Except he is a victim of the false narrative by the media hype. Free thinking means unbiased pondering about things. He was not even listening to the answer of the question he just asked, thus proving he was just a mere heckler. On the other hand, Qur'an commands Muslims to ponder about the things around us. To think deeply about the universe around us. True, you would find few do these days, because Muslims themselves have gone far from the teachings of Qur'an. Daily at least 21 times, a Muslim asks the Creator for Guidance, showing that the Muslim is constantly on a journey to seek and to be steadfast on the Truth about matters of life and death. The things which matter the most.
islam wasnt forced, if it was forced, everyone would be wearing hijab before 1970's... the iranians brought this on themselves by kicking king reza out, if reza was still king, anyone would be free to practice their religion.
@@mbert7537 yes Muslims forced non Muslims to convert only very very very few people converted on their own just check indian history for example how many Hindus were converted even if you check the ancestors of present day Muslims theu were Hindus who were forcefully converted , Christians did the same thing in india and now they are brainwashing poor people to convert to Christianity you may find it fake but it is true , in india there are 28 states out of the 28 states in 8 states Hindus have become minorities our population percentage if you check from 1947 to 2022 it Is not increasing but if you check Muslim and Christians population they are growing rapidly
@@ahmadrazashaikh7417 bro a person can not have two biological mother. Likewise a person can not have two different ideologies. Hence you can not be Indian by heart and a true muslim.
@@ubobu3613 He did not answer as to why. The young man asked why Islam was spread by force, when the Zoroastrians believed in virtually the same concepts already.
Dude when ur black sheep get together and become the strongest army in the world and try to conquer the world… that’s no longer black sheep… that’s the transformation of ur religion into a violent cult… which is really what happens with ALL religions
zakir naik is left without answer thats why he tried to scare the boy by making him forcefully repeat what he said!! hats off to the guy who stood up against the manipulative devil
Bro he answered with a source of a non-muslim historian. He even told the page out of his head. Before that he pointed out many other examples that are more clear and after the guy claimed that history is always true he asked him to recite the historian he mentioned. Did you even watch the video the guy smiles from ear to ear. Where did he scare him of? 😂😂😂
Long live persia and persians. Proud to be persian . We were the only nation that capture roman empreror and made him to bent toward our empreror( it's in history). Cuz we die for persia more than for islam😊
The man who asked the question is the one who read history and is personally so dignified not willing to accept Islam as it was forcefully introduced in civilized Persia. Today the converted Muslims don't have minds to learn how terrifying this Islam is
Hey bro this asshole is himself hindu converted to Islam. He is still having his Hindu surname. Can he himself first tell the world is he the original Muslim from Arab. He himself doesn't know that Persia and India follow the fire God. Even the real Muslim from Arab and Turkish Muslim they themselves doesn't have a fool person like him preaching Islam. Arabs even don't make they stand in front of them. They say you are converted not real Arab Muslim and this fools preach Islam.....
I happy to hear that muslim rulers forced our ancestor to convert in islam otherwise we had to worship useless idols, had believe fictional. mythology and can't eat delicious beef🥱
What did Aurangzeb and other Mughals do to the Sikh gurus Islam was forced on people. People who did not convert. The reason why not every body converted was because we had Hindu kings and Sikh warriors protecting our Religion. what happened to the Kashmir pandits.
4:55 "Muslims ruled india for a 1000 years, we could have forced every non muslim indian to be muslim if we wanted to..." Bruhhv warriors like chatrapati shivaji maharaj , maharana pratap, guru gobind singh etc. Didnt let u do that....in fact in their presence muslim rulers didnt have the GUTS.... Have u heard of a few hundred marathas and rajputs defeating a mughal army of thousands... Yaa we r those marathas nd we are those rajputs and yaa WE ARE THE PROUD DESCENDANTS AND STILL SANATANIS....🕉🚩 And ever heard of 21 sikhs pushing 10,000 afghans to tjeir edges yaa those are our sikh brothers...🧡 Jai bhavani, jai shivrai Jai maharana pratap Jai siya ram Jai sanatan dharm Vande mataram Bharat mata ki jai 🇮🇳🚩
200 million indians are muslim they could have forced everyone to convert via death threats. The muslims didn't because they wanted to keep getting tax money. India was lucky look at bengal and pak they are muslim now cus the muslims wanted to convert people there
If one man can marry two three women and give birth to a. dozen of dogs oviously population increases. But many Muslims are turning back to ancestor religion specially Arabian peninsula.
Muslim rulers tried their best to spread islam in india but failed. The guy here asked about Persia not Indonesia and Malaysia. It is a matter of historical fact that Islam was forced upon persians. That is why parsis fled iran and settled in india
:5 they tried to force Islam in india, they tried every possible way to destroy Hinduism, our brave hindu soldiers let there lives for hinduism ,and I am proud to be hindu🚩🚩🚩
I’m a muslim but I hate it when someone lies. Stop lying and saying muslims didn’t attack Persia and destroyed the Sassanid empire. Prophets own companion fought in those battles. Zakir uses bully tactics and either intentionally lies or is completely ignorant of history.
He says non sense and he doesn't know the real history I'm Iranian,and Lur, we know what happened to our country, not some random muslims that Don't know the truth He should know that the invasion happened and many bad things happened, islam was,is and will be a cancer in iran unless secularism comes
Islam was not spread by force, people freely chose to convert. Muslim did conquer land for political reason but never forced people to convert, it just speculation.
4:46 The fact is they tried to convert all of the Hindu brothers Infact most of the muslims in indian subcontinent are converted folks But we Hindus(and shiks, Buddhists,Jain's) fought for our religion our culture and not accepted conversion And retained our religion Many of the brave people and kings have laid there lives So we are Hindus not because your forefathers have let us but because our forefathers have sacrificed their lives for the sake of it
Islam COULD NOT be spread by the sword in India. We had a big population and none of the Muslim rulers wanted to unite the millions of Hindus to fight in unison. So it isn't that they did not, it was that they COULD NOT convert us.
Lol bro, muslims invader of mughal invade and conquer millions of hindus and slaughtered them, the rest of them FORCED converted into islam, read history Lol
Muslims didn't ruled India 1000 years. They ruled 800 years actually not more than that Caliphates reached Indus region actually but not gangetic region and Dravidian region actually Basically 12th century AD they have entered into North India and settled in Delhi city actually They entered into Afghanistan and Pakistan in 8th century actually Caliphates reached that region and stopped their only Basically we became less violent and less cruel in 11th century to 20th century actually Muslims were much stronger and powerful that they could achieve everything easily We let them enter into north India due to the Hindu kings and emperors who have extreme ego to get united with each other actually and fought against Muslim invaders actually
Muslims came to India after the defeat by deceit of Emperor Prithviraj Chauhan through Muhammad Ghori. Many kings & dynasty ruled India and converted Hindus into Muslims. The deed of Aurangzeb are worthy enough to note. All the Muslims in India are not Islam's, but forcible converts of Mughals and other kings
"Why Muslim Came to Persia and Forced the Islam, Dr. Zakir Naik" Persia was originally Christian, read in the bible. Then the then powerful Arabs invaded Persia then converted them to Islam, then slowely the Persians converted them selves to Islam. Now, the persians/most of them believe that the quran is not a copy of the bible and modifications. The persians are cheated, heavily.
He still didn't answer the question. The whole reason "PArsis" exist, is because Zoroastrians were persecuted by the Muslims 1300-1400 Year ago. So him saying "Your History is False" is absurd. Why would Zoroastrians go through such a treacherous Journey to India to save the religion. It's common sense.
