Exactly...very well spotted 👍 I was thinking the same thing. Before that the terrace door was never locked it seems. Like there were blood stains on the stairs leading up to the terrace. How can they miss that... like wtf was going on.
The police are easily bribed in India. You can get away with murder by incompetent police (bribed off). Which obviously is very bad especially if you have no money and you are looking for justice. Unfair
@@CosmosChill7649 Couldn't agree more...this is 100% correct 👍...The police department in India is there only to serve the rich and highly influential people like corrupt politicians and they harass the poor. Hate the police here. There is nothing like an honest police officer in India.
The fact that the parents right away said Hemraj did it , asked the maid to clean the rooms while the police is still there and stopped the police from going to the terrace says so many things. The crime scene was contaminated too.
I have a theory. Considering they suspect she was raped, I think possibly the man living there (sorry bad with names) had been grooming and sexually assaulting her. He could have threatened her to say it was consensual if they were caught. On top of that, some cultures still believe that a girl/woman is just as much to blame when she’s raped and “unclean”. This has lead to male family members killing the girl/victim in the past, extremely sad and horrific. If the father found his daughter being raped, and she tried to protect her family by saying it was consensual, he could have gone into a rage and killed them both. It would explain everything, including the coverup by both him and his wife.
@@tinydream Parents were too stoic and poised throughout. Their only daughter of 13 yrs killed so brutally. I never heard them even once, ask forcefully for Justice, for the Law to find the killers. They were just wooden with well rehearsed and matching stories. But when a lawyer activist knifed The Father outside the Courts, the Father started crying profusely. 😂😂😂😂
Why is it only speculated that the father caught his daughter in a compromising position? Why was it never considered that Hemraj caught Rajesh abusing his daughter? His wife said he felt fatherly towards Arushi. The boyfriend said she had been having problems with her father. If something had been going on, low-key, and that night it escalated, he, Hemraj, might have felt he needed to step in. Which led to his murder, and then Arushi‘s, in order to prevent her from spilling the beans, about the abuse and subsequent murder. That to me seems the most likely.
Yesss!!Yess!!! This is what I was thinking too. I feel like that Hemraj was killed trying to protect the poor girl. Parental SA is such a tabooh but it happens and in many places like India it is always kept so hidden. Your scenerio makes so much sense.
My thoughts exactly, why allow all those people into their house??? I'm sure they were well aware of the risk of contaminating the evidence before the police arrived.
The father obviously knew that Hemraj was dead on the balcony, because he paid for the police to not search the balcony. Your theory seems very plausible.
My heart breaks that Hemraj was vilified as the killer, only to find out that he most likely died defending her. Tragically for both victims, this case cannot ever be definitively solved due to the state of the crime scene.
Things that really stand out for me and make me believe that the parents are the ones that committed the murders: 1. Blaming Hemraj from the get go, without any evidence. 2. Destroying and tampering with the evidence by allowing media and other people inside and having the crime scene cleaned up 3. Bribing the police 4. Asking to keep the mention of rape out of the autopsy report. 5. Cleaning her vagina 6. Saying they don’t want to throw any allegations on anyone and then saying it’s possible that it could be the help when they’ve already got alibis.
I have watched several videos about murders in India and in all the cases the crime scene was contaminated because a lot of people were allowed into the crime scene including family members and media were allowed in while the bodies were still laying there.
I agree. Most plausible explanation is Rajest got angry and snapped and killed her. either he was sexually assaulting her or not. However, what i find hard to accept is a mother covering up for her husband? even after all these years? One other angle is - Hemraj's friend attacked Arushi and Hemraj was trying to help, and in the process killed. but this theory seems far fetched when parents were acting shady
@@madmax797 bruh the truth when it comes to India is that justice seldom prevails, the cops contaminated the whole crime scene , their way of solving crime is just by pointing fingers instead of hard evidence, you should come live here to see for yourself
Actually they are innocents how can someone brutally murder their only child for a moment we can take servant there are many evidences which shows they aren't culprits it was someone else only who did this and got escaped cleverly & professionally damn
@@tangerinetangerine4400 these wealthy doctors (her parents) were very much wealthy and liberal, they didn't believe in dishonour and all that bs, it's something else that led to her murder, no doubt the parents and complict in one way or the other but the boyfriend angle is not true
Everyone in India knows that the Dad did it, and the Mom helped cover it up, but unfortunately it cannot be proved. Its just sad. I really hope her soul is at peace. Om Shanti
Exactly you cannot sleep in the next room and do not realize what is happening in the room next to yours. If the Father was drunk The Mother atleast wasn't and she could've heard it. But both the parents made the same exact statement which shows there more to it than what they were telling. And if they wanted to pin it on Hemraj the butler, atleast his body should've been near the crime scene and not insise the Water storage tank.
I was born and raised in India and now live in the USA. I remember this case being HUGE back when I was growing up. It is still such a mystery. Thank you for doing an AMAZING job with this. We all pray that Arushi gets the justice that she deserves. There’s even a Bollywood movie made on this movie called ‘Talvar’.
We all know it’s d parents….yet corruption in India at its peak…2 innocent lives were lost 😔😔 no one entered d house or left Dad also had an affair with his co- assistant and on top of that “ MOVIE WAS MADE ON THIS TRYING TO CLEAR PARENT’s NAME🙄🙄) Y did dad/ mom instantly took Hemraj’s name? Y not neone else? Y were arrushi’s bed was made and room was mopped ? Thanks for letting us know new things…I never knew talwar paid LE 25,000k to not look at terrace but search outside for hemraaj…. Who wud delete d data of AARUSHI’s cell? Obviously,house helpers or others wud know how to delete it…..WE ALL KNOW,PARENTS ARE RESPONSIBLE YET INDIAN JUDICIAL SYSTEM IS MOST CORRUPTED…AND WERE BOUGHT BY DESE KILLERS 🙄🙄 Does neone know whose Bedsheet was it in which Hemraj was covered?
I remember this case being all over the news. When Hemraj's body was discovered in the same building, who had already been reported the prime suspect, even not knowing much about how these things work, I was shocked that the whole building hadn't been searched at the very first. The investigation of this case was so thoroughly ruined, it's a shame.
Sadly parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that their daughter Aarushi and servant Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
@@ilyaskashmiri4903 Seriously ??? Arushi was 13 yr old & even if she had an affair it would be considered rape by law as she is minor... Parents could have easily lied saying Hemraj was raping my daughter so I killed the servant in anger & daughter by mistake??? They don't need to hide anything if they could get sympathy from court & less punishment. If police has contaminated crime scene then how can you say for sure outsiders have not come. The parents room had loud AC hence they couldn't hear anything. Please watch the CNA 4 part documentary on this, it'll raise so many questions on how CBI team conducted investigation & manipulated the evidence. And the servants from Nepal, Krishna is missing & has gone crazy (maybe because of guilt) & another servant Rajkumar showed body langauge signs of NPD. These 2 servants are murderers
The parents absolutely did it. No question. They lock her in her room, they don't even seemed phased by the police botching the case, they INTENTIONALLY had evidence cleaned! What innocent parents do that??
Umm not necessarily disagreeing with your opinion but her door locked from the inside and needed a key to access it from the outside. So thats why the mom had a key on her nightstand. Not the other way around.
Like a comment from above says, I believe the father was drunk on his whiskey and was compromising his daughter when Hemraj discovered them. Hemraj looked upon the daughter as his own daughter and may have came to her rescue inturn being killed by the father and dragged up to the terrace where he was dumped and the door remained locked. The evidence of blood trail proves he was moved up there. Also the daughter's boyfriend claimed she was having difficulty with her father leading up to this. I definitely think he was the killer and in his drunken panic chose to slay his daughter aswell so as to keep her quiet and not have his reputation tarnished. The mother too helped cover it all up.
Please don't try to understand Indian people by your standards. Indians are different. Her parents were super chill and father and daughter had endless talks and discussions. India doesn't have a very sophisticated system of investigation. No crime scene expert accompanies the police. And we in India know it's a helpless system so we have learnt to just get on. I know countless people who just give up because they don't have the strength to fight a corrupt system. And the state of UP is most corrupt in India. Also Hindus believe in karma. Karma js a Hindu word. So they don't really believe in helping the justice system
I honestly feel the parents or one parent has something to do with both deaths. Hamraj (I'm sure I spelled that wrong) was killed for trying to protect the daughter. I think he walked in on her being attacked or he knew something going on in the home and felt the need to protect her but was killed in the process. And with this family's status in the community I'm sure they can cover up what really happened.
There are many theories some say the daughter was caught in a compromising position with the servant . Dad got mad killed them both and later tried to cover it .
Or the dad killed Hemraj before/after killing his daughter because he needed someone to blame. The police spent the first two days searching for Hemraj instead of thoroughly investigating the crime scene because they were convinced he was the murderer.
Actually they are innocents how can someone brutally murder their only child for a moment we can take servant there are many evidences which shows they aren't culprits it was someone else only who did this and got escaped cleverly & professionally damn
I remember this case, especially because I was the same age as Arushi when it happened. I remember my parents and relatives talking about the case at family dinners and outings. I recall thinking how one is not safe even in one’s own house. What a beautiful girl Arushi was, may her soul rest in peace 💐
True, I was also of same age as hers then. This is what I think. Often times, especially where a complex crime is committed like this which involves 2 murders (related or unrelated we dont know), I cannot even trust the police report because even with all evidences, there still is 5% chance that innocent people are put in jail; as has been the case in the country in the past. It is very rare for a rich and influential person who has committed a crime to sit behind bars, not only in India but in most countries. This is one such case. If Talwars were not the culprit, then trust me they would not have left any stone unturned to catch the actual culprits. They are intelligent people and they knew from the beginning that it is a game of evidences, and this they achieved successfully by allowing for a shoddy investigation during the first week of investigation. They had successfully executed their plan by that time and even if they were implicated still, they knew very well that evidences would never be sufficient for a long term punishment. Being both parents doctors, it can be safely assumed that they are not fools.
@@Sana-ik8fo I understand your point. Keeping in mind that one could never tell what went on in that house that night except the killers and the victims, I don’t think it’s okay to blatantly blame the parents because there was nobody else to blame. In this case, the parents were announced guilty until proven innocent, this is a direct result of having a ridiculous investigation and a joke for law enforcement. The whole case was so focused on the parents, that I don’t think they even had a chance to actually try and find the culprits. Now I don’t think the parents are innocent, all I’m saying is that the evidence could be hampered with by any party i.e., the parents, the servants/drivers, the cops, the CBI etc It’s sad but unfortunately that’s the reality of this case that we’ll all just have to accept.
She was absolutely stunning, and she sounds like she was an amazing girl with so much promise. This is one of those cases that never leaves people's hearts...
i feel so bad for hemraj. just an honest man trying to support his family and he was killed bc of this disgusting family. also interesting she was found with a bag covering her face. in psychology, they say if a killer covers his/her victims face its because they subconsciously feel regret or guilt. definitely the father who did it.
@@sinthiyasnigdha5541 That’s a movie and other forces trying to put the blame on a dead immigrant worker. It’s always like that in our country. The poor get the brunt for what the rich do.
This case really bothered me. I was so surprised when this case was all over the news where the media was portraying arushi's character as bad and having sexual relationship with hemraj. I didn't believe it then and won't believe it now. We may never know what happened that night. Everything is messed up. RIP beautiful girl
NEws in India is fucked up. How can a 14 year old have sexual relationship with a 45 year old. It will be called sexual assault in every other country because she is a minor.
Parents definitely did it. They are doctors and should have known better. After the murders they allowed the scene to be contaminated by many people. I think this was intentional. They wanted the evidence to be destroyed. I also believe the father was abusing his daughter and the helper must have heard her scream and come to her defense.
It’s absolutely ridiculous that in 2008 a police investigation should go that bad. That entire city should be ashamed of their police department and the press for bursting into the scene. I hope there were some serious changes in policy after this. With the dna advances at that time this should have been a solved case. The terrace being locked and not investigated was outrageous. I’m so mad they were so brutally murdered in such a sloppily way and still did not get any justice. Boy they just arrest people without any evidence. Plus giving people a truth serum. I’m so mad. It’s like ok it was the parents. Wait no. Ok maybe. No not them. Ok yes it must have been. Well…
Although there have been some improvements in laws around the country, sadly Police's approach to solving cases has not improved much, specifically in the state of Uttar Pradesh where this murder took place, it remains a State with one of the highest crime rates in the country specifically sexual crimes against women.
@Nick Young I have watched a lot of videos on this channel and there is a stark contrast in how such cases are handled in developed vs developing countries. Delayed action is so common that it's a norm here. In cases from US and Europe I see police rushing to secure the crime scene and preserve every single piece of forensic and DNA evidence and still sometimes struggle to find the actual criminals. In our country, media and huge crowds will reach before the police to get those first pictures. Cases being solved by DNA evidence is a rare occurrence.
