Yar keya kamal ka explain keya, being Sindhi i loved the way you narrated the real history with your jolly style :) History is often marked by bloodshed, yet your ability to remain neutral is beautifully reflected in your explanation.
A few months ago I started listening to some Desi liberals and I had become against the Arab conquerors.... But you beautifully explained how it was a strategic war...
@@mohsinmahesar8407 exactly that's the point that the locals and Kattars fabricated and created stories to make us believe that Arabs came here for strategic purposes not for Islam
What a great narration! You make the story very interesting. Lots of love from Mumbai, India Would like to know more about Mohd. Bin Qasim and his governance in Sindh and how did the Arab regime end here.
Shafat Bhai This Is Sohaib I Want To Suggest Topics. Underground Water Reserves Which Are Fast Depleting Because Of Water Cans Ecosystem. This Water Never Goes Back To The Land Rather Drained To The Sea. It Will Desertify Our Cities
Chacha was a Kashmri berhaman and he was Chamberlin of Last Rai ruler Sindh Raja sahasi , but he involved in conspiracy with queen and killed raja ... that's why people in Sindh dont like him 2nd Sindhi were mostly Buddhists . Traders of Sindh always like that they went to invader and have payed large sum to have their business saved..... till 1800 this practiced was as usual.. Hajjaj died during Waleed time before Suleiman but Suleiman didn't pardoned him and his skull was hanged after taking him out of grave
Sahi baat hai wo bewaQoof north ki traF Jany se behter tha south men hi kahin chup jata or apni army ko Mazboot krta ya phr thar Dessert ki traF jata wahn se Gujrat or baqi Hindustan se Army Recruit kr ky Le aata to aaj taarekh mukhtalif Hoti.
Just because he explains in layman's terms and adds humor to keep the audience interested-it doesn't mean he hasn't done his homework. All the references are mentioned in the video. Learn to appreciate the effort instead of seeking unnecessary attention.
All of your power is wasted rewriting history where raja dahir is abrave leader..moqa and other locals are great heros whereas arab are greedy and coward...
Wali saleman Mohammad bon qasim ki ibrat naak mout hoii khalifey k hathon.. in ko choro.. is baat ko pakro k musalamno moula hussain k sath ahl bait k sath kia kuch nahi kia.. bias ho k nahi achey scholar ki tarha tarikh parho to muslamano ki harkaton per bohot afsos hoga
Kya jannat ka qarina hoga! Ammar bhi Razi Allah, qatil bhi RA. Shocker of all shockers! The son of Abu Talib and Fatima bint Asad is lowered to the level of the son of Abu Sufyan and Honda for the same job!! Wow! Husayn bhi Alaihis salaam, Yazeed bh RA! Ghazab ka jannat hoga, wallah😅
Arabs never conquered India for any long period and were defeated after brief period. It was turks which finally conquered later, and they also conquered Arabs also.
point to be noted is that in start the one brahman who helped mohammad bin qasim to win his first seige indirectly got responsible for making mohammad bin qasim winning from raja dahir also
You should have given sources of truth to make a hero of Pakistan, a bloody invader. In fact, Mohd bin qasim came to spread Islam and wanted to loot Sindh. He was greedy of wealth and Sindh region is very rich area. We, Sindhis love king Dahir. He died to defend Sindh. We are proud of King Dahir. Everybody knows the beginning of Islam is for spreading Islamic culture. We are Sindhi and hate invaders. Nobody can be our hero that not belongs to our soil.
So basiclly a momin (bin qasim) conquered sindh with the help of hindu(moqa).meqns this was totally a politically war between power hungry kings.to phr hmara hero muhammad bin qasim kasey hua.kia wo sb kahani krwai gai the???
Sir love from India, I deeply sad to hear this bloody history that you guys suffered in past. I deeply respect for your sacrifices in respect of your life, wealth, culture and religion.
Excellent vlog. I have few suggestions ti make it even better. Can you please reference the incidences in the subs. Secondly can you please also tell the modern names of the cities such as sikka?
Ap aa gy hain dosri side batantany..Allah hamari hifazat kry roz naya historian paida ho raha hai...bata raha hai kaisy muslim itny crrupt thy aur hindus aur locals kitny azeem thy...
