For those not caught up on the Garam case: This case was resolved over 2 months ago when Kim Garam released the FULL School Violence Committee Document (Eunseo, the “victim” had previously shown the public ONLY the first 3 lines of the document). Turns out the person that called themselves the “victim” (we call her Eunseo) and said she got bullied by Garam was actually Garams friend in middle school, but they decided to stop being friends because Eunseo kept talking behind all her friends back. Eunseo was salty she lost all her friends and decided to hack into an ex-friends Facebook account (to make it look like it wasn’t her who did this) and posted pictures of another ex-friend (which said ex-friend was 12 years old at the time) where they were ONLY wearing their underwear. (Thats considered as Identity Theft and Child p*rn)This was very traumatic for the girl whose pictures were posted because she still had to attend school after the students saw her half naked so she called Garam and asked for help. Garam tried to reach Eunseo, but she wouldn’t pick up so frustrated Garam cursed a couple of times over text and when they eventually met up Garam cursed and yelled at Eunseo some more and asked her to delete the photo and apologize. Eunseo later went to the School Violence Committee and asked them to punish Garam for the cursing over text and Garam got the level 5 punishment (which is the most COMMON punishment in her school). Eunseo got a Level 8 punishment so to AVOID punishment Eunseo transferred schools and then continued to spread rumours about Garam in the new school (which in her new school she got older students of different grades to pick up a fight with Garam and her friends). It was never bullying, it was never bullying because before this incident Garam and Eunseo were literally FRIENDS. So yeah, Garams career got ruined by a jealous person and former (FAKE) friend (and toxic k-netizens) who couldn’t stand to see Garam achieve her dreams. If you want to see the SVC (school violence case) document and what ACTUALLY happened, here’s the link: twitter.com/oncemimosa/status/1557479971052048384?t=Ax61xNOSisxuGWDa4F9NsA&s=19 There has also been a website made to make it easier to access all the information on the case: sites.google.com/view/garam-scandal/home
no way that's honestly so fucked up, garam is innocent. why isn't garam back tho if they know the truth? does garam not want to come back or does lesserafims company not want to take her back or smth? sorry for asking so many questions, just a baby fearnot 😭
@@nizzimura.. I think now could be a good moment to negotiate a contract to bring Garam back to the group. Many people have come to realize that Kim Garam is innocent, but she faced a lot of hatred and attacks from netizens. Therefore, it's understandable if she never wants to pursue a career as a singer again.
@@nizzimura..Garam’s contract has already been terminated. That was done back when the issue was still fresh (iirc, it was right after Eunseo posted the cropped school document). We don’t know exactly what happened behind the scenes: Garam could’ve chosen to exit her contract quietly, or Hybe may have felt she now posed too much of a risk & kicked her out. Either way, she no longer has any legal ties to Hybe. Le SSerafim have proven themselves profitable without Garam, so Hybe has little reason to reopen a closed case by issuing her a new contract, especially with an issue that provided such heated debate within the fandom. I’m pleased she’s finally getting the truth out and justice she deserves, but she’s definitely not coming back to LSF. We may see her redebut now that her reputation is improved, like Soojin, but I can guarantee her days with LSF are over.
@@spy6205it was said that it was Garam’s parent’s decision for not continuing the contract and that all her activities with Le Seerafim regarding the documentary series, will not be shown to the public. That’s what I heard
honestly most the songs , the cover sounds the same . the only song where her vocal’s actually impact the song is sour grapes , gotta give it to her on that one, she really MADE that her song
I'm pretty sure she was supposed to be lead vocal along chaewon (plus I remember that they actually confirmed she was going to share the center position with sakura)
Honestly her voice gave so much image and identity to Le Sserafim. When they first debuted, her voice is all that I remember whenever I think of Le Sserafim songs.
without garam, the vocals of the group are much weaker for sure. it used to be a 50/50 split of decent vocalists to non-vocalists, but now it’s very uneven.