@Nick Young yes I watch this channel all the time and it’s so frustrating watching the ones that are not investigated well or when they to long to respond. I really wanted justice for these two.
"oh hey our daughter was murdered but you can all come and contaminate the crime scene, don't break any doors to find the murderer or the weapon." They are diabolical. And they waited for the maid to see their dead daughter?
My gut tells me that the mother was in fact waiting for the maid to come, she led her in,and actually waited for her to tell the neighbours. I think it was this way. I found it weird, unnatural. Even later mom.was deadpan.
The parents are pathetic. "We don't want to blame anyone". No tears, nothing. That dame has her arms crossed, talking about how they cry at night. Two people's throats slit, and they "have nothing". Ya'll really know how to tell a story, thank you so much. Rest in Peace, Arushi.
They cannot accept that they killed their daughter becoz she was found in a compromising position with his man servant as ppl will character assasinate their daughter so they have to hide the truth that they killed the daughter all their lives.....
@@kashif9145They also didn’t allow the police to search the home and contaminated the crime scene. They were super uncooperative. It’s odd behavior in addition to their emotional state where they don’t show any sort of sympathy for their daughter.
@@ilyaskashmiri4903No. He was completely innocent and absolved of everything. I suspect the father. He hid so much information and was so double sided in what he said and what was happening. He wasn’t honest when it was such a dire situation. He definitely did something and the servant saw something.
I have been following Arushi - Hemraj murder case from day 1 and from what I have observed and understood so far the parents are the culprits. They may perhaps escape the human legal system due to a lack of so-called evidence, which was undoubtedly botched up. But they would never escape God's judgment, it comes late though.
Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that Aarushi and Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
No the guy who called from PCO was the real killer. I have investigated every possible angle and studied this case for many years. It was the deed of any outsider who very cunningly entered the flat dodging the security guards probably climbed the walls or any other way entered the flat, met Hemraj, and then whatever reason killed him and arushi.
@@NellyMacharia no you want to really know why? Because it's even WORSE than an honor killing to EVEN THINK that an Indian father could be molesting his own daughter. This is a subject which Indians HATE to bring up. It happens, yet they like to pretend it doesn't.....
Thank you for shedding light on this case. The father stopping the search of the terrace with a clear bribe to Police throws up enough red flags. Shame that the evidence was tampered so that justice cannot be properly served. May they rest in peace
I remember that I joined Facebook to know more about this case. It was so mysterious and still is. I believe this would go unsolved and the only person who would know the full truth would be those who committed this crime. Rip to Hemraj though. His death is nothing but a foot note in this grand family media court drama focusing on the talvers.
I’ve watched pretty much all your content, and I must say, this is probably the best video you’ve made. Love the effort and research you put into your work
The contradictory part here is that the parents never called the police a neighbor asked the security of the gated community to call the police and by that time all evidence was contaminated or destroyed. When the police arrived on the crime scene there were 12-15 people in the house. Even the forensic policeman collecting evidence said most of the fingerprints had been smudged comprised. Rajesh Pointing to hemraj as the murderer was justified as he was missing.
Sab vaasta ki baat hai, such people have connection in high up places and one phone call can change the story. Their daughter has died in a mysterious way and they are requesting the Post Mortem doctors not to mention rape? They could not protect the daughter, but worry about family honour which to me is also suspicious. Poor arushi just lay there in her bed and died taking the truth with her. See the nirbhaya case - it happened in delhi, 4 hanged - their backgrounds were dalit etc etc basically they were poor. See Talwar case - again in delhi - 50 days in prison and out with no evidence to prove they were innocent, let loose on emotional grounds cause parents cant do it. Look at the Sheena Bora case - that mother of hers is doing womens rights or jail rights from her cell...no remorse. Crimes happen at every level.....but the rope is too weak for the people with contacts. This was either an honour killing, or a case of sexual abuse by the father which was seen by hemraj. Arushi had to die as she might have given away who killed hemraj and why. Alot goes on in regular families that is never revealed, but nothing is impossible.
@@TheLotussong "50 days in prison and out with no evidence to prove they were innocent"...i guess in backward societies the normal rule of law doesnt apply, where you are innocent unless proven guilty (and not the other way around)
@@MrRisingapple There is no backward or forward here, its all about money and connections and that applies everywhere. When was the last time a rich criminal hanged in india? Crimes are happening but they either sit in airconditioned jail cells with full facilities till the law finds a way to prove them innocent - or they fly off to dubai. The law is for the poor and uneducated . So whether one is guilty till proven innocent or innocent till proven guilty - just remains in the books. Less or more , this happens worldwide. Arushis parents have the answer, but they wont speak,all fingers point at the servants and helpers.
Often times, especially where a complex crime is committed like this which involves 2 murders (related or unrelated we dont know), I cannot even trust the police report because even with all evidences, there still is 5% chance that innocent people are put in jail; as has been the case in India in the past. It is very rare for a rich and influential person who has committed a crime to sit behind bars, not only in India but in most countries. This is one such case. If Talwars were not the culprit, then trust me they would not have left any stone unturned to catch the actual culprits. They are intelligent people and they knew from the beginning that it is a game of evidences, and this they achieved successfully by allowing for a shoddy investigation during the first week of investigation. They had successfully executed their plan by that time and even if they were implicated still, they knew very well that evidences would never be sufficient for a long term punishment. Being both parents doctors, it can be safely assumed that they are not fools.
Actually they are innocents how can someone brutally murder their only child for a moment we can take servant there are many evidences which shows they aren't culprits it was someone else only who did this and got escaped cleverly & professionally damn
This case for me has always equated to the Jon Benet Ramsey case. A child dead, in a house with limited people at the time and in both cases the crime scene was tampered with, rooms/terrace in this case were locked/not allowed access to. Both cases educated and well placed parents invited support who in turn formed early conclusions and helped knowingly or unknowingly with the contamination and clean up of the scene. It's sad this case will like the Job Benet one, may never see the light of justice.
I’d never heard of this case but with your narration, I was hooked. Thank you for taking the time to cover cases outside the Uk& USA. ( love it) Only 4 people in a very small apartment 2 murdered so violently , 2 survived and didt hear a thing🙄yes the police did an awful job protecting evidence …. But the Parents did it and now they are free😡 No justice here!!
@@jyotsnasharma6180 Bollywood is now exposed as Gutterwood.! Nexus of criminals. Can we yrust them to bring out the truth? The parents never asked for Justice for their daughter. Hemraj told his friends his life was in danger.
@@jyotsnasharma6180'Talwar' is a commercial movie. It's a fictional account and is biased. In order to absolve the parents, the movie depicts the investigation and the police officers who blamed the parents as inefficient, corrupt and as jokers. Moreover, one of India's finest actors, late Irrfan Khan was roped in to play the officer who concluded that the parents were innocent victims of a media trial and botched investigation. So, please talk about facts and not some Bollywood propoganda movie! Thanks.
My relatives lives in the same society and I remember how she told me while we were talking a walk that this is the house of Arushi. And at that time all those memories of what media told us about Arushi came back . Even if Parents are not the murderers they have played a major role in destroying the evidence . As doctors themselves they had better known that this is a murder scene which is not supposed to be tampered with anything.
Sadly Rajesh and Nupur Talwat cannot accept the truth publicly that Aarushi and Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
This was definitely NO WICH HUNT, the evidence was 100% compromised with the 100% help from the parents, and any evidence left ONLY points to dad NO ONE ELSE. Mom 100% covered for dad. They deserve to be locked up for life and I pray they NEVER rest and that what they did haunts them for the rest of their lives, may they NOT find joy or pleasure or rest. Absolutely disgusting.
What an incredible video. You guys really are the cream of this genre. It’s so professionally put together and impeccably narrated. I so wish I could work on these videos with you!!! You are sheer class ❤️
I’m a true crime fanatic, & I totally agree. They’re the best of the best. Seriously, they’re in my top 5. Being #1 🤣🥰 whenever they post a video, I’m so excited to watch. The way she narrates clearly, gives ample & thorough amount of detail, & just all in all tells the story in a way I just totally enjoy lol it’s THE BEST 💕
Drugging people up and interrogating them to me doesn't seem to be fruitful especially after they all previously had knowledge of the details just a thought but i will say this was a very well done episode and this is definitely one of my favorite channels
Sodium pentothal would never work in this manner l agree because they fed all 3 the crime details so of course they would or could speak about them whilst mixing in thoughts already in their memories. That's exactly what one of them did although he wasn't able to give the details that they needed that were not fed to him to begin with. Precisely why he was given the med in the first place.
The body language in the interview with the parents says it all. Especially the mom leaning farther and farther away from the dad. The crossed arms. All defensiveness.
I did not watch the whole episode but am aware of what I had read in newspapers/ watched on TV those days. Many questions remain unanswered. 1. Arushi and Hemraj's throats were slit by a surgically trained person and in both cases, the jugular veins were cut. Only a doctor would know how to cut the jugular vein. Initially, Hemraj and other male house help were blamed for the murder. House helps do not have to be 'surgically trained' to chop veggies! 2. As doctors why did the parents not preserve the victim's viscera? They did know that the viscera report would have nailed the culprit. 3. Why the hush-hush cremation the next morning and immediate ash imersion without informing the police, family, and friends? 4. Who cleaned up the victim's private parts? Except for the parents, there was no third person in the house. Why did they clean her up? As doctors, the parents knew how to get rid of evidence to protect the murderer. The parents ensured to clean up all evidence ASAP including cremation. 5. None bothered to check the incest angle. 6. While the investigation was going on (TV), the mother did not break down even once. How is that possible? The daughter was born 10 years after marriage (according to newspapers) and was the only child? I am aware that some women can be tough but how can one not feel for an only child who was born after 10 years of marriage? Personally, I find it strange. 7. The mother did break down finally when she was sentenced with her husband. She broke down again while she was being interviewed inside the jail. I find it bizarre. A woman who did not cry when her only teen daughter is brutally murdered cried because she was convicted. 8. Do not recollect any boyfriend angle in the case. 9. The flat is not so huge that while two murders were being committed, one body was dragged to the terrace after opening the locked gate, and the parents continued to sleep soundly? Find it difficult to digest. 10. I often think about the kid and pray she gets justice and the murderers are caught and put behind for life. You cannot kill a kid full of life and forget about it. 11. Why are the parents not pursuing the case and seeking justice for the brutal murder of their only child? Heartless parents!
This is an excellent analisis! Parents were suspecting something odd that made them to suspect that their own child would have been hiding from them; It was said that their daughter changed in those days. Probably, the child told her parents about someone was sexually abusing her and she named it. Parents could promised their daughter that nothing was going to happen to her that they needed her to help them to caught the one who was sexually abusing her. OR her parents wanted to caught them in that sexual act. Mother didn't lock her room's door, while her child was asleep or pretending being asleep, so she could not lock the door from inside..... A gross honor killing indeed!
Its the parents, everyone knows but no solid evidence to charge them...its so sad..all the evidences was tampered. I rightfully agree with all your points, I also feel bad for Hemraj, he was an innocent house help, but had to die in the tragic way possible. Hemraj used to work there , stay far away from home and own family. Both the victims didn't deserve to die this way...the young girl had miles to go. And as you said the mother broke down when they were being charged in the first place for the murder.. that's the perk of a sociopath..I think the parents are absolute sociopaths to murder their own daughter and then cover it up that too very minutely...they have cleared the crime scene just like a psychopath.
Sad her mother went through a bunch of ivf treatments to conceive her daughter only to allow her to be killed by her father later in life. Makes no sense.
@@wink7779 incorrect. Rajesh and Nupur met at Maulana Azad Medical College in Delhi and married in 1990. Aarushi was born four years later. you have mixed up Sheena Bora case or some other with this.
Drug a suspect and then slap them silly when they are subsequently unfit to he interviews, really professional. It’s a really shame this case wasn’t handed in a more professional matter, this is not justice for a sweet young girl.
I have always wondered about this case and still do. Please cover the case of Ayesha Meera, a girl from Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh who was brutally murdered in the girls hostel with at least 100 people in the same hostel but had not been solved conclusively.
@@nevereverigoteyesonyou8377 you would be shocked by the police's handling of the case and twists in the story. I wish I could find a channel which covered it with all the details. It's such a dark case and it haunts many people to this day.
@@tippusultan8173 is there any documentary made on this on TH-cam?? if yes please help where can I know about this case. And yes!! there are so many criminal cases still unsolved and inconclusive because of lack of solid evidence and contamination of crime scene!! its sad reality.
@@Redwoodtree34567 I tried but I find mostly news reports and inaccurate news and videos . I will try again and will let you know. Her name is Ayesha Meera. Please search it by her name Ayesha Meera murder case.
