with what's currently happening, almost as if Mufasa's death was a happier moment for Simba than hanging from a rock is.
I think the red in the flashback in the 1994 version also symbolizes Simba literally seeing red in rage after Scar confesses his little secret
@@wilyserpent And the fact that it zooms in on Simba's eye as opposed to out of it really shows it ingrained in his mind even as an adult just as it did when he was a cub. You can't do the with the remake because they messed up the zoom on that one so bad.
@@klltx2001 exactly!!!
I definitely prefer his reaction in the original. You can tell it was traumatic event for him. Where as 2019. It looks like a cat upset you didn't give him milk or treats!
It’s funny how the animated G rated version is more darker than the photorealistic PG rated version.
3:28 Calm down, Disney, Simba going "Nyaaa!!" when his father died already nearly killed me with laughter. You didn't need to deal the finishing blow by making me watch it again in slow mo at the most dramatic and emotionally heavy moment in the movie
i about scream-laughed in the theater when i saw it because the ending was getting good. then it hits you with THAT
I laugh EVERYTIME and my kids get so mad 🤣🤣🤣
i laughed so hard at this moment, it is shot and edited the same way as some broke direct-to-dvd movie
I remember I snorted in the theater 😂
To me it sounds like a cat throwing a temper cause you didn't give it milk or treats!
The 2019 scene feels like an essay that's trying to meet the minimum word requirement
I’m glad I’m not the only one who thinks that lol
And yet the remake is longer...
@@DonnieTheGent1 That's the point i was trying to make. It feels like it's longer than necessary to the point that it moves much slower and the scenes have no punch to them
Oh hi northflower
Thought the build up was a bit better though. It felt more realistic for an interrogation.
1:57 sounds like Simbas apoligizing for sneaking out at night, not for causing the death of his father.
Exactly it's like please don't ground me!!!
😭😭😭
No it sounds like Simba's too cowardly to apologize he made an AI voice say "I'm sorry" instead of himself.
I simply love the original scar best his voice acting is on a whole different level and just gives me a certain vibe Im really disappointed they didn't reach out to him so he could reprise his role like mufasa did. He was actually waiting for it but it didn't happen is what I read.
I think they failed in scars voice
@@oziomaezemenaka1100 in the new one? I agree
In the remake, Scar's voice is good too, and it suits him, because the 2019 version introduced a different image of Scar
Some say that Jeremy Irons was underacting the whole time, and Andreas Deja managed to animate his expressions with the voice perfectly. If this were true, then I would admire Iron's performance more than Pauly Shore playing Pinocchio.
@@jaythebillz9543 that's amazing!
"Daddy isn't here to save you, and now everyone knows why!" >> "Then bow to your king!"
THAT SCAR IN BOTH ANIMATED AND THE REAL DISNEYS THE LION 🦁 KING, ARE BAD LIONS BUT AT THE END OF THE LION 🦁 KING, THE ANIMATED OF THE LION 🦁 KING AND THE REAL DISNEYS THE LION 🦁 KING, SIMBA BEAT SCAR IN THE REAL DISNEYS THE LION 🦁 KING AND THE ANIMATED ONE TOO
Jesus Christ, ok so ur saying scar was a villain and he was defeated in both films? Did you want him to succeed? How is this Amy relevanc eot the comment?
Disney read along
@@tigrytime658Hey brother, I just wanted to say to you man that Jesus is God and to say His name like that is using God’s name in vain. I just wanted to tell you that brother. I hope all is well with you. Jesus loves you brother and He d*ed on the cross for you and for me and for our sins so that we can live with Him for eternity. Jesus calls us to repent of our sins and to put our faith and trust in Him and be baptized. I know this is coming out of nowhere, but I thought you should know brother. I pray you come home to the Catholic Church friend. God bless you!
@@philippierangeli4412 hey so I probably was a bit excessive with my blasphemy and I apologise but I’m agnostic until the day I die. The fact that the bible is so contradictory and the cruel ways religion has been used in the past means I have no reason to believe in its power or significance
The remake is trying too hard to be a beat-for-beat, line-for-line remake but every line comes across as awkward. Like they could have tried to give it it’s own identity but they weren’t interested in that, they just wanted to scab off nostalgia by making the same film but they somehow did it so much worse.
Because the 1994 version runs circles around the 2019 version every time.
Which is very odd because I can think of so many scenes from the original that they shortened significantly and one or two didn't even make it in to the remake, yet the 2019 version is half an hour longer!