The situation in Korea is that she was not a bully(or not sure) but still she did smoking and drink even she is like only in Y10-11. So most of the Korean fans doesn't really want her to come back.. It's sad to lose the visual member but honestly I think they tried hard to decide the best choice...
@@typh2630 calm down I'm not trying to judge or smth o.o If you felt offensive Im sorry abt that. But I also kinda can't understand what you mean 'regular' student. Is this like a cultural difference?
@@bembi_ii good? Yes, sweet? No. The only group members with 'Sweet' voice were Chaewon and Garam. Yunjin is amazing but her voice is more powerful and strong.
She has like the soft and delicate as well as the feminine kind of feel to her vocal that I feel like the others simply lack.And that's what compliment Le Sserafim's songs the most particularly the fearless era
still this day garam’s voice is still one of my favourite her voice compliments so well with the other members. she has the soft angelic voice that made le sserafim unique
If i felt this sad watching them doing her parts like she never existed before i wonder how sad she felt when she saw them for the first time without her. Love u garam . Love u le sserafim
I feel so sorry for garam. Most of the allegations were from school days and she never got a chance for redemption. Leserrafm is great but im sure wouldve been good with her to this day as well
I think if she had not been removed from the group she would have been one of the most popular member,maybe even the most popular/favorite I'm sad for her😕
Garam has a beautiful voice and is very talented. She had a sweet personality from what I saw when she was in LSF. She's stil so young and I think she would be able to debut again. The current group is doing great as well.
i haven't been a fan for that long, but upon finding out that there was a 6th member before, i will say that garam had so much center energy, even it girl material. like garam and chaewon would've definitely been the unstoppable duo
People this made me cry I can't believe that 2 years have passed since the scandal, I loved her from minute 1 and when the rumors started, I informed myself and I saw that she was a much stronger girl than I expected, I decided to support her But it all ended as soon as it began and the only thing left was the longing to continue seeing her, how she would have shone in ANTIFRAGIL, and what her beautiful presence would have been in PERFECT NIGHT... my girl I am always attentive to news about her, I hope she does well in everything she does 💗
She sings the best part of all the songs I just know if she was still in the group the songs like perfect night would have been even better because of her beautiful voice
Garam dance and movement have more soul then eunchae. No wonder garam has more lines and center part, garam so shining the the other until the case show up
its crazy to me because i’m assuming based off of fearless era that garam was lowkey the main vocalist / center of group. and then all of that spotlight got taken away in just 3 weeks because of false allegations.
Ikr. I’ve been watch Lesserafim since the beginning and fell in love with Garam’s voice first. Her snippet in the highlight Medly for FEARLESS specially in Sour Grapes got people hooked & in rewind. This was without even knowing the members or which member matched with what voice. Garam was definitely the centre (or shared it with Sakura cuz of her Japan popularity). In the end of their songs when they posed Garam used to be in the center 😭. Garam was also known to be part of Lesserafim’s vocal line which consisted of Garam, Chaewon & Yunjin (so now when I hear them, it’s not so balanced anymore or are limited since there’s only 2 people whose vocals can hit a high register)
if she stayed with no doubt would be one of the most favorited members. she was only in a few songs yet in those few songs her parts were the best parts in the songs
not a fan or a hater but i know each lesserafim members: i unknowingly played the 2023 blue flame for the first time, i know the song very well but I don't know the line distribution of each members but i love the part "Jemeottaero chumeul chuda sarajigo" but the vocals sounds different in the second part of the song, that's why i searched the first blue flame and found out that it's garam's voice. And sour grapes too 😭 that's the first song of le sserafim that i love because of tiktok trend, i fall inlove in the line "Chakgageun ma Ttaki neol joahan.. all day, all night, yeah" 😢 her voice is so amazing and i really love it.