It's really scary to know that there is still a person out there who knows he killed them both and exactly what happened that night. While all the fingers/proofs point to the parents, the questions are yet unanswered. I pray whether out of guilty conscience or whatever reason, that murderer comes out and accepts what he did to these two innocent souls. RIP Arushi and Hemraj.
@@knightking216 You do know satellite images are not very detailed or clear right? They take photos miles away from earth in space, do you really think it’s gonna identify a tiny person sneaking into a house / killing a girl in her bedroom?
The father was SA his daughter. Probably doing so for years. Went to do so that night, got caught out by the poor housekeeper, Hemraj. Out of panic, killed him with the first thing in sight, the bottle. Then finished off his own daughter as she was a witness. The wife was in on it, cleaned up the crime scene and their daughters body. Both of them dragged Hemraj’s body up to the terrace and both work together to cover up themselves. They would rather kill and cover up than expose themselves and ruin their reputations since they were well known doctors in the community. They knew that inviting many into the crime scene will botch the investigation. Absolutely sickening. All that effort to have a child and they do this to her and their housekeeper. Sickening
I believe parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that their daughter Aarushi and servant Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
The father did so much suspicious acts: 1.) redirecting investigations away from where the decomposing body of male house keeper was, 2.) asking someone to lie about SA in the coroner’s report. He can’t escape the consequences of the truth forever that’s for sure!
Often times, especially where a complex crime is committed like this which involves 2 murders (related or unrelated we dont know), I cannot even trust the police report because even with all evidences, there still is 5% chance that innocent people are put in jail; as has been the case in India. It is very rare for a rich and influential person who has committed a crime to sit behind bars, not only in India but in most countries. This is one such case. If Talwars were not the culprit, then trust me they would not have left any stone unturned to catch the actual culprits. They are intelligent people and they knew from the beginning that it is a game of evidences, and this they achieved successfully by allowing for a shoddy investigation during the first week of investigation. They had successfully executed their plan by that time and even if they were implicated still, they knew very well that evidences would never be sufficient for a long term punishment. Being both parents doctors, it can be safely assumed that they are not fools.
Actually they are innocents how can someone brutally murder their only child for a moment we can take servant there are many evidences which shows they aren't culprits it was someone else only who did this and got escaped cleverly & professionally damn
Sadly Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that Aarushi and Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
This is a case study on how badly the cops, media and corruption could botch a case. This case was so widely covered on the media when it has just happened, as if this was a reality show. The smallest detail would become breaking news. Very well covered, this gives better closure to a lot of us who did not know the other details the media did not reveal.
I hope I'm never accused of a crime in India. I've never seen police, medical investigators, etc. like that. It was like they were pretending to be cops. What kind of press conference was that?
Yes we have seen how police are always morally exemplary in other countries like sarah everard in london or george floyd in usa or lock up deaths in aborginals in australia etc eh ?
💯 the Dad is the main culprit for both murders. Can’t believe all evidence was tampered and contaminated with! Why were the police so careless? 🤷🏻♀️ The parents interview was simply one of the most cold blooded and calculated without showing any emotions. How can such parents that fully know their child has been brutally murdered sit there and speak like as if she didn’t matter much to them! Shocking! Totally shocking!!
Here's my thought. The parents had an inkling about her boyfriend and didn't want her to chat with him. Hence, they wanted to turn off the wifi router. And Aarushi turned it back on and started chatting , when her dad came to know about this he started hitting her in rage only to be intervened by Hemraj. This angered Rajesh Talwar and in a fit of rage killed Hemraj in front of Arushi. Fearing she will spill the beans, he killed her too to save his image in society. Then dragged out Hemraj's body and his wife played the role of an accomplice and opened the terrace door while Rajesh was dragging the domestic help's body. Dumped his body upstairs and locked the terrace door. Came back to their apartment and Rajesh went and started to drink whiskey, while his wife placed those toys on the mattress and lowered her daughter's pants exposing her rear to make it look like she was sexually assaulted by Hemraj. Then both of them cleaned the house removing their fingerprints. In the morning when the maid arrived, Rajesh calls the maid to Aarushi's room and showing her tells," look what he has done to her". Who on earth does that? He just wanted to pin the blame on Hemraj and have people believe that he did it, so maid will spread the rumour to people. The verdict is the dad killed them both, the mother an accomplice who covered it up.
100%. The helper saw the little girl as his own daughter and there's no doubt he intervened. The father was enraged that his authority to beat his own daughter would be challenged and he beat the man to death and then to save his own skin he killed the only witness ; his own daughter. He then drank and him and his wife covered it all up. he didn’t want the coroner to look into any rape possibilities because it would come out that she did not get raped so this way they could continue to say that the guy had molested her or that somebody had molested her and killed her so yes in the end sadly that man was not a very good father. The way that you have assessed it 100% makes sense
@@samsamcupcakes6476 That's mostly because Hemraj was knocked unconscious with the golf club and was only slightly bleeding. Then he was dragged by the parents and some blood stains were found on the stairs leading up to the terrace. Once his body was dumped on the terrace, they slit his throat while he was in an unconscious state.
The quality of content provided is always superb! Very informative, respectful to everyone involved, and not overly dramatized. I get very excited when you post, thank you for your excellent work!
Like another comment below says, I believe the father was drunk on his whiskey and was compromising his daughter when Hemraj discovered them. Hemraj looked upon the daughter as his own daughter and may have came to her rescue inturn being killed by the father and dragged up to the terrace where he was dumped and the door remained locked. The evidence of blood trail proves he was moved up there. Also the daughter's boyfriend claimed she was having difficulty with her father leading up to this. I definitely think he was the killer and in his drunken panic chose to slay his daughter aswell so as to keep her quiet and not have his reputation tarnished. The mother too helped cover it all up
@@ryangreen45 🙄 Clearly I mean more than "difficulty". TH-cam censors anything to do with mentioning what I mean un the comments. I'll help you understand, two words; first word starts wish S and ends in exual and second word starts with A and ends in buse.
The interview that the parents did their body language is just really off to me I'm going to go ahead and say I feel that they know exactly what happened to their daughter
This is perhaps the most beautifully told documentary I've ever seen, and I'm a 51 year old guy who's been following media documentaries since my early teens. The case is a total mess, and the makers finished it off so completely by leaving the final words to Aarushi's friend Fisa(?) who so eloquently explained her feelings about the case.
I remember this news I don't know why is this still a mystery when anyone can say what really happened. Years later I still say that the father has something to do with the murder and Hemraj was a witness so he had to be silenced. I read many articles and few of them did mention that she and her father didn't see eye to eye and the day of her death her parents had few drinks before going to bed. It is really heartbreaking.
I believe parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that their daughter Aarushi and servant Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
Great video. But this is so convoluted that I had to press pause and go on Wikipedia for a few minutes just to understand and differentiate between all those names. By the end ,I was 100% convinced that it was the dad who killed them,his wife helped covered it up ,and he also probably SA his daughter and the servant was a witness to this and he had to go too. Tragic
I agree.. I think that’s what happened.. somehow the servant found out or walked in on the father doing something to his daughter and that was the only way he would be able to silence both of them. It’s the only scenario that really makes sense.
Why not the father walked in on the servant and killed them out of rage? What are the probability that the servant would walk in on dad,and the dad walking in on the servant? I think the latter is more probable. If really the mum knew and covered for him then the theory of the dad been the abuser wouldn't make much sense.
@@lumensss5869 The servant quarter is quite a distance from the main house. Also he has not been in his room through out the night and his dinner was untouched.
@@kimfoster6755 Mike is the best and I get tired of being pandered to by true crime podcasters who insert their personal/political views into the stories they tell. They can do what they like on their podcasts but if they want to alienate viewers w/unnecessary personal stuff, I'm not interested. And Mike does not do this. He has respect for ALL viewers and to the victims in the cases he presents. I💓MIKE! 🌺
@@kimfoster6755 From these comments around TH-cam I've noticed that people, and mostly women, like Mike from TC cuz he does that lovable boyish character. My theory is that it doesn't threaten them when the subject matter is very dark. TC is ok but it gets formulaic. This channel has a bit more meat to it.
I could have done a better job than these clowns at figuring out who did it. I hope they feel some deep shame at their screw ups. Good video, thanks for this
I absolutely LOVE this channel. Your videos are always top-notch every single time. Hands down you are one of the BEST true crime channels out there!!! Thank you for bringing us different cases from around the world. I wish more true crime channels would do this. Anyway, very well done and you are always so caring and professional. Thanks for all the work you put into these videos.
Dr Nupoor was my doctor as a kid. She worked in a dental clinic at Khan market in Delhi with Dr Metta. Both very good doctors having treated my grand parents, my parents and myself. I remember this case bringing shock to my whole family and me. We believe that Dr Nupoor is innocent. She was too calm and soft spoken. So kind and gentle. Same can't be said about Rajesh as we never associated with him. It's terrible what happened to the family. I hope they find peace and are doing well now
Sadly parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that their daughter Aarushi and servant Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
@@ilyaskashmiri4903How can you say something like that? Compromising position? Are you fr? Why would they kill their daughter and not just the servant. Logically that’s what any parent would do. She’s only 12. What in the disgusting hell are you saying. Hemraj has been cleared and y’all are still dragging him. The dad 100% sexually abused her and then tried to cover up his crimes. He has no emotion towards that girl.
I find it strange that some people seem to feel that this case is a complete mystery, because to me, without doubt or question, the parents are the only 2 people it could possibly be...all points & logic points right back at the parents. Although, granted, the Indian police seem to be very primitive & incompetent with the way that they investigated but still, the parents seem to be the guilty party.
The thing with Indian police is that they just catch all the possible suspects, beat them up endlessly until one of them accepts and tells the whole story, it's been happening for a long time, and this case happened in 2008 , it's been 14 yrs and there have been considerable technological advancements in the Indian police system however the brutal beating up of suspects still happens lol
No intruder came in was unanimous conclusion by all investigative teams, so it's obvious who did it. They obliterated all evidence and pinned blame on shoddy police probe. The way the parents were shying away from blaming anyone else is a give away. Not an iota of grief on their face. And look at how their service in jail, free dental care for inmates is being lauded. Is it hard to see, that press has been bought?
yes!!!! its not confusing, the confusion is about the evidence! because of lack of solid evidence, the parents were not guilty...that was the confusion.
Wow! Thank you TC crew for the hard work that each of you did to create yet another fantastic episode. I was unaware of this case. It's shocking how many people were in & near the crime scene ruining all of that important evidence & how badly the entire investigation was handled. Cringy.
finally glad that someone is covering this case. there have been many movie adaptations of this case and everytime i hear about it its just so breathtaking!
The parents claiming it was the police covering up poor handling of the case... While literally bribing police, and cleaning and contaminating the crime scene at the same time.... Who would believe that?
Watching from the United States, crazy how different each country handles murder cases. I like that this channel has a wide range of different stories from around the world also
I think the parents did it. Their behavior is just too strange and mysterious to not be involved. I think Hamraj (spelling?) walked in on something horrible happening and was killed when he decided to talk.
Hemraj met Usha Thakur social worker saying he feared for his life, just few hours before he was killed. So it wasn't a sudden walk in thing. He felt threatened from before. Usha Thakur interview videos are there on TH-cam and also she was a witness in the case to confirm the same. She had suggested him to tell his employer and police. But he didn't which means he was threatened by rajesh talwar and police would not believe a servants version over a rich owner.
Can someone confirm if I heard this right or not please So I thought I heard them say that the dad announced “look what hemrage did!” After he found his daughters body And later in an interview did the parents say they didn’t consider hemrage the suspect until the police said so? I think I misheard the interview lol
It's so shocking to see the law enforcement and forensic department in India is failing in 2008. The offender is clear and loud yet no evidence hard to consume. Documentary well articulated. Rip young girl.
Wow! You covered this like a rock star! Was on the edge of my seat the whole time! So much incompetance on the part of the police. Thanks for covering this.
One of the most baffling cases I’ve come across. Don’t want to believe that the parents could do this to their only child but the evidence points otherwise!! Truly sad..
Actually the evidence doesn’t show anything. Everything was so contaminated or misinterpreted it was screwed up from the start. The only thing that does make me wonder about them was that as doctor/dentists surely they would have understood the need for keeping the crime scene pristine but they apparently let 2 dozen people in the apartment before the police showed up. But then maybe the maid let them in and the parents were too upset to think about that
@@suekelley2109 I thought it was odd too that they let it get so chaotic. But dentist or not cultural things run deep, and death is something I find a lot of cultures, even that are very science based, throw science out the window for and it becomes very ceremonial or ritualistic if that makes sense.