@@rosssimpson4919 The 2 scenes I hate that didn't make it in was when Timon distracted the Hyenas by doing that dance, and when Rafiki whacks Simba in the head with his stick!
@@aliciacleeland2257 yeah, at least with Timone’s dance, I wasn’t expecting the lifeless “realistic” remake to do exactly that, whatever they did instead must have been really stale because I’ve forgotten about it, but with the stick scene with Simba they removed a PIVOTAL moment for his character development! That one they had no excuse removing it for being unrealistic to have a mandrill carrying a stick the whole time but they LET HIM HAVE IT FOR THE FIGHT!!! What part of the fight was more important to stop being realistic, than one of the most important scenes for Simba’s character????
@@rosssimpson4919 There was nothing realistic about the movie! What Mandrill holds up a cub. Showing him to the pride land. Idk I hated the 2019 version it was super boring.
1994: NOOOOOO!!!!! MURDERER!!!
2019: MY FATHER!!! YOUR OWN BROTHER!!! HOW COULD YOU?!!!
I like the 2019 line better
It has more feeling to it
@@darkkomet1653 I understand. At least both versions tell the same story, just two alternate perspectives.
I have to say that I like the 2019 version better simply because I connect the old version to a difficult time I had as a child
@@writingismymagic3565 What do you mean by that?
@@ericwood2062 my mum got into a car accident and was in the hospital, and while we waited my dad wanted to distract me, so he let me watch the lion king on his tablet
the 2019 version is sooooo lifeless. where’s the heart
"Heart is a emotion and emotion aren't real," jOn fAvReaU
And expressionless
It probably wouldn’t be realistic enough for JOOONNN
My sentiments exactly. This is why I love animated films because you have to really use your vocal muscles to bring forth the performance.
The 2019 version is not bad but it's not as awesome as the original 1994 version.
They just thought, "as long as we use nostalgia we don't even need to try. People wont care".
I literally never noticed this until now, but at 1:19 you can see Simba make a “what is he talking about?” face just as Scar starts whispering in his ear. Such attention to detail in expression that’s completely lost in the 2019 remake.
They did that very well back then, having the characters react to what the other said or did in the moment
I killed mufasa ☠️
Not only is there emotion in the original but better acting and choreography overall. Ironically it feels more natural and realistic especially with the dialog choices where as the remake, it ends up feeling forced to make up for the lack of emotion. Also that scream mufasa does when he falls in the flash 100% feels like it was taken from the original.
Probably because they usually animate the scenes after they record so they can get the facial expressions to match. Where as the 2019 movie being a bit too realistic makes it impossible for the Lions to exaggerate enough for us to feel the drama.
1:16 - Scar lunges at Simba. Swift, sharp, threatening.
3:12 - *bounce*
Haha that jump 🤣💀💀
Right! And that roar of Simba's in the 2019 was a joke, it seemed more like a hiss! The "bounce" felt forced! Where it was more dramatic in 1994
Then how do you see the look in Mufasa's eyes?!
1994 version: *How we want it*
2019 version: *How it actually turned out*
😭😭😭😭
Naw all the had to do is make it real.. stop changing words
(I know this isn't the same scene, but close enough ehe) The way Simba reacts to Mufasa's death in 2019 is so funny. He looks like a angry little kitten, and the way it zooms out from him and he is so tiny raging on the cliff made me laugh out loud in the theater (it was just my family, I wouldn't do that in front of other people, I hate when people make a ruckus in the theater) but seriously it looked ridiculous.
I'm glad I'm not the only one who did this :P
That part made me laugh so hard I had to take a deep breath. Then I paused the movie and continued watching after a few months cause I hated it. I pirated it, but I still feel robbed😂
😭😭😭nah cause the first time I watched the movie I was giggling
Love the original because the animation is amazing but it shows more emotion, expressions and is like relatable while the live action is like a zoo visit
Especially when Scar circles around Simba and the cuts in between to their faces is just 🙌🏼
@@razahyder8541 facts!
@@razahyder8541 I know, it's just so cinematic.
On like drugs lol
In the 1994 version, Matthew Broderick uses his slow-to-anger personality as the voice of Adult Simba while Donald Glover throws a hissy fit as the voice of the rightful king of the Pride Lands in the 2019 version.
Honestly I like Matthew Broderick's Adult Simba better than Donald Glover's Adult Simba because Matthew showed real emotion meanwhile Donald just didn't act like he had real emotions.
Scar thinks Simba's the murderer, but he's not. But Scar is.