Dear zaker. I m Iranian living in USA 🇺🇸 Florida for 23 years and I did not understand your quote from the historian 😅 partly your specific Indian accent (cute but hard) and also the vocabulary is not my best strength. This poor guy never would understand. I am glad Islam came to Iran. This fellow boy needs to read book by ayatollah Motahhari: The gift of Islam to iran and iran to Islam As far as answering his questions: You said many right things but you dodged the question. If we use this method we should accept Jesus is God and many other none sense. Inavasion of Iran by Muslims happened during Omar and it was some bloody war. Same as invasion of Roman land. It was not perfect Islam way and prophet Mohammad would do it differently. Some burning 🔥 of libraries and … But, many Iranian people of time were tired of kings. Some helped Arabs. Also the Islam ideology was so beautiful and superior for them to accept it and take the Koran as way of writing and …. Otherwise they would not do it. Islam was introduced through invasion but accepted by heart by many. And some hated it until today. Same way abusofian never accepted by heart. No need to sugar coat it by talking Malaysia 🇲🇾 Ps. Historian basically said It s biggest lie that Muslims used force.. I think you say obsured
Historical records clearly explains what happened to the entire native Arab culture, later from Persia to Indonesian, turkey to kazak, Mongolia and other middle eastern cultures ?
( Hindu, Buddha, jain, Sikh ... based on principal of self purification on complete perfect purification = Moksha .. PURE SOULS eligible to reach God ... God is parama athma = eternal Pure soul and complete perfect good )
@@asadyousafzai7563 ignore the comment from the guy above me. To be clear almost all Hindus believe in different things but the back bone of the philosophy is that no one could possibly be correct so worship god in whatever form he takes for you and pursue your life's purpose with good intentions. God takes every form and that's why there are so many. The Devas and Pantheon of Hinduism are just the collection of every single belief in India and put into one broad category. To be clear, Hindus never created the concept of Hinduism as it is currently, it's a byproduct of Islamic and British invasions. Some worship idols some idolize them in rock statues but in the end of the day it really doesn't matter. Whatever helps them concentrate on worship better really doesn't make much of a difference. I personally believe the idols don't actually exist (or did exist but with mythicized like the Trojan War) and are just exactly that, idols who we can model our behavior after. For example Ganesh is the god of removing obstacles, he holds and axe in one hand and flowers and sweets in the other and in that way when you idolize him you embody his character (not literally ofc just mentally). But the core idea is there's no way for humans to have the answers of the divine and is therefore less about believing and more about seeking. Too be clear I have respect for many aspects of the Islamic religion and I'm not looking for a fight just a conversation.
Dr Zakir Niak did not make sense to me too… why am I or is anyone for that matter supposed to take the authors words as unequivocal fact… Alhamdullillah I am a proud Muslim but the question should have been answered honestly as per history
islam wasnt forced, if it was forced, everyone would be wearing hijab before 1970's... the iranians brought this on themselves by kicking king reza out, if reza was still king, anyone would be free to practice their religion.
Traders rarely came to trade sans weapons especially for long distance trades in the past . They did not kill or attack like conventional armies but were lethal in their own way especially if they had religious and political agendas also.The conversions they carried out were also violent but less dramatic than those by the military.This was how Indonesia and Malaysia became Muslim.For a first hand and live experience of violence in Islamic mercantile conversions you can study the conversions by Muslim Indonesian traders of the native people in the Indonesian side of Papua New Guinea.World ignores this violence and terror which makes it easy for people like Zakir to commit taqiya.
Zakir refers to existence of Coptic Christians as proof of Islamic tolerance in Arab land.Firstly Egypt was not Arab land,it now is a land conquered by Arabs.It was and is the land of the Coptic.The stoic existence of dhimmified Coptics under the terror and violence of Sharia laws for centuries is a great example of the opposite.They were tolerated as source for jazziya ,slave and sex trade ,forced conscription etc.
i am from kashmir. our forefathers were hindu brahmins. islamic preachers from arab came here and preached islam by giving lectures peacefully . our forefathers found islam as a true , logical, peaceful religion.
Either ☪️ or ⚔️ 47: 35 Don't cry for peace, for you will have the upper hand and Allah is with you. 9 :29. Fight those who don't believe in Allah and the Last Day
Well done young chap.You are the definition of not being ignorant.You won this debate Clearly islam was forced by force.God will punish e sinners so dunt worry young chap. Follow what you said.Do not care about people Love each otherAnd do good as you said. I seen many good islam peopleAnd even many bad islam people who read quran and act as good.So do not believe not even 1 human beingLet them barkAs long you do good god lives you more than people acting as good praying
Zakir says, "we Muslims ruled India for more than a thousand years." Having been born in India and being an Indian citizen, he claims he is not an Indian. He is a Muslim and and says he and his Muslim rulers ruled India. Look at the inner side of him and look at the massive crowd of his supporters who are hailing his name. Isn't it crystal clear what Indian Muslims think in their mind? Indian Muslims are the children and grandchildren of slavery, rape, and torture by Arabs on Hindu and Sikh women. These great grandchildren, all of whom are products of forceful conversions, are siding with their masters. They have no patriotism.
When Arabs conquered Persia, They gave Persia 3 options. 1: Pay tax and you can stay Zoroastrian. 2: Fight us and if you defeat us, you can stay Zoroastrian. 3: Accept Islam. They chose fighting and lost and became Muslim. Well yes, they didn't force it directly but that's literally forcing
And his source is telegram and facebook reels 😅😅😅 Any Persian saying we were forced is disrespecting our fathers to be cowards. If Islam was something they hated they would never accept by force and at least they had chance to pay extra tax and not convert to Islam. They chose because it was superior ideology and was accepted.
@@faradpack they fought for 900 years , yes your ancestors were cowards not mine.Islam is dead in Iran. look at anti hijab protests or are you blind ? people are burning mosques. Shia Islam is not Islam anyway but that’s different argument.
We fought because we didn't want to be under the aRaBiC ruling which would wipe away our identity aRaBs even disturbed using Farsi, they mocked us because of our accent and many more iSlAm iS a pEaCeFuL rElIgIoN😂😂😂
The problem was with the word's accent/pronunciation of Dr. Zakir Naik. Because for a persian person (native language is Persian, and English is the second language) on the open-air public-presense it is difficult to understand the speech by all means.
My all Iranians you guys are zorastrian and will be zorastrian good thoughts , good words and good deeds these are the ways of living . In simple you do good you get good law of karma. Also religion is a sacred thing and not a product. Stay strong.
I am trying to leave Hinduism Because it does not allow me to ask some questions ...... What Dr zakir says is from our Hindu Books and 99% Hindu say it is wrong . WTF
islam wasnt forced, if it was forced, everyone would be wearing hijab before 1970's... the iranians brought this on themselves by kicking king reza out, if reza was still king, anyone would be free to practice their religion.
Zakir Naik you come to India, we'll teach you how to change yourself not by force but by the Medina model of preaching. RSS, Viswa Hindu Parishad will help you. Please come and recite your verses.
Message from an iranian to india "stop islam at all costs even if it means deporting or even killing muslims" because it wont end good for your country
I am not sure Dr Zakir Naik is not talking clearly and simply to the questioner. The young man is simply confused and wants clear-cut answers. Shouting at him was not necessary.
Muna Masood All of the commenters against Zakir Naik or the ones that have dislike of some of his characteristics, remember that backbiting is haram. By saying bad things about him behind his back, even if true, you're destroying his respect and making people hate him or not listen to him. Its best if you spoke to him one on one so that he could improve himself, but most of you cant do that, except from maybe through email or his website, so just stop backbiting. If you spoke to him one on one his respect would be maintained and he would improve improve himself InshAllah.
Yeah no one is forcing anyone ...ur religion is growing because some of people in ur religion r still having 6,7,8 kids simple zakir naik....like u said in america europe or other developed countries to get centre link ..just saying no offence
True. Ameen. I wasn't happy with his approach as well. As a speaker/answerer, he should be more calm, polite, elegant and sensible while delivering answers. He wasn't like this when he was young, totally opposite to now. He probably looses his temperament as he gets older. Being a bit aggressive towards young guy like him won't help at all. Hope Allah gives Dr. Zakir hidaya (guidance) and keep him on the right track. We don't want to miss these opportunities while someone actually want to know about Islam and give them a bad attitude while delivering the info to non-Muslims. We want all these non-Muslim brothers and sisters come to Islam.