You can understand how wealthy & influential 'Talvars' are by the fact that a Bollywood movie with big names was made to defend them. It's pretty clear the parents are the culprits. PS: Their only daughter was killed and they show no emotion....such poker faced criminals.
Why can't poor be criminal. In india almost all rape case convicts are poor people. How can u blame talwar family ans how can u give such a clear chit to that servant ???
@@prakashverma7053 , ??? What?? Dude, there is so much corruption in india and this is a 2008 case so why can't these rich parents give money and get their name cleared?? They tempered all the evidences almost 90% of it. And i don't know where you get this "poor people are the ones who commit crimes" thing but here that's definitely not the case.
@@Shup_bowl_ corruption didn't means that all are corrupt. They were rich because they were hard working educated people. They were not like a mafia or landlords. They were doctors. Shut up ur filthy mouth. Why do u think that uneducated people are innocent??? In most of the crimes uneducated people are involved in india, specially sex related crimes. U r judging people on the basis of their financial status. The most brutal rape case in india, which happened in Delhi in 2012, accused were drivers. Drivers, servants and other like that has been always involved in rape cases in India. What is the basis of ur argument??? Many poor men commit crime like raping his own daughter. See the facts and then speak. Shut ur mouth, when u don't know anything.
Very well covered!!! I remember this case vividly and was utterly confused with the way the media had reported this. The parents do not seem innocent at all. If I was her mum, I would be hysterical and would definitely NOT wait until the next morning…and have a chat with the maid about opening the door!
But you are not her mum. Thinking your reality should be everyone else's reality is absurd and ridiculous. People react differently emotionally to situations. Not saying she is innocent but you can't judge people's reaction on how you would have in situations.
@@sadiyasaleh233 I've lost a son. He was 6 months old when he died. It's not about 'people know about everything these days', It's about a mother not knowing where her child is and what's happened to them. I was paranoid if my son was out of my sight for more than 10 minutes. So before you start judging my seemingly 'know-it-all' comment about how a mother would usually react, look at yourself and ask if you are the ones passing judgement. Just because you want comment, kutch bhi!
The Talwar's house is barely a kilometer from my place & I literally saw it developing on a day-to-day basis. The police investigation was an embarrassment. A group of 5-7 policemen would go to the house & sit around discussing theories and betting on them. They would take their lunches inside the crime scene since it would be hot outside & they wanted AC. The Talwars are a good couple & have been giving back to society by treating patients for free for a long time. It certainly doesn't mean that they are innocent but the people who know them find it extremely hard to fathom their guilt. It's a travesty of justice brought on by our inefficient investigating agencies. I hope this case gets solved & Aarushi and Hemraj get the justice they deserve.
Pinning blame on shoddy probe, won't help, but looking through what all investigative teams concluded, might. There was no intruder entry, so where does the finger point to ?
@@param971 Intruders(krishna, rajkumar) came through terrace bcoz adjacent buildings roofs were adjoint, anybody could jump from one roof to another. Krishna was speculating stories from the beginning and also he had a jealousy with Hemraj bcoz he thought that Hemraj and Arushi were in a relationship. Investigators had matched DNA of Krishna, Rajkumar and Vijay but they didn't produce in court. Totally botched up investigation.
@@joydeepchakraborty2849 Did you watch the concluding remarks made by ex CBI director? All 3 teams unanimously concluded no intrusion occurred. Blaming servants or shoddy probe, is not going to cover the obvious. Hemraj had confided his fears, about threat to his life for knowing the family secrets. When none is left alive to tell the other side of story, it doesn't take a genius to understand who did it.
Sadly parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that their daughter Aarushi and servant Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
Anybody else find it weird that he offered to pay the police to look elsewhere? Also, anybody else look up the book to see if there was a hidden message? I watched a summary video, but didn’t see any major connection. But the title is still kinda uncanny though. 🤔 Great video BTW! ✨
I LOVE the style of the channel. It has a very documentary/TV feel, rather than just another true crime channel with too much speculation & personal feelings of the narrator/youtuber. You show respect and show its about the victims story, not about the narrator/youtuber, aka "influencer" 🙄 That's why you're the best ✌🏻❤
Two other excellent channels: Coffeehouse Crime, and This is Monsters. Always great respect shown to the victims and their families. Detailed research.
Definitely one of the very best Chanel’s covering murders on TH-cam. Thanks so much for staying true to the cases you cover without adding too much of your own feelings
One thing I've always felt strange about this incident is that 2ppl from the same house are brutally killed but parents left unharmed. The house isn't even that big for an outsider to not notice there's someone right next to the room they're killing in? Hearing about the bribe and terrace check the first time. Were these two points never brought up in court?
I find it hard to believe that two violent murders could take place in a small apartment without the parents knowledge, it's also unlikely that an outsider would fix himself a scotch before leaving the scene. Unfortunately the forensic evidence was not secured or processed correctly and any motives seem to be based only on speculation. Sherlock Holmes's definition of the truth is unfortunately not sufficient for a court of law.
Motive in my opinion should not be a necessary part of proving the case. Only the cold logic of who had the means and opportunity to both commit the crime and to cover it up afterwards. If you must have a motive then consider the motive to cover up the crime, to hide Hemraj from sight and then later to restrict access to the terrace. Who would have motive to clean the scene and the body? Only someone who owned the house. No one else would care to cover it up, they would flee and be done with it.
@@zombrero7870 I don't think motive is necessary to prove a case but I think suspects with a motive and opportunity will be looked at before those who only have opportunity. Without evidence however I think a conviction is unlikely in either case but I am not an expert, I was neither a policeman or a prosecutor.
@@shariwelch8760 Of course you are correct, That which I find hard to believe is irrelevant, gullibility varies from person to person. It's what the police and the courts believe that matters.
@@davymckeown4577 I just want you to be aware that quite a few killers have fixed themselves food and drink after murdering someone in their own home. It's a possibility, that's all.
This was a great video. The media circus and the lack of proper investigation are the main reason why this case is so much fucked up to its core. Also Indian courts work at snail pace so this case will probably still be on courts until the parents or any other possible culprits are dead. RIP Aarushi and Hemraj.
It is very strange that parents who lost their young daughter from the start were having a defensive posture instead of strongly urging the authorities to find the real culprits. Lack of emotions at the time of the incident indicates their minds were more pre-occupied with how to cover up or answer questions by the police. After seeing their daughter brutally murdered, they were expected to immediately call the police for help considering their own lives could be in danger. As part of medical profession they should been conscious and protested the contamination of the crime scene by media people having opportunity to enter the premises and contaminating the crime scene.
One of the best deep dive videos into this case I have ever seen Bravo! This is becoming my favorite TH-cam true crime channel and we know there's like 50 other good ones
The haste to cremate, the want to keep rape out of reports, the haste to clean up the evidence. Local police allowed the media also parents did not stop from contamination, these were the doctors who knew about DNA and evidences. They were more about keeping up a respectable front. I think the issue that happened was crazy media attention. And it is very easy to blame the male, poor, non Indian helpers. These people should have been the first people to make sure the evidence was there and preserved.
![[#2024MAMA] G-DRAGON - 무제(Untitled, 2014)+POWER+HOME SWEET HOME+뱅뱅뱅+FANTASTIC BABY | Mnet 241123 방송](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Ox29z5Nf1Uk/mqdefault.jpg)
Dad offering to bribe the police to search the streets instead of letting them on the terrace was the single biggest reg flag to me.
Exactly...very well spotted 👍 I was thinking the same thing. Before that the terrace door was never locked it seems. Like there were blood stains on the stairs leading up to the terrace. How can they miss that... like wtf was going on.
Did he also ask not to check if his daughter was sexually assaulted?
The police are easily bribed in India. You can get away with murder by incompetent police (bribed off). Which obviously is very bad especially if you have no money and you are looking for justice. Unfair
The father committed these murders.
@@CosmosChill7649 Couldn't agree more...this is 100% correct 👍...The police department in India is there only to serve the rich and highly influential people like corrupt politicians and they harass the poor. Hate the police here. There is nothing like an honest police officer in India.
The fact that the parents right away said Hemraj did it , asked the maid to clean the rooms while the police is still there and stopped the police from going to the terrace says so many things. The crime scene was contaminated too.
I have a theory. Considering they suspect she was raped, I think possibly the man living there (sorry bad with names) had been grooming and sexually assaulting her. He could have threatened her to say it was consensual if they were caught. On top of that, some cultures still believe that a girl/woman is just as much to blame when she’s raped and “unclean”. This has lead to male family members killing the girl/victim in the past, extremely sad and horrific. If the father found his daughter being raped, and she tried to protect her family by saying it was consensual, he could have gone into a rage and killed them both. It would explain everything, including the coverup by both him and his wife.
@@tinydream
Parents were too stoic and poised throughout. Their only daughter of 13 yrs killed so brutally. I never heard them even once, ask forcefully for Justice, for the Law to find the killers.
They were just wooden with well rehearsed and matching stories.
But when a lawyer activist knifed The Father outside the Courts, the Father started crying profusely. 😂😂😂😂
@susan ivy I strongly agree….the parents did it
@susan ivy That was the police's version. No evidence yo prove that. Only hearsay
The police did a shoddy job, no doubt about it. Looks much of the evidence was wiped out right in front of the police.
Why is it only speculated that the father caught his daughter in a compromising position? Why was it never considered that Hemraj caught Rajesh abusing his daughter? His wife said he felt fatherly towards Arushi. The boyfriend said she had been having problems with her father. If something had been going on, low-key, and that night it escalated, he, Hemraj, might have felt he needed to step in. Which led to his murder, and then Arushi‘s, in order to prevent her from spilling the beans, about the abuse and subsequent murder. That to me seems the most likely.
It is exactly what happened. He was drunk, tied to abuse her and Hemraj came to the rescue. The Dad killed them both and the Mom helped cover it up.
Yesss!!Yess!!! This is what I was thinking too. I feel like that Hemraj was killed trying to protect the poor girl. Parental SA is such a tabooh but it happens and in many places like India it is always kept so hidden. Your scenerio makes so much sense.
My thoughts exactly, why allow all those people into their house??? I'm sure they were well aware of the risk of contaminating the evidence before the police arrived.
Dayum, you just cracked it. This is a brilliant perspective, no wonder they rush for her cremation, no mention of rape, what not, this lines up.
The father obviously knew that Hemraj was dead on the balcony, because he paid for the police to not search the balcony. Your theory seems very plausible.
My heart breaks that Hemraj was vilified as the killer, only to find out that he most likely died defending her. Tragically for both victims, this case cannot ever be definitively solved due to the state of the crime scene.
Only FDP can solve this case if DNA samples are still preserved and are suitable or aarushi's reincarnation
@@knightking216Reincarnation???
@@MarlainaI think that was sarcasm lol
Things that really stand out for me and make me believe that the parents are the ones that committed the murders:
1. Blaming Hemraj from the get go, without any evidence.
2. Destroying and tampering with the evidence by allowing media and other people inside and having the crime scene cleaned up
3. Bribing the police
4. Asking to keep the mention of rape out of the autopsy report.
5. Cleaning her vagina
6. Saying they don’t want to throw any allegations on anyone and then saying it’s possible that it could be the help when they’ve already got alibis.
I have watched several videos about murders in India and in all the cases the crime scene was contaminated because a lot of people were allowed into the crime scene including family members and media were allowed in while the bodies were still laying there.
Corruption at it's finest. Arrest the parents and question later. That's India's legal system
I agree. Most plausible explanation is Rajest got angry and snapped and killed her. either he was sexually assaulting her or not. However, what i find hard to accept is a mother covering up for her husband? even after all these years? One other angle is - Hemraj's friend attacked Arushi and Hemraj was trying to help, and in the process killed. but this theory seems far fetched when parents were acting shady
@@madmax797 bruh the truth when it comes to India is that justice seldom prevails, the cops contaminated the whole crime scene , their way of solving crime is just by pointing fingers instead of hard evidence, you should come live here to see for yourself
Actually they are innocents how can someone brutally murder their only child for a moment we can take servant there are many evidences which shows they aren't culprits it was someone else only who did this and got escaped cleverly & professionally damn
So the dad killed the girl and the hired help. And he's wealthy and powerful, so couldn't be touched. Not much of a mystery there.
Exactly.
@@tangerinetangerine4400 doesnt that mean he had to rape her as well? considering the genital findings
@@tangerinetangerine4400 these wealthy doctors (her parents) were very much wealthy and liberal, they didn't believe in dishonour and all that bs, it's something else that led to her murder, no doubt the parents and complict in one way or the other but the boyfriend angle is not true
@@pranav8423 several 'wealthy' and apparently progressive people still harbour such old age views.
“Wealthy”... lol. You call this man wealthy. Look at the filthy place he lives. Is that wealth to you?😂😂
Everyone in India knows that the Dad did it, and the Mom helped cover it up, but unfortunately it cannot be proved. Its just sad. I really hope her soul is at peace. Om Shanti
Thank you for confirming what i thought after 2 minutes into the video.
