I see everybody complementing all the other member’s vocals and rap but nobody is complementing Gaeul’s vocals and she also rapped so weelll Let’s appreciate her vocals and rap also… girl even got really few lines and screen time
the amount of comments negatively talking about wonyoung,, like everywhere she is there’s just people mad at her sheesh she doesn’t even sound bad at all
They did a spectacular performance with their vocals. They're just new but, they got great potentials. Not just visuals but with voice and dancing. They're still young and they will do great as they grow older in the industry. Good job IVE!! fighting!
Vocal Ranking 1. Yujin/Liz 2. Liz/Yujin 3. Rei 4. Wonyoung 5. Leeseo 6. Gaeul Tbh I know Wonyoung needs some improvement, but I don’t think her vocals are super bad like everyone says it is
@@urhomexel but it's only ppl putting her down or hating on her :( the comment didn't say that nobody comment abt her but nobody "compliment" her. Dives never appreciate or compliment her work
If 🤔Liz joined PD48 and became the 13th member, who knows how more powerful would IZ*ONE be and by thinking 12 vocals are already a power house think of it how more powerful if Liz became the 13th member😵
I think she would suit a more deeper tone, although I rlly appreciate the improvement and training she did outside of I*ZONE. Love dive she sounds rlly good
@@milkyuuu6170 yeah I agree, love dive was good. I think wonyoung needs to train herself to sing the complicated notes. Love dive didn't have any of that notes as compared to eleven 🙂
Im hoping its because shes still going through puberty and perhaps her voice will mature. wonyoung also was criticised for the same thing when she was in izone (along with her pitchy squeaky voice) but her voice hasn't changed much, besides her technique and confidence improving a little.
@@animerocksyourworld6229 but then I'm pretty sure puberty wouldn't change the technique of the singers... because nasal is a technique...maybe her voice might change after puberty but it doesn't change the fact that she would still use a nasal technique....this is def up to the vocal teachers...they gotta guide these children to sing using the proper technique so that their voice wouldn't be harmed
No hate, but I'm rather disappointed by Wonyoung's vocals. I'm not sure if it was because she got harder lines, but why is she constantly losing breath. Okay I guess it might be because of the part too since Yujin seems to be doing the same.
well wony's still being trained w her vocals, same w the other mems. its kinda hard for her bc she didnt get many training before pd48 its understandable same w yujin. but yujin's vocal support is better no hate to wony
@@pomegranate7618 how does girl boss have anything to do with sounding off-key? such a weird thing to say. and yes, she does sound off-key in the studio. we all know she's a good singer but in this clip, she sounds off.
Don't think that I'm a hater or something else, but I'm just more convinced that Wonyoung's voice doesn't suit this song. When she's singing live, you can hear back-vocals that even louder than her voice, in my opinion her version (in a softer and quieter voice) sounds better, but unfortunately this is not what was needed in the final version of the song... it even upsets me.
@@Emmacoffee8 i do believe in her too, but not in the company she has a soft voice that sounds good when she sings low-pitched parts and suits perfectly for pre-chorus parts or something like this, yet she gets parts that too high for her, that's company's mistake (idk who's in duty of the line distribution) i think the right key for her voice is already found in love dive and i hope next comeback she'll get similar parts
![[IVE ON] IVE 'After LIKE' Recording BEHIND](/img/n.gif)
Actually I like Leeseo’s first version of “odd”, because of embarrassment she changed to “ode” sound.
No it’s odd duh shut up
lees
I agree
0:10
i love it
I see everybody complementing all the other member’s vocals and rap but nobody is complementing Gaeul’s vocals and she also rapped so weelll
Let’s appreciate her vocals and rap also… girl even got really few lines and screen time
I love her voice a lot
she's my ultimate bias
her vocals deserve to be appreciated more
Gaeul vocal is quite weak tho
@@suicao4980 just like the others since shes the 3rd best vocalist just bc she doesnt have enough lines doesnt mean she cant sing
This is why Liz is the main
Most people don’t give Rei as much credit for her vocals as a rapper, b it she by far the most stable during live performances.
🥺
r-rapper? ive has a rapper? ive? rei? rapper?? huh??
@@nagisa4018 a kpop rapper.. not as in underground rapper or anything
She has written her own raps too i believe
@@nagisa4018 yes and she Can rap well and sing vert well than u
OMG THIS SONG DEFINITELY SUITS REI’S VOICE
does everyone notice that everytime leeseo sings, she winks HAHAHAH
Baby WY
shes so cute 😂♥
Liz is strongest in her lower register, and honestly the part just before aya aya aya has a lot of ups and downs, it's not easy
rei at 5:01 and the m producer "uhh" approving was everything to me
Rei’s voice is natural.
🥰
Yujin vocals !!!! WOW
🖤
4:12 REI'S rap is so amazing I can't stop replying,
There so amazing!💕
Multi-talented!💫
Thank you for this comment, now I have no regret adding her rap parts in this video😁🥰
THAT'S OUR MAIN RAPPER NAOI REIIIII💙💙💙
What song is it from?