The questioner was not listening. It was obvious he was there to challenge. As a viewer, I was able to recall what the historian was saying.. but not the questioner. So he was nothing better than a heckler. There is a limit to politeness. Wisdom comes in many forms, including knowing the direction a heckler could take. If allowed, these ignorant people would disrupt the entire forum, which would also mean the rights of the people behind the guy waiting in line to ask genuine questions would be lost. In short, we are Muslims, we are courteous, polite and law abiding, however, do not think we are fools and lame ducks to be taken advantage of.
forgetful history my friend thank you! l love Muslims just like l love Jews and Christians and everyone else! We all have our differences in some ways! No one is better then anyone else, we all fall short of the Glory of GOD! l respect you and your comment, GodBless you!
Muhammad bin Muhammad All of the commenters against Zakir Naik or the ones that have dislike of some of his characteristics, remember that backbiting is haram. By saying bad things about him behind his back, even if true, you're destroying his respect and making people hate him or not listen to him. Its best if you spoke to him one on one so that he could improve himself, but most of you cant do that, except from maybe through email or his website, so just stop backbiting. If you spoke to him one on one his respect would be maintained and he would improve improve himself InshAllah.
the reason most of the comments are non muslims comments because the society is bound to not exept the truth...... May Allah Guide people who are confused
i am nameless the thing is that I am not judging anyone on there religion.... I am saying what I think of my beloved religion just like what others say
DUSTY MAGE ARTS obviously you are not!!! Why are you lying? You muslims have a strong sense of superiority over other faiths......see your own comment, it speaks clearer than Naik......
Parsis or zoroastrian came to india around 700 from iran just to protect their religion .......... Their is a book that tell how hard the journey was and what was happening in iran that time written by parsis around 700-800 AD
I got much religious education & experience being a Muslim, this reply of Zakir Naik is not satisfactory to a common man. According to my studies, Islam exerted a force on society but that was an indirect force in the form of "suppressing religious freedom in public domain" and "snatching away political freedom of non-muslims" and making them a protected citizen who were required to obey Muslim's supremacy in political matters. However the protected non-muslims were free to keep their faith & culture and practice it silently without influencing the society. Their property, lives, women & children were completely safe and respected as a "dhimmi" (state protected apolitical non-muslim civilians). If they wanted to get more respect and freedom equal to Muslims, they were highly encouraged to convert to Islam and even get financial rewards as a reason to think about conversion, and after they convert they were treated as a new born Muslim getting full trust, love and acceptance in Muslim community. Secondly Islamic belief and teachings are magnetic in nature for a common man of this world who experience great suffering because of injustices and clamities. That's one reason I feel why women are more converting to Islam than men because women have more emotions than men and they easily recognize Islamic creed as friendly and optimistic. These two factors are powerful enough to convert a whole population to proud Muslims that magically worked in history very well. But in modern era the first factor is backfiring while the second factor is still giving positive results. It's good to retrospect one's own religious history but do not stop and develop prejudices at any point of time, instead continue studying with rationale.
And all those who were allowed to believe in their faiths had to pay a tax called 'Jizyah', which was mandatory, and if for some reason they couldn't pay it, they had two options: 1) Either to vacate their property and forfeit their possessions or 2) Accept Islam. So they indirectly forced people to convert to Islam by draining their resources, and all the unprivileged people who converted to Islam did it because they couldn't bare the tax and also couldn't afford to lose their home. Those who could afford, did it until their resources dried and eventually converted. So nothing about Islam is peaceful, and if you think conversion didn't happen by force, then you're doing 'taqiyya' to yourself.
Only wicked folks despise Muhammad(SAW), if you hate the final messenger than you only destroyed your hereafter thats all. You are likely a wicked atheist or christian who views homosexuality, alcohol, strip clubs as good. It is true Islam divides society between those who believe in the one God and the disbelievers/wicked, and its clear you are in the camp of satan. Enjoy your short time here Quran 11:17. Can they (Muslims) who rely on a clear proof (the Qur'an) from their Lord, and whom a witness [Prophet Muhammad through Jibrael (Gabriel)] from Him follows it (can they be equal with the disbelievers); and before it, came the Book of Musa (Moses), a guidance and a mercy, they believe therein, but those of the sects (Jews, Christians and all the other non-Muslim nations) that reject it (the Qur'an), the Fire will be their promised meeting-place. So be not in doubt about it (i.e. those who denied Prophet Muhammad and also denied all that which he brought from Allah, surely, they will enter Hell). Verily, it is the truth from your Lord, but most of the mankind believe not .
Bertrand Russell Bertrand Russell (1872-1970) British philosopher, mathematician, and Nobel laureate, whose emphasis on logical analysis greatly influenced the course of 20th-century philosophy. • "Our use of the phrase 'the Dark Ages' to cover the period from 699 to 1,000 marks our undue concentration on Western Europe… From India to Spain, the brilliant civilization of Islam flourished. What was lost to Christendom at this time was not lost to civilization, but quite the contrary… To us it seems that West-European civilization is civilization; but this is a narrow view." [History of Western Philosophy, London, 1948, p. 419]
Iranian population is included of various ethnicities and beliefs. Arab, Kurdish, Turkish (Azeri), Balouch, Lor, Farsi etc. So those who call themselves Persian, are still living in today's society but with a very uneducated brain like they think about ancient history all day long. In fact, Persian was an empire which does not exist anymore and there is no pure Persian blood anymore since Persia has been occupied by Hijazi Arabs, Mongolians, Afghans, Ottomans, Romanians, etc So my main point is, that whatever has happened in the past will remain in the past forever. If you were born as a muslim but you do not feel belonged to it, then you should go and find the truth. Find your own way of peace instead of building hate against Muslims or Islam.
When an umimmigrant Muslim couple PRODUCES 3 ..4...5 children and the non immigrants produce 1..2 ..obviously a sword is not needed ...at this point ...first increase the population then .... Naik can brainwash Muslims using the QURAN but logic does not have a religion and there are people who THINK
Because of chtrapati shivaji Maharaj we make our own Hindu empire swarajya and the interesting thing is Mughal empire aurangjeb tries to win swarajya for 27 year.his end days he denied to wear kafan on his head because he would kill chtrapati sambhaji Maharaj the true warrior who fought for people.
If islam was spread by the sword there are so many muslim rulers who have ruled the European countries, for example umayyad caliphate, rashidun caliphate, abaasid caliphate, ottoman empire, seljuk empire. They were all muslim empires as they said if islam was spread by sword these European countries will be a muslim country today, but they aren't, why
2:191-“Kill them (unbelievers) wherever you find them. Drive them out of the places from which they drove you, for persecution is worse than slaughter…. Such is the reward of those who reject faith.” 2:193-“Fight against them (unbelievers) until there is no dissension, and the religion is for Allah.” Fight until no other religion exists but Islam. 2:218-“But those who believe and those who migrate and struggle in the way of Allah, those, have hope of the mercy of Allah.” Those who fight for Allah may have hope of forgiveness. 3:10-“Those who disbelieve, neither their riches nor their children shall save them from Allah. They shall become the fuel of the fire.” 3:19-“The only true faith in God’s sight is Islam. Those to whom the book was given disagreed among themselves only after knowledge had been given to them, being insolent among themselves. He who disbelieves the verses of Allah indeed Allah is swift in reckoning.” 3:28-“The believers should not take the unbelievers as friends or helpers in preference to the believers. He who does this does not belong to Allah in anything, unless you have a fear of them.”
sagor 777 if you are so sure that most convert in freedom and under free will how do you explain the existence of the murderous apostasy and blasphemy laws from the time of the the final revelation.You dare not lift these laws because you know the truth is the very opposite of what you claim.