In french it's Emmanuel curtil as the voice of simba adult , in french it's very much better 💜
💜👍🏼Emmanuel also make the voice fr of Doug Savant(Tom Scavo) and jim Carrey
I guess Simba's not a murderer. But Scar is. He's the one who killed Simba's father at the gorge!
1994: Aged like wine
2019: Aged like milk
2019: Aged like poop.
FR, How does anybody like it ? Those lions have no distinction, no expressions.
Now, I am worried about HTTYD Live-action remake.
@@DragonOfTheMortalKombat Many are just a bunch of blind sheep thinking Disney can do no wrong.
Wine is slept on
I dont know why, but for me 1994 version have much soul in every scene...not bad, but this will never beat up the original Lion King
This ties with the original make
@@FaraanBabar2616 some scenes were utter shit but some were better than the original so that makes up for it personally I prefer can you feel the love tonight in the more recent version
@@bigbootylatinas9313 I agree with u
that’s because the 2019 version is cancer
I would recommend watching the YMS review of the remake, it’ll explain most of why you feel this way about it. It’s only on part 1 right now, but so far it’s explained why every change made was for the worse.
It is funny how many people say that they like the 1994 version more. There are objective reasons why the 1994 is better.
They took away everything emotional impactful in the 2019 version. Voice acting is weak, everything is blue, the new music sounds very generic, there are points where the lions look like they are in a 3D environment, there are no expressions at all and there are no characters. I can not believe we live in a world where the 2019 is one of the most successful movies of all time.
There is even purpose in the flashback in the 1994 version. While in the 2019 version it is just a slow-mo version of the event.
Also the teeth of Mufasa look weird when he falls in the 2019 version.
Holy crap. I didn't realise it after pausing it. When scar put his claws on simbas paws they bleed a bit. Such nice details. I miss these old animated movies..
Yo same here!
3:11 god I love that little pounce he does, looks like a 2010 gmod parody
I like 1994's Scar than 2019's Scar.
Me too
I don't really like 2019 Scar
2019 Scar kinda acts like one of those generic villians added just because they needed an antagonist. He doesn't really stand out and charm the audience like his 1994 counterpart.
I like both.
Same here! 1994 version of Scar rocks!
I forgot how amazing this scene was in the 1994 version: the score, the lightning strikes, the emotions on the character and Jeremy Irons’s voice performance is absolutely perfect. Probably my favorite voice acting performance ever
3:11 That little pounce! I can't!
Imagine if Sarabi said "it's not true, that's impossible" 😳
Star Wars vibes be gettin to me
jOn was overly excited about star wars, described the scene when the monkey retrieve his staff was his lightsaber.
Really show where his head is focuses on.
"search your feelings. you will know it to be true." - Scar
"Our goal was to make it as real to life as it possibly could be" Well congrats John Favro, you succeed. And it's absoultely horrible because of it. You know what this beautifully animated musical needs? Painfully accurate realism! Paste swilling simpleton.
@Nate Rivers Ikr?! Like ironically, the 1994 version is more realistic than the 2019 version because of the emotion and acting put in it 😂
@@noodles_poodles392 In a way, yes actually. Like it's even more silly to see a photo realistic lion try it's hardest to emote, sing and move like a cartoon than seeing an actual cartoon do it.
Though seeing the dinosaur planet thing, I'm honestly convinced this was just a proof of concept to show the technology was possible while casually making 7 figures. Not cause the move itself was any good, but because Lion King is so beloved you'd have to do a theatrical release of a bunch of furries dressed as lions in a fur pile with the Lion King logo slapped on it not to profit well into the billions. And even then it would make money just because the title alone is that damn powerful. For more on this, look into the marketing for Craptain Marvel. Yeah, the 4th wave feminist drivel was there, but it was mostly market as you needed to see it understand what went on to be the most profitable movie in history, Avengers End Game.
I liked the remake and the animation one tho
I’m taking that insult and storing it for future use
@@noodles_poodles392 lol lion don't show emotion dumbass 🤪🤪🤪
The original: Scar actually lashes onto Simbas paws
Remake:Lightly jumps onto his paws
I noticed that too hahaha, he just stands on them, it's really a moment I remember from my childhood the way he claws into Simba
The 1994 version: Full of life and emotion, very realistic.
The 2019 version: A lifeless husk of the original scene that looks like something out of a budget puppet show
😭 cry
Yes. It’s so realistic that Simba suddenly flies and pounces on Scar 😂😂
@@mjjcontentbetter than the live action tho 👀
Wow. I've never watched a full scene from the 2019 version until now, and it looks like I was completely correct to avoid it. Disney really demonstrates the principle "just because you can, doesn't mean you should."