U missed the interesting story of Raja Dahir beautiful girls that we have studied in Pakistan studies that soon after the death of Rajah Dahir his family girls were captured by Mohammed bin Qasim and he used them very well and then send them to Hajjaj bi yousaf as a gift . When the girls reveled the story with Hajjaj about Mohammed bin Qasim and this burst the hanger of Hajjaj and he called back to Mohammed bin Qasim and killed him to death
Muhammad bin Qasim was our hero. The purpose of Muhammad Bin Qasim wasn't lootering. For your sake of information After Muhammad Bin Qasim Banu Sama ruled Multan and Banu Habbar ruled Mansura.
Shafat and this type of people is the result of unalign with Islamic teaching and its trainings bcz they read & learn all things from western literature although his work is very detailed and academic but he doesn’t know how to present in Muslim society But I appreciate his work at least showing history in anyway
@ShafaatAli bht zabardast bhai aap nay wese he casual method itni bari history suna di k boriyat bhi nahi hoee or maza bhi aya… apse request hai k Hindko (hazara division) ki bhi history or wahan basnay wali qoumo k baaray mai history se kuch vlogs banayen please.
Thank you very much for the detailed explanation. Very interresting. It would have been a bit more of intertest, if you had named the present day names of the historical places e.g place were the arab army crossed the indus etc. Otherwise enjoyed the episode very much.
At 18:36 the image depicting Arab archer shooting the burning arrow at Raja Dahir is holding the bow in such a way that he's gonna shoot himself in his face. Must be an AI generated image 😃
Aoa, telling story is not enough, how much it is authentic? it is important. As a student of history I think speaker did not approach the authentic references.
It's tough to say something authentic in history. what we can do is approach the oldest traditions and accounts of the incident. Both Chachnama (13th Century) and Futuh ul Buldan ( 9th Century) have been referenced for this video.
Getting married with biological siblings was a common practice back in time. It was practiced in indus, Egyptian, mesopotamia and in some parts of India. The purpose of It used to keep the blood line pure. It was not considered a Taboo just as we don't consider a taboo marrying our cousins
@@ShafaatAli007 she was not cousin she was Real sister. Isliye uske hindu Pandit aur hindu log bhi uskey khilaf ho gaye the. Pandito ne bol ye bhi bol diya tha k is PAAP gunaah ki wajah se Azaab aayega aur RAJ khatam ho jayega 😂 don't become biased
The believe of Muslims based on teaching of the holy prophet Muhammad (saw) and quran...islam doesn't recognize any arab ,sindi,or other ethnicity...we own the every aspect of islam and ...we are the followers of prophet and we also appreciate Muhammad bin Qasim,hajaj for thier good actions because of them islam reached to us , Muslims of subcontinent,other all bad action if any Muslim ruler including Muhammad bin qasim did, are not asset of Muslims umma,they are responsible for thier own actions on day of judgement 😊
Khilafat k bad jo b arbon ny jaang ki hen wo islam k le ny balka sonay chandi or dhan dolat k le the Or Raja dahir ny offer kiya tha imam hussain ko sindh main any k le tu hijaj bin yousif ny wo gusa nikala tha
Yar keya kamal ka explain keya, being Sindhi i loved the way you narrated the real history with your jolly style :)
History is often marked by bloodshed, yet your ability to remain neutral is beautifully reflected in your explanation.
Thank you :)
A few months ago I started listening to some Desi liberals and I had become against the Arab conquerors.... But you beautifully explained how it was a strategic war...
But why they fought amongst themselves in the last
But why no any info about those women who call hujjaj for help?
@@mohsinmahesar8407 exactly that's the point that the locals and Kattars fabricated and created stories to make us believe that Arabs came here for strategic purposes not for Islam
Your amazing really like your content, how you get such a deep knowledge?
Shafat Sir hats off to you ❤️🌼💛
What a great narration! You make the story very interesting. Lots of love from Mumbai, India
Would like to know more about Mohd. Bin Qasim and his governance in Sindh and how did the Arab regime end here.
You just gave me an idea for a video
Shafat Bhai This Is Sohaib I Want To Suggest Topics.
Underground Water Reserves Which Are Fast Depleting Because Of Water Cans Ecosystem. This Water Never Goes Back To The Land Rather Drained To The Sea. It Will Desertify Our Cities
Beautiful
Mohd bin Qasim ka hasher kia hua
logo ko zaroor btao
Hello Shafaat bhai from ur cute little fan. Ur style of telling a historical story is admirable
Plz share your views on syeds in sindh and pakistan, when and how they came here?