@@kameliahbritton4703 eleven ive
Wait that was a rap?😭 I never knew
@@zerked. I think she meant the rap at 4:34
Rei!!! Rei's vocal is amazing! She's a banger
not a fan of IVE but Liz best girl ever🤧🤧🤧
Rei’s voice is the most stable.. shes so natural
Rei's rap was so cool.
liz’s voice is pure honey😭
So pretty IVE
yeah the visual❤️❤️❤️
@@zner5344 Ok thank you
the amount of comments negatively talking about wonyoung,, like everywhere she is there’s just people mad at her sheesh she doesn’t even sound bad at all
Exactly
True
exactly !!
these weirdos have really started to think they're better than wonyoung
leeseo is a mini wonyoung and it’s so satisfying that they are in the same group
this song was made to be sung by Rei, eleven suits Rei so well
They did a spectacular performance with their vocals. They're just new but, they got great potentials. Not just visuals but with voice and dancing. They're still young and they will do great as they grow older in the industry. Good job IVE!! fighting!
WONYOUNG AND REI’S SOUND SO GOOD IN THIS VIDEO
🖤🖤
2:39 Wonyoung's vocal is beautiful 🥇🥺👑
Liz sound so good
wonyoung's voice is just
I love watching Wonyoung in the studio and radio performances - she’s really into it and I love it!!😍🙌🏾
I more appreciate Rei's voice than Liz
Idk why but i love unique voices
YESSS!!!!!
@Espurrrxd it's not comparing, it's just our opinion and personal preference.
The word "than" thats used in the sentence is comparing
he's comparing his preference/appreciation 😊
my ears are in paradise...✨
rei's voice is just soo 😍
idk why but when i watched eleven mv for the first time Yujin give me Jisoo's vibes
lol same
@@im_jos4506 lol i was like "oh idk why but she's a lil bit like Jisoo"
@@integralservices1382 facts lol
She give me Jeongyeon vibe😆
@@zner5344 oh lol
ok but why ain't anyone appreciating gaeul's skills-
i rly love liz and leeseo’s voice
No one complimenting Leeseo's vocals?? They're amazing ❤️
Vocal Ranking
1. Yujin/Liz
2. Liz/Yujin
3. Rei
4. Wonyoung
5. Leeseo
6. Gaeul
Tbh I know Wonyoung needs some improvement, but I don’t think her vocals are super bad like everyone says it is
Everyone who?
liz is 1 bec her vocal technique is good
Actually Liz would be first... Didn't you hear Royal?
@@lasandia_sana199 I think Liz’s studio voice is better, but I feel like yujin is a bit more stable live but they’re very close
gaeul and leesoo is better than wonyoung
Leeseo is really such a great singer. I love her tone, too.
YUJIN SLAAAYYY
I like LEESEO because she are my idol, i chosse for my class 6
Wonyoung vocals is so good💗
leeseoo!
Wonyoung vocal is soooooo
Wonyoung did so well! Her vocals sound consistent and great
i love yujin's unique voice
0:35 UGH I WOULDVE LOVED TO HEAR LEESEO DOING THAT CHORUS
My gosh I need more Rei rap content! Would love to hear a full solo from her
Liz!
A Wonyoung está arrasando como sempre
E a Yujin tbm né queridos kkkk
Minhas bias
6:19 meu Deus que vocal lindooo
REI
lIZ
LEESEO
GAEUL
WONYOUNG
YUNJIN
Frfrfr
My opinion anyways
Why does nobody compliment wonyoung? Her vocals are so pretty, just like her!
true !!
Yeah but for me it sounds too nasal even if she improved a lot
(no offense) half of the comments are filled with wonyoung sooo
@@urhomexel but it's only ppl putting her down or hating on her :( the comment didn't say that nobody comment abt her but nobody "compliment" her. Dives never appreciate or compliment her work
@@urhomexel not for me they aren’t. I’ve seen one comment and it was for yujin and included wony sooo.
liz is in a lower key? it's different from the song
gaeul face looks like rich Chinese beauty
I LOVE YOU REI
rei and gaeul 💗
Liz and Gaeul 🙌😍
4:32 REI THE BEST RAPPER IN GEN4 🔥🔥💕💕
gaeul only needs to record one like since her lines are only repeated + her adlibs. poor gaeul 😢
Whoaa leeseo does blink a lot
liz is amazing
Wowwwww lizzzz
in love with yujins voice
im falling in love with rei damnnnnn
rei is amazing
The first girl odd is cute.. she is preety
Her name is leeseo
Rei best rapper
5:44 Yujin is so stable!
💗💗they're so cute💗💗
The amount of wink😅😅😅
😂😂
Lesso is fine
Wdym?
@@xinyiyis maybe he says that Leeseo is fine not good not bad
4:38 so good
wow
gaeul rap>>>>
The best of this gen
Who's your bias in IVE? 🙂
I do like yujin but also liz
All OT6
OT6🌻 JSJSJ😭
OT6🙂
OT6
No hate pls.