It was awful. I would stick to the original!
RIP James Earl Jones, the voice of Mufasa in the Lion King (1994). He was 93. 9-9-24
The thing I’ve noticed about Scar in the original movie is that he uses the least amount of words to get the most amount of impact when accusing Simba of being a murderer. In the live action, he didn’t need to keep demanding, “Say it!” as he backs Simba down. Maybe for the hyenas, but once would have been enough for Scar if they built up his menacing presence in Be Prepared.
The animation had more PERSONALITY/ CONTINUITY! I love how they BLEND young Simba's NO with the adult Simba - the with a rush of adrenaline jumps on Scar!
Seeing the 2019 live action/cgi version after the 1994 animated classic hurts so much. All the life and personality has been completely sucked dry. People will continue to watch the 1994 animated movie cause it's timeless and anyone can watch it (my nephews love it!), while the 2019 version will fade into obscurity; the only use I could think of it would be to use it in film school as an example on when a remake fails.
the way scar stalks and prances around him whispering thoughts into his head like a muse, the way he verbally trips simba up forcing a half baked confession, the vibrancy and details making it easy to tell which lion is which, a complete masterpiece. Right, the 2019 version, um, very realistic
The Lion King is the first movie I remember seeing in the theaters and having the movie make me _feel_ things, even at 8 years old. It was a defining film experience of my childhood. All these years later and the original animated scene is _still_ giving me chills. Which leads to my question. Who the heck thought that the CGI remake (I refuse to call it live action because it isn't) was a good idea? I feel absolutely nothing at all watching the scene from the remake.
Only thing I like about the remake is how we see Simba get up the ledge. I didn’t really like how in the original Simba magically just finds a footing to propel himself so drastically.
You have a point about that, but its execution lacks the impact like in the original. The way Simba lunges at Scar is full of energy and shows his rage while the remake undercuts it with a quick and weak looking bite.
The new lion king is not realistic..you cannot feel the way that they spoke..sounds like their reading script..compare to 1994 lion king, every that the spoke you can feel their feeiling
@MJS I agree 100% John Favreau wanted the remake to be “realistic as possible”, but ironically enough, the 1994 version was even more realistic af
This scene hits harder now that James died😭😭
I'm with ya 😢😢😢😢
James Earl Jones didn’t die, he is with the greatest kings of the past. Long live the king 👑
1994 Lion King will always be the best Disney film ever created ♥️
Aladdin, Hercules, Mulan?
Everyone is focusing on one or two lines of dialogue and saying "Oh the 2019 version is great it alters the lines" sure if it was the same and just altered the lines it would be fine, but it doesn't.
Notice as Scar accuses him the difference in body language and emphasis on tone and words. Scar circles him in the original, his words stabbing at Simba. In the Live Action "Scar" just shouts at him while laying down then moves towards him. The way Scar pauses and places a claw to his chin in feigned contemplation of trying to remember why the scene is familiar to the dull and lifeless version of "Scar" standing over "Simba" and then just bouncing to claw him. The realization showing in Simba's face is shown through expression and his anger is palpable, compared to the "Rawr I bit you and will now shout at you".
I liked both
My favorite part about the 1994 is that you can actually feel Simba's emotions
The agony in Sarabi’s eyes and voice when she thinks that Simba was responsible for Mufasa’s death couldn’t be replicated.
In the original 1994 movie, Simba comes determined to confront Scar, and when Scar accuses Simba of Murder, he respects the punishment looks on lionesses's faces(because obviously, he thought that the lionesses would be disappointed in him by telling them)and is trying to reason the cause of his actions, by saying things like "It was an accident! I'm not a murderer!"
In 2019 version, he looks more like a scared little kitty.
The 1994 version is more intense... 1:21. The "NOOOOOOO!!!" was much stronger....
Exactly Simba also showed more anger here.
While the “NOOOOOO” at 3:28 was just hilarious as hell 😂
Man's really went "nyaaaaa" 💀
@@noodles_poodles392 1994 "NOOOOOOO" was emotional while 2019 was like he accidentally dropped a glass
2:53 in this part it’s really hard to tell his emotion of being mischievous and looks more like he’s angry which is giving the wrong idea to the audience
'It was me... I'm sorry 🙄🙄 I'm not a MURDERER 😒'
Original is so much better
Scar just casually lying down in the second version just...lol the VA just sounded so insincere in my op
1994 movie: What you saw in the online store
2019 movie: What actually arrived at your home
I agree 1994 was more dramatic than 2019
Not only that but Mufasa’s death was painfully funny to watch in the 2019 one.