No one knows, everyone only thinks they know...
I agree with you 100%
I agree and the police aided with their incompetence
Exactly you cannot sleep in the next room and do not realize what is happening in the room next to yours. If the Father was drunk The Mother atleast wasn't and she could've heard it. But both the parents made the same exact statement which shows there more to it than what they were telling. And if they wanted to pin it on Hemraj the butler, atleast his body should've been near the crime scene and not insise the Water storage tank.
I was born and raised in India and now live in the USA. I remember this case being HUGE back when I was growing up. It is still such a mystery. Thank you for doing an AMAZING job with this. We all pray that Arushi gets the justice that she deserves. There’s even a Bollywood movie made on this movie called ‘Talvar’.
Omg are all police in India this ignorant??
@@bdsaints1986... Not just
Ignorant but corrupt to the core...
Give them money 💷 and they
Will turn a blind eye...
I hope you pray that Hemraj too gets justice. Don't forget that 2 people died that day.
We all know it’s d parents….yet corruption in India at its peak…2 innocent lives were lost 😔😔 no one entered d house or left
Dad also had an affair with his co- assistant and on top of that “ MOVIE WAS MADE ON THIS TRYING TO CLEAR PARENT’s NAME🙄🙄)
Y did dad/ mom instantly took Hemraj’s name? Y not neone else? Y were arrushi’s bed was made and room was mopped ?
Thanks for letting us know new things…I never knew talwar paid LE 25,000k to not look at terrace but search outside for hemraaj….
Who wud delete d data of AARUSHI’s cell? Obviously,house helpers or others wud know how to delete it…..WE ALL KNOW,PARENTS ARE RESPONSIBLE YET INDIAN JUDICIAL SYSTEM IS MOST CORRUPTED…AND WERE BOUGHT BY DESE KILLERS 🙄🙄
Does neone know whose Bedsheet was it in which Hemraj was covered?
@@SA-yh3lb It wasn't a bedsheet. It was an air conditioning vent.
I remember this case being all over the news. When Hemraj's body was discovered in the same building, who had already been reported the prime suspect, even not knowing much about how these things work, I was shocked that the whole building hadn't been searched at the very first. The investigation of this case was so thoroughly ruined, it's a shame.
When rich and powerful are involved that's how it's investigated
Money talked parents walked! This is beyond disgusting, disturbing, and heartbreaking.
Sadly parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that their daughter Aarushi and servant Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
@@ilyaskashmiri4903 Epidemic of parents who live in a 1st century
@@ilyaskashmiri4903 Seriously ??? Arushi was 13 yr old & even if she had an affair it would be considered rape by law as she is minor... Parents could have easily lied saying Hemraj was raping my daughter so I killed the servant in anger & daughter by mistake??? They don't need to hide anything if they could get sympathy from court & less punishment. If police has contaminated crime scene then how can you say for sure outsiders have not come. The parents room had loud AC hence they couldn't hear anything. Please watch the CNA 4 part documentary on this, it'll raise so many questions on how CBI team conducted investigation & manipulated the evidence. And the servants from Nepal, Krishna is missing & has gone crazy (maybe because of guilt) & another servant Rajkumar showed body langauge signs of NPD. These 2 servants are murderers
The parents absolutely did it. No question. They lock her in her room, they don't even seemed phased by the police botching the case, they INTENTIONALLY had evidence cleaned! What innocent parents do that??
Umm not necessarily disagreeing with your opinion but her door locked from the inside and needed a key to access it from the outside. So thats why the mom had a key on her nightstand. Not the other way around.
Also, india just does things very differently. Its cultural. There were 15 people in her house when the police showed up. I imagine all family.
Like a comment from above says, I believe the father was drunk on his whiskey and was compromising his daughter when Hemraj discovered them. Hemraj looked upon the daughter as his own daughter and may have came to her rescue inturn being killed by the father and dragged up to the terrace where he was dumped and the door remained locked. The evidence of blood trail proves he was moved up there. Also the daughter's boyfriend claimed she was having difficulty with her father leading up to this. I definitely think he was the killer and in his drunken panic chose to slay his daughter aswell so as to keep her quiet and not have his reputation tarnished. The mother too helped cover it all up.
No it's the servant... The murder weapon was found from the servants house with blood all over it...
Please don't try to understand Indian people by your standards. Indians are different. Her parents were super chill and father and daughter had endless talks and discussions. India doesn't have a very sophisticated system of investigation. No crime scene expert accompanies the police. And we in India know it's a helpless system so we have learnt to just get on. I know countless people who just give up because they don't have the strength to fight a corrupt system. And the state of UP is most corrupt in India. Also Hindus believe in karma. Karma js a Hindu word. So they don't really believe in helping the justice system
I honestly feel the parents or one parent has something to do with both deaths. Hamraj (I'm sure I spelled that wrong) was killed for trying to protect the daughter. I think he walked in on her being attacked or he knew something going on in the home and felt the need to protect her but was killed in the process. And with this family's status in the community I'm sure they can cover up what really happened.
There are many theories some say the daughter was caught in a compromising position with the servant . Dad got mad killed them both and later tried to cover it .
Or the dad killed Hemraj before/after killing his daughter because he needed someone to blame. The police spent the first two days searching for Hemraj instead of thoroughly investigating the crime scene because they were convinced he was the murderer.
@@Tomatzoma I just can't see a 14 year-old girl with her upbringing having a relationship with a man in his 40s.
Actually they are innocents how can someone brutally murder their only child for a moment we can take servant there are many evidences which shows they aren't culprits it was someone else only who did this and got escaped cleverly & professionally damn
This case can be solved once we get satellite images of that night there is not one single fucking cctv footage in this case.
I remember this case, especially because I was the same age as Arushi when it happened. I remember my parents and relatives talking about the case at family dinners and outings. I recall thinking how one is not safe even in one’s own house.
What a beautiful girl Arushi was, may her soul rest in peace 💐
Yo
You should leave your home
True, I was also of same age as hers then. This is what I think.
Often times, especially where a complex crime is committed like this which involves 2 murders (related or unrelated we dont know), I cannot even trust the police report because even with all evidences, there still is 5% chance that innocent people are put in jail; as has been the case in the country in the past.
It is very rare for a rich and influential person who has committed a crime to sit behind bars, not only in India but in most countries. This is one such case. If Talwars were not the culprit, then trust me they would not have left any stone unturned to catch the actual culprits. They are intelligent people and they knew from the beginning that it is a game of evidences, and this they achieved successfully by allowing for a shoddy investigation during the first week of investigation. They had successfully executed their plan by that time and even if they were implicated still, they knew very well that evidences would never be sufficient for a long term punishment. Being both parents doctors, it can be safely assumed that they are not fools.
@@Sana-ik8fo I understand your point. Keeping in mind that one could never tell what went on in that house that night except the killers and the victims, I don’t think it’s okay to blatantly blame the parents because there was nobody else to blame. In this case, the parents were announced guilty until proven innocent, this is a direct result of having a ridiculous investigation and a joke for law enforcement. The whole case was so focused on the parents, that I don’t think they even had a chance to actually try and find the culprits. Now I don’t think the parents are innocent, all I’m saying is that the evidence could be hampered with by any party i.e., the parents, the servants/drivers, the cops, the CBI etc
It’s sad but unfortunately that’s the reality of this case that we’ll all just have to accept.
She was absolutely stunning, and she sounds like she was an amazing girl with so much promise. This is one of those cases that never leaves people's hearts...
i feel so bad for hemraj. just an honest man trying to support his family and he was killed bc of this disgusting family.
also interesting she was found with a bag covering her face. in psychology, they say if a killer covers his/her victims face its because they subconsciously feel regret or guilt. definitely the father who did it.
You said it right 🙏🙏
There has been a movie about this incident from which it is understood that the servant friends were guilty
agreed..but what about the bloody palm print on the terrace? and the footprint from a size 8-9 shoe?
@@girish1gowda bro who knows what's the real size we all are being fooled
@@sinthiyasnigdha5541 That’s a movie and other forces trying to put the blame on a dead immigrant worker. It’s always like that in our country. The poor get the brunt for what the rich do.
This case really bothered me. I was so surprised when this case was all over the news where the media was portraying arushi's character as bad and having sexual relationship with hemraj. I didn't believe it then and won't believe it now. We may never know what happened that night. Everything is messed up. RIP beautiful girl
Same, didn't add up
Only FDP can solve this case if DNA samples are still preserved and are suitable or aarushi's reincarnation
NEws in India is fucked up. How can a 14 year old have sexual relationship with a 45 year old. It will be called sexual assault in every other country because she is a minor.
Parents definitely did it. They are doctors and should have known better. After the murders they allowed the scene to be contaminated by many people. I think this was intentional. They wanted the evidence to be destroyed. I also believe the father was abusing his daughter and the helper must have heard her scream and come to her defense.
Not true, Arushi's childhood friend had said that she loved her parents
@@pranav8423 just because she loved her parents, doesn’t mean her father wasn’t abusing her
The parents deliberately compromised the crime scene.
There was one photo of her with her dad which gave me that doubt .
@@pranav8423 unfortunately that doesn’t mean that she was not being abused. Especially when the abuse starts at a very young age.
It’s absolutely ridiculous that in 2008 a police investigation should go that bad. That entire city should be ashamed of their police department and the press for bursting into the scene. I hope there were some serious changes in policy after this. With the dna advances at that time this should have been a solved case. The terrace being locked and not investigated was outrageous. I’m so mad they were so brutally murdered in such a sloppily way and still did not get any justice. Boy they just arrest people without any evidence. Plus giving people a truth serum. I’m so mad. It’s like ok it was the parents. Wait no. Ok maybe. No not them. Ok yes it must have been. Well…
Although there have been some improvements in laws around the country, sadly Police's approach to solving cases has not improved much, specifically in the state of Uttar Pradesh where this murder took place, it remains a State with one of the highest crime rates in the country specifically sexual crimes against women.
"The terrace being locked and not investigated was outrageous"
But muh 25,000 Rupees
@Nick Young I have watched a lot of videos on this channel and there is a stark contrast in how such cases are handled in developed vs developing countries. Delayed action is so common that it's a norm here. In cases from US and Europe I see police rushing to secure the crime scene and preserve every single piece of forensic and DNA evidence and still sometimes struggle to find the actual criminals. In our country, media and huge crowds will reach before the police to get those first pictures. Cases being solved by DNA evidence is a rare occurrence.
@Nick Young yes I watch this channel all the time and it’s so frustrating watching the ones that are not investigated well or when they to long to respond. I really wanted justice for these two.
@@iamitsk that’s terrible. I hope one day it does improve.
"oh hey our daughter was murdered but you can all come and contaminate the crime scene, don't break any doors to find the murderer or the weapon." They are diabolical. And they waited for the maid to see their dead daughter?
My gut tells me that the mother was in fact waiting for the maid to come, she led her in,and actually waited for her to tell the neighbours. I think it was this way. I found it weird, unnatural. Even later mom.was deadpan.
@@seemamenon9897 they both had their arms crossed during the interviews. They were being defensive instead of indulging.
The parents are pathetic. "We don't want to blame anyone". No tears, nothing. That dame has her arms crossed, talking about how they cry at night. Two people's throats slit, and they "have nothing".
Ya'll really know how to tell a story, thank you so much. Rest in Peace, Arushi.
I won’t have tears! The tears will be constant & private!!!!
This case can be solved once we get satellite images of that night there is not one single fucking cctv footage in this case.
They cannot accept that they killed their daughter becoz she was found in a compromising position with his man servant as ppl will character assasinate their daughter so they have to hide the truth that they killed the daughter all their lives.....
@@kashif9145They also didn’t allow the police to search the home and contaminated the crime scene. They were super uncooperative. It’s odd behavior in addition to their emotional state where they don’t show any sort of sympathy for their daughter.
@@ilyaskashmiri4903No. He was completely innocent and absolved of everything. I suspect the father. He hid so much information and was so double sided in what he said and what was happening. He wasn’t honest when it was such a dire situation. He definitely did something and the servant saw something.
I have been following Arushi - Hemraj murder case from day 1 and from what I have observed and understood so far the parents are the culprits. They may perhaps escape the human legal system due to a lack of so-called evidence, which was undoubtedly botched up. But they would never escape God's judgment, it comes late though.
they will 1 day receive the wrath of the god Vishnu.
Only FDP can solve this case if DNA samples are still preserved and are suitable or aarushi's reincarnation
Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that Aarushi and Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
No the guy who called from PCO was the real killer. I have investigated every possible angle and studied this case for many years. It was the deed of any outsider who very cunningly entered the flat dodging the security guards probably climbed the walls or any other way entered the flat, met Hemraj, and then whatever reason killed him and arushi.