First of all, he is part of a propaganda, Islam definitely tried to force India to convert as they did in Iran , Iranians gave up and couldn't resist Indians fought back for very long to stop them to take over India If you see , Islam was able to conquer just North India as it was the gate to enter India and they almost converted half of the population by putting large taxes which they call jizyah on non muslims to force them to convert, and they prohibit muslim girls to marry a non muslim boy but a muslim boy can marry non muslim girl which also resulted in conversion And ofcourse the capturing and rapings which is still part of Jihadis In Asia and around the muslim Majority countries But Islam get slower as they moved towards South India because of a lot of rebel from north and south both sides Sikhs rebelled in North and took back most of the India And South Indians kept resisting and freed from Muslim rules But at a time ,when muslims were able to capture whole India , Britishers arrived and they took down Muslim rulers and they also became slaves as rest of Indians Which is why Indians weren't Converted to Islam and we were saved from the conversion You should read yourself before trusting a muslim They always try to spread fake knowledge to convert people It's called brainwashing in normal language And to them , it's called jihad
They goddamn came to india asking for refuge, their descendants still exist here, heard of Tata? Serum institute of India? Godrej? Jinnah s wife? Jinnah s son-in-law? All Zoroastrians, thanks to Indians.
he did....he told there were black sheeps who might have used sword...but thats wrong...and also told that now a days so many people converting to islam without war....so you cant say islam is spread by sword. thats his clear answer..which i dont know why isnt understood
Hahaha I am a doctor history, geography, psychology, Neurology, fine arts, bakchodi, chutiapa etc... I know everything but sir you don't know how to respect somebody's personal point of view a very narrow minded man (doctor) who know how to talk nonsense.
islam wasnt forced, if it was forced, everyone would be wearing hijab before 1970's... the iranians brought this on themselves by kicking king reza out, if reza was still king, anyone would be free to practice their religion.
Zakir in this video mentioned that all People of India if wanted could have been converted to Islam by force but were not - this is not true it is because people of India especially Sikhs fought back and Mughal empire was squashed so DR Zakir needs to check the facts Please do know that I have nothing against Islam but truth must be said Dr Zakir I strongly agree with the Sufi branch of Islam
I like this Iranian guy, he's cool when he said humans were meant to be free.Free thinkers
Except he is a victim of the false narrative by the media hype. Free thinking means unbiased pondering about things. He was not even listening to the answer of the question he just asked, thus proving he was just a mere heckler. On the other hand, Qur'an commands Muslims to ponder about the things around us. To think deeply about the universe around us. True, you would find few do these days, because Muslims themselves have gone far from the teachings of Qur'an. Daily at least 21 times, a Muslim asks the Creator for Guidance, showing that the Muslim is constantly on a journey to seek and to be steadfast on the Truth about matters of life and death. The things which matter the most.
O YEAH, LIKE THE DEVIL SATAN ITSELF, isn't it ?
@@lilyakter5051 no like obi Von Konobi.
islam wasnt forced, if it was forced, everyone would be wearing hijab before 1970's... the iranians brought this on themselves by kicking king reza out, if reza was still king, anyone would be free to practice their religion.
If every humans are muslims that is good inshallah oneday everyone believe Islam is true religion
Just to make it clear....only zoroastrians in India are called Parsi. Zoroastrians in Iran or samarkand are called zoroastrians only.
If Islam wasn't spread by sword then Zakir Naik won't be a Muslim today because Naik is not a Muslim Surname. Naik is a Marathi Hindu Surname.
Means, you didn't got what dr said!
As the questioner did!
Don't worry your generations will also b Muslims one day InshAllah
😂😂 nailed it
@@budgies8990 kis bhosdi ke ki itni aukaat hai . Wapis aasman me fek dunga kitaab
@@grammarnazi8877 huh!
But mann!!!
You should also read our comments!!
The boy is right those days they were forced to convert he knows the history
Thats not True dont lie.
@@mbert7537 yes Muslims forced non Muslims to convert only very very very few people converted on their own just check indian history for example how many Hindus were converted even if you check the ancestors of present day Muslims theu were Hindus who were forcefully converted , Christians did the same thing in india and now they are brainwashing poor people to convert to Christianity you may find it fake but it is true , in india there are 28 states out of the 28 states in 8 states Hindus have become minorities our population percentage if you check from 1947 to 2022 it Is not increasing but if you check Muslim and Christians population they are growing rapidly
@@mbert7537 it is true and it is also happening today
Indian!😂😂😂
@@IsmailHossain-bq2bo ya because now your filthy religion is trying this in India too wherever you guys go hate is must
This young man is still.persian by heart...the religion did not change him
I am Indian by heart and follow abhramic religion.
its born in us . something every persian has. islam is just a mask over for the country .
@@ahmadrazashaikh7417inbred
@@ahmadrazashaikh7417 bro a person can not have two biological mother. Likewise a person can not have two different ideologies. Hence you can not be Indian by heart and a true muslim.
@@junpreet9261 agree . bulla ki jana mai kaun. born in Muslim family and indian country therefore
He is not answering the
Question he is diverting the subject
@@alireact1827 he said there were some black sheeps who spread islam by the sword yes and it was spread by it
@@ubobu3613 He did not answer as to why. The young man asked why Islam was spread by force, when the Zoroastrians believed in virtually the same concepts already.
@@ubobu3613 yes. He did say there were “ black sheep”
Dude when ur black sheep get together and become the strongest army in the world and try to conquer the world… that’s no longer black sheep… that’s the transformation of ur religion into a violent cult… which is really what happens with ALL religions
How?
zakir naik is left without answer thats why he tried to scare the boy by making him forcefully repeat what he said!! hats off to the guy who stood up against the manipulative devil
He was bastard man who was corrupted by media
Idiot
Bro he answered with a source of a non-muslim historian. He even told the page out of his head. Before that he pointed out many other examples that are more clear and after the guy claimed that history is always true he asked him to recite the historian he mentioned. Did you even watch the video the guy smiles from ear to ear. Where did he scare him of? 😂😂😂
Yeh he is not sure what to say lol. How can he defend the arabs who forced people to convert.
The debate ended when the ex Muslim said I am a free thinker and use my mind to make my own judgements. Not follow some stone or book etc.
Long live persia and persians. Proud to be persian . We were the only nation that capture roman empreror and made him to bent toward our empreror( it's in history). Cuz we die for persia more than for islam😊
Sad , they lost to islam , only If they would have defeated those jihadi, world would be a peaceful place
I’m Muslim before I’m persian
@@dm1frm25 you are outnumbered apparently
@@dm1frm25 Love real Muslim of Iran. They are amazing Muslim in Iran.
@@indianinja420 you don't need numbers to be a winner . Unlike him, the others are hellfire fuel.
The man who asked the question is the one who read history and is personally so dignified not willing to accept Islam as it was forcefully introduced in civilized Persia. Today the converted Muslims don't have minds to learn how terrifying this Islam is
Indian Hindu islami is all potty
Hey bro this asshole is himself hindu converted to Islam. He is still having his Hindu surname. Can he himself first tell the world is he the original Muslim from Arab. He himself doesn't know that Persia and India follow the fire God. Even the real Muslim from Arab and Turkish Muslim they themselves doesn't have a fool person like him preaching Islam. Arabs even don't make they stand in front of them. They say you are converted not real Arab Muslim and this fools preach Islam.....
Literally true brother
I happy to hear that muslim rulers forced our ancestor to convert in islam otherwise we had to worship useless idols, had believe fictional. mythology and can't eat delicious beef🥱
@@rahmanreshad4909 pork is more delicious try it once then you became addicted
So Naik wants to ignore the historians and listen to one critic.
Islam is increasing because they have 4 wives and they have 12 kids 😂😂😂😂😂😂 this is the main reason of growth of Islam
Most Muslim men do not have 4 wifes.
do some research and you might find that your mother is also among those 4 wives 😂😂
@@uuxas hahax, excellent reply 🎉
Yes absolutely 😂 Even in my country (M..l..ysi..) that's how that fungus grows..
@@creativemd8512 among that 4 wives 1 is your mother, 1 is your sister, 1 is your wife and 1 is your daughter 🤣🤣🤣
The Iranian guy hold his calmness through the argument...
What did Aurangzeb and other Mughals do to the Sikh gurus Islam was forced on people. People who did not convert. The reason why not every body converted was because we had Hindu kings and Sikh warriors protecting our Religion. what happened to the Kashmir pandits.