Just my opinion...
1. Rei
2. Leeseo
3. Wonyoung
4. Liz
5. Yujin
6. Gaeul (just because of the lesser line 🥺, poor gaeul)
wonyoung vocal better than yujin and liz 😐 who’s both of them vocalist in the group !!!
I love won but this is too much
@@Rr-gf1gj that's his opinion-_-
@@Rr-gf1gj It's not only about vocal It's about voice + singing style and many other things It's just their opinion
Gal what.. 😭how the lead and main vocalists lower than wonyoung 💀
@@z_neta07 that's his opinion
poor gaeul :(
I wish she had more lines, she has a beautiful voice
liz 💝
"Live" yeah put the encore of the song then we can talk live
If 🤔Liz joined PD48 and became the 13th member, who knows how more powerful would IZ*ONE be and by thinking 12 vocals are already a power house think of it how more powerful if Liz became the 13th member😵
Okay no hate but I think wonyoung needs to improve
I actually think she sounds good hahahaha
I think she would suit a more deeper tone, although I rlly appreciate the improvement and training she did outside of I*ZONE. Love dive she sounds rlly good
@@milkyuuu6170 yeah I agree, love dive was good. I think wonyoung needs to train herself to sing the complicated notes. Love dive didn't have any of that notes as compared to eleven 🙂
yeah i think her higher register is weaker but i’m sure she can improve!
I agree with this... she sounds amazing but I don't think she found the right key for her voice as yet, soon enough she will find it
Rei lesso and Yujin are the best singers
Everyone is good. They are all great vocalists.
why wonyoung's voice is so much beautiful?
i love gaeul rap
What's name the rap song? Cause I like it!!
Eleven
what is the title of the song that is part when Rei raps?
It's actually studio recording not practice/studio
👀
No hate but leeseo's vocals is good but she is very nasally based
Im hoping its because shes still going through puberty and perhaps her voice will mature. wonyoung also was criticised for the same thing when she was in izone (along with her pitchy squeaky voice) but her voice hasn't changed much, besides her technique and confidence improving a little.
@@animerocksyourworld6229 but then I'm pretty sure puberty wouldn't change the technique of the singers... because nasal is a technique...maybe her voice might change after puberty but it doesn't change the fact that she would still use a nasal technique....this is def up to the vocal teachers...they gotta guide these children to sing using the proper technique so that their voice wouldn't be harmed
GAuel is ace
my top 3 vocalists
1. Liz
2. Rei
3. Yujin
I just prefer Rei's over Yujin.
poor Wonnie has such a short vocal range. one octave and no heft. must be hard.
No hate, but I'm rather disappointed by Wonyoung's vocals. I'm not sure if it was because she got harder lines, but why is she constantly losing breath.
Okay I guess it might be because of the part too since Yujin seems to be doing the same.
So you telling me that her vocals are bad, after all she is just 16 and she has alot of work even yujin was breathless.
Honestly plus if your constantly losing breath while just doing the studio recording how are you dancing and singing live on stage
well wony's still being trained w her vocals, same w the other mems. its kinda hard for her bc she didnt get many training before pd48 its understandable same w yujin. but yujin's vocal support is better no hate to wony
@@Fearless_Fationista 17
Yujin seungmin and taehyun are siblings
Perasaaan yang lainn pada ga nampak muka si bibir doang yang bisa" nya jauh amat mic nya dari tuh bibirnyaa
A mais desafinadinha é a Woonyoung. Mas ainda sim canta bem
Liz sounds so off-key 😭
NO SHE DOES NOT SHES A GIRLBOSS
@@pomegranate7618 how does girl boss have anything to do with sounding off-key? such a weird thing to say. and yes, she does sound off-key in the studio. we all know she's a good singer but in this clip, she sounds off.
@@pomegranate7618 in order to make it understandable for you: she sounds flat.
may i know which part pls
time stamp?
Don't think that I'm a hater or something else, but I'm just more convinced that Wonyoung's voice doesn't suit this song. When she's singing live, you can hear back-vocals that even louder than her voice, in my opinion her version (in a softer and quieter voice) sounds better, but unfortunately this is not what was needed in the final version of the song... it even upsets me.
She hasn't found the right key for her voice to fit as yet... soon enough she will, I believe in her
@@Emmacoffee8 i do believe in her too, but not in the company
she has a soft voice that sounds good when she sings low-pitched parts and suits perfectly for pre-chorus parts or something like this, yet she gets parts that too high for her, that's company's mistake (idk who's in duty of the line distribution)
i think the right key for her voice is already found in love dive and i hope next comeback she'll get similar parts
You know , i know, wonyoung got popular because her beauty..😶not talent heheheh.....but you know other members doing great specially rei, gaeul♥️
Just say you're a ot5 dive and go
She's top 3 in vocalz but ok