@@M.A.C.01😭fell like he was in a video game
Dam uncle scar probably made simba feel like a kid when he said "Oh simba your in trouble again but this time DADDY ISINT here to save you"
The 2019 movie really ain’t that bad… I didn’t hate it, but I do agree that the original is better.
1994:Piece of art of love
2019: just because it’s realistic doesn’t mean it books good! Scar doesn’t look like a thing like him then he did in 1994! Neither did Mufasa
When you realize they said 'kill' in old Disney properties, but now we get
"I HAVE SOME CHILDREN I NEED TO MAKE INTO *CORPSES!!!!!"*
(I love that quote from Bill Cipher by the way)
Technically, the question should read “who is responsible for Mufasa‘s death?“ The correct answer: Disney
3:34 that scene explains the way Simba returned to the dominant position and made struggle begging for mercy 1:27
it still shocks me how amazing the original animation looks in comparison considering how old it is
I like how in the 2019 version Scar gets exposed by Sarabi by asking how he would have known the look in Mufasa’s eyes if he hadn’t gotten to the gorge in time instead of being strangled into admitting it
I've watched both of them,
1994 impacted me way more than the 2019 and I was able to see that one in theaters
It's just something about the original that is just so much better
I really love how you can see 0 emotion in the remake thanks a bunch JON
The original had so much more emotion in it, I feel like if they used realistic versions of the original characters instead of straight up realistic lions it would’ve been better
1994 version - masterpiece/
2019 - well, its a best movie you can show to your dog or cat.
1:00 now this looks familiar
when scar is thinking about " hmm were have a seen this before " when you look at Simba he looks so creepy.
👍
thumbs up
That "I killed Mufasa" whispered is such an iconic line .
I rlly liked liked '' I can't wait to be king'' for example because it was so colorful, funny and I love the expressions of Zazoo being so done with the cubs. The songs are very good and nostalgic. I really don' t wanna imagine what they did in the life action with that after I have seen this bland shit in such a scene where there needs to be emotion and drama. The 1994 version made me feel stuff and cry every time Mufasa died even after 20 times. The life remake is just nothing imo. Glad i did not watch it
I find the "yOu GuYs ArE mIsSiNg ThE pOiNt" crowd hilarious.
The live action remake used the original's existence as a selling point. You can't just handwave the animated version away just because this is a separate movie. They knew what they were doing in the marketing and the filming. It tried to tell the same story, keeping many of the same lines and having similar shots, but that's it.
Not gonna lie, Scar looks like one badass lion!!!!
in the animated version the scene feels better represented plus the shocking music and the way Scar surrounds Simba in circles.. and the line "Simba, you're in trouble again, but this time daddy isn't here to save you" catches me because of how Scar says it... although in live action the new lines are also fine when Scar, to put the lionesses against Simba, begins by saying: should we believe the son who causes the death of a king? A son who abandons his mother? and that also begins to denigrate him saying: you're what? are you the king? pushing him back to the edge of saying that he is nothing..and the way Simba remembers his father's death after Scar confesses the truth in the animated version is much better, because you can feel his pain and anger that his father was taken from him by Scar
R.i.p. James Earl Jones
The money they had spent on a live action, they could have spent it on another 2D animated movie. 😭 Which they dont make anymore. 3D is the new way to go, but Id LOVE to see a handdrawn animation again... In the style of 101 dalmations for examplehe
The classic confession is more sinister and 2x better then the stupid remake.
1:05
"Where have I seen this before.."
Haha 🤣
1994: Full-powered pounce counter and turned the tables around their positions
2019: Haha! Hair chomp go nyomm
Something I hated about the remake is that i could never tell Simba and Scar apart from each other
Sarabi gets more character development in the new version and she found out that Scar was lying to the pride.
But she's never happy with her family, she's all serious and even an incompetent queen who nearly drove her own pride to starvation just because she refuse to leave her native home and think to the memories of the one she loves instead of the other lives. Sure I liked that Sarabi got more screen-time but unfortunately she doesn't serve the plot very well and Mufasa, Rafiki, Timon and Pumbaa and Nala already served the plot very well so there was no need of that. Also in the original there's was no need of someone pointing out Scar was liying all this while because after his confession of Mufasa's death it was already enough Simba forcing him to admit the truth to the pride by pinning him down and leaving him terrified for his life.