This mc ancestors himself got converted by sword
Naik is a marathi brahmin surname
4:55 "Muslims ruled india for a 1000 years, we could have forced every non muslim indian to be muslim if we wanted to..."
Bruhhv warriors like chatrapati shivaji maharaj , maharana pratap, guru gobind singh etc. Didnt let u do that....in fact in their presence muslim rulers didnt have the GUTS....
Have u heard of a few hundred marathas and rajputs defeating a mughal army of thousands... Yaa we r those marathas nd we are those rajputs and yaa WE ARE THE PROUD DESCENDANTS AND STILL SANATANIS....🕉🚩
And ever heard of 21 sikhs pushing 10,000 afghans to tjeir edges yaa those are our sikh brothers...🧡
Jai bhavani, jai shivrai
Jai maharana pratap
Jai siya ram
Jai sanatan dharm
Vande mataram
Bharat mata ki jai 🇮🇳🚩
200 million indians are muslim they could have forced everyone to convert via death threats. The muslims didn't because they wanted to keep getting tax money. India was lucky look at bengal and pak they are muslim now cus the muslims wanted to convert people there
This is solidifying the young guys views even more.
Islam is the fastest religion. The matter is simple. Hum paanch and hamaare pachaas.
sagar jose yahi kaam india me chal rahaa hai.
If one man can marry two three women and give birth to a. dozen of dogs oviously population increases. But many Muslims are turning back to ancestor religion specially Arabian peninsula.
😂😂
😂😂
Muslim rulers tried their best to spread islam in india but failed. The guy here asked about Persia not Indonesia and Malaysia. It is a matter of historical fact that Islam was forced upon persians. That is why parsis fled iran and settled in india
Did the boy reach home safely 🤣 after speaking the truth
Subhan Allah..!!. Sorry to say but Dr.Zakir Naik is now seen losing his temper more and often.
:5 they tried to force Islam in india, they tried every possible way to destroy Hinduism, our brave hindu soldiers let there lives for hinduism ,and I am proud to be hindu🚩🚩🚩
FAITH IS IN YOUR HEART YOU CAN NEVER FORCE IT......NO BODY CAN
Then you must be superhumans as despite the fact you can never force it, you've some how found a way to force it anyways at every turn
@@indianinja420 you research the history of Islam and you will know Islam was and is not spread by sword
I’m a muslim but I hate it when someone lies. Stop lying and saying muslims didn’t attack Persia and destroyed the Sassanid empire. Prophets own companion fought in those battles. Zakir uses bully tactics and either intentionally lies or is completely ignorant of history.
He says non sense and he doesn't know the real history
I'm Iranian,and Lur, we know what happened to our country, not some random muslims that Don't know the truth
He should know that the invasion happened and many bad things happened, islam was,is and will be a cancer in iran unless secularism comes
Islam was not spread by force, people freely chose to convert. Muslim did conquer land for political reason but never forced people to convert, it just speculation.
4:46 The fact is they tried to convert all of the Hindu brothers
Infact most of the muslims in indian subcontinent are converted folks
But we Hindus(and shiks, Buddhists,Jain's) fought for our religion our culture and not accepted conversion
And retained our religion
Many of the brave people and kings have laid there lives
So we are Hindus not because your forefathers have let us but because our forefathers have sacrificed their lives for the sake of it
LMAO there are many hindu rulers throughout history who tried to force hinduism over other religion 😂😂
@@uuxas Name me one.
Why Dr Zakir don't give any proper answer to any of the questions... Haha I'm a doctor.😂😂😂
What proper brother
You're beautiful ML nerf player.
Burn
@@TheSamosaCritic thank you
Smelled burning
Islam COULD NOT be spread by the sword in India. We had a big population and none of the Muslim rulers wanted to unite the millions of Hindus to fight in unison. So it isn't that they did not, it was that they COULD NOT convert us.
Lol bro, muslims invader of mughal invade and conquer millions of hindus and slaughtered them, the rest of them FORCED converted into islam, read history Lol
mate pakistan is fully muslim as well as bangladesh and a big part of India as well
india lost every war since its birth . just so you know .
@@sammydiamond6115 what about now you have balls to take on india now😂
Muslim countries today are all slaves of west Iraq Libya Syria usa can invade anywhere😂 you guys cannot do anything
Dr. Zakir Nail has the answer. No apologies 😂
doctor may allah protect you from evil thinkers
Isam Sebri brother but your Allah is main evil
@@sejfzlrrhman
Well said dear bro.
This doctor is evil himself
Muslims didn't ruled India 1000 years.
They ruled 800 years actually not more than that
Caliphates reached Indus region actually but not gangetic region and Dravidian region actually
Basically 12th century AD they have entered into North India and settled in Delhi city actually
They entered into Afghanistan and Pakistan in 8th century actually
Caliphates reached that region and stopped their only
Basically we became less violent and less cruel in 11th century to 20th century actually Muslims were much stronger and powerful that they could achieve everything easily
We let them enter into north India due to the Hindu kings and emperors who have extreme ego to get united with each other actually and fought against Muslim invaders actually
please write the name of the Lord ( the most gracious the most merciful) with capital letters " ALLAH"
Muslims came to India after the defeat by deceit of Emperor Prithviraj Chauhan through Muhammad Ghori. Many kings & dynasty ruled India and converted Hindus into Muslims. The deed of Aurangzeb are worthy enough to note. All the Muslims in India are not Islam's, but forcible converts of Mughals and other kings
Bro pritiviraj didn’t defeat muhammmad ghori
@@sunychowdhury278 first battle prithviraj defeat mohmmad gohri
They killed too many people in india . Historians say Islamic conquest of India is bloodiest in the history
"Why Muslim Came to Persia and Forced the Islam, Dr. Zakir Naik" Persia was originally Christian, read in the bible. Then the then powerful Arabs invaded Persia then converted them to Islam, then slowely the Persians converted them selves to Islam. Now, the persians/most of them believe that the quran is not a copy of the bible and modifications. The persians are cheated, heavily.
Persia was Zoroastrians ! Never Christianity
😂
Lol , muslim never used swords for the conversion🤣🤣🤣 a joke
And u r still non muslim.. lol!!!
Toni Tottobini i talking to arjun singh 😂😂
Mullo ki gand me jiziya dal do
Jihad forced everyone
Hacking Daily did jihad force ur grandmother??
He still didn't answer the question. The whole reason "PArsis" exist, is because Zoroastrians were persecuted by the Muslims 1300-1400 Year ago. So him saying "Your History is False" is absurd. Why would Zoroastrians go through such a treacherous Journey to India to save the religion. It's common sense.
All Muslims say are lies
He’s one moron, he’s followed by morons. Simple!
Dear zaker.
I m Iranian living in USA 🇺🇸 Florida for 23 years and I did not understand your quote from the historian 😅 partly your specific Indian accent (cute but hard) and also the vocabulary is not my best strength. This poor guy never would understand.
I am glad Islam came to Iran. This fellow boy needs to read book by ayatollah Motahhari:
The gift of Islam to iran and iran to Islam
As far as answering his questions:
You said many right things but you dodged the question. If we use this method we should accept Jesus is God and many other none sense.
Inavasion of Iran by Muslims happened during Omar and it was some bloody war.
Same as invasion of Roman land. It was not perfect Islam way and prophet Mohammad would do it differently.
Some burning 🔥 of libraries and …
But, many Iranian people of time were tired of kings.
Some helped Arabs.
Also the Islam ideology was so beautiful and superior for them to accept it and take the Koran as way of writing and ….
Otherwise they would not do it. Islam was introduced through invasion but accepted by heart by many.
And some hated it until today.
Same way abusofian never accepted by heart.
No need to sugar coat it by talking Malaysia 🇲🇾
Ps. Historian basically said
It s biggest lie that Muslims used force..
I think you say obsured
A very smart Persian youth.
Historical records clearly explains what happened to the entire native Arab culture, later from Persia to Indonesian, turkey to kazak, Mongolia and other middle eastern cultures ?
He contradicts himself as well on the history part? Anyone catch that lol?