Very informative vlog. God bless.
Yaar loved it … what’s next ????
This series was superb.
Jaani attock ki history par koi vlog banao plzz
Shafaat Bro Please World War 1 and World War 2 pe videos banaiye Please. ❤❤❤❤
Remarkable awareness spreading truth and daring with subtle content and maturity imported government not accepted
Chacha was a Kashmri berhaman and he was Chamberlin of Last Rai ruler Sindh Raja sahasi , but he involved in conspiracy with queen and killed raja ... that's why people in Sindh dont like him 2nd Sindhi were mostly Buddhists . Traders of Sindh always like that they went to invader and have payed large sum to have their business saved..... till 1800 this practiced was as usual.. Hajjaj died during Waleed time before Suleiman but Suleiman didn't pardoned him and his skull was hanged after taking him out of grave
Ap se rabta kesy karhun
shafaatalisyed@yahoo.com
yeah qasim sahab ki lipstick walee pic hee milee thee aap ko :D ? @Shafaat Ali
Shafaat bhai❤❤❤
اصل ہیرو تو جیسیہ ہے جس کے چکر میں پورا سندھ فتح ہوگیا
Sahi baat hai wo bewaQoof north ki traF Jany se behter tha south men hi kahin chup jata or apni army ko Mazboot krta ya phr thar Dessert ki traF jata wahn se Gujrat or baqi Hindustan se Army Recruit kr ky Le aata to aaj taarekh mukhtalif Hoti.
😮😮😮
Pata nahi konsi History bata tay ho
Brother, without historical references, I believe the narration of very crucial history does not qualify the authenticity.
I have mentioned and referred ChachNama and Balazari repeatedly. Please do not comment in haste without listening
Just because he explains in layman's terms and adds humor to keep the audience interested-it doesn't mean he hasn't done his homework. All the references are mentioned in the video. Learn to appreciate the effort instead of seeking unnecessary attention.
@@PG-ys4ri many thanks 🙏
You are manipulate story tell truth who killed hazrat Abdullah Shah ghazi r.a ...
All of your power is wasted rewriting history where raja dahir is abrave leader..moqa and other locals are great heros whereas arab are greedy and coward...
محمد بن قاسم کے بارے میں مشہور ہے کہ حجاج بن یوسف نے اپنی زندگی میں ہی اسے قتل کروا دیا تھا؟؟؟ روشنی ڈالیے گا. شکریہ
دونوں واقعات میں 13 مہینے کا فرق ہے۔
Wali saleman Mohammad bon qasim ki ibrat naak mout hoii khalifey k hathon.. in ko choro.. is baat ko pakro k musalamno moula hussain k sath ahl bait k sath kia kuch nahi kia.. bias ho k nahi achey scholar ki tarha tarikh parho to muslamano ki harkaton per bohot afsos hoga
Kya jannat ka qarina hoga! Ammar bhi Razi Allah, qatil bhi RA. Shocker of all shockers! The son of Abu Talib and Fatima bint Asad is lowered to the level of the son of Abu Sufyan and Honda for the same job!! Wow! Husayn bhi Alaihis salaam, Yazeed bh RA! Ghazab ka jannat hoga, wallah😅
For your kind information sindh is well come land . Sindhi never resist against outsider I mean the intruder 😂 they were BAHANG addict.
Panah geer Spotted. 😂
لوٹا نہیں تھا آپ غلط بیانی کر رہے ہیں
سککا سکھر تھا
Nahi
Arabs never conquered India for any long period and were defeated after brief period. It was turks which finally conquered later, and they also conquered Arabs also.
You are Delhi guy can you tell me why mughals or ghori or turks all came to Delhi instead of going somewhere else?
Very said listen to the faq history, total wrong story ,
Telling a complex story in a simple and interesting way is an art...
Shafat Bhai knows it very well...
Sahi baat hai
point to be noted is that in start the one brahman who helped mohammad bin qasim to win his first seige indirectly got responsible for making mohammad bin qasim winning from raja dahir also
Fake story
@@neemavinireality, that's why Rajput were not against Arab.
Azim paki momins ki stories hai mashallah inshallah.