![เปิด อาณาจักร หมื่นล้าน "สาระตั้ม" l [Nickynachat]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/3XE0nPF4YkQ/mqdefault.jpg)
For those not caught up on the Garam case: This case was resolved over 2 months ago when Kim Garam released the FULL School Violence Committee Document (Eunseo, the “victim” had previously shown the public ONLY the first 3 lines of the document). Turns out the person that called themselves the “victim” (we call her Eunseo) and said she got bullied by Garam was actually Garams friend in middle school, but they decided to stop being friends because Eunseo kept talking behind all her friends back. Eunseo was salty she lost all her friends and decided to hack into an ex-friends Facebook account (to make it look like it wasn’t her who did this) and posted pictures of another ex-friend (which said ex-friend was 12 years old at the time) where they were ONLY wearing their underwear. (Thats considered as Identity Theft and Child p*rn)This was very traumatic for the girl whose pictures were posted because she still had to attend school after the students saw her half naked so she called Garam and asked for help. Garam tried to reach Eunseo, but she wouldn’t pick up so frustrated Garam cursed a couple of times over text and when they eventually met up Garam cursed and yelled at Eunseo some more and asked her to delete the photo and apologize. Eunseo later went to the School Violence Committee and asked them to punish Garam for the cursing over text and Garam got the level 5 punishment (which is the most COMMON punishment in her school). Eunseo got a Level 8 punishment so to AVOID punishment Eunseo transferred schools and then continued to spread rumours about Garam in the new school (which in her new school she got older students of different grades to pick up a fight with Garam and her friends). It was never bullying, it was never bullying because before this incident Garam and Eunseo were literally FRIENDS.
So yeah, Garams career got ruined by a jealous person and former (FAKE) friend (and toxic k-netizens) who couldn’t stand to see Garam achieve her dreams.
If you want to see the SVC (school violence case) document and what ACTUALLY happened, here’s the link:
twitter.com/oncemimosa/status/1557479971052048384?t=Ax61xNOSisxuGWDa4F9NsA&s=19
There has also been a website made to make it easier to access all the information on the case:
sites.google.com/view/garam-scandal/home
no way that's honestly so fucked up, garam is innocent. why isn't garam back tho if they know the truth? does garam not want to come back or does lesserafims company not want to take her back or smth? sorry for asking so many questions, just a baby fearnot 😭
@@nizzimura.. I think now could be a good moment to negotiate a contract to bring Garam back to the group. Many people have come to realize that Kim Garam is innocent, but she faced a lot of hatred and attacks from netizens. Therefore, it's understandable if she never wants to pursue a career as a singer again.
@@nizzimura..Garam’s contract has already been terminated. That was done back when the issue was still fresh (iirc, it was right after Eunseo posted the cropped school document). We don’t know exactly what happened behind the scenes: Garam could’ve chosen to exit her contract quietly, or Hybe may have felt she now posed too much of a risk & kicked her out. Either way, she no longer has any legal ties to Hybe. Le SSerafim have proven themselves profitable without Garam, so Hybe has little reason to reopen a closed case by issuing her a new contract, especially with an issue that provided such heated debate within the fandom. I’m pleased she’s finally getting the truth out and justice she deserves, but she’s definitely not coming back to LSF. We may see her redebut now that her reputation is improved, like Soojin, but I can guarantee her days with LSF are over.
@@spy6205 I see, tysm!
@@spy6205it was said that it was Garam’s parent’s decision for not continuing the contract and that all her activities with Le Seerafim regarding the documentary series, will not be shown to the public. That’s what I heard
ngl her vocals in blue flame and sour grapes are untouchable but they did great in their own way
This is honestly true.
Literally there’s no difference
@@urielhs4726 thats a lie but ok
honestly most the songs , the cover sounds the same . the only song where her vocal’s actually impact the song is sour grapes , gotta give it to her on that one, she really MADE that her song
@@urielhs4726her voice is softer.
i never hate her since the garam case, i really love her so much. she's voice is so insane, so talented. she deserve better
I never even realized that my favorite parts in blue flame are sung by Garam
Bro I miss her 💔
same! i was listening to sour grapes and i started thinking abt her..
X2 JAJAJAJ
She is my bias....😭 I have no bias in LE SSERAFIM now....😭
How about Chaewon?@@SilitaAnderson
i think they used to prepare Garam as a front liner, so many important and center lines of her, its sad she didn't make it.