( Hindu, Buddha, jain, Sikh ... based on principal of self purification on complete perfect purification = Moksha .. PURE SOULS eligible to reach God ... God is parama athma = eternal Pure soul and complete perfect good )
Yet you guys instead of worshipping paramatma the eternal and only one you guys worship devas and represent them with rock statutes
@@asadyousafzai7563 u guys don't even have photos of ur God and u still believing in his existence and fighting with others 😂😂
@@asadyousafzai7563 ignore the comment from the guy above me. To be clear almost all Hindus believe in different things but the back bone of the philosophy is that no one could possibly be correct so worship god in whatever form he takes for you and pursue your life's purpose with good intentions. God takes every form and that's why there are so many. The Devas and Pantheon of Hinduism are just the collection of every single belief in India and put into one broad category. To be clear, Hindus never created the concept of Hinduism as it is currently, it's a byproduct of Islamic and British invasions. Some worship idols some idolize them in rock statues but in the end of the day it really doesn't matter. Whatever helps them concentrate on worship better really doesn't make much of a difference. I personally believe the idols don't actually exist (or did exist but with mythicized like the Trojan War) and are just exactly that, idols who we can model our behavior after. For example Ganesh is the god of removing obstacles, he holds and axe in one hand and flowers and sweets in the other and in that way when you idolize him you embody his character (not literally ofc just mentally). But the core idea is there's no way for humans to have the answers of the divine and is therefore less about believing and more about seeking. Too be clear I have respect for many aspects of the Islamic religion and I'm not looking for a fight just a conversation.
@@asadyousafzai7563 why you worship a letter??
Buddhism rejects Athman. Study Tripitaka
Dr Zakir Niak did not make sense to me too… why am I or is anyone for that matter supposed to take the authors words as unequivocal fact… Alhamdullillah I am a proud Muslim but the question should have been answered honestly as per history
brave persian man! he is telling THE TRUTH!👌❤
islam wasnt forced, if it was forced, everyone would be wearing hijab before 1970's... the iranians brought this on themselves by kicking king reza out, if reza was still king, anyone would be free to practice their religion.
@@jakeevolution3941 they are talking about the Initial arab conquest and the treatment of zoroastrians mate
Exactly 💯
So many people like him here in Iran my Arian friend❤️🤍💚🦁🌞🤝 🇮🇳
Free Iran!
The questioner looked like a very decent guy
He just needed guidance
May Allah show him the correct path
Abdullah Kashif thank u for being honest
Abdullah Kashif shut up u brainwashed prick he don’t need allah
Let allah never lead him to violent islam
@@lordwarrenhastings2201 yeah bro 👍🏼
Dr Zakir couldn’t answer the question thats why he got angry
Naji Zr he answered the question however he appeared upset when the individual didn’t understand what was being said to him.
No he answer it....he say that there was no force or attack iran to accept islam...iran is still a majoosi state not a islam state....
True
Traders rarely came to trade sans weapons especially for long distance trades in the past . They did not kill or attack like conventional armies but were lethal in their own way especially if they had religious and political agendas also.The conversions they carried out were also violent but less dramatic than those by the military.This was how Indonesia and Malaysia became Muslim.For a first hand and live experience of violence in Islamic mercantile conversions you can study the conversions by Muslim Indonesian traders of the native people in the Indonesian side of Papua New Guinea.World ignores this violence and terror which makes it easy for people like Zakir to commit taqiya.
Zakir refers to existence of Coptic Christians as proof of Islamic tolerance in Arab land.Firstly Egypt was not Arab land,it now is a land conquered by Arabs.It was and is the land of the Coptic.The stoic existence of dhimmified Coptics under the terror and violence of Sharia laws for centuries is a great example of the opposite.They were tolerated as source for jazziya ,slave and sex trade ,forced conscription etc.
Nah dude it’s just black sheep… same with the Nazis
Taqiya is a Shiism concept. Zakir is a Sunni Muslim
i am from kashmir. our forefathers were hindu brahmins. islamic preachers from arab came here and preached islam by giving lectures peacefully . our forefathers found islam as a true , logical, peaceful religion.
Spreading of Islam in Kashmir was in a good way , so I like it . But in Iran it's different by swords
Thts false in Kashmir as well it was spread by sword.
Worst thing happened in Kashmir was spread of Islam ,it made it hell
🤣 LOL No Isl@maphobe
Nice joke😂😂😂
Either ☪️ or ⚔️
47: 35 Don't cry for peace, for you will have the upper hand and Allah is with you.
9 :29. Fight those who don't believe in Allah and the Last Day
His book allows him to lie (al-taqayya)
Well done young chap.You are the definition of not being ignorant.You won this debate
Clearly islam was forced by force.God will punish e sinners so dunt worry young chap.
Follow what you said.Do not care about people Love each otherAnd do good as you said.
I seen many good islam peopleAnd even many bad islam people who read quran and act as good.So do not believe not even 1 human beingLet them barkAs long you do good god lives you more than people acting as good praying
I have never heard of Islam people. If someone knows, please inform me what is Islam people.
Islam was forced by force... gyahahahhaha that's why nobody takes pple like Mark seriously
lol Christians pissed off zakir
Humans mean freedom islam is restriction
Zakir says, "we Muslims ruled India for more than a thousand years." Having been born in India and being an Indian citizen, he claims he is not an Indian. He is a Muslim and and says he and his Muslim rulers ruled India. Look at the inner side of him and look at the massive crowd of his supporters who are hailing his name. Isn't it crystal clear what Indian Muslims think in their mind? Indian Muslims are the children and grandchildren of slavery, rape, and torture by Arabs on Hindu and Sikh women. These great grandchildren, all of whom are products of forceful conversions, are siding with their masters. They have no patriotism.
I love my country but faith comes first
I hope that Allah will show you his light
you have to open your heart for that
prithvi narayan sahi baat he
prithvi narayan bro Muslims ruled India for about 1000 years. If they were cruel 1000 years were enough destroy the name of hindus.
prithvi narayan sorry to say mam but when muslim ruled this land it never known as india. I think u should reserch
NATIONALISM is not alllowed in Islam.
Islam destroyed persia
When Arabs conquered Persia, They gave Persia 3 options. 1: Pay tax and you can stay Zoroastrian. 2: Fight us and if you defeat us, you can stay Zoroastrian. 3: Accept Islam. They chose fighting and lost and became Muslim. Well yes, they didn't force it directly but that's literally forcing
And his source is telegram and facebook reels 😅😅😅
Any Persian saying we were forced is disrespecting our fathers to be cowards. If Islam was something they hated they would never accept by force and at least they had chance to pay extra tax and not convert to Islam. They chose because it was superior ideology and was accepted.
@@faradpack they fought for 900 years , yes your ancestors were cowards not mine.Islam is dead in Iran. look at anti hijab protests or are you blind ? people are burning mosques. Shia Islam is not Islam anyway but that’s different argument.
We fought because we didn't want to be under the aRaBiC ruling which would wipe away our identity
aRaBs even disturbed using Farsi, they mocked us because of our accent and many more
iSlAm iS a pEaCeFuL rElIgIoN😂😂😂
Today Africa Is 45+ christian.
But Before slavery African people
Were Muslim or believed in African traditional religions
The problem was with the word's accent/pronunciation of Dr. Zakir Naik. Because for a persian person (native language is Persian, and English is the second language) on the open-air public-presense it is difficult to understand the speech by all means.
My all Iranians you guys are zorastrian and will be zorastrian good thoughts , good words and good deeds these are the ways of living . In simple you do good you get good law of karma. Also religion is a sacred thing and not a product. Stay strong.
The arrogance of this man Zakir Naik! islam is spread by the sword!!!!!
Vishal Maraj Islam is worstthingshappenedtohumanity
lol good joke
Where's your proof? Also, Hinduism was definitely spread by the sword.
You talking like 1 pariah I can see that.
1. Accept Islam
2. Pay Jizya
3. Die
Iykyk
What a joke zakir is. He doesn't have answer to his question.