That aunt seemed more worried about the injustice towards the parents than the injustice towards Aarushi and Hemraj, the real victims.
Because I was most likely an honor killing that's the only thing that could make sense why the family was soo eager to protect the parents
@@NellyMacharia no you want to really know why? Because it's even WORSE than an honor killing to EVEN THINK that an Indian father could be molesting his own daughter. This is a subject which Indians HATE to bring up. It happens, yet they like to pretend it doesn't.....
Thank you for shedding light on this case. The father stopping the search of the terrace with a clear bribe to Police throws up enough red flags. Shame that the evidence was tampered so that justice cannot be properly served. May they rest in peace
I remember that I joined Facebook to know more about this case. It was so mysterious and still is. I believe this would go unsolved and the only person who would know the full truth would be those who committed this crime.
Rip to Hemraj though. His death is nothing but a foot note in this grand family media court drama focusing on the talvers.
I’ve watched pretty much all your content, and I must say, this is probably the best video you’ve made. Love the effort and research you put into your work
I agree. I also thought the video on Ricardo Lopez was just perfect. That one gave me chills the way they edited everything, flawless.
The contradictory part here is that the parents never called the police a neighbor asked the security of the gated community to call the police and by that time all evidence was contaminated or destroyed. When the police arrived on the crime scene there were 12-15 people in the house. Even the forensic policeman collecting evidence said most of the fingerprints had been smudged comprised. Rajesh Pointing to hemraj as the murderer was justified as he was missing.
Sab vaasta ki baat hai, such people have connection in high up places and one phone call can change the story. Their daughter has died in a mysterious way and they are requesting the Post Mortem doctors not to mention rape? They could not protect the daughter, but worry about family honour which to me is also suspicious. Poor arushi just lay there in her bed and died taking the truth with her. See the nirbhaya case - it happened in delhi, 4 hanged - their backgrounds were dalit etc etc basically they were poor. See Talwar case - again in delhi - 50 days in prison and out with no evidence to prove they were innocent, let loose on emotional grounds cause parents cant do it. Look at the Sheena Bora case - that mother of hers is doing womens rights or jail rights from her cell...no remorse. Crimes happen at every level.....but the rope is too weak for the people with contacts. This was either an honour killing, or a case of sexual abuse by the father which was seen by hemraj. Arushi had to die as she might have given away who killed hemraj and why. Alot goes on in regular families that is never revealed, but nothing is impossible.
@@TheLotussong "50 days in prison and out with no evidence to prove they were innocent"...i guess in backward societies the normal rule of law doesnt apply, where you are innocent unless proven guilty (and not the other way around)
@@MrRisingapple There is no backward or forward here, its all about money and connections and that applies everywhere. When was the last time a rich criminal hanged in india? Crimes are happening but they either sit in airconditioned jail cells with full facilities till the law finds a way to prove them innocent - or they fly off to dubai. The law is for the poor and uneducated . So whether one is guilty till proven innocent or innocent till proven guilty - just remains in the books. Less or more , this happens worldwide. Arushis parents have the answer, but they wont speak,all fingers point at the servants and helpers.
Often times, especially where a complex crime is committed like this which involves 2 murders (related or unrelated we dont know), I cannot even trust the police report because even with all evidences, there still is 5% chance that innocent people are put in jail; as has been the case in India in the past.
It is very rare for a rich and influential person who has committed a crime to sit behind bars, not only in India but in most countries. This is one such case. If Talwars were not the culprit, then trust me they would not have left any stone unturned to catch the actual culprits. They are intelligent people and they knew from the beginning that it is a game of evidences, and this they achieved successfully by allowing for a shoddy investigation during the first week of investigation. They had successfully executed their plan by that time and even if they were implicated still, they knew very well that evidences would never be sufficient for a long term punishment. Being both parents doctors, it can be safely assumed that they are not fools.
Actually they are innocents how can someone brutally murder their only child for a moment we can take servant there are many evidences which shows they aren't culprits it was someone else only who did this and got escaped cleverly & professionally damn
Thank you for professional coverage of these cases. No drama, no out of taste jokes just retelling of the story and known facts.
This case for me has always equated to the Jon Benet Ramsey case. A child dead, in a house with limited people at the time and in both cases the crime scene was tampered with, rooms/terrace in this case were locked/not allowed access to. Both cases educated and well placed parents invited support who in turn formed early conclusions and helped knowingly or unknowingly with the contamination and clean up of the scene.
It's sad this case will like the Job Benet one, may never see the light of justice.
Very true, there are a lot of similarities here.
i was about to saythe same thing
Agreed!
Exactly
Yes you're right
I’d never heard of this case but with your narration, I was hooked. Thank you for taking the time to cover cases outside the Uk& USA.
( love it) Only 4 people in a very small apartment 2 murdered so violently , 2 survived and didt hear a thing🙄yes the police did an awful job protecting evidence …. But the Parents did it and now they are free😡 No justice here!!
You should watch the movie “talwar” Its about this case. Then you’ll understand what actually happened
@@jyotsnasharma6180 ok… will do😀
@@jyotsnasharma6180 its only a movie, not a real stuff...
@@jyotsnasharma6180 Bollywood is now exposed as Gutterwood.! Nexus of criminals. Can we yrust them to bring out the truth? The parents never asked for Justice for their daughter. Hemraj told his friends his life was in danger.
@@jyotsnasharma6180'Talwar' is a commercial movie. It's a fictional account and is biased. In order to absolve the parents, the movie depicts the investigation and the police officers who blamed the parents as inefficient, corrupt and as jokers. Moreover, one of India's finest actors, late Irrfan Khan was roped in to play the officer who concluded that the parents were innocent victims of a media trial and botched investigation. So, please talk about facts and not some Bollywood propoganda movie! Thanks.
My relatives lives in the same society and I remember how she told me while we were talking a walk that this is the house of Arushi. And at that time all those memories of what media told us about Arushi came back .
Even if Parents are not the murderers they have played a major role in destroying the evidence . As doctors themselves they had better known that this is a murder scene which is not supposed to be tampered with anything.
Only FDP can solve this case if DNA samples are still preserved and are suitable or aarushi's reincarnation
Sadly Rajesh and Nupur Talwat cannot accept the truth publicly that Aarushi and Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
This was definitely NO WICH HUNT, the evidence was 100% compromised with the 100% help from the parents, and any evidence left ONLY points to dad NO ONE ELSE. Mom 100% covered for dad. They deserve to be locked up for life and I pray they NEVER rest and that what they did haunts them for the rest of their lives, may they NOT find joy or pleasure or rest. Absolutely disgusting.
What an incredible video. You guys really are the cream of this genre. It’s so professionally put together and impeccably narrated. I so wish I could work on these videos with you!!!
You are sheer class ❤️
Absolutely! Lots of work went into putting this together, I'm sure.
I’m a true crime fanatic, & I totally agree. They’re the best of the best. Seriously, they’re in my top 5. Being #1 🤣🥰 whenever they post a video, I’m so excited to watch. The way she narrates clearly, gives ample & thorough amount of detail, & just all in all tells the story in a way I just totally enjoy lol it’s THE BEST 💕
Agreed!
Parents did it....just not enough evidence. Plain and simple.
Thank YOU!
Good grief! How badly the police botched this is beyond comprehension. Zero justice in this case.
The accused father was said to bribe the police to botch up the case to protect dignity of her daughter......
Drugging people up and interrogating them to me doesn't seem to be fruitful especially after they all previously had knowledge of the details just a thought but i will say this was a very well done episode and this is definitely one of my favorite channels
Right?! How could you believe anything said by someone in that state, that was totally absurd.
But hey, free drugs :D
Drugged so hard she was slapping the guy in the face while shouting questions at him. Damn
Sodium pentothal would never work in this manner l agree because they fed all 3 the crime details so of course they would or could speak about them whilst mixing in thoughts already in their memories. That's exactly what one of them did although he wasn't able to give the details that they needed that were not fed to him to begin with. Precisely why he was given the med in the first place.
Agreed that went out in the 1960’s
The body language in the interview with the parents says it all. Especially the mom leaning farther and farther away from the dad. The crossed arms. All defensiveness.
I did not watch the whole episode but am aware of what I had read in newspapers/ watched on TV those days. Many questions remain unanswered.
1. Arushi and Hemraj's throats were slit by a surgically trained person and in both cases, the jugular veins were cut. Only a doctor would know how to cut the jugular vein. Initially, Hemraj and other male house help were blamed for the murder. House helps do not have to be 'surgically trained' to chop veggies!
2. As doctors why did the parents not preserve the victim's viscera? They did know that the viscera report would have nailed the culprit.
3. Why the hush-hush cremation the next morning and immediate ash imersion without informing the police, family, and friends?
4. Who cleaned up the victim's private parts? Except for the parents, there was no third person in the house. Why did they clean her up? As doctors, the parents knew how to get rid of evidence to protect the murderer. The parents ensured to clean up all evidence ASAP including cremation.
5. None bothered to check the incest angle.
6. While the investigation was going on (TV), the mother did not break down even once. How is that possible? The daughter was born 10 years after marriage (according to newspapers) and was the only child? I am aware that some women can be tough but how can one not feel for an only child who was born after 10 years of marriage? Personally, I find it strange.
7. The mother did break down finally when she was sentenced with her husband. She broke down again while she was being interviewed inside the jail. I find it bizarre. A woman who did not cry when her only teen daughter is brutally murdered cried because she was convicted.
8. Do not recollect any boyfriend angle in the case.
9. The flat is not so huge that while two murders were being committed, one body was dragged to the terrace after opening the locked gate, and the parents continued to sleep soundly? Find it difficult to digest.
10. I often think about the kid and pray she gets justice and the murderers are caught and put behind for life. You cannot kill a kid full of life and forget about it.
11. Why are the parents not pursuing the case and seeking justice for the brutal murder of their only child? Heartless parents!
This is an excellent analisis!
Parents were suspecting something odd that made them to suspect that their own child would have been hiding from them; It was said that their daughter changed in those days. Probably, the child told her parents about someone was sexually abusing her and she named it. Parents could promised their daughter that nothing was going to happen to her that they needed her to help them to caught the one who was sexually abusing her. OR her parents wanted to caught them in that sexual act. Mother didn't lock her room's door, while her child was asleep or pretending being asleep, so she could not lock the door from inside..... A gross honor killing indeed!
Its the parents, everyone knows but no solid evidence to charge them...its so sad..all the evidences was tampered. I rightfully agree with all your points, I also feel bad for Hemraj, he was an innocent house help, but had to die in the tragic way possible. Hemraj used to work there , stay far away from home and own family. Both the victims didn't deserve to die this way...the young girl had miles to go. And as you said the mother broke down when they were being charged in the first place for the murder.. that's the perk of a sociopath..I think the parents are absolute sociopaths to murder their own daughter and then cover it up that too very minutely...they have cleared the crime scene just like a psychopath.
Wow❤
Sad her mother went through a bunch of ivf treatments to conceive her daughter only to allow her to be killed by her father later in life. Makes no sense.
Arushi was Rajesh's step daughter, I think I read this somewhere in a news article.
@@wink7779 incorrect. Rajesh and Nupur met at Maulana Azad Medical College in Delhi and married in 1990. Aarushi was born four years later. you have mixed up Sheena Bora case or some other with this.
Drug a suspect and then slap them silly when they are subsequently unfit to he interviews, really professional. It’s a really shame this case wasn’t handed in a more professional matter, this is not justice for a sweet young girl.
I have always wondered about this case and still do. Please cover the case of Ayesha Meera, a girl from Vijayawada, Andhra Pradesh who was brutally murdered in the girls hostel with at least 100 people in the same hostel but had not been solved conclusively.
Has any TH-cam channel covered this case , in hindi or english ??? Coz i never heard abt it n would like to watch
@@nevereverigoteyesonyou8377 you would be shocked by the police's handling of the case and twists in the story. I wish I could find a channel which covered it with all the details. It's such a dark case and it haunts many people to this day.
@@tippusultan8173 is there any documentary made on this on TH-cam?? if yes please help where can I know about this case.
And yes!! there are so many criminal cases still unsolved and inconclusive because of lack of solid evidence and contamination of crime scene!! its sad reality.
@@Redwoodtree34567 I tried but I find mostly news reports and inaccurate news and videos . I will try again and will let you know. Her name is Ayesha Meera. Please search it by her name Ayesha Meera murder case.
Was that the model with the bright green eyes? Set-up like she ended her own life but her friend was shady af
It's really scary to know that there is still a person out there who knows he killed them both and exactly what happened that night. While all the fingers/proofs point to the parents, the questions are yet unanswered. I pray whether out of guilty conscience or whatever reason, that murderer comes out and accepts what he did to these two innocent souls. RIP Arushi and Hemraj.