Yes, she is the projected center
@@3riyantoI miss her sm she was gonna be my bias, and now it’s yunjin imo they both stand out way too much in their group. Gorgeous and talented
I'm pretty sure she was supposed to be lead vocal along chaewon (plus I remember that they actually confirmed she was going to share the center position with sakura)
@@Nanetysyeah and the visual also
Same @@sseraeno
3:03 This line is irreplaceable. No one can do it like her.
fr
frfrr
REAAAAAAAL.
The way I instantly knew which part you were talking about before even watching the video.
@@nobody_17 fr same
SOUR GRAPES BRIDGE IN GARAM'S VOICE>>>>>
Honestly her voice gave so much image and identity to Le Sserafim. When they first debuted, her voice is all that I remember whenever I think of Le Sserafim songs.
without garam, the vocals of the group are much weaker for sure. it used to be a 50/50 split of decent vocalists to non-vocalists, but now it’s very uneven.
True... 😢
@@marleybeaversyeah. Now it's two vocalists vs three non-vocalists
THEY DID GREAT BUT GARAM JUST SLAYED
Ill miss her so much, I feel like her soft and delicate feminine energy really fit with their seraphim concept.
I disagree but she a great foil to contrast everyone. Teamwork
The situation in Korea is that she was not a bully(or not sure) but still she did smoking and drink even she is like only in Y10-11. So most of the Korean fans doesn't really want her to come back.. It's sad to lose the visual member but honestly I think they tried hard to decide the best choice...
@@On.1132 can we not bring up this shit anymore? There’s no point in it, ur just talking about a regular student at this point.
@@typh2630 calm down I'm not trying to judge or smth o.o If you felt offensive Im sorry abt that. But I also kinda can't understand what you mean 'regular' student. Is this like a cultural difference?
@@On.1132 what does being a student have anything to do with cultural difference?
She has put her entire heart at her lines especially sour grapes it even went viral 😭 I really like her vocal, it just hit differently❤❤❤
her tone just really suits the parts given to her that it really shows when it’s not there
blue flame just isn’t the same without her vocals 😭
it isnt but idk i prefer 2023 ver.
@@tori.singss29same !!
Agree
fr
till now, when im listen to blue flame, i always put the original version on my playlist
I really like Garam voice so relaxing and that harmonize to other members voice which so strong and loud voice..
actually no... the rest don't have loud or strong voices, maybe yunjin but ur gonna tell me chaewon's voice is strong? nah more like cute voice
@@tori.singss29Garam had the softest vocals.
@@bluerose1613garam and chaewon almost sounded the same or had the same pitch
@@tori.singss29Eunchae, Yunjin and Kazuha have all deeper singing voices than Chaewon, Sakura and Garam.
Some of the cover are ok but sour grapes hit different when miss kim garam sing😌
Fr like sour grapes was HER song imo
Sour grapes was her era (ik it's not the album title or whatever etc)
200th liker of this comment
3:03 this like can’t be replaced
My favorite part 😢
Fr
Fr
her vocal will be forever iconic
3:03 this cant be replaced
her voice was the most beautiful and sweet in the group
😢😢😢 all of them is beautiful and sweet
and all of the voices too🥹
@@bembi_ii good? Yes, sweet? No. The only group members with 'Sweet' voice were Chaewon and Garam. Yunjin is amazing but her voice is more powerful and strong.
Her voice was pretty but Chaewon can't be topped at all
@@HiImCool2008Naah chaewons tone is not that good
@@Eclipwzeeh Yes it is what are you on..
it's a pity that she left the group, she looks pretty charismatic and she have stage presence
Sour grape doesn’t hit the same without Garam:/ No hate or anything.
fearless anc blue flame too
She has like the soft and delicate as well as the feminine kind of feel to her vocal that I feel like the others simply lack.And that's what compliment Le Sserafim's songs the most particularly the fearless era
I miss Garam. She was such a nice singer. She didn't deserved to be removed from the group
still this day garam’s voice is still one of my favourite her voice compliments so well with the other members. she has the soft angelic voice that made le sserafim unique
If i felt this sad watching them doing her parts like she never existed before i wonder how sad she felt when she saw them for the first time without her.