Lokhande sudar ja.. Nhi to tere maa ek din pachtayega jo tuj jaise oulad paida kiya
@@rking-r3g teri ma to pachta rhi h ki usne tere jaisi aulad hagi.
I am trying to leave Hinduism Because it does not allow me to ask some questions ...... What Dr zakir says is from our Hindu Books and 99% Hindu say it is wrong . WTF
Zak even didnt know what is persia . I think he had some heroin before lecture🤣🤣🤣!!!!!
islam wasnt forced, if it was forced, everyone would be wearing hijab before 1970's... the iranians brought this on themselves by kicking king reza out, if reza was still king, anyone would be free to practice their religion.
Zakir Naik you come to India, we'll teach you how to change yourself not by force but by the Medina model of preaching.
RSS, Viswa Hindu Parishad will help you.
Please come and recite your verses.
Message from an iranian to india "stop islam at all costs even if it means deporting or even killing muslims" because it wont end good for your country
11:31 sounds like the boy got annoyed and cursed (saying ‘f*** you’) in the microphone. 🤦🏽♂️ Hope he listens to Dr Zakir Naik.
F u is right. I live it. The Dr. Is a lier.
Iraq was originally part of Persia until they destroyed Zorostianisms!!! Truth
All Iranians like this boy should leave Islam
Hahaha well said
This boy is absolutely correct.
I am not sure Dr Zakir Naik is not talking clearly and simply to the questioner. The young man is simply confused and wants clear-cut answers. Shouting at him was not necessary.
Muna Masood because he was not listning to the answer . he could not repeat and keep arguing
Muna Masood All of the commenters against Zakir Naik or the ones that have dislike of some of his characteristics, remember that backbiting is haram. By saying bad things about him behind his back, even if true, you're destroying his respect and making people hate him or not listen to him. Its best if you spoke to him one on one so that he could improve himself, but most of you cant do that, except from maybe through email or his website, so just stop backbiting. If you spoke to him one on one his respect would be maintained and he would improve improve himself InshAllah.
I feel he is a bit weak in English. Answer was given but he didn't understand that.
If you ask someone a question and they spend their time answering you, it's only respectful to at the very least pay attention.
Farzan Fathi so your accent is good? Im just wondering how God react to your comment.
The assertion that Islam was never spread by the sword is simply not true.
Yeah no one is forcing anyone ...ur religion is growing because some of people in ur religion r still having 6,7,8 kids simple zakir naik....like u said in america europe or other developed countries to get centre link ..just saying no offence
Islam was forced by sword....they are 60 crore muslim in india pakistan and bangladesh put together . So without sword?????
Persia became muslim as state religion. Nobody forced them..
Shias forced iranians to become shia...
Persians were genocided until they had no choice but accepting Islam. Millions where killed and enslaved!
Proof that persians willingly became Muslims?
Never force your beliefs
What
But who done?
However, wisdom and politeness are vital aspects while answering any question. May ALLAH protect our zakir naik.
True. Ameen.
I wasn't happy with his approach as well. As a speaker/answerer, he should be more calm, polite, elegant and sensible while delivering answers. He wasn't like this when he was young, totally opposite to now. He probably looses his temperament as he gets older. Being a bit aggressive towards young guy like him won't help at all. Hope Allah gives Dr. Zakir hidaya (guidance) and keep him on the right track. We don't want to miss these opportunities while someone actually want to know about Islam and give them a bad attitude while delivering the info to non-Muslims. We want all these non-Muslim brothers and sisters come to Islam.
Zakir Naik is a false teacher. He’s misleading you.
The questioner was not listening. It was obvious he was there to challenge. As a viewer, I was able to recall what the historian was saying.. but not the questioner. So he was nothing better than a heckler. There is a limit to politeness. Wisdom comes in many forms, including knowing the direction a heckler could take. If allowed, these ignorant people would disrupt the entire forum, which would also mean the rights of the people behind the guy waiting in line to ask genuine questions would be lost.
In short, we are Muslims, we are courteous, polite and law abiding, however, do not think we are fools and lame ducks to be taken advantage of.
forgetful history my friend thank you! l love Muslims just like l love Jews and Christians and everyone else! We all have our differences in some ways! No one is better then anyone else, we all fall short of the Glory of GOD! l respect you and your comment, GodBless you!
Muhammad bin Muhammad All of the commenters against Zakir Naik or the ones that have dislike of some of his characteristics, remember that backbiting is haram. By saying bad things about him behind his back, even if true, you're destroying his respect and making people hate him or not listen to him. Its best if you spoke to him one on one so that he could improve himself, but most of you cant do that, except from maybe through email or his website, so just stop backbiting. If you spoke to him one on one his respect would be maintained and he would improve improve himself InshAllah.
Christianity is peaceful
Islam is a cruel and not tolerancji religion
the reason most of the comments are non muslims comments because the society is bound to not exept the truth...... May Allah Guide people who are confused
Zakir Naik is a fool. End of conversation.
DUSTY MAGE ARTS it's not that we don't accept the truth, the fact is, your way of interpreting the truth is different from ours.......
i am nameless the thing is that I am not judging anyone on there religion.... I am saying what I think of my beloved religion just like what others say
DUSTY MAGE ARTS obviously you are not!!! Why are you lying?
You muslims have a strong sense of superiority over other faiths......see your own comment, it speaks clearer than Naik......
DUSTY MAGE ARTS "society is bound to not accept truth"? What does that mean then?? Islam is only truth?
Parsis or zoroastrian came to india around 700 from iran just to protect their religion ..........
Their is a book that tell how hard the journey was and what was happening in iran that time written by parsis around 700-800 AD
One of the wisest things done by their ancestors. They receive a lot of respect from Indians.
I got much religious education & experience being a Muslim, this reply of Zakir Naik is not satisfactory to a common man. According to my studies, Islam exerted a force on society but that was an indirect force in the form of "suppressing religious freedom in public domain" and "snatching away political freedom of non-muslims" and making them a protected citizen who were required to obey Muslim's supremacy in political matters. However the protected non-muslims were free to keep their faith & culture and practice it silently without influencing the society. Their property, lives, women & children were completely safe and respected as a "dhimmi" (state protected apolitical non-muslim civilians). If they wanted to get more respect and freedom equal to Muslims, they were highly encouraged to convert to Islam and even get financial rewards as a reason to think about conversion, and after they convert they were treated as a new born Muslim getting full trust, love and acceptance in Muslim community. Secondly Islamic belief and teachings are magnetic in nature for a common man of this world who experience great suffering because of injustices and clamities. That's one reason I feel why women are more converting to Islam than men because women have more emotions than men and they easily recognize Islamic creed as friendly and optimistic. These two factors are powerful enough to convert a whole population to proud Muslims that magically worked in history very well. But in modern era the first factor is backfiring while the second factor is still giving positive results. It's good to retrospect one's own religious history but do not stop and develop prejudices at any point of time, instead continue studying with rationale.
And all those who were allowed to believe in their faiths had to pay a tax called 'Jizyah', which was mandatory, and if for some reason they couldn't pay it, they had two options: 1) Either to vacate their property and forfeit their possessions or 2) Accept Islam. So they indirectly forced people to convert to Islam by draining their resources, and all the unprivileged people who converted to Islam did it because they couldn't bare the tax and also couldn't afford to lose their home. Those who could afford, did it until their resources dried and eventually converted. So nothing about Islam is peaceful, and if you think conversion didn't happen by force, then you're doing 'taqiyya' to yourself.
you cant even provide proof.
Only wicked folks despise Muhammad(SAW), if you hate the final messenger than you only destroyed your hereafter thats all. You are likely a wicked atheist or christian who views homosexuality, alcohol, strip clubs as good. It is true Islam divides society between those who believe in the one God and the disbelievers/wicked, and its clear you are in the camp of satan. Enjoy your short time here
Quran 11:17. Can they (Muslims) who rely on a clear proof (the Qur'an) from their Lord, and whom a witness
[Prophet Muhammad through Jibrael (Gabriel)] from Him follows it (can they be equal with the disbelievers);
and before it, came the Book of Musa (Moses), a guidance and a mercy, they believe therein, but those of the
sects (Jews, Christians and all the other non-Muslim nations) that reject it (the Qur'an), the Fire will be their
promised meeting-place. So be not in doubt about it (i.e. those who denied Prophet Muhammad and
also denied all that which he brought from Allah, surely, they will enter Hell). Verily, it is the truth from your Lord, but most of the mankind believe not .