This case can be solved once we get satellite images of that night there is not one single fucking cctv footage in this case.
@@knightking216 exactly 💯
Only FDP can solve this case if DNA samples are still preserved and are suitable or aarushi's reincarnation
@@knightking216 You do know satellite images are not very detailed or clear right?
They take photos miles away from earth in space, do you really think it’s gonna identify a tiny person sneaking into a house / killing a girl in her bedroom?
The father was SA his daughter. Probably doing so for years. Went to do so that night, got caught out by the poor housekeeper, Hemraj. Out of panic, killed him with the first thing in sight, the bottle. Then finished off his own daughter as she was a witness. The wife was in on it, cleaned up the crime scene and their daughters body. Both of them dragged Hemraj’s body up to the terrace and both work together to cover up themselves. They would rather kill and cover up than expose themselves and ruin their reputations since they were well known doctors in the community. They knew that inviting many into the crime scene will botch the investigation. Absolutely sickening. All that effort to have a child and they do this to her and their housekeeper. Sickening
I believe parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that their daughter Aarushi and servant Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
@@ilyaskashmiri4903That theory doesn’t make sense and it sounds like you’re defending the parents.
The father did so much suspicious acts: 1.) redirecting investigations away from where the decomposing body of male house keeper was, 2.) asking someone to lie about SA in the coroner’s report. He can’t escape the consequences of the truth forever that’s for sure!
Often times, especially where a complex crime is committed like this which involves 2 murders (related or unrelated we dont know), I cannot even trust the police report because even with all evidences, there still is 5% chance that innocent people are put in jail; as has been the case in India.
It is very rare for a rich and influential person who has committed a crime to sit behind bars, not only in India but in most countries. This is one such case. If Talwars were not the culprit, then trust me they would not have left any stone unturned to catch the actual culprits. They are intelligent people and they knew from the beginning that it is a game of evidences, and this they achieved successfully by allowing for a shoddy investigation during the first week of investigation. They had successfully executed their plan by that time and even if they were implicated still, they knew very well that evidences would never be sufficient for a long term punishment. Being both parents doctors, it can be safely assumed that they are not fools.
@@Sana-ik8fo They werent smart enough. Plenty of true crime cases with rich and smart people getting caught.
Actually they are innocents how can someone brutally murder their only child for a moment we can take servant there are many evidences which shows they aren't culprits it was someone else only who did this and got escaped cleverly & professionally damn
Sadly Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that Aarushi and Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
This is a case study on how badly the cops, media and corruption could botch a case. This case was so widely covered on the media when it has just happened, as if this was a reality show. The smallest detail would become breaking news.
Very well covered, this gives better closure to a lot of us who did not know the other details the media did not reveal.
💯exactly , the sheer incompetence and corruption of the police has effectively helped killers get away with 2murders
botched up or neatly covered up
@@suman-by7gt Or messily covered up.
CBI.. Clearly Bullshit Investigation
Just like Jon Benet Ramsey in the US. Sad
I've watched too much true crime on YT.... only just came across this channel but the depth you go into and clarity is top notch 👍 well done peeps
I hope I'm never accused of a crime in India. I've never seen police, medical investigators, etc. like that. It was like they were pretending to be cops. What kind of press conference was that?
Undeveloped country's cops, sadly.
@@n0odles86 it is ranked in 40s in democracy index
Yes we have seen how police are always morally exemplary in other countries like sarah everard in london or george floyd in usa or lock up deaths in aborginals in australia etc eh ?
@@n0odles86 who did george floyd's murder and countless other crimes in usa
💯 the Dad is the main culprit for both murders. Can’t believe all evidence was tampered and contaminated with! Why were the police so careless? 🤷🏻♀️ The parents interview was simply one of the most cold blooded and calculated without showing any emotions. How can such parents that fully know their child has been brutally murdered sit there and speak like as if she didn’t matter much to them! Shocking! Totally shocking!!
Here's my thought. The parents had an inkling about her boyfriend and didn't want her to chat with him. Hence, they wanted to turn off the wifi router. And Aarushi turned it back on and started chatting , when her dad came to know about this he started hitting her in rage only to be intervened by Hemraj. This angered Rajesh Talwar and in a fit of rage killed Hemraj in front of Arushi. Fearing she will spill the beans, he killed her too to save his image in society. Then dragged out Hemraj's body and his wife played the role of an accomplice and opened the terrace door while Rajesh was dragging the domestic help's body. Dumped his body upstairs and locked the terrace door. Came back to their apartment and Rajesh went and started to drink whiskey, while his wife placed those toys on the mattress and lowered her daughter's pants exposing her rear to make it look like she was sexually assaulted by Hemraj. Then both of them cleaned the house removing their fingerprints. In the morning when the maid arrived, Rajesh calls the maid to Aarushi's room and showing her tells," look what he has done to her". Who on earth does that? He just wanted to pin the blame on Hemraj and have people believe that he did it, so maid will spread the rumour to people. The verdict is the dad killed them both, the mother an accomplice who covered it up.
100%. The helper saw the little girl as his own daughter and there's no doubt he intervened. The father was enraged that his authority to beat his own daughter would be challenged and he beat the man to death and then to save his own skin he killed the only witness ; his own daughter. He then drank and him and his wife covered it all up.
he didn’t want the coroner to look into any rape possibilities because it would come out that she did not get raped so this way they could continue to say that the guy had molested her or that somebody had molested her and killed her so yes in the end sadly that man was not a very good father. The way that you have assessed it 100% makes sense
Well said! Who tells their house help “come, look what HemRaj has done?” Instead of calling an ambulance? The parents are 100% guilty.
But why didn't they find anything, any blood from Hemraj?
@@SanketKulkarni10 yeaaaa so true
@@samsamcupcakes6476 That's mostly because Hemraj was knocked unconscious with the golf club and was only slightly bleeding. Then he was dragged by the parents and some blood stains were found on the stairs leading up to the terrace. Once his body was dumped on the terrace, they slit his throat while he was in an unconscious state.
Everyone here in India knows the parents did it
May Aarushi and Hemraj's soul rest in peace
😉
I am indian but don't believe anything the media tells me. Maybe I'm smart.
@@sanky1211 A smart person calling himself smart
Smartness at it's peak
Yes, you are right.
@@techmania5957 would you accept that you are foolish?
The quality of content provided is always superb! Very informative, respectful to everyone involved, and not overly dramatized.
I get very excited when you post, thank you for your excellent work!
Horrible how uncontrolled the crime scene was, but touching to see how fiercely the community rallied for justice for Aarushi.
Incredible video, looks like the video about the Talwar case was made more professionally than the actual investigation about the case.
Like another comment below says, I believe the father was drunk on his whiskey and was compromising his daughter when Hemraj discovered them. Hemraj looked upon the daughter as his own daughter and may have came to her rescue inturn being killed by the father and dragged up to the terrace where he was dumped and the door remained locked. The evidence of blood trail proves he was moved up there. Also the daughter's boyfriend claimed she was having difficulty with her father leading up to this. I definitely think he was the killer and in his drunken panic chose to slay his daughter aswell so as to keep her quiet and not have his reputation tarnished. The mother too helped cover it all up
a teenager having difficulty with her father, that's something I've never heard before
Sounds plausible.
@@ryangreen45 🙄
Clearly I mean more than "difficulty". TH-cam censors anything to do with mentioning what I mean un the comments. I'll help you understand, two words; first word starts wish S and ends in exual and second word starts with A and ends in buse.
@@dcsc1 All speculations.
@@ryangreen45 he never said it wasn't speculation. That's why the word "believe" was used. I'm glad you added so much to the OP's speculation though.
The interview that the parents did their body language is just really off to me I'm going to go ahead and say I feel that they know exactly what happened to their daughter
Agree
even the interviewer is not convinced...he keeps cutting them
This is perhaps the most beautifully told documentary I've ever seen, and I'm a 51 year old guy who's been following media documentaries since my early teens. The case is a total mess, and the makers finished it off so completely by leaving the final words to Aarushi's friend Fisa(?) who so eloquently explained her feelings about the case.
What a story. And again I’d like to thank your amazing channel for bringing such a case to our attention. Amazing work guys ❤️
I remember this news I don't know why is this still a mystery when anyone can say what really happened. Years later I still say that the father has something to do with the murder and Hemraj was a witness so he had to be silenced. I read many articles and few of them did mention that she and her father didn't see eye to eye and the day of her death her parents had few drinks before going to bed. It is really heartbreaking.
Only FDP can solve this case if DNA samples are still preserved and are suitable or aarushi's reincarnation
I believe parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that their daughter Aarushi and servant Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
Great video. But this is so convoluted that I had to press pause and go on Wikipedia for a few minutes just to understand and differentiate between all those names. By the end ,I was 100% convinced that it was the dad who killed them,his wife helped covered it up ,and he also probably SA his daughter and the servant was a witness to this and he had to go too. Tragic
I agree.. I think that’s what happened.. somehow the servant found out or walked in on the father doing something to his daughter and that was the only way he would be able to silence both of them. It’s the only scenario that really makes sense.
Lumens I agreed with you fully.
Why not the father walked in on the servant and killed them out of rage? What are the probability that the servant would walk in on dad,and the dad walking in on the servant? I think the latter is more probable. If really the mum knew and covered for him then the theory of the dad been the abuser wouldn't make much sense.
@@sadiyasaleh233 maybe is was not as much as 'walking in ' on someone. Perhaps she screamed or something and the servant heard.
@@lumensss5869
The servant quarter is quite a distance from the main house. Also he has not been in his room through out the night and his dinner was untouched.
This is, hands down, my favorite true crime channel. Even beats TC and many others. Thank you for the amazing content!
That Chapter is my favorite, is my this is my second. I just love Mike so much. ❤️🤗
TC is assssssss. So overrated
@@kimfoster6755 Mike is the best and I get tired of being pandered to by true crime podcasters who insert their personal/political views into the stories they tell. They can do what they like on their podcasts but if they want to alienate viewers w/unnecessary personal stuff, I'm not interested. And Mike does not do this. He has respect for ALL viewers and to the victims in the cases he presents. I💓MIKE! 🌺
TC and JCS have their signature content,. but this channel also good,..
@@kimfoster6755 From these comments around TH-cam I've noticed that people, and mostly women, like Mike from TC cuz he does that lovable boyish character.
My theory is that it doesn't threaten them when the subject matter is very dark.
TC is ok but it gets formulaic.
This channel has a bit more meat to it.
I could have done a better job than these clowns at figuring out who did it. I hope they feel some deep shame at their screw ups. Good video, thanks for this
Honestly, I bet it was more of a cover up than a screw up.
Money played important role here
Our government has no spine or ethics to begin with.
I absolutely LOVE this channel. Your videos are always top-notch every single time. Hands down you are one of the BEST true crime channels out there!!! Thank you for bringing us different cases from around the world. I wish more true crime channels would do this. Anyway, very well done and you are always so caring and professional. Thanks for all the work you put into these videos.
Try MrBallen channel.
Thank me later
Dr Nupoor was my doctor as a kid. She worked in a dental clinic at Khan market in Delhi with Dr Metta. Both very good doctors having treated my grand parents, my parents and myself. I remember this case bringing shock to my whole family and me. We believe that Dr Nupoor is innocent. She was too calm and soft spoken. So kind and gentle. Same can't be said about Rajesh as we never associated with him. It's terrible what happened to the family. I hope they find peace and are doing well now
Sadly parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that their daughter Aarushi and servant Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
@@ilyaskashmiri4903How can you say something like that? Compromising position? Are you fr? Why would they kill their daughter and not just the servant. Logically that’s what any parent would do. She’s only 12. What in the disgusting hell are you saying. Hemraj has been cleared and y’all are still dragging him. The dad 100% sexually abused her and then tried to cover up his crimes. He has no emotion towards that girl.
I find it strange that some people seem to feel that this case is a complete mystery, because to me, without doubt or question, the parents are the only 2 people it could possibly be...all points & logic points right back at the parents. Although, granted, the Indian police seem to be very primitive & incompetent with the way that they investigated but still, the parents seem to be the guilty party.
The thing with Indian police is that they just catch all the possible suspects, beat them up endlessly until one of them accepts and tells the whole story, it's been happening for a long time, and this case happened in 2008 , it's been 14 yrs and there have been considerable technological advancements in the Indian police system however the brutal beating up of suspects still happens lol
I just think indian police is capable of they want to be.. n most of the times they are corrupted or act like they r incompetent
No intruder came in was unanimous conclusion by all investigative teams, so it's obvious who did it. They obliterated all evidence and pinned blame on shoddy police probe. The way the parents were shying away from blaming anyone else is a give away. Not an iota of grief on their face. And look at how their service in jail, free dental care for inmates is being lauded. Is it hard to see, that press has been bought?
yes!!!! its not confusing, the confusion is about the evidence! because of lack of solid evidence, the parents were not guilty...that was the confusion.