@@fuckalldisneyremakesorigin5560Ok so we wants to live in a world where everything sucks or we want to see something good in the things who has sucked a bit
@@fuckalldisneyremakesorigin5560 nice name lol
@@mregggentlepartner1046 sorry but it's so undeniable that if Simba didn't return to reclaim his throne, the pride would have been starved to death. Also what she told Nala is pointless, because Nala didn't learn nothing from those words and did actually the right choice to leave the Pride Rock to find help otherwise would have starve. This Sarabi is stupid, selfish, incompetent and insignificant, she's a terribly written character.
@@fuckalldisneyremakesorigin5560 O k you've right is only that I got sick to people who thinks that everything of new is horrible!!!! In fact found only one of the Fandom that say that present things are worst the
When I was a child, me and my dad would watch Lion king very often because I loved it so much and we were both crying our eyes out. My name is Simon and even today many years later he calls me Simba
I hate the pacing of the remake in this scene it's so BAD.
"It's true I'm sorry" there's no emotion in this performance. Vs in the original, the lionesses look shocked at learning this lie that Scar stated, that Simba is responsible for Mufasa's death. Then Sarabi faces her son, begging him to tell her that it isn't true, Simba can't even look her in the eyes. "It's true." this is said haltingly like he can't even get the words out. THEN Scar pounces on the moment. In the remake it's just "It's true I'm sorry" there's no moment to breathe, no moment of Sarabi begging her son to tell her he isn't responsible for his father's death it's just ALL. WRONG.
I understand the intent of Simba not facing Sarabi, the intent is that he can't face her, but it's more powerful for Sarabi to try and look at her son in the eye while she gets the truth, and he unable to.
Scar circling Simba is so much more of an impactful image then Simba just HAPPENING to be forced to the ledge. Scar's whole speech isn't as impactful either. THE ENTIRE POINT OF THE SCENE IS THAT HE IS KILLING SIMBA WITH THE GUILT OF CAUSING HIS FATHER'S DEATH. "Ohhhh Simba, you're in trouble again. Only this time, DADDY isn't here to save you. And now everyone KNOWS. WHY." Bam lightning strike. The editing the pacing, the line delivery, the camerawork it all compliments the moment. Why would Scar hammer home the fact that Simba killed the king he just said this it would be better for Scar to eat at Simba's guilt.
Mufasa's dialogue is what got me to enjoy villians and their perspective more, and I was seven years old.
2019 lion king When scar is asking question to cimba he seated and looks like relaxing..😂..unlike the original he is walking around to cimba to pressure him..even the accent of scar more pressure to me, and I think if Im in the cimba's situation I would say "ah no, yes ,no, i mean it was an accident" 😆
I’m pretty sure scar was calm in the 2019 version because he knew Simba was going to say he was the reason for mufasa’s death😂
3:32 cute simba
The story the voices the animation the soundtrack never gets old🦁
“I saw the fear in his eyes”
Bro how can you even tell-💀💀💀
@Kejser Yusuf Genghis Ali Demun Easy there, buddy. That’s not what I meant. I meant that in the newest lion king, you can’t see the fear in his eyes because all of the characters are completely expressionless.
This is a scary and sad flashback that simba had that happened a long time ago but simba still remembers
Sure the 2019 version feels like the crew were watching Game of Thrones backstage but where’s the sass??
It’s not the Lion King without sassy scar!
Take the animated movie, remove the facial expressions, the music and the epic dialogue, increase budget and here we are.
"You're what? Say it!"
"I'm nothing"
"Then BOW TO YOUR KING!"
Say what u want about the remake, that is awesome!
I like how in the 1994 version, Scar is walking everywhere and yet in the 2019, he’s just sitting on his @ss 😂
The way remake Simba says "It's true, I'm sorry." makes it sound more like he's confessing to stealing money from his moms purse than accidentally causing someone's death lmao
Who here after hearing the news 😭😭😭
I like the "Then bow to your King" line.
Otherwise, 1994 was so much better
Maybe but he's saying that when he's about to kill him.
@@fuckalldisneyremakesorigin5560 exactly. To humiliate him one last time before killing
Simba: Scar, you killed my father.
I will say that I do like the dialogue's build up a bit more in the 2019 version, where the lionnesses realize Scar was lying from what he told Simba before he realizes Scar killed him. Scar tries to brush off his screw up by trying to pretend Simba was theatening him. Though the delivery was better in 1994 with better voice acting, 2019's scar has some moments.