@@neemavini so share the Truth I am eager to know
You should have given sources of truth to make a hero of Pakistan, a bloody invader. In fact, Mohd bin qasim came to spread Islam and wanted to loot Sindh. He was greedy of wealth and Sindh region is very rich area. We, Sindhis love king Dahir. He died to defend Sindh. We are proud of King Dahir. Everybody knows the beginning of Islam is for spreading Islamic culture. We are Sindhi and hate invaders. Nobody can be our hero that not belongs to our soil.
Abe jaa jaake moot pee😂😂😂
@@khabibnurmagomedov8581
mohammad unt ka moot pita tha, quran me likha hai..😂😂
That's totally amazing. Now i understand why sindhi friends oppose bin Qasim.
Raja dahir married his own daughter for power
Kyun k sindhi log Pakistani planted history parhene se ijtanab kartr hain 😅
So basiclly a momin (bin qasim) conquered sindh with the help of hindu(moqa).meqns this was totally a politically war between power hungry kings.to phr hmara hero muhammad bin qasim kasey hua.kia wo sb kahani krwai gai the???
Vlog is good, even better, but why haven’t you discussed that how was tyrant Muhammad Bin Qasim was died or killed ?
Shafahat sir, please make a video on Muslims conquest of Europe. And if possible can you tell how to search for books on these topics.
This is so much needed, will cover it in my future videos. Please read great Arab Conquests by Hugh Kennedy
Sir love from India, I deeply sad to hear this bloody history that you guys suffered in past. I deeply respect for your sacrifices in respect of your life, wealth, culture and religion.
Excellent vlog. I have few suggestions ti make it even better.
Can you please reference the incidences in the subs.
Secondly can you please also tell the modern names of the cities such as sikka?
Shafat bhi... you might be facing criticism. but as a student of history I really appreciate this video...
very well done 👍✅
Assalamualaikum Bro you are doing a great job.
Please also mention books.
In description
Nice narration... Can you continue the story in the region till the 15th century ?
Regards
Excellent vlog. Please continue this format with different historical information/stories. ❤
Ap aa gy hain dosri side batantany..Allah hamari hifazat kry roz naya historian paida ho raha hai...bata raha hai kaisy muslim itny crrupt thy aur hindus aur locals kitny azeem thy...
Yes ...😮muslim defeated super powers of their time by chance..and then india by chance ...a new version of history
Arab bychary aur local surma....but jay shafqat sb ki...in the end muslims are winning by chance as usual..
U missed the interesting story of Raja Dahir beautiful girls that we have studied in Pakistan studies that soon after the death of Rajah Dahir his family girls were captured by Mohammed bin Qasim and he used them very well and then send them to Hajjaj bi yousaf as a gift . When the girls reveled the story with Hajjaj about Mohammed bin Qasim and this burst the hanger of Hajjaj and he called back to Mohammed bin Qasim and killed him to death
Muhammad bin Qasim was our hero. The purpose of Muhammad Bin Qasim wasn't lootering. For your sake of information After Muhammad Bin Qasim Banu Sama ruled Multan and Banu Habbar ruled Mansura.
Bhai this history absolutely wrong 🫠
Moh'd Bin Qasim's was 12th attack on Sindh. Before 11 attack of Arab regime were defeated by Maha Raja Dhaher.
Good Analysis ماشاءاللّٰه
Ben Qasim is a Myth.
I know although your pathan but your urdu accent is amazing ❤wish you good luck 👍
this was awesome
Very detailed and informative
Keep the rest of the historical story intact, thanks.
Glad you enjoyed it
He is not historian nor researcher ...
Thanks Shafaat!
can you please share the name or the link of the source or reference please.
Raja Dahar is our hero ❤
Bro you have the art of story telling, desperately waiting for more content.
Excellent look into history
Shafat and this type of people is the result of unalign with Islamic teaching and its trainings bcz they read & learn all things from western literature although his work is very detailed and academic but he doesn’t know how to present in Muslim society
But I appreciate his work at least showing history in anyway
gripping narration!
Very nice
Well n simply a best story teller keep it up mashallah
both parts were extremely good keep it up
Great job
Vlog acha tha..
@ShafaatAli bht zabardast bhai aap nay wese he casual method itni bari history suna di k boriyat bhi nahi hoee or maza bhi aya… apse request hai k Hindko (hazara division) ki bhi history or wahan basnay wali qoumo k baaray mai history se kuch vlogs banayen please.