How can they kill there only child which they got after so many years of ivf
Wow! Thank you TC crew for the hard work that each of you did to create yet another fantastic episode. I was unaware of this case. It's shocking how many people were in & near the crime scene ruining all of that important evidence & how badly the entire investigation was handled. Cringy.
finally glad that someone is covering this case. there have been many movie adaptations of this case and everytime i hear about it its just so breathtaking!
The parents claiming it was the police covering up poor handling of the case... While literally bribing police, and cleaning and contaminating the crime scene at the same time.... Who would believe that?
Watching from the United States, crazy how different each country handles murder cases. I like that this channel has a wide range of different stories from around the world also
This is your best video yet. The length was perfect...not just a tease...a good in depth documentary. Thank you
This case has so many questions that will never be answered. There is an Hindi Movie Named Talwar if anyone is interested to watch that too
Yeah, it was a really great movie!
I think the parents did it. Their behavior is just too strange and mysterious to not be involved. I think Hamraj (spelling?) walked in on something horrible happening and was killed when he decided to talk.
Hemraj.
And I think you might be right
@@emiliasanchez3637 Thank you for the spelling correction! I'm sad to say, but I can't believe that was never a theory.
Hemraj met Usha Thakur social worker saying he feared for his life, just few hours before he was killed. So it wasn't a sudden walk in thing. He felt threatened from before. Usha Thakur interview videos are there on TH-cam and also she was a witness in the case to confirm the same. She had suggested him to tell his employer and police. But he didn't which means he was threatened by rajesh talwar and police would not believe a servants version over a rich owner.
Can someone confirm if I heard this right or not please
So I thought I heard them say that the dad announced “look what hemrage did!” After he found his daughters body
And later in an interview did the parents say they didn’t consider hemrage the suspect until the police said so?
I think I misheard the interview lol
It's so shocking to see the law enforcement and forensic department in India is failing in 2008. The offender is clear and loud yet no evidence hard to consume. Documentary well articulated. Rip young girl.
The only words that keep running through my mind is “what a mess”!
I hope the police learned a lesson. Unfortunately for the victims.
This is absolutely your best video yet. Brilliant work, thanks so much x
Doesn’t take a genius to figure out who was involved in this crime. So sad little angel rest in peace both of you.
Well I must be an absolute simpleton because I haven't got the foggiest idea as to who did it.
@@therealruckus5263 🤣🤣
@@therealruckus5263 the father
Only FDP can solve this case if DNA samples are still preserved and are suitable or aarushi's reincarnation
I was really young when I first saw this on the news. I didn't think even after so many years this case would still be unsolved.
Wow! You covered this like a rock star! Was on the edge of my seat the whole time! So much incompetance on the part of the police. Thanks for covering this.
One of the most baffling cases I’ve come across. Don’t want to believe that the parents could do this to their only child but the evidence points otherwise!! Truly sad..
I know, but why, after spending so much money on IVF and clearly wanting her badly? It just doesn't make sense.
Actually the evidence doesn’t show anything. Everything was so contaminated or misinterpreted it was screwed up from the start. The only thing that does make me wonder about them was that as doctor/dentists surely they would have understood the need for keeping the crime scene pristine but they apparently let 2 dozen people in the apartment before the police showed up. But then maybe the maid let them in and the parents were too upset to think about that
@@suekelley2109 I thought it was odd too that they let it get so chaotic. But dentist or not cultural things run deep, and death is something I find a lot of cultures, even that are very science based, throw science out the window for and it becomes very ceremonial or ritualistic if that makes sense.
@@temp_unknown the documentary actually leaves out a lot of other things..go to Reddit, you'll find them
Only FDP can solve this case if DNA samples are still preserved and are suitable or aarushi's reincarnation
You can understand how wealthy & influential 'Talvars' are by the fact that a Bollywood movie with big names was made to defend them. It's pretty clear the parents are the culprits.
PS: Their only daughter was killed and they show no emotion....such poker faced criminals.
Why can't poor be criminal. In india almost all rape case convicts are poor people. How can u blame talwar family ans how can u give such a clear chit to that servant ???
@@prakashverma7053 , ??? What?? Dude, there is so much corruption in india and this is a 2008 case so why can't these rich parents give money and get their name cleared?? They tempered all the evidences almost 90% of it. And i don't know where you get this "poor people are the ones who commit crimes" thing but here that's definitely not the case.
@@Shup_bowl_ corruption didn't means that all are corrupt. They were rich because they were hard working educated people. They were not like a mafia or landlords. They were doctors. Shut up ur filthy mouth. Why do u think that uneducated people are innocent??? In most of the crimes uneducated people are involved in india, specially sex related crimes. U r judging people on the basis of their financial status. The most brutal rape case in india, which happened in Delhi in 2012, accused were drivers. Drivers, servants and other like that has been always involved in rape cases in India. What is the basis of ur argument??? Many poor men commit crime like raping his own daughter. See the facts and then speak. Shut ur mouth, when u don't know anything.
A whole hour?!? Thank you I love your voice and how you tell the stories of these victims who can no longer tell their own stories.
so sad man! what a beautiful young lady she had so much to live for! absolutely sad! 🥺
I just really found this channel and now I’m obsessed. I don’t know if I should thank you or to cry. Lol. Great job!!!
Very well covered!!! I remember this case vividly and was utterly confused with the way the media had reported this. The parents do not seem innocent at all. If I was her mum, I would be hysterical and would definitely NOT wait until the next morning…and have a chat with the maid about opening the door!
I completely agree. No parent EVER would do that!
But you are not her mum. Thinking your reality should be everyone else's reality is absurd and ridiculous. People react differently emotionally to situations. Not saying she is innocent but you can't judge people's reaction on how you would have in situations.
@@sadiyasaleh233 well said ! Ppl seem to know everything dis days 🙄
@@sadiyasaleh233 then Why did dad bribe the police?
@@sadiyasaleh233 I've lost a son. He was 6 months old when he died. It's not about 'people know about everything these days', It's about a mother not knowing where her child is and what's happened to them. I was paranoid if my son was out of my sight for more than 10 minutes. So before you start judging my seemingly 'know-it-all' comment about how a mother would usually react, look at yourself and ask if you are the ones passing judgement. Just because you want comment, kutch bhi!
Thank you so much for covering this case! You're the only crime reporter channel that covers a vast array of diverse cases! Thank you so much!
The Talwar's house is barely a kilometer from my place & I literally saw it developing on a day-to-day basis. The police investigation was an embarrassment. A group of 5-7 policemen would go to the house & sit around discussing theories and betting on them. They would take their lunches inside the crime scene since it would be hot outside & they wanted AC.
The Talwars are a good couple & have been giving back to society by treating patients for free for a long time. It certainly doesn't mean that they are innocent but the people who know them find it extremely hard to fathom their guilt. It's a travesty of justice brought on by our inefficient investigating agencies.
I hope this case gets solved & Aarushi and Hemraj get the justice they deserve.
Pinning blame on shoddy probe, won't help, but looking through what all investigative teams concluded, might. There was no intruder entry, so where does the finger point to ?
@@param971 even to the extent bribing the police to go search the street instead of the terrace.
The dad did it, just shows how closed minded you are. The filthy rat and the mum are free. Disgraceful
@@param971 Intruders(krishna, rajkumar) came through terrace bcoz adjacent buildings roofs were adjoint, anybody could jump from one roof to another. Krishna was speculating stories from the beginning and also he had a jealousy with Hemraj bcoz he thought that Hemraj and Arushi were in a relationship. Investigators had matched DNA of Krishna, Rajkumar and Vijay but they didn't produce in court. Totally botched up investigation.
@@joydeepchakraborty2849 Did you watch the concluding remarks made by ex CBI director? All 3 teams unanimously concluded no intrusion occurred.
Blaming servants or shoddy probe, is not going to cover the obvious. Hemraj had confided his fears, about threat to his life for knowing the family secrets. When none is left alive to tell the other side of story, it doesn't take a genius to understand who did it.
Confusing, frustrating, uncomfortable, but thanks for sharing...
This is one of the most depressing cases i have ever watched!!No justice for those two,such a shame
Sadly parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar cannot accept the truth publicly that their daughter Aarushi and servant Hemraj were caught in a compromising position that's why in rage her father Rajesh Talwar murdered them as ppl will laugh at Aarushi for her conduct so they are doing this to protect Aarushi's dignity.....
Anybody else find it weird that he offered to pay the police to look elsewhere? Also, anybody else look up the book to see if there was a hidden message? I watched a summary video, but didn’t see any major connection. But the title is still kinda uncanny though. 🤔 Great video BTW! ✨
I LOVE the style of the channel. It has a very documentary/TV feel, rather than just another true crime channel with too much speculation & personal feelings of the narrator/youtuber. You show respect and show its about the victims story, not about the narrator/youtuber, aka "influencer" 🙄
That's why you're the best ✌🏻❤
Two other excellent channels: Coffeehouse Crime, and This is Monsters. Always great respect shown to the victims and their families. Detailed research.
This is MONSTERS!!! I second that!!! True Crime mysteries, dark curiosities....x
The InvestiGator too!!x
I truly agree. I love this channel!
@@12thDecember coffeehouse crime is so annoying. He’s bit too much for me!
Definitely one of the very best Chanel’s covering murders on TH-cam. Thanks so much for staying true to the cases you cover without adding too much of your own feelings
This clearly shows how inefficient is Indian police service.
One thing I've always felt strange about this incident is that 2ppl from the same house are brutally killed but parents left unharmed. The house isn't even that big for an outsider to not notice there's someone right next to the room they're killing in? Hearing about the bribe and terrace check the first time. Were these two points never brought up in court?
I find it hard to believe that two violent murders could take place in a small apartment without the parents knowledge, it's also unlikely that an outsider would fix himself a scotch before leaving the scene. Unfortunately the forensic evidence was not secured or processed correctly and any motives seem to be based only on speculation. Sherlock Holmes's definition of the truth is unfortunately not sufficient for a court of law.
Motive in my opinion should not be a necessary part of proving the case. Only the cold logic of who had the means and opportunity to both commit the crime and to cover it up afterwards. If you must have a motive then consider the motive to cover up the crime, to hide Hemraj from sight and then later to restrict access to the terrace. Who would have motive to clean the scene and the body? Only someone who owned the house. No one else would care to cover it up, they would flee and be done with it.
Just because something is hard to believe doesn't mean it isn't true.
@@zombrero7870 I don't think motive is necessary to prove a case but I think suspects with a motive and opportunity will be looked at before those who only have opportunity. Without evidence however I think a conviction is unlikely in either case but I am not an expert, I was neither a policeman or a prosecutor.
@@shariwelch8760 Of course you are correct, That which I find hard to believe is irrelevant, gullibility varies from person to person. It's what the police and the courts believe that matters.
@@davymckeown4577 I just want you to be aware that quite a few killers have fixed themselves food and drink after murdering someone in their own home. It's a possibility, that's all.
Wow, an hour long video of quality content. Thank you Truly Criminal.
Absolutely amazing video, great work! So sad that both victims have still not received justice. Hopefully one day this case will be solved.
This was a great video.
The media circus and the lack of proper investigation are the main reason why this case is so much fucked up to its core. Also Indian courts work at snail pace so this case will probably still be on courts until the parents or any other possible culprits are dead.
RIP Aarushi and Hemraj.
It is very strange that parents who lost their young daughter from the start were having a defensive posture instead of strongly urging the authorities to find the real culprits. Lack of emotions at the time of the incident indicates their minds were more pre-occupied with how to cover up or answer questions by the police. After seeing their daughter brutally murdered, they were expected to immediately call the police for help considering their own lives could be in danger. As part of medical profession they should been conscious and protested the contamination of the crime scene by media people having opportunity to enter the premises and contaminating the crime scene.
One of the best deep dive videos into this case I have ever seen
Bravo! This is becoming my favorite TH-cam true crime channel and we know there's like 50 other good ones
Mum and dad had some hand in this. That's why they allowed so many things to get messed up, paid someone to not go out the doors and lied so much
I just can’t stop watching your videos! First time the recommended section actually showed me something awesome. Definitely my new favorite ❤️
The haste to cremate, the want to keep rape out of reports, the haste to clean up the evidence. Local police allowed the media also parents did not stop from contamination, these were the doctors who knew about DNA and evidences. They were more about keeping up a respectable front. I think the issue that happened was crazy media attention. And it is very easy to blame the male, poor, non Indian helpers. These people should have been the first people to make sure the evidence was there and preserved.
that hand print on the roof wall could have d been the turning point