Love u garam . Love u le sserafim
OMG Garam's vocals are so good! ❤❤
I feel so sorry for garam. Most of the allegations were from school days and she never got a chance for redemption. Leserrafm is great but im sure wouldve been good with her to this day as well
Garam vocal is amazing. I just realized that my fav parts in Sour Grapes are sung by Garam.
Garam's pearly voice, i miss her so much 😢 .❤
I just know if Garam wasn’t kicked she would’ve been Center of le sserafim. I mean people still talk about her till this day
she could become it girl for sure
The way her lines are iconic and best parts of the song. They really lost a gem❤
I wonder how Le Sserafim would be if she never left.
Sonce garam is a top visual, she could be there with yunjin and kazuha as the ones that gets viral everytime
@@ninemilwer she a center material.
Probably much better than now. Because she attracted a lot of fans into the group because of her visuals and charisma
@@ninemilwerpotential it girl imo
GARAM IN SOUR GRAPES HAD LOT OF MY FAVORITE PARTS😭❤️BRING HER BACK DUDE
Shes so talented. People ruined her dreams. Idk why some people already believes on those rumors so fast without any proof.
Garam sounds angelic
I think if she had not been removed from the group she would have been one of the most popular member,maybe even the most popular/favorite
I'm sad for her😕
agreed… definitely the visual and center
@@moaswrldThey get rid of her to balance the group. This isn’t IVE (Wonyoung and the girls)
@@motherhoodsbeauty9279 nope, they got rid of her bc of false accusations.
no one can change her huhuhuhu:((((
yeah, she's irreplaceable
@@___lycanwolfcub yeah huuhuhu
huhuhuhuhuhuhu 😔😔
Garam has a beautiful voice and is very talented. She had a sweet personality from what I saw when she was in LSF. She's stil so young and I think she would be able to debut again. The current group is doing great as well.
Years after she was removed LE SSERAFIM is still incomplete without her 😢
3:02 This is HER part. Nobody does it like her
how can they kick out such a talented and pretty gurl? those bullying scandals are just very insane
I'm still blaming knetz for this 😭
Fr
Garam is such a queen. The kpop industry is horrifyingly toxic
Garam’s voice was such a great bridge between Chaewon’s voice and the other members
I just realized that my favorite parts of sour grapes are sung by Garam 🥲
her vocals are crazygood
She added so much femininity to the group, no wonder why everything sounded so harmonious
"No one is better than the original"😩
She was such an amazing vocalist and hybe using her for publicly, not even trying to defend her was so unfair to her
3:03 ❤ no one can't do it like her
This part is the best part. I love the song beacuse of this part 😢❤️🩹
I will always love her💕
i hope we get to see her perform again in the future, she's so talented
i haven't been a fan for that long, but upon finding out that there was a 6th member before, i will say that garam had so much center energy, even it girl material. like garam and chaewon would've definitely been the unstoppable duo
I’ll miss you Garam! I’m hoping for your undeniable success in your upcoming career. I will support you no matter what!
I miss her beautiful voice🎶💗
Sour grapes isn't the same without her anymore 😢
Garam,s vocals in blue flame ill be always legendary
They all did so well covering the parts.
i don’t think so
@@piraateeboa2288 i mean they did their best; it would be better if they kept garam until their next album and THEN she left that would've been better
@@piraateeboa2288why not?
I like the covers but you can’t beat the OG :)
@@LovelyLara123 ok? they still did good covering her parts
I love her vocal so much, I want her back
I miss herrrrr😢❤
3:03 best part
Literally still can't believe Hybe kicked out their best vocalist.
Im literally inlove with her voice. I really wanted her to become the main vocalist. I miss her so much.