I wondered the same thing.
d klyts .
Bertrand Russell
Bertrand Russell (1872-1970) British philosopher, mathematician, and Nobel laureate, whose emphasis on logical analysis greatly influenced the course of 20th-century philosophy.
• "Our use of the phrase 'the Dark Ages' to cover the period from 699 to 1,000 marks our undue concentration on Western Europe… From India to Spain, the brilliant civilization of Islam flourished. What was lost to Christendom at this time was not lost to civilization, but quite the contrary… To us it seems that West-European civilization is civilization; but this is a narrow view." [History of Western Philosophy, London, 1948, p. 419]
"i'M a DoCtOr" "i'Ve DoNe PsYcHoLoGy aLsO" 🥴
Iranian population is included of various ethnicities and beliefs. Arab, Kurdish, Turkish (Azeri), Balouch, Lor, Farsi etc. So those who call themselves Persian, are still living in today's society but with a very uneducated brain like they think about ancient history all day long. In fact, Persian was an empire which does not exist anymore and there is no pure Persian blood anymore since Persia has been occupied by Hijazi Arabs, Mongolians, Afghans, Ottomans, Romanians, etc
So my main point is, that whatever has happened in the past will remain in the past forever. If you were born as a muslim but you do not feel belonged to it, then you should go and find the truth. Find your own way of peace instead of building hate against Muslims or Islam.
When an umimmigrant Muslim couple PRODUCES 3 ..4...5 children and the non immigrants produce 1..2 ..obviously a sword is not needed ...at this point ...first increase the population then ....
Naik can brainwash Muslims using the QURAN but logic does not have a religion and there are people who THINK
Because of chtrapati shivaji Maharaj we make our own Hindu empire swarajya and the interesting thing is Mughal empire aurangjeb tries to win swarajya for 27 year.his end days he denied to wear kafan on his head because he would kill chtrapati sambhaji Maharaj the true warrior who fought for people.
Whoever keeps saying "I am this and that" is not "this and that".
"Any man who says 'I am king is no true king'." -GRRM
11:30 is it just me or did the guy really said "fuck you" XD
🤣🤣
Iran used to be mostly Sunni before Shia came and was forced on the population by the Safavid Dynasty.
The arab extremists looted and conquered many areas and states of the peaceful and secular nations in the past in the name of Mahmad and his Allah.
If islam was spread by the sword there are so many muslim rulers who have ruled the European countries, for example umayyad caliphate, rashidun caliphate, abaasid caliphate, ottoman empire, seljuk empire. They were all muslim empires as they said if islam was spread by sword these European countries will be a muslim country today, but they aren't, why
Because all these Caliphates that you mentioned are in Asia not europe
It was spread by sword and they lost afterwards, even India was conquered by sword , but they lost it to British
2:191-“Kill them (unbelievers) wherever you find them. Drive them out of the places from which they drove you, for persecution is worse than slaughter…. Such is the reward of those who reject faith.”
2:193-“Fight against them (unbelievers) until there is no dissension, and the religion is for Allah.”
Fight until no other religion exists but Islam.
2:218-“But those who believe and those who migrate and struggle in the way of Allah, those, have hope of the mercy of Allah.”
Those who fight for Allah may have hope of forgiveness.
3:10-“Those who disbelieve, neither their riches nor their children shall save them from Allah. They shall become the fuel of the fire.”
3:19-“The only true faith in God’s sight is Islam. Those to whom the book was given disagreed among themselves only after knowledge had been given to them, being insolent among themselves. He who disbelieves the verses of Allah indeed Allah is swift in reckoning.”
3:28-“The believers should not take the unbelievers as friends or helpers in preference to the believers. He who does this does not belong to Allah in anything, unless you have a fear of them.”
my fav verses 🔥
In history facts and reality Persians have their religion and cultural heritage and they live well too
This brother has put the best question to Dr. Zakir Naik and he still didn't give him the correct answer....
Arab (Ummaiyids) didn't let iranins convert for the sake of jaziyah tax. Iranian revolted against ummaiyids and converted to Islam.
you cant force people to accept anything, especially a religion. they loved and accepted islam .
sagor 777 if you are so sure that most convert in freedom and under free will how do you explain the existence of the murderous apostasy and blasphemy laws from the time of the the final revelation.You dare not lift these laws because you know the truth is the very opposite of what you claim.
First of all, he is part of a propaganda, Islam definitely tried to force India to convert as they did in Iran , Iranians gave up and couldn't resist
Indians fought back for very long to stop them to take over India
If you see , Islam was able to conquer just North India as it was the gate to enter India and they almost converted half of the population by putting large taxes which they call jizyah on non muslims to force them to convert, and they prohibit muslim girls to marry a non muslim boy but a muslim boy can marry non muslim girl which also resulted in conversion
And ofcourse the capturing and rapings which is still part of Jihadis In Asia and around the muslim Majority countries
But Islam get slower as they moved towards South India because of a lot of rebel from north and south both sides
Sikhs rebelled in North and took back most of the India
And South Indians kept resisting and freed from Muslim rules
But at a time ,when muslims were able to capture whole India , Britishers arrived and they took down Muslim rulers and they also became slaves as rest of Indians
Which is why Indians weren't Converted to Islam and we were saved from the conversion
You should read yourself before trusting a muslim
They always try to spread fake knowledge to convert people
It's called brainwashing in normal language
And to them , it's called jihad
They goddamn came to india asking for refuge, their descendants still exist here, heard of Tata? Serum institute of India? Godrej?
Jinnah s wife? Jinnah s son-in-law?
All Zoroastrians, thanks to Indians.
Muslims couldn't convert India to Muslims because the Hindu Kings fought back. The Ahom dynasty, the Vijaynagara Empire, etc.
Df Zakir,You didn't answer his question,did you ?
he did....he told there were black sheeps who might have used sword...but thats wrong...and also told that now a days so many people converting to islam without war....so you cant say islam is spread by sword.
thats his clear answer..which i dont know why isnt understood
you havent seen whole video have you ?
th-cam.com/video/VGl48YnJGhY/w-d-xo.html
he answered. get a pen a paper and right down the points he made in case you have understanding or memory problems.
Another stupid fuck..listen to the historian...
Don't you understand English???
He’s going in circles and not answering the question. This is why I don’t watch Zakir Naik anymore. You will never hear a straight answer.
Hahaha
I am a doctor
history, geography, psychology, Neurology, fine arts, bakchodi, chutiapa etc...
I know everything
but sir you don't know how to respect somebody's personal point of view
a very narrow minded man (doctor) who know how to talk nonsense.
islam wasnt forced, if it was forced, everyone would be wearing hijab before 1970's... the iranians brought this on themselves by kicking king reza out, if reza was still king, anyone would be free to practice their religion.
We are hindu because our ancestors fought and defeated for our etnicity and those who didn't fought became muslim
You are right my friend.
Zakir in this video mentioned that all People of India if wanted could have been converted to Islam by force but were not - this is not true it is because people of India especially Sikhs fought back and Mughal empire was squashed so DR Zakir needs to check the facts
Please do know that I have nothing against Islam but truth must be said Dr Zakir
I strongly agree with the Sufi branch of Islam
Sikh, rajput, jat, maratha and many are generals in the muslim ruler army and how they dare to convert if they tried themselves were killed by hindus
Respect to you brother... not crazy zakir
SOMETIMES I WONDER WHY SUNNIS ARE ACCUSING SHEAS ABOUT BEING KAFFURS! Now I Got It!
7.51 ....europe and american population increasing becoz of immigration and low birth rate of white women....!
Why ?
To steal Persian’s land, property and enslave their women and men and impose jiziya and colonize Persia.
That was their motive.