Sir Bohot shukriya. Inshallah in future
I love the way you explain history. 😅
Buht alla shafat bhai arbon ke bd pe ek 3rd episode hojae to kya kehne
Bus bhayya Episode 2 he acchay
@@ShafaatAli007 ok sir
Well done boy ❤
Thank you
Thank you very much for the detailed explanation. Very interresting. It would have been a bit more of intertest, if you had named the present day names of the historical places e.g place were the arab army crossed the indus etc. Otherwise enjoyed the episode very much.
Banu Umaiah was probably the worst family to rule except Ibne Aziz
Shafaat, you have found you mettle,keep it up,you are much more than a comedian and an actor.
At 18:36 the image depicting Arab archer shooting the burning arrow at Raja Dahir is holding the bow in such a way that he's gonna shoot himself in his face. Must be an AI generated image 😃
What's your source of history??? I mean, books etc
I never knew this much history of the detailed invasion. Very well explained
Aoa, telling story is not enough, how much it is authentic? it is important. As a student of history I think speaker did not approach the authentic references.
It's tough to say something authentic in history. what we can do is approach the oldest traditions and accounts of the incident. Both Chachnama (13th Century) and Futuh ul Buldan ( 9th Century) have been referenced for this video.
Assalamualaikum ,
Hello ! bhai , this is interesting , maza aya
Raja Daheer ne uski sagi behen Real sister se shaadi ki thi ayyashi k liye wo kyo chupa liya aapne?😂😂
Getting married with biological siblings was a common practice back in time. It was practiced in indus, Egyptian, mesopotamia and in some parts of India. The purpose of It used to keep the blood line pure. It was not considered a Taboo just as we don't consider a taboo marrying our cousins
@@ShafaatAli007 she was not cousin she was Real sister. Isliye uske hindu Pandit aur hindu log bhi uskey khilaf ho gaye the. Pandito ne bol ye bhi bol diya tha k is PAAP gunaah ki wajah se Azaab aayega aur RAJ khatam ho jayega 😂 don't become biased
@@being_humann did you read what I just write? Or if you can't please do not bother yourself
turk history seljuq ottoman empire sb suna do yr
Other ethnics tries so hard to speak Urdu
History bhot kofnook h yr bus ......
It was not arrival but, conquest.
Many thanks for telling truth
Very interesting episode
Bahut achha laga 😊
What happed after that?
From which sources you have gathered the history of sindh and how can you verify its authenticity???
ChachNama by Ali Kufi (13th Century)
Kitab e Futuhul Buldan by Balazari (9th Century)
Great 👍🎉🎉🎉
Shukar ha Hindu army sy Sindhi army ko change Kia 😂😂
Muslim vs Hindu
Arabs vs Sindhi.
😂
my city Sehwan* (Siwistan)
Sharm aani chahiye apki city waLon ny to bina lary hi lait gye arabio ky samny or surrender kr diya.
@@Alex-r2l8t baat to sahi hai lekin me sharam kyon karu acha hua kisi tarha musalman to aye
Bhai pakistani Dna origin per vedio banao
Hindu
Great Leader 18 year old SHAHEED MUHAMMED BIN QASIM r.h 👍 aur abhi 30-40 saal k log berozgaar ghumrahe h whatsapp facebook chala rahe h bas😂😂😂😂
The believe of Muslims based on teaching of the holy prophet Muhammad (saw) and quran...islam doesn't recognize any arab ,sindi,or other ethnicity...we own the every aspect of islam and ...we are the followers of prophet and we also appreciate Muhammad bin Qasim,hajaj for thier good actions because of them islam reached to us , Muslims of subcontinent,other all bad action if any Muslim ruler including Muhammad bin qasim did, are not asset of Muslims umma,they are responsible for thier own actions on day of judgement 😊
Zabrdasst❤❤❤❤❤
Zaalim tha qasim
Hindu kay liye
Khilafat k bad jo b arbon ny jaang ki hen wo islam k le ny balka sonay chandi or dhan dolat k le the
Or Raja dahir ny offer kiya tha imam hussain ko sindh main any k le tu hijaj bin yousif ny wo gusa nikala tha
Khatun ko laundi banaya gaya.