GARAM WAS MY BIASSSSSSS
Me too !!!
Her voice is so refreshing I miss her🍓
Her voice is so calm and vibey its just irreplaceable
People this made me cry I can't believe that 2 years have passed since the scandal, I loved her from minute 1 and when the rumors started, I informed myself and I saw that she was a much stronger girl than I expected, I decided to support her But it all ended as soon as it began and the only thing left was the longing to continue seeing her, how she would have shone in ANTIFRAGIL, and what her beautiful presence would have been in PERFECT NIGHT... my girl I am always attentive to news about her, I hope she does well in everything she does 💗
She sings the best part of all the songs I just know if she was still in the group the songs like perfect night would have been even better because of her beautiful voice
Fact: Le sserafim would have had better vocals if Garam was still in the group 😢
My fav parts of Sour grapes are sang by Garam 🤧
Garam dance and movement have more soul then eunchae. No wonder garam has more lines and center part, garam so shining the the other until the case show up
Garam has such a gorgeous voice. To this day she would’ve been my bias.
I miss you
I miss her so much!!! I still love all the songs with garam:(
I'm in love with her voice
the kpop world lost one of its IT girls on this day 😔rip
Garam best iconic lines (literally all) 😭
i miss garam she was my bias 😢
Garam vocals are amazing ❤
Im sorry but no one can replace her
Her parts were the best
its crazy to me because i’m assuming based off of fearless era that garam was lowkey the main vocalist / center of group. and then all of that spotlight got taken away in just 3 weeks because of false allegations.
Ikr. I’ve been watch Lesserafim since the beginning and fell in love with Garam’s voice first. Her snippet in the highlight Medly for FEARLESS specially in Sour Grapes got people hooked & in rewind. This was without even knowing the members or which member matched with what voice. Garam was definitely the centre (or shared it with Sakura cuz of her Japan popularity). In the end of their songs when they posed Garam used to be in the center 😭. Garam was also known to be part of Lesserafim’s vocal line which consisted of Garam, Chaewon & Yunjin (so now when I hear them, it’s not so balanced anymore or are limited since there’s only 2 people whose vocals can hit a high register)
My favourite lines were all mostly from garam. So sad man
never forget the injustice towards Garam
You could see the pain in Eunchae's smile when she covered garam's part in Sour grapes
Tysm❤i really wanted know who covered her and i miss her sm😢
Every time I hear her voice makes me feel so sad, it just break my heart…again.
Her soft voice carried blue flame so hard 😢she was a gem, really hate netizens so much
Honestly Fearless was garam's era imo she fits every song and she had such iconic lines in every song, especially her sour grapes line at 3:03
I miss her so so so much
I MISS YOU EVERYDAY GARAMIEEEEEEEEEEE I HOPE YOU'RE SEEING THIS
I love her voice
BRING HER BACK
Sour Grapes is literally Garam's song tbh...
Hit diff so much with her voice.
Miss Garam so much💗
i miss her
if she stayed with no doubt would be one of the most favorited members. she was only in a few songs yet in those few songs her parts were the best parts in the songs
3:04 Nobody can sing this like Garam
I’m literally tearing up watching this video.....😭😭😭💔💔💔
i literally cried during this 😭😭😭😭
Her voice was so soft and sweet!
It would be so cool that she could go to Coachella with them 😢
I feel bad for what happened to garam,all because of her fake and horrible friend😢
Yall are making it hard not to miss her
not a fan or a hater but i know each lesserafim members:
i unknowingly played the 2023 blue flame for the first time, i know the song very well but I don't know the line distribution of each members but i love the part "Jemeottaero chumeul chuda sarajigo" but the vocals sounds different in the second part of the song, that's why i searched the first blue flame and found out that it's garam's voice.
And sour grapes too 😭 that's the first song of le sserafim that i love because of tiktok trend, i fall inlove in the line "Chakgageun ma Ttaki neol joahan.. all day, all night, yeah" 😢 her voice is so amazing and i really love it.
sour grapes